TO
CHIREC MUN
2014
Speak. Hear. Resolve.
July 18 19 and 20
th th th
2. Behaviour:
A delegate has to behave cordially at all times in or out of committee.
Delegates have to be respectful to their fellow delegate, the executive
board and the secretariat. Any delegate caught exhibiting
unparliamentarily or unruly behaviour will be suspended from the
conference.
Smoking is prohibited in all conference buildings at all times. Alcohol
and illegal drugs are prohibited at all times. Any delegate caught in
possession of alcoholic beverages or illegal drugs will be barred from
the conference.
Yields
The usage of yields is restricted to formal debate. Once a delegate has
finished speaking on the general speaker’s list or a provisional speaker’s
list, and still has some time remaining, he/she can yield to the following:
1. To the chair: Delegates have the option to yield their remaining time
to chair. Once this is done, the delegate can simply go back to his/her
seat.
2. To another delegate: This yield is usually made when the resolution is
being discussed through a provisional speaker’s list. In this yield, the
speaker can yield their remaining time to another delegate.
Motions
1. Motion to set the agenda: This is the first motion raised in an MUN
conference. It is used to change the default order of the agenda. This is
a debatable motion and once it is raised 2 delegates are selected to
speak for it and 2 delegates are selected to speak against it. Once all
the speakers have spoken simple placard voting is conducted. The
motion passes with simple majority (50%+1).
2. Motion to open General Speaker’s List: This motion is raised once the
agenda has been set. It requires simple majority
3. Motion to set Speaker’s time: This motion allows delegates to set the
speaker’s time in the. The time limit can be increased or decreased to
any extent. This motion is debatable, 2 delegates speak for and against.
It passes by simple majority.
11. Motion to divide the question: question: Once debate on a topic has
been closed a delegate can raise a motion to divide the draft resolution
into part A and part B (the number of parts can be more than 2) and
that voting on each part should take place separately. This is a
debatable motion where 2 speakers will speak for and 2 speakers will
speak against the motion. After this the chair will take a vote. The
motion passes with simple majority. Each part is taken as separate
resolution and is subject to a substantive vote.
Plea to follow up
A plea to follow up is used when a delegate feels that another delegate
hasn’t answered his/her question/point of information satisfactorily. It
can only be asked by the delegate whose point of information was
recognized. In essence it is a tool used to cross question.
Right to Reply
If a member of the committee makes a personal attack on another
delegate, then the offended delegate is permitted to reply to the
delegate. It is not applicable is an attack is made on the delegate’s
stance. The chair makes the ultimate ruling to whether the delegate in
question deserves a right of reply. All rights of reply must be submitted
in writing to the chair.
Flow of Debate
Roll Call
The roll call is the first order of business in any MUN conference. The
Assistant Director begins with reading aloud the names of all member
states. A delegate can respond to their roll call either as ‘present’ or
‘present and voting’. A ‘present and voting’ response to the roll call
prevents a delegate from abstaining on a substantive vote.
Formal Debate
It is the ‘standard’ debate that occurs at an MUN conference. Delegates
speak for a certain amount of time in an order based on the speaker’s
list. Formal debate includes all speeches made in the GSL. Every GSL
speech can be subject to questions at the delegate's discretion. Formal
debate must end before moving into informal debate.
Informal Debate
As and when the committee deems fit, it can move into informal debate
through the use of a motion. Informal debate has 2 components:
1. Moderated Caucus: The moderated caucus is by far one of the most
important parts of an MUN. It is simply a discussion on any topic that
falls within the ambit of the entire agenda. It facilitates freer exchange of
ideas, delegates remain seated and the chair will call on willing
delegates to speak one at a time. A moderated caucus can be initiated
by raising a motion to suspend formal debate.
2. Unmoderated Caucus: A type of caucus in which delegates leave
their seats to mingle and speak freely. Enables the free sharing of ideas
to an extent not possible in formal debate or moderated caucuses.
Unmoderated Caucuses are used by delegates to divide themselves into
blocs, find support and to write working papers and draft resolutions.
An unmoderated caucus can be started through a motion to suspend
debate.
Resolution Process
The process involving the introduction of a resolution, its modification
and its passing is called the resolution process. The resolution process
begins with the introduction of the working paper.
1. Working Paper:
• A working paper is pre-cursor to the final resolution.
• A working paper is usually worked on during an Un-moderated
caucus and is introduced once the committee feels that the
agenda has been sufficiently discussed through debate taking
place in both the formal and informal format.
• It is simply a list of proposed solutions.
• Once a working paper is prepared sufficiently by a bloc, it is
submitted to the executive board.
• The executive board will only accept the working paper if it has the
support of more than 20% of member states present at that time.
• New points and ideas should be added and when a working paper
is comprehensive enough, delegates should formulate it into a
draft resolution.
• If 2 working papers are similar then the executive can ask the
authors or the 2 submitting blocs to merge the working papers.
2. Draft Resolution:
Format-
DRAFT RESOLUTION
Committee: ABC
Agenda: xyz
Sponsors: USA, UK…. (maximum 4-5, sometimes 2)
Signatories: India, China, Afghanistan…. (no upper limit)
Pre-ambulatory Clauses:
Clause 1 beginning……… ,
Clause 2 beginning……… ,
Clause 3 beginning……… , (pre-ambulatory clauses are not numbered.)
Operative Clauses:
1. …………;
2. ………….;
3. ………… .( the last operative clause ends with a full stop)
• A draft resolution is a document that seeks to fix the problems
addressed by a committee. If passed the draft resolution becomes
a resolution.
• Sponsor: A sponsor is a delegate who has played an integral part
in the formulation of a draft resolution. A sponsor knows and can
defend all the points of the draft resolution.
• Signatory: A signatory is a delegate who simply wants to see the
draft resolution discussed in committee.
• Pre- ambulatory clauses: They describe the problem being
addressed, recall past actions, explain the purpose of the
resolution and offer support for the operative clauses that follow.
Each clause in the preamble begins with an underlines word that
and ends with a comma.
• The total number of Sponsors and Signatories must constitute at
least 20% of the total committee present.
• Operative clause: They are numbered and state the action to be
taken by the body. These clauses all begin with present tense
active verbs, which are generally stronger than those used in the
preamble. Each operative clause is followed by a semi colon and
the last operative clause end with a period.
• Once the draft resolution has been introduced, it can be discussed
either through a moderated caucus or a provisional speaker’s list.
In each case sponsors are expected to defend their draft
resolution and answer any questions with regards to it that will be
brought up by the delegates of the committee.
Addition
Amendment
To: Executive Board
From: (Country name)
Draft Resolution (number of draft resolution to be amended)
-------New clause-------
Deletion
Amendment
To: Executive Board
From: (Country name)
Draft resolution (number of draft resolution to be amended)
Deletion of clause x
Modification
Amendment
To: Executive Board
From: (Country name)
Draft resolution(number of draft resolution to be amended)
Original clause:----------
New clause:----------
Voting
Voting on any draft resolution can be done only when a motion to
close debate is passed by the committee. Delegates can vote in 3
different ways- yes, no or abstain. A resolution can only pass if it has
2/3rd majority support of the committee minus the absent members and
abstaining members. If a delegate replied ‘present’ to the roll call then
all the 3 options of agreeing, disagreeing and abstaining to a resolution
are present. However, if a delegate replied ‘present and voting’ to the
roll call, then during the voting for a resolution that delegate does not
have the choice to abstain from a resolution. Available votes to
delegates:
1. Yes- The delegate agrees to a resolution.
2. No- The delegate disagrees to a resolution.
3. Abstain- The delegate has no opinion of the resolution and it does
not matter to the respective country if it passes or fails.
4. No with rights- This is used if a sponsor has to say no to his/her
own resolution usually when it has been amended to an extent
that it goes against the delegate’s foreign policy.
5. Pass-When this is used, the delegate vote is not registered, and
the delegate shall be recalled after completion of voting to
register his/her vote.
Position Paper
Writing a well-researched and substantive position paper is the best way to
prepare for any Model United Nations conference. Through the position paper
your delegation will express its ideas and policies by defining your nation -state’s
perspective on the issues at hand. Moreover, it is the means by which you bring all
of your research together in a logical and succinct form.
Overview
Researching and writing a position paper go hand in hand. While researching will
give you an overwhelming amount of information, it is through the position paper
that you will be able to narrow in on the mission you have set before yourself. In
writing the position paper, you will be able to understand the complexity of the
situations and issues, as seen from your country’s vantage point. To say it simply,
you will be condensing the vast amounts of books, magazine articles, newspaper
clippings, and websites you’ve collected down to just a few more comprehensible
pages.
After breaking it down, your position paper should flow smoothly. What you
should aim for is quality not quantity. Overall, your position paper should exhibit
the following:
comprehensive research into the matter
an organized and argumentative structure
original thinking that follows with the policy of the represented state.
an attitude of seriousness to the issues in question
Requirements
One position paper is due per delegation (country) for each topic on the
committee agenda, whether it has been assigned to a single delegate or
partnership.
8.5 inch by 11 inch paper (A4 size)
No cover page
1 inch margins on all sides (top, left, right, and bottom)
typed in 12 point Times New Roman font
1 page per topic
all quotations must be citied
All position paper will be extensively cross referenced through various sources, both
online and in-print. If there is any evidence of using the work of others without citations,
the position paper will not be eligible for an award.
Delegates must also remember to correctly cite sources, and papers without any cited
sources will not be accepted. All Position Papers must be emailed by 10 th July, 2014 to
their committee chair’s email ID.