Sie sind auf Seite 1von 5

2018 IEEE 3rd International Conference on Intelligent Energy and Power Systems (IEPS)

Energy Efficiency of Microgrid Implementation with


Solar Photovoltaic Power Plants
Dmitry Tugay, Serhii Kotelevets, Serhii Korneliuk George Zhemerov, life member, IEEE
Dept. of Alternative Power Engineering and Electrical Dept. of Industrial and Biomedical Electronics
Engineering National Technical University “KhPI”
O.M. Beketov NUUE Kharkiv, Ukraine
Kharkiv, Ukraine zhemerov@gmail.com
tugaydmytro@gmail.com

Abstract— The work with the use of simulation in the software basis of distributed solar power plants, power consuming
Matlab / Simulink / SymPowerSystems environment considers storage and power filtering devices using simulation tools.
construction of a local Smart Grid energy supply system with
distributed solar power plants. The obtained model allows us to II. LOCAL MICROGRID BLOCK DIAGRAM
investigate the work of the intelligent network in any quasi-steady As an object for the implementation of microgrid we shall
and transitional modes, including emergency ones. A distinctive
consider a local energy supply system, which is a collection of
feature of the proposed model is the localization of places for the
small households, whose electricity is supplied from the
installation of power active filter-compensating devices, the use of
which allows providing the necessary quality of electric energy and transformer substation along the trunk circuit with a four-wire
achieving the minimum energy losses in the elements of the energy 0.4 kV cable line (Fig. 1). The useful installed power of the
supply system. According to the results of the simulation, the load is 8, 5, 4.2, 3 and 4 kW respectively. The reactive power
comparison of the energy efficiency of the traditional energy supply of the load is 7, 4, 2, 2 and 4 kVAr respectively. The third load
system and Smart Grid has been made. contains nonlinear elements. The distances between the loads
are 100 m, and the cable cross-section of the cable lines
Keywords—energy supply system, microgrid, minimum energy starting from the transformer are 10, 6, 4, 2.5 mm2 respectively.
losses, solar power plant, efficiency, short cut power, useful power We shall suppose that some distributed households have a solar
power plant nominal power of 10, 5 and 3 kW installed that
I. INTRODUCTION can operate in both the network and autonomous modes.
The change of the concept of developing modern power
engineering is conditioned by growing interest in renewable
energy sources [1–9]. The most rapid pace of the development
among low-power distributed renewable energy sources is
presented by private solar power plants, which operate both
autonomously, and can be integrated into the industrial
network [7, 9–14].
Structural changes in the electricity market, where the
consumer acquires additional functionalities and partial energy
independence, contributed to the emergence of a new concept
of energy development – Smart Grid. The most significant
feature of Smart Grid is the presence of a bi-directional energy Fig. 1. Microgrid schematics of the local energy supply system
flow in the elements of the energy supply system (ESS) [3, 10].
Operation of the Smart Grid ESS is conditioned by the The implementation of microgrid is carried out by
operation of the industrial network, renewable energy sources installing specialized power equipment, the work of which is
and variable load profiles. In the intelligent ESS with small controlled by the information management system, according
solar power plants, the combination of such modes causes to the state of the ESS at the current time.
some difficulties in implementing an information management Parallel power active filters (PAF) (blocks PAF 1 and PAF 2)
system that would ensure not only high reliability of power are connected in common connection points of loads. The tasks
supply but also increase its energy efficiency [11–15]. solved by installing filters related to ensuring the required quality
Therefore, at the pre-design stage, close attention should be of electricity are compensation of reactive power, elimination of
paid to the means of computer simulation to study the work of higher harmonic components of network currents and asymmetry
the smart ESS in operating and emergency modes. of currents in terms of uneven loading of phases.
The aim of the article is to study of the operating modes At an even distance from the distributed solar power
and energy efficiency assessment of local microgrid on the plants, a system energy-saving storage device (ES) is installed,

978-1-5386-9545-6/18/$31.00 ©2018 IEEE 275


2018 IEEE 3rd International Conference on Intelligent Energy and Power Systems (IEPS)

which is designed to solve two key tasks – performing the


function of the backup power supply in the autonomous
operating modes of the system and the alignment of the load
profile, that is, the elimination of daily peaks and failures in
power consumption. The implementation of these functions,
combined with the installation of power active filters will
minimize losses in the line and elements of ESS [19, 20]. The
results of the performed calculations have shown that,
depending on the parameters of the ESS, the theoretically
possible reduction in the energy losses is in the range of 2 to
15% [19]. If the level of loss reduction is greater than the loss
in the installed equipment, the implementation of these
measures is energy justifiable.
The formed network structure allows implementing
separately the energy supply system of direct current (Fig. 1).
The system energy storage is charged from distributed solar Fig. 2. Daily graphs of solar insolation (E) and load profile (*)
power plants, and in case of full charge, network inverters are
switched on, and renewable sources give energy to the AC The total relative losses power in the three-phase four-weir
network. In offline mode, when the automatic switch in the ESS to the PAF connection is determined by the ratio [19]
beginning of the AC supply lines is open, with the help of a
stand-alone inverter, the sinusoidal voltage is formed with a
frequency of 50 Hz and the energy supply of the loads (
2
ΔPΣ* = ΔPmin* 1 + QRMS 2
* + PpulsRMS * + ) (2)
+ ΔPn* ⋅ (1 + ΔPmin* )2 .
connected to the microgrid is carried out from the system ES.
Independent DC power can be connected by the appropriate
low-power load or electric vehicles, both for recharging on-
board batteries and as additional backup sources. where QRMS* = QRMS/Pusf – relative RMS of the reactive power,
measured on the transformer busbar; PpulsRMS* =
The diversity of the modes of operation of microgrid is PpulsRMS* = PpulsRMS/Pusf – is the relative mean square value of
provided by an additional information level (Fig. 1), which the variable component of the instantaneous active power;
collects information about the status of each element of the Pn* = Pn/Pusf – the relative losses power from the current
system and, in accordance with the priority algorithms, control flow through zero wire. For three-phase three-conductor or
impacts are formed, which are worked out by power symmetric three-phase four-conductor ESS Pn* = 0.
semiconductor converters.
The relative value of the minimum possible losses power
III. ENERGY-SAVING EFFECTS OF MICROGRID IMPLEMENTING can be calculated after the circuit is transformed in Fig. 1 to the
equivalent one, representing a serial connection of an energy
The efficiency of solar power plants depends to a large
source, a Rs resistor and a resistor RL. The Rs resistor imitates
extent on weather conditions and seasons. Therefore, during
the equivalent resistance of the connecting cable line which the
the implementation of microgrid the solar irradiance level in a
load is connected to. The RL resistor imitates an equivalent load
particular region, which is often presented as a daily graph for
resistance, which determines the average useful power of Pusf.
each calendar month, should be taken into account. Also,
For trunk circuit ESS, the relative value of the minimum
during the calendar year, the daily load profile changes. The
possible losses power is determined by two methods – by the
overlay of these two charts allows predicting the share of
short circuit test, carried out on the clamps of the most distant
electricity that will be consumed by microgrid objects from
from the power supply of the load, or by measuring the
the industrial network, taking into account the generation of
equivalent resistance of the ESS at the beginning of the trunk
alternative sources, and hence the reduction of the current
line R(*), which is a function of the variable load profile.
density in the supply cable and the losses power from its flow.
Figure 2 shows a daily graph of solar insolation (E) for a July According to the second method
day, typical for eastern Ukraine [16], and a daily load profile
in the fractions of the maximum installed power P* = P/PH, n P n P
RS
which is typical for household loading [17, 18]. ΔPmin* = = RS  * = RΣ (P* ) * − 1 , (3)
RL i =1 Ri i =1 Ri
An additional energy-saving effect is achieved by using
active power filters that compensate reactive components of
currents and pulsations of instantaneous active power. The total where Ri is the impedance of the i-th load, n – the number of
relative (in fractions of the average useful power of Pusf) losses loads connected to the main line.
power after using the PAF will consist of a relative minimum The equivalent resistance R(*) can be found by
possible losses power Pmin* = Pmin/Pusf and relative losses measuring the instantaneous values of phase currents and
power in PAF PPAF* = PPAF/Pusf voltage on the transformer busbar

ΔPΣ* PAF = ΔPmin* + ΔPPAF * . (1)

276
2018 IEEE 3rd International Conference on Intelligent Energy and Power Systems (IEPS)

−1 The model of the solar photomodule in Matlab environment


T 
( )
RΣ P* = 3U S2T
(ua ia + ub ib + uc ic )dt  , (4) is created using standard SolarCell blocks of the
SimElectronics library, which reproduce a detailed

0  mathematical model of the solar cell that takes into account the
features of its electrical and thermal characteristics (Fig. 5) [3].
where US – is the RMS value of phase voltage,  – the period
of repetition, which can equal the period of measurements In the Matlab-model a monocrystalline solar photomodule
repetition. CHN200-72M is implemented with the following
characteristics: maximum power – Pm = 200 W; number of
Taking into account the fact, that the maximum possible elements per module – N = 72; open circuit voltage Uoc = 45 V;
efficiency of the three-phase ESS is uniquely determined by short circuit current – Isc = 5.8 A; voltage at the point of
the ratio of the resistive short-circuit power to the average maximum power tracking – Ump = 38.8 V; current at the point
useful load power kSC = PSC/Pusf [19, 20] the following can be of maximum power tracking – Imp = 5.15 A; maximum voltage
written of the system of direct current – UDCmax = 1000 V; temperature
under normal conditions – NOCT = 45 °  ± 2 ° ; temperature
−1 coefficient of open circuit voltage – Koc = –0.34% / ° ;
 −1  
2
 −1  
n temperature coefficient of short-circuit current –

k SC = 0.25 − RΣ (P* ) ⋅ P*  (Ri ) − 0.5  . (5) Ksc = +0,66% / ° ; temperature coefficient of maximum power

i =1

  – Pm = –0.44% / ° C; efficiency – 18.31%. The layout of the

 
solar power plant is carried out by pair wise inclusion of
Figure 3 shows the dependence of the kSC coefficient on the photomodules into parallel cells, the number of which is
load factor P*, constructed according to (4) for the ESS in determined by the nominal power of the station.
Fig. 1 for the above parameters. The figure shows that under V. ENERGY EFFICIENCY CALCULATION OF MICROGRID
the considered load profile kSC varies widely ranging from 53 IMPLEMENTATION
to 12.
Figure 6 shows a comparison of the traditional ESS with a
unidirectional flow of energy from the microgrid, after its
model implementation at P* = 1. In the power supply of the
considered loads from the industrial network in the curves of
instantaneous network currents, there are higher harmonics,
and the basic harmonics of the currents are lagging behind the
corresponding instantaneous voltage, which indicates the
presence in the system of calculated reactive power.
After microgrid implementation, from the industrial
network point, the smart energy supply system is considered
as a low-power load that has a purely resistive character.
Figure 7 shows the efficiency daily change of the ESS,
calculated using the Matlab-model, for three cases: the
Fig. 3. Dependence of the kSC coefficient on the load factor P* traditional ESS with unidirectional energy flow (); microgrid
ESS (MG); for ESS with disconnected solar power plants and
IV. MATLAB-MODEL OF MICROGRID WITH SOLAR POWER PLANTS ideal PAFs (PPAF = 0) (max). Fig. 7 and fig. 2 shows that the
The study of the control algorithms and operating modes implementation of microgrid can significantly increase the
of microgrid at the design stage is carried out conveniently efficiency of the ESS, especially for the intervals of the day
using computer simulation tools, for example, in the Matlab / when high levels of solar insolation (6 – 8 hours) are observed
Simulink / SymPowerSystems environment. Figure 4 shows during high load factors. According to the accepted parameters
the structure of the microgrid computer Matlab-model, which of ESS, the efficiency increases by 6%. During the night-time
corresponds to the ESS scheme for Fig. 1. failure of the load profile (1–5 hours), the use of PAF leads to a
decrease in the efficiency of the ESS, but this affects the
The model consists of three Solar Station units simulating integral daily efficiency insignificantly. An increase in the
distributed solar power stations with a rated power of 10, 5 efficiency of microgrid at this time interval is achieved by
and 3 kW, an Energy Storage unit simulating a system drive, using the power of the system drive or by disconnecting the
five Load 1-Load 5 units simulating linear active-reactive and PAF.
non-linear loads, and two PAF 1, PAF 2 blocks imitating
parallel power active filters. Consider the structure of the main
blocks of the model.

277
2018 IEEE 3rd International Conference on Intelligent Energy and Power Systems (IEPS)

Fig. 4. Microgrid Matlab-model with solar power plants

Fig. 5. Structural diagram of the Matlab model of the solar photomodule

Fig. 6. Instantaneous values of voltages and currents measured on TP busbar: a – traditional ESS; b – microgrid

278
2018 IEEE 3rd International Conference on Intelligent Energy and Power Systems (IEPS)

[5] X. Liang, ‘‘Emerging power quality challenges due to integration of


renewable energy sources’’, IEEE Trans. Industry Applications, vol. 53,
no. 2, pp. 855-866, 2017.
[6] A. U. Rehman, S. Zeb, H. U. Khan, S. S. U. Shah, A. Ullah, “Design and
operation of microgrid with renewable energy sources and energy
storage system: A case study”, In Engineering Technologies and Social
Sciences (ICETSS), 2017 IEEE 3rd International Conference, pp. 1-6,
2017.
[7] R. Kamphuis, S. Galsworthy, M. Stifter, T. Esterl, S. Kaser, S.
Widergren, M. Renting, “Integrating demand flexibility with distributed
generation–renewable energy sources (DG-RES) at the residential
household and commercial customer level in electricity grids”, CIRED-
Open Access Proceedings Journal, vol. 2017, iss. 1, pp. 1827-1830,
2017.
[8] B. Jie, T. Tsuji, K. Uchida, “Analysis and modelling regarding
frequency regulation of power systems and power supply–demand-
control based on penetration of renewable energy sources”, The Journal
of Engineering, vol. 2017, iss. 13, pp. 1824-1828, 2017.
[9] A. Bagheri, V. Vahidinasab, K. Mehran, “A novel multiobjective
Fig. 7. Dependence of the kSC coefficient on the load factor P* generation and transmission investment framework for implementing
100% renewable energy sources”, IET Generation, Transmission &
It should be noted that due to the use of PAF the reduced Distribution, vol. 12, iss. 2, pp. 455-465, 2018.
total harmonic distortional coefficient (THD) decreases from [10] J. Praß, J. Weber, S. Staub, J. Bürner, R. Böhm, T. Braun, J. Franke
10% to less than 3%. “Smart energy and grid: novel approaches for the efficient generation,
storage, and usage of energy in the smart home and the smart grid
VI. CONCLUSIONS linkup”, Smart Cities: Foundations, Principles, and Applications, pp.
575-604, 2017.
At the design stage of the microgrid ESS it is necessary to
[11] IEEE Std 929-2000, ‘‘IEEE Recommended Practice for Utility Interface
compare energy efficiency indicators before and after its of Photovoltaic (PV) Systems’’, 2000.
implementation. The specification of the energy efficiency [12] R. K. Varma, M. Salama, “Large-Scale Photovoltaic Solar Power
indicators estimation is based on comparison of daily profiles Integration in Transmission and Distribution Networks”, 2011 IEEE
of loading and of solar insolation in the course of the calendar Power and Energy Society General Meeting, pp. 1-4, 2011.
year. [13] A. Tuohy, J. Zack, S. E. Haupt, J. Sharp, M. Ahlstrom, S. Dise, E.
Grimit, C. Mohrlen, M. Lange, M. G. Casado, J. Black, M. Marquis, and
The implementation of microgrid with solar power plants C. Collier, “Solar forecasting: Methods, challenges, and performance,”
allows to increase the efficiency of the ESS. The reserve for IEEE Power and Energy Magazine, vol. 13, no. 6, pp. 50–59, 2015.
increasing the efficiency through the implementation of [14] R. K. Varma, and M. Salama, ‘‘Large-Scale Photovoltaic Solar Power
microgrid has two components, the first one is related to the Integration in Transmission and Distribution Networks’’, 2011 IEEE
normalization of the power consumption mode, and the second Power and Energy Society General Meeting, pp. 1-4, 2011.
one to the optimization of the structure of the network, when [15] A. Tripathi, K. B. Sahay, “Modeling & simulation of proposed grid
connected 10 MW solar PV array power plant at Lucknow”,. In Power
the distances between energy sources and consumers are Electronics, Intelligent Control and Energy Systems (ICPEICES), IEEE
reduced, and the density of the network energy flow and trunk International Conference on, pp. 1-5, 2016.
line decreases. Moreover, the second component makes a more [16] “Prediction Of Worldwide Energy Resource” Available at
significant contribution to increasing the efficiency of the https://power.larc.nasa.gov accessed: 10 May 2018.
energy supply system. [17] L. He, N. Liu, “Load profile analysis for commercial buildings
microgrids under demand response”, In Industrial Electronics and
REFERENCES Applications (ICIEA), 2017 12th IEEE Conference on, pp. 461-465,
2017.
[1] A. Huang, G. Heydt, S. Dale, J. Zheng, M. Crow, “Energy internet –
future renewable electric energy delivery and management (FREEDM) [18] C. Wagner, C. Waniek, U. Häger, “Modeling of household electricity
systems,” IEEE Power Electronics Society News letter, Fourth Quarter, load profiles for distribution grid planning and operation”, In Power
pp. 8-9, 2008. System Technology (POWERCON), 2016 IEEE International
Conference on, pp. 1-6, 2016.
[2] IEEE Standart for Interconnecting Distributed Resources With Electric
Power Systems, IEEE Std. 1547.2-2008, 2008. [19] G. Zhemerov, N. Ilina, D. Tugay, “The theorem of minimum energy
losses in three-phase four-wire energy supply system”, IEEE, In
[3] B.S. Stogniy, O.V. Kyrylenko, S.P. Denysyuk, “Intelligent electricity
Intelligent Energy and Power Systems (IEPS), 2016 2nd International
networks of energy systems and their technological support”, Technical
Conference on, pp. 1-3, 2016.
Electrodynamics, no. 6, pp. 44-50, 2010.
[20] M.Yu. Artemenko, L.M. Batrak, V.M. Mykhalskyi, S.Y. Polishchuk,
[4] H. Xia, Q. Li, R. Xu, T. Chen, J. Wang, M. A. S. Hassan, M. Chen,
“Analysis of possibility to increase the efficiency of three-phase four-
“Distributed Control Method for Economic Dispatch in Islanded
wire power system by means of shunt active filter”, Technical
Microgrids with Renewable Energy Sources”, IEEE Access, vol. 6, pp.
Electrodynamics, no.6, pp. 12-18, 2015.
21802-21811, 2018.

279