Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
A Research Paper
Submitted by:
basic need in order to survive. Since, clothes are used mainly for protection;
weather. As time passes by, fashion trends rose which made people see
clothing as an art aside from being a protection. Therefore, the clothing shops
followed the trend according to the people's demand. Before, the only way to
purchase clothing items is through going physically to the preferred shop to buy
what the customer wanted which basically means that he/she must be present
inside the shop to look for outfits. This has been the condition for so many years
start or expand a particular business. This resulted in online shopping stores which
are very popular nowadays. Some of well-known internationally online shops are
Zalora, Amazon, eBay, SheIn, and Wish while locally there are Shopee, Lazada,
OLX, etc.
similarities and difference that can help the consumers to their decision making.
These major differences makes a large gap between shopping in-store or online.
The consumer will more likely enjoy the shopping environment of in-store shops,
especially because he/she has the pleasure to actually see and touch the
3
garment, unlike in online shops, wherein the consumer can only see the picture
of the product, check sizes, and that is it. On the other hand, marketing
make vlogs (video blogs), send them their items, for them to make videos about
People nowadays are very conscious of their looks, especially the young
generation. Since, the main targets of fashion markets are usually the group of
current information about the preferred fashion store of grade 12 ABM students
Considering that they are prone to shopping more, and they are the target of
the market.
into fashion trends. There could be some participants who are not a fan of either
4
shopping will be supported equally. Since, there is still an ongoing competition
Nonetheless, clothing items are basic needs of a person, which basically means
that everyone is directly related to it. Furthermore, fashion trends are very trendy
This study intends to discover which among the e-commerce and in-store
is the most preferred shopping store of grade 12 ABM students in buying fashion
items.
The students of grade 12 ABM of St. Dominic College of Asia prefer the in-
store method of shopping in buying fashion items more than the online method
approximately forty-two (42) senior high school students of St. Dominic College
of Asia. The main objective of the study is to discover what method of shopping
5
students. The study conducted in St. Dominic College of Asia through the form of
Research Question
This study intend to discover which among the e-commerce and in-store is the
most preferred shopping store of grade 12 ABM students in buying fashion items.
3. What are the qualities that grade 12 ABM students value the most on
Research Hypothesis
The researchers hypothesized this study that, the students still preferred the
in-store on buying fashion items. Consumers still want to physically examine the
product before they buy it regardless of the progress of technology these days.
Future researchers
6
This study will benefit the future researcher that will investigate further on
the same or relevant topic. It will also be a sort of guide for them to have ideas
based on the matter they want to discover as long as the information included
in the research is connected to their study. The result of the study could also be
subjects. Moreover, they could also fill in the gap which the current research did
not cover due to further updates regarding the fashion industry in the future.
The researchers
The finding of this study will be useful to the researcher since they are also
commerce. It will also be a source of new information that will add up to the
particular, is the best fashion shop (e-commerce or in-store), to buy any fashion
related products.
The current fashion shop owners will be the biggest user of the advantage
since they are already engaging in the business world of fashion industry, and
so, this research would extend awareness to the owners on their innovations or
7
when they formulate strategies regarding their operations to increase their
profitability. Especially because, the subjects of the research are students which
The ideas presented in this study will enable the potential fashion shop
owners to decide on what type of fashion store will he/she put up having the
considerations present in the result or conclusion of the study. They will also have
the benefit of taking into account the advantages and disadvantages at hand
Consumers
The result of this study will be useful for the consumers in choosing the right
shopping store for buying their fashion stuffs. This paper can also give consumers
more knowledge about the current trend in buying fashion items that new
generation find more convenient, cheap and secure. It is important for the
consumer, especially for those who are really into fashion, to be aware on the
latest fashion trend as well as the fashion store that can provide low cost yet
high quality materials and serves the customer to buy with ease and without
remorse.
8
Scope and delimitation
commerce. The subjects of the research will cover 50% of the population, or
exactly forty-two (42) senior high school students of St. Dominic College of Asia.
students. The study will be conducted in St. Dominic College of Asia through the
9
Review of Related Literature
The goal of online fashion shoppers is to look for clothing items that would
enable them to look and feel better despite of not seeing it in personal. And this
requires that all photos and pictures present are flattering, clear, and
photos of each item from all angles (back and front). A zoom feature should
also be involved on the page for clear viewing (Maven, n.d.). Currently, the
most affected group for this kind of influence is the young generation. Gupta
(2015) have conducted a quantitative study. This study examined the sex,
goods, and etcetera of its respondents. The data was collected from 150
individuals of Rourkela in the city of Odisha, India. The results show that the most
number of gender that into shopping was female. While the group that gives the
largest part of income of online site came from the group of students. And this
aligns also to the majority of costumer’s age between 18-25 years old that use
online shopping. The said group of people, which is a part of millennial, is known
10
in patronizing the sense of fashion styling; which resulted as the higher rate of
Understanding why shoppers choose a specific channel for purchases can help
businesses better address the needs of their customers (Kuczwara, 2017). The
percent), and accessibility (8 percent). Also, the design, usability, content and
any information they seek for. Thus, online shopping cameto be an option as a
11
convenience, and competitive discounts.Undoubtedly, digitalization has made
of friendly payment systems (Toral, 2017). Online store offers a lot of options for
that one of these is through the use credit cards payments for the product they
select in the product catalog of web shops. This product catalog is where
consumer can order goods make payments access customer service, provide
In the study of Islam, Jafar, &Khan (2014), mentioned in the study of Adrita,
Shahjahan, &Ummul (2016), they addressed that E-commerce was where the
seller and buyers transaction makes easier and convenient given that the
consumer’s physical presence is not necessary to buy the product from distant
There are some fantastic benefits to selling online that get the interest of
physical or brick and mortar store. This includes the benefit of not needing to
12
pay for a large area and the other costs that can require. For this reason, one
can start an online store quickly, with less capital investment.The powerful tool is
the internationalization process that offers by the internet and online channels
to enjoy shopping from the comfort of one’s home without direct sales pressure,
and with the ability to look through in your own time makes the process much
their door, within a few days and even at a time to suit the customer, can be
even more attractive (Shackleton, 2016).A lot of consumers are also pointing out
are still a lot of things that cause of not patronizing by the costumer, such thing
like the lack of trust; which is also the most commonly cited basis on why
consumers do not buy online (Jubayer, 2015). Another, it is also more difficult to
interaction. (Shackleton, 2016). Some consumers trying out online shopping got
13
along with some troubles in using it on the process. In the study of
consumer in buying goods through the use of internet, and these are “fair price,
shipping cost in purchasing online goods which involves the weight of the
product, the distance of the recipient, and other criteria, contributes to the
There is also a study that in-store is much better than online shops in terms
to web shops since it bid the shopping experience of the costumers (Store of the
future, 2016) cited on the study of Moes and Van Vliet (2017). The advantages of
offline retail are well cemented. It stated there that offline retail still remains the
most popular shopping channel for consumers and can’t currently be matched
mortar store, you can craft a unique experience for your customers and express
the biggest reason cited by some surveyed was the ability to see, feel and try
out the item they were looking to purchase (Kuczwara, 2017). A consumer has a
chance to try out or check first the product before buying it because some
14
physical store business offers free trial of their product to their potential
costumer.
(Kuczwara, 2017). Aside of that, there are other thing that also cause of
Newswire (2017) shows what consumers like least about in-store shopping. And,
that it is too time consuming with long-wait times to check out or return
sizes, desired styles, specific colors, and travel time to and from the store. For the
a novice person to the business industry. Traditional stores generally have higher
running costs than online retailers, with electricity, water, rent and more to pay
Moes and Van Vliet (2017) cited in their study, in their previous study (Moes
and Van Vliet , 2015) the differences of advantages between online shops and
in-store. First, it said there that e-commerce has the capability to gain a lot of
offer a 24/7 availability for their costumer to check out the available products
15
they have. Online shopping also gives a lot of generous discount for their
retailers need to blend technology and service to meet their needs," and "A
simple add on may be the ability to select clothes online and reserve a dressing
Newswire, 2017). On the other hand, Moes and Van Vliet (2017) cited in their
current study that physical stores can offer a personal communication between
the seller and consumer that can make a strong relationship between the two.
The product sold can take home instantly as well as the payments that can
receive by the seller directly to their equity. In addition, it also gives personal
experience of the service that business offers which can also lead for businesses
to build up some loyal costumer for their brand (Moes and Van Vliet, 2017).
The two shopping channels may have differ in benefit that can get by the
consumer, there are studies proven that it is still better when both of these are
use in the business. “As e-commerce gains traction in the country, online retailers
are also investing in brick and mortar stores to allow consumers to try their
2018). Also, in-store shoppers proceed to using their phones to check prices of a
16
consumers will check prices for an item on their mobile devices before making a
both land to the main basis of business, such as the transaction. The basic trade
that most of all did every day, the exchange of goods or/and service over a
right amount of money. “It works in a similar way if you're buying online, but
there's one important difference: you never actually get to handle (or even see)
the goods until they arrive at your home sometime later.”as Woodford (2018)
mentioned.
this days, there are still steadiness in operating physical store business. E-
commerce and in-store business has its own strengths and weaknesses due to
their differences in segment of marketing. This study shows that the two different
having a different roles in selling product. Business owners can use the benefit of
In that way, proprietors can saves a lot of money for advertisement at the same
time there is a high potential to get a large number of costumer. On the other
hand, physical store is still important to the business because it serves as the
17
main location of online business and also this is where customers can pick up
Synthesis
In this review, nineteen recent studies has been observed by the researchers.
These literatures are published from the year 2013 to 2018, but one of those
local and foreign works. To sum it up, these studies will help widen the
18
Methods of Research and Procedures
Method of Research
This section explained the methods of the research, consisting of the (1)
Research Locale, (2) Sampling Method, (3) Instrumentation, and (4) Procedure
will be shown.
variable was in-store or e-commerce while the dependent variable was their
Research Locale
Emilio Aguinaldo Highway, Bacoor City, 4102 Cavite. The College traces its roots
with the establishment of the St. Dominic Medical Center (SDMC) in 1991 by
19
Methods of Collecting Data and Development of the Research Instrument
known method of gathering the data needed for quantitative study because of
that measured the preferred shopping store of grade 12 ABM students of St.
Instrumentation
The instrument that was used for the research is a questionnaire, as stated
questionnaire from a study of Cao (2018), The growth of e-commerce and its
impact on the fast fashion retailers, only, some questions will be removed as they
are not connected to the current study and some questions were added. Also,
The participants of the research are the grade 12 ABM students. The
picked. Every single student was given the same probability of chance to be a
20
Procedures
number of student per section, also considering the equal number of male and
This section presents the findings, analysis, and interpretation of the data
Legend
Disagree – 1.5-2.49
Agree – 2.5-3.49
21
The respondents of the research are 42 in total. There are 14 respondents
Cook.
16-17
52% 48%
18-19
This pie chart shows the profile of respondents in accordance to their age.
It is shown that the group of 18-19 years old covers the majority of the
22
Profile of Respondents
According to Gender
Male
50% 50%
Female
This pie chart shows the profile of respondents in accordance to their gender. It
is shown that there are 21 male respondents which covers 50% and 21 female
16-17 3 15%
Online Shops
18-19 4 18%
16-17 17 85%
In-Store Shops
18-19 18 82%
Table 1.1 shows the preferred shopping store of the respondents in terms of age.
According to the table, 3 of the total number of participants with age ranging
from 16-17 prefers to do most of their shopping online, which covers 15% while
17 of them, covering the remaining 85%, prefers to shop in-store. On the other
hand 4 of the total number of participants with age ranging from 18-19 prefers
23
to do most of their shopping online, which covers 18% while 18 of them,
Male 5 24%
Online Shops
Female 2 10%
Male 16 76%
In-Store Shops
Female 19 90%
Table 1.2 shows the preferred shopping store of the respondents in terms of
gender. According to the table, 5 male participants which covers 24% of the
them, covering the remaining 76%, prefers to shop in-store. On the other hand, 2
female participants which covers 10% prefers to do most of their shopping online
Always Sometimes
Online 6 14 13 9 42
24
Shopping 24 42 26 9 101
Table 2.1 shows the frequency of the respondents in shopping online. 14, which
sometimes, covering 31%. Third is 9 who answered never, covering 21%. Lastly, 6
Sometimes
In-store 24 13 5 0 42
Shopping 96 39 10 0 145
Table 2.2 shows the frequency of the respondents in shopping in-store. 24, which
is the majority answered always, covering 57%. Next is 13 who answered often,
covering 31%. Third is 5 who answered sometimes, covering 12% of the total
25
Mean Interpretation
Table 2.3 shows the frequency of shopping online and in-store of the
2.4, with an interpretation of sometimes while the mean of the in-store shopping
Mean Interpretation
navigate.
26
measurements presented.
the buyer.
Table 3 shows the qualities respondents value when shopping online. The mean
Mean Interpretation
done in-store
home.
27
There is a space for fitting the products. 3.45 Agree
products.
Table 4 shows the qualities respondents value when shopping in-store. The mean
IV. Discussion
This section entails to describe the significance of the main finding of what
The total respondents are divided in terms of their age and gender. The
ages 16-17 years old got the forty-eight (48%) of the total respondents, while the
group of 18-19 years old got the remaining fifty-two (52%). There are fifteen
percent (15%) of ages ranging from 16-17 that preferred online shops and the
other 85% of the participants preferred the In-store. On the other hand, the
participants from 18-19 years of age has 18% that prefers to purchase online,
and the remaining 82% covers by the respondents who choose to shop in In-
28
store over online shops. In terms of gender, there are equal number of
percentage in both males and females. The 76% of the male respondents
preferred to do most of their fashion shopping in In-store rather than online shops
which only covers the 24% of the total male respondents. However, there are
90% from female respondents preferred the In-store and only 10% of them
Overall, there are 33% of the respondents often purchase in online, 31%
said sometimes, 21% respondents answered never, and the remaining 14%
31% respondents often do most of their fashion shopping in bricks and mortar ,
while the online shops only got the 2.4 average that includes in the
interpretation of sometimes. Lastly, both In-store and bricks and mortar got an
interpretation of ‘Agree’ in terms of the qualities that participants value the most
V. Conclusion
Based on the finding of this study, the researchers conclude that the
Bricks and mortar are still the best way to put up a fashion related business.
29
According to the result, both ages ranging from 16-17 and 18-19 preferred the
In-store than online shops. This is also the outcome in terms gender of the
respondents, the majority of both male and female prefer to do their fashion
shopping in In-store instead of using online shops. In relation to that, most of the
participants do their fashion shopping in bricks and mortar where they can
physically examine the fit and quality of the product. However, even though the
finding is clearly show that In-store is still the most relevant when purchasing
fashion products; the findings in terms of the qualities that respondents value the
most on shopping in In-store and online shops are both got an interpretation of
‘Agree’. This basically means that even though the most of the respondents is
preferred to purchase in bricks and mortar, their views about the benefits that In-
store and online shops are still the same. Lastly, the researchers conclude that
the availability and advantages of In-store is the most essential thing for the
chosen respondents.
References
ABS-CBN News (2018). Retailers bet on 'bricks and clicks' in Philippines. Retrieved
bricks-and-clicks-in- philippines
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/306236579_PREFERENCE_OF_
30
SHOPPING_ON_ONLINE_VS_OFFLINE_IN_BANGLADESH
http://www.researchersworld.com/vol7/issue3/Paper_08.pdf
Bernal P.M., Guercini, S., & Prentice, C. (2018). New marketing in fashion e-
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/20932685.2018.1407018
Cao, H. (2018). The growth of e-commerce and its impact on the fast fashion
https://www.theseus.fi/bitstream/handle/10024/148582/Cao_Hien.pdf?se
quence=2&isAllowed=y
https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/the-shopping-habits-of-
todays- consumers-ecommerce-vs-in-store-300535550.html
http://ethesis.nitrkl.ac.in/6738/1/Comparative__Gupta_2015.pdf
jbm/papers/Vol17-issue1/Version-2/C017121424.pdf
31
Khandelwal R. (2018, March 27). Preference for Today's Consumers: Online
https://www.entrepreneur.com/article/311093
Kim, S.Y. and Lim, Y.J. (2010). Consumers' perceived importance of and
https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/b68d/0ca31c7c129572cf059f89819de228
de2db2.pdf
and-mortar-vs-ecommerce-stores/
commerce/
Moes, A. and Van Vliet, H. (2015). Het effect van beacons in de ByAmfi Store
https://www.marketingtribune.nl/food-en-retail/nieuws/2015/04/het-
effect-van-beacons-in-de-byamfi-store/index.xml.
Moes A. and Van Vliet, H. (2017). The online appeal of the physical shop: How a
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/317967310_The_online_appeal
_of_the_physical_shop_How_a_physical_store_can_benefit_from_a_virtual
_representation
32
Newsbytes.ph (2015, December 20).Study: Rise in online shopping in PH driven
http://newsbytes.ph/2015/12/20/study-rise-in-online-shopping-in-ph-
driven-by-mobile-devices/
Nordmeyer, B. (2017, September 26). How does an online store work?. Retrieve
from https://bizfluent.com/how-does-4671808-online-store-work.html
shopping-vs-offline-shopping-a-comparative-study
https://www.statementagency.com/blog/2016/08/online-vs-offline-retail-
pros-cons-an-omni-channel-future
Store of the Future (2016). Online goes offline. Whitepaper. Retrieved from
http://www.hva.nl/createit/lectoraten/lectoraten/lectoraten/content/fol
der/lectoraat-crossmedia/publicaties?tools/item/online-goes-offline.html
33
34