Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Investigative Memorandum
Date:
On September 1,2016, the tipster, Oliver Kamm, forwarded a 29-page email string for the period
from August 17 through September 1, 2016. The emails, which were sent to the village council,
include his assertion that the lake has not been properly maintained and is an imminent health
hazard, that the village has not been connected to a municipal sewer system as was contemplated
many years before, and the village is not complying with its 1989 land use regulations. Kamm
further insists that when he was still a councilmember, the other councilmembers would not
discuss the condition of the lake or other matters with him by email or at any time other than at a
council meeting, based on their incorrect application of the Sunshine Laws. Mayor Caroline
White replied to Kamm on August 27 (after he resigned from the council), on September 1,
2016, that the village had taken a number of steps to correct the lake issues, and more steps were
contemplated.
The referenced emails are attached to this memorandum and were saved to the G-drive.
Caroline —
For the sake of transparency, I will share with the rest of the email list the complete change exchange you and I
had regarding the ethical and legal obligations of a municipal government that is has knowingly cosigning on
not taking action on very serious health and safety issues.
You know that I am personally very fond of you however, this might as well all be above board. I’m sorry to
have to send this out.
Truly, I am.
My concerns regarding — as you know in detail — the responsibilities and failing of the council we discussed
privately, I think it only right that all the information be available to everyone who is a stakeholder.
I have done extensive research, spoken with experts, offered both the direction I received from the BEPA, the
Department of Health, Code Compliance, Broward Department of Health, and the Drainage District, and
suggestions - all of which were dismissed out of hand.
No one cares.
Caroline,
i
First - thank you for responding. I appreciate it. And I’m very sorry about the fire and I know
you must have a lot on your plate.
I guess your response misses the biggest issue though. If it takes 11 days to get a response from
anyone to my first email, we have an inherent structural Municipal problem. I’ll be frank — the
biggest problem is Joe having grossly abused his power as Clerk to run the Village basically any
way he chose, apparently for as long as anyone can remember. The more I realized the
implications of him not having shared ANY regulation with a single member of the council,
the more I realized we were all just puppets in a game he is playing. The cards were staked
against the council having any measurable influence on the Village as all ruled were per Joe’s
“memory” rather than what was codified in the Charter and Land use regulations.
I know you and I agree — the issues with the lake are important. And I know you have the best
of intentions.
Bust I cannot stress strongly enough that a lack of response from anyone to the health concerns
that are in need of immediate address: the mosquito problem and our complete lack of a plan or
coordination with the county with a mosquito plan. I can’t make this with any finer a point. I
have a compromised immune system, and while I’m not pregnant, the effects of mosquito bourn
disease is not a joke and cannot be adjourned until the next meeting.
There is no point person, and no one willing to either, a.) do the legwork or b.) pay for it. And at
the very least there is no way for the village to communicate with residents.
I have found my experience on the council, which I had preciously enjoyed, completely futile
and wasted once I realized Joe had knowingly kept relevant information from us that hindered
our decision making process. In my first meeting I asked about Lake Doctors and was only given
a brusk blow off. And then after being mocked by Sally who isn't smart enough to realize that
when she said she had no reason to read the land use document, that this is a fundamentally
unfair system that has no checks and balances and no concern for the well being of th community
as a whole. As I said at the time — I ave the highest assessment and a taz incread will fall row
heavily on me than anyone else, but when the council is basically filled with a crooked clerk, two
brain dead members who have no interest other than their own and no qualifications given there
insignificant experience in Municipal government as well as lack of concern for the regulations,
and John — this is an unacceptable way to run a municipality.
Joe is not the king and does not get to steer any substantive conversation into a haze of
misinformation. When I think that he essentially wasted 7 moths from when I inquired about the
trees — and then the real asskicer, implying the late Mrs. Benson and her surviving family were
responsible — and wasting Code Enforcement budgeted money to harass them — when he as
Clerk knew full well thats was not even their property if infuriating. To target the least fortunate
members of the community because of his pride in keeping a $35,000,000 budget — is stomach
turning.
As far as the research — I have done a ton. You are right — the problem is not simply lack of
sewers for the houses that are not connected, it is aeration, lack of beneficial bacteria and the
years of decomposing waste at the bottom of the lake. See my letter from 11 days ago. It fleshes
out the issues and proposes solutions. I have met with 3 different lake companies and done hours
and hours of research. We need a professionally managed plan.
2
Caroline — lets face facts. The current pool of potential council members is woefully inadequate
to have a functioning municipal government. The current board will have three voting members
who have stated they do not care about the land use regulations (unless it serves Joe’s plans —
i.e. his refusal to let his neighbor rebuild a structure he did;t like)
It is at the very least unethical and I would venture to say that since it was willful withholding of
relevant regulations, including not speaking up when a proposal was made to do a sewer
feasibility study, his withholding of the relevant regulations that REQUIRED one was most
likely criminal.
I have no interest in seeing Joe prosecuted — but I refuse to stand by and have the council not
function for the benefit if the community and actively work against any program to clean and
restore the cesspool we call a lake. I’m tired of apologizing to guests for how disgusting it looks
and I most certainly am nt willing to have my health threatened by the lack of action. There is
only so much I can do. We need a mubiciplal response to address is immediately. Full stop.
I don;t envy your position as Mayor at this juncture but i am not please that you have not
excerscised your power to call an emergency meeting. No quorum? Then we are not in a position
to govern ourselves.
I mean none of this personally, but you at the very least should call an emergency meeting (I’m
not being an alarmist — read the CDC webpages for the guidelines for mosquito abatement in
the ramp up of a pandemic that has already affected both counties surrounding us) if there is no
quorum there is no quorum. But to not call a meeting in the face of the current bog and breeding
ground outside my house, and every piece of lake that is stagnant — including the bat ramp and
whatever else I am not in a position to go out and look at myself is not right. And it is not fair to
the neighbors and it is not fair to me.
I know we were and are volunteers, this does not negate the fact that we have absolutely no
backbone of communication, or way to respond nimbly to avoid a crisis. We have people so
ignorant of the ethics laws that they think any email communication between Council member
outside of a public meeting are illegal and refuse to address business matters in emails that
involve ALL members of the council. They are not illegal — the are available if requested as
publicly accessible documents.
The mishandling of the Villages resources is going to stop. I haven’t done anything other than
send th letters you ave seen, however if Joe ends up seated as a councilman and no measurable
progress is madden short order I will escalate this.
Caroline I think you are awesome and I really like you and bear you absolutely no ill will. I
know you are in a tough spot but....
The other members of the council who knowingly choose to disregard the regulations and the
gross violations Joe has committed ar a different story. They either prove me wrong by acting
like a group of adults capable of managing a village in short order, or I will file more complaints
with the sate regarding their behavior the they can shake a stick at.
OK, I’m as tired of writing this as you are of reading it. :-)
3
Know this is not about you, but I m serious when I tell you my health concerns and the ability of
Village government to oversee or coordinate with the county on a plan of action needs to be
addressed now. We don;t have the luxury of time..
All my best and with apologies for the headache I am certain giving you at this very minute,
Oliver
This as you know can not be a fudntioning municipal government as there is no quorum and
Oliver,
Be assured that I share your concerns about serious health issues relating to residents. We are
not ignoring you. We have a meeting next week and the issue can be addressed then. Solving
this problem is going to require technical expertise and advices from experts. Making decisions
about the best way to spend taxpayer dollars requires that we as a group not only become better
educated about the issue and the possible solutions but also to evaluate which approaches and
professionals can execute on a a comprehensive plan within our budget. We all have a stake in
this. Since we were not able to have a meeting in August, this will be our first opportunity to
meet, discuss the problem, and work toward a collegial consensus on how to proceed.
Subject: Re: Broward County EML: Lazy Lake DNA source tracking
results
Oliver, sorry I cannot respond to this tonight. We had a fire at the business today
and am trying to help my business partner whatever I can do. As to the Algae, I
have been educating myself on it so as not to misunderstand or make any
missteps. It is my understanding that step 2, stocking the lake with algae eaters is
happening or has already happened. Stage one of course was clearing the debris
island and overgrown wild hibiscus from behind your property. I also believe in
the importance of caring for the lake.
I believe there is more going on than just Septic service on a few houses. Many
years have passed with abundant fronds, leaves, pine needles and bark, etc being
discharged into the lake and wonder if the natural springs may be clogged or
disturbed by this accretion. Just trying to learn about it while life has thrown me a
4
basket full of things to do.I'm not intentionally dragging my feet and I do
appreciate that you keep the issue live and in the forefront.
I too believe in the importance and priority of this project.
Would anyone care to explain why the tax increase via millage
agreed and approved by the entire council at the last council
meeting I attended is not reflected in the statement I received from
the Broward County Assessors Office?
It lists the same rate of 4.7931 which we were all in agreement was
inadequate to meet the neglected maintenance that the village is
responsible for. We voted for and approved an increase. Was this
changed and for what reason?
Please advise.
8
without another vote to counter the voting block at
the far end of Lazy Lane.
Oliver Kamm
2210 Lazy Lane
Lazy Lake FL, 33305
okamm@mac.com
917-400-7972
http://www.wunderground.com/weatherstation/WX
DailvHistorv.asp?ID=KFLLAZYL2
Sincerely,
Oliver Kamm
2210 Lazy Lane
Lazy Lake FL, 33305
okamm@inac.com
917-400-7972
http://www.wunderground.com/weat
herstation/WXDailyHistory.asp?!^
FCFLLAZYL2
Begin forwarded
message:
Dear Neighbors,
At long last we
received the report
form the BEPA on the
lake.
To summarize (and
again I stress this is
my personal opinion)
there are a few pieces
I would like to see us
do more of.
My biggest concern
lies in the ability of
the Council to
function (or to have
previously
functioned) without
using the charter and
Land Use plan as a
guide. There is no
information for
incoming council
members presented
upon election, or
14
much direction. Since
finding these in the
file and confirming
with the clerk they are
accurate, and still in
force, I feel like much
of my time was
wasted
We were supposed to
have done a
feasibility study years
ago about getting the
remaining houses that
are on septic attached
to the sewer, however
when the same idea
was proposed by a
resident this year it
was shot down and
killed without, in my
opinion, the interests
of the greater
community taken into
consideration. While I
applaud the hard work
of the current council,
I cannot condone us
ignoring what was,
and is , specified to
preserve and conserve
in their words “Lazy
Lake’s primary
amenity.”
16
Given my experience
I personally was not
pleased that this
proposal was
dismissed as I
recall that “spending
$3,000.00 will mean
spending
$200,000.00.” It was
not an accurate
characterization in my
opinion of the grants,
knowledge, research
and help available
from the County, the
State and at the
Federal level. It was
understood 30 years
ago that moving
away form septic was
in our best interest.
As a village.
I asked on a general
level what they
suggested to properly
maintain the lake
— and Patricia said
“You should hire a
lake maintenance
company and put in
aerators, general
maintenance and
upkeep”
I have researched
aerators, lake flows
and placements, and
our current system is
woefully inadequate
for the size and
irregular shape of our
lake.
As a homeowner and
voter, (and the house
most recently and
highly assessed I
believe) I understand
that we need to bite
the bullet and raise
taxes, if we choose to
stay an independent
municipality.
I have expressed to
the Council, that in
my opinion the
current participation
level is not adequate
enough to sustain
staying independent.
There will be 3
households that have
all of the voting
power for the
village, I believe if
the current situation
remains.
19
On a personal level I
would like to thank
Joe for his many years
of hard work and his
institutional memory
that many of us on the
council did not
possess. He has been
an incredible asset to
the town and worked
tirelessly—■ pretty
thanklessly— fora
long time to make
sure we stay
independent.
21
likely cause of
blockages.
Regards,
Oliver Kamm
2210 Lazy Lane
Lazy Lake FL, 33305
okamm@mac.com
917-400-7972
http://www.wundergr
ound.com/weatherstat
ion/WXDailvHistory.
asp?ID=KFLLAZYL
2
Link to Village of
Lazy Lake
Comprehensive Plan
https://www.dropbox.
com/s/v6tkqe257srx3
qx/VoLL%20Leg%20
St%20of%20FLQCR.
pdf?dl=0
https ://www.dropbox.
com/s/v6tkq e257srx3
qx/VoLL%20Leg%20
St%20of%20FLQCR.
pdf?dl=0
Link to Email to
Village Clerk in
January 2016 re:
Tree overgrowth
(filled with typos)
https://www.dropbox.
com/s/ra2tc0p 1 dpcwu
vg/Trees%20in%20La
ke%20at%202210%2
0Lazy%20Lane%20L
azv%20Lake%20FL
%2033305.pdf?dl=0
22
Link to 2210 Lake
Pics Today with
Sludge, but restored
access to lake:
https://www-dropbox.
com/sc/mdi49hvqq7b
bvim/AACCakvB8z3
qR6sZAX61BapWa
Begin
forwar
ded
messag
e:
From:
"Holo
wecky,
Patrici
a”
<PHO
LOWE
CKY
@brow
ard.org
>
Subjec
t:
Browa
rd
Count
y
EML:
Lazy
Lake
DNA
source
tracki
ng
results
Date:
August
17,
2016 at
11:12:
27 AM
EDT
23
To:
'Oliver
Kamm'
<okam
m@ma
c.com>
Cc:
"Suare
z-Hale,
Ileana"
<ISUA
REZH
ALE@
browar
d.org>
Good
Mornin
g
Oliver,
Please
see the
attache
d
report
with
the
results
from
the
DNA
source
tracking
analyse
s at
Lazy
Lake. If
you
have
any
questio
ns in
regards
to the
report,
please
feel
free to
contact
me. An
invoice
24
for the
bacteri
a
samplin
gand
DNA
source
tracking
analyse
s will
follow
in the
coming
weeks.
I hope
that the
informa
tion
provide
d will
assist
the
Lazy
Lake
commu
nity
with
their
water
quality
concern
s. If
you
would
like to
discuss
any
further
testing,
please
be sure
to
contact
the Lab
Manag
er,
lleana
Suarez-
Hale at
(954)
519-
25
1477
or isuar
ezhale
(5)brow
ard.org
Best
Regards
Patricia
<image001.png>
PATRICi
A
HOLO
WECKY
, NATU
RAL
RESOU
RCE
SPECIAL
1ST II
Environ
mental
Protectio
n and
Growth
Manage
ment
Departm
ent
ENVIRO
NMENT
AL
PLANNI
NG
AND
COMM
UNITY
RESILIE
NCE
DIVISIO
N
ENVIRO
NMENT
AL
MONiT
ORING
LABOR
ATORY
3211
College
Ave
Davie,
26
Florida
33314
954.519
.1277
Browar
d.org/N
aturaIR
esource
s | Face
book |
Twitter
| Natur
eScape
14-
STAR
<image003.jpg>
<image005.jpg>
Broward
County
is a
certified
4- Star
Commu
nity
Recogniz
ed for
National
Excellenc
e in
Sustainab
ility
Under
Florid
a law,
most
e-mail
messa
ges to
or
from
Browa
rd
Count
y
emplo
27
yees
or
official
s are
public
record
s
availa
ble to
any
perso
n
upon
reque
st
absen
t an
exem
ption.
Theref
ore
any e-
mai
messa
geto
or
from
the
Count
y
inclusi
ve of
e-mail
addre
sses
contai
ned
therei
n
may
be
subjec
t to
public
disclo
sure.
28
6Z