Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Competitors
The products VMware Horizon 7.1, Citrix XenDesktop 7.13 and Huawei FusionCloud 6.0
are considered competing solution products given the fact that these products occupy high
share in the VDI market.
Comparisons
▌ Functions of VDI solutions (basic specification, performance, and operation management)
▌ Functions of connection broker (basic specification, performance, and operation)
3. NEC has own history providing solutions and support for both software and hardware.
Production LAN
Migration LAN
ThinClient
Terminal
VirtualPC Server FC Network
FC FC (7)
Switch Switch
CSV (4)
(5)
SAN Storage
The numbers shown on each function correspond to the functions on the following pages.
Basic Specifications
Operation Management
▌ Proposal tips
Explain customers that products of other companies may not offer satisfactory results since virtualization of GPU degrades
graphics functions on virtual PC. Moreover, virtualization of GPU lowers the number of virtual PC that can hold in a
system, raises the cost higher, and limits functionalities such as vMotion. Propose to introduce dedicated workstations for
such users; run high-graphical application natively on the workstation and business applications on virtual PC.
14 © NEC Corporation 2017 NEC Group and Partners Only
Optimal Resource Allocation (2)
▌ Comparison point
The function to monitor load state of virtual machine; and to keep appropriate load state by transferring virtual PC or
shutdown / boot the virtual machine server.
▌ Target to be benefited
IT manager, End user
▌ Status
VPCC…Provides “VM Optimized Placement" and “Power and Utilization Optimization".
VMware Horizon…Equivalent function is provided.
Citrix XenDesktop…Provides optimized distribution at startup. No other function.
Huawei FusionCloud...Resources are centralized for elastic resource allocation and sharing.
▌ Proposal tips
For VMware Horizon...Equivalent function is provided, but VPCC has an additional function of repositioning the virtual
PC to its default position.
ThinClient Virtual PC
▌ Target to be benefited
End user
▌ Status
RDP10 obtained higher screen transfer efficiency which performance with competing protocols.
▌ Proposal tips
Performance difference between RDP10 and other protocols is getting smaller.
▌ Proposal tips
End user
VPCC…Setting is not necessary and end user can use the closest printer promptly.
IT manager
IT manager can control printer assignment flexibly such as mapping a dedicated printer for each floor.
Basic Specifications
Virtual PC Distribution Distribution method of virtual PC private / share / private / share / private / share / private / share /
private / share / initial distribution advance distribution initial distribution initial distribution initial distribution
Support for Support range of ThinClient terminal; and WinEmbedded, WTOS, WinEmbedded, WTOS, WinEmbedded, WTOS, WinEmbedded, WTOS,
Connecting Terminals of iPad, iPhone, and Android terminal Android, iOS etc. Android, iOS etc. Android, iOS etc. Android, iOS etc.
Performance
Supportable Quantity Link by connection broker between Up to 20 CMO servers Up to 20,000 virtual Up to 10,000 virtual Up to 80,000 virtual
in Large Scale multiple servers or 40,000 virtual PCs PCs PCs PCs
Operation management
▌ Target to be benefited
End user
▌ Status
RDP10 obtained higher screen transfer efficiency which performance is as good as other protocols.
Each protocol has different default setting. The default setting of HDX is optimized for narrow band, PCoIP is
optimized for high resolution, RDP is for balancing both narrow band and high resolution. However by tuning, each
protocol can achieve a desirable performance.
▌ Proposal tips
Performance over RDP10 and other protocols are almost equivalent.
▌ Target to be benefited
End user
▌ Status
VPCC…USB Redirection of RDP10.
VMware Horizon supports the function with Policy Template.
Citrix XenDesktop and Huawei FusionCloud supports with HDX and USB Redirection, although there are limitation in
terminals types.
▌ Proposal tips
Performance over RDP10 and other protocols are almost equivalent.