Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Abstract: Decreasing annual maximum flood peaks on the rivers and streams in the Wisconsin driftless area have been reported in recent
studies. Various explanations have been offered, generally suggesting different episodes or change points separating the early periods of
higher peak flows from the more recent lower peak flows. The present research used two statistical tests to detect a change point in annual
flood peaks at Freeport on the Pecatonica River for the period 1914–2008. Both tests indicated that the most significant change occurred in
1954. Next, to find an explanation for the decreasing peaks, this research carried out a seasonal analysis of flood timing. The decrease in
winter flood peaks was partly explained by the decrease in snow depth and the increase in winter temperature, providing less favorable
conditions for winter flooding. In turn, the decrease in winter peak flows made once smaller summer peak flows more dominant in recent
years, causing the shift in flood timing. Similar analysis showed a significant degree of resemblance between the Pecatonica River and several
streams in its vicinity. DOI: 10.1061/(ASCE)HE.1943-5584.0000604. © 2013 American Society of Civil Engineers.
CE Database subject headings: Flood frequency; Climate change; Federal agencies; Insurance; Wisconsin.
Author keywords: Flood frequency; Trend; Climate change; Kendal-Tau test; T-test; FEMA; National Floodplain Insurance Program
(NFIP); Pecatonica River.
Major tributaries along this reach of the Pecatonica River include for frequency analysis. This research focuses on the station with
Richland and Yellow Creeks. The reach runs through the city of a longer record (Pecatonica River at Freeport), however, for a more
Freeport. The Pecatonica River drains to the Rock River approx- reliable episodic change analysis.
imately 58 kilometers downstream of the Winnebago/Stephenson A centrally located climate monitoring station with the longest
county line in the neighboring Winnebago County. record, at Darlington, WI, was selected to relate changes in climatic
The watershed drainage area is 4,308 square kilometers (km2 ) at variables to the decreasing peaks in the Pecatonica River at
the downstream county boundary. The watershed is largely agricul- Freeport (Fig. 1). The daily rainfall, snowfall, and minimum and
tural. Only 6% of the land use is developed, with 82% cultivated maximum temperatures are available for the periods of record
crops and pasture/hay, 10% forest/shrub, and the remaining 2% a 1901–1905 and 1910–2008, while the observed snow depth data
combination of water, grassland, and wetland (Homer et al. 2004). were available for the 1919–1930 and 1940–2008 periods, with oc-
About one-third of the watershed is in Illinois and two-thirds are in casional observations prior to 1919. The data were obtained using
the southwest corner of Wisconsin (Fig. 1). This region is known as the Midwestern Regional Climate Center (MRCC) site: http://mcc
the Wisconsin driftless area due to the lack of glacial drift deposits .sws.uiuc.edu/. Similar to many other stations in the region, this
from continental glaciers. station has been moved several times. The records suggest that
Fig. 1. Pecatonica River watershed upstream of the boundary between Stephenson and Winnebago counties in Illinois, Martintown, Wisconsin
(USGS No. 05434500), and Freeport, Illinois (USGS No. 05435500) stream gages
(a) (a)
(b) (b)
(c) (c)
Fig. 7. Fox River at Berlin, Wisconsin: (a) 5-year moving average, Fig. 8. Wisconsin River at Muscoda, Wisconsin: (a) 5-year moving
linear trend, and averages for 1914–1953 and 1954–2008; (b) change- average, linear trend, and averages for 1914–1953 and 1954–2008;
point analysis; (c) shift in timing of flood peaks (b) change-point analysis; (c) shift in timing of flood peaks
(c)
Fig. 10. Rock River at Afton, Wisconsin: (a) 5-year moving average,
linear trend, and averages for 1914–1953 and 1954–2008; (b) change-
point analysis; (c) shift in timing of flood peaks
Concluding Remarks
(a)
The flood frequency analysis presented in this study was a part of a
mapping project with the goal of determining 1% peak discharges
for the Pecatonica River in Illinois, within the framework of the
FEMA NFIP. The apparent episodic change in the annual peak
discharge time series necessitated additional statistical analysis.
The t-test indicated that 1954 was the change year in annual maxi-
mum flood peaks. The Kendal-Tau test confirmed it by detecting a
99% significant trend for the entire record (1914–2008), and no
trend after 1954, for the 1954–2008 record. Following the current
hydrologic practices adopted by FEMA NFIP, the record after 1954
(b)
was assumed to reflect the existing hydrologic conditions and
thus was used as an input to the standard flood frequency analysis
methodology, described in Bulletin 17B.
The causes for the change were investigated, and it was found
that the decreasing trend was accompanied by a seasonal shift in the
timing of floods from late winter to spring or summer. The late
winter floods were typically snowmelt driven, and in the early part
of the record they were much larger than the rainfall-driven floods
observed in other seasons. As the late winter floods decreased,
the smaller spring/summer rainfall-driven floods became dominant
(c) in the later part of the record. The decrease in the winter floods
could be explained by the increasing winter temperatures and de-
Fig. 9. Maquoketa River at Maquoketa, Iowa: (a) 5-year moving aver- creasing conditions favorable to large floods such as frozen ground
age, linear trend, and averages for 1914–1953 and 1954–2008; and snowmelt in the watershed. A regional comparison indicated
(b) change-point analysis; (c) shift in timing of flood peaks that the episodic change in the peaks in the Pecatonica River is