Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Volume I
Pages: 1-18
Exhibits: 0
COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS
APPEARANCES:
For the Plaintiff:
Morrison Mahoney LLP
250 Summer Street
Boston, Massachusetts 02210
By: Alan E. Brown, Esq.
Boston, Massachusetts
June 14, 2019
I N D E X
None - Hearing
Page | 3
1 P R O C E E D I N G S
4 Bank.
15 of the defendants.
19 cause.
20 And thank you for pointing out that the Superior Court
9 of them again this morning, and I don’t know that I agree with
15 MR. BROWN: So, Your Honor, starting first with the 93A
21 about now?
23 this action.
1 happened in 2018.
11 never really discussed this with you, but, you know, your
2 litigation.
12 again --
20 some reason --
23 a different question.
5 On page 25.
13 property in 2010.
19 Paragraph 237.
12 So you come into Court, you say I have this case that I
13 of conduct.
22 you lose, and then there’s another event between the same
23 parties and they can rope in all the earlier ones that they
24 lost on?
6 the merits?
9 our footnote, --
14 merits.
16 brought because it’s too late, that can't change as more time
17 goes by.
14 93A.
19 it.
20 THE COURT: I'm not sure you’re correct about that, for
10 MS. LAKE: No, though I will point out that part of the
15 our law firm, but that his knowledge of what happened in that
23 Fargo and Auckland through the U.S. District Court and -- no,
2 don’t know that they would have had that same knowledge if it
4 clients.
10 exhibit, and -- and even, you know, the exhibits are kind of
13 find it.
4 litigation.
9 of that litigation.
15 litigated to completion.
16 All right.
20 advisement.
25 the edge very often, and -- and I'm just concerned that in
P a g e | 17
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25 (Adjourned)
The Commonwealth of Massachusetts
OFFICE OF COURT MANAGEMENT, Transcription Services
For court transcribers: Complete this assessment form for each volume of transcript
produced, and include it at the back of every original and copy transcript with the certificate
page, word index, and CD PDF transcript.
low audio
____________________ _____________________________________
____________________ _____________________________________
____________________ _____________________________________
COMMENTS:_
P a g e | 18
Certificate of Accuracy
above-entitled matter.
(781) 575-8000___________________
donna@dhreporting.com
DH Reporting Services, Inc. (781) 575-8000
adding [1] 7:14 away [1] 14:2 clearly [2] 10:5 13:2
1 addition [3] 11:4,6 12:25 clerk [1] 3:3
107 [1] 16:2 address [1] 4:10
B clients [2] 8:11 15:4
11 [1] 6:18 adjourned [1] 17:25 back [3] 8:12 11:2 15:23 close [2] 16:24 17:2
18 [1] 3:3 adjudicated [2] 4:14 7:3 bad [2] 6:24 12:21 come [1] 9:12
19 [1] 15:17 adjudication [1] 12:5 bank [1] 3:4 compensable [7] 7:3,19
barred [2] 13:3,4
2 advanced [1] 6:23
based [2] 10:9 16:11
9:24 10:6 11:17 13:15,24
advancing [1] 12:20 complaint [28] 3:21,25 4:
200 [1] 3:25 begin [2] 10:3,4
advisement [1] 16:20 13,17,20,22 5:22 6:8,16,20
2007 [3] 5:24 6:3 8:11 beginning [2] 4:25 15:16
affirmed [1] 9:14 8:1,7,8 9:2,7,22 10:10,17,
2008 [1] 8:24 begins [1] 4:17
ago [2] 9:13 10:5 18,22 11:12 12:24 15:7,18,
2010 [1] 8:13 behalf [1] 3:14
agree [7] 4:9 6:13 9:19 10: 22,23 16:5,8
2014 [3] 4:13 5:22 8:8 belabor [1] 15:15
14,18 12:11 13:25 complaints [1] 6:12
2018 [4] 5:15 6:1,2 9:3 believe [6] 7:22 9:22 12:8
alan [1] 3:10 completely [1] 4:13
215 [7] 4:25 5:11,15 6:6,25 14:1,5,21
allegation [3] 7:11,14 8: completion [1] 16:15
11:2,13 belong [1] 6:16
15 concede [1] 13:6
218 [1] 11:14
allegations [10] 6:15 8:7, between [1] 11:22 conceding [1] 6:20
22 [5] 4:17,25 5:10,11 15:
9,10 9:2,23 10:24 11:15 12: beyond 7:4 8:16 10:7
[3]
concerned [3] 6:19 16:13,
17 both 3:13 4:8 6:3
[3]
24 14:7 25
221 [1] 11:14 bring [2] 10:10 11:20
alleged [1] 7:1 conduct [16] 5:12 7:1,16,
225 [1] 11:14 brought [2] 4:5 12:16
alleges [3] 9:6 11:2 13:8 17 8:10 9:6,20 10:1,9,10,
23 [2] 16:2,7
alleging [3] 6:25 9:20 10:9 brown [44] 3:10,10,18 4:3, 13 13:11 14:1,2,5 15:25
232 [1] 8:4 11,12,15,19,22,25 5:3,5,7,9,
allowed [3] 10:10 13:13, conference [3] 4:4 14:18,
237 [1] 8:19 11,17 6:6,17 7:5,7,9,13,15,
15 21
25 [2] 8:5 10:5 22 8:17 9:5,17,19 10:16 11:
already [1] 16:14 confusing [1] 15:11
26 [1] 15:17 5,7,11,19,25 12:7,11,18 13:
analysis [1] 12:21 consider [8] 9:10 13:13,
3 another [6] 8:18 11:22 15: 25 14:5 15:6,14 16:17,18 16,18,21,23 14:2,6
1,3,3 17:2 17:4 considering [1] 13:11
327 [1] 3:3
apart 15:7
[1] buried [1] 3:22
considers [1] 12:13
8 appeals [5] 4:14 8:15 9:14 C contained [2] 7:19 9:5
85 [2] 3:25 15:22 13:24 14:24 context [2] 12:22 13:7
call [3] 3:21,23,25
88 [1] 16:1 appeared [1] 14:21 continuing [1] 5:1
called [1] 3:2
9 appreciate [1] 16:5 correct [1] 13:20
came [1] 14:17
aren't [1] 13:15 couldn't [1] 13:22
93a [16] 4:15 10:2,25 11:2, arguably [1] 11:16 cannot [1] 8:17
counsel [2] 3:8 8:23
3,15,16,20 12:1,4,25 13:8, arose [1] 8:8 case [13] 4:4 9:4,12,14,25
count [9] 4:16 9:6,20 10:4,
10,14,22 14:7 11:20 12:8,12,15 14:17,21
artfully [3] 6:9,21 10:18 8 11:2,8,13 13:7
15:20 17:1
“ artfulness [1] 6:19
cause [3] 3:19 12:20 14:11
counts [1] 4:13
assertions [1] 8:21 couple [2] 6:14 8:2
“plaintiffs [1] 8:20 certainly [3] 4:1 6:17 15:
assigned [1] 15:1 course [7] 7:1,17 8:9 9:8
14
A attached [2] 15:7 16:6
chance [1] 14:25
10:12 16:2 17:3
able [1] 9:22 attaching [1] 12:24 court [58] 3:2,8,13,16,20 4:
change [1] 12:16
acknowledge [2] 9:21 10: attempt [2] 15:19 16:14 circles [1] 15:23
12,14,18,20,24 5:2,4,6,8,10,
17 attempts [1] 9:9 16,18 6:10 7:3,6,8,11,14,
claim [10] 4:6 5:23,25 6:2,
action [6] 4:23,24 8:24 14: attorney [11] 3:11,11 7:24 3,4,4 13:22,22,23
16,21 8:2,15,18 9:10,12,14,
13,13,19 9:22 12:19 14:12,14,20 15: 18 10:10,14 11:4,6,9,19,21
claims [6] 12:21 13:4,15,
actions [3] 5:13 13:3,12 17,22 16:24 12:3,5,10,15 13:3,20,24 14:
25 14:1,6
add [4] 14:9 15:6,16 16:21 auckland [1] 14:23 4,8,17,23,24 15:5,8,23 16:
clause [3] 5:20,21,23
added [2] 5:20 6:4 aware [4] 12:7,12 14:18 16: 3,10,19 17:5
clear [1] 10:15
7 court.” [1] 8:25
Sheet 1 107 - court.”
DH Reporting Services, Inc. (781) 575-8000
court’s [2] 7:9 14:3 frankly [1] 15:8 involved [1] 14:20
current [12] 5:15 7:16 9:6
E freely [1] 10:17 isn't [1] 11:14
10:9,9,24 11:3,15 12:24 13: earlier [4] 8:7 9:1 11:23 13:
full [1] 6:15 isolated [2] 10:12 11:14
8 14:6,7 11 fully [1] 4:14 issue [2] 16:14 17:2
easy [1] 10:22 further [1] 8:20 it’s [7] 4:6,6 5:23 6:2 10:22
D edge [1] 16:25 12:5,16
date [2] 11:21 15:25 entirely [1] 8:6 G itself [2] 12:4 15:7
deceptive [1] 8:20 entitled [4] 9:15 13:18 14: generally [1] 6:12
deciding 13:10[1] 2,6 glenn [1] 3:11 K
decision [5] 7:9 12:13,13 even [3] 4:5 13:15 15:10 got [3] 15:1,3 16:13 kind [2] 3:24 15:10
16:10 17:3 event [1] 11:22 grounds [1] 12:2 knowledge [2] 14:15 15:2
defend 8:23
[1] events 10:5,6 11:20
[3] knows [1] 14:14
defendant’s [4] 8:20,24 everyone [2] 3:5 9:21
H
10:1 13:12 everything [1] 13:17 hale [1] 3:14 L
defendants [1] 3:15 example [1] 5:18 happened [6] 6:1,3 10:5 lake [8] 3:7,14,14,16 14:9,
depending [1] 11:18 exhibit [5] 3:24 15:10,11, 11:21 13:17 14:15 10,20 17:6
describing [2] 7:16 16:8 24 16:6 he’s [4] 6:4 7:11 8:1 10:15 land [1] 8:25
detail [1] 4:19 exhibits [1] 15:10 hearing [2] 4:2 14:17 larace [1] 3:3
details [1] 16:3 explain [1] 7:16 hire 8:23
[1] larger [3] 7:17,25 10:12
determination [1] 12:3 explanation [1] 10:2 history [6] 10:11 11:12 13: last [4] 5:14,20,21,23
determined [2] 13:3,23 express [1] 6:7 9,16 16:3,8 late [1] 12:16
detriment [2] 8:21,21 expressly [1] 9:7 hold [3] 4:18 5:4,6 law [5] 6:15 14:15 15:1,1,3
different [2] 7:23 15:12 honor [41] 3:10,14 4:11,15 lawsuit [1] 14:16
difficult [1] 10:20
F 5:11,14 6:6,7,17,25 7:10, lawyer [1] 6:23
dig [1] 15:12 fabella [3] 14:12,14,20 15,18 8:17 9:5,15,17,25 10: least [2] 3:22 16:7
disagree [2] 6:5 8:17 fact 6:15 13:22
[2] 16 11:1,8,11,25 12:7,11,18, leave [1] 8:11
disclose [1] 16:11 facts [3] 6:13 9:8 13:2 22,25 13:1,6,9 14:1,14 15: lengthy [2] 15:18 16:6
disclosed [4] 3:22 4:4 9: failure 16:11 [1] 6,14,21 16:3,5,18 17:4,6 let’s [6] 5:18 8:18 9:10,10,
11,16 fair [2] 7:15,24 honor’s [1] 11:18 10 10:4
discloses [1] 9:7 faith 6:24 12:21
[2] however [5] 6:22 9:20 10: light [2] 6:7 14:3
disclosing [1] 12:22 fall [1] 11:16 8,21 16:6 limitations [6] 7:8 8:16
disclosure [1] 4:1 falling [1] 6:19 hundred [1] 6:14 10:7 11:17 12:2 13:4
discussed [3] 4:1,4 6:11 far 17:1[1] hypothetically [1] 11:20 litigated [4] 4:14 5:13 9:13
fargo [3] 3:3 14:12,23 16:15
discussing [1] 6:18 I
dismissal [2] 9:14 12:10 file [2] 9:4,15 litigation [10] 7:2 9:7 12:
filed [2] 8:9 9:13 i’d [3] 3:21,23,25 23,23 13:16 15:20,25 16:1,
dismissed [1] 12:1
filing [1] 15:24 i’ll [2] 5:1 17:2 4,9
dispute [1] 13:1
i’ve [2] 3:18 5:7
distinction [2] 10:15 11:9 find [1] 15:13 litigations [1] 14:25
identified [2] 5:7,12
distinguish [2] 9:9 15:19 firm [4] 14:15 15:1,1,3 little [2] 8:14 17:1
identify [1] 3:8
distinguishing [1] 12:23 first [4] 4:15 6:4 9:8 10:19 long [1] 10:19
fits [1] 7:25 incident [1] 10:12 longer [1] 14:14
district [1] 14:23
five [1] 9:13 initiative [1] 8:12 look [3] 8:18 11:13 17:2
document [2] 3:24 15:9
fly [1] 16:24 instance [1] 15:11 lose [1] 11:22
documents [1] 15:12
instead [1] 6:2
don’t [11] 3:21 4:9,10 6:15 follow [2] 10:20,22 lost [2] 9:13 11:24
instigation [1] 3:17
8:4 12:5 13:1 15:2,6,14 16: footnote 12:9 lot [1] 11:12
[1]
forced [1] 8:22 intentional [3] 10:2,23 13: lure [1] 8:22
21
foreclosure [2] 5:24 9:3 13
done [1] 8:1
forthrightly [1] 4:5 intentionally [1] 12:20 M
drafted [3] 6:9,21 10:18
four [2] 9:13 15:11 intentioned 16:24 [1] made [1] 10:25
drafting [1] 6:16
fourth 3:24 [1] interpretation [1] 13:5 main [2] 4:3,5
due [2] 7:22 17:3
Sheet 2 court’s - main
DH Reporting Services, Inc. (781) 575-8000
management [3] 4:4 14: outline [1] 7:25 provided [1] 11:12 same [6] 4:6 5:22 7:11 9:4
18,21 over [2] 9:8 16:2 provides [1] 13:8 11:22 15:2
many [1] 9:25 own [1] 8:12 published [1] 5:17 saying [2] 10:4 12:25
massachusetts [2] 12:8, purported [1] 5:15 says [1] 5:24
12
P purports [1] 8:10 section [1] 4:17
matter [2] 6:16 16:19 page [7] 4:17,25 5:8,11 8:5 see [2] 4:12 15:8
matters 8:8 [1] 15:16,21 Q seem [1] 4:7
mean [1] 14:24 pages [1] 16:7 question [8] 6:8,9,25 7:23 sent [1] 15:3
mentioned [1] 10:16 paragraph [16] 3:25,25 4: 11:7,11 12:19 15:18 short [1] 6:12
mentions 14:11 [1] 25 5:11,14,21 6:6,25 7:19 quiet [1] 8:24
show [3] 3:18 12:20 14:11
8:4,6,15,19 11:2,5 15:22
meritless [2] 6:23 12:21
paragraphs [14] 4:16 6:
R showing [1] 10:11
merits 12:6,14
[2] signed [1] 6:23
14 8:3 9:5,8,9 10:25 11:1, read [4] 3:18 4:8,8 10:19
miscellaneous [1] 3:3 simply [1] 10:25
13 13:8 15:17 16:1,2,8 really [3] 6:11,16 15:12
misconduct 10:23 [1] situation [1] 10:24
part [15] 7:1,17,18 9:6,19, reason [1] 7:20
morning [10] 3:5,6,7,10,13, sorry [1] 8:23
20,21 10:2,8,12,23 13:21 received [1] 10:19
14,16 4:8,9 5:19 sort [1] 12:13
14:10 15:18 16:6 recent [1] 9:20
ms 3:7,14,16 14:9,10,20
[7] specific [3] 5:12 6:24 8:7
particular [1] 11:21 record [1] 3:9
17:6 specifically [2] 8:14 11:
parties [1] 11:23 reference [2] 11:14 15:23
multiple 4:16 9:9 10:25
[6] 13
parts [2] 13:22,23 referenced [1] 16:11
11:1,15 13:7 standard [3] 6:18,22 10:
passing [1] 11:14 references [3] 15:24,24,
myself 5:19 [1] 21
past [3] 10:4 11:6 13:18 25
stark [1] 8:3
N phrase [1] 5:14 referred [1] 3:24
starting [1] 4:15
never [1] 6:11 picture [1] 7:25 relate [1] 13:2
state [2] 1:53 4:7
new [1] 8:9 plain [1] 6:13 relied [1] 8:20
statement [1] 6:13
next [1] 16:2 plaintiff’s [1] 4:22 relief [1] 11:10
statute [6] 7:6 8:16 10:7
nine [1] 15:21 plaintiffs [1] 8:22 re-litigate [1] 16:14
11:16 12:2 13:4
note [1] 5:14 plaintiffs’ [1] 8:23 relitigated [1] 13:18
statutory [1] 7:4
noted [1] 5:19 pleadings [1] 3:23 repeating [1] 6:4
still 6:4 16:13
[2]
nothing [3] 13:9,11 14:16 please [1] 3:8 represented [2] 14:12,22
street [2] 1:38,53
pleasure [1] 16:21 represents [1] 15:3
O point [8] 8:2 10:3 12:7,8 request [1] 11:10
subject [2] 14:19 16:1
suggesting [1] 13:17
obviously [1] 10:6 13:6 14:10 15:15 16:22 respect [4] 5:25 8:8,10 9:2
superior [3] 3:20 15:23 16:
occurred [5] 6:8 10:4,11 pointed [1] 4:1 respondent [1] 3:11
3
12:4 15:19 pointing [1] 3:20 respondent’s [1] 14:11
sword [1] 6:19
occurring [1] 15:20 prejudice [1] 12:10 response [3] 3:18 6:24 14:
often [1] 16:25 premises [2] 8:11,25 11 T
okay 8:3 15:5 17:3
[3]
present [2] 8:23 15:20 result 11:17
[1]
that’s [3] 5:19 7:22 16:14
one [9] 5:3,3,18,19 8:18 10: pretty [2] 8:3 16:13 rights [1] 8:24 themselves [1] 3:9
25 12:3 13:21 14:22 prevents 13:9 [1] rock [1] 1:38
there’s [3] 6:9 11:22 16:17
ones [3] 5:5,19 11:23 previous [1] 14:19 rope [1] 11:23 thereafter [1] 8:22
only [2] 8:7 15:6 previously [1] 13:3 rule [1] 6:18 they’re [2] 6:14,14
opposite [1] 6:12 prior [14] 5:13 7:1,22 9:7,9, ruled [2] 8:15 12:15
third [1] 3:23
order [5] 3:2,18 12:20 14: 22 12:1,23,23,24 13:25 14: rules [1] 7:18 though [2] 7:15 14:10
11 16:12 3,12 15:20 ruling [3] 7:22 11:18 14:3
three [4] 4:13 9:8 15:11,16
other [6] 5:21 8:3 9:23 12: problem [2] 4:3,5 russell [13] 3:6,11,12 5:20 throughout [1] 8:1
3 13:5 14:16 procedural [2] 16:3,8 6:10 7:24 9:22 10:14,23 12: title [1] 8:24
otherwise [1] 4:7 prohibits [1] 13:11 19 15:17,22 16:23 today [3] 3:12 6:18 10:21
out [10] 3:20 4:2 8:2,6 9:1
10:3 12:7,8 14:10 16:22
property [1] 8:13 S trying [1] 6:7
provide 9:23[1] turn [3] 8:4 11:2 15:21
Sheet 3 management - turn
DH Reporting Services, Inc. (781) 575-8000
twice [1] 9:4 you’ll [2] 6:13 10:14
two [1] 4:12 you’re [6] 9:18 13:15,18,
20 14:6 16:23
U you’ve [2] 12:15 17:1
u.s [1] 14:23
ultimately [2] 7:18 9:24
under [4] 6:18 13:13 14:7
16:19
underlying [1] 14:1
understand [3] 12:19 14:
22 15:8
understanding [2] 7:7
11:25
unless [1] 16:17
unnecessarily [1] 8:22
until [2] 5:23 8:11
up [2] 4:6 5:23
utterly [1] 6:23
V
verbally [1] 4:1
verbatim [3] 5:21 8:6 9:1
verbose [1] 10:20
verified [2] 4:22 15:22
violated [1] 10:3
violation [4] 10:9,24 12:4
13:10
violations [8] 9:23 11:3,
15,16 12:1,25 13:8 14:7
volition [1] 8:12
W
wait [1] 5:2
wasn’t [1] 4:1
way [2] 4:2 12:3
we’re [6] 5:24,25 6:2,3 12:
7 13:17
weighing [1] 14:6
wells [3] 3:3 14:12,22
what’s [2] 6:7 10:11
whatever [1] 16:10
whether [9] 4:3 7:18 9:23
10:1,21,22 12:3 13:10,12
whole [1] 13:16
will [3] 14:10 16:19 17:2
within [3] 4:16 11:16 15:12
without [1] 12:10
wrongful [1] 8:24
Y
years [2] 9:13 10:5
Sheet 4 twice - you’ve