Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
GLOBALIZATION
MEANING:
The worldwide movement toward economic, financial, trade, and communications
integration. Globalization implies the opening of local and nationalistic perspectives to a
broader outlook of an interconnected and interdependent world with free transfer of capital,
goods, and services across national frontiers. However, it does not include unhindered
movement of labour and, as suggested by some economists, may hurt smaller or fragile
economies if applied indiscriminately.
DEFINITION OF GLOBALIZATION:
Held and his co-writers' definition of globalization in that same book as "transformation in the
spatial organization of social relations and transactions—assessed in terms of their extensity,
intensity, velocity and impact—generating transcontinental or inter-regional flows"
DIMENISIONS OF GLOBALIZATION:
Economic
Political:
Political globalization is the intensification and expansion of political interrelations around
the globe. Aspects of political globalization include the modern-nation state system and its
changing place in today’s world, the role of global governance, and the direction of our
global political systems.
Military:
Cultural:
Cultural globalization is the intensification and expansion of cultural flows across the globe.
Culture is a very broad concept and has many facets, but in the discussion on globalization,
Steger means it to refer to “the symbolic construction, articulation, and dissemination of
meaning.” Topics under this heading include discussion about the development of a global
culture, or lack thereof, the role of the media in shaping our identities and desires, and the
globalization of languages.
Ecological:
Topics of ecological globalization include population growth, access to food, worldwide
reduction in biodiversity, the gap between rich and poor as well as between the global North
and global South, human-induced climate change, and global environmental degradation.
FEATURES OF GLOBALIZATION:
1. Liberalisation:
It stands for the freedom of the entrepreneurs to establish any industry or trade or business
venture, within their own countries or abroad.
2. Free trade:
It stands for free flow of trade relations among all the nations. Each state grants MFN (most
favoured nation) status to other states and keeps its business and trade away from excessive
and hard regulatory and protective regimes.
Economic activities are be governed both by the domestic market and also the world market.
It stands for the process of integrating the domestic economies with world economy.
It stands for liberating the import-export activity and securing a free flow of goods and
services across borders.
5. Privatisation:
Keeping the state away from ownership of means of production and distribution and letting
the free flow of industrial, trade and economic activity across borders.
6. Increased Collaborations:
Encouraging the process of collaborations among the entrepreneurs with a view to secure
rapid modernisation, development and technological advancement.
7. Economic Reforms:
Encouraging fiscal and financial reforms with a view to give strength to free world trade, free
enterprise, and market forces.
8. Several dimensions of Globalisation:
Increased and Active Social, Economic and Cultural Linkages among the people.
Globalisation has social, economic, political cultural and technological dimensions. It
involves all round inter-linkages among all the people of the world.
Free flow of knowledge, technology goods services and people across all societies is it key
feature. It attempts at making geographical borders soft permitting all the people to develop
their relations and links.
Globalisation accepts and advocates the value of free world, free trade, freedom of access to
world markets and a free flow of investments across borders. It stands for integration and
democratisation of the world’s culture, economy and infrastructure through global
investments.
ADVANTAGES OF GLOBALIZATION:
When fully taking advantage of globalization, you are no longer restrained by talent that is
available in your city. Today your remote workforce could work from anywhere in the world
with an internet connection opening you up to the brightest and best candidates the entire
world has to offer.
Cultural diversity:
With more diversity comes a need for more coaching and training of employees, particularly
around cultural competency to help workers form different backgrounds connect with and
understand one another. With this level of coaching and training, your business is more likely
to be successful.
Globalization helps to break down more than just trade barriers, it helps countries
communicate and collaborate and share knowledge.
Larger markets:
Openness to trade brings bigger and better opportunities to the economy including larger
markets and increased opportunities to specialize. This includes global economic growth, job
creation, more competitive companies and lower prices for consumers.
Higher standards:
Globalization has been blamed for the loss of millions of jobs around the world – in particular
middle-wage, middle skilled jobs like managers, assembly line workers or secretaries.
These jobs are often outsourced to regions that have lower wages, or are being replaced
entirely by rapid advances in technology, making them obsolete. The jobs that remain are the
higher paid and lower paid jobs, meaning the middle has been “hollowed out”.
Earnings changes:
With more and more companies accessing overseas outsourcing opportunities, wages have
decreased for many workers in the original countries. Companies in the developing world are
able to offer their services at a much reduced rate from those who live in countries with
greater living standards. This means that workers in larger countries are affected.
Social injustice:
Many multinational corporations have been accused of exploitation when working in poorer,
developing countries and delivering unfair work conditions such as slave labour, poor
standards of living and unsafe working practices. They are also often accused of damaging
the environment and depleting it of natural resources and causing problems with ecological
systems.
Many opponents of globalization say that it has worsened inequality internationally with the
richest 20 per cent of the world population consuming 86 per cent of the world’s resources
and the poorest 80 per cent of the world’s population consume just 14 per cent of the world’s
resources.
Some multinational corporations no longer just limit themselves to corporate activities and
become part of politics and actively attempt to influence political decisions in some parts of
the world.
When products are built overseas in factories on behalf of a company based in another
country, there is potential that intellectual property and designs could be copied and stolen
and replicated and sold for cheaper elsewhere.
Globalization refers to several different concepts all rolled into one package. It may refer to
the ease in which businesses conduct operations in different countries other than their own.
Some look at this subject as a way to create a world without national borders. There are
concepts of communication, information access, and technology development to consider
when looking at this subject matter too.
Even though the geographic size of our planet remains consistent, how we interact with each
other is changing by the minute. Despite more than 200 countries independently working for
their best interests, we all come together in ways to make the world a better place. If you have
access to a computer or mobile device with data or an ISP, then you can communicate with
anyone else in the world with the same setup.
We are closer than ever before. That closeness also means that groups of people are further
apart than ever before. Neighbourhoods’ form around common interests or political
perspectives more than our common humanity. Travel restrictions dictate where some people
can go, and others cannot.
As the advantages and disadvantages of globalization show, even though progress occurs, we
are also taking steps backward.
Disadvantages of Globalization:
With fewer restrictions in place at the national level, some businesses may use off shoring to
their advantage. Even if they kept jobs local, the threat of sending jobs to a different, cheaper
region overseas could be used to justify lower wages at home. The end result of an effort to
remove borders would be an increase in wages in the developing world, but a decrease in
developed countries. Many households could see their standard of living go down if
consumable price decreases don’t occur simultaneously.
Value-added taxes above 25% exist in some nations. Tariffs above 70% exist for some
products. Unless borders are completely removed, the advantages of globalization are
challenging to achieve. The people who have the power to dictate policy would reap the most
significant rewards. Those with money to invest would see their bank accounts continue to
rise. At the same time, households living pay check-to-pay check would struggle to access
what they require, suppressing their ability to pursue a better job.
Most nations today offer those in extreme poverty access to safety net programs for basic
supplies. Even in the United States, programs like WIC and SNAP offer food and care access
to those who cannot afford it on their own for whatever reason. When we reduce or eliminate
borders, there would be a likely shift in social programs to benefit those earning less than $2
per day while ignoring the needs of those at home. Households living in poverty in the U.S.
or United Kingdom fit into a different definition when compared to global poverty.
We’ve already received a sneak peek of what a global society would be like from a political
perspective. The individuals and organizations who spend the most to lobby politicians would
receive the best chance of having their needs met first. We’ve seen billions spent in U.S.
elections lately to influence legislation and policy to become favourable toward specific
outcomes. This issue would translate to a global economy, where only the richest and most
influential would influence laws which would impact everyone.
The goal of globalization is to equalize patterns of consumption for populations around the
world. Even though there would be movement toward doing so, there is no getting around the
fact that the wealthiest nations will still consume the most resources. The 20 richest countries
in the world today consume almost 90% of the planet’s resources each year. The United
States constitutes 5% of the global population right now, but it consumes 24% of the world’s
energy as a country.
When you look at the per capita consumption rates of energy globally, one American
consumes as much energy as 31 people in India. If you go to a developing nation, it takes 370
Ethiopians to use the same amount of energy that a single U.S. citizen uses to meet their
needs.
The statistics of consumption (especially food) show us already that those who are in power
take the majority of resources away from the general population. Americans eat almost 200
billion more calories per day as a nation than they require, which means 80 million people are
hungry needlessly because of these consumption habits. About 200,000 tons of edible food is
disposed of daily in the United States. By the age of 75, the average person in the U.S. creates
52 tons of garbage.
Globalization would likely centralize distribution of necessary resources. With only a few
controlling access to the many, the chance to negatively impact populations on a large scale
become greater when borders are reduced.
Humans are global citizens in some ways already. We all share the same planet, after all, so
we are united with that common ground. If we lose borders, however, we also lose a piece of
our culture, ethnicity, or family heritage. People identify themselves based on their history, so
being Irish in a global world would have less impact than it does today. We already seen how
this works when Texas came into the U.S. after being an independent nation. Some Texans
label themselves as such first, but many see themselves as an American before being a Texan.
We’ve already seen what free trade does to the environment. Greenhouse gas emissions rose
in 2018 despite efforts to curtail them. Micro-plastics invaded our oceans, creating negative
impacts on marine life. The waters of our planet are slowly acidifying, creating economic and
health impacts every day. Over 200,000 Americans die each year because of pollution
exposure. If caps are taken off of what is not permitted through globalization, then this issue
will continue growing worse.
FDI can bring impressive growth, as in China's coastal provinces, but also instability and
economic distress, as during the 1997-98 Asian financial crisis. Governments of many poor
countries see foreign capital as a means of economic growth, and they have taken steps to
attract it.
These steps often include minimizing business regulation and weakening codes for labour,
health, and the environment. Such governments may also try to improve the investment
climate by using violence to silence opposition parties and movements.
Rich countries, for their part, have sought legal protection for investors, and have used the
World Bank and the IMF to impose new arrangements in this field. Bilateral and multilateral
agreements, such as the North American Free Trade Area, protect investments at the expense
of environmental and health regulations. The proposed Multilateral Investment Agreement
(MIA), under negotiation at the WTO, would replicate this imbalance at the global level.
Foreign direct investment can stimulate the target country’s economic development, creating
a more conducive environment for you as the investor and benefits for the local industry.
Commonly, a country has its own import tariff, and this is one of the reasons why trading
with it is quite difficult. Also, there are industries that usually require their presence in the
international markets to ensure their sales and goals will be completely met. With FDI, all
these will be made easier.
Foreign direct investment creates new jobs, as investors build new companies in the target
country, create new opportunities. This leads to an increase in income and more buying
power to the people, which in turn leads to an economic boost.
One big advantage brought about by FDI is the development of human capital resources,
which is also often understated as it is not immediately apparent. Human capital is the
competence and knowledge of those able to perform labor, more known to us as the
workforce. The attributes gained by training and sharing experience would increase the
education and overall human capital of a country. Its resource is not a tangible asset that is
owned by companies, but instead something that is on loan. With this in mind, a country with
FDI can benefit greatly by developing its human resources while maintaining ownership.
5. Tax Incentives.
Parent enterprises would also provide foreign direct investment to get additional expertise,
technology and products. As the foreign investor, you can receive tax incentives that will be
highly useful in your selected field of business.
6. Resource Transfer.
Foreign direct investment will allow resource transfer and other exchanges of knowledge,
where various countries are given access to new technologies and skills.
8. Increased Productivity.
The facilities and equipment provided by foreign investors can increase a workforce’s
productivity in the target country.
9. Increment in Income.
Another big advantage of foreign direct investment is the increase of the target country’s
income. With more jobs and higher wages, the national income normally increases. As a
result, economic growth is spurred. Take note that larger corporations would usually offer
higher salary levels than what you would normally find in the target country, which can lead
to increment in income.
4. Higher Costs.
If you invest in some foreign countries, you might notice that it is more expensive than when
you export goods. So, it is very imperative to prepare sufficient money to set up your
operations.
5. Economic Non-Viability.
Considering that foreign direct investments may be capital-intensive from the point of view
of the investor, it can sometimes be very risky or economically non-viable.
6. Expropriation.
Remember that political changes can also lead to expropriation, which is a scenario where the
government will have control over your property and assets.
Horizontal
Vertical
However, two other forms of FDI have also been observed: conglomerate and
platform FDI.
Platform: a business expands into a foreign country but the output from the
foreign operations is exported to a third country. This is also referred to as export-
platform FDI. Platform FDI commonly happens in low-cost locations inside free-
trade areas. For example, if Ford purchased manufacturing plants in Ireland with
the primary purpose of exporting cars to other countries in the EU.
OBJECTIVES OF FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT'S AND PI
2. Technological gap :
The under developed countries have very low level of technology as compared to the
advanced countries. However they possess strong urge for industrialization to develop
their economies and to wriggle out of the low level equilibrium trap in which they are
caught.
This raises the necessity for importing technology from advanced countries. Such
technology usually comes with foreign capital when it assumes the form of private
foreign investment or foreign collaboration. In the Indian case technical assistance
received from abroad has helped in filling the technological gap through the following
three ways:
(a) Provision for expert services
(b) Training of Indian personnel
(c) Education research and training institution in the country
FDI is the major source of foreign exchange inflow in the country. It offers a supreme benefit
to country’s external borrowings as the government needs to repay the international debt with
the interest over a particular period of time. The inflow of foreign currency in the economy
allows the government to generate adequate resources which help to stabilize the BOP
(Balance of Payment).
Foreign companies carry a broad international marketing network and marketing information
which helps in promoting domestic products across the globe. Hence, FDI promotes the
export-oriented activities that improve export performance of the country.
Apart from these advantages, FDI helps in creating a competitive environment in the country
which leads to higher efficiency and superior products and services.
Types of FDI:
i. Greenfield Investment:
It is the direct investment in new facilities or the expansion of existing facilities. It is the
principal mode of investing in developing countries like India.
It occurs when a transfer of existing assets from local firms takes place.
The Indian economy stood at the 11th position in the world with regards to the nominal gross
domestic product (GDP) for the fiscal year 2011-12 witnessed a year low growth of the
Indian economy (grew at a rate of 6.5%) and reasons traced could be the weak monetary
policy, inflation issues, and cut in investments.
India is one of the most attractive destinations for foreign investment. Since liberalization,
when foreign direct investments (FDI) were allowed to enter India, our economy has grown
by manifolds. Foreign investments play a very significant role in the Indian economy.
ii. Enhanced Flow of Equity Capital Improved Corporate Governance Increased Employment
Opportunities.
The U.N. Conference on Trade and Development publishes the Global Investment Trends
Monitor. It summarizes FDI trends around the world.
The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development publishes quarterly
FDI statistics for its member countries. It reports on both inflows and outflows. The only
statistics it doesn't capture are those between the emerging markets themselves.
The IMF published its first Worldwide Survey of Foreign Direct Investment Positions in
2010. This annual worldwide survey is available as an online database. It covers investment
positions for 72 countries. The IMF received help from the European Central Bank, Eurostat,
the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, and the United Nations
Conference on Trade and Development.
The Bureau of Economic Analysis reports on the FDI activities of foreign affiliates of U.S.
companies. It provides the financial and operating data of these affiliates. It says which U.S.
companies were acquired or created by foreign ones. It also describes how much U.S.
companies have invested overseas.
MULTINATIONAL COMPANY(MNCS)
It must be emphasized that the headquarters of a multinational company are located in the
home country.
Definition:
If the vendor fails to do so, then the multinational corporation can move to a different
supplier immediately. This practice directly eliminates some distribution businesses overseas
with a single decision, which is why this structure creates competences of scale that keep
prices down while still ensuring reasonably excellent product quality.
2. Innovation happens because of the investments made by multinational corporations.
Most multinational corporations spend about 5%-10% of their yearly budget on innovative
research and development projects. Most of the firms that invest richly into R&D are the
organizations who are on the Fortune Global 500 list consistently.
Only two companies, Stanley Black and Decker and Apple, qualify as high-leverage
innovators because of their investments today. The world’s largest spenders increased their
investments by 11.4% in 2018 to total almost $800 billion. Without these investments, the
world would be a very different place.
When each person expands their reasoning to include new viewpoints, the planet becomes a
healthier place because of that action. These organizations provide a resolute influence on
cross-culture information when this advantage becomes a prime preference for them.
You’ll see similar designs, ordering procedures, and best practices implemented at all
managed locations for a multinational company. Customers believe in these institutions
because they realize what the value proposition is before they ever spend any money with
that brand. This advantage works the same way for every business which excels because of
their status in different markets.
It’s the “rising tide lifts all boats” analogy, but then put into practice in real life. This
advantage is helping some developing countries to triple their GDP over the past 10 years.
With more multinational companies entering new markets all over the world, it will not take
long for there to be more developed than developing nations.
When multinational corporations build a presence in the developing world, their capital
inflows help each country to develop better access to the import-export market. This
advantage gives each marketplace better access to valuable goods, creates more opportunities
for trade, and it ultimately raises the standard of living for the entire economy.
The presence of multinational corporations could boost the levels of trade on the African
continent by up to 50% in the next decade, which would put this region into the same
category as Southeast Asia for trade opportunities in the global market.
These agencies must move into the developing world to earn profits through the investments
that they make there to maintain the value of their overall portfolio. Multinational companies
are a leading source of capital inflows to the developing world because they build
manufacturing centers, investing in workforce training, and support institutions of learning to
advance their productive capacity in foreign markets.
When these structures are present and treated in this way, then the benefits of scale allow the
multinational corporation to price everyone out of the market. There might still be local
competition, but the average consumer will work with the cheapest offer whenever if
provides a similar amount of value for them.
Did you know that the minimum wage in China is the equivalent of less than $1 per hour?
Some African countries have a minimum wage that pays workers less than a nickel per hour
for the work that they do. If a multinational company can transfer hundreds of jobs and save
$10 per hour in wages without a harmful drop in quality, then that cost savings can go
straight into their budget and the pockets of their C-Suite.
Smaller, less developed governments often trade an increase in revenues for access to their
natural resources. The lower standards create better pricing structures for each customer, but
it also creates environmental damage that could have future generations paying the price for
today’s decisions. Some nations even trade in recycled materials and trash, which can place
even more stress on local resources.
6. Profits often go back to the multinational company instead of staying in the local
market.
Multinational corporations might provide job opportunities in each local market, but they also
funnel out many of the profits back to their centralized office. Some might see this as a return
on their infrastructure and educational investments, but it can also be a decision that further
weakens an already underperforming government or economy. When you compare how
much goes into foreign markets with what comes out of them, the difference is usually
minimal and can sometimes be a negative return.
The best jobs, especially the ones which become available in a developing country, are
therefore given to someone who may not even live in the local community. That means their
wages will not have the same economic impact that they would have if a local employee was
in that position.
“The largest 100 corporations hold 25% of the worldwide productive assets, which in turn
control 75% of international trade and 98% of all foreign direct investment,” said Peter
Drucker. “The multinational corporation… puts the economic decision beyond the effective
reach of the political process and its decision-makers, national governments.”
10. It creates a dependency on the business that can be unhealthy for an economy.
Because a multinational corporation can control a majority of the decisions that people make
thanks to the size and scope of their structure, their presence can create dependencies that are
unhealthy for the local marketplace. Consumers might think that they have choices when
shopping, but the reality of their situation is that one company is pulling all of the strings of
their transaction. That’s why Zbigniew Brzezinski said that the people, governments, and
economies of each country must serve the needs of this entity.
Unilever sells everything from soap to olive oil and has products selling in over 190
countries. Coca-Cola and PepsiCo sell a combination of beverages and snacks that
encompass hundreds of different brands – sometimes competing with each other for the same
shelf space. Anheuser-Busch InBev controls a lineup of more than 200 different beer brands.
Over 2 billion people use the products from these companies on any given day.
Because of operations on a global basis, MNCs have huge physical and financial assets. This
also results in huge turnover (sales) of MNCs. In fact, in terms of assets and turnover, many
MNCs are bigger than national economies of several countries.
MNCs have production and marketing operations in several countries; operating through a
network of branches, subsidiaries and affiliates in host countries.
MNCs are characterized by unity of control. MNCs control business activities of their
branches in foreign countries through head office located in the home country. Managements
of branches operate within the policy framework of the parent corporation.
(iv) Mighty Economic Power:
MNCs are powerful economic entities. They keep on adding to their economic power through
constant mergers and acquisitions of companies, in host countries.
Generally, a MNC has at its command advanced and sophisticated technology. It employs
capital intensive technology in manufacturing and marketing.
A MNC employs professionally trained managers to handle huge funds, advanced technology
and international business operations.
MNCs spend huge sums of money on advertising and marketing to secure international
business. This is, perhaps, the biggest strategy of success of MNCs. Because of this strategy,
they are able to sell whatever products/services, they produce/generate.
A MNC has to compete on the world level. It, therefore, has to pay special attention to the
quality of its products.
Limitations of MNCs :
MNCs, because of their vast economic power, pose a danger to domestic industries; which
are still in the process of development. Domestic industries cannot face challenges posed by
MNCs. Many domestic industries have to wind up, as a result of threat from MNCs. Thus
MNCs give a setback to the economic growth of host countries.
MNCs earn huge profits. Repatriation of profits by MNCs adversely affects the foreign
exchange reserves of the host country; which means that a large amount of foreign exchange
goes out of the host country.
MNCs produce only those things, which are used by the rich. Therefore, poor people of host
countries do not get, generally, any benefit, out of MNCs.
MNCs invest in most profitable sectors; and disregard the national goals and priorities of the
host country. They do not care for the development of backward regions; and never care to
solve chronic problems of the host country like unemployment and poverty.
MNCs are powerful economic entities. They can afford to bear losses for a long while, in the
hope of earning huge profits-once they have ended local competition and achieved monopoly.
This may be the dirties strategy of MNCs to wipe off local competitors from the host country.
MNCs tend to use the natural resources of the host country carelessly. They cause rapid
depletion of some of the non-renewable natural resources of the host country. In this way,
MNCs cause a permanent damage to the economic development of the host country.
MNCs tend to promote alien culture in host country to sell their products. They make people
forget about their own cultural heritage. In India, e.g. MNCs have created a taste for synthetic
food, soft drinks etc. This promotion of foreign culture by MNCs is injurious to the health of
people also.
MNCs join hands with big business houses of host country and emerge as powerful
monopolies. This leads to concentration of economic power only in a few hands. Gradually
these monopolies make it their birth right to exploit poor people and enrich themselves at the
cost of the poor working class.
Characteristics of MNCs:
The MNC has considerable freedom in selecting the financial channel through which funds or
profits or both are moved, e.g., patents and trademarks can be sold outright or transferred in
return through contractual binding on royalty payments.
Similarly, the MNC can move profits and cash from one unit to another by adjusting transfer
prices on intercompany sales and purchases of goods and services. MNCs can use these
various channels, singly or in combination, to transfer funds internationally, depending on the
specific circumstances encountered.
(ii) Value for Money:
By shifting profits from high-tax to low-tax nations, MNCs can reduce their global tax
payments. In addition, they can transfer funds among their various units, which allow them to
circumvents currency controls and other regulations and to tap previously inaccessible
investment and financing opportunities.
(iii) Flexibility:
Some to the internationally generated claims require a fixed payment schedule; other can be
accelerated or delayed. MNCs can extend trade credit to their other subsidiaries through open
account terms, say from 90 to 180 days. This give a major leverage to financial status. In
addition, the timing for payment of fees and royalties may be modified when all parties to the
agreement are related.
Importance of MNC’S :
1.TRANSFER OF CAPITAL AND TECHNOLOGY
The multinational companies transfer investment ,advance technology to developing
countries through establishing branches and subsidiaries. Therefore developing countries like
Nepal get benefited of receiving Advanced technology and capital
investment through such companies.
2. Mass production
With help of advanced technology, the can produce quality goods and products at cheaper
price. Due to Job innovation and specialization help to produce more consumption increase as
production in more unit reduce cost.
Most of the MNCs try to prevent operations in developing countries by other local entities
without their cooperation. This can be achieved if the company maintains control of an
element of operations.
For example, food and soft drink manufacturers keep their special ingredients secret.
Automobile companies may produce vital parts such as engines in some other country and
refuse to supply these parts if their operations are seized.
There is an alternative technique to handover ownership and control to local people in future.
This is sometimes a requirement of the host government. There is a calculated move to
involve themselves in stages.
3. Joint Ventures:
Instead of promising shared ownership in future, an alternative technique for reducing the
risk of expropriation is to share ownership with private or official partners in the host country
from the very beginning.
Such shared ownerships, known as joint ventures rely on the reluctance of local partners, if
private, to accept the interference of their own Government as a means of reducing
expropriation.
When the partner is the government itself, the disincentive to expropriation is concerned over
the loss of future investments. Multiple joint ventures in different countries reduce the risk of
expropriation, even if there is no local participation. If the government of one country does
expropriate the business, it faces the risk of being isolated simultaneously by numerous
foreign powers.