#HAPTER

4(%02%2%15)3)4%3&/2
!35##%33&5,).352'%.#9

4HECAUSEOFMOSTRECENTINSURGENCIESCANEASILYBEATTRIBUTEDTOREVOLUTIONARY
SITUATIONSTHATMIGHTHAVEEXPLODEDINTOSPONTANEOUSREVOLUTIONSBUTBRED
INSTEADAGROUPOFLEADERSWHOTHENPROCEEDEDTOORGANIZEANDCONDUCTTHE
INSURGENCIES)NVIEWOFTHISFACTITWOULDBEWRONGANDUNJUSTTOCONCLUDE
THATINSURGENCIESAREMERELYTHEPRODUCTOFPERSONALAMBITIONSONTHEPARTOF
THEIRLEADERSWHODEVELOPEDTHEWHOLEMOVEMENTARTIlCIALLYSOTOSPEAK
&ORTHESAKEOFDEMONSTRATIONLETUSSUPPOSETHATIN#OUNTRY8ASMALL
GROUPOFDISCONTENTEDMENˆPOSSESSINGTHEATTRIBUTESOFLEADERSHIPINSPIRED
BYTHESUCCESSOFSOMANYINSURGENCIESINTHEPASTTWENTYYEARSWELLAWARE
OFTHESTRATEGICANDTACTICALPROBLEMSINVOLVEDINSUCHANENTERPRISEˆHAVE
METANDDECIDEDTOOVERTHROWTHEEXISTINGORDERBYTHEPATHOFINSURGENCY
)NLIGHTOFTHECOUNTERINSURGENTSMATERIALSUPERIORITYATTHEOUTSETTHEIR
CHANCESOFVICTORYWILLOBVIOUSLYDEPENDONWHETHERCERTAINPRELIMINARY
CONDITIONS ARE MET 7HAT CONDITIONS !RE THESE CONDITIONS A MUST )N
OTHERWORDSWHATARETHEPREREQUISITESFORASUCCESSFULINSURGENCY
+NOWINGWHATTHEYAREWOULDHELPINASSESSINGFROMACOUNTERINSURGENTS
POINTOFVIEWHOWVULNERABLEACOUNTRYWOULDBETOANINSURGENCY

!#!53%

.ECESSITYOFA#AUSE
(OWCANTHEINSURGENTEVERHOPETOPRYTHEPOPULATIONAWAYFROMTHE
COUNTERINSURGENTTOCONTROLITANDTOMOBILIZEIT"YlNDINGSUPPORTERS
 #/5.4%2).352'%.#97!2&!2%

AMONGTHEPOPULATIONPEOPLEWHOSESUPPORTWILLRANGEFROMACTIVEPAR
TICIPATIONINTHESTRUGGLETOPASSIVEAPPROVAL4HElRSTBASICNEEDFORAN
INSURGENTWHOAIMSATMORETHANSIMPLYMAKINGTROUBLEISANATTRACTIVE
CAUSEPARTICULARLYINVIEWOFTHERISKSINVOLVEDANDINVIEWOFTHEFACTTHAT
THEEARLYSUPPORTERSANDTHEACTIVESUPPORTERSˆNOTNECESSARILYTHESAME
PERSONSˆHAVETOBERECRUITEDBYPERSUASION
7ITHACAUSETHEINSURGENTHASAFORMIDABLEIFINTANGIBLEASSETTHATHE
CANPROGRESSIVELYTRANSFORMINTOCONCRETESTRENGTH!SMALLGROUPOFMEN
SANSCAUSECANSEIZEPOWERBYALUCKYPLOTˆTHISHASHAPPENEDINHISTORYˆ
BUTTHENAPLOTISNOTANINSURGENCY4HELACKOFANATTRACTIVECAUSEISWHAT
RESTRAINS A PRIORI APOLITICAL CRIME SYNDICATES FROM ATTEMPTING TO ASSUME
POWERFORTHEYREALIZETHATONLYCRIMINALSWILLFOLLOWTHEM
4HEn#OMMUNISTINSURGENCYIN'REECEATEXTBOOKCASEOFEVERY
THINGTHATCANGOWRONGINANINSURGENCYISANEXAMPLEOFFAILUREDUEAMONG
OTHERLESSESSENTIALREASONSTOTHELACKOFACAUSE4HE#OMMUNIST0ARTYTHE
%!-ANDITSARMYTHE%,!3GREWDURING7ORLD7AR))WHENTHEENTIRE
POPULATIONWASRESISTINGTHE'ERMANS/NCETHECOUNTRYWASLIBERATEDTHE
%!-COULDlNDNOVALIDCAUSE'REECEHADLITTLEINDUSTRYANDCONSEQUENTLY
NOPROLETARIATEXCEPTTHEDOCKERSOF0IRAEUSANDTOBACCO FACTORYWORKERS
THEMERCHANTSAILORSWHOSEJOBSKEPTTHEMMOVINGABOUTCOULDPROVIDENO
CONSTANTSUPPORT4HEREWASNOAPPALLINGAGRARIANPROBLEMTOEXPLOIT4HE
WEALTHY'REEKCAPITALISTSWHOSEFORTUNESHADUSUALLYBEENMADEABROAD
WEREANOBJECTOFADMIRATIONRATHERTHANOFHOSTILITYINATRADE MINDEDNATION
.OSHARPLYlXEDCLASSESEXISTEDTHE-INISTEROFTHE.AVYMIGHTWELLBETHE
COUSINOFACAFÏWAITER4OMAKEMATTERSWORSETHE'REEK#OMMUNISTSWERE
PERFORCEALLIEDTO"ULGARIA'REECESTRADITIONALENEMYTO9UGOSLAVIAWHICH
CLAIMSAPARTOF'REECES-ACEDONIATO!LBANIAFROMWHICH'REECECLAIMS
PART OF %PIRUS 7ITH NATIONAL FEELINGS RUNNING AS HIGH AS THEY DO IN THE
"ALKANS THESE ASSOCIATIONS DID NOT INCREASE THE POPULARITY OF THE 'REEK
#OMMUNISTS
5SINGWHATFORCESTHEYHADATTHEENDOFTHEWARTAKINGADVANTAGEOFTHE
DIFlCULT TERRAIN WITHDRAWING INTO SAFE ASYLUM ACROSS THE SATELLITES BOR
DERS WHEN NECESSARY THE #OMMUNIST INSURGENTS WERE ABLE TO WAGE
COMMANDO TYPE OPERATIONS BUT NOT TRUE GUERRILLA WARFARE IN FACT THEIR
INlLTRATINGUNITSHADTOHIDEFROMTHEPOPULATIONWHENTHEYCOULDNOTCOW
ITANDTHEIROPERATIONSLASTEDGENERALLYASLONGASTHESUPPLIESTHEYCARRIED
WITHTHEM4HE%,!3WASOBLIGEDTOENLISTPARTISANSBYFORCE7HENEVER
THEUNWILLINGRECRUITSFOUNDTHEPOLITICALCOMMISSARBEHINDTHEIRBACKLESS
DANGEROUSTHANTHENATIONALISTFORCESINFRONTTHEYDESERTED
4HEMAINREASONTHEINSURGENCYLASTEDSOLONGWASTHATATTHESTART
THEREGULARGOVERNMENTFORCESCONSISTEDOFONLYASINGLEBRIGADEWHICH
HADFOUGHTWITHTHE!LLIESINTHE-EDITERRANEAN4HEATERANDWASGREATLY
 4(%02%2%15)3)4%3&/2!35##%33&5,).352'%.#9 

OUTNUMBEREDBYTHEINSURGENTS!SSOONASTHEARMYWASREORGANIZED
ANDSTRENGTHENEDlRSTWITH"RITISHTHENWITH53AIDTHENATIONALIST
COMMANDUNDERTOOKTOCLEANTHECOUNTRYAREABYAREABYPURELYMILITARY
ACTION ! CLEANED AREA WAS KEPT CLEAN BY ARMING LOCAL MILITIAS THIS
PRESENTED LITTLE DIFlCULTY SINCE THE POPULATION WAS DElNITELY ANTI
#OMMUNISTANDCOULDBERELIEDUPON

3TRATEGIC#RITERIAOFA#AUSE
4HEBESTCAUSEFORTHEINSURGENTSPURPOSEISONETHATBYDElNITIONCAN
ATTRACTTHELARGESTNUMBEROFSUPPORTERSANDREPELTHEMINIMUMOFOPPO
NENTS4HUSACAUSEAPPEALINGTOTHEPROLETARIATINANINDUSTRIALIZEDCOUN
TRYORTOTHEPEASANTSINANUNDERDEVELOPEDONE ISAGOODCAUSE!PURELY
.EGRO MOVEMENT TRYING TO EXPLOIT THE .EGRO PROBLEM AS A BASIS FOR AN
INSURGENCYINTHE5NITED3TATESWITHAPOPULATIONOFMILLION.EGROES
ANDMILLIONWHITES WOULDBEDOOMEDFROMTHESTART)N3OUTH!FRICA
WITH  MILLION .EGROES AND  MILLION WHITES  ITS CHANCES WOULD BE
GOODˆOTHERFACTORSASIDE)NDEPENDENCEFROMCOLONIALRULEWASAUTOMATI
CALLY A GOOD CAUSE IN )NDONESIA )NDOCHINA 4UNISIA -OROCCO!LGERIA
#YPRUSTHE"ELGIAN#ONGOANDNOW!NGOLA
4HEINSURGENTMUSTOFCOURSEBEABLETOIDENTIFYHIMSELFTOTALLYWITHTHE
CAUSEORMOREPRECISELYWITHTHEENTIREMAJORITYOFTHEPOPULATIONTHEO
RETICALLYATTRACTEDBYIT)N-ALAYAINDEPENDENCEFROM'REAT"RITAINWAS
THECAUSECHOSENBYTHEINSURGENTSTHE-ALAYAN#OMMUNIST0ARTY(OW
EVERPERCENTOFTHE0ARTYMEMBERSWERE#HINESENOTTRUE-ALAYSTHE
-ALAYS CONSEQUENTLY REMAINED LARGELY INDIFFERENT TO THE STRUGGLE 4HE
SAMESTORYOCCURREDIN+ENYAIFONECHOOSESTOQUALIFYWHATTOOKPLACE
THEREASAREVOLUTIONARYWARTHEINSURGENCYWASCONDUCTEDINSOCRUDEA
FASHIONASTOMAKEITSINCLUSIONINTHISCATEGORYQUESTIONABLE )NDEPEN
DENCEWASPURSUEDBYMEMBERSOFASINGLETRIBETHE+IKUYUSNOOTHER
TRIBEMOVEDINSUPPORT
4OBEPERFECTLYSOUNDTHECAUSEMUSTBESUCHTHATTHECOUNTERINSURGENT
CANNOT ESPOUSE IT TOO OR CAN DO SO ONLY AT THE RISK OF LOSING HIS POWER
WHICHISAFTERALLWHATHEISlGHTINGFOR,ANDREFORMLOOKEDLIKEAPROM
ISINGCAUSETOTHE(UKBALAHAPSAFTERTHEDEFEATOF*APANANDTHEACCESSION
OFTHE0HILIPPINESTOINDEPENDENCEBUTWHENTHEGOVERNMENTOFFEREDLAND
TOTHE(UKSACTUALANDPOTENTIALSUPPORTERSTHEINSURGENTSLOSTTHEIRCAUSE
AND THE GAME4HE SAME DISASTER STRUCK THE -ALAYAN #OMMUNIST 0ARTY
ONCE"RITAINPROMISEDINDEPENDENCETOTHECOUNTRYANDSETADATEFORIT
!CAUSElNALLYMUSTALSOBELASTINGIFNOTFORTHEDURATIONOFTHEREVO
LUTIONARYWARATLEASTUNTILTHEINSURGENTMOVEMENTISWELLONITSFEET4HIS
DIFFERENTIATES A STRATEGIC CAUSE FROM A TACTICAL ONE A DEEP SEATED CAUSE
 #/5.4%2).352'%.#97!2&!2%

FROM A TEMPORARY ONE RESULTING FROM THE EXPLOITATION OF AN EPHEMERAL
DIFlCULTYSUCHASFORINSTANCETHEHIGHPRICEANDTHESCARCITYOFFOODAFTER
AYEAROFNATURALCALAMITIES

4HE.ATUREOFTHE#AUSE
7HATISAPOLITICALPROBLEM)TIShANUNSOLVEDCONTRADICTIONvACCORDING
TO-AO4SE TUNG)FONEACCEPTSTHISDElNITIONTHENAPOLITICALCAUSEISTHE
CHAMPIONINGOFONESIDEOFTHECONTRADICTION)NOTHERWORDSWHERETHERE
IS NO PROBLEM THERE IS NO CAUSE BUT THERE ARE ALWAYS PROBLEMS IN ANY
COUNTRY7HATMAKESONECOUNTRYMOREVULNERABLETHANANOTHERTOINSUR
GENCYISTHEDEPTHANDTHEACUITYOFITSEXISTINGPROBLEMS
0ROBLEMSOFALLNATURESAREEXPLOITABLEFORANINSURGENCYPROVIDEDTHE
CAUSESTHEYLEADTOMEETTHEABOVECRITERIA4HEPROBLEMMAYBEESSENTIALLY
POLITICAL RELATED TO THE NATIONAL OR INTERNATIONAL SITUATION OF THE COUNTRY
4HEDICTATORSHIPOF"ATISTAFORTHE#UBANINSURGENTSTHE*APANESEAGGRES
SIONFORTHE#HINESEAREEXAMPLESOFPOLITICALPROBLEMS)TFOLLOWSTHATANY
COUNTRYWHERETHEPOWERISINVESTEDINANOLIGARCHYWHETHERINDIGENOUSOR
FOREIGNISPOTENTIALGROUNDFORAREVOLUTIONARYWAR
4HEPROBLEMMAYBESOCIALASWHENONECLASSISEXPLOITEDBYANOTHEROR
DENIED ANY POSSIBILITY OF IMPROVING ITS LOT 4HIS HAS BEEN EXHAUSTIVELY
DISCUSSED SINCE +ARL -ARX AND LITTLE NEED BE ADDED HERE4HE PROBLEM
BECOMESPARTICULARLYDANGEROUSWHENTHESOCIETYDOESNOTINTEGRATETHOSE
WHOBYTHELEVELOFTHEIREDUCATIONORBYTHEIRACHIEVEMENTSHAVEPROVED
TOBELONGTOTHETRUEELITE&ORITISAMONGTHISREJECTEDELITETHATTHEINSUR
GENTSCANlNDTHEINDISPENSABLELEADERS
4HE PROBLEM MAY BE ECONOMIC SUCH AS THE LOW PRICE OF AGRICULTURAL
PRODUCTSINRELATIONTOINDUSTRIALGOODSORTHELOWPRICEOFRAWMATERIALIN
RELATIONTOlNISHEDPRODUCTSORTHEIMPORTOFFOREIGNGOODSRATHERTHANTHE
DEVELOPMENTOFANATIONALINDUSTRY4HEISSUEOFNEOCOLONIALISMTODAYIS
CLOSELYRELATEDTOTHISPROBLEM
4HEPROBLEMMAYBERACIALASITWOULDBEIN3OUTH!FRICA/RRELIGIOUS
ASITWOULDBEIN,EBANONALTHOUGHHERETHEPOPULATIONISEVENLYDIVIDED
BETWEEN #HRISTIANS AND -OSLEMS /R CULTURAL AS IN )NDIA WHERE THE
MULTIPLICITYOFLANGUAGESHASALREADYPRODUCEDCONSIDERABLEAGITATION
4HE PROBLEM MAY EVEN BE ARTIlCIAL SO LONG AS IT HAS A CHANCE TO BE
ACCEPTEDASAFACT4HELOTOFTHE#HINESEFARMERSˆVICTIMSOFEXACTIONSBY
THEAUTHORITIESANDOFTHERAPACITYOFTHELOCALUSURERSˆWASNODOUBTAHARD
ONE 4HE #HINESE #OMMUNISTS DID EXPLOIT THIS PROBLEM (OWEVER THEIR
CHIEFCAUSEBORROWEDFROM3UN9AT SENWASLANDREFORM)TSREVOLUTIONARY
VALUE LIES IN THE IDEA THAT LAND OWNERSHIP WAS CONCENTRATED IN A SMALL
MINORITYACLASSWARONTHEISSUEWOULDTHEORETICALLYBRINGTOTHEIRSIDETHE
 4(%02%2%15)3)4%3&/2!35##%33&5,).352'%.#9 

MAJORITYOFTHEFARMERS4HESOLECOMPREHENSIVEWORKONTHESUBJECTOF
LAND TENURE IN #HINA BY * ,OSSING "UCK CONTRADICTED THE #OMMUNIST
PICTUREOFTHESITUATIONBUTTHISFACTDIDNOTDECREASEINTHESLIGHTESTTHE
PSYCHOLOGICALVALUEOFTHESLOGANh,ANDTOTHE4ILLERv!NEFlCIENTPROPA
GANDAMACHINECANTURNANARTIlCIALPROBLEMINTOAREALONE
)T IS NOT ABSOLUTELY NECESSARY THAT THE PROBLEM BE ACUTE ALTHOUGH THE
INSURGENTSWORKISFACILITATEDIFSUCHISTHECASE)FTHEPROBLEMISMERELY
LATENT THE lRST TASK OF THE INSURGENT IS TO MAKE IT ACUTE BY hRAISING THE
POLITICALCONSCIOUSNESSOFTHEMASSESv4ERRORISMMAYBEAQUICKMEANSOF
PRODUCING THIS EFFECT "ATISTAS DICTATORSHIP DID NOT BY ITSELF SUDDENLY
BECOMEUNBEARABLETOTHE#UBANPEOPLETHEYHADLIVEDUNDEROTHERDICTA
TORSHIPSINTHEPASTINCLUDINGAPREVIOUS"ATISTAREGIME!NDTHECOUNTRY
WASPROSPEROUSINALTHOUGHTHEREWASGREATDISPARITYINTHEDISTRIBU
TIONOFWEALTH"ATISTAMIGHTPERHAPSHAVELASTEDMANYMOREYEARSHADIT
NOTBEENFOR#ASTROANDHISFOLLOWERSWHOSPECTACULARLYRAISEDTHEISSUE
ANDFOCUSEDTHELATENTOPPOSITIONONTHEIRMOVEMENT

4ACTICAL-ANIPULATIONOFTHE#AUSE
4HEINSURGENTISNOTRESTRICTEDTOTHECHOICEOFASINGLECAUSE5NLESSHE
HAS FOUND AN OVER ALL CAUSE LIKE ANTICOLONIALISM WHICH IS SUFlCIENT IN
ITSELFBECAUSEITCOMBINESALLTHEPOLITICALSOCIALECONOMICRACIALRELI
GIOUSANDCULTURALCAUSESDESCRIBEDABOVEHEHASMUCHTOGAINBYSELECT
INGANASSORTMENTOFCAUSESESPECIALLYTAILOREDFORTHEVARIOUSGROUPSIN
THESOCIETYTHATHEISSEEKINGTOATTRACT
,ETUSSUPPOSETHATTHEREVOLUTIONARYMOVEMENTISTENTATIVELYMADEUP
ASITWASIN#HINAOFTHE#OMMUNIST0ARTYhVANGUARDOFTHEREVOLUTION
PARTYOFTHEWORKERSANDTHEPOORFARMERSv ANDITSALLIESMEDIUMANDRICH
PEASANTSARTISANSPLUSTHEhNATIONALBOURGEOISIEvANDTHECAPITALISTSWHO
SUFFER FROM hBUREAUCRATIC CAPITALISMv AND FROM THE ECONOMIC ENCROACH
MENTSOFTHEIMPERIALISTS 4HEINSURGENTHASTOAPPEALTOTHEWHOLEANDA
CAUSEISNECESSARYFORTHAT3INCEITISEASIERTOUNITEhAGAINSTvTHANhFORv
PARTICULARLY WHEN THE COMPONENTS ARE SO VARIED THE GENERAL CAUSE WILL
MOSTPROBABLYBEANEGATIVEONESOMETHINGLIKEhTHROWTHERASCALSOUTv
THERASCALSINTHISCASE#HIANG+AI SHEKANDTHE+UOMINTANGREACTIONAR
IESTHEFEUDALWARLORDShBUREAUCRATICCAPITALISMvTHECOMPRADOREShRUN
NINGDOGSOFIMPERIALISMvANDTHELANDLORDS )NADDITIONTHEINSURGENT
MUSTAPPEALTOEACHCOMPONENTOFTHEMOVEMENTANDINTHISASPECTTHE
VARIOUSCAUSESWILLPROBABLYCONTAINACONSTRUCTIVEELEMENTFORTHEPROLE
TARIATA-ARXISTSOCIETYFORTHEPOORFARMERSLANDFORTHEMEDIUMFARM
ERSFAIRTAXESFORTHERICHFARMERSJUSTREASONABLEANDLASTINGSETTLEMENT
FORTHENATIONALBOURGEOISIEDEFENSEOFTHENATIONALINTERESTSORDERFAIR
 #/5.4%2).352'%.#97!2&!2%

TAXES DEVELOPMENT OF TRADE AND INDUSTRY PROTECTION AGAINST IMPERIALIST

COMPETITION
.OTHINGOBLIGESTHEINSURGENTTOSTICKTOTHESAMECAUSEIFANOTHERONE
LOOKSMOREPROlTABLE4HUSIN#HINATHE#OMMUNISTSINITIALLYTOOKTHE
CLASSIC -ARXIST STAND IN FAVOR OF THE WORKERS n  4HEN THEY
ACTIVELYESPOUSEDTHENATIONALCAUSEOFTHE+UOMINTANGFORTHEUNIlCA
TIONOF#HINAAGAINSTTHEWARLORDSn !FTERTHE+UOMINTANGn
#OMMUNISTSPLITTHEYLARGELYDROPPEDTHEWORKERSINFAVOROFTHEPOOR
PEASANTS ADVOCATING LAND REFORM BY RADICAL MEANS n  4HEN
*APANESEAGGRESSIONBECAMETHECENTRALISSUEIN#HINAANDTHE#OM
MUNISTS ADVOCATED A PATRIOTIC UNITED FRONT AGAINST *APAN n 
ADOPTING MEANWHILE A MODERATE AGRARIAN POLICY ,AND REDISTRIBUTION
WOULDBEENDEDBUTINSTEADTHE#OMMUNISTSWOULDIMPOSESTRICTCON
TROLOFRENTSANDINTERESTRATES!FTERTHE*APANESESURRENDERTHEYlNALLY
REVERTEDTOLANDREFORMWITHTHETEMPERATEPROVISOTHATLANDLORDSTHEM
SELVESWOULDBEENTITLEDTOASHAREOFLANDn 7HATTHE#OM
MUNISTSACTUALLYDIDAFTERTHEIRVICTORYBETWEENANDWASTO
CARRYOUTTHEIRLANDREFORMhTHROUGHVIOLENTSTRUGGLESvINORDERTOCON
DUCT A CLASS WAR AMONG THE RURAL POPULATION AND THEREBY DElNITELY TO
COMMIT THE ACTIVISTS ON THEIR SIDE IF ONLY BECAUSE THESE ACTIVISTS HAD
SHARED IN THE CRIMES /NCE THIS WAS ACHIEVED THE 0ARTY BURIED LAND
REFORMFORGOODANDSTARTEDCOLLECTIVIZINGTHELAND
4HUSIFIDEALISMANDASENSEOFETHICSWEIGHINFAVOROFACONSISTENT
STANDTACTICSPULLTOWARDOPPORTUNISM

$IMINISHING)MPORTANCEOFTHE#AUSE
4HEIMPORTANCEOFACAUSEANABSOLUTEESSENTIALATTHEOUTSETOFANINSUR
GENCYDECREASESPROGRESSIVELYASTHEINSURGENTACQUIRESSTRENGTH4HEWAR
ITSELF BECOMES THE PRINCIPAL ISSUE FORCING THE POPULATION TO TAKE SIDES
PREFERABLYTHEWINNINGONE4HISHASALREADYBEENEXPLAINEDINTHEPREVI
OUSCHAPTER

7%!+.%33/&4(%#/5.4%2).352'%.4
,ET US ASSUME NOW THAT OUR MINUTE GROUP OF INSURGENT LEADERS IN
#OUNTRY 8 HAS FOUND SEVERAL GOOD CAUSES SOME ACUTE SOME LATENT
SOMEEVENARTIlCIALONWHICHTOBASETHEIRINSURGENCY4HEYALLHAVE
AGREEDONAPOTENTPLATFORM#ANTHEYSTARTOPERATING.OTUNLESSANOTHER
PRELIMINARYCONDITIONHASBEENMET4HEINSURGENTSTARTINGFROMALMOST
ZEROWHILEHISENEMYSTILLHASEVERYMEANSATHISDISPOSALISASVULNER
ABLEASANEW BORNBABY(ECANNOTLIVEANDGROWWITHOUTSOMESORTOF
 4(%02%2%15)3)4%3&/2!35##%33&5,).352'%.#9 

PROTECTIONANDWHOBUTTHECOUNTERINSURGENTHIMSELFCANPROTECTHIM
4HEREFORE WE MUST ANALYZE WHAT MAKES A BODY POLITIC RESISTANT TO
INFECTION

3TRENGTHSAND7EAKNESSESOFTHE0OLITICAL2EGIME
 !BSENCEOFPROBLEMS!COUNTRYFORTUNATEENOUGHTOKNOWNOPROBLEMIS
OBVIOUSLYIMMUNEFROMINSURGENCY"UTSINCEWEHAVEASSUMEDTHATOUR
POTENTIAL INSURGENT LEADERS HAVE FOUND A CAUSE LET US ELIMINATE THESE
COUNTRIESˆIFTHEREAREANYˆFROMOURCONSIDERATION
 .ATIONALCONSENSUS4HESOLIDITYOFAREGIMEISPRIMARILYBASEDUPONTHIS
FACTOR4HAILANDMAYLIVEUNDERADICTATORSHIPORADEMOCRATICSYSTEM
BUT HER NATIONAL CONSENSUSˆWHICH IS NOT APATHY FOR THE4HAIS WOULD
REACTVIGOROUSLYTOANYATTEMPTAGAINSTTHEIR+INGANDTHEIRWAYOFLIFEˆ
HASSOFARALWAYSSTRENGTHENEDTHEREGIMEINPOWER/NTHEOTHERHAND
NONATIONALCONSENSUSBACKSUP%AST'ERMANYSGOVERNMENT
 2ESOLUTENESSOFTHECOUNTERINSURGENTLEADERSHIP2ESOLUTENESSISAMAJOR
FACTORINANYSORTOFCONmICTBUTPARTICULARLYSOINAREVOLUTIONARYWARFOR
THE REASONS THAT A THE INSURGENT HAS THE INITIAL BENElT OF A DYNAMIC
CAUSEB ANINSURGENCYDOESNOTGROWSUDDENLYINTOANATIONALDANGER
ANDTHEPEOPLESREACTIONAGAINSTITISSLOW#ONSEQUENTLYTHEROLEOFTHE
COUNTERINSURGENTLEADERSISPARAMOUNT
 #OUNTERINSURGENT LEADERS KNOWLEDGE OF COUNTERINSURGENCY WARFARE )T
ISNOTENOUGHFORTHECOUNTERINSURGENTLEADERSTOBERESOLUTETHEYMUST
ALSOBEAWAREOFTHESTRATEGYANDTACTICSREQUIREDINlGHTINGANINSUR
GENCY'ENERALISSIMO#HIANG+AI SHEKSDETERMINATIONCANNOTBEQUES
TIONEDHEPROVEDITAGAINST*APANANDSTILLSHOWSITIN4AIWAN"UTDIDHE
KNOWHOWTOCOPEWITHTHE#OMMUNISTSMETHODS
 4HEMACHINEFORTHECONTROLOFTHEPOPULATION&OURINSTRUMENTSOFCON
TROL COUNT IN A REVOLUTIONARY WAR SITUATION THE POLITICAL STRUCTURE THE
ADMINISTRATIVEBUREAUCRACYTHEPOLICETHEARMEDFORCES
A 4
HEPOLITICALSTRUCTURE)F#OUNTRY8ISLOCATEDBEHINDTHE)RON#UR
TAINWHEREPOLITICALOPPOSITIONISNOTTOLERATEDANDWHERETHEPOPULA
TIONISKEPTUNDERASYSTEMOFTERRORANDMUTUALSUSPICIONTHEINITIAL
GROUP OF INSURGENTS HAS NO CHANCE TO DEVELOP AT BEST THE GROUP
WILL BE ABLE TO SURVIVE IN TOTAL SECRECYˆAND HENCE BE COMPLETELY
INACTIVEˆWHILEWAITINGFORBETTERTIMES

3INCETHEREAREPEOPLEWHODREAMOFUNLEASHINGINSURGENCIESINCERTAIN
#OMMUNISTCOUNTRIESˆh$ONTTHEPEOPLEHATETHEREGIMETHEREvˆITMAY
BEUSEFULTOGIVEANIDEAOFTHEEXTENTOFPOPULATIONCONTROLACHIEVEDBYTHE
#OMMUNISTTECHNIQUESOFTERRORANDMUTUALSUSPICIONOFWHICHTHE2ED
#HINESEAREPASTMASTERS
 #/5.4%2).352'%.#97!2&!2%

)N#ANTONINANEIGHBORSAWANOLD#HINESELADYGIVINGSOMERICE

TOHERCAT
h)AMSORRYBUT)WILLBEOBLIGEDTOREPORTYOUATTHENEXTSTREETMEETINGv
SAIDTHENEIGHBORTOTHEOWNEROFTHECAT
h7HYvASKEDTHEOLDLADY
h"ECAUSERICEISRATIONEDANDYOUHAVEBEENWASTINGITONYOURCATv
h)FYOUREPORTMETHEYWILLCUTOFFMYRICERATION7HYDONTYOUJUST
KEEPSILENTv
h3UPPOSESOMEONEELSESAWYOUANDREPORTSYOU7HATWILLHAPPENTO
MEYOURNEIGHBORIF)HAVENOTREPORTEDYOUlRST)AMYOURFRIEND)FTHEY
SUPPRESSYOURRATION)WILLGIVEYOUHALFOFMINEv
4HISISEXACTLYWHATHAPPENEDINACITYWHEREACCORDINGTOSOME7ESTERN
VISITORS #HINESE #OMMUNIST CONTROL WAS LESS EFlCIENT THAN ELSEWHERE IN
#HINA
!TTHEENDOFA%UROPEANWASEXPELLEDFROM(AINAN)SLANDWHERE
HEHADLIVEDFORMANYYEARS/NREACHING(ONG+ONGHEREPORTEDTHATTHE
PEASANTShHATEDvTHEREGIMEANDHEGAVEMUCHCONVINCINGEVIDENCEOFIT
(EMENTIONEDLATERTHATTHE.ATIONALISTSHADTWICEATTEMPTEDTODROPAGENTS
INHISAREAFROM4AIWAN)NEACHCASETHEMILITIAONDUTYATNIGHTHEARDTHE
PLANESSAWTHEPARACHUTESCOMINGDOWNGAVETHEALERTANDTHE.ATIONALIST
AGENTSWERECORNEREDANDCAPTUREDBYSEVERALHUNDREDARMEDVILLAGERS
4HE %UROPEAN WAS CHALLENGED ON THIS h)SNT THERE A CONTRADICTION
BETWEENYOURSTATEMENTCONCERNINGTHEFEELINGSOFTHEPEASANTSTOWARDTHE
REGIMEANDTHEATTITUDEOFTHEMILITIAMENWHOAFTERALLAREPEASANTSTOO
7HYDIDNTTHEYKEEPSILENTv
h0UT YOURSELF IN THE PLACE OF ONE OF THESE MILITIAMENv HE EXPLAINED
h(OWDOESHEKNOWWHETHERTHEOTHERMEMBERSOFTHEMILITIAWONTGIVE
THEALERT)FTHEYDOANDHEHASNTHEWILLBEINGREATTROUBLEWHENTHE
#OMMUNISTCADRESMAKETHEIRUSUALPOST MORTEMINVESTIGATIONSv
)N*ULYDURINGTHE+OREAN7ARTHE.ATIONALISTSDECIDEDTOMAKE
ARAIDONTHEMAINLANDOF#HINA4HEYSELECTEDASTHEIROBJECTIVETHESMALL
PENINSULA OF 4UNGSHAN JUTTING OUT OF THE &UKIEN COAST WHICH IS TRANS
FORMEDINTOANISLANDATHIGHTIDE4HE#OMMUNISTGARRISONWASMADEUP
OFAREGULARBATTALIONPLUSATHOUSAND MANMILITIA4HELATTERTHE.ATIONAL
ISTSTHOUGHTWOULDPUTUPNOREALlGHT)NDEEDEVERYPIECEOFAVAILABLE
INTELLIGENCEINDICATEDTHATTHEPOPULATIONWASTHOROUGHLYFEDUPWITHTHE
#OMMUNISTS4HEPLANWASTODROPAREGIMENTOFPARATROOPERSTONEUTRAL
IZETHE#OMMUNISTBATTALIONANDTOCONTROLTHEISTHMUSINORDERTOPREVENT
REINFORCEMENTFROMTHEMAINLANDANAMPHIBIOUSLANDINGWOULDFOLLOWTO
WIPEOUTTHEOPPOSITION
"ECAUSEOFAMISCALCULATIONINCOMPUTINGTHELOCALTIDETHEAMPHIBIOUS
LANDINGWASDELAYEDANDTHE.ATIONALISTPARATROOPERSBORETHEBRUNTOFTHE
 4(%02%2%15)3)4%3&/2!35##%33&5,).352'%.#9 

OPPOSITIONALONE4HEYWEREVIRTUALLYANNIHILATED4HEMILITIAFOUGHTLIKE
DEVILS(OWCOULDTHEYACTOTHERWISEWHENTHEYKNEWTHATTHE.ATIONALIST
ACTIONWASJUSTARAID
!CONTROLOFTHISORDERRULESOUTTHEPOSSIBILITYOFLAUNCHINGANINSUR
GENCY!SLONGASTHEREISNOPRIVACYASLONGASEVERYUNUSUALMOVEOR
EVENTISREPORTEDANDCHECKEDASLONGASPARENTSAREAFRAIDTOTALKINFRONT
OF THEIR CHILDREN HOW CAN CONTACTS BE MADE IDEAS SPREAD RECRUITING
ACCOMPLISHED
7HATISPOSSIBLEISTERRORISMINALIMITEDWAYBECAUSEASINGLEMAN
EVEN THOUGH COMPLETELY ISOLATED CAN CONDUCT A TERRORIST CAMPAIGN
WITNESSTHECASEOFTHEhMADBOMBERvIN.EW9ORK"UTTERRORISMITSELF
HASFARLESSVALUETHANTHEPUBLICITYTHATITISEXPECTEDTOPRODUCEAND
IT IS RATHER DOUBTFUL THAT #OMMUNIST AUTHORITIES WOULD COMPLACENTLY
FURNISHPUBLICITY
!NOTHERTACTICTHATCONTINUESTOBEPOSSIBLEWASONEUSEDIN'REECEBY
THE #OMMUNISTSˆUNSUSTAINED COMMANDOTYPE OPERATIONS WHERE TERRAIN
CONDITIONSAREFAVORABLE
!TTHEOTHEREXTREMEIFANARCHYPREVAILSIN#OUNTRY8THEINSURGENTWILL
lNDALLTHEFACILITIESHENEEDSINORDERTOMEETTOTRAVELTOCONTACTPEOPLE
TOMAKEKNOWNHISPROGRAMTOlNDANDORGANIZETHEEARLYSUPPORTERSTO
RECEIVEANDTODISTRIBUTEFUNDSTOAGITATEANDTOSUBVERTORTOLAUNCHA
WIDESPREADCAMPAIGNOFTERRORISM
)NBETWEENTHESEEXTREMESLIESAWIDERANGEOFPOLITICALSTRUCTURESTHAT
INVARYINGDEGREESFACILITATEORHINDERTHETASKOFTHEINSURGENTDICTATOR
SHIPWITHAONE PARTYSYSTEMDICTATORSHIPWITHNOLINKTOTHEGRASSROOTS
VIGILANTDEMOCRACYINDOLENTDEMOCRACYETC
B 4HEADMINISTRATIVEBUREAUCRACY!COUNTRYISRUNINITSDAY TO DAYLIFE
BYITSBUREAUCRACYWHICHHASAFORCEOFITSOWNTHATHASSOMETIMESNO
RELATION TO THE STRENGTH OR WEAKNESS OF THE TOP POLITICAL LEADERSHIP
&RANCEUNDERTHE4HIRDAND&OURTH2EPUBLICSHADAWEAKLEADERSHIPBUT
ASTRONGADMINISTRATIVEAPPARATUSTHEOPPOSITEAPPEARSTOBETHECASEIN
3OUTH 6IETNAM TODAY 3INCE AN INSURGENCY IS A BOTTOM TO TOP MOVE
MENTANADMINISTRATIVEVACUUMATTHEBOTTOMANINCOMPETENTBUREAU
CRACYPLAYSINTOTHEHANDSOFTHEINSURGENT
4HE CASE OF!LGERIA MAY BE TAKEN AS AN EXAMPLE 4HE TERRITORY WAS
NOTORIOUSLYUNDERADMINISTEREDONTHEEVEOFTHEINSURGENCYNOTBECAUSE
THECIVILSERVANTSWEREINCOMPETENTBUTRATHERBECAUSETHEBUREAUCRATIC
ESTABLISHMENTHADNORELATIONTOTHESIZEOFTHECOUNTRYANDITSPOPULATION
!LGERIANOTCOUNTINGTHE3AHARA EXTENDSMORETHANMILESALONGTHE
-EDITERRANEAN3EAANDMILESINLANDWITHANAREAOFSQUARE
MILESANDAPOPULATIONOFOFWHOMAREOF%URO
PEANSTOCK
 #/5.4%2).352'%.#97!2&!2%

5NDERAGOVERNORGENERALIN!LGIERSTHETERRITORYWASDIVIDEDINTOTHREE
DÏPARTEMENTSWITHSEATSIN/RAN!LGIERSAND#ONSTANTINEEACHUNDERA
PRÏFETASSISTEDBYALARGESTAFF!DÏPARTEMENTWASINTURNDIVIDEDINTO
SOUS PRÏFECTURESFORINSTANCEINTHEDÏPARTEMENTOF!LGIERSTHEREWAS
THESOUS PRÏFECTUREOF+ABYLIAWITHITSSEATIN4IZI /UZOU+ABYLIACON
SISTEDOFSQUAREMILESOFRUGGEDMOUNTAINTERRAINWITH
INHABITANTSOFWHOMPERCENTWERE-OSLEMS
4HELOWERECHELONINPREDOMINANTLY-OSLEMAREASWASTHECOMMUNE
MIXTEUNDERA&RENCHADMINISTRATORWITHORASSISTANTSANDGENDARMES
THECOMMUNE MIXTEOF4IGZIRTIN+ABYLIAMEASUREDMILESBYMILES
WITHSOMEINHABITANTS
!T THE LOWEST LEVEL WAS THE DOUAR WHERE THE POWER OF THE STATE WAS
EMBODIEDINAGARDE CHAMPÐTREANATIVERURALPOLICEMANARMEDWITHAN
OLDPISTOLINAHOLSTERONWHICHSHONEABRASSSIGNENGRAVEDWITHTHEAWE
INSPIRINGWORDSh,A,OIv/NESUCHDOUARCOVEREDANAREAOFMILESBY
MILESWITHAPOPULATIONOF+ABYLIAS
7ITHTHISSETUPTHEINSURGENTSHADAlELDDAY

C 4HEPOLICE4HEEYEANDTHEARMOFTHEGOVERNMENTINALLMATTERSPERTAIN
INGTOINTERNALORDERTHEPOLICEAREOBVIOUSLYAKEYFACTORINTHEEARLY
STAGESOFANINSURGENCYTHEYARETHElRSTCOUNTERINSURGENTORGANIZATION
THATHASTOBEINlLTRATEDANDNEUTRALIZED

4HEIREFlCIENCYDEPENDSONTHEIRNUMERICALSTRENGTHTHECOMPETENCYOF
THEIRMEMBERSTHEIRLOYALTYTOWARDTHEGOVERNMENTANDLASTBUTNOTLEAST
ON THE BACKING THEY GET FROM THE OTHER BRANCHES OF THE GOVERNMENTˆ
PARTICULARLYTHEJUDICIALSYSTEM)FINSURGENTSTHOUGHIDENTIlEDANDARRESTED
BYTHEPOLICETAKEADVANTAGEOFTHEMANYNORMALSAFEGUARDSBUILTINTOTHE
JUDICIALSYSTEMANDARERELEASEDTHEPOLICECANDOLITTLE0ROMPTADAPTATION
OFTHEJUDICIALSYSTEMTOTHEEXTRAORDINARYCONDITIONSOFANINSURGENCYAN
AGONIZINGPROBLEMATBESTISANECESSITY!LGERIAMAYAGAINSERVEASAN
EXAMPLE4HETOTALPOLICEFORCEINWASLESSTHANBARELYLARGER
THANTHEPOLICEFORCEFORTHECITYOF0ARIS7HENTHEINSURGENCYWASBREW
ING THE!LGERIAN POLICE GAVE TIMELY WARNINGS WHICH WERE NOT HEEDED
! YEAR AFTER THE INSURGENCY BROKE OUT THE &RENCH .ATIONAL !SSEMBLY
lNALLYGRANTEDTHEGOVERNMENTTHEhSPECIALPOWERSvREQUIREDTODEALWITH
THESITUATION"YTHATTIMETHEPOLICEˆPARTICULARLYITS-OSLEMMEMBERSˆ
HADBEENENGULFEDINTHECHAOS

D 4HEARMEDFORCES,EAVINGASIDETHEFACTORSOFSTRENGTHAPPLICABLETO
THEARMEDFORCESINALLWARSTHOSETHATARERELEVANTINAREVOLUTIONARY
WARARE
 4(%02%2%15)3)4%3&/2!35##%33&5,).352'%.#9 

I 4HENUMERICALSTRENGTHOFTHEARMEDFORCESINRELATIONTOTHESIZEAND
THEPOPULATIONOFTHECOUNTRY!NINSURGENCYISATWO DIMENSIONAL
WARFOUGHTFORTHECONTROLOFTHEPOPULATION4HEREISNOFRONTNO
SAFEREAR.OAREANOSIGNIlCANTSEGMENTOFTHEPOPULATIONCANBE
ABANDONEDFORLONGˆUNLESSTHEPOPULATIONCANBETRUSTEDTODEFEND
ITSELF4HISISWHYARATIOOFFORCEOFTENORTWENTYTOONEBETWEENTHE
COUNTERINSURGENTANDTHEINSURGENTISNOTUNCOMMONWHENTHEINSUR
GENCYDEVELOPSINTOGUERRILLAWARFARE4HE&RENCHFORCESIN)NDO
CHINANEVERAPPROACHEDTHISRATIOAFACTTHATMORETHANANYOTHER
EXPLAINSWHYTHE&RENCHCOULDNOTHAVEWONTHEREEVENIFTHEYHAD
BEEN LED BY .APOLEON REGARDLESS OF THE POWER OF THE NATIONALIST
CAUSEINITIALLY
II 4HE COMPOSITION OF THE ARMED FORCES ! CONVENTIONAL WAR TODAY
REQUIRESAMODERNWELL BALANCEDFORCEWITHITSAIRSEAANDGROUND
COMPONENTS"UTAREVOLUTIONARYWARISPRIMARILYAWAROFINFANTRY
0ARADOXICALLYTHELESSSOPHISTICATEDTHECOUNTERINSURGENTFORCESTHE
BETTERTHEYARE&RANCES.!4/DIVISIONSWEREUSELESSIN!LGERIA
THEIRMODERNEQUIPMENTHADTOBELEFTBEHINDANDHIGHLYSPECIALIZED
ENGINEERORSIGNALUNITSHADTOBEHURRIEDLYCONVERTEDINTOORDINARY
INFANTRY.AVALOPERATIONSBYTHEINSURGENTBEINGUNLIKELYALLANAVY
NEEDSISASUFlCIENTFORCETOBLOCKADETHECOASTLINEEFFECTIVELY!S
FORANAIRFORCEWHOSESUPREMACYTHEINSURGENTCANNOTCHALLENGE
WHAT IT NEEDS ARE SLOW ASSAULT lGHTERS SHORT TAKE OFF TRANSPORT
PLANESANDHELICOPTERS
III 4HEFEELINGOFTHEINDIVIDUALSOLDIERTOWARDTHEINSURGENTSCAUSE
AND TOWARD THE COUNTERINSURGENT REGIME7HEREAS THE INSURGENT
INITIALLYCANUSEONLYAFEWCOMBATANTSANDCANTHEREFORESELECT
VOLUNTEERS THE COUNTERINSURGENTS MANPOWER DEMANDS ARE SO
HIGHTHATHEISCONDEMNEDTODRAFTSOLDIERSANDHEMAYWELLBE
PLAGUED BY THE PROBLEM OF LOYALTY ! FEW CASES OF COLLECTIVE
DESERTIONSMAYCASTSOMUCHSUSPICIONONCOUNTERINSURGENTUNITS
THAT THEIR VALUE MAY EVAPORATE ALTOGETHER 4HIS HAPPENED WITH
!LGERIAN 2ImE UNITS IN THE EARLY STAGE OF THE WAR IN !LGERIA
ALTHOUGH BASICALLY SOUND AND TRUSTWORTHY THESE UNITS HAD TO BE
RETIRED FROM DIRECT CONTACT WITH THE POPULATION AND USED IN A
PURELYMILITARYCAPACITY
IV 4HETIMELAPSEBEFOREINTERVENTION"ECAUSEOFTHEGRADUALTRANSI
TIONFROMPEACETOWARINAREVOLUTIONARYWARTHEARMEDFORCESARE
NOTORDEREDINTOACTIONASFASTASTHEYWOULDBEINACONVENTIONAL
WAR4HISDELAYISANOTHERCHARACTERISTICOFREVOLUTIONARYWARS4O
REDUCEITISAPOLITICALRESPONSIBILITYOFTHECOUNTRYSLEADERS
 'EOGRAPHIC CONDITIONS 'EOGRAPHY CAN WEAKEN THE STRONGEST POLITICAL
REGIMEORSTRENGTHENTHEWEAKESTONE4HISQUESTIONWILLSUBSEQUENTLY
BEEXAMINEDINMOREDETAIL
 #/5.4%2).352'%.#97!2&!2%

)T IS THE COMBINATION OF ALL THESE FACTORS THAT DETERMINES WHETHER AN
INSURGENCYISPOSSIBLEORNOTONCETHEPOTENTIALINSURGENTHASACAUSE

#RISISAND)NSURGENCY
4HEINSURGENTCANNOTOFCOURSECHOOSEHISOPPONENTHEMUSTACCEPTHIM
ASHEIS)FHEISCONFRONTEDBYAPOWERFULCOUNTERINSURGENTHEHASNORECOURSE
BUTTOWAITUNTILHISOPPONENTISWEAKENEDBYSOMEINTERNALOREXTERNALCRISIS
4HERECENTSERIESOFCOLONIALINSURGENCIESISNODOUBTACONSEQUENCE
OF7ORLD7AR )) WHICH CONSTITUTED A FORMIDABLE CRISIS FOR THE COLONIAL
POWERS4HERECORDSHOWSTHATNOINSURGENCYORREVOLTSUCCEEDEDINCOLO
NIALTERRITORIESBEFOREALTHOUGHTHESITUATIONTHENWASNOLESSREVO
LUTIONARYTHANAFTERTHEWAR&EWWEREEVENATTEMPTEDˆAREVOLTINTHE
$UTCH %AST )NDIES IN n AND THE EXTRAORDINARY PASSIVE RESISTANCE
MOVEMENTHEADEDBY'ANDHIIN)NDIAVIRTUALLYEXHAUSTTHELIST
4HEHISTORYOFTHE#HINESE#OMMUNISTINSURGENCYOFFERSANOTHEREXAM
PLEOFTHEEXPLOITATIONOFACRISIS!FTERASLOWCLIMBFROMMEMBERSIN
 TO  IN  THE #HINESE #OMMUNIST 0ARTY ASSOCIATED ITSELF
WITH THE +UOMINTANG AND ITS MEMBERSHIP ROSE SUDDENLY TO  IN
4HEEXPANSIONWASFACILITATEDBYTHESTATEOFANARCHYPREVAILINGIN
#HINAANDBYTHEPOPULARITYOFTHESTRUGGLELEDBYTHE+UOMINTANGAGAINST
THEWARLORDSANDTHEIMPERIALISTS4HETWOPARTIESSPLITINANDTHE
##0 WENT INTO OPEN REBELLION )MMEDIATELY THE MEMBERSHIP FELL TO
 ! #OMMUNIST GROUP WITH -AO 4SE TUNG TOOK REFUGE IN THE
+IANGSI (UNANAREAWHILEOTHERGROUPSSCATTEREDINVARIOUSPLACES4HEY
SLOWLYINITIATEDGUERRILLAWARFAREANDALTHOUGHATlRSTTHEYCOMMITTED
THEMISTAKEOFATTACKINGWELL DEFENDEDTOWNSTHEYMANAGEDTODEVELOP
THEIR MILITARY STRENGTH -EMBERSHIP ROSE TO  IN  4HE
+UOMINTANGHADSUCCEEDEDBYTHATTIMEINESTABLISHINGITSELFASTHECEN
TRALGOVERNMENTOF#HINAANDTHE#OMMUNISTSALONEPRESENTEDACHAL
LENGE TO ITS AUTHORITY 4HE +UOMINTANG BY NOW A STRONG POWER WAS
ENERGETICALLYTRYINGTOSTAMPOUTTHEREBELLION!FTERSEVERALUNSUCCESSFUL
OFFENSIVESAGAINSTTHE#OMMUNISTSTHE.ATIONALISTFORCESPRESSEDTHEM
SOHARDTHATTHE##0WASREALLYlGHTINGFORITSSURVIVAL)NORDERTOESCAPE
ANNIHILATIONTHE#OMMUNISTSSETOFFONTHEIR,ONG-ARCHFROM+IANGSI
TOAREMOTEAREAINTHENORTHOF3HENSI)NAFTERTHE,ONG-ARCH
MEMBERSHIPHADFALLENAGAINTO#HIANG+AI SHEKWASPREPARING
ANOTHERPOWERFULOFFENSIVETOlNISHOFFTHE2EDSWHENTHEYWERESAVEDBY
ACRISISTHE*APANESEAGGRESSIONAGAINST#HINA"Y6 *DAYTHE0ARTYHAD
GROWNTOCONTROLLEDANAREAOFSQUAREMILESWITHA
POPULATIONOFMILLIONANDHADAREGULARARMYOFMENANDA
MILITIAFORCEOF)TWASNOLONGERVULNERABLE
 4(%02%2%15)3)4%3&/2!35##%33&5,).352'%.#9 

4HE"ORDER$OCTRINE
%VERYCOUNTRYISDIVIDEDFORADMINISTRATIVEANDMILITARYPURPOSESINTO
PROVINCESCOUNTIESDISTRICTSZONESETC4HEBORDERAREASAREAPERMANENT
SOURCEOFWEAKNESSFORTHECOUNTERINSURGENTWHATEVERHISADMINISTRATIVE
STRUCTURESANDTHISADVANTAGEISUSUALLYEXPLOITEDBYTHEINSURGENTESPE
CIALLYINTHEINITIALVIOLENTSTAGESOFTHEINSURGENCY"YMOVINGFROMONE
SIDEOFTHEBORDERTOTHEOTHERTHEINSURGENTISOFTENABLETOESCAPEPRESSURE
ORATLEASTTOCOMPLICATEOPERATIONSFORHISOPPONENT
)TWASNOACCIDENTTHATTHE#HINESE#OMMUNIST DOMINATEDAREASINCLUDED
THE3HENSI +ANSU .INGSIA"ORDER!REATHE3HANSI #HAHAR (OPEI-ILITARY
2EGION THE (OPEI 3HANTUNG (ONAN -ILITARY 2EGION AND THE 3HANSI
(OPEI (ONAN -ILITARY 2EGION /PERATING ASTRIDE BORDERS HAD BECOME A
MATTEROFDOCTRINEFORTHEM

'%/'2!0()##/.$)4)/.3
4HEROLEOFGEOGRAPHYALARGEONEINANORDINARYWARMAYBEOVERRIDING
INAREVOLUTIONARYWAR)FTHEINSURGENTWITHHISINITIALWEAKNESSCANNOTGET
ANYHELPFROMGEOGRAPHYHEMAYWELLBECONDEMNEDTOFAILUREBEFOREHE
STARTS,ETUSEXAMINEBRIEmYTHEEFFECTSOFTHEVARIOUSGEOGRAPHICFACTORS

 ,OCATION!COUNTRYISOLATEDBYNATURALBARRIERSSEADESERTFORBIDDING

MOUNTAINRANGES ORSITUATEDAMONGCOUNTRIESTHATOPPOSETHEINSURGENCY
ISFAVORABLETOTHECOUNTERINSURGENT
 3IZE4HELARGERTHECOUNTRYTHEMOREDIFlCULTFORAGOVERNMENTTOCON
TROLIT3IZECANWEAKENEVENTHEMOSTTOTALITARIANREGIMEWITNESS#HINAS
PRESENTTROUBLESIN4IBET
 #ONlGURATION!COUNTRYEASYTOCOMPARTMENTALIZEHINDERSTHEINSURGENT
4HUSTHE'REEKNATIONALFORCESHADANEASYTASKCLEANINGTHE0ELOPONNE
SUSPENINSULA)FTHECOUNTRYISANARCHIPELAGOTHEINSURGENCYCANNOTEAS
ILYSPREADASWASTHECASEINTHE0HILIPPINES4HE)NDONESIAN'OVERNMENT
WHICHISNOTREMARKABLEFORITSSTRENGTHMANAGEDNEVERTHELESSTOSTAMP
OUTREBELLIONSINTHE-OLUCCAS!MBOINAANDOTHERISLANDS
 )NTERNATIONAL BORDERS 4HE LENGTH OF THE BORDERS PARTICULARLY IF THE
NEIGHBORING COUNTRIES ARE SYMPATHETIC TO THE INSURGENTS AS WAS THE
CASE IN 'REECE )NDOCHINA AND!LGERIA FAVORS THE INSURGENT! HIGH
PROPORTION OF COAST LINE TO INLAND BORDERS HELPS THE COUNTERINSURGENT
BECAUSE MARITIME TRAFlC CAN BE CONTROLLED WITH A LIMITED AMOUNT OF
TECHNICAL MEANS WHICH THE COUNTERINSURGENT POSSESSES OR IS USUALLY
ABLE TO ACQUIRE )T WAS CHEAPER IN MONEY AND MANPOWER TO SUPPRESS
SMUGGLING ALONG THE COAST OF !LGERIA THAN ALONG THE 4UNISIAN AND
-OROCCANBORDERSWHERETHE&RENCH!RMYHADTOBUILDMAINTAINAND
MANANARTIlCIALFENCE
 #/5.4%2).352'%.#97!2&!2%

 4ERRAIN)THELPSTHEINSURGENTINSOFARASITISRUGGEDANDDIFlCULTEITHER

BECAUSEOFMOUNTAINSANDSWAMPSORBECAUSEOFTHEVEGETATION4HEHILLS
OF+IANGSITHEMOUNTAINSOF'REECETHE3IERRA-AESTRATHESWAMPSOF
THE0LAINOF2EEDSIN#OCHINCHINATHEPADDYlELDSOF4ONKINTHEJUNGLE
OF-ALAYAGAVEASTRONGADVANTAGETOTHEINSURGENTS4HE#HINESE#OM
MUNISTSIN-ANCHURIAPROlTABLYUSEDTHETIMEWHENTHElELDSWERECOV
EREDWITHHIGHKAOLIANGSTALKS
/NTHEOTHERHANDTHE&,.WASNEVERABLETOOPERATEFORANYSUS
TAINEDPERIODINTHEVASTEXPANSESOFTHE3AHARAWITHTHE&RENCHFORCES
SECURINGTHEOASESANDVITALWELLSANDAIRSURVEILLANCEDETECTINGEVERY
MOVEANDEVENTRACESOFMOVEMENTLEFTONSAND
 #LIMATE#ONTRARYTOTHEGENERALBELIEFHARSHCLIMATESFAVORTHECOUNTER
INSURGENTFORCESWHICHHAVEASARULEBETTERLOGISTICALANDOPERATIONAL
FACILITIES4HISWILLBEESPECIALLYFAVORABLEIFTHECOUNTERINSURGENTSOLDIER
ISANATIVEANDTHEREFOREACCUSTOMEDTOTHERIGORSOFTHECLIMATE4HE
RAINYSEASONIN)NDOCHINAHAMPEREDTHE6IETMINHMORETHANITDIDTHE
&RENCH7INTER IN!LGERIA BROUGHT &,. ACTIVITY TO ALMOST A STANDSTILL
-ERELYTOKEEPSCARCEWEAPONSANDAMMUNITIONINGOODCONDITIONWHEN
ONELIVESCONTINUOUSLYINTHEOPENASTHEGUERRILLADOESISAPERPETUAL
HEADACHE
 0OPULATION4HESIZEOFTHEPOPULATIONAFFECTSTHEREVOLUTIONARYWARIN
THESAMEWAYASDOESTHESIZEOFTHECOUNTRYTHEMOREINHABITANTSTHE
MORE DIFlCULT TO CONTROL THEM "UT THIS FACTOR CAN BE ATTENUATED OR
ENHANCEDBYTHEDENSITYANDTHEDISTRIBUTIONOFTHEPOPULATION4HEMORE
SCATTEREDTHEPOPULATIONTHEBETTERFORTHEINSURGENTTHISISWHYCOUNTER
INSURGENTS IN -ALAYA IN !LGERIA AND IN 3OUTH 6IETNAM TODAY HAVE
ATTEMPTED TO REGROUP THE POPULATION AS IN #AMBODIA IN n 
!HIGHRATIOOFRURALTOURBANPOPULATIONGIVESANADVANTAGETOTHEINSUR
GENT THE /!3 IN!LGERIA WAS DOOMED TACTICALLY BECAUSE IT COULD RELY
ONLYONTHE%UROPEANPOPULATIONWHICHWASCONCENTRATEDINCITIESPAR
TICULARLY!LGIERSAND/RAN4HECONTROLOFATOWNWHICHISEXTREMELY
DEPENDENTONOUTSIDESUPPLIESREQUIRESSMALLERFORCESTHANTHECONTROLOF
THESAMENUMBEROFPEOPLESPREADOVERTHECOUNTRYSIDEˆEXCEPTINTHE
CASEOFAMASSUPRISINGWHICHCANNEVERLASTLONGINANYEVENT
 %CONOMY4HEDEGREEOFDEVELOPMENTANDSOPHISTICATIONOFTHEECONOMY
CANWORKBOTHWAYS!HIGHLYDEVELOPEDCOUNTRYISVERYVULNERABLETOA
SHORTANDINTENSEWAVEOFTERRORISM"UTIFTERRORISMLASTSTHEDISRUPTION
BECOMESSUCHTHATTHEPOPULATIONMAYNOTBEABLETOENDUREITANDCON
SEQUENTLYMAYTURNAGAINSTTHEINSURGENTEVENWHENITWASNOTINITIALLY
HOSTILETOHIM
!NUNDERDEVELOPEDCOUNTRYISLESSVULNERABLETOTERRORISMBUTMUCH
MOREOPENTOGUERRILLAWARFAREIFONLYBECAUSETHECOUNTERINSURGENTCAN
NOTCOUNTONAGOODNETWORKOFTRANSPORTANDCOMMUNICATIONFACILITIES
ANDBECAUSETHEPOPULATIONISMOREAUTARCHIC
 4(%02%2%15)3)4%3&/2!35##%33&5,).352'%.#9 

4OSUMUPTHEIDEALSITUATIONFORTHEINSURGENTWOULDBEALARGELAND
LOCKEDCOUNTRYSHAPEDLIKEABLUNT TIPPEDSTARWITHJUNGLE COVEREDMOUN
TAINSALONGTHEBORDERSANDSCATTEREDSWAMPSINTHEPLAINSINATEMPERATE
ZONEWITHALARGEANDDISPERSEDRURALPOPULATIONANDAPRIMITIVEECONOMY
3EE&IGURE 4HECOUNTERINSURGENTWOULDPREFERASMALLISLANDSHAPED
LIKEAPOINTEDSTARONWHICHACLUSTEROFEVENLYSPACEDTOWNSARESEPA
RATEDBYDESERTINATROPICALORARCTICCLIMATEWITHANINDUSTRIALECONOMY
3EE&IGURE

&IGURE
&IGURE

/543)$%3500/24
/UTSIDESUPPORTTOANINSURGENCYCANTAKETHEFORMOF

 -ORALSUPPORTFROMWHICHTHEINSURGENTWILLBENElTWITHOUTANYEFFORT

ONHISPARTPROVIDEDHISCAUSEGOESALONGWITHhTHEWINDOFHISTORYv
4HUSINTHEPRESENTSTRUGGLEBETWEEN!NGOLANSANDTHE0ORTUGUESE'OV
ERNMENTTHEFORMERBENElTFROMCONSIDERABLEMORALSUPPORTWHILETHE
LATTER IS ISOLATED -ORAL SUPPORT IS EXPRESSED BY THE WEIGHT OF PUBLIC
OPINIONANDTHROUGHVARIOUSCOMMUNICATIONSMEDIA0ROPAGANDAISTHE
CHIEFINSTRUMENTOFMORALSUPPORTUSEDTOSWAYPUBLICOPINIONWHENIT
ISADVERSEORTOREINFORCEEXISTINGPUBLICSYMPATHY
 0OLITICALSUPPORTWITHPRESSUREAPPLIEDDIRECTLYONTHECOUNTERINSURGENT
ORINDIRECTLYBYDIPLOMATICACTIONINTHEINTERNATIONALFORUM4AKINGTHE
SAMECASEASANEXAMPLEWESEETHATMANY!FRICANSTATESHAVEBROKENOFF
DIPLOMATICRELATIONSWITH,ISBONANDRECOGNIZEDAPROVISIONALGOVERNMENT
OF!NGOLATHEYHAVEALSOSUCCEEDEDINEXPELLING0ORTUGALFROMVARIOUS
INTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSSUCHASTHE)NTERNATIONAL,ABOR/RGANIZATION
 4ECHNICALSUPPORTINTHEFORMOFADVICETOTHEINSURGENTFORTHEORGANI
ZATION OF HIS MOVEMENT AND THE CONDUCT OF HIS POLITICAL AND MILITARY
OPERATIONS4HESIMILARITYBETWEENTHE6IETMINHANDTHE#HINESE#OM
MUNISTSMETHODSWASNOTACCIDENTAL
 #/5.4%2).352'%.#97!2&!2%

 &INANCIALSUPPORTOVERTORCOVERT!GREATPARTOFTHE&,.BUDGETCAME

FROMGRANTSBYTHE!RAB,EAGUE2ED#HINASHIPPEDTEATOTHE&,.IN
-OROCCOWHEREITWASSOLDONTHEOPENMARKET
 -ILITARY SUPPORT EITHER THROUGH DIRECT INTERVENTION ON THE INSURGENTS
SIDEORBYGIVINGHIMTRAININGFACILITIESANDEQUIPMENT

.OOUTSIDESUPPORTISABSOLUTELYNECESSARYATTHESTARTOFANINSURGENCY
ALTHOUGHITOBVIOUSLYHELPSWHENAVAILABLE-ILITARYSUPPORTSHORTOFDIRECT
INTERVENTIONINPARTICULARCANNOTBEABSORBEDINASIGNIlCANTAMOUNTBY
THEINSURGENTUNTILHISFORCESHAVEREACHEDACERTAINLEVELOFDEVELOPMENT
4HEINITIALMILITARYPHASEOFANINSURGENCYWHETHERTERRORISMORGUERRILLA
WARFAREREQUIRESLITTLEINTHEWAYOFEQUIPMENTARMSAMMUNITIONAND
EXPLOSIVES4HESECANUSUALLYBEFOUNDLOCALLYORSMUGGLEDIN
7HENTHETIMECOMESHOWEVERFORTHEINSURGENTTOPASSFROMGUER
RILLAWARFARETOAHIGHERFORMOFOPERATIONSTOCREATEAREGULARARMY
THE NEED FOR MUCH LARGER AND MORE VARIED SUPPLIES BECOMES ACUTE
%ITHER HE IS ABLE TO CAPTURE IT FROM THE COUNTERINSURGENT OR IT MUST
COMEFROMTHEOUTSIDE)FNOTTHEDEVELOPMENTOFTHEINSURGENTMILI
TARYESTABLISHMENTISIMPOSSIBLE
4HE#OMMUNISTSIN#HINARECEIVEDLITTLEORNOSUPPORTFROMABROADUNTIL
-ANCHURIAWASOCCUPIEDBYTHE3OVIET!RMYTHEARMSANDEQUIPMENTOF
THE*APANESE+WANTUNG!RMYWERETURNEDOVERTOSOLDIERSFROM
THE0EOPLES,IBERATION!RMYWHOHADCROSSEDINTO-ANCHURIAFROM*EHOL
AND3HANTUNG4HE#OMMUNISTSIN-ANCHURIAWEREATONCEABLETOCON
DUCTLARGE SCALESUSTAINEDOPERATIONSANDTHENATUREOFTHElGHTINGINTHIS
AREAWASMARKEDLYDIFFERENTFROMTHE#OMMUNISTOPERATIONSSOUTHOFTHE
'REAT7ALL!CCESSTOTHE*APANESE!RMYSTORESWASNOTTHEDECISIVEFACTOR
INTHEOUTCOMEOFTHEWARSINCETHE#OMMUNISTFORCESIN#HINAPROPER
WHORECEIVEDFEWSUPPLIESFROM-ANCHURIASUCCEEDEDINARMINGTHEM
SELVESWITHCAPTURED.ATIONALISTEQUIPMENTBUTITCERTAINLYHASTENEDTHE
DEFEAT OF THE BEST .ATIONALIST TROOPS IN -ANCHURIA 4HE #OMMUNISTS
BOASTEDTHATTHEIRQUARTERMASTERANDORDNANCEDEPOTSWERECONVENIENTLY
LOCATEDFORWARDINTHEHANDSOFTHE.ATIONALISTS4HEIRSLOGANh&EEDTHE
7ARBY7ARvWASNOTANEMPTYASSERTION
)N )NDOCHINA THE TURNING POINT OCCURRED IN  WHEN THE 6IETMINH
BEGANRECEIVINGAIDFROM2ED#HINA5NTILTHENTHEYHADBEENUNABLETO
DEVELOPTHEIRFORCESANDTOSTAGELARGE SCALEOPERATIONSNOTBECAUSETHEY
SUFFEREDFROMMANPOWERPROBLEMSˆTHEYHADMOREPOTENTIALSOLDIERSTHAN
THEY COULD USEˆBUT BECAUSE THEIR PRIMITIVE ARSENALS COULD NOT lLL THEIR
NEEDSANDTHEYCOULDNOTCAPTURESIGNIlCANTAMOUNTSOF&RENCHWEAPONS
!LTHOUGHTHE6IETMINHCOULDHAVEFOUGHTAPROTRACTEDGUERRILLAWARFAREAND
THUSCOULDHAVEDENIEDTHE&RENCHANYBENElTFROMAPROLONGEDOCCUPATION
 4(%02%2%15)3)4%3&/2!35##%33&5,).352'%.#9 

OFTHECOUNTRYTHEYWOULDNOTHAVEBEENABLETORAISEAPOWERFULREGULAR
ARMYWITHOUT#HINESEAID"Y3EPTEMBERMENINTHE6IET
MINHFORCESHADBEENEQUIPPEDWITHMACHINEGUNSHEAVYMORTARSANTI
AIRCRAFTWEAPONS4HE6IETMINHCOMMANDWASABLETOORGANIZEA(EAVY
$IVISIONTHEST)NACCORDINGTO&RENCHESTIMATES#HINESEAID
AMOUNTEDTORImESMACHINEGUNSnHEAVYMORTARS
ANDABOUTRECOILLESSGUNS
)N-ALAYAANDTHE0HILIPPINESTHEINSURGENTSRECEIVEDNOOUTSIDEMILI
TARYSUPPORTANDDIDNOTDEVELOP
)N'REECETHE#OMMUNISTINSURGENTSRECEIVEDSUPPORTFROMANDTHROUGH
THESATELLITECOUNTRIESBUTTHESPLITBETWEEN4ITOAND3TALININTERRUPTEDTHE
LOWJUSTWHENTHEINSURGENTSHAVINGORGANIZEDTHEIRFORCESINTOLARGEˆ
ANDVULNERABLEˆUNITSNEEDEDITMOST
)N!LGERIA THE &RENCH NAVAL BLOCKADE AND THE SEALING OF THE BORDERS
PREVENTED THE mOW OF SUPPLIES TO !LGERIA FROM 4UNISIA AND -OROCCO
WHERE LARGE REBEL STOCKS HAD BEEN ACCUMULATED .O DEVELOPMENT WAS
POSSIBLE4HESITUATIONOFTHE&,.FORCESAFTERBECAMESOCRITICAL
THAT MOST OF THEIRAUTOMATICWEAPONSWEREBURIED FOR LACK OF AMMUNI
TION
4HE%AST 7ESTCONmICTTHATTODAYCOVERSTHEENTIREWORLDCANNOTFAILTO
BE AFFECTED BY ANY INSURGENCY OCCURRING ANYWHERE4HUS A #OMMUNIST
INSURGENCY IS ALMOST CERTAIN TO RECEIVE AUTOMATIC SUPPORT FROM THE
#OMMUNISTBLOC#HANCESFOR#OMMUNISTSUPPORTAREGOODEVENFORNON
#OMMUNIST INSURGENTS PROVIDED OF COURSE THAT THEIR OPPONENT IS AN
hIMPERIALISTvORANALLYOFhIMPERIALISMv
#ONVERSELYTHE%AST 7ESTCONmICTSOMETIMESACCELERATESTHEOUTBREAK
OFINSURGENCIESˆANDTHISISNOTALWAYSABLESSINGFORTHEINSURGENTSAS
WEHAVESEENINTHECASESOFTHE#OMMUNISTMOVEMENTSIN!SIAAFTERTHE
 #ALCUTTA MEETINGˆAND SOMETIMES SLOWS THEM DOWN OR INHIBITS
THEMENTIRELYWHENINSURGENCIESDONOTlTINWITHTHEOVER ALLPOLICYOF
THE#OMMUNISTBLOC4HISLASTPOINTCANNOTBEDOCUMENTEDNATURALLYBUT
THEREARESTRONGPRESUMPTIONSTHATTHESURPRISINGLYQUIETATTITUDEOFTHE
)NDONESIAN#OMMUNIST0ARTYTODAYWHICHSEEMSPOWERFULENOUGHTOGO
INTOVIOLENTACTIONMAYBEATTRIBUTEDTOSOMESORTOFVETOFROM-OSCOW
ANDOR0EKING
)FOUTSIDESUPPORTISTOOEASILYOBTAINABLEITCANDESTROYORHARMSELF
RELIANCEINTHEINSURGENTRANKS&ORTHISREASONPARTLY#OMMUNISTINSUR
GENTSIN!SIAHAVEALWAYSEMPHASIZEDTHENECESSITYOFCOUNTINGONTHEIR
OWNEFFORTS4HERESOLUTIONOFTHE&IRST3ESSIONOFTHE6IETNAMESE#ENTRAL
#OMMITTEEOFTHE,AO$ONG#OMMUNIST 0ARTYINREMINDED0ARTY
MEMBERSTHAThOUR2ESISTANCE7ARISALONGANDHARDSTRUGGLEvANDhWE
HAVEMAINLYTORELYONOUROWNFORCESv
 #/5.4%2).352'%.#97!2&!2%

)NCONCLUSION ACAUSE APOLICEANDADMINISTRATIVEWEAKNESSIN

THECOUNTERINSURGENTCAMP ANOT TOO HOSTILEGEOGRAPHICENVIRONMENT
AND OUTSIDESUPPORTINTHEMIDDLEANDLATERSTAGESOFANINSURGENCYˆ
THESE ARE THE CONDITIONS FOR A SUCCESSFUL INSURGENCY 4HE lRST TWO ARE
MUSTS4HELASTONEISAHELPTHATMAYBECOMEANECESSITY

./4%3
 "UCKS,AND5TILIZATIONIN#HINA,ONDON/XFORD5NIVERSITY0RESS
WASBASEDONINVESTIGATIONSCONDUCTEDINnINFARMSLOCALITIES
HSIENCOUNTIES PROVINCES
4ABLE GIVESTHEPERCENTAGESOFFARMERSWHOWEREOWNERSPART OWNERSAND
TENANTS
/WNERS 0ART OWNERS 4ENANTS

)N THE WHEAT REGION OF .ORTH #HINA WHERE THE #OMMUNISTS WERE STRONGLY
ESTABLISHEDTHEPERCENTAGESWERE
/WNERS 0ART OWNERS 4ENANTS

4ABLE GIVESTHEAVERAGESIZESOFFARMSINHECTARES BYCLASSOFOWNERSHIP

)NTHEWHEATREGION
/WNERS 0ART OWNERS 4ENANTS

!NOTHERTABLEGIVESTHENUMBERSANDPERCENTAGESOFFARMSINEACHSIZECLASS
&ORTHEWHEATREGION
6ERY3MALL 3MALL -EDIUM -EDIUM,ARGE ,ARGE
6ERY,ARGE 6ERY6ERY,ARGE 6ERY6ERY6ERY,ARGE

4HE#HINESE#OMMUNISTlGURESONLANDDISTRIBUTIONBASEDONAREPORTBY,IU
3HAO CHIIN*UNEWERETHESEh,ANDLORDSANDPEASANTSWHOACCOUNTFOR
LESSTHANPERCENTOFTHERURALPOPULATIONOWNTOPERCENTOFALLTHELAND
WHILEPOORPEASANTSAGRICULTURALLABORERSANDMIDDLEPEASANTSWHOACCOUNTFOR
ABOUT  PER CENT OF THE RURAL POPULATION OWN ONLY  TO  PER CENT OF THE
LANDv %DITORIAL IN *EN MIN *IH 0AO AS QUOTED IN # + 9ANG ! #HINESE
6ILLAGEIN%ARLY#OMMUNIST4RANSITION;#AMBRIDGE-ASS4HE4ECHNOLOGY0RESS
-ASSACHUSETTS)NSTITUTEOF4ECHNOLOGY=
 "ERNARD&ALL,E6IET -INH0ARIS,IBRAIRIE!RMAND#OLIN P