Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
CONTENT
Chapter Title Page
no.
1 An open letter to The Vice Chancellor, Bengaluru North
University
2 ADIMA – the organization, origin and activities
3 ADIMA – the churning on “Art & Life”, culture
4 “Multiple Intelligences” [author – Howard Gardner] and
Education – A huge window of opportunity
5 Outstanding examples in education and teaching
methodologies
6 The potential of ADIMA to work on this mission
7 Macro environment offering synergy to this mission
8 The Mission – Drama Repertory to achieve objectives of
primary and secondary education
9 ADIMA “Rangabhoomi Shikshana Kendra” – the proposal for
the Innovative Drama Repertory
10 Proposed Budget
Respected Sir,
The last two decades of the twentieth century has witnessed an unprecedented
mobilization of the Dalits and the disadvantaged of Karnataka in the form of
Dalit Movements. While the movements were focusing on realizing the Rights
and Privileges as enshrined in the Constitution, several leaders were also
disturbed by the range of issues and dilemmas in modern society, which could
not be answered by only addressing Rights and Privileges enshrined under the
Constitution. These leaders believed [and developed a strong conviction too]
that several cultural practices of the OBCs and SC / STs [a vast majority of
people constituting the bottom of the pyramid in society] handed over through
generations by word of mouth and practice contributed to a sustainable life in
harmony with nature. After all, this vast majority has not only lived through
centuries in the hinterland across all geographies but also made enormous
contributions to the society in which we live today
ADIMA was established with this quest and has been nurtured over the last two
decades by this leadership. The quest for “Nelasamskriti” [the cultural practices
referred in the preceding paragraph] has been nothing but a road of thorns and
hurdles, what with the search for hitherto undocumented practices on the one
hand, and the easy visibility available for “art and culture” in the modern ‘world
of exhibition and entertainment’ on the other hand.
ADIMA has treaded this treacherous path over the past two decades and is
presently beaming with confidence and conviction of having a hold of the
“Nelasamskriti” and is desirous of offering it to the world. The proposed ADIMA
“Live and Let Live” Learning Centre is the first expression of this conviction, and
is presently a ‘bird developing wings on the verge of flying’
ADIMA is revving up its engine with this renewed energy and is looking forward
to pilot a project to dovetail “Nelasamskriti” in the field of education. This is
titled ADIMA “Rangabhoomi Shikshana Kendra”, an Innovative Drama Repertory
where student interns will be put through a three year program [our guess is
that this may eventually be a four year program] which will prepare them as a
teacher – facilitator to accomplish the basic objectives of primary and secondary
education. Throughout the three year program, the student interns will be
interacting with children of school going age group and will be responsible –
accountable for the accomplishment of these children
ADIMA believes that this will be path breaking work in the field of education in
India and is looking forward to partner with all individuals and institutions which
could contribute to this mission
With this mission in mind, I am writing to you seeking an affiliation for this
program with your esteemed University. I hereby do commit, on behalf of all my
colleagues in ADIMA that we will adhere to all the norms and rules prescribed by
the University for this Affiliation.
N.Muniswamy
President
“Hoonime Haadu” – 153 full moon day events conducted till mid-
December 2018
Water harvesting structures
Local knowhow and architecture applied in construction
Traditional crafts and art
Native vocations
Native Health Systems
Compilation of poems and stories on Native Knowledge used as part of co-
curricular syllabus in higher primary / secondary education in Karnataka
‘ADIMA’ publications
Mobile cultural troupe on native knowledge and culture, with special
emphasis on water - traversing across Karnataka
Cultural representation in Delhi and Columbia, reciprocal visits from other
countries
Quantum of Community Participation
Research processes and activities to understand and assimilate the
‘ADIMA’ cultural practices
“Hoonime Haadu” or the full moon day event conducted at Shivagange right
from the establishment of ‘ADIMA’ the organization has been the mainstay
program which people from all walks of life look forward to
Harvesting seepage water is an age old native practice for collecting and using
water in low rainfall regions. The Antaragange hills in Kolar, in which the
Shivagange campus of ADIMA is located, serves as an ideal location to harvest
such seepage water and store it for the prospective. A glimpse of the storage
structure or ‘Kalyani’ built and operational in the ADIMA campus is given below
This model is being used to illustrate to children in particular during the camps
and to the public in general – on the importance of water as a natural resource
and the ways and means to harvest, conserve and use
Native vocations
Going further, along the same lines, native vocations and native tools and their
relevance are also emphasized. Care is taken to ensure that the knowledge and
know-how discussed in local architecture, traditional crafts and art as well as
native vocations do not create a romantic image of the past meant for archiving
and storage, but their actual relevance even in the current context is discussed
and debated. A couple of illustrations are given below
Native health systems do not look at ‘health’ as a separate entity, but have a
holistic approach to local climate – food – diseases, etc. treating them with a
‘continuum’ perspective. The consequences of modern health practices treating
these factors as ‘isolated’ and ‘disaggregated’, on human health and life are
enormous over the last 200 years or so
Reducing these aspects of ‘modern medicine’ and getting the people to their
‘roots’ has been the endeavour of “Talemaaru Kutira’, an associate organization
of ‘ADIMA’. Not only have numerous people benefitted from the practice of
native health systems, but a few practitioners have also been trained – who are
leading their life and livelihood based on the knowledge gained. Of course, like in
any traditional health systems practiced across the globe, the data on long term
costs, benefits and absence of side-effects vis-à-vis the current allopathic
practices in vogue are anecdotal in nature owing to the absence of resources and
methodology to do a structured research and comparison
ADIMA has compiled a collection of poems titled “Darr Barr Buddanna” and a
collection of short stories titled “Kathe Kathe Karunda” based on native
‘ADIMA’ publications
Sl Title Author
1 Aavarana Anavarana N S Shankar
2 Kanaka Musuku Dr. K N Ganeshaiah
3 Saamanyana Sankramana N S Halappa
4 Kaaridaar Kaalakosha Je. Su. Na.
Brahmana Dharmada Digvijaya – Translation N S Shankar
5
[primary literature by Dr. B. R. Ambedkar]
Nadekaara Doddi Venkatagireppa mattavara Padmalaya Nagaraj
6
Aadhyaatmika Parampare
7 Nelakanaja Govindappa
Mobile cultural troupe on native knowledge and culture, with spec ial
emphasis on water - traversing across Karnataka
ADIMA cultural troupe cum Repertoire has traversed across all the districts of
Karnataka, conducted plays and other events on multiple themes
A cultural troupe of ADIMA visited New Delhi as well as Columbia in the year
2013 to stage the play “Eklayva Uvaach” [Eklavya speaks out] [PN / HMR to
give details about this play and the message as relevant to our proposal]
The most significant aspect of ADIMA’s existence over the last decade has been
the quantum of community participation in all its activities – be it in physical
participation by the people, pooling in of material resources for various activities
and last but not the least, in the form of money. The participation listed above is
in the descending order unlike most organizations where the order is reversed.
This is a fundamental aspect of ‘Nelasamskruthi’. The present accounting
systems have adequate means and potential to capture various forms of
community participation, but the same have not been in practice in ‘ADIMA’
organization over the years. Hence, it is very difficult to quantify this
participation, but a glimpse can be had from the comparison of the scale
and quantum of activities [as known in the public domain] vis-à-vis the
In the first phase, the organization decided to research the lives and teachings
[and document the experiences] of various practitioners of ‘Nelasamskruthi’ in
the past – in order to determine the path to be taken in the future. These
include Kaiwar Naarenappa, Tavarekere Ramavadhootha, Doddi Venkatgireppa,
Dakshinamoorthy, Malur T. Sonnappa, Ragi Lakshmanayya, Saalumarada
Thimmakka, Emme Basappa amongst others
Besides the leadership of ‘ADIMA’, others have also been carrying out this
research resulting in mainstream recognition of such literature
‘ADIMA’ envisages the study and assimilation of all these traditions and practices
[available in various forms like literature, tatvapada, Shataka sahitya, riddles
and puzzles, proverbs, folk literature, etc.] and apply it to the current context in
order to remedy the current ills thru an appropriately formulated education
system
Right through the two decades of existence of ADIMA, the quest for
‘Nelasamskriti’ remained in the context of finding answers towards a sustainable
life amidst the ever-increasing ‘consumerist’ society of today little caring about
tomorrow. Simultaneously, modern day discourse and thoughts were also at play
wherein everything native or tribal (be it an art form or dance or music or even
tools for life and livelihood) were ready material for exhibition and different
forms of entertainment. The glitz and glamour of the world of ‘Exhibition and
Entertainment’ would dilute the quest to ‘Show Value’. After the moment or
event when the exhibition or entertainment is over, there was little by way of
these being imbibed in today’s life. Neither these exhibitors [those within Adima]
nor the consumers [those who came to witness these exhibitions and shows]
demonstrated reasonable measure of adaptation in modern day life.
On the other hand, the serious quest for ‘Nelasamskriti’ showed that art and
culture were an integral part of life – be it in food practices or educating the
children or keeping good health or even including entertainment at regular
intervals. ‘Nelasamskriti’ never appeared to have any of these
compartmentalization.
The leadership of ADIMA kept on churning their minds with this dichotomy –
dilemma and were looking forward to possible ways where the overt and sole
focus on ‘Exhibition and Entertainment’ could be curtailed, if not eliminated
altogether.
One such experiment on which ADIMA is presently working is the ‘Live and Let
Live’ Learning Centre. A brief on this is enclosed below
The twenty-first century, on one hand, has brought a lot of scientific and
technological inventions while, on the other hand, has brought a range of issues
and dilemmas to mankind as a whole and to policy makers in particular – be it
Scores of people practicing this ‘ADIMA’ culture can be seen in the regions of
Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh and Tamilnadu as described earlier. ‘ADIMA’
practitioners have remained away from all the limelight in society, silently
practicing their culture without making any claims for redemption of this world in
any forum. These practitioners have developed and sustained a vast spectrum of
knowledge and practices in agriculture, crafts, medicine, art and artisans, etc.
Literature on ‘ADIMA’ culture in Telugu under various titles have even been
published and circulated even in the twentieth century, post-independence.
If ‘Nelasamskruthi’ advocates and provides for life and livelihood for every soul
on the face of this earth, then it should be able to provide an appropriate life and
livelihood to each and every teenager described in the preceding para. This is
the vision envisaged in the ADIMA ‘Live and Let Live’ Learning Centre. A three-
year life and livelihood learning curriculum [incorporating the ‘Deconstruction’
(Nirachane / Nirasana) aspect as well as life sciences and life skills] is proposed
for the students.
While the processes are underway to establish the ADIMA ‘Live & Let Live’
Learning Centre, there was a strong call within the organization to establish a
‘Rangabhoomi Shikshana Kendra’ [drama repertory] to effectively utilize the
infrastructure and experience over the years. The inspiration came from the four
drama repertories established and functioning in Karnataka [Rangayana in
Mysore, Neenasam in Sagar (Shivamogga), Shivasanchaara in Sanehalli
(hosadurga, Chitradurga district) and Kundapura Ranga samsthe in Kundapur
(Udupi district). These drama repertories conduct a one year certificate [or
diploma] course and the students passing out have active careers in the field of
art, cinema, TV serials, etc.
Once again the question of “Art and culture” for Life or for Entertainment came
to the fore. The Governing Body of ADIMA vehemently opposed setting up a
This chapter puts together excerpts from the various research papers and books
written by Howard Gardner prior to expressing the “Opportunity” available to
ADIMA. [The author of this proposal has taken the liberty to juxtapose different
pieces from different writings. Some paragraphs may appear disjoint or
disconnected. Any misrepresentation of Howard Gardner due to this is solely due
to the ignorance of the author of this proposal]
====
I am often asked how I first got the idea of the theory of multiple intelligences.
As a young person I was a serious pianist and enthusiastically involved with
other arts as well. When I began to study developmental and cognitive
psychology, I was struck by the virtual absence of any mention of the arts. An
early professional goal was to find a place for the arts within academic
psychology. I am still trying! In 1967 my continuing interest in the arts
prompted me to become a founding member of Project Zero, a basic research
group at the Harvard Graduate School of Education begun by a noted
philosopher of art, Nelson Goodman. For 28 years, I was the co-director of
Project Zero and I am happy to say that the organization continues to thrive.
Support from the Van Leer Foundation allowed me to carry out an extensive
research program with the aid of many younger colleagues. I saw this as a once
in a lifetime opportunity to collate and synthesize what I and others had learned
about the development of cognitive capacities in normal and gifted children as
well as the breakdown of such capacities in individuals who suffered some form
of pathology. To put it in terms of my daily calendar, I was seeking to synthesize
what I was learning in the morning from my study of brain damage with what I
was learning in the afternoon from my study of cognitive development. My
colleagues and I combed the literature from brain study, genetics, anthropology,
and psychology in an effort to ascertain the optimal taxonomy of human
capacities.
I was claiming that all human beings possess not just a single intelligence (often
called “g” for general intelligence). Rather, as a species we human beings are
better described as having a set of relatively autonomous intelligences. Most lay
and scholarly writings about intelligence focus on a combination of linguistic and
logical intelligences—the intellectual strengths, I often maintain, of a law
professor. However, a fuller appreciation of human beings occurs if we take into
account spatial, bodily-kinesthetic, musical, interpersonal, and intrapersonal
intelligences. While we all have these intelligences, individuals differ for both
genetic and experiential reasons in their respective profiles of intellectual
strengths and weaknesses. No intelligence is in and of itself artistic or non-
artistic; rather several intelligences can be put to aesthetic ends, if individuals so
desire. No direct educational implications follow from this psychological theory;
but if individuals differ in their intellectual profiles, it makes sense to take this
fact into account in devising an educational system.
In 1994-5 I took a sabbatical and used part of that time to review evidence for
the existence of new intelligences. I concluded that there was ample evidence
for a naturalist intelligence; and suggestive evidence as well for a possible
existential intelligence (“the intelligence of big questions”). I also explored much
more deeply the relation between intelligences—which I construe as
biopsychological potentials—and the various domains and disciplines that exist in
various cultures.
A final feature of this second phase entailed a more active involvement with
educational reform. This involvement took both a practical and a scholarly form.
On the practical level, my colleagues and I at Harvard Project Zero began
working with schools as they attempted to implement MI practices and other
educational programs that we have developed, such as teaching for
understanding. We also launched a Summer Institute which is now in its 7th
year. On the scholarly side, I began to articulate my own educational philosophy.
In particular, I focussed on the importance in the pre-collegiate years of
achieving understanding in the major disciplines—science, mathematics, history,
and the arts. For various reasons achieving such understanding is quite
challenging. Efforts to cover too much material doom the achievement of
understanding. We are most likely to enhance understanding if we probe deeply
in a small number of topics. And once the decision is made to “uncover” rather
than “cover,” it is possible to take advantage of our multiple intelligences. Put
concretely, we can approach topics in a number of ways; we can make use of
analogies and comparisons drawn from a range of domains; and we can express
the key notions or concepts in a number of different symbolic forms. This
analysis has led to a perhaps surprising conclusion. “Multiple intelligences”
Much work needs to be done on the question of how the intelligences can best
be mobilized to achieve specific pedagogical goals. I do not believe that
educational programs created under the aegis of MI theory lend themselves to
the kinds of randomized control studies that the federal government is now
calling for in education. But I do believe that well choreographed “design
experiments” can reveal the kinds of educational endeavors where an MI
perspective is appropriate and where it is not. To state just one example, I think
that MI approaches are particularly useful when a student is trying to master a
challenging new concept—say, gravity in physics, or the Zeitgeist in history. I
am less persuaded that it can be useful in mastering a foreign language—though
I admire those teachers of foreign languages who claim success using MI
approaches.
=====
On a more practical level, Gardner was disturbed by the nearly exclusive stress
in school on two forms of sym-bol use: linguistic symbolization and logical-
mathematical symbolization. Al-though these two forms are obviously important
in a scholastic setting, other varieties of symbol use also figure prominently in
human cognitive activ-ity within and especially outside of school. Moreover, the
emphasis on lin-guistic and logical capacities was over-whelming in the
construction of items on intelligence, aptitude, and achievement tests. If
different kinds of items were used, or different kinds of assess-ment instruments
devised, a quite dif-ferent view of the human intellect might issue forth. These
and other factors led Gardner to a conceptualization of human in-tellect that was
more capacious. This took into account a wide variety of human cognitive
capacities, entailed many kinds of symbol systems, and in-corporated as well the
skills valued in a variety of cultural and historical set-tings. Realizing that he was
stretching the word intelligence beyond its customary application in educational
psychology, Gardner proposed the ex-istence of a number of relatively auton-
omous humani ntelligences. He defined intelligence as the capacity to solve
problems or to fashion products that are valued in one or more cultural settings
and detailed a set of criteria for what counts as a human intelligence. Gardner's
definition and his criteria deviated significantly from established practices in the
field of intelligence
====
[The following is the interpretation of the proposal writer and not subject to any
academic scrutiny]
Each of these experiments has been commended for enhancing the overall
accomplishments and performance of the students enrolled under these
programs. Similarly, there is no dearth of summer camps for children with a
variety of themes promising higher accomplishments and performance in the
children.
Howard Gardner has lamented that across the globe primary and secondary
education focus on only two of the intelligences viz. linguistic and math-logic. A
close look at each of the above experiments reveals that they have incorporated
more than just the regular two intelligences (linguistic and math-logic).
Parents are more than willing to send their wards to such thematic camps and
schools being aware of the impact they have on the overall development of their
children. ADIMA itself has conducted a host of such summer camps for children
with gratifying results. These experiments are an indicator that if one was to
develop a curriculum with appropriate mix of “multiple intelligences” aimed at
developing the five frames of mind (as recommended by Howard Gardner), one
would be able to set a benchmark in education as well as render yeoman service
to society (after all, if children develop with the five frames of mind, they will no
doubt contribute to every walk of life they interact with and live in)
It is easy to discern that the five frames of mind are true characteristics of an
independent mind which is the objective of ‘Nelasamskriti’ and ‘Achala’
practitioners. This, in turn implies that the educational framework must include
elimination of static perspectives or UNLEARNING in order to realize the five
frames of mind recommended above. Together, the five frames of mind would
result in the term “mindfulness” used for ‘Achala’ practitioners in English
literature.
A couple of these teachers have taken voluntary retirement from their services
only to be able to do such meaningful work in ADIMA. There are more teachers
yearning to join this experiment cum pilot project
A glimpse of the chapter ‘ADIMA – the organization, origin and activities’ gives
ample evidence of use of components of “multiple intelligences” in all the
activities, especially with children
To begin with, there are many reports about the status of primary and
secondary education in Karnataka, which present a very dismal picture. For e.g.
the Annual Status of Education Report [ASER 2017] ‘Beyond Basics’ report
details the poor reading, writing and math capability among the youth aged 14 –
18 who will be entering the productive age group. The report further indicates
that these youth may not be able to lead productive lives owing to this. There is
enormous pressure on all concerned to find viable solutions to these problems
At the same time, there is no dearth of support for initiatives. Besides the efforts
of the education department, there are others who are willing to pitch in their
support for alternatives which hold promise. The Department of Social Welfare
supports innovative projects which could have a bearing on the disadvantaged
children in the last mile, mostly comprising dalits, tribes and OBCs. The
accreditation of Universities and global ranking give preference to innovative
programs which will have a bearing on the education of the future generation.
Thus universities established under the State Act as well as Central Act are open
to affiliate with such programs.
Why is the word “Mission” used in this proposal? There are several reasons to
this.
1. Howard Gardner himself in his writings has detailed evidence stating that
education systems and policies seldom change or change very slowly in
countries across the globe. This is a universal phenomenon. The inertia
involved is unbelievably high. Thus, any person, or institution, or
movement intending to pilot an example which should eventually lead to a
change in the education system and policy needs to take into account this
huge inertia
It is very essential that all the above happen in tandem. They should neither be
in sequence nor be asymmetrical. Hence the term “Mission” is used. Planning
and execution needs to be in Mission mode at all times
Having used the word “Mission” in the preceding chapter, it must be humbly
admitted that the current draft proposal is just an eye-opener on the subject
with several layers of detailing to be done to ensure that the “Mission” is well set
and is accomplishable. Each of the challenges mentioned in the preceding
chapter [along with those that are not yet envisaged and listed here] needs to
be addressed within the Mission. Broadly, they are categorised into the following
six modules at this juncture (can be altered as needed)
The members of the executive committee of ‘ADIMA’ and various activists who
have been involved with the various activities of ADIMA and / or involved in
schools as teachers over the years will be undergoing the process of
‘Deconstruction’ and learning the multiple intelligences theory and framework.
Such candidates will automatically be eligible to be teachers of the
‘Rangabhoomi Shikshana Kendra’, once they complete the above processes and
lessons and are certified practitioners. Ten such teachers are required for the
school. All the artists, writers and activists actively involved in ‘ADIMA’ over the
ADIMA envisages utilizing the pool of researchers and experts in order to define
the research required and the Action research Methodology. Defining such
research activities and action research methodology appropriately will naturally
add to the outcome of this mission as it will embed process monitoring, output
monitoring and outcome monitoring in a scientific manner from day one
Since the academic year 2018-19 is reserved for all preparatory activities
including seeking affiliation of the Bangalore North University, student intake is
proposed from academic year 2019-20 onwards. Each batch will consist of 30
students. Each such batch will receive residential education facilities at
Shivagange campus for a period of three years. The eligibility criteria and
selection process for the students will be determined along with the development
of syllabus and curriculum. Besides lessons on ‘Deconstruction’ and multiple
intelligences framework, the syllabus also includes actual involvement with
children in educational activities. This necessitates a lot of field activities and
practical work outside the Shivagange campus.
The first batch of 30 students seeking admission in the academic year 2019-20
will be able to graduate from the “Rangabhoomi Shikshana Kendra” around
March – April 2022. If ADIMA carries out the “Mission” appropriately, these
graduates should be in a commanding position to get significant roles in primary
and secondary education. They could also choose alternate careers since they
will be very experienced artists. This proposal is prepared taking into account
the expenses till academic year 2021-22
30 teenager students are proposed to be admitted every year from the academic
year 2019-20 onwards. A three year education would mean that accommodation
for 90 such teenagers needs to be available on-campus. Residential facilities for
the 10 teachers as well as guest house facilities for visiting experts / resource
persons are to be newly built. Computer systems for this Learning Centre are
also envisaged. Study of each of the multiple intelligences will need a well-
equipped laboratory cum study centre with its own specific features
incorporated. All these additional infrastructure are proposed under the “Non-
Recurrent” component of the budget enclosed.