Sie sind auf Seite 1von 2

Comparative Chart of International Arbitration Rules

UNCITRAL
LCIA Rules ICC Rules SCC Rules CIETAC Rules SIAC Rules HKIAC Rules
Ad hoc Rules
2014 2012 2010 2014 2013 2013
2013
Deemed start date of arbitration Articles 1.4, 4.4 Articles 3.3, 4.2 Articles 4, 8(3) Article 11 Rules 2.2, 3.3 Articles 2.1, 2.2, 4.2, Articles 2.5, 3.2
Date of receipt by the Registrar, Day request is received by Day request is received by SCC Day request is received by the Day request is delivered to Day request is delivered or Day request is delivered or
which is the date delivered (if hard Secretariat, Arbitration Court Registrar transmitted to HKIAC attempted to be delivered to
copy) or transmitted (if soft copy) respondent

Default deadline for response Article 2.1 Article 5.1 Article 5(1) Article 15 Rule 4.1 Article 5.1 Article 4.1
28 days from the start of arbitration 30 days from receiving request Set by Secretariat 45 days from receipt of notice of 14 days from receipt of notice of 30 days from receipt of notice of 30 days from receipt of notice of
from ICC Secretariat by respondent arbitration by respondent arbitration by respondent arbitration by respondent arbitration by respondent

Default number of arbitrators Article 5.8 Article 12.2 Article 12 Article 25 Rule 6.1 Article 6 Article 7
Sole arbitrator Sole arbitrator (in deemed complex Three arbitrators (unless SCC Three arbitrators Sole arbitrator HKIAC decides Three arbitrators
cases the default number of Board considers sole arbitrator is
arbitrators is three) sufficient)
Default appointment of a sole Article 5.6 Articles 12.2, 12.3 Article 13(2) Article 27,28 Rule 7 Article 7 Article 8.1
arbitrator By LCIA after receipt of response By ICC Court after 30 days from Joint appointment within 10 days, Joint appointment within 15 days Joint appointment within 21 days Joint appointment within 30 days Joint appointment within 30 days,
or, if no response, 35 days from the the start of the arbitration, unless otherwise by the SCC Board from respondent's receipt of notice, from receipt of request by from HKIAC's decision, otherwise otherwise by appointing authority
start of arbitration sole arbitrator agreed by parties otherwise by Chairman of CIETAC Registrar, otherwise by President HKIAC using list procedure
of SIAC
Default appointment of three Article 5.6, 5.8 Articles 12.2, 12.4, 12.5 Article 13(3) Article 27 Rule 8 Article 8 Article 9
member tribunal By LCIA after receipt of response Each party nominates an arbitrator, Parties appoint equal number of Within 15 days from receipt of Each party nominates an arbitrator, Claimant nominates its arbitrator Each party appoints an arbitrator, if
or, if no response, 35 days from the chair appointed by ICC arbitrators, chair appointed by SCC request, parties each appoint (or if within 14 days of first nomination within 15 days of HKIAC's decision, within 30 days of first nomination a
start of arbitration Board entrust Chairman of CIETAC to a party fails to nominate its and respondent nominates within party fails to nominate its arbitrator
appoint) an arbitrator, and jointly arbitrator, President of SIAC will 15 days after that, the two the appointing authority will appoint
nominate (or entrust the Chairman appoint on its behalf; chair arbitrators nominate the chair on its behalf, the two arbitrators
of CIETAC to appoint) chair appointed by President of SIAC within 30 days of confirmation of appoint the chair within 30 days
second arbitrator, otherwise by from appointment of second
HKIAC arbitrator
Default restrictions on Article 6.1 Article 13.5 Article 13(5) None None Article 11.2 None
arbitrators where parties with Sole arbitrator/chair not of Sole arbitrator/chair not of Sole arbitrator/chair not of Sole arbitrator/chair not of
different nationalities nationality of any party nationality of any party nationality of any party nationality of any party

Time limit for challenging Article 10.3 Article 14.2 Article 15(2) Articles 32.1/32.3 Rule 12.1 Article 11.7 Article 13
arbitrator 14 days from appointment or, if 30 days from 15 days from becoming aware of 10 days where based on 14 days from appointment or 14 15 days from appointment or 15 15 days from appointment or 15
later, 14 days from becoming appointment/confirmation or 30 relevant circumstances information disclosed by arbitrator days from becoming aware of days from becoming aware of days from becoming aware of
aware of relevant circumstances days from becoming aware of on appointment relevant circumstances relevant circumstances relevant circumstances
relevant circumstances 15 days once the tribunal is formed
and 15 days from becoming aware
of relevant circumstances
Joinder Article 22.1(viii) Article 7.1 No provision Article 18 Rule 24.1(b) Article 27 Article 17.5
Only on application by a party and On request by a party and only Only on application by a party On request by a party and only if On request by party or third party On request by party and only if
consent of applicant and new party permitted prior to either before or after formation of third party is party to arbitration and only if third party is prima facie third party is party to arbitration
required confirmation/appointment of any tribunal; in case of objection, agreement and consents to joinder party to the arbitration agreement agreement; joinder cannot
arbitrator, unless otherwise agreed CIETAC decides prejudice any party
Consolidation Article 22.1(ix;x) Article 10 Article 11 Article 19 No provision Article 28.1 No provision
Subject to approval by LCIA where: On request by party, ICC Court can On request by party, the SCC On request by party, CIETAC can On request by party, tribunal can
 all parties consent; or consolidate pending ICC Board can consolidate new claims consolidate where: consolidate where:
 LCIA arbitrations arbitrations under ICC Rules where:  all claims are under same  parties agree;
commenced under where:  these concern same legal arbitration agreement;  claims under same
same/compatible arbitration  the parties agree; or relationship;  identical or compatible arbitration agreement; or
agreement between same  all claims made under same  in respect of which there is claims under multiple  common question of law/fact
parties; and no tribunal arbitration agreement; or pending SCC arbitration; arbitration agreements in all arbitrations, relief from
appointed or composed of  same parties, in connection  between same parties where either, claims involve same transaction, and
same arbitrators with same legal relationship, same parties or there is a HKIAC finds arbitration
and ICC finds arbitration principle contract; or agreements compatible
agreements compatible  all the parties agree
© 2016 Baker & McKenzie LLP 1
Comparative Chart of International Arbitration Rules
UNCITRAL
LCIA Rules ICC Rules SCC Rules CIETAC Rules SIAC Rules HKIAC Rules
Ad hoc Rules
2014 2012 2010 2014 2013 2013
2013
Tribunal's discretion to order Article 25.1 Article 28.1 Article 32(1) Article 23.3 Rule 26(1) Article 23.2 Article 26.1
Interim Measures On request by any party the On request by any party the On request by any party the On request by any party the On request by any party the On request by any party the On request by any party the
tribunal has power to order: tribunal has power to order any tribunal has power to order any tribunal has power to order any tribunal has power to order or tribunal has power to order any tribunal has power to order any
 respondent to provide interim or conservatory measure interim measure tribunal deems interim measure tribunal deems award any injunction or any other interim measures tribunal deems Interim measures
security for all or part of the tribunal deems appropriate appropriate necessary or proper interim relief tribunal deems necessary or appropriate
amount in dispute appropriate; tribunal may ask for
 preservation, storage, sale security from requesting party
or disposal of property or
thing under control of any
party and relating to
arbitration
 provisional relief subject to
final award
Confidentiality Article 30 Article 22.3 Article 46 Article 38 Rule 35 Article 42 Article 34.5
Awards and any materials in Any party can apply for SCC and tribunal maintain Private hearings, all parties have All matters relating to proceedings Awards and any information about Award may be made public if all
proceedings are confidential; confidentiality of proceedings, or to confidentiality of arbitration and obligation not to disclose any and award, disclosure permitted in the arbitration, disclosure permitted parties consent or other limited
disclosure permitted in limited protect trade secrets or confidential award, unless otherwise agreed by matters relating to the case. Parties limited circumstances in limited circumstances circumstances
circumstances information parties can request open hearing.
Time limit for issuing award No time limit Article 30 Article 37 Article 48 Rule 28.2 No time limit No time limit
Within 6 months from date of last Within 6 months from date of Within 6 months from formation of Tribunal to give draft award to
signature of Terms of Reference referral to tribunal tribunal Registrar within 45 days from close
of proceedings; award to be
delivered as soon as practicable
afterwards following Registrar
comments
Expedited / summary procedure Article 9A Not available Not available Article 56 Rule 5 Article 41 Not available
Expedited tribunal available in (See Rules for Expedited Summary procedure mandatory if Expedited procedure available in Available prior to formation of
exceptional urgency Arbitrations 2010) amount in dispute below RMB limited circumstances if applied for tribunal in limited circumstances
5,000,000 or available in limited prior to constitution of tribunal
circumstances above that amount
Availability of emergency Article 9B Article 29 and Appendix V Appendix II, Article 1(1) Article 23.2 and Appendix III Schedule 1, Paragraph 1 Article 23 and Schedule 4 Not available
arbitrator Emergency, unless arbitration Emergency application has to be Prior to arbitration file being Prior to the formation of the tribunal Prior to the constitution of the Prior to the constitution of the
agreed before 1 Oct 2014 and submitted prior to arbitration file transmitted to tribunal tribunal tribunal
parties not 'opt-in'; or parties being transmitted to tribunal
agreed to 'opt-out'
Cost allocation Article 28.4 Article 37.4, 37.5 Articles 43(5), 44 Article 82 Rule 31.1 Article 33.2 Article 42
Tribunal has discretion, with Tribunal has discretion and will Unless agreed by the parites, In principle, costs will be borne by Tribunal has discretion, unless Tribunal has discretion In principle, costs will be borne by
general principle that costs reflect consider relevant factors including thetribunal has discretion having the unsuccessful party but tribunal otherwise agreed by parties the unsuccessful party but tribunal
parties' relative success and conduct of parties regard to outcome and other has discretion has discretion
failures in the award relevant circumstances

Mediation LCIA Mediation Rules available. ICC Mediation Rules available. SCC Mediation Rules available. No CIETAC mediation rules. SIAC-SIMC Arb-Med-Arb Protocol HKIAC Mediation Rules available. UNCITRAL Conciliation Rules
Recommended mediation clauses Recommended mediation clauses Recommended mediation clauses No recommended mediation available. Recommended mediation clause available.
available available available clause. Recommended Arb-Med-Arb available. Recommended conciliation clause
clause available. available.

Important Note: This is a simplified guide intended to provide an overview of the similarities and differences among some of the major institutional and ad hoc international arbitration rules. It is not intended as a substitute for detailed legal advice as to the procedures and laws which govern a particular
dispute. Advice should be sought when agreeing to arbitration and at any early stage of any dispute. Correct as at 19 April 2016.

www.bakermckenzie.com

Baker & McKenzie International is a Swiss Verein with member law firms around the world. In accordance with the common terminology used in For more information, please contact:
professional service organizations, reference to “partner” means a person who is a partner, or equivalent, in such a law firm. Similarly, reference to Ed Poulton, Partner Ekaterina Finkel, Associate
an “office” means an office of any such law firm. This may qualify as "Attorney Advertising" requiring notice in some jurisdictions. Prior results do not T: +44 20 7919 1606 T: +44 20 7919 1756
guarantee a similar outcome. E: ed.poulton@bakermckenzie.com E: Ekaterina.Finkel@bakermckenzie.com
© 2016 Baker & McKenzie. All rights reserved.

© 2016 Baker & McKenzie LLP 2

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen