Bad Cop News » Post Topic » U.S. Department Of Justice Banned From Wiki...

leting Article Material And Making Questionable Edits To Other Articles

Bad Cop News

Critical News Related To Police And Others In Law Enforcement.

Home

Contact

Submit Link

1
May

U.S. Department Of Justice Banned From Wikipedia

After Deleting Article Material And Making
Questionable Edits To Other Articles
Posted by Admin Published in DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

WASHINGTON, DC - Wikipedia has temporarily blocked edits from the US Department of Justice after

someone inside the government agency tried to erase references to a particularly-controversial Wiki-

scandal.

Early last week, the Boston-based Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting in America

(CAMERA) was accused of organizing a secret campaign to influence certain articles on the “free

encyclopedia anyone can edit”. Just days later, the DoJ’s IP range was used to edit the site’s entry on

http://www.badcopnews.com/2008/05/01/us-department-of-justi...e-material-and-making-questionable-edits-to-other-articles/ (1 of 7)5/2/2008 8:08:22 AM

Bad Cop News » Post Topic » U.S. Department Of Justice Banned From Wiki...leting Article Material And Making Questionable Edits To Other Articles

the Pro-Israel “media-monitoring group,” lifting a new section that detailed the controversy.

The DoJ did not respond to our requests for comment. But odds are, the edits were made by a single

individual acting independently. Wikipedia’s ban on the department’s IP is due to be lifted today.

On April 21, the Pro-Palestine site Electronic Intifada published a series of emails in which CAMERA

Senior Research Analyst Gilead Ini seems to enlist volunteers to help “keep Israel-related entries on

Wikipedia from becoming tainted by anti-Israel editors”. Ini asks these volunteers to avoid forwarding his

emails to the news media and invites them onto a Google Group called “Isra-pedia.”

In an email to The Reg, Ini declined to say if the messages published by Electronic Intifada were

genuine, but he acknowledged that CAMERA recently ran an email campaign meant to promote edits

that “ensure accuracy” on certain Wikipedia articles.

Electronic Intifada

On the alleged Isra-pedia thread - also published by Electronic Intifada - one longtime Wikipedia editor

gives volunteers a primer on how to become a site administrator. “There is in Wikipedia the ability by an

administrator to set significant limits on other editor [sic],” he writes. “One or more of you who want to

take this route should stay away from any Israel realted [sic] articles for month [sic] until they [sic] interact

in a positive way with 100 Wikipedia editors who would be used later to vote you as an administrator.”

This Wikipedia editor, known as “Zeq,” and several others involved with the CAMERA emails were

subsequently sanctioned. Some were barred from editing topics involving the Arab-Israeli conflict, and at

least one - “Gni,” believed to be Ini - was banned from the site entirely.

In the wake of these sanctions, a paragraph on the scandal was added to Wikipedia’s CAMERA article,

and on two separate occasions, someone inside the DoJ tried to remove it. The user also made a few

questionable edits to other articles, and the DoJ’s entire IP was banned for four days.

http://www.badcopnews.com/2008/05/01/us-department-of-justi...e-material-and-making-questionable-edits-to-other-articles/ (2 of 7)5/2/2008 8:08:22 AM

Bad Cop News » Post Topic » U.S. Department Of Justice Banned From Wiki...leting Article Material And Making Questionable Edits To Other Articles

This ongoing affair brings up all the old questions about the social experiment that is Wikipedia. On one

level, the site is working hard to police its own content. But on another, you have to wonder if all this back

and forth is really necessary.

Longtime contributor Christiano Moreschi, one of the editors that banned the accounts in questions, sees

the CAMERA crackdown as Wikipedia at its best. “This was an amateur and quite pathetic attempt to

subvert the purpose of Wikipedia,” he told The Reg. “I have no doubt these chaps were genuine - they

were genuinely trying to slant articles towards a pro-Israel point of view, but were massively incompetent

at doing so.

“Even if their emails had not been leaked to Electronic Intifada I don’t think we would have had much

trouble dealing with them as individuals…Once EI had published the emails, the response of the

Wikipedia administrative corps was swift, competent, and professional.”

‘Capricious’

But Gilead Ini sees things differently. Declining to say whether he’s behind the Gni account, he argues

that Wikipedia is banning contributors without sufficient evidence. “Wikipedia notes that ‘Revealing the

names of pseudonymous editors is in all cases against basic policy,’” he told us. “Some Wikipedia

administrators - editors elected to a position of power in Wikipedia - are capriciously banning Wikipedia

accounts based on nothing more than speculation about who owns that account.”

Ini insists that his email campaign adhered to Wikipedia’s rules - which he sees as vague and only

intermittently enforced. Some have accused him of creating “sockpuppets” and “meatpuppets” - extra

accounts used to push his own point of view - but he’s adamant this is not the case.

“A meat puppet is described as ‘one who edits on behalf of or as proxy for another editor,’” he said.

“Nobody who participated in [his email group] was expected to be a ‘proxy’ for me or anybody else. They

were encouraged to learn about, and if they are moved to do so, participate in, Wikipedia.”

You may think Ini is talking rubbish. But as we’ve said before, Wikipedia invites such controversy in

http://www.badcopnews.com/2008/05/01/us-department-of-justi...e-material-and-making-questionable-edits-to-other-articles/ (3 of 7)5/2/2008 8:08:22 AM

Bad Cop News » Post Topic » U.S. Department Of Justice Banned From Wiki...leting Article Material And Making Questionable Edits To Other Articles

giving editors the right to anonymity. If users were required to identify themselves, puppetry wouldn’t be

the problem it is - and the site could suppress a single voice without blocking the DoJ’s entire IP range.

But there’s another question worth asking: If Wikipedia is right to ban someone who merely attempted to

game the site, why hasn’t it banned others who’ve actually succeeded?Appeared Here

Search

Asshole Of The Month

April 2008 ** Cel Rivera ** Chief - Lorain, Ohio Sorry Sack Of Shit
This whining Bitch blocked BCN website from city and county computers. ----------------

March 2008 ** June Maxam ** Conspiracy Theorist And Liar North Country Gazette

http://www.badcopnews.com/2008/05/01/us-department-of-justi...e-material-and-making-questionable-edits-to-other-articles/ (4 of 7)5/2/2008 8:08:22 AM

Bad Cop News » Post Topic » U.S. Department Of Justice Banned From Wiki...leting Article Material And Making Questionable Edits To Other Articles

Thanks for all the Maxam horror stories! ----------------

February 2008 ** June Maxam ** Conspiracy Theorist North Country Gazette

"Just because she has a blog doesn't mean she has a brain."
----------------
January 2008 ** RANDY MUCHA ** Flaming Asshole Disgraced Oak Brook, IL Cop

---------------- Nominate someone for BCN's AOM, see Contact page.

Submissions must include reason for nomination, and a photo must be available.

Locations

● 9/11 Hysteria
● ALABAMA
● ALASKA
● ARIZONA
● ARKANSAS
● AUSTRALIA
● Bad Cop News

http://www.badcopnews.com/2008/05/01/us-department-of-justi...e-material-and-making-questionable-edits-to-other-articles/ (5 of 7)5/2/2008 8:08:22 AM

Bad Cop News » Post Topic » U.S. Department Of Justice Banned From Wiki...leting Article Material And Making Questionable Edits To Other Articles

● Bad Cops
● Barbie Cummings
● Brattleboro VT
● CALIFORNIA
● CANADA
● Cary Illinois
● COLORADO
● CONNECTICUT
● DELAWARE
● DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
● ELSEWHERE (NOT US)
● FLORIDA
● GEORGIA
● Greenwood, Mississippi
● HAWAII
● HostPC
● IDAHO
● ILLINOIS
● INDIANA
● IOWA
● iPower
● iPowerWeb
● Jaffrey New Hampshire
● June Maxam
● KANSAS
● KENTUCKY
● LORAIN OHIO
● LOUISIANA
● MAINE
● Marengo Illinois
● Martin Dunn
● MARYLAND
● MASSACHUSETTS
● McHenry County Illinois
● MICHIGAN
● MINNESOTA
● MISSISSIPPI
● MISSOURI
● MONTANA
● NEBRASKA
● NEVADA
● NEW HAMPSHIRE
● NEW JERSEY
● NEW MEXICO

http://www.badcopnews.com/2008/05/01/us-department-of-justi...e-material-and-making-questionable-edits-to-other-articles/ (6 of 7)5/2/2008 8:08:22 AM

 Bad Cop News » Post Topic » U.S. Department Of Justice Banned From Wiki...leting Article Material And Making Questionable Edits To Other Articles

● NEW YORK
● NEW ZEALAND
● NORTH CAROLINA
● North Country Gazette
● NORTH DAKOTA
● Oak Brook Illinois
● OHIO
● OKLAHOMA
● OREGON
● PENNSYLVANIA
● PUERTO RICO
● Randy Mucha
● RHODE ISLAND
● Road Runner
● Robert Higbee
● Ron Delelio
● SCOTLAND
● Seaside Park New Jersey
● SITE
● SOUTH CAROLINA
● SOUTH DAKOTA
● TENNESSEE
● TEXAS
● Time Warner
● Uncategorized
● UNITED KINGDOM
● UTAH
● VERMONT
● VIRGIN ISLANDS
● VIRGINIA
● Warren Ohio
● WASHINGTON
● WEST VIRGINIA
● WISCONSIN
● WYOMING

Bad Cop News

MAXAM DOCTRINE: In an extension to June Maxam's (North Country Gazette) near-legendary nutty
interpretation of Fair Use of Copyright, WE FORBID ANY REPRODUCTION of any word, phrase, letter,
number, doodle, character, color, texture, smell or combination of any letters, numbers, scents,
characters, colors, or textures used or even remotely considered for future use on Bad Cop News :)

http://www.badcopnews.com/2008/05/01/us-department-of-justi...e-material-and-making-questionable-edits-to-other-articles/ (7 of 7)5/2/2008 8:08:22 AM