Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
However, the System Approach has certain weaknesses as it doesn’t take micro perspective. It takes
macro perspective only explain institutions, and functions within political system. Example: Judiciary.
Thorson argued that persistence of the system is central not only to Easton’s theory but to his
exposition as well. He further argues that Easton’s framework is both mechanistic and artistic at the
same time-like a machine which is also alive but lacks operational possibilities.
William Mitchell criticized Easton’s concept of politics as the allocation of values, as leading to
misleading assumptions in theorizing politics.
Traditionalist says that system’s approach is nothing but conceptual framework. It brings complications,
lacks analytical depth, and is too general in nature.
Marxist call it status quoist, and Paul Kress called System's approach empty vision of politics which lacks
substance & projects very artificial nature of working of political system.
Despite numerous studies proving the effectivity of Political Economy approach, there exists certain
limitations which render its use only upto an extent. Lane Kenworthy says the approach seems
inadequately sensitive to the historical, political, and cultural contexts; As a matter of fact, political
culture scholars argue that the conceptual weakness of rational choice theory can be corrected through
the use of political cultures; political culture when conceptually clear and empirically defined is able to
specify the whole range of human objectives or goals.
William Roseberry writes that despite all the advancements in political economy through Marxism, some
short falls in the approach has led to criticism and alternate views on the interaction between society
and economy. Modes of production on a global scale often created conflicting forces across the
landscape because there is little room for human agency. Rather than serving the analysis of social
groups, mode of production analysis has been criticized as serving its self. Theories of political economy
understand that studying people in terms of capitalist processes often move into a kind of functionalist
reasoning. Political Economy Approach neglects understanding of Constitution, and Political Institutions
by turning its focus to economic aspects of polity. Studies related to the approach uses nomenclature
like North-South countries, Developing- Developed countries, Third world countries which has made
political economy approach biased. The approach is normative, and specialized knowledge is needed for
quantitative techniques utilized by it. Political Economy studies are costly due to sophistication, and due
to such numerous faultlines, it can't give comprehensive understanding of the subject.
Harsh Pant says that there is attitude problem in both nations, Russia has started looking all
relationships thru prism of zero-sum games whereas problem with India that it fails to accept "new
normal" of India-Russia relationship.
Recent visit of US National Security Advisor Gen McMaster and subsequent meetings with PM Modi,
NSA Doval points toward cordial continuation of Indo-US relationship. The two sides discussed a range
of bilateral and regional issues, including their shared interest in increasing defense and counter-
terrorism cooperation. NSA McMaster emphasized the importance of the US-India strategic relationship
and reaffirmed India’s designation as a Major Defence Partner,” it added while noting that the meetings
were “productive”.
According to a White House statement, Trump emphasised that Washington considers India a “true
friend and partner in addressing challenges around the world.” Both leaders were said to have discussed
opportunities to strengthen their partnership on the economy and defence. Several visits by Foreign
Secretary, National Security Advisor after the coming of new dispensation have reportedly discussed
contentious issues like H1B visa, safety of Indians, and a wide range of bilateral security issues related to
the defence relationship. Recent killings of Indian origin people in America have been flagging concerns
in both the countries, and If Trump acts on his promise of bringing down the corporate tax in the USA
from 35% to 15% & policy of “Buy American, Hire American”, it could encourage and tempt some US
companies currently based in India to relocate to USA. This could have an adverse impact on the Make
in India initiative of the Indian government if some companies leave the country.
As Manoj Joshi writes, a perusal of statements made by Trump during his campaigning would
demonstrate that he did not make any sharply critical comments about India as he did for many other
countries. On the contrary, he by and large made positive and laudatory references to India. He said that
if he got elected, India will have a true friend in the White House. He showered encomiums on Prime
Minister Modi saying that he is very energetic and that he (Trump) was looking forward to working with
him.
C Raja Mohan further adds that IORA can be a game-changer as New Delhi, Canberra seems to reinvest
in Indian Ocean regionalism lately but it's success would depend, to a large extent, upon what the
middle powers of the Indian Ocean littoral, like Indonesia, Australia and India, can do. Together the
three countries have already breathed new life into an organisation that few had heard of. Those who
did had taken IORA for dead. Indian Ocean Rim Association (IORA) celebrated its 20th Anniversary when
Indonesia, as the current Chair of IORA, hosted the first ever IORA Leaders' Summit on 7 March 2017 in
Jakarta under the theme "Strengthening Maritime Cooperation for a Peaceful, Stable, and Prosperous
Indian Ocean". In a historic first, the Summit brought together the Leaders of the 21 IORA Member
States and its 7 Dialogue Partners as well as other special invitees including the Republic of the Union of
Myanmar. Member States issued the Jakarta Concord - Promoting Regional Cooperation for a Peaceful,
Stable and Prosperous Indian Ocean - which sets out a vision for a revitalized and sustainable regional
architecture.
Conclude on following lines
However, IORA has a challenging task ahead. The ideas of regional and global integration that held sway
since the turn of the 1990s has taken some beating amidst the resurgence of the dark forces of de-
globalisation in the West. While Indonesia, Australia and other middle powers are important players in
the Indian Ocean, their regionalist priorities are elsewhere. As the largest economy and biggest military
power, it is largely up to India to shape the future of Indian Ocean regionalism.
Although Russia continues to insist that its ties with Pakistan will not come at the cost of its ties with
India, Moscow's tilt towards Islamabad has certainly injected growing uncertainty in the direction of the
India-Russia relationship.
After officially lifting an arms embargo against Pakistan in 2014, Pakistan’s military will be receiving four
Russian-made Mi-35M attack helicopters this year. This could bring concerns in India regarding this new
found love between Moscow and Islamabad.
India’s policy vis-à-vis Afghanistan will also have to evolve with these changing ground realities. New
Delhi has been demanding dismantling of safe havens and terror sanctuaries in the region, besides
pressing for deeper engagement of various stakeholders for Kabul’s stability and security.
Question : Do you think Japan is India's natural ally or India-Japan relations are
sub set of India-US relations?
Answer : Define India’s relations with Japan
Former Foreign Secretary Kanwal Sibbal defines Indo-Japanese partnership passing through "cherry
blossom" times. Former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, used the label “transformational” to describe
India’s relations with only two countries – the US and Japan, and the relationship with both these
countries have been phenomenally becoming the pillar of New Delhi’s Foreign policy.
In 2007, Abe wrote it would “not be a surprise if in another decade, Japan-India relations overtake
Japan-US and Japan-China ties”. Abe wants Japan to become a “normal” country in diplomacy and
defence which makes him aligned towards partnership with India. When PM Modi went to Japan last
year, this two-way domestic tie-up was tightened with Tokyo agreeing to help his flagship projects such
as Digital India and Skill India. Japan through successes such as the Delhi Metro and Maruti Suzuki, has
helped India expand its mindset. Recent Nuclear deal of Japan with India despite being Non-NPT
signatory was a marked exception from Japanese principle position and prove that relationship with
India is no more a mere sub-set of India-USA relationship.
Hence, India and Japan are creating a “Special Strategic and Global Partnership”, even as the Sino-Indian
“Strategic and Cooperative Partnership for Peace and Prosperity,” deepens.
While capital markets across the globe were quick to react and bounce back, long-term ramifications of
this verdict on geopolitics and geo-economics will unfold in the months to come. The decision certainly
does not bode well for the world economy that is still grappling in the clutches of recession and
austerity. However, this verdict may have positive implications for India, especially in economic and
trade ties, according to experts.
Moreover, now is the time for India to enter into an FTA with the UK. A depreciating pound also means
cheaper British imports into India, especially in the field of food, technology, fine liquor and capital
machinery. Also, in the longer run, Brexit could help strengthen India-UK economic relationship as the
UK seeks to compensate for loss of preferential access to EU markets.
Brexit may have the potential to affect immigration negatively, through "work and study routes" from
non-EU nations, as the nation has done in a move expected to make it difficult for British firms to hire
professionals from countries like India. The most worrying issue is that this exit might prompt other
nations to go ahead with shifting the power back to national governments in areas like immigration,
while maintaining the trading union.
Impact of Brexit on higher education opportunities for Indian students appears beneficial. A cheaper
pound will benefit Indian students seeking education in the UK.
Hence, as C Raja Mohan says New Delhi must immediately signal strong solidarity with Britain and
Europe, both of whom are likely to be weakened in the near term. Finding ways to rejuvenate the
economic and political ties to both should now be at the top of India’s diplomatic agenda.