Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Abstract - Microgrids are networks of small, distributed There exists considerable research to date on
electrical power generators operated as a collective unit - Microgrids with a number of major research projects
a system of energy systems. The range of hardware and underway, for example [1-8]. A number of demonstration
control options for Microgrid operation are reviewed. The projects have been commissioned internationally. However
paper summarizes and highlights the operating principles development of these systems and projects has largely been
and key conclusions of research andfield trials to-date. An undertaken independently. For the first time, this paper
overview is given on demonstration projects for brings together information from these field trials, in the
Microgrids which have been, and are being, constructed. context of research to date. The information presented is
perforce limited, in so far as public information on some
Keywords: Microgrids, renewables, power quality, energy projects is limited. Space also precludes the discussion of
storage, distributed generation, micro-generation. many of the smaller laboratory-scale Microgrids at
universities (as used for example in [2-5]).
1 Introduction
The use of micro-generation based on combined heat 2 Microgrid Structures
and power (CHP) or small-scale renewable generation has The topology elements required in a Microgrid are
a significant potential for reducing our dependency on strongly dependent on its operating states. A Microgrid has
fossil fuels. Since this could turn many consumers of two steady states of operation: grid connected operation
electricity into net producers, this strategy is not easily and islanded. It also has two transient states, corresponding
to the transitions between these steady-states. During all
accmmoatd i peset istibtio ntwoks
Some form of fast-acting energy absorption and Clearly the steady-state coordination of loads and
injection capability (2, figure 1) is usually required to micro-generation is an important topic [9]. However it is
balance power flows at the onset of Microgrid islanding. In the transient behaviour requirements of semi-autonomous
a more sophisticated Microgrid control scheme, energy operation which determine much of the additional cost of a
storage could also be used to control the net power flows to Microgrid over conventional distributed generation. An
and from the utility in the grid connected mode, allowing example of such behaviour is the control response to
the Microgrid to behave as a 'model' citizen, capable maintain system stability during islanding. Proposals for
assisting stable network operation by providing improved Microgrids can be categorized roughly into three types,
power quality and voltage control for example. depending on how they achieve this transient (short time-
frame) stability:
Point of Couplng
(P_C) nrUW 1A. Virtual 'Prime Mover' - In this scheme a central
ET G2 controller samples Microgrid state variables and dispatches
Utility network C&ftL r- signals to all (or at least the dominant) micro-sources using
fast telecommunications. This aggregation creates one
5Y 8 | _PE
1|1 1 4 virtual power supply unit which dominates and controls the
Possible Power
11Electwnxcsilerface 55
Microgrid's behaviour. Problems with this method are the
need to achieve a reliable communications system, the need
CorinecUon Mtr for some back-up control should the communications fail,
_
_ Communication
OMMXitStn AGA G-----r
eneratort I6
-
the telecommunications cost and the restriction imposed by
line1 ft/lal
PElimited numbers of telecommunications channels /
V I sensor Photovolts a _Ibandwidth on Microgrid expansion.
NumtOr See text tfr description
General load (impedance, or 7 B. Physical 'Prime Mover'- In this scheme a large
motr, or powr elteronics). central hardware unit, either energy storage or generation,
isiscnrletohdetasetpwrfosadst
controlled to handle transient power flows and set
Figure Potential Microgrid System Technologies
1.1.PotentialMicrogridSystemTechnologies
Figure voltage magnitude and frequency to balance steady-state
real and reactive power flows in islanded mode. Problems
The characteristics of the loads and micro-generation are the cost of the central unit (or aggregate unit if multiple
(i.e. 3-7, figure 1) determine the requirements for energy units are paralleled), the reliance of Microgrid operation on
storage and power quality in the Microgrid. In general the this centralluit(ie ove relia bility) an th
addition of a power electronics interface to a unit adds difficulty of sizing the central unit bearing in mind the
extra controllability and increases the unit's speed of potential for future changes in load and micro-generation.
response. Local energy storage in conjunction with a power
electronics interface (for example on the dc link of the C Distributed Control - In this last scheme each unit
power electronics) can add robustness. As a crude form of responds to variation in local state variables, typically
control, non-critical loads may have under-frequency load- voltage magnitude and frequency. A slow central controller
shedding relays (e.g. 7, fig. 1). Load power electronics may send signals to vary steady-state (nominal) set-points,
interfaces in contrast could potentially be used to provide but for redundancy, local control determines transient and
continuously variable power consumption by non-critical default behaviour. The speed of response of the distributed
power loads (e.g. ventilation). Power electronics interfaces elements must be sufficient to ensure stable Microgrid
do have disadvantages; they potentially increase harmonic operation with careful Microgrid design. This type of
injection and can be quite sensitive to systems control typically requires that micro-generation units have
disturbances. power electronic interfaces to achieve the fast response
required. An 'intelligent' connection interface is also
There must be some degree of central control (8, needed to reconnect the Microgrid to the utility network
figure 1) or co-ordination between all Microgrid elements when their voltages (which will need to be at different
in order that they operate as a system. Common Microgrid frequencies by design) pass close to alignment. Careful
state variables, instantaneous phase voltages and currents at system design is necessary to balance loads and generation
the point of coupling, must be regulated. The drn sadn n eoncinwtotuacpal
communication required can be by means of a voltage disturbance.
telecommunications line, a signal superimposed on the
2
Authorized licensed use limited to: Inha University. Downloaded on August 17,2010 at 01:06:17 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
The Microgrid implementations described below have two commercial customers (in the initial, phase A, of
been categorized further by geography and the research project) and serves a mixed load set [12]. The medium
consortia which were involved in their implementation i.e. voltage switch and NPS new building are controlled by a
American, Asian and European. central Microgrid controller. Although the central
controller, and absence of storage, makes this is a type A
3 American Microgrids Microgrid, the autonomous micro-generation makes the
design of this type of Microgrid extremely challenging.
3.1 AEPCERTS
PoC 1~kI$Vvrar
_~~~~~~~~ 14
od Utilty networkCer
I v
95kWh peak
ra le Z loa
X I-
7.2kV 4
UtiIl
ty
variabe Z load,
I95kW peak
.PEEG
P0 fbse
20W
500kVA prop ne
gen et
100kW
PE Z load,
abIE H
variable _ 25kVA
Vltoad bus
cri ica biodiesel
genset
6OkW ~~~~2Ohp motor load bulddIng) P
variable Z load, II 2.5kVA 30I
95kW peak
The Consortium for Electric Reliability Technology Figure 3. Mad River Microgrid
Solution (CERTS) Microgrid is a collaboration between
AEP, TECOGEN, Northern Power Systems, S&C Electric 3.3 BC Hydro Boston Bar
Co, Sandia National Laboratories and the University of
Wisconsin. The facility is located at the AEP Walnut Test The British Columbia Hydro Boston Bar substation
facility and is formed by a radial feeder with line lengths allows intentional islanding of a feeder with 3MW peak
up to 175 yards, connected through a 1.5MVA load and 8.6MVA of hydroelectric generation [11]. Power
480V/13.2kV transformer to the utility. Three 60kW
Tecogen Combined Heat and Power Sources, driven by
outages occur severalytimesperiyear forebetweenl12 and20
hours Studies of system islanding, resynchronization and
natural gas fed engines, form the Micro-generation. They black-start on this system (by means of a 50kW diesel-
are interfaced by controlled inverters which use terminal generator) are useful for Microgrid technology
voltage and real power export as the control variables, with development. The system effectively employs a single
a combination of P-f and V-Q droop line and PI control large generation station to control the net sub-system
loops [10,11]. Four load banks are used. Three are behaviour, i.e. uses type B Microgrid control.
impedances which can be varied in steps (with a peak real
*
power rating of 95kW). A fourth load bank *also includes 6~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~9kV25kV
a Utiliy network 1M
directly connected induction motor, to allow islanded
motor starting tests. Energy storage is integrated via a
bidirectional dc:dc converter into the dc link of the power POC
electronics interface of the micro-generation. The system
has been designed so that the critical loads are located to 3MW peak 043MVA hydro
the right of the solid-state (anti-parallel thyristor)
connection interface (figure 2) and there is always
4 h
3
Authorized licensed use limited to: Inha University. Downloaded on August 17,2010 at 01:06:17 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
A Microgrid concept.
27VV as turbine
scanliTmalr
scalemicro9id
22kW gas
20KW lea3d'acd
banttery T
engine
RI|
PE m
I0k
P
IEF
2_kW gas
PERX
. .....
T
turbine G PE 350VV
Cotrol Syste
C _ntral
G
4
4.1
Asian Microgrids
Shimizu's Microgrid
ility network
as engine
350kW gas engie
n PE1 TX NiMH
400kh
battery
uEtrapaciEor supply
consumer
Hachinohe Project
The New Energy and Industrial Technology
Development Organization (NEDO) in Japan has started
three demonstrations as part of the "the Regional Power
Grid with Renewable Energy Resources Project". These
projects qualify for the national program because they have
a significant share of renewable energy in a microgrid. The
sites are in Hachinohe, Aichi and Kyoto.
Y tit network
building' 360kWV
Sewge
G
2W wind 10kW P
turbines
50kW 100kW
This project,
Bia
at
40kW load
engines
_
4k ld
rkW
I
Wl -
lad
G 'onakano
ementaY
Elementary
battery
ultracapacitor (4 second rating). The Shimizu research generation units over a variety of telecommunications
4
Authorized licensed use limited to: Inha University. Downloaded on August 17,2010 at 01:06:17 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
UUiltynetwork
PV
30kWN
4.4
lOOkW
PV
3301tWPV
33OkW PV
Aichi Project
g_ ti1ty network
FOl
25kWFuel
O
Fuel Cell
Fuel Cielg
Ce~I
Kowakj substation
i_ asaka,tuebine
substation
citra 1MW Of
E~
PV
PE0kW
lOkW
RE
~~~~~central systemj
control
*_rn~ ~ ~ ~ PV
infrastructure, and the existing utility network to control
demand and supply, making this a type A Microgrid.
Biogas is generated from (food) waste.
FO 250kW
-
ybattery
EXhibition Building
Exhdt-
FelCll,
~ G~ Mgui
~ -PE-C, 3OO
CFC
Budding gnignl P
FO270kW MC
powewerpantCl
qaityOloads)
-_______
Cmentra C ontro Ssterfi
L4.6
Q
205_M ga
~
Wg
Utility network
PE
system
igr .SediPojc:Mltpepwe
Hsinchiang, China
P
ADG
TO
ultyspl
380V feeder
40 homes, 3 businesses_
(90kW peak load, night)
Cl
DR
High powr qualiy
loads (B3 )3OkW
High powe qua hty
odsB)lk
Pium' power
AdCAC quality loads (A)
Load 20kW
|b 1 00kW genset
Q
80kW
batter
60kW
Renewable generation, battery energy storage and fuel cells PV
(solid-oxide, molten carbon and phosphoric acid) were Figure 10. Hsinchiang China
integrated. The MCFC and SOFC act as base-load
generation. Garbage fermentation and gasification act as In addition to its other Microgrids research,
energy input to the MCFC. A by-product of employing the Mitsubishi Electric has also installed a small Microgrid in
fuel cells was refrigeration of cold water for air Hsinchiang China [20]. The peak load of 90kW can be
conditioning. A common central interconnection console supplied by a combination of the distribution network, PV,
allows energy management to be simplified, by selecting battery and genset operation.
which systems to run, making this a type A system. The
system was moved to Central Japan Airport City. 5 European Microgrids
5
Authorized licensed use limited to: Inha University. Downloaded on August 17,2010 at 01:06:17 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Control is by means of real power (P) vs. frequency (f )
and reactive power (Q) vs. voltage (V) droop lines, though
on a single-phase basis. The single-phase nature of the
system places limits on the available bandwidth of the
power signals and has led to the suggestion that input and
output control signals be
10k`W
Battery
Energy
Storage
5.2
36kW PV
5VA
diesel
get
interchanged, i.e. inverter output
frequency and voltage be controlled in response to
measured power signals [23]. The system is essentially a
prototype for the type B Microgrid control philosophy.
1 1kW PV
3phase
55kWdi8esel
generator
-t.
5m'c
microtutbine
'
PE
_PE
generator lZ51V
55kW diesel
REP
Figure 13. Labein Microgrid
i
2
PE PE
1 kVA
peak
household
loads
]rbin
1
1925Ah
6kW
lultracap
flywheel
6kW wind
Ut net
Utlity network
~~~~~5.4CESI
PE1Utility ne|
l,kW
800
1 0kW ste rIiin
engine
FuelCell
100kW
flywhee
microturb4ne
1
G
15OkWMC~ ~ diesl
I 10kW
kVA
CAme
Poc
Gicrturbine
, jI ! (. ¢| I,
a_
PE
e=
Line
Contro
80kW
HE
XOOkW
P
71kVApeak
consumer8Woads
tW l| |l{<2D~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 2kW
6
Authorized licensed use limited to: Inha University. Downloaded on August 17,2010 at 01:06:17 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Together with EMforce and Germanos, Continuon is Pentadyne flywheel forms the energy storage. Expansion of
upgrading a holiday park it runs in the Netherlands into a the Microgrid is planned with two CHP units rated at 9kW
Microgrid [3]. At present the park consists of 200 holiday and 5.5kW (electrical). The total on-site load varies
cottages, many of which have grid-connected between about 80kW to 230kW. The building's 60kW
photovoltaics. The total 315kW of installed photovoltaics ventilation and 48kW boiler loads are controllable. This
exceeds the load during the day. Plans are underway to add Microgrid's structure is still under development though at
a central battery energy storage unit and power electronic present the combination of a large central store makes it a
converter along with a central microgrid controller to allow type B Microgrid. The addition of centrally controllable
load control and resynchronization. The Microgrid is thus a loads would however introduce type A elements.
type B.
The 'Am Steinweg' estate with 400 inhabitants in
5.6 Demotec Stutensee, Germany is another of MVV's Microgrid
projects. The low voltage (LV) closed ring structure has
Utlity 400kVA 5kPwind 28kW (electrical) of CHP installed and PV installations
rbine simrulator with a total peak power of 35kW. In addition 880Ah of
kVA MG Set \ )
lead-acid battery are interfaced through a bi-directional
kV 15Jtconverter. MVV is using this installation to trial the use of
their power management system in this type A system.
1 75kVA_ PV-Battery
LP subsysem Lastly MVV is constructing a Microgrid in
Mannheim-Wallstadt. The installed microgeneration is at
present only 30kW peak of PV, but substantial further
80kVAMG set 4 | Lliil_ 'expansion of the microgeneration is planned.
2OkVA diesel G P P PV-Battery- 6 Conclusions
genlset _ di.esel sub-
3OkVA diesel gen G Many systems have been constructed to evaluate the
concept of enhanced micro-generation. Colloquially called
'Microgrids', this has become a 'buzz-word' that covers a
great many types of system. The majority of such systems
PV Inverte t s P Ehave opted for either a virtual or a physical 'prime mover'
PE;_ Solar-Battery topology. In part this reflects the on-going development of
tSm
_ iXs, Microgrids from distributed generation systems and the
PV-Balte 1 X1Supervisory nature of these projects as 'hardware demonstrators'. In
l monAonnl
1gl
u
connection
-rid part it reflects the usefulness of a single large prime-mover
Connection u bredktr
nt located near the point-of-coupling (PoC) with the utility
Batbery banks! W PE to unwersity contol E being able to dominate the system behaviour at the PoC.
virual baftery labs
A distributed approach throws up more challenges for
the system design - PoC behaviour is no longer dictated by
a single unit (physical or virtual). However, in principle,
The Demotec facility at ISET [27] in Kassel
the Microgrid is less reliant on any one piece of hardware
Germany has been used extensively to develop and extending the Microgrid would not require a change to
methodologies for the control of distributed generation. It
was also used in the first EC Microgrids project [2] to e hardwareofof anyy of the already
the y installed system
y
evaluate central control and unit control strategies.elmnsOfcuesotae elemnts Ofcourse software changes hngs may ay still
tilbbe
necessary to ensure that design constraints of the modified
system (e.g. feeder voltage limits) are still observed.
5.7 MVV Energie Projects
MVV in Germany is presently piloting a number of We look forward to the results of on-going field trials
Microgrid Projects [3]. The substation network connected to address these and other issues in the development of this
to the MVV headquarters building in Mannheim Germany exciting field.
has been identified by MVV as a site to investigate
Microgrids [28]. The proposed system includes residential References:
and commercial units and loads: the MVV headquarters and
an adjacent apartment block which are fed from a single [1] R.H. Lasseter, "Microgrids", IEEE Power
substation. A 4.7kW PEM fuel cell and 3.8kW of PV form Engineering Society Winter Meeting, 2001, vol. 1, pp. 146-
the installed on-site micro-generation [3]. A 120kW g
Authorized licensed use limited to: Inha University. Downloaded on August 17,2010 at 01:06:17 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
[2] European Research Project "Microgrids", [17] "Garbage becomes electricity at state-of-the-art plant",
http://microgrids.power.ece.ntua.gr, 2003-5. New Energy and Industrial Technology Development
Organization (NEDO),
[3] European Research Project "More-Microgrids", http://www.nedo.gojp/kankobutsu/pamphlets/kouhou/fy20
http://microgrids.power.ece.ntua.gr, 2006-9. 04/27_28.pdf
[4] "Highly Distributed Power Systems" UK Research [18] "New Energy on-site research at EXPO 2005 Aichi,
Council Supergen project grant GR/T28836/01, 2005-9. Japan", http://www.ntt.co.jp/csr_e/kankyo/03_03.html,
NTT on-line newsletter.
[5] "UK-Microgrids", UK Research Council EPSRC grant
EP/C00177X/1, 2005-8. [19] K.Hirose et al, "Study on Field Demonstration of
Multiple Power Quality Levels System in Sendai,
[6] S.Morozumi, "Technology Development For Grid- International Telecommunications Energy Conference,
Connection Issues", Renewable Energy 2006, Chiba, September 2006
Japan, Oct. 2006
[20] T. Goda, "Microgrid Research at Mistubishi",
[7] US Department of Energy Electricity Distribution California Energy Commission symposium, June
Programme, "Advanced Distribution Technologies and 2005,http://www.energy.ca.gov/pier/esi/documents/2005-
Operating Concepts - Microgrids", http:// 06-17_symposium/GODA_2005-06-17.PDF
www.electricdistribution.ctc .com/microgrids .htm
[21] P. Strauss and A. Engler, "AC Coupled PV Systems
[8] International Journal of Distributed Energy Resources, and Microgrids - State of the Art and Future Trends", 3rd
Microgrids Special Issue 2006/7, ISSN 1614-7138, editor World Conf. on Photovoltaic Energy Conversion, Japan,
N Hatziargyriou 2003, pp. 2129-2134.
[9] A.L Dimeas and N Hatziargyriou, "Operation of a [22] J. Schmidt, P. Strauss and P. Schweizer-Ries, "More
Multi-agent system for microgrid control", IEEE Trans. than a Light-bulb", Renewable Energy World, July-August
Power Systems, vol. 20, no. 3, Aug. 2005, pp. 1447-55 2003, pp. 192-199
[10] P. Piagi and R.H. Lasseter, "Autonomous Control of [23] A. Engler, C. Hardt, P. Strauss and M. Vandenbergh,
Microgrids", IEEE PES Meeting, Montreal, 2006. "Parallel operation of generations for stand-alone single-
phase hybrid system", EPVSEC Conference, Munich
[11] R.H. Lasseter and P. Piagi, "Control and Design of Germany, 2001.
Microgrid Components", Final project report, PSERC
publication 06-03, http://certs.aeptechlab.com/ [24] A. Amorim, A.L. Cardoso, J. Oyarzabal and N. Melo,
"Analysis of the Connection of a Microturbine to a Low
[12] J. Lynch, "Update on Mad River Microgrid and Voltage Grid", International Conference on Future Power
Related Activities", CERTS Microgrid Symposium, June Systems, 2005
17, 2005.
[25] J. Oyarzabal, F. Fresquet, A. Amorim and A.
[13] C. Abbey, F. Katiraei, C. Brothers, L. Dignard-Bailey Androutsos, "Large Scale Integration of Micro-Generation
and G. Joos, "Integration of Distributed Generation and to Low Voltage Grids", DII Deliverable Report, European
Wind Energy in Canada", IEEE Power Engineering Commission Framework V Microgrids project.
Society Meeting, June 2006
[26] A. Invernizzi, "Technologies to Innovate Distribution
[14] J. Baba, S. Suzuki, S. Numata, T. Yonezu, S. Networks with DG", IEA Workshop on Electricity T&D,
Kusagawa, A. Denda, T. Nitta and E. Masada, "Combined Session V - Integrated Distributed and Intermittent
Power Supply Method for Microgrid by the Use of Several Sources, Paris Nov. 2004.
types of Distributed Power Generation systems", European
Conf. on Power Electronics and Applications (EPE), 2005. [27] T. Degner, and P Strauss, "Laboratory for Distributed
Generation", EC Project DISPOWER , Project Highlight
[15] A. Denda, "Shimizu's microgrid research activities", document no. 3, http:// www.iset.uni-kassel.de/
Symposium on Microgrids, Montreal, June 2006.
[28] "ISET Institutionsbericht 2005 - Erfolge und
[16] 5. Morozumi, "Overview of Microgrid Research and Perspektive", 2005 Yearly Report of the Institute for Solar
Development Activities in Japan", International Energy Technology, Kassel, Germany.
Symposium on Microgrids, Montreal, June 2006.
8
Authorized licensed use limited to: Inha University. Downloaded on August 17,2010 at 01:06:17 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.