Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
1021204
This article deals with coins of varying consistency in silver and the problems of conserving them. The
aim of the research was to find the most suitable method for the conservation of poorly preserved
early post-medieval period coins with varying composition. To achieve this, first, the composition of
both the metal and the corrosion products of the ancient coins were analysed, and then comparisons
of experiments with different cleaning methods were carried out in order to find out the least harm-
ful and most efficient one. A test was also performed to determine the necessity and efficiency of
stabilising the surface of the coins after cleaning.
1. Introduction
The earliest hoard of coins found in Estonia dates back
to the Early Iron Age (1st–5th century AD), but most of
the hoards found date to the period of 1558–1611. While
from the entire Middle Ages we only have information
about fifty coin hoards, the turn of the 16th and 17th cen-
turies has brought about hundreds of discoveries which
contain tens of thousands of coins (Kiudsoo 2007: 3–6).
This extraordinary number of hoards is primarily related
to the Livonian War (1558–1583) and the Polish-Swedish
Wars (1600–1629) during which large number of the
inhabitants of Estonia and Livonia perished and whose Fig. 1: Cross-section of the edge of a schilling (AI 5000,
meagre savings, hidden in the ground, out of fear of wars, 964:24). The sparse surface layer rich in silver was
remained there for centuries. This circumstance points to formed due to selective corrosion.
the magnitude of tragedy that beset the country, but on 2. The environment of the finds and condition of
the other hand provides researchers with an opportunity the objects
to study abundant material (Kiudsoo 2007: 23–24). One
Preservation of objects in the environment is affected by
peculiarity of the coins dating back to the Livonian War
a number of factors: mechanical and chemical parameters
is the fact that often they only have a very thin surface
of the soil, conditions of humidity, contact with air, mov-
layer rich in silver, while the content of silver in the bulk
ing of objects (arable lands), and also the composition
material is very small (even below 10%). The conservation
of the material, its homogeneity and other materials in
of such coins is very complicated and it is easy to spoil
direct contact with it, the macro- and micro-composition
them irrevocably by inept handling. The aim of this pro-
arising from its manufacture and finally the quality of the
ject was to develop reliable methods for conservation of
surface of the metal (Watkinson and Neal 2001: 1–8).
debased silver coins which are poorly preserved. The coin
Archaeological silver (which in the case of coins may
collection of the Institute of History (IH) of Tallinn Univer-
also contain a substantial amount of copper) may easily
sity was used as source material; cleaning methods were
become brittle after lying in the soil for a long time. The
tested on recently excavated coins from several medieval
reasons for this are changes in its microstructure caused
and early post-medieval hoards. Samples were selected by
by corrosion and long-term ageing. Although silver is gen-
the principle that all main types of coins used in this area
erally little susceptible to corrosion, one can still come
should be represented. Coins the conservation of which
across mineralised objects that are extremely fragile. The
does not usually cause serious problems because of the-
surface of the silver may be porous and easily damaged,
high silver content - for instance thalers and Russian wire
if copper (or another alloying element) has vanished due
kopecks - were left out.
to selective corrosion and the object has thus acquired an
‘enriched’ layer of silver (figure 1).
In unfavourable conditions, the silver-copper alloys tend
Conservator, Institute of History,
*
Tallinn University, Estonia first to lose copper, leaving behind a surface layer rich in
aive.viljus@gmail.com silver. Such objects are often fully covered with the cor-
†
Senior Researcher, Center for Materials Research, rosion products of copper, which is why they can be mis-
Tallinn University of Technology, Estonia takenly taken for copper materials, if determined only by
mart.viljus@gmail.com
The Conservation of Early Post-Medieval Period Coins Found in Estonia 31
Fig. 3: X-ray diffraction pattern of coins: a – Otepää (946:26); b – Kaarma (10588:406), c – Kaarma (10588:405), d –
Kaarma (10588:5).
Table 1: Composition of analysed coins analysed with EDS grouped according to Ag content in group A (Ag content over
30%) and B (Ag content below 30%) (last column). The coins found in Padise, Harju-Risti and Kurna are recently exca-
vated and, as they are currently under identification-registration process, they have so far only temporary ID numbers.
Experience has shown that with coins containing 30% or the conservation laboratory, it is not easy to distinguish
more silver, there are usually little, if any, serious conser- whether their alloy is predominantly silver, copper, or
vation issues, while the lower-content pieces are highly whether it contains any other impurities. The simple
sensitive to improper handling. So, from a conservators’ laboratory tests may also not be of help, for these are
viewpoint, coins can be classified into two groups: mostly based on the reaction of the surface layer of the
A - silver content 30% or more coin and may therefore yield misleading results. Hence,
B - silver content below 30% although handling of silver itself is generally less critical
than of other metals, there may be a considerable amount
Hereinafter, coins used in the current experiment are
of copper in a seemingly silver object. If one is not sure
marked as group A or B, according to their composition.
about the composition of the metal and does not know
3.2 Conservation methods of archaeological coins whether it contains more silver or copper, it is safer to
treat it as copper (Hamilton 1999: 304).
Coin hoards can contain hundreds, or even thousands of Within this experiment, it was decided to try out some
coins, which have to be identified by numismatists. The of the conservation procedures found in literature and
surface of coins and their legends are often hidden below determine based on the results their suitability for the
corrosion products and burial deposits. Coin hoards must conservation of coins found in hoards of the early post-
be treated with an efficient and non-damaging way in medieval period. Coins with lesser numismatic value
order to reveal the surface legends and produce coins that from several hoards and finds were used as trial objects.
are stable in the museum environment. Emphasis was on chemical methods as the large amount
When a collection of recently excavated coins, often of material to be conserved in a typical coin hoard makes
covered with dirt or corroded together, is delivered to it difficult to treat coins individually by hand. In the lit-
34 The Conservation of Early Post-Medieval Period Coins Found in Estonia
the principles of minimal intervention and reversibility. In age, final cleaning was performed with formic acid solu-
the current experiment it was only used as an emergency tion (figure 12, additional treatment). A newly-minted,
measure for restoring the appearance of the coins after group B sample coin was damaged by becoming tarnished
unsuccessful electrochemical treatment. and porous (figure 13). The surface of a group A coin
remained visually unchanged.
3.2.3 Chemical cleaning
Conclusion: The solution of ammonia cannot be recom-
A large part of archaeological silver objects only needs mended for cleaning archaeological silver coins, because
slight treatment. In most cases, corrosion products can most of them are alloyed with copper and ammonia dam-
be removed with a simple chemical solution. Various for- ages the structure of the surface of coins by reacting with Cu.
mulas and solutions for cleaning silver and copper can be Acetic acid: Acetic acid is a relatively weak acid, which is
found in several sources (Thickett and Enderly 1997: 185; why separation of corrosion products is slow (it may take
days or even weeks). For this reason, however, the process
Fig. 13: Surface of a newly minted sample coin of group B is easily observable and entails minimal risk (Nikitin and
(94% Cu - 6% Ag) before (a) and after (b) treatment with Melnikova 2002: 130).
a solution of ammonia. Experiment: Archaeological coins from groups A and B were
treated with a 10% acetic acid solution from 3 to 24 hours.
Nikitin and Melnikova 2002: 128–129, 172–173; Rodg- Result: In 6 hours a blue, surface corrosion layer was sepa-
ers 2004: 107–119). Usually, silver and copper are dealt rated from a group A coin. In 24 hours the rest of the cor-
with separately, which is why the presented formulas rosion products separated only partially and final cleaning
and recommendations have to be taken with a reason- was performed with formic acid solution. The group B coin
able caution. In the specialised literature, solutions based was cleaned completely in 3 hours (figure 14).
on organic acids, EDTA and ammonia are mostly recom- Conclusion: The procedure may be recommended for
mended. cleaning both A and B group coins but one should con-
Ammonia: Many formulas for cleaning silver contain sider the time-consuming nature of the treatment in case
ammonia, but with archaeological coins the term silver of thicker corrosion layers.
must be taken ‘with a grain of salt’, because often the Formic acid: Formic acid is the strongest organic
main component of the material is copper. Ammonia acid, which is why it is also very effective as a cleaning
is dangerous for copper because oxygen present in the agent for archaeological coins. Separation of most cor-
air reacts with copper and causes corrosion. With the rosion products and burial deposits takes place quite
alloys of silver and copper the use of ammonia has to quickly (usually in 1–3 hours). Some corrosion products,
be regarded with the greatest caution (Nikitin and Mel- however, may need longer treatment; in most cases a
nikova 2002: 130). positive result is more or less guaranteed. In the Brit-
Experiment: An archaeological coin (group A, ish Museum, 30% formic acid solution is also used for
SM10588:754) was treated in a 10% solution of ammo- removing cuprite corrosion from debased silver coins
nia for 6 and 24 hours; and, a comparative experiment (Thickett and Enderly 1997: 185). In the current experi-
was performed in the same conditions with new, specially ment it was not a coincidence that, in case of insufficient
made sample coins with silver content of 50% and 6% effect of less active chemicals, additional treatment was
(group A and B). mostly (and successfully) applied with formic acid solu-
Result: In 24 hours, not all corrosion products were tion. Due to the pungent odour and irritating effect,
separated from the coin, but the surface of the metal had any handling of formic acid should be conducted under
become very porous (figure 12, initial treatment, upper a fume hood and contact with skin should be avoided
half of the coin). To save the artifact from further dam- (Dedik 1989: 97).
The Conservation of Early Post-Medieval Period Coins Found in Estonia 37
Ammonium tiosulphate and sodium tiosulphate have 233; Nikitin and Melnikova 2002: 174). Ammonium tio-
been used for treatment of archaeological silver artefacts sulphate is able to dissolve even the almost insoluble sil-
for decades. Both are also used in photography as fixing ver sulphide layer (Selwyn 2004: 137) and is used on regu-
agents. The role of fixers in photography is to remove lar basis for removal of silver chloride deposits (Ghoneim
unexposed silver halides from the image by transforming and Megahed 2009: 149). In some cases, however, ammo-
them to water-soluble complex compounds, which can nium tiosulphate has been reported to work insufficiently
be easily washed out. The same complexing reactions are (Lowenstam et al. 1987: 8) and to have a tendency to etch
applied for the removal of insoluble halides and sulphides the surface of already clean silver (Boyd and Mango 1992:
from the surface of archaeological silver (Cronyn 1990: 85). In debased silver coins found in earth, horn silver is
38 The Conservation of Early Post-Medieval Period Coins Found in Estonia
Fig. 27: Coins of group B from the same hoard after different treatment: a - SM 10663:1809, alkaline Rochelle solution;
b - SM 10663:4, formic acid solution; c - SM 10663:1803, sodium tiosulphate solution; d - SM 10663:1805, electrolysis
in sodium carbonate solution; e - SM 10663:1821, galvanic treatment in alkaline Rochelle solution.
Fig. 28: The effect of light on coated and uncoated coins: I - before the experiment, II - after the experiment; a – un-
covered, b – Paraloid B-72, 15% solution, c – microcrystalline wax.
Electrochemical treatment
Type/agent Solution Recommendations
Galvanic sodium carbonate effect questionable
alkaline Rochelle salt not recommended
Electrolytic sodium carbonate not recommended
sodium hydroxide not recommended
formic acid effect questionable
Chemical treatment
Acidic acetic acid recommended*
formic acid recommended
EDTA recommended
Alkaline alkaline Rochelle salt recommended
ammonia not recommended
Complexing sodium tiosulphate recommended
thiourea not recommended
Reducing alkaline dithionite effect questionable
Table 2: Recommendations for cleaning debased archaeological silver coins with electrochemical and chemical methods,
based on current experiments. * All recommended solutions have their terms and limitations, for details see above.
44 The Conservation of Early Post-Medieval Period Coins Found in Estonia
Moreover, the laser impulse damages the surface of the of 4th International Congress on Science and Technology
coin by melting locally the surface layer of the coin. for the Safeguard of Cultural Heritage in the Mediter-
• Stabilisation of properly cleaned and correctly pre- ranean Basin. Vol. II. Cairo, Egypt, 6th-8th December
served coins by coating is generally not necessary. Sta- 2009. Italy: Angelo Ferrari and CNR, Institute of Chem-
bilising may appear necessary when the preservation ical Methodologies, 143–153.
environment contains chemicals damaging the metal Hamilton, D L 1999 Conservation of Cultural Materials
of coins or if coins have been previously cleaned with from Underwater Sites. Archives and Museum Infor-
a blaster or some other destructive method. matics 13 (3–4), 291–323.
Recommendations about particular chemical agents are Hickman, B (ed.) 1977 Japanese Crafts: Materials and
presented in Table 2, based on the results with the low- their Applications. London: Fine Books Oriental.
grade (group B) silver coins, as they are more sensitive. Hucke, J, and Bleck, R D 1983 Restaurierung und Muse-
umstechnik, Chemikalien und Rezepte. Weimar: Muse-
Acknowledgements um für Ur- und Frühgeschichte Thüringens.
Kiudsoo, M 2007 Estonian Medieval and Post-Medieval
This work was supported by research project ETF7680 Hoards. Coins and their Periods of Circulation. Master
and program HLK04–2. Authors are also grateful to Mauri thesis (in Estonian). University of Tartu. http://hdl.
Kiudsoo (Institute of History of Tallinn University), Villu handle.net/10062/2756
Kadakas (Agu EMS OÜ) and Sergey Sarap (Vitaclinika). Koh, Y S 2006 Laser Cleaning as a Conservation Technique
for Corroded Metal Artifacts. Doctoral Thesis, Luleå
Notes University of Technology, Sweden.
Numbers in brackets refer to the names of the hoards
1 Lowenstam, S, Moore, M B and Kenrick, P M 1987 The
and sample IDs. Extramural Sanctuary of Demeter and Persephone at
Cyrene, Libya. 3. Scarabs, Inscribed Gems, and Engraved
References Finger Rings, Part IV, Philadelphia: University of Penn-
sylvania, Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology.
Al-Saad, Z and Bani-Hani, M 2007 Corrosion Behavior and MacLeod, I, and North, N A 1979 Conservation of Cor-
Preservation of Islamic Silver Alloy Coins. In: Argyropou- roded Silver. Studies in Conservartion 24, 165–170.
los, V, Hein, A and Abdel-Harith, M (eds.) Strategies for Nikitin, M K and Melnikova, E P 2002 Chemistry in Res-
Saving our Cultural Heritage. Proceedings of Interna- toration (in Russian). St Peterburg.
tional Conference on Strategies for Saving Indoor Metallic Pini, R, Siano, S, Salimbeni, R, Pasquinucci, M and Mic-
Collections. Cairo, 25 February - 1 March 2007. Athens: cio, M 2000 Tests of Laser Cleaning on Archeological
Technological Educational Institute, Department of Metal Artefacts. Journal of Cultural Heritage 1, 129–137.
Conservation of Antiquities and Works of Art, 177–183. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S1296–2074(00)00139–4
Boyd, S A and Mango, M M 1992 Ecclesiastical Silver Plate Plenderleith, H J, and Torraca, G 1968 The Conserva-
in Sixth-Century Byzantium. Washington D.C.: Dumbar- tion of Metals in the Tropics. In: The Conservation of
ton Oaks, Trustees for Harvard University. Cultural Property. Museum and Monuments 11. Paris:
Cronyn, J M 1990 The Elements of Archaeological Conser- UNESCO, 237–249.
vation. New York, London: Routlege. Rodgers, B A 2004 The Archaeologist’s Manual for Conser-
Dedik, V N 1989 Restoration of Metal (in Russian). vation. New York: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Moscow. Scott, D A 2002 Copper and Bronze in Art: Corrosion, Col-
Doménech-Carbó, A, Doménech-Carbó, M T and Cos- orants, Conservation. Los Angeles: Getty Publications.
ta, V (eds.) 2009 Electrochemical Methods in Archaeom- Selwyn, L 2004 Metals and Corrosion. Ottawa: Canadian
etry, Conservation and Restoration. Berlin, Heidelberg: Conservation Istitute.
Springer-Verlag. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978–3- Smith, S C, and Gnudi, M T (ed. and transl.) 1990 The
540–92868-3 Pirotechnia of Vannoccio Biringuccio: The Classic Six-
Drakaki, E, Karydas, A G, Klinkenberg, B, Kokkoris, teenth-Century Treatise on Metals and Metallurgy. New
M, Serafetinides, A A, Stavrou, E, Vlastou, R and York: Dover Publications.
Zarkadas, C 2004 Laser Cleaning on Roman Coins. Thickett, D, and Enderly, C 1997 The Cleaning of Coin
Applied Physics A 79, 1111–1115, http://dx.doi.org/ Hoards: The Benefits of a Collaborative Approach. Brit-
10.1007/s00339–004-2657–3 ish Museum Occasional Paper No.116. London: British
Ghoneim, M A M, and Megahed, M M 2009 Treatment Museum, 183–192.
and Conservation of a Group of Roman Coins Discov- Watkinson, D and Neal, V 2001 First Aid for Finds. Lon-
ered in Tell Basta, Egypt. In: Ferrari, A (ed.) Proceedings don: RESCUE/UKIC Archaeology Section.