Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Lowe (13792)
Eric W. Hinckley (13991)
James R. Jackson (15869)
LOWE LAW GROUP
310 E. 4500 S., Ste. 150
Salt Lake City, Utah
Telephone: (801) 917-8500
Facsimile: (801) 917-8484
pete@lowelawgroup.com
eric_h@lowelawgroup.com
james@lowelawgroup.com
Attorneys for Plaintiff
Defendants.
Cindreia Europe, by and through undersigned counsel, hereby complains and alleges against
Defendants as follows:
Page 1 of 10
PARTIES
Douglas County, Colorado and is the mother of the deceased, Cindreia Europe, and serves as
Center (“Defendant VECC”) is a Utah corporation doing business in Salt Lake County, Utah.
6. Upon information and belief, Defendant West Valley City (“Defendant West
Valley”) is an incorporated city whose police department operates in Salt Lake County, Utah.
7. DOES I-V and ROES CORPORATIONS VI-X are individuals and corporations
8. This Court has jurisdiction over the parties and the subject matter of this Complaint
GENERAL ALLEGATIONS
10. On the night of March 5, 2019, Cindreia Europe (“Cindreia”) laid down in the
Page 2 of 10
parking lot located at 2300 East and 3304 South in Millcreek, Utah.
11. Rodney Johnson, an employee of a nearby business, called 911 dispatch regarding
12. Upon information and belief, Mr. Johnson’s 911 call was routed to an Unknown
Dispatcher at VECC.
13. Mr. Johnson specifically informed the Unknown Dispatcher that there was an
individual in dark clothing laying down in the middle of the parking lot near the Zions Bank and
14. Upon information and belief, the Unknown Dispatcher was working within the
course and scope of her employment with VECC at the time she received Mr. Johnson’s 911
emergency call.
15. Upon information and belief, in response to Mr. Johnson’s 911 emergency call, the
16. Defendant Megan Franklin, an officer of the Unified Police Department, responded
to the dispatch that she was in the area and would respond.
17. The Unknown Dispatcher informed Officer Franklin of the need for a welfare check
of an individual on the ground wearing dark clothing and provided Officer Franklin with the
18. Upon information and belief, the Unknown Dispatcher failed to relay further
information regarding Cindreia, including but not limited to, that Cindreia was laying down in the
parking lot and Mr. Johnson was concerned that she would be run over.
Page 3 of 10
20. After entering the parking lot, Defendant Franklin failed to keep a proper lookout
and was travelling at an unreasonable speed and ran over Cindreia with her patrol vehicle.
21. Despite running over Cindreia, Defendant Franklin, apparently unaware that she
had run over Cindreia, failed to slow or stop her patrol vehicle, resulting in her patrol vehicle
22. Defendant Franklin turned her vehicle to the left as she turned the corner of the
Zion’s Bank, which upon information and belief, caused Defendant Franklin’s vehicle to run over
23. After Defendant Franklin made the left turn, Cindreia came out from under
24. Cindreia thrashed around in pain for minutes fighting for her life before eventually
25. Prior to this subject accident, Defendant Franklin was formerly employed with the
West Valley Police Department where she was at-fault for numerous car accidents and damage to
26. Said incidents include, but may not be limited to, the following: Officer Franklin
damaged her vehicle on April 10, 2010 by running into a large rock; ran into a vehicle after
performing a U-turn on July 26, 2010; was reported speeding and weaving in and out of traffic on
March 4, 2012; hit a construction barrel with her patrol vehicle on August 27, 2013; backed her
patrol vehicle into a light pole on November 8, 2014; hit a concrete curb on December 22, 2014;
rear ended another vehicle due to “taking her eyes of the road” and injured herself for not wearing
a seat belt on February 24, 2015; and damaged her patrol vehicle due to running over large rocks
Page 4 of 10
on May 6, 2017.
28. As a result of her poor driving history, Defendant Franklin resigned from the West
29. Upon information and belief, representatives of the West Valley Police Department
failed to disclose Defendant Franklin’s dangerously poor driving record to Unified Police
Department.
30. Upon information and belief, representatives of the Unified Police Department
failed to inquire as to Defendant Franklin’s driving history prior to beginning her employment
31. As a result of the Defendants’ negligence described above, Cindreia Europe passed
away.
32. Plaintiff incorporates all preceding paragraphs herein and further alleges the
following.
including, but not limited to, her duty to exercise reasonable care and to avoid putting others in
danger.
34. Defendant Franklin breached this duty by failing to maintain a proper lookout in
her patrol vehicle and/or driving at an unreasonable rate or speed resulting in her striking Cindreia.
Page 5 of 10
35. Defendant Franklin is liable for these acts of negligence and for such other acts of
negligence as may become apparent during the course of discovery in this case.
37. As a direct and proximate cause of Defendant’s negligence, Plaintiff has incurred
38. Plaintiff incorporates all preceding paragraphs herein and further alleges the
following.
39. At all relevant times, Defendant Franklin was acting within the course and scope of
40. Defendant Unified Police Department is vicariously liable for Defendant Franklin’s
negligence.
41. Plaintiff incorporates all preceding paragraphs herein and further alleges the
following:
42. Defendant Unified PD’s actions constituted a breach of multiple duties of care
including, but not limited to, its duty to exercise reasonable care in hiring and/or retaining
Defendant Franklin.
43. Defendant is liable for these acts of negligence and for such other acts of negligence
Page 6 of 10
44. As a direct and proximate cause of Defendant’s negligence, Cindreia Europe passed
away.
45. As a direct and proximate cause of Defendant’s negligence, Plaintiff has incurred
46. Plaintiff incorporates all preceding paragraphs herein and further alleges the
following:
47. Defendant Unified PD had a duty to provide its employees with the proper training,
equipment, and tools necessary to complete all duties in a manner which prevented foreseeable
practices of its employees, which created a foreseeable risk of injury to foreseeable plaintiffs.
49. Defendant Unified PD’s work practices violated applicable rules and regulations,
50. As a direct and proximate cause of Defendant’s negligence, Plaintiff has incurred
51. Plaintiff incorporates all preceding paragraphs herein and further alleges the
following:
care including, but not limited to, her duty to reasonably inform responding officers of the
Page 7 of 10
information she had been provided.
53. Defendant Unknown Dispatcher breached this duty by failing to properly notify the
responding police officers that Cindreia was laying down in the parking lot.
54. Defendant is liable for these acts of negligence and for such other acts of negligence
56. As a direct and proximate cause of Defendant’s negligence, Plaintiff has incurred
57. Plaintiff incorporates all preceding paragraphs herein and further alleges the
following:
58. At all relevant times, Defendant Unknown Dispatcher was acting within the course
negligence.
60. Plaintiff incorporates all preceding paragraphs herein and further alleges the
following:
61. Defendant West Valley had a duty to disclose Defendant Franklin’s dangerously
Page 8 of 10
62. Defendant West Valley breached this duty when its representatives failed to inform
63. As a direct and proximate cause of Defendant West Valley’s negligence, Officer
Franklin was hired by Unified Police Department and allowed to drive a patrol car, resulting in the
64. As a direct and proximate cause of Defendant West Valley’s negligence, Plaintiff
65. Plaintiff incorporates all preceding paragraphs herein and further alleges the
following:
66. Cindreia experienced significant pain and suffering from her injuries caused by
67. Cindreia suffered both economic and non-economic damages due to injuries which
69. Pursuant to Utah Code Ann. § 78B-3-107, Cindreia’s heirs may pursue her claims
against Defendants for the special and general damages she suffered prior to her death.
TIER DESIGNATION
70. Pursuant to Utah R. Civ. P. 8(a) and 26(c)(3), this matter falls under Tier 3 and
JURY DEMAND
Page 9 of 10
71. Pursuant to URCP 38, Plaintiff hereby demands a trial by jury on all issues
presented herein.
1. For general damages for pain and suffering in an amount to be proven at trial.
6. For such other relief as may be deemed fair and equitable under the circumstances.
Page 10 of 10