Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Finding
autism. It is designed as a replicable
housing model that incorporates
autism-specific design and supports
environmental stewardship.
THE
Balance Point
© Tim Griffith
B Y M A R S H A M AY T U M , FA I A ; A N D G W E N F U E R T E S , A S S O C I AT E A I A
ADULTS WITH AUTISM may experience a diverse range of sensory sensitivities. They may
not be able to block out the hum of an HVAC unit or the movement of the blades of a ceiling
fan. Sweetwater Spectrum is a new national model for supportive housing, designed to offer
life with purpose and dignity for adults on the autism spectrum. The Sonoma, Calif., community
integrates the latest research on autism specific design with universal design principles and
complementary sustainable, energy-efficient strategies.
S
weetwater Spectrum is The project includes four homes for standards, but the client elected not to
a nonprofit organization 16 residents, a community center, ther- proceed with final certification.
founded in 2009 by fami- apy pools, and a farm. Autism-specific
lies, autism professionals, design strategies promote serene, leg- Designed for Net Zero
and community leaders; its mission is ible spaces that create a safe, nurturing The Sweetwater Spectrum organization
to provide adults with autism an inno- environment. Practical sustainable is committed to creating a replicable
vative supportive residential commu- design strategies promote health and housing model with autism-specific
nity that challenges each individual wellness, reduce energy consumption, design that also supports environmental
to reach his or her highest potential. and offer multiple long-term benefits to stewardship. In most cases, the strate-
Autism is the fastest-growing devel- residents, staff, and the community. gies used to design a low-carbon facil-
opmental disability in the U.S., affect- The privately funded project was ity (Figure 1) went hand in hand with
ing one in 68 children. In the coming designed to exceed California Title Sweetwater’s project goals: to design
decade, some 500,000 children with 24-2008 energy standards by 30% and a durable and flexible building that is
autism will reach adulthood, yet few the AIA 2030 Commitment by 88%. sensitive to the climate and right-sized
residential options exist for them. It was designed to meet LEED Gold to the needs of the occupants.
This article was published in High Performing Buildings, Winter 2016. Copyright 2015 ASHRAE. Reprinted by permission at www.hpbmagazine.org. This article may not be
copied and/or distributed electronically or in paper form without permission of ASHRAE. For more information about High Performing Buildings, visit www.hpbmagazine.org.
Load Reduction. From the outset,
passive strategies controlled major
aspects of the orientation and archi-
tecture, and the techniques respond
to the mild, marine climate of the
Northern California inland coastal
region. The buildings orient to the
prevailing winds, allowing 100% of
the primary residential and program
spaces to be naturally ventilated.
Solar control and access to daylight
are intrinsic to the buildings’ design,
with overhangs on the south façades
Produce from the farm and orchard is used
and high clerestory openings to the daily by the residents and also sold at a
north to deliver even light throughout
© Deidre Sheerin
radiant systems and fan coil unit. amount of research has resulted in
Lighting systems are comprised of the generation of design guidelines
linear fluorescent and LED lamps, for those living with autism (or ASDs,
with dimmers in certain areas. Sensors autism spectrum disorders). One purpose of Sweetwater Spectrum is to
and controls are specifically designed The design guidelines recommended push residents to engage in activities and
for the needs of the users (see by Arizona State University’s Stardust encourage choices. It is located in a residen-
tial area that is within easy walking and bik-
Tailoring Systems Design). Center, “Advancing Full Spectrum ing distance of the Sonoma Town Square.
Housing,” were a reference for the
BUILDING AT A GLANCE Daylighting 100% of the primary residential and HVAC. While a typical low-energy
program areas are day-lit. Overall, 93% of all residential unit in Sonoma might
Name Sweetwater Spectrum buildings spaces use daylight as the primary
light source.
include ceiling fans to circulate air,
Location Sonoma, Calif. this is an untenable technique for
(33 miles NE of San Francisco) Individual Controls High-efficiency lighting is
controlled by switches and timers rather than
Sweetwater. Due to the issues related
Owner Sweetwater Spectrum occupancy sensors due to the potential dis- to sounds and visual patterns that
Principal Use Residential turbance occupancy sensors could cause this fans create, the design team instead
Includes Therapy pools, farm specific population.
elected to deliver fresh air discretely
Employees/Occupants 16 residents, 3 full-time Carbon Reduction Strategies 51 kW using a low-velocity ventilation air
staff, 8-12 contract employees photovoltaic system on site; solar thermal
collectors are designed to provide 68% of all system and visually unobtrusive slot
Percent Occupied 100%
domestic water heating needs. diffusers throughout occupied zones.
Gross Square Footage 16,315 Selection of a zoned hydronic radi-
Transportation Mitigation Strategies
Distinctions/Awards Estimated percent of occupants using alterna- ant heating system was a clear choice
2015 AIA/COTE, Top Ten Green Building Award; tive transportation: 40% from the outset, not only to support
2014 AIA National, Housing Award
the project’s low energy goals, but
Substantial Completion/Occupancy 2013 BUILDING ENVELOPE
also because it serves as the cleanest,
Roof quietest, least cluttered option when
ENERGY AT A GLANCE
Type Standing seam metal and built up seeing and experiencing a space,
Overall R-value 53.2
Annual Energy Use Intensity (EUI) (Site)
Reflectance 0.34 allowing for a quiet, calm and predict-
42.8 kBtu/ft2
Emittance 0.87 able environment.
Electricity (Grid Purchase) 28.4 kBtu/ft2
Electricity (on-Site Solar or Wind Installation) Walls
14.4 kBtu/ft2 Type Wood 2 × 6 framing, 24 in. o.c. Lighting. Similarly, motion-based
Overall R-value 22 lighting controls are considered star-
Annual On-Site Renewable Energy Exported 1.3
Glazing Percentage 22%
Annual Net Energy Use Intensity 27.2
tling to some individuals; instead,
Basement/Foundation outdoor site lighting is controlled based
Annual Source (Primary) Energy 103.7 Slab Edge Insulation R-value R-7.5
Under-Slab Insulation R-value R-10 on a day/night schedule, and interior
Annual Energy Cost Index (ECI) $1.33/ft2 lighting is controlled by switches and
Windows
Annual Load Factor 0.69 Effective U-factor for Assembly 0.29 vacancy sensors in staff areas. For
Savings vs. Calif. Title 24-2008 Design
Solar Heat Gain Coefficient (SHGC) 0.28 safety and durability, general area
Visual Transmittance 64
Building 30% (modeled) lighting fixtures are recessed or in a
Heating Degree Days (Base 65˚F) 2,513
Location light cove—an affordable and effective
Latitude 38° N
Cooling Degree Days (Base 65˚F) 445 Orientation SSW
method to deliver light that reduces
glare and breakage. In bedrooms, gen-
Annual Hours Occupied 8,760
BUILDING TEAM eral lighting is recessed in a cove, dis-
WATER AT A GLANCE
tributing even light across the ceiling.
Building Owner/Representative
Sweetwater Spectrum, Sonoma, Calif.
Annual Water Use 861,000 gallons: includes Equipment. Energy Star rated appli-
all four residences, community building and site Architect
irrigation except water used for the farm, which Leddy Maytum Stacy Architects, San Francisco
ances and induction cook tops are
is well water and is not metered used for safety and energy efficiency.
General Contractor
Midstate Construction, Petaluma, Calif.
KEY SUSTAINABLE FEATURES Water Use. Some people with ASDs
Mechanical, Electrical Engineer, Energy Modeler
Timmons Design Engineers, San Francisco
have patterns of using more domestic
Water Conservation 100% of storm water
managed on site; overall water use reduced by water than average. Bathrooms, kitch-
Structural Engineer
over 33%.
Structural Design Group, Santa Rosa, Calif. ens and laundry rooms are designed
Recycled Materials Over 10% of all materi- to accommodate those potential pat-
Civil Engineer
als are recycled, including fly ash in concrete,
Adobe Associates, Inc., Santa Rosa, Calif. terns of activity, and focus on limiting
carpet, aluminum, countertops, and steel. 15%
of all materials were regionally harvested and
wasted water and avoiding spilled
Landscape Architect Roche + Roche
manufactured to reduce embodied energy. Landscape Architecture, Sonoma, Calif. water damage.
Rapidly renewable materials include cotton
Lighting Design
Durable low-flow plumbing fixtures
insulation, rubber base, and linoleum flooring.
Architectural Lighting Design, San Francisco are used throughout the project, and
bathrooms are finished and plumbed
to collect and dispose of water. The
1 1
3
5 2 3
2 5
7 7
6 4 6
4
© LMS Architects
1. Photovoltaic & Solar Hot Water Panels 3. Operable Windows 6. Bio-swale
2. Low Velocity Ventilation System 4. Radiant Slab Heating & Cooling 7. Natural Ventilation
5. Solar Tube Skylights
therapy pools use high efficiency scale, with options to retreat within
olfactory input, another may be hypo-
filtration systems, solar hot water heat- each space, and the ability to preview
sensitive—that is, to seek more input.
ing systems, and year-round pool cov- a space before entering the next area
Thermal, visual, and acoustic comfort
ers to minimize water evaporation and (Figures 2 and 3). In terms of systems
issues had to be carefully tuned to
heat loss. designing, and in particular with the
align with the full range of the spec-
indoor-outdoor connections that are
trum and provide healthy, supportive
Beyond Thermal Comfort promoted by this approach, the subdi-
and safe environments.
Designing for a population with vision of zones for heating/cooling and
heightened comfort sensitivity brought Control, Choice, Independence. lighting were designed to promote a
about new methods and challenges The ASU Stardust Center advocates comfortable transition from one space
to consider in designing the build- for those with ASDs to have control to the next.
ings. Autism is a spectrum condition, over and options for how one experi- With respect to thermal comfort,
meaning every individual is unique. ences a space. The buildings and people with ASDs experience wide
While one adult living with ASDs landscape at Sweetwater are organized comfort ranges not dissimilar to the
might be hypersensitive to stimuli and as a series of thresholds, from the average population, but heightened
need to avoid certain audio/visual/ individual scale to the community in some cases. The microclimates
HOUSE
THRESHOLD
PREVIEW PREVIEW PREVIEW
INDIVIDUAL
RETREAT RETREAT RETREAT
THRESHOLD
THRESHOLD THRESHOLD THRESHOLD THRESHOLD THRESHOLD PLAZA THRESHOLD
© LMS Architects
© LMS Architects
THRESHOLD THRESHOLD
THERAPY POOL
HOUSE HOUSE
© Tim Griffith
Social areas extend into the landscape, with a
series of courtyards, active and contemplative
spaces, therapy pool, and one-acre farm.
© Marion Brennar
© Kyle Jeffers
created in the landscape—from the Visual Comfort. Research sug- light source. 100% of regularly occu-
shade of the community terrace, to the gests that access to daylight can have pied spaces have views to the out-
warm sunny conditions at the urban positive health effects for people with doors, with direct connection to out-
farm, to the evaporative cooling effects ASDs. Integrating proper orientation, door areas including private patios,
of the therapy pool area—each zone well-positioned windows, and tubular community terraces, and gardens.
contributes a unique thermal environ- skylights, 100% of the primary resi- This connection to nature is a power-
ment. Inside the residences, all win- dential and program areas are day-lit. ful driver to allow a sense of place
dows are operable and each room is Overall, 93% of all buildings’ and familiarity over time.
separately zoned. spaces use daylight as their primary
© Tim Griffith
© Tim Griffith
Aug 2013
Sep 2013
Oct 2013
Nov 2013
Dec 2013
Jan 2014
Feb 2014
Mar 2014
Apr 2014
May 2014
Jun 2014
July 2014
Post-Occupancy Monitoring
While Sweetwater was originally
designed to reach zero net energy,
the project budget did not allow for
the purchase of the photovoltaic
solar panels as part of the initial
project. The final construction bid for
Sweetwater only included the instal-
lation of the domestic solar hot water
system on each building and for the
therapy pool and spas. However, a
third party renewable energy service
provider installed the photovoltaic
© Tim Griffith
solar panels as part of a power pur-
chase agreement.
Although the project budget only allowed In addition to the benefit of reduced
for the installation of half of the PV pan-
els needed to meet the modeled energy
energy costs during the lease period,
project’s energy goals were achieved Sweetwater Spectrum has addi- Weaving these spaces together with
(Figures 4 and 5, Page 20). During this tional energy audits and project a sensitivity to solar access and low-
period the net site energy use intensity evaluations underway to study the energy systems demonstrates that
for the entire complex, including PV replicability of this housing model. achieving low energy goals does not
contribution, was 27 kBtu/ft2, while the It is also partnering with Dominican compete with, but rather enhances the
gross EUI was 43 kBtu/ft2. University and the University of design of a generous environment that
In the residence, the monitoring California San Francisco to conduct embraces calm, clarity and comfort. •
assessment found that energy use had research on resident satisfaction
significant deviations from what was and quality of life indicators for this
modeled, mostly due to higher light- residential community for adults Web Exclusive Q&A
ing and plug loads. The residence that with autism. Learn more about how the authors
approached this project and the
was monitored has a higher level of challenges they encountered.
staffing requirement than other resi- Conclusion
http://www.hpbmagazine.org/
dences in the facility, and is staffed Sweetwater Spectrum has established
Web-Exclusive-Q-A-Sweetwater
24 hours per day. Over the course of new territory in architecture and sys-
a day, 10 people, including staff and tems design: an intersection of ZNE
visitors, may spend time in the build- goals and autism specific design.
ing designed for four residents. (See This combination brings to bear a ABOUT THE AUTHORS
Lessons Learned.) climate-sensitive, human-centric Marsha Maytum, FAIA, LEED AP, is a prin-
Additionally, during the monitoring approach; passive techniques and cipal at Leddy Maytum Stacy Architects in
study, fans and the air-to-water heat load reduction goes hand in hand San Francisco.
pumps were found to be operating with a sensitivity to creating open Gwen Fuertes, Associate AIA, LEED AP,
inconsistently. A retro-commissioning thresholds and ability for residents to is with Leddy Maytum Stacy Architects in
of these systems occurred after the have options and control within their San Francisco.
study was completed to improve sys- space—an approach that can serve
tem functionality. as a model for other projects.
COMPREHENSIVE COVERAGE OF
DISTRICT HEATING AND COOLING
SYSTEM DESIGN
Get both books for one low price
Select features:
• Comprehensive coverage of district heating
and cooling system design
• Equal depth in coverage for both
steam and hot water based systems
• Detailed coverage of piping systems
for chilled water distribution
AVAILABLE NOW • Coverage of cogeneration and thermal storage
Price: $179 ($152 ASHRAE Member) as well as O&M issues
www.ashrae.org/districtguide
HPB.hotims.com/60105-15
HPB.hotims.com/60105-2