Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Megan Oakleaf
Syracuse University
Steven Hoover
University of Nevada, Las Vegas
Beth Woodard
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
Jennifer Corbin
Tulane University
Randy Hensley
Baruch College
Diana Wakimoto
San Jose State University
Christopher V. Hollister
University at Buffalo
Debra Gilchrist
Pierce College
Michelle Millet
John Carroll University
Patty Iannuzzi
University of Nevada, Las Vegas
5
Oakleaf, et al. Notes from the Field: 10 Short Lessons Communications in Information Literacy 6(1), 2012
Librarians teach. It might not be what we there’s quite a lot involved. Let’s see…
planned to do when we entered the Well, the students will need to be able
profession, or it may have been our secret to develop search strategies, generate
hope all along. Either way, we teach. We keywords, and use the databases. I
teach users of all types, including students, really like the MLA International
faculty, and our co-workers. We teach in Bibliography, so show them that, and
multiple venues including classrooms, make sure they know how to use all of
reference desks, face-to-face, and online. the features. Actually, they should
While the variety of teaching audiences and probably also know how to use Scopus,
environments are endless, one teaching Academic Search Premier, CQ
scenario remains quintessential: the one- Researcher, EconLit, EEBO, SciFinder
shot library instruction session. No one Scholar, Web of Science, Factiva, and
knows better than librarians the limitations Lexis-Nexis. They are writing an
of this format, yet it remains central to our annotated bibliography that will be due
teaching efforts. the following day, so please don’t
forget to talk about how to evaluate
In recognition of the unremitting persistence information. Last semester, they had
of the “one-shot,” a number of your trouble with that. They will also need to
librarian colleagues have come together to know how to construct an annotation;
share a few “notes from the field” that we we don’t go over that in class. And
learned as librarians and teachers. We offer citations! Citing is important. They’ll
these insights in our own words in hopes be using a hybrid of APA and MLA, so
that other teaching librarians may benefit. be sure to cover both. Ah, I almost
As an entry point to the notes, we offer a forgot the books. I love books, and I
highly, but not wildly, exaggerated excerpt know the students do too, so talk about
from a conversation we all have had: the library catalog! Why don’t you
show them around the stacks too? My
Librarian: Next Thursday sounds great, students say they love books but can’t
professor. I can’t wait to work with seem to ever find them. Actually, a tour
your students! in general would be great. You do that
right? Right. Oh, and the students won’t
Professor: Well, I think it’s very know their topics when they arrive and
important that the students visit and likely won’t have any idea why they are
learn about the library, especially in there.
their first year. You are all so helpful.
Librarian: [Incredulous silence.]
Librarian: Aww, thanks. It’s what we
do! So, we should probably talk about Professor: You still there?
the session. I’ve had a look at your
syllabus and the assignment and have a Librarian: [Sound of a forehead
few ideas of what to cover, but I hitting a keyboard.]
wanted to hear what ideas you had, too!
We’re all in this together, after all. Hopefully, a conversation this rough only
happens in the nightmares that have
Professor: I’m glad you asked. This is replaced the ones you used to have about
the major assignment for the course, so your high school math class. Still, there is
6
Oakleaf, et al. Notes from the Field: 10 Short Lessons Communications in Information Literacy 6(1), 2012
probably enough truth in the exchange to be successful in this particular class? What
stimulate a little nervous laughter, a few do they need to know at this particular point
tears, or some combination of the two. We in their trajectory through the minefield of
all have found ourselves in equally higher education? Be honest. Do first-year
challenging instructional situations and undergraduates really need to comprehend
through our struggles, we have developed the entire scope of the library’s resources,
coping mechanisms. Some librarians keep use every feature and limiter of Academic
small brown paper bags in their desk Search Premier, utilize the full-functionality
drawers, but there are approaches to of RefWorks, and understand the intricacies
instruction that don’t involve of the scholarly publishing cycle in order to
hyperventilation! The following notes find a few reliable sources that examine the
provide a range of strategies for developing current state of same sex marriage? Of
pedagogically sound one-shot library course not. Would it be beneficial for them
instruction sessions or perspectives on how to learn all that we can teach them about the
librarians can enhance their impact on the most efficient and comprehensive way to do
educational experiences of their students. so? Sure, but that’s not realistic given the
They can be grouped loosely into three time constraints we often work within. We
categories: planning, delivery, and need to teach to the levels and needs of our
integration. students, so careful consideration of those
levels and needs is crucial to developing any
PLANNING plan for instruction. Doing so will help
clarify priorities for what actually needs to
Note #1: “Less is more… right?” be learned as opposed to what would be nice
by Steven Hoover to learn.
7
Oakleaf, et al. Notes from the Field: 10 Short Lessons Communications in Information Literacy 6(1), 2012
these things is true about the particular Think about what they can teach, or
outcome or content under consideration, it is probably already are teaching, in the class.
probably a great candidate for a pre- They would not hesitate to suggest that you
assignment, handout, course page, or cover something in the library session, so
tutorial. Think about “the flipped you should feel free to suggest the same,
classroom.” What content or instruction can just be prepared to generate ideas about how
you move out of class to create space for to integrate the outcomes or content into
active learning and engagement? Encourage their instruction.
the students to prepare before class by
reviewing content or to follow up after This is certainly not always easy to do and
class. Remember, they are given homework may not work out exactly as you had hoped
all the time! Self-directed study is a on the first try, so it is important to
perfectly acceptable way to free up some remember that, more than likely, the session
class time. Another great option is your that you are planning is not the last time that
partner in crime, the subject faculty. the students will ever have the opportunity
8
Oakleaf, et al. Notes from the Field: 10 Short Lessons Communications in Information Literacy 6(1), 2012
to learn something. It often feels this way, students with a variety of ways to learn and
so we do our best to teach everything in a interact with content. We can include
single shot, but sometimes not making any activities that are comfortable and natural to
choices about what to teach can be just as them, which help them capitalize on their
damaging as making the wrong choices! strengths. We can include activities that are
less natural where students are less
Note #2: “Some students learn like you comfortable or might actually experience
do. Most don’t.” some failure. Doing so helps students
by Beth Woodard become better learners by building skills,
abilities, and persistence. Examining
When people talk about learning styles, they information in a variety of modes and
often imply that we should accommodate formats gives students the opportunity to
every student's unique learning style every build a much richer understanding of a
time we teach and for every topic that we topic. It also makes it more likely that the
teach. However, there are over seventy content that we teach “sticks,” because
different learning style inventories, each they've interacted with it in more than one
advocating that teachers engage a different way.
set of student preferences and styles. As
teachers, many of us throw up our hands in As an example, let’s consider one learning
despair, feeling that we can never style inventory. David Kolb developed a
adequately understand the learning learning style inventory based on how we
preferences of students we may only see for perceive information and how we process it,
brief periods of time. and he suggests that students learn new
tasks best when given practice in all four
Instead of seeking to engage a variety of modes. Kolb believes that students have
learning styles, we tend to base our personal, concrete experiences that engage
instructional patterns and choices on our their feelings about a particular learning
own learning preferences. For example, situation. According to Kolb, students can
librarians who like to dive right in and be encouraged to reflect and develop
experiment in a database may skip the abstract principles that can be learned from
conceptual thinking that some students need concrete experiences. Students should then
to analyze a problem. Unfortunately, this be encouraged to try out these new
causes those students to struggle, perhaps principles in different environments to test
needlessly. On the other hand, the students out the theories they create.
who prefer to go right to the searching (like
the teacher) also lose; if their preferred Now, for a moment, don’t think about the
learning style is the only one addressed, fact that some students prefer one learning
they miss the opportunity to develop skills approach or another. Instead, focus on the
associated with other learning approaches, idea that all students learn better when
including reflective observation. information is presented in different ways
and when they interact with the information
Usually, in a one-shot context, we can’t and concepts in different modes. In the
know the preferences of each and every context of Kolb’s learning inventory, that
individual student, nor can we incorporate means that we should consciously combine
all learning styles. Still, we can use what we “concrete experience” with “active
know about learning styles to provide experimentation,” “reflective observation,”
9
Oakleaf, et al. Notes from the Field: 10 Short Lessons Communications in Information Literacy 6(1), 2012
and “abstract conceptualization” learning no time for assessment. And it’s true, if one
approaches. teaches according to a traditional
instructional design framework, making
When I teach students about searching for time for assessment can be a real challenge.
articles, I balance Kolb’s approaches by But when librarians embrace an “assessment
asking them questions about their past for learning” approach, they assess and
(concrete) experiences in searching, or work teach simultaneously. The methods they use
through an example with them and attempt to teach are also the methods they use to
to help them draw general (abstract) gather assessment data. The two processes
concepts from personal observations. I ask become one. Essentially, you’re not really
questions like, “What happens when you teaching if you’re not also assessing.
add more synonyms using the OR
connector?” or “What happens when you So how does one teach and assess
add another concept? Do you get more simultaneously? First, you have to know
articles or fewer articles?” Then, I what you’re trying to teach. This is also
encourage them to do more searches and try known as having an outcome or two, or
out what they’ve just expressed as a search maybe even three. Not 5 or 8 or 10. Then,
strategy. When students construct these you determine how you’ll know that the
conceptual approaches themselves, rather students have achieved that outcome. What
than listening to my experiences, they are will you look for? What will you be able to
more likely to retain these skills and use observe them doing? It is difficult, for
them later. instance, to know if students are learning
when they are sitting quietly and listening to
So, instead of trying to incorporate all you. In this situation, you have nearly no
learning styles or designing instruction that evidence that they are learning. They are
only applies to us, a more useful way to sitting. They are not speaking. That’s all
think about learning styles is this: don’t you know.
focus so much on the styles of individual
students, but instead acknowledge that all For you to know that students are learning,
students need to expand their ability to learn they have to actually do something that
and the ways in which they learn. For every shows you whether or not they are learning.
topic we introduce, we need to provide a They have to take some kind of action—
variety of experiences—personal, direct perhaps by saying or writing something, by
experiences, reflection time, concepts, and moving or organizing something, by
active learning. choosing or not choosing something—and
this action should be observable in some
Note #3: “If you’re not assessing, you’re way. This process, where a teacher engages
not teaching.” students actively in the learning process is
by Megan Oakleaf known as “active learning,” but it could also
be known as “active assessment.” The
It’s easy to think of assessment as an “add- moment that students actively engage in
on”—the last part of the teaching cycle and learning, they are also providing you, their
the one that no one has time for. It’s hard teacher, with assessment data that can be
and time-consuming enough, some used to tailor instruction immediately or
librarians argue, to engage students in active over the long term to understand what
learning. Once you do that, they say, there’s students know or are able to do and how
10
Oakleaf, et al. Notes from the Field: 10 Short Lessons Communications in Information Literacy 6(1), 2012
future instruction can be improved. Of course, once you have this assessment
data, it only makes sense to track it over
Thus, the second step in pairing teaching time or programs, and organize your data by
and assessment is to design learning outcome. So the third step is to gather all
experiences that actively involve students in your data on distinguishing popular and
their learning and provide opportunities to scholarly materials together (perhaps across
assess that learning. Using this approach, multiple sections, courses, majors, or years),
one experience can do double duty. If you or to go one step further and categorize this
want to teach students to distinguish evidence more broadly by including it with
between popular and scholarly sources, you other data about students’ ability to evaluate
develop learning/assessment experiences information. Tracking evidence of learning
that engage students actively. This may can be made easier with the use of an
mean you lead students to 1) list hallmarks assessment management system, but that’s a
of scholarly sources, 2) divide a stack of topic for another day. Once assessment data
print publications into popular and scholarly is recorded and organized around outcomes,
categories, 3) examine a student-generated whether you use an assessment management
bibliography and determine which sources system or not, you can compile and
are scholarly based on their citations, or 4) communicate what you know about student
find scholarly articles on their topic and achievement of learning outcomes to your
provide a rationale for their selection based colleagues, disciplinary faculty, and the
on scholarly criteria in a research log. In students themselves. Chances are, a variety
each of these scenarios, students are of stakeholders throughout your institution
learning as they take part in distinguishing are interested in student outcomes focusing
between popular and scholarly—not reading on the ability to evaluate information in the
about distinguishing or listening to someone context of inquiry, problem solving, critical
else talk about distinguishing but actually thinking, quantitative reasoning, and other
participating in the process themselves. At similar outcomes. Having outcome
the same time, you as their teacher are assessment data in these areas makes your
collecting data about their ability to achieve work relevant and impactful on an
this outcome (to distinguish between institutional level. But that’s also a topic for
popular and scholarly). You may 1) another day.
compare a student-generated list of
hallmarks to a prepared checklist, 2) The main idea is this: Being a good teacher
photograph the stacks of popular and means using active learning techniques that
scholarly print publications, 3) use a student enable students to learn and be assessed
response system to poll accurate selection of simultaneously. Students can learn while
scholarly sources on a bibliography, or 4) they’re being assessed, and so can we—we
assess research log entries using a rubric. learn what they know and can do, what they
All of these options pair teaching with don’t know and can’t do, what we’ve taught
assessment. All of them help students learn well, and what we can teach better next
and provide you with data about the degree time. In short, the better you assess, the
to which they have learned. And the more better you teach.
you know about how much students have
learned and how much they have yet to
learn, the better teacher you can be.
11
Oakleaf, et al. Notes from the Field: 10 Short Lessons Communications in Information Literacy 6(1), 2012
Note #4: “Have a (lesson) plan.” remember how Boolean operators work
by Jennifer Corbin when they have to wait 20 minutes to try
them out? Doubtful. Breaking the session
“Winging it” in the classroom does not into 7 to 10 minute chunks makes it easier
work for me. When I first started teaching, to keep students’ attention and hold it for
my approach to instructional design was to the entire session. You can design your
write down every word I would say during session so students immediately apply a new
the class and practice it over and over. Once concept and actively engage in creating new
I got comfortable with presenting the knowledge for themselves.
material, I quickly became frustrated. I had
no idea if my students were learning When planning a lesson, I estimate the
anything! After speaking with other amount of time each activity will take.
librarians, talking to professors who were When I’m trying out something new, I may
recognized as excellent teachers, reading the have to guess, but it’s worthwhile to think
professional literature, and participating in about. If my mini-lecture on using the
some very focused professional thesaurus in Sociological Abstract looks like
development (e.g., the ACRL Institute for it’s going to be 20 minutes, this is a sign
Information Literacy Immersion Teacher that I need to re-think my approach.
Track), I changed my approach. I began Tracking the time helps me to determine
teaching rather than making a presentation. how many learning outcomes I can really fit
That began with writing lesson plans to into the time available. It’s also helpful
prepare for class. when I give a colleague my lesson plan and
ask him/her to time the sections being
My lesson plans include learning outcomes, observed.
a teaching strategy focused on student
learning, and some type of assessment of the For each outcome I include details on what
learning. These are the basic building I’m hoping students will learn and how I
blocks. And of course, I have a space to will know they learned them. Depending on
record the name of the professor, the name the teaching strategy, I may have a list of
of the course, the date and time of the examples to show during a demonstration or
workshop, how many people attended, and a note to myself to make sure students
so on. understand the directions I provide for the
activity they will complete. Because I build
I start with a short introduction, including an the assessment into the activity, I include a
overview of what students will learn in the list of what will tell me that the students
session and how that relates to the course. have learned the concept. This could be that
Next, I list the first learning outcome, the students correctly filled in a worksheet or
teaching strategy and the assessment and a that they were able to answer a series of
transition. This is repeated for the remaining questions. I also ask if students have
outcomes. This approach lends itself to questions about what they just learned
breaking up the session into chunks rather before moving to the next part of the lesson.
than presenting everything at once and
leaving time at the end of class for people to After the session, I write down what
"practice." Why break the workshop into worked, what didn't, what I want to
chunks? Because people have short remember the next time I teach that session
attention spans. Are students going to and anything else that might help to
12
Oakleaf, et al. Notes from the Field: 10 Short Lessons Communications in Information Literacy 6(1), 2012
improve student learning. Why? Because a engage the teacher and the content because
couple of semesters ago, I retreived my there is something appealing. Often this
notes from the previous semester because appeal is based on the humanness we bring
the professor was in my office and we both to the teaching and learning environment.
remembered that something was “off” about
the session. I hadn’t written down any There are particular attributes of enthusiasm
details. Opportunity missed! Reflecting on a that matter to me.
session, in writing, can also provide you
with insight on your growth as a teacher and Enthusiasm is authentic. Parker Palmer
could be useful in tenure and promotion writes about authenticity—the importance
dossiers. of personhood in teaching. I like to remind
myself about why my content and time with
My colleagues and I use the same lesson students matters. Why do I think the things
planning approach and format so we can I will teach are important? I try to think of
share information and learn from each other. the importance not in terms of ‘shoulds’ but
This comes in handy when someone has to in terms of actualities. What difference
be out of the office unexpectedly. For this to could my teaching really make? What have
work well, we try to be as detailed as been my own experiences with the learning
possible and we include a list of materials objectives I will try to achieve? Who am I
needed during the session – pens, as a human being in relation to this content
computers, specific handouts, smart board, and these students? Why do they matter to
etc. We upload the lesson plans to a shared me, not as a librarian and teacher, but as a
web space. Even if you’re not sharing lesson human being?
plans with other librarians, I promise that by
using them you will see an improvement in Enthusiasm is humanizing. By going
student engagement with your workshop, through this questioning process, I
you’ll know what students are learning, and humanize instruction into an opportunity to
you might even feel better about your meet people, to show them who I am, and to
teaching. learn a little more about who they are. It’s
important to remember that there are the
DELIVERY other personhoods in the room, representing
not just categories like English students, or
Note #5: “Your enthusiasm is first-year students, or international students,
contagious.” but individuals with all kinds of reasons for
by Randy Hensley being in school and in this class. Each class
can be seen as an invitation to a party where
Once, just after completing a one-shot I don’t know anyone. There might be
information literacy session, I overheard a someone provocative or anxious or shy or
student say to a classmate, “It was pretty knowledgeable, and I get to meet them. I
boring, but the teacher was sure excited reflect on how I am like them and bring that
about it.” Is the medium more the message to my attitude for the class. I try to figure
than we think? It seems to be, or at least it out what I can do to make that sharing of
is a key component. When I say medium in who we are happen.
this context I mean us, the teachers.
Enthusiasm, commitment, and personality Enthusiasm amplifies. I relish considering
contribute to student engagement. Students the showbiz element of teaching. I get to be
13
Oakleaf, et al. Notes from the Field: 10 Short Lessons Communications in Information Literacy 6(1), 2012
myself, but bigger. I am, like any actor, learning something new is hard, takes time,
speaking to a group that is comprised of and habitually is frustrating before it is
individuals. I must reach the whole by achieved.
reaching the parts as any good performer
does. We can call this element of teaching Enthusiasm supports risk-taking. Taking
enthusiasm: the ability to amplify who we risks in the classroom is one of the best
are through technique and authenticity. ways for me to make teaching real. Doing
Performance is not artifice. The great something I am not sure will work, trying
performers do not let the technique show something new, being improvisational,
but find the truth of themselves and the truth reminds me that I am vulnerable, I am
for their audience and communicate it. human, I am present. My risks invite
students to take their own risks, to
Enthusiasm is reciprocal. What I give, I get. sympathize and empathize with me so that
It is returned. To be present is to be attentive the teaching and learning experience
and receptive to the results of my becomes more interpersonal.
enthusiasm. I want to be ready to receive
student responsiveness to my efforts and to Teaching is an opportunity to discover who
use it to invigorate myself in the actual and students are and to re-discover who I am.
subsequent session I teach. Being enthusiastic is a way to describe that
amazing experience.
Enthusiasm nurtures. Caring is one of the
most effective manifestations of enthusiasm. Note #6: “Go with evidence, not your
I locate how I care about students by gut.”
recalling how I was cared for by my past by Diana K. Wakimoto
teachers and also by remembering how past
students have responded to my concern for Question: Why are needs
their learning, their frustrations, their assessments important, especially for
successes. one-shot classes?
14
Oakleaf, et al. Notes from the Field: 10 Short Lessons Communications in Information Literacy 6(1), 2012
Answer: You’ll bore the students and interactive and cooperative environment.
wonder why no one is paying You’ll get the students talking and engaging
attention. with the materials because you’ll be helping
them with “just in time” instruction. There’s
A needs assessment at the beginning of your nothing like personal relevance to get
one-shot class can help you avoid this students interested in your session (and yes,
situation. I’ve collected evidence to back up that
statement).
The benefits of needs assessments are three-
fold: they are fast and easy; they And, finally, conducting a needs assessment
demonstrate your respect for students; and and using the results to shape your one-shot
they enable you to become a more effective classes makes you a more effective
instructor. instructor. You’ll be able to tailor your one-
shot classes to the students’ actual needs
Needs assessments can be quick and dirty instead of what you think they need. You’ll
and will get you immediate, actionable be using evidence to make your classes
results. Hopefully you’ve already talked relevant, engaging, and timely. That’s
with the faculty member and know about definitely a win-win situation.
the assignment the students are working on.
But if you and the professor haven’t been Needs assessments are just one quick and
able to connect, that’s okay. A needs simple way to apply evidence-based
assessment will provide the data you need in practice to one-shot classes. Try it out and
the moment. It’s quite simple: ask the go with the evidence. It won’t lead you
students what they know, what they don’t, astray.
and what they want out of the session. You
can simply poll the students, via clickers or Note #7: “You should not be tired.”
hands, to find out what they already know by Chris Hollister
and what they want to learn. Or you could
use a short, one minute, writing exercise at Students learn best when they are active in
the beginning to get students to tell you their own learning. This should be a no-
what they need from the one-shot class. Use brainer. It is a research-proven fact which is
whatever quick method to gather data that borne out in the pedagogical literature of all
works for you and allows you to figure out disciplines. Still, it is shocking to discover
what really needs to be covered. Maybe they just how many librarians continue the
know about Boolean operators, so skip disservice of providing library instruction
them. Maybe none of them have heard of by the rote of lecture and demonstration.
interlibrary loan, so walk them through the
process of setting up their accounts. For numerous reasons, many librarians do
not get it, or perhaps they do not want to get
By finding out what students need, you also it. In my experience, ignorance plays a role;
demonstrate that you care enough about librarians in general are not formally
what they learn to involve them in the schooled in learning theory or trained to
teaching and learning process. This shows teach. Frankly, it is also my experience that
your respect for crafting a one-shot class laziness and lack of imagination can be part
that meets their needs. This creates, at the of the equation. (Please, no hate mail. We
beginning of the one-shot class, a more have all seen ill-prepared and poorly
15
Oakleaf, et al. Notes from the Field: 10 Short Lessons Communications in Information Literacy 6(1), 2012
16
Oakleaf, et al. Notes from the Field: 10 Short Lessons Communications in Information Literacy 6(1), 2012
work. Yes, it is for the students’ benefit, but grade the final draft of a paper, or librarians
it is my experience that engaging them in evaluate a final bibliography) and do not
more productive ways is also reinvigorating provide students with feedback on the
and rewarding to library instructors. It is quality of the thought-path they traveled to
also my experience that teaching faculty develop that product. Shining a spotlight on
have a greater appreciation for the the research process draws attention to this
educational role of the library when important element of topic development and
librarians seize the opportunity to genuinely asks them to reflect more critically on the
improve their students’ learning. choice and application of their research
strategies. Students require as much
INTEGRATION formative assistance and scaffolding in
learning the research process as they do in
Note #8: “Integrated, not separated.” the writing and final formatting of their
by Debra Gilchrist paper—and their thought trail should be
formally evaluated as a component of the
Preparing students for life and work means assignment. Critics of education would
educating them to be critical consumers and often use the image of teachers opening up a
users of information. Part of being an active student’s mind and “pouring in”
citizen, a good pharmacist, or an excellent information. With this type of assignment I
automotive technician means keeping up think of that in reverse – that the mind is
with professional and societal changes. opening up but the student’s thoughts are
Students need to value their own questions emerging so that we can see and interpret
and be fluent with information systems and their thinking.
strategies. I want my students to graduate
ready to incorporate information use into the For example, as part of a course assignment
professional or consumer role they will students can demonstrate their application
play; I want them to understand that it’s part of information literacy in several ways:
of thinking like a pharmacist, citizen, or
technician. The best way to teach and model Students writing a research paper
this in the academy is by integrating submit a critical evaluation of the
information literacy into course-based three sources that made the most
assignments so that students learn that the impact in their thinking about the
inquiry methods utilized in the classroom topic, why they are quality sources,
are key to their success beyond college. and what key ideas came from each.
17
Oakleaf, et al. Notes from the Field: 10 Short Lessons Communications in Information Literacy 6(1), 2012
18
Oakleaf, et al. Notes from the Field: 10 Short Lessons Communications in Information Literacy 6(1), 2012
that separate instruction is definitely not increasing student learning and assessment.
equal! Integrate your thoughts, integrate Start by having more regular conversations
your teaching, integrate your work with with your faculty about their students’ work.
faculty, and absolutely integrate your Ask to see the papers or whatever it is
assessments! students are turning in. Ask your faculty if
they are happy with the work and use what
Note #9: “Faculty are your friends.” you learn to close the loop. Go back to your
by Michelle Millet original instruction session. What were the
goals and were they met? Can you see
First, stop being a babysitter for faculty evidence of student learning? When you
when they are at conferences. Second, stop have an idea about a way to make the class
giving tours or demos of all of the library’s more creative or the assignment more
resources just because faculty members say meaningful, even in situations beyond your
that’s what they want. It is crucial that library instruction, tell the faculty member.
instruction librarians build relationships You are a colleague who often has inside
with their colleagues—the teaching knowledge and important expertise.
faculty—that allow for the integration of Students will often share with you what they
specific programmatic information literacy hide from others. When ten students from a
outcomes at all points in the design of class seek you out to ask you to explain
assignments and courses, not just in library parts of an assignment that has nothing to do
instruction sessions. Relationships with with you or your instruction, you should feel
faculty should extend beyond conversations comfortable engaging the faculty member,
on the actual content for the day of the being honest about the problem, and
library instruction; they are about creating working towards solutions.
ongoing discussions, substantial
collaborations, and deliberate strategies that This level of collaboration won’t happen
facilitate student learning. You should, and with all faculty members, but the important
you must, move beyond casual relationships ones—the ones who value all of the players
with your faculty. Yes, it’s great if they call in the educational mission—will listen to
you to schedule instruction every semester you and try new things. Those faculty
and have been doing so for ten years, but members will then talk to others. Before you
you should also be asking yourself some know it, you have faculty that are not only
deeper questions. What are the students your friends but your colleagues, and you
learning? Is there some way to make will be sharing in the process of improving
information literacy a more integrated and student learning.
interactive part of the class? And if so, how
do you go about doing this? Note #10: “Your teaching matters to your
institution.”
The simple answer is that first you have to by Patty Iannuzzi
see yourself as a colleague, an equal, an ally
in student learning. You’re not the guest Since the first day I had the privilege of
lecturer. You’re not the sideshow for the working in a library, I’ve taken advantage of
day. You’re not an academic “support.” every teachable moment. I’ve spent my
You’re someone with a deep knowledge of entire career promoting the educational role
information literacy—an equal partner of libraries: responding to questions at the
working towards the common goal of reference desk by teaching, not just
19
Oakleaf, et al. Notes from the Field: 10 Short Lessons Communications in Information Literacy 6(1), 2012
Student Learning
inquiry and analysis; critical and
creative thinking; written and oral communication;
quantitative literacy; information literacy
Co-
Faculty Curriculum Curriculum
How they teach
What they teach Where else
Role of they learn
librarians Learning
as partners outcomes Pedagogy of
and in beginning place
faculty middle
development end Libraries
as labs
Student Engagement
20
Oakleaf, et al. Notes from the Field: 10 Short Lessons Communications in Information Literacy 6(1), 2012
Course Authentic
Assessment
Library Performance
Library Based
Instruction
21
Oakleaf, et al. Notes from the Field: 10 Short Lessons Communications in Information Literacy 6(1), 2012
that extends far beyond the curriculum. One of the learning experience extends far
way to visually capture the new emphasis beyond the content of any individual course.
on broader student learning is through a A single column, or even two, cannot hold
model I developed to remind all in higher up the roof—the desired student learning
education of the interconnected parts results. The learning outcomes desired
required for student learning (See FIGURE require a solid foundation of practices that
2). engage students and a deliberate focus on
what is taught, how it is taught, and how the
These initiatives address the importance of a co-curricular experiences are structured to
solid foundation of engaging students in contribute to student success.
their educational experience in three ways:
Librarians are uniquely positioned to play a
1. Motivate students through the special role.
content of the curriculum; engage
students in big questions and Librarians may well be the only group on
through relevant, real-world campus who contribute in all three areas.
applications. Librarians participate (or should) in the
development of the learning outcomes for
2. Inspire and engage students through the campus—especially those related to
learning strategies designed to information literacy—and ensure that the
encourage individual passion and outcomes are embedded in the beginning,
curiosity; utilize teaching methods middle, and end of the curriculum.
that are student centered, research Librarians also contribute to the
based, and rooted in real life development of the teaching environment
applications; develop and by helping faculty design authentic
incorporate teaching methods that assignments that place information literacy
require students to navigate within learning outcomes and library collections at
the world of information as critical the heart of student learning. In addition,
explorers, regardless of the topic or librarians need to be part of the assessment
the discipline. methods used to measure the student
learning outcomes demonstrated via
3. Encourage students to take steps for authentic assessments. And, of course,
their own development through librarians offer critical contributions outside
learning that occurs outside of the the curriculum through the real and virtual
classroom and directly link these places we create for students to learn
experiences to their education. independently, or with us, outside of the
These range from academic support classroom. With such a vast need to
activities such as advising, tutoring, articulate, teach, and assess student
and library and field work, to social learning, it is crucial that librarians can
and lifestyle experiences including clearly articulate their impact on the
living/learning communities, clubs, educational experience of our students.
arts, and athletics. They also include
student leadership activities such as “One shot” library instruction classes are
work study and student government. not enough.
This “temple” is a reminder that complexity The learning outcomes of library instruction
22
Oakleaf, et al. Notes from the Field: 10 Short Lessons Communications in Information Literacy 6(1), 2012
23