Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY IN
PHYSICAL EDUCATION
By
B.SIVAKUMAR
Research supervisor
Dr.D.SULTANA
May 2010
Dr. D. SULTANA,
Reader,
Department of Physical Education and Sports,
Pondicherry University,
Pondicherry- 605 014
India.
CERTIFICATE
research work done by Mr. B.SIVAKUMAR, during the period of his study
under my guidance and that the thesis has not previously been formed on the
basis for the award of any degree, diploma, associateship, fellowship or any
This is also to certify that the thesis represents the independent work of
the candidate.
DECLARATION
(B.SIVAKUMAR)
Place: Puducherry
Date:
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First of all I thank God Almighty for giving me the knowledge and
wisdom for taking up this study.
I express my profound gratitude and sincere thanks to my inspiring
guide Dr.D.Sultana, Reader, Pondicherry University, Puducherry for her
scholarly guidance and advice, valuable suggestions and supervision, needed
encouragement and above all for being patient with me throughout the study.
I would like to extend my gratitude to Dr.N.Govindarajulu, Head of
the Department, and Dr. P.K. Subramaniam, Reader, Department of Physical
Education and Sports, Pondicherry University, Puducherry for his support and
encouragement for the completion of the thesis.
I would like to express my sincere thanks to Dr.S. Pannirselvame,
Professor, Department of French, Pondicherry University, Puducherry for his
help rendered towards the successful completion of the study.
I acknowledge with thanks the help rendered by Dr.G.Ravindran,
Professor, Annamalai University, Dr.M.Elango, Head of the Department,
Department of Physical Education, MDT Hindu College, Tirunelveli and
Thiru. B. Selvam, Sr. Lecturer Department of Mathematics, Bharathidassan
College for Women, Puducherry, in computing the statistics.
I extend my gratitude to Thiru. V. Meibalan, Deputy Librarian,
Pondicherry University, Puducherry for his valuable suggestions and
references from the Library for the Completion of the thesis.
I extend my sincere thanks to Thiru. B. Ramesh, Sr. Lecturer, Rajiv
Gandhi College of Engineering and technology for help and support rendered
for the whole study.
This thesis would not have been a success if my better half
Mrs. Sivashanthi,TGT, had not shown love and affection all through these
years.
I must acknowledge the help and guidance of Dr.T. Santhamoorthy,
Senior Resident, JIPMER, Puducherry.
I extend my hearty thanks to Mr. Ram Mohan Singh, Physical
Puducherry, for his help and support rendered for the whole study.
collection of data.
School, Ariyankuppam, Puducherry, for his Data entry work and the Staff
Last but not the least; the researcher sincerely extends his profound
gratefulness to the teachers who acted as subjects in the test and training with
enthusiasm.
B.Sivakumar
VITAE
Degrees Awarded
Professional Experience
Awards
Page
LIST OF TABLES i
Chapter
I INTRODUCTION 1
Fitness
Physical fitness
Meaning of yoga
Physiological views of yoga
Benefits of yoga
Recent Development in yoga
Aerobic exercises
Meaning of aerobic exercises
Aerobic is an excellent physical activity
Benefits of aerobics
Physiological changes on aerobics
Recent development in aerobics
Yoga and aerobic exercises
Importance of dependent variables
Statement of the problem
Hypothesis
Delimitations
Limitations
Definition of the terms
Significance of the study
III METHODOLOGY 56
Selection of subjects
Experimental design
Selection of criterion variables
Criterion measures
Reliability of instruments
Reliability of data and tester competency
Orientation to the subjects
Pilot study
Training programme
Aerobic exercise training programme
Details of yogic practices
Method of data collection
Administration of Tests
Experimental Design and statistical procedure
Analysis of Data
Level of significance
Discussion on the Findings
Discussion on Hypothesis
Summary
Conclusions
Recommendations
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Books 141
Journals
Unpublished Thesis
APPENDICES 153
LIST OF TABLES
XXIII Scheffe's test for the differences between the adjusted post test 126
paired means on triglycerides
ii
XXIV Analysis of Covariance for the pre and post test on low density 129
lipoprotein of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group
and control group
XXV Scheffe's test for the differences between the adjusted post test 130
paired means on low density lipoprotein
iii
LIST OF FIGURES
VIII Adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercises group, 108
yogic practices group and control group on breath holding
time
XII Adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercises group, 116
yogic practices group and control group on packed cell
volume
iv
LIST OF FIGURES (Cont…)
XIII Mean values of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group 119
and control group on total cholesterol
XIV Adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercises group, 120
yogic practices group and control group on total cholesterol
XVI Adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercises group, 124
yogic practices group and control group on high density
lipoprotein
XVII Mean values of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group 127
and control group on triglycerides
XVIII Adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercises group, 128
and yogic practices and control group on triglycerides
XIX Mean values of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group 131
and control group on low density lipoprotein
v
Chapter I
INTRODUCTION
“Lack of activity destroys the good condition of every human being, while
movement and methodical physical exercise save it and preserve it”.
~Plato~
The body is the temple of soul and to reach a harmony of the mind, body
and spirit, the body must be physically fit (Charles A. Bucher). Throughout
the ages, man has had to be physically active in order to procure his daily food
to succeed in the battle of survival. For every individual physical activity is
essential for harmonious physical and mental development.
Exercise plays a major role in improving the quality and most likely the
longevity of our lives. Most people who exercise regularly will agree that one
of the main reasons for their exercise is that it makes them feel good, and help
them to attain or maintain good health and physical fitness. The effect of
regular physical activity significantly improves health, physical fitness and
work capacity and enables people to use their leisure time more beneficially
and thereby assists in adding life to years and also years to lives.
2
Young adulthood typically covers the period from 20-35 years of age,
when both biological function and physical performance reach their peak.
During young middle-age (35-45 years), physical activity usually wanes, with a
5-10 kg accumulation of body fat. Active pursuits may be shared with a
growing family, but it becomes less important to impress either an employer or
persons of the opposite sex with physical appearance and performance. During
later middle-age (45-65 years), women reach the menopause, and men also
substantially reduce their output of sex hormones. Career opportunities have
commonly peaked, and a larger disposable income often allows energy
demanding domestic tasks to be deputed to service contractors. The decline in
physical condition thus continues and may accelerate.
FITNESS
Fit people make a fit nation. Fitness is that State which characterizes the
degree to which a person is able to function more efficiently. Fitness is an
individual matter. It implies the ability of each person to live most effectively
within his potentialities (HockeyEd.’1985)
3
PHYSICAL FITNESS
Many researchers strongly support the view that regular exercise helps
to keep a strong and healthy heart and prevents cardiovascular diseases. A
physically fit heart beats at a lower rate and pumps more blood per beat at rest.
As a result of regular exercise, an individual’s capacity to use oxygen is
increased substantially. To develop and maintain physical fitness, vigorous
effort by the individual is required. Cardio-respiratory endurance, strength,
muscular endurance, flexibility, power and agility are the basic compounds of
physical fitness. Physical fitness is considered as one of the most valuable
assets and it has received a high priority in all thoughts and actions. Modern
coaches denote their time in coaching during pre season mainly for ensuring
endurance, strength and flexibility. These are improved by training.
4
Powell (1972) explains that fitness is not an end, it is the beginning. A
person must get fit to perform and will not necessarily get fit by performing.
Fitness is not a matter of physical capacity alone. To develop and maintain a
person’s physical fitness, vigorous effort by the individual is required. Body
fitness and weight control greatly reduce cardiovascular diseases. This results
from (a) maintenance of moderately lower blood pressure, (b) reduced blood
cholesterol and (c) low density lipoprotein along with increased high-density
lipoprotein. As pointed out earlier, these change all a work together to reduce
the number of heart attacks and brain strokes.
From the above, it is inferred that yoga and Aerobic exercises are very
much needed to maintain a general level of physical fitness, particularly as it
enhances the physical stamina and the cardio respiratory endurance.
YOGA
Yoga is the “Union of the individual self with the universal self”
(Iyengar, 2001)
Yoga means the union or communication or unity with our inner being.
’Asana’ means a state of being in which we can remain steady, calm, quiet and
comfortable with our physical body and mind.
5
MEANING OF YOGA
The word yoga is derived from the Sanskrit root “yug” meaning “to
unite” or “union” or “ to combine” or “to join” development of the personality
of a human being physical, mental, moral, intellectual and spiritual. Yoga is a
science by which the individual approaches the truth of disease and of age.
Asanas are an integral part of yoga. Yoga uses the body to exercise and
controls the mind so that at a later stage the body and the mind together may
harmonize with the soul. The yogasanas affect and penetrate every single cell
and tissues making them come to life.
Regular practice of yoga helps to keep our body fit, controls cholesterol
level, reduces weight, normalizes blood pressure and improves heart
performances.
Further, preliminary studies in the United States and India suggest that
yoga may be helpful for specific conditions, such as asthma, epilepsy, anxiety,
stress and others.
6
Exercise increases the volume of hemoglobin and erythrocyte of the
blood. Also blood vessels are seen to maintain elasticity and suppleness when
stressed systematically probably by the beneficial effect of the heart.
BENEFITS OF YOGA
7
cure diseases by improving functions of the vital organs of the body. Yoga and
yogic practices awaken the inner strength of the body. The health of our body
and mind depends upon the soundness of the health of internal organs.
Yoga is universal and benefits people of all ages. Yogic research has
proven its efficiency in effectively maintaining and for bringing about the
psycho physiological equilibrium and emotional stability and so far as the
functional development is concerned, the yogic system is perhaps the best.
In good olden days, the citizen of Rome had recognized that regular
exercise and temperature would ensure ‘positive’ life-style.
AEROBIC EXERCISES
MEANING OF AEROBICS
8
AEROBICS IS AN EXCELLENT FITNESS ACTIVITY
Aerobic exercise means the exercise where all body parts/muscles are
supplied with enough oxygen with the increased heart rate.
BENEFITS OF AEROBICS
9
Aerobics and calisthenics are performed to the rhythmic pulse of disco
music and strength together in what amounts to a modern dance form, so as to
make the exercise more enjoyable and encouraging without extra effort.
By doing exercise, the whole system of our body carries oxygen-rich air
enters the organs and tissues of the muscles has been called “the aerobic
system” and for this reason training the system for stamina is called aerobic
training.
An aerobic exercise work out is divided into four phases: warm up, skill
review, aerobic and cool down. Each phase has its own purposes, without
which the work out is incomplete. Each phase of the program is necessary is
aerobic dance is to provide the desires benefits.
10
According to Bucher (1983) aerobic exercise is any physical activity
that requires the heart rate to reach at least 60% of the maximal heart rate for an
extended period of time. Also it is an activity that can be sustained for an
extended period of time without developing an oxygen deficit.
There is normally an increase in the number of red blood cells, but not in
the concentration of haemoglobin in the blood. Some of the benefits of
aerobic exercises include the productivity of less lactic acid and greater
endurance. Physiologists have found that it reduces blood pressure and change
blood chemistry. It also improves the efficiency of the heart.
11
Also in the increased number and size of mitochondria, increased
muscle glycogen, reduction in triglycerides, increased activity of enzymes of
involved in fatty acid activation, transport and oxidation.
12
nerves are more tightened through physical exercise. Nerves and body muscles
are relaxed by yoga.
Yogic exercise aims at both prevention and treatment of various
diseases. Breathing exercise aims at both prevention and treatment of various
diseases. Breathing exercises like pranayama including Kapalabhati is very
effective for keeping the lungs healthy and prevent lung infections. With
deep breathing air circulates to every part of the lungs whereas with most other
physical exercises, there is mainly an increase in the respiratory rate. However,
physical exercise wastes more energy due to quick movements and more lactic
acids are formed in the muscle fibres. But energy is not wasted in yoga
practices. Yoga postures and breathing exercises unlike physical exercises do
not strain the cardio vascular system, and they improve one’s physical fitness
and endurance.
13
Tissue oxygenation is the basic regulator of Red Blood Cell production.
Any condition, that causes the quantity of oxygen transported to the tissues to
decrease ordinarily increase the rate of red blood cell production. When a
person, become extremely anemic as a result of hemorrhage or another
condition, the bone marrow immediately begins to produce large quantities of
red blood cells. At very high altitudes, where the quantity of oxygen in the air
is greatly decreased insufficient oxygen is transported to the tissues and red cell
production is considerably increased. It is not the concentration of red blood
cells in the blood that controls the rate of red cell production but the functional
ability of the cells to transport oxygen to the tissues in relation to the tissue
demand for oxygen.
Haemoglobin is a coloured pigment. It is present in the blood and binds
with the red blood cells. It gives red colour to the blood. It is very important
in carrying oxygen to various tissues for energy production.
Blood contains plasma and formed elements which form about forty five
percent of the blood. When the blood was centrifuged the total volume of
formed elements that has been packed in a tube is called packed cell volume.
Heart Rate (HR) is one of the simplest and most informative of the
cardiovascular parameters. Measuring it involves simply taking the subject’s
pulse, usually at the radical oar carotid site. Heart rate reflects the amount of
work the hear must do to meet the increased demands of the body when
engaged in activity. To understand this, we must compare the heart rate at rest
and during exercise.
Resting heart rate averages from 60 to 80 beats/ min. In middle aged,
unconditioned, sedentary individuals, the resting rate can exceed 100beats/min.
In highly conditioned, endurance trained athletes, resting rates is in the range of
28 to 40 beats / min have been reported. Your resting heart rate typically
decreases with age. It is important to understand that, alternatively slow heart
rate, coupled with a relatively large stroke volume, signifies an efficient
circulatory system. During exercise the heart rates of the athletes increased at
14
a lesser rate to a lower level. Hence it is possible for the athlete to do more and
achieve high oxygen consumption before reaching the maximal heart rate.
Cholesterol is an odourless, tasteless, white fatty alcohol found in all cell
membranes and is vital to cell survival and growth. Cholesterol is also a key
precursor or intermediate compound in the production of numerous
biologically important substance collectively called as steroids.
Cholesterol is present in certain foods mainly though not exclusively in
fatty foods. If cholesterol rich food is limited from the diet, it will lower the
cholesterol content of the blood only by about 15 % which however makes all
the differences between the healthy functioning of the system and the
development of life threatening disorders. High cholesterol levels in blood
almost lead to narrowing of the arteries as a result of the formation of large
deposits of atheroma in the arteries.
Cholesterol has been linked statistically with atherosclerosis (the
building of fatty deposits in arteries) whether this build ups eventual clog of the
arteries and cause heart diseases may depend upon the type and quantity of the
lipoproteins in an individual’s blood stream. Lipoproteins are molecules of fat
and protein that serve as a two day delivery system of cholesterol.
Low density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C) digests cholesterol from
the live and distributes it throughout the body. High density lipoprotein
cholesterol (HDL-C) gathers excess cholesterol and returns it to the liver for
excretion. Studies indicate that high level of cholesterol and LDL-C lead to
heart diseases, but high level of HDL-C prevents harmful cholesterol buildups
and offers a measure of protection from heart disease.
Like every other fatty substance, cholesterol is insoluble in plasma
unless combined with carrier molecules, the lipoproteins. There are four
classes lipoproteins namely, a)chyclomicrons carry absorbed dietary fat chiefly
triglycerides, b) very low density lipoprotein(VLDL) that carry mainly
triglycerides produced within the body, c)low density lipoproteins(LDL)carry
about 175-80% of cholesterol in blood plasma, d)high density
15
lipoproteins(HDL) that carry mainly phospholipids and the remaining 20-25%
of blood cholesterol.
Increased physical activity induces a number of positive changes in the
metabolism of lipoproteins. Serum triglycerides are lowered by the increased
lipolytic activity and the production of native high density lipoprotein is
increased. The increased lecithin cholesterol acetyltranserase activity leads to
an increased production of HDL, which in addition is catabolished more slowly
due to a decreased activity of hepatic lipase.
The effects have been demonstrated in cross sectional studies as well as
longitudinal studies and induced by training independent of changes in body
weight. It has been shown that small dense LDL particles represent a particular
risk for atherosclerosis, and there is strong evidence for the claim that LDL
level and composition can be influenced favorably by physical activity.
One of the biological mechanisms underlying the preventive effects of
physical exercise seems to be the beneficial modification of plasma lipoprotein
concentration in particular, the reduction of atherogenic lipoprotein (LDL,
VLDL) and the increase of protective lipoprotein (HDL). The exact process by
which exercise affects cholesterol levels has not yet been determined.
However, factors resulting from endurance training viz. body weight loss and
changes in body composition, plasma volume and hormone and enzyme
activities alter the rates of synthesis, transport and clearance of lipids synthesis,
transport and clearance of lipids and lipoproteins from the blood. Exercise also
influences triglyceride synthesis, lipoprotein lipase (LPL) activity, lecithin
cholesterol acetyltransferase (LACT) ratio and cholesterol ester transfer protein
(CETP) regulation, resulting in enhanced cholesterol transport. The average
exercising subjects were found to have a reduction in total cholesterol,
triglycerides and LDL cholesterol and increase HDL cholesterol and it has been
proved that mild intensity exercise training is capable of reducing serum TG
levels.
Lipids and sterols circulate as a part of macromolecular complexes
known as lipoproteins. These are the means by which insoluble lipids are able
16
to circulate in an aqueous medium. Lipoproteins consist of various
combinations of cholesterol, triglycerides and phospholipids which are
specifically known as apoproteins. Lipoproteins are divided by their ultra
centrifugal properties into chylomicrons, very low density lipoproteins
(VLDL), low density lipoproteins (LDL) and high density lipoproteins (HDL).
Lipoproteins are the organic compounds formed from lipids and proteins that
transport fat and cholesterol through the blood stream and lymph.
AIM AND OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
Number of studies has been conducted in different fields of Physical
Education .But there was lacking a complete treatise on the subjects especially
on the Effect of aerobic Exercises and Yogic practices on Selected
Physiological, Hematological and Bio-Chemical Parameters related to the
Middle aged Men. Aging and ultimate death seem characteristics of all living
organism .During middle age, physical activity usually wanes, with an
accumulation of body fat. Physical inactivity is more dangerous for middle
aged people.
Middle aged people are very prone to metabolic disorders because they
are not involving any physical activity. They are living sedentary life .To give
more awareness for healthy living, for that purpose the scholar selected this
topic for his research work.
The purpose of the study was to find out the effect of aerobic exercises
and yogic practices on selected physiological, haematological and bio-chemical
parameters among the middle aged men.
17
HYPOTHESES
1. It is hypothesized that there will be a significant improvement as a
result of aerobic exercise and yogic practices on physiological,
haematological and bio-chemical parameters when compared to the
control group.
2. It is hypothesized that there will not be significant differences in
the changes in physiological, haematological and bio-chemical
parameters between yogic practices and aerobic exercise groups.
DELIMITATIONS
1. The study was confined to sixty middle aged men teachers from
various schools of Pondicherry region, and their age ranging from
35 to 40 years.
2. The selected training methods were yogic practices and aerobic
exercises.
3. The experimental period was limited to 16 weeks only.
4. The study was restricted to physiological variables of blood
pressure, breath holding time and resting heart rate.
5. The study was limited to haematological variables of haemoglobin
and packed cell volume.
6. The selected biochemical variables were total cholesterol, high
density lipoprotein cholesterol, triglycerides and low density
lipoprotein cholesterol
LIMITATIONS
1. The subjects taken for the study were healthy men teachers, who had
no primary or secondary complications and did not have the same
characteristics as far as the selected variables were concerned, i.e.,
lipid and lipoproteins and blood pressure level may vary from person
to person.
18
2. Psychological and sociological aspects of their day–to-day life
interactions to their environment could not be controlled.
3. The food habits, hereditary aspects life styles of the subjects were
not ascertained and this may influence the study.
4. The race, smoking habits, and emotional states were not ascertained
and this may influence the study.
Yoga
The word ‘Yoga’ is derived from the Sanskrit ‘yug’ which means ‘to
join’ or ‘to yoke’ the related meaning is to focus attention or ‘to use’. ‘Asanas’
one of yoga’s most significant ‘tools’ helps in the positioning of the body in
various postures with the total involvement of the mind and self in order to
establish communication between our external and internal
selves(Iyengar,2001).
Aerobic Exercise
Blood pressure
Blood pressure is the lateral pressure exerted by the blood on the vessel
walls flowing throwing it (Chatterjee, 1980).
19
Heart Rate
Pulse rate or heart rate is the rate of beats of the heart per minute
(Morehouse and Miller, 1976)
Haemoglobin
Cholesterol
Triglycerides
Triglycerides are the most common lipids. These fats do not circulate
freely in the blood but are carried on a protein called lipoprotein
20
Low Density Lipoprotein Cholesterol
21
Chapter II
Cox and others (2001) evaluated the long term effects of regular to
moderate intensity exercise on blood pressure and blood lipids in previously
sedentary older women. Subjects were randomly assigned to either a
supervised center based (CB) or a minimally supervised home based (HB)
exercise programme, initially for 6 months. Within each programme, subjects
were further randomized to exercise either at a moderate (40-55%) heart rate
reserve, Hrres) or vigorous intensity (65-80% Hrres). After 6 months, all
groups continued a HB moderate or vigorous exercise programme for another
twelve months. Methods: Healthy, sedentary women ( aged 40—65 years)
(n=126) were recruited from the community. The subjects exercised thrall of
2.81 mmHg in systolic blood pressure (P=0.049) and 2.70 mmHg in a diastolic
23
blood pressure (P=0.004) after correction for age and baseline values with
moderate exercise, but not with vigorous intensity exercise. When this
analysis was repeated with the change in the body mass included, the results
were unchanged. After correction for potential confounding factors, there was
a significant fall in total cholesterol and low density lipoprotein cholesterol
with vigorous but not moderate exercise at a6 months (P<0.05) but 18 months.
In this largely normotenisve population of older women, a moderate, but not
vigorous exercise programme, achieved sustained falls in resting systolic and
diastolic blood pressure over 18 months. The study demonstrated that in older
women, moderate intensity exercise is well accepted, in a sustainable long term
and has the health benefit of reduced blood pressure.
24
300 mg/L(mean decrease, -13%). A relationship between baseline Lp(a) and
the change in Lp (a) was also observed. After the exercise programme 3, of 4
patients with LDL phenotype B changed to LDL phenotype A, and the
proportion of LDL (-) tended to decrease. No changes were observed for LDL
composition or susceptibility to oxidation. In addition to its known beneficial
effects on the classic cardiovascular risk factors, regular physical exercise may
reduce the risk of cardiovascular disease in diabetic patients by reducing Lp (a)
levels in those with elevated Lp (a) and producing favourable qualitative LDL
modifications.
25
walking groups showed statistically no significant changes in total cholesterol,
LDL cholesterol, HDL cholesterol, apo, A 1, apo A11, apo B, or the ratios of
total cholesterol, HDL cholesterol, apo, A 1, apo A 11, apo A11, apo B, or the
ratios of total cholesterol, HDL cholesterol, LDL, cholesterol; HDL
cholesterol, apo A 1: apo B or apo A 1: apo A 11 (P < 0.05). We conclude that
although both walking programmes appeared to improve aerobic fitness, there
was no evidence of improvements in the blood lipids or associated
apolioproteins of the walking groups. Further analysis indicated that this
apparent lack of change may have been related to the subjects’ relatively well
pre-intervention blood lipid profiles, which restricted the potential for change.
The implications of the observed changes in the coagulation /fibrinolytic
factors remain unclear.
26
intervention reduced body weight by 9% body fat by 21% waist girth by 9%
and WHR by 3% and increased VO2 Max by 16% (P <).01 for all). This was
associated with decrease of 14 +3mm Hg in systolic and 10+2 mm Hg in
diastolic BP, significant changes in GIR at the low (+42%) and responses
during OGIT (P< 0.02 for all). AEX + WL also lowered total cholesterol by
14% and TG by 34% and raised HDL2-C levels twofold (P < .01 for all) <
Thus a 6 month AEX + WL intervention Substantially lower BP and improves
glucose and lipid metabolism in obese, sedentary, hypertensive men. This
suggests that hypertension and the metabolic risk factors for cardiovascular
disease associated with it can be ameliorated by AEX + WL in obese,
sedentary, middle –aged men.
27
Angelopoulos and others (1993) determined the effect of repeated
exercise bouts on High Density Lipoprotein – Cholesterol and its sub fraction
HDL2-C and HDL3-C. Nine sedentary men [ mean age, 22.8 yrs] were
studied during and after treadmill exercise at 65% VO2 Max to determine the
number of repeated exercise bouts required to bring about a sustained elevation
in HDL- Cholesterol and its sub fraction HDL2-C and HDL3-C. A Latin
square counter balanced design was used. Thirty-minute exercise sessions
were undertaken in by 365ml or 11.8%. The increase in PCV was
accompanied by reductions in haematocrit, hemoglobin concentration (g.100
ml 01) and RBC s [10(6) mm-3].
The results obtained from the study after the four week dances were as
follows:
28
The composition and concentration of plasma lipoproteins were studied in five
young men [mean BMI = 27.5+ 2.9 (s.d)] before, during (after 25 and 50 days
of training), and after the completion of a 100 day exercise training programme
that included daily 4.2M] calorie deficit. Along with reductions in body
weight (from 86.7+ 20.0 to 78.7 + 17.1 Kg, P <0.01) and in fat mass (from 17.0
+ 9.7 to 10.4 + 7.4 kg, P < 0.01), the exercise training programme induced
numerous changes in plasma lipoprotein levels. Plasma total cholesterol level
fell significantly after 25 days of training (P < 0.05) and remained significant;
reduced at the end of the training experiment (P ,0.05). This reduction in total
plasma cholesterol was accompanied by reductions in plasma apoprotin (apo)
B, LDL- cholesterol and LDL – apo B levels (P < 0.05). There were trends for
reductions in plasma triglycerides and VLDL components that were significant
only VLDL-triglycerides (P < 0.05). Plasma HDL – Cholesterol level
increased significantly only at the end of the training programmed (P < 0.01).
This increase in plasma HDL- Cholesterol was not accompanied by an increase
in HDL – Cholesterol content rather than an increase in HDL, particle number.
Ratios of HDL- Cholesterol /Cholesterol (P < 0.01) and apo A- 1 apo B (P <
0.05) were significantly increased by exercise training, suggesting a decreased
risk of cardiovascular disease. These results indicate the reduction in a fat
man solely induced by aerobic exercise has substantial beneficial effects on
plasma lipoprotein levels.
29
Kin Jsier and Others (2001) examined the effect of 8 weeks of step
aerobics and aerobic dancing on blood lipids and lipoproteins. Methods:
Experimental Design: Comparative Training. Setting: Two months of physical
fitness programme. Participants: Forty –five sedentary female college student
volunteers randomly assigned to one of the three groups as step aerobics
(n=15), aerobic dancing (n=15 (and the control group (n=15). The step
aerobics and aerobic dancing groups participate in sessions of 45 min per day,
3 days per week for 8 weeks with 50-70% of their heart rate reserve. Total
cholesterol (TC), triglycerides (TG), low- density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-
C), the ratio of total cholesterol to high density lipoprotein cholesterol (TC-
HDL -C). RESULTS: At the end of the 8 weeks period, a significant difference
has been found between the step aerobics group and the control group and
between the aerobic dancing group and the control group in TC levels (F [2,
44] =8.33; P < 0.01). A significant difference in HDL-C levels (F [2, 44]
=3.65, P < 0.05) and TC: HDL-C ratio (F [2, 44] =11,56, P < 0.01) has been
found only between the step aerobics group and the control group. These
results indicate that step aerobics training is an effective training is an effective
training mode for modifying lipid and lipoprotein profiles of female college –
aged students.
30
responses to training body weight , VO2 (Max), and blood total cholesterol (Tc)
and low density lipoprotein-cholesterol (LDL-C), high density lipoprotein-
cholesterol (HDL-C) and triglyceride (TG) of the identified 51 studies, 28 were
randomized controlled trials and AET was generally performed as a moderate
to hard intensity, with weekly energy expenditures ranging from 2090 to
>20,000 kj. A marked inconsistency was observed in the responsiveness of
blood lipids. The most commonly observed change was an increase in HDL-C
(with reductions in TC, LDL-C, and TG less frequently observed). Insufficient
date are failed to establish dose- response relationships between exercise
intensity and volume with lipid changes. The increase in HDL-C with AET
was inversely associated with its baseline level (r= 0.462, but no significant
associations were found with age, sex, weekly volume of exercise, or with
exercise-induced changes in body weight or VO2 (Max). Conclusions:
Moderate too hard – intensity AET inconsistently results in an improvement in
the blood lipid profile, with the data insufficient to establish dose-response
relationships.
31
men with HDL/LDL ratios below the group median at baseline showed even
more favourable changes in their lipid profile than those with higher initial
HDL /LDL ratios. Body mass index, % body fat and haemoglobin A 1 c did
not change during the training period in either group. Endurance training
improved the lipid profile in already physically active type 1 diabetic men,
indepenedently of effects on body composition or glycemic control. The most
favourable changes were in patients with low baseline HDFL/ LDL ratios, like
the group with the greatest benefit to be gained by such changes.
32
density lipoprotein – cholesterol in the blood did not change during the study in
RTG, XTG and CG. The RTG increased upper and lower body strength by
29% (P < 0.01) and 38% respectively. The 6 week detraining strength values
obtained in RTG were significantly greater than those obtained at baseline.
The LXTG increased upper and lower body strength by 19% (P < 0.01) and
25% (P <L 0.001), respectively. The 6 week detraining strength values
obtained in XTG were significantly greater than those obtains at baseline. The
RTG, XTG and CG did not demonstrate any significant changes in either VO2
Max, or body composition during the training and detraining periods. The
results of this study suggest that aerobic-type exercise improves lipoprotein-
lipid profiles, cardio-respiratory fitness and body compositions in healthy,
young woman, while resistance training significantly improved upper and
lower body strength only.
33
and lipoprotein variables in previously sedentary women. Walkers [n=10,
mean (s.e.m.) age 47.3 (2.0 years)] maintained their habitual sedentary lifestyle
throughout. Endurance fitness was determined using laboratory measures of
responses to treadmill walking. Serum lipid and lipoprotein variables were
determined in venous blood (12 h fasted). Body fatness was assessed by
anthropometry and dietary practice using the 7 days weighed food intake
technique functional activity of platelets that included lower levels of
cholesterol, thrombin, lower blood oxidative activity and higher contraction of
prostaglandin 12 and high density lipoprotein.
Sayed (1996) evaluated the effect of high and low intensity exercise
conditioning programmes on components pertinent of blood fibrinolysis and
selected lipid profile variables in sedentary, but healthy individuals. Eighteen
normal subjects were divided into two equal groups; High intensity and low
intensity exercise groups. Each subject in the high and low intensity groups
exercised on a bicycle ergo meter for 20 min, three times a week for 12 weeks
at an intensity corresponding to 80% and 30 % VO2 Max, respectively. One
week before and one week after the conditioning programmes data were
collected for body weight, percentage body fat, VO2 Max and 12 h fasting
blood levels of total tissue type plasminogen activator It-Pa), tissue type
plasminogen activator activity (t –PA), total plasminogen activator inhibitor
(PA 1-T), plaminogen activator inhibitor activity (Pa 1 sterol (CHOL),
triglycerides (1G) and high density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL –C). In the
post-conditioning, maximum oxygen consumption increased significantly (P <
0.05) only in high intensity exercise group while body weight and percentage
body fat did not change (P>0.05) in either of the groups. Physical
conditioning induced no statistically significant (P>0.5) between two groups.
Similarly after training there was no significant change in t-PA, t-PAa or
PA1-1. However PA1-1 decreased significantly (P < 0.05) in the high
intensity group, but not in the low intensity (P >0.05). It is concluded that
34
high, but not low, intensity physical conditioning significantly enhances the
cardio respiratory fitness and reduces the resting level of plasminogen activator
inhibitor activity which may be linked with the favourable effects of exercise
conditioning.
35
These results suggest that exercise induces changes in the lipoprotein (a) in an
untrained healthy individual.
Aellen and others (1993) studied the effects of aerobic and anaerobic
training on lipoprotein concentrations in 45 healthy untrained men. Thirty
three subjects exercised four times per week during nine weeks on a bicycle
ergo meter. Sixteen trained with an intensity above the anaerobic threshold
(blood lactate concentration > 4 mmol. 1-1) and 17 trained with an intensity
below the anaerobic threshold. In addition, twelve subjects served as controls.
The calculated caloric expenditure of the two training groups was smiliar. In
all three groups, total cholesterol, total high density lipoprotein (HDL), HDL
subtractions (HDL2, HDL3), and low density lipoprotein (LDL) were measure.
Training had a significant influence on HDL, HDL2, LDL/HDL, HDL2/HDL3,
and chol/ HDL with anaerobic training, these variables changed in the opposite
direction composed with aerobic training which influenced the lipoprotein
profile on the desired direction. Cholesterol, HDL3 and LDL did not alter
during the nine weeks of training. After nine weeks of training the higher
blood lactate concentration during exercise( representing training intensity), the
higher resting LDL/HDL ratio was found. The correlation between these two
variables was highly significant. They concluded that training above the
anaerobic threshold had no negative effects of blood profile. Therefore,
beneficial adaptations in lipoprotein profile. Therefore, beneficial adaptations
in lipoprotein profile must be achieved with moderate training intensities below
the anaerobic threshold.
36
=20.4 + 1.6 years). WA elicited a mean HR of 162b.min-1 and a mean VO2 of
18.4 ml.kg-1 min-1 which represented 74% of HR reserve, 82 % of maximal
HR, and 48% of VO2 Max. Average caloric expenditure was 5.7 kcal.min-1,
HR values for WA were consistent with guidelines established by the
established by the American College of Sports Medicine for developing and
maintaining CR fitness in healthy adults. However, the VO2 Max fell just
below the recommended minimum threshold level. It was concluded that WA
may provide an attractive alternative to traditional models of exercise for
improving CR fitness; however, HR measures may over estimate the metabolic
intensity of the exercise.
37
dance programme is an effective alternative to a traditional walk-jog training
regime.
38
conditioned elderly women, 65 to 84 years of age, who were active in
endurance competitions and has been training for 11.2 +1.2 years were
recruited at baseline for cross-sectional comparisons. Sedentary subjects were
randomized to either a walking or calisthenics group. Intervention groups
exercised 30 to 40 minutes, 5 days a week for 12 weeks, with the walking
group training at 60% heart rate reserve and the calisthenics group engaging
in mild range-of-motion and flexibility movements that kept their heart rates
close to resting levels. Serum lipids and lipoproteins, maximal aerobic
capacity (VO2 Max), four skin folds, and dietary intake at baseline and after 5
and 12 weeks. RESULTS: When the highly conditioned serum and combined
group of sedentary subjects were compared at baseline, serum high-density
lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C; 1.61 + 0.14 Vs 1.27 + 0.05 mmol/L
respectively: P=002), but not total serum cholesterol (5.72 + /0.36 Vs 5.72
+/0.19 mm0l/L, respectively ) and low density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C:
3.62+/0.36 Vs 3.72 +/0.18 mmol /L respectively, were significantly different.
Twelve weeks of moderate cardio respiratory exercise improved the VO2 Max
of the sedentary subjects 12.6% but did not result in any change in body
weight, energy intake, dietary quality, or any of the serum lipids or lipoprotein.
Highly conditioned and lean elderly women, when compared with their
sedentary counterparts, had higher HDL-C and lower glycerides, but similar
total serum cholesterol and LDL-C values. However, twelve weeks of
moderate cardio respiratory exercise were not associated with an improvement
in serum lipid or lipoprotein profiles in previously sedentary elderly women.
39
from their blood pressure levels. The present knowledge of blood pressure
behaviour during isotonic physical activity is almost wholly based on the
results obtained by means of ergo metric tests. Several maximal and sub
maximal exercise protocols have been introduced, but none has proved to be
superior for diagnostic purpose. There is general agreement that the systolic
blood pressure increase determined by isotonic exercise usually ranges from 50
to 70 mm/Hg in both normotensive and hypertensive subjects. Diastolic blood
pressure shows only minor changes in the normotensives, while in the
hypertensive it tends to substantially increase because of their inability to
adequately reduce their peripheral resistance. This mechanism may also
explain the delay shown by the hypertensive in reaching pre-exercise blood
pressure values during the recovery. On average diastolic blood pressure
increases to a greater extent during bicycle ergometry than during treadmill,
while no differences in external systolic blood pressure have been observed
between the 2 tests. The results of several studies indicate that the blood
pressure response to isotonic exercise is a marker for detection of hypertension
earlier in the course of the disease, while resting blood pressure is still normal.
According to some authors it is also of value in predicting future hypertension
in individuals with borderline pressure levels. There are no conclusive data on
the effect of training in blood pressure response to exercise. The majority of
the published studies report small external pressure reductions after
conditioning, which would merely reflect the reduction in resting blood
pressure. Vasodilatation greatly influences the exercise-induced rise in blood
pressure; in fact the external pressure increase is blunted when the test is
preceded by an adequate warm-up session. Isometric effort is tough to be
contraindicated in hypertensive subjects, as it causes a pronounced increase not
only of systolic but also of diastolic pressure. Mean blood pressure is,
however, increased to the same extent by isotonic and isometric exercise, even
though minor discrepancies have been reported by some authors.
40
Albert (1978) conducted the study to determine the effect of a 12 week
quantitative aerobic training programme [jogging] on the fasting serum
concentration of cholesterol © and triglycerides ( TC) in the high density
lipoprotein of (HDL), low density lipoprotein (LDL) and very low
density(VLDL) classes in middle aged men after 3,6,9 and 12 weeks. U*sing
the 2x3 or 2x5 multivariate and univariate ANOVAS with repeated measure no
significant changes were observed in the concentration to total serum [LDL-C,
HDL-TC-, LDL-TC and the ration of HDL-C /LDL-C. The jogging however,
had significantly (P <.05) Lower level of total serum Tc (130.9 Vs 177.5mg
%), VLDL-T (83.6. vs. 128.mg %) and VLDL- C (21.5 Vs 34.2 mg%) than the
TRL. The analysis of covariance indicated that these changes in the
lipoprotein fraction were independent of diet and alterations in weight and
adipose tissue. The data (1) supported the contention that aerobic training may
aid in prevention of hyper triglyceridmia and (2) suggests that a training
threshold may exist with respect to exercise induced changes in the level of
HDL-C.
Joseph (1981) conducted the study on sixty college women between
the ages of 18 and 2, one group (x=20) consisted of number of physical
education class engaged in a twelve weekfitness programme employing the
Aero kinetic programme developed by human performance systems, in the
Fayetteville, Arkanasas. The second experimental group consisted of 20
subjects in physical education class engaged in twelve week progressive
running programme. An additional group of 20 matched volunteers was also
used ot serve as control. Participation in the aerokinetic programme yielded
significant improvements in the cardio – vascular fitness, total cholesterol,
triglycerides, LDL Cholesterol and the risk ratios. No participation in either
running on aero kinetic programme resulted in similar improvement in cardio-
vascular fitness total cholesterol, LDL cholesterol and the lipoprotein risk ratio
41
while the running programme yielded greater improvements than the
aeroklinetic group in percent body fat, body weight and triglycerides.
42
Franklin and other (1989) conducted a study on lean and obese middle
aged female subjects who participated in the 12 week aerobic training program.
The program was structured along ALSM guidelines, (walking – Jogging 15 to
25 minutes, 4 days per week, 75% max VO2 ) Normal Weight, subjects
decreased their body fat from 24.7 to 23.9 % obese subjects reduced from 38.0
to 36.2 % and the sum of 10 skin folds decreased significantly in both groups.
This moderate intensity physical conditioning program affected both obese and
leaner women in similar fashion.
Judith Jee (1991) studied the effect of an eight week water
aerobic programme on selected physiological measurement of 54 female
participants aged eighteen to twenty five years. The previously secondary
subjects were divided into control group (n=29) and the experimental group
participated in a progressive water aerobic dance programme three times per
week for eight weeks. Each subject was pre and post tested on using heart rate,
resting systolic blood pressure, resting diastolic blood pressure, body weight
and percentage of body fat. Analysis of covariance was used to determine if
any significant difference between the two groups existed on the variables.
The results of this study indicated a significant difference at the 0.05 level in
resting heart rate between the groups. No differences were found in either
systolic or diastolic pressure, body weight or percentage of body fat. It was
concluded that water aerobic dance need to be of sufficient intensity to increase
fitness in young sedentary individuals.
Kravitz et. al., (1993) conducted a study on aerobic dance which
continues to enjoy wide-spread popularity with estimates of over 23 million
adult participants. Numerous aerobic dance styles and variations have been
developed. The new aerobic exercise modality is step training or step
aerobics, which is a modification of aerobic dance using stepping bench
ranging in height from 10.2-30.5 cms. A study was conducted to examine the
physiological effects of eight weeks of step training with (N=12) and without
43
(N=12) ahdn weights. The main effects of step training resulted in significant
(P<).05) overall improvements in VO2 max (38.29 + 1.05 to 41.32 +0.95
ml.Kg-1/min-1). Arm flexion strength (30.73+1.83 to 35.08 + 1.73N/m) Fore
arm flexion strength (26.89+1.13 to 29.29 + 1.14 N/M) and Fore arm extension
strength (28.13 +1.26 to 31.07 + 1.38 N/m)
Masanta, N.C. (2000) stated the acute aerobic exercise and chronic
heavy exercise can act as stressor. To evaluate the effect of glucose on the
reduction of stress response, thirty brick field workers were studied. They
were grouped into two equal halves. One of the groups is allowed to drink 75
gm D-glucose in 200ml water before work. Blood samples were drawn from
both groups at rest and as recovery period. Samples were analysed for
leukocyte count, haemoglobic, blood sugar, lipid profiles and cortisol
estionation. Result showed significant neutropenia ( P< 0.05) and cortisol (
P,0.01) are increased.
44
in both 40mm. Hg test in both male and female subjects (P<0.05 for all
comparisons). Yoga training for a short period of six weeks can produce
significant improvement in respiratory pressures, hand grip strength and
endurance.
45
hematologicl variables (P<0.05). The assessments showed that the cognitive
variables difference were much superior to the control group.
Telles and others (1997) studied the heart rate, breathing rate and skin
resistance for 20 community girls (home group) and for 20 age –matched girls
46
from a regular school (school group). The former group had a significantly
higher rate of breathing and a more irregular breath pattern known to correlate
with high fear and anxiety, than the school group, skin resistance was
significantly lower in the school group, which may suggest greater arousal, 28
girls of the Home group formed 14 pairs, matched for age and duration of stay
in the Home. Subjects of a pair were randomly assigned to either yoga or
games groups. For the former emphasis was on relaxation and awareness,
whereas for the latter increasing physical activity was emphasized. At the end
of an hour daily for six months both the groups showed a significant decrease
in the resting heart rate relative to initial values (wilcoxon paired sample test)
and the yoga group showed a significant decrease in breath rate, which
appeared more regular but no significant increase in the skin resistance.
These results suggest that yoga programme which includes relaxation,
awareness and graded physical activity, is a useful addition to the routine of
community Home children. A group of 25 healthy adults who were
performing yoga and age matched control group were compared in this study.
The examination included biochemical, hematological and ventilator function
tests. Showing of pulse rate, corrective improvement in hematological values,
significant decrease in blood sugar with increase in plasma protein specially
albumin were noted in this study. Mid expiratory flow rate was found to have
appreciable improvement in majority of the patients.
Raja and others (1997) examined the short term effects of 4 weeks of
intensive yoga practice on physiological responses in six healthy adult female
47
volunteers who were measured by using the maximal exercise treadmill test.
Yoga practice involved daily morning and evening sessions of 90 minutes each.
Pre and post yoga exercise performance was compared maximal work out put
9WMAX0 for the group increased by 21% with a significantly reduced level of
oxygen consumption per unit work but without a concomitant significant
change in heart rate. After intensive yoga training, at 154 Wmin (-1)
(corresponding to Wmax of the pre yoga maximal exercise test) participants
could exercise more comfortably with a significantly lower heart rate (P<0.05)
and a significantly lower respiratory lower heart rate (P<0.05), and a
significantly lower respiratory quotient (P, 0.05). The implications for the
effect of intensive yoga on cardio respiratory efficiency are discussed, with the
suggestion that yoga has some transparently difference quantifiable
physiological effects to other exercises.
48
experiment. The yoga group had significant higher scores in high spirits and
extravertedness.
49
Yoga can play an important role in risk modification for cardiovascular
diseases in mild to moderate hypertension.
Manchanda and others (2000) evaluated the possible role of life style
modification incorporating yoga on retardation of coronary artherosclerotic
disease. In this prospective randomized, controlled trial, 42 men with
angiographically proven coronary artery disease (CAD) were randomized to
control (n=21) and yoga intervention group (n=21) and were followed for one
year. The active group was treated with a user friendly programme consisting
of yoga, control of risk factors, diet control and moderate aerobic exercise.
The control group was managed by conventional methods i.e. risk factor
control and American Heart Association Step I diet. After one year, the yoga
groups showed significant reduction in number of angina episodes per week,
improved exercise capacity and decrease in body weight. Serum total
cholesterol, LDL cholesterol and triglyceride levels also showed greater
reductions as compared with control group.
50
weeks and lasted for 14 weeks. Thus, the effect of yogic lifestyle on some of
the modifiable risk factors could probably explain the preventive and
therapeutic beneficial effect observed in coronary artery disease.
51
training of yoga. The scores in breath holding time and vital capacity had also
improved. It was statistically significant. She also recommended that the
athletes could adopt these exercises and thereby increase in the cardio
respiratory function and further she adds, yoga could be included in the regular
programme of Physical Education in schools and colleges.
52
were 1 day apart. Cyclic meditation includes the practice of yoga postures
interspersed with periods of supine relaxation. During SH the subject lay in a
supine position throughout the practice. There was a significant decrease in
the amount of oxygen consumed and in the breath rate and an increase in breath
volume after both types of sessions (2 factors ANOVA, paired t test).
However, the magnitude of change on all 3 measures was greater after CM: (1)
Oxygen consumption decreased to 32.1% after CM compared with 10.1% after
SH; (2) breath rate decreased to 18.0% after CM and 15.2% after SII; and (3)
breath volume increased 28.8% after CM and 15.9% after SII. These results
support the idea that a combination of yoga postures interspersed with
relaxation reduces arousal more than what relaxation alone does.
Dhanraj (1974) studied that the effects of yoga and the 5 Bx fitness
plan on selected physiological parameters. The results indicated increase in
basal metabolic rate total volume in basal state T-4 thryoxine, hemoglobin,
blood cell PWC 130, vital capacity, chest in expansion, breath holding time and
flexibility after yoga training. Decreases in heart rate were also observed.
When yogic training was discontinued for six weeks following in treatment a
significant decline in the values of PWC 130, flexibility and breath holding
time were noticed.
53
groups concerning endocrine parameters and blood pressure. The course of
heart rate was significantly different; the yoga group had a decrease during the
yoga practice. Significant differences between both groups were found in
psychological parameters. In the personality inventory the yoga group showed
markedly higher scores in life satisfaction and lower scores in excitability,
aggressiveness, openness, emotionally and somatic complaints. Significant
differences could also be observed concerning coping with stress and the mood
at the end of the experiment. The yoga group had significant higher scores in
high spirits and extravertedness.
54
Chapter – III
METHODOLOGY
In this chapter the procedure adopted involves the sources and selection
of subjects, selection of criterion variables, experimental design, reliability of
data and tester competency, instrument reliability, orientation to the subjects,
pilot study, training programme schedule, test administration, collection of data
and statistical analysis are explained.
SELELCTION OF SUBJECTS
To achieve the purpose of the study 60 middle aged men teachers were
selected randomly from the group of seventy five middle aged men teachers.
The subjects’ age ranged from 35 years to 40 years. They were examined by
a qualified medical practitioner and were found to be medically and physically
fit to participate in the training programme. The subjects were teachers of
different schools in Puducherry and hence there was no difference in routine
life pattern and hence were considered as a homogeneous group.
Experimental Design
The selected subjects (N=60) were divided into three groups equally and
randomly. Of which Experimental Group I underwent aerobic training,
Experimental Group II underwent yogic practices training and Group III acted
as Control Group. The two experimental groups were treated with their
respective training for one and half hour per day for three days a week for a
period of sixteen weeks.
Aerobic and yogic practices awaken the mental and physical strength.
“Aerobics” increases red blood cells count, which contains hemoglobin that is
responsible for transporting oxygen in the blood, a decrease in resting blood
pressure and a decrease in blood lipids. A regular aerobic exercise programme
will cause a reduction in blood fats such as cholesterol and triglycerides.
Aerobics builds stamina and increases the efficiency of bones, joints, muscles,
blood circulation, respiratory, feeding, urine and nerve centers, organs and
glands.
Yogic practices, if done regularly and with proper preparations, they
lend their full benefit to the fitness of the body and mind. Yoga helps to
perform hard tasks confidently and successfully. It improves the functioning of
veins and arteries. On the whole yoga can be powerful enhancement in regular
training exercises.
The special feature of the yogic practices, is that what they do for the
body, they do for the mind also in an effective way. Physical fitness can be
excellently maintained by practicing in a selected yogic routine.
The impurities which are formed due to the wear and tear of the body
are sent out properly through the outlets besides strengthening the organs
which are responsible for our life, while building strength, power and
flexibility. Aerobics is a good way to decrease percentage of body fat and to
attain the other metabolic benefits of fitness. Aerobics and Yogasana were
selected as independent variables. The investigator reviewed the available
scientific literatures, journals, periodical, magazines and research papers
pertaining to the study and selected the following dependent variables to the
investigation.
Physiological Variables
56
Haematological variables
Haemoglobin
Packed cell volume
Bio-Chemical Variables
Total cholesterol
High density lipoprotein
Triglycerides
Low density lipoprotein
Criterion Measures
The selected tests for this research are highly standardised, relevant to
the study and ideal to assess the selected variables. Having the expert
consultation in the field of physical education, sports sciences and scanning
various literatures related to yogic practices and aerobics the investigator has
selected the following variables and test items as criterion measures and is
presented in Table I
57
Table I
Reliability of Instruments
Standard equipments were used for this study. Stethoscope, Stop watch,
and electronic sphygmomanometer were utilized from the Department of
physical Education and sports, Pondicherry University, Puducherry. For
hematological variables and bio-Chemical variables Aruna Clinical Laboratory
was utilized. These instruments were procured from the standard scientific
companies and were accepted as accurate enough for the purpose of this study.
58
Reliability of the Data and Tester Competency
Table II
INTRA CLASS RELIABILITY COEFFICIENTS OF
SELECTED DEPENDENT VARIABLES
Sl. No. Variables Co-efficient of
Correlation 'R'
Physiological Variables
5 Haemoglobin 0.980*
6 Packed cell volume 0.964*
Bio chemical Variables
59
Orientation to the subjects
Pilot Study
Based on the results of the pilot study the training programmes were
scheduled. During the training period, the experimental groups underwent their
respective training programmes for sixteen weeks. The assistance of three
senior research fellows specially trained in the field was sought on
administration of various tests. The scientifically structured general training
programmes are presented in the table 3.3
60
Table III
61
Table IV
AEROBIC EXERCISES TRAINING PROGRAMME
Forward
Sideward
1-4 Backward 50 % 10 times 5 3 days 1 minute 30
Kick seconds
Lunge
Forward
Sideward
5-8 Backward 60% 8 times 5 3 days 1 30
Kick minute Seconds
Lunge
Forward
Sideward
9-12 Backward 70% 6 times 5 3 days 1 30
Kick minute seconds
Lunge
Forward
Sideward
13-16 Backward 80% 4 times 5 3 days 1 minute 30
Kick seconds
Lunge
(RM- Repetition Maximum)
Basic step : Right leg up and down. Left leg up down
V step : Right leg up right forward diagonally down. Left leg
up forward diagonally down. Repeat with alternate legs.
Over the top : Turn the body side. Feet close. Right leg up apart
down. Left leg up down close together. Right foot
apart over down. Do with alternate legs.
62
L step : Right leg knee up toe forward and down diagonally.
Repeat with alternate legs.
Basic straddle
step : Right foot up apart on the right side and down. Left
knee up straddle down on the spot and move a right
foot right side apart. Repeat with alternate leg.
Side to side : Right leg apart hands forward left leg tap down
Sideward hands down. Repeat with other leg.
Double step side : Right leg apart and hands up. Left leg tap down
hands pull down clap. Repeat the same with right
leg once again. Same action with alternate leg on
both sides.
Knee kick : Right knee up kick down. Same action with alternate
leg on both sides.
Grapevine : Right leg apart. Left leg tap down behind right leg.
Move right leg apart. Bring left leg close and parallel
to the right leg.
Side lunging : Right leg stretch sideward and lunge. Repeat with
alternate leg.
Back lunging : Right leg push back land on toe lunge. Repeat on the
other side.
Leg curl : Right leg apart and curl left leg. Do with alternate
side.
Touch out : Right leg stretch apart land on toe and heel. Do with
alternate leg.
63
Kick sideward : Right leg stretch and kick sideward down. Repeat
the same on the other leg on other side.
Step touch : Right leg diagonally forward on right side left leg
close together to the right leg. Stretch the left leg
apart left side. Right leg close to the left. Repeat
on the other side with alternate leg.
64
65
66
67
DETAILS OF YOGIC PRACTICES
68
Standing Position
Trikonasana
Stand erect keeping a distance of about 75 cms between the feet. Stretch
the arms sideways. Then raise them to the level of the shoulders. Let the
palms face the ground. Stand erect. Then bend the trunk to the left side and
touch the left toes with the left hand. Stretch the right arm upwards and
straighten it. Keep the eyes fixed on the right arm. Bring the left hand near to
the left toe. Keep the left hand in the same position and rotate the right arm
from over the waist and bring it to head level. Look downward. Then touch
the right toes with the right hand. This is the final position of Trikonasana.
Veerasana
Stand straight and erect on the ground. Keep left foot forward at the
maximum distance from the initial position. Join palms and place them on the
left knee. Bend the left leg knee and keep the right knee straight. Raise the
joined hands up and back above the head without bending the elbows. Bend
the head backward. Stay for few seconds. Slowly bring the body and hands
forward and to the original position. Repeat this with the other leg.
Vrikshanana
69
Straighten the elbows. Inhale slowly. Hold this position for about ten
seconds. Then repeat the post, standing on the other leg.
Sitting position
Padmasana
Sit on the ground. Spread the legs forward and place the right foot on the
left thigh and left foot on the right thigh. Some persons like to place first the
left foot on the right thigh and then to put the right foot on the left thigh. Either
process is right. Let the left hand rest on the left knee and the right hand on
the right knee. Let the trips of the thumbs of both the hands touch the tips of
the index fingers. Keep the hand and the spinal column erect. Keep your
eyes close or open.
Pachimottasana
Sit on the floor with the legs stretched straight in front. Bend the trunk
and hold the feet with the thumbs and the first and the middle fingers. Exhale,
and bend the trunk lower so that the head rests on the knees. Draw the
abdomen in while bending lower. This will make the bending of the trunk
easy. While bending bring the head between the arms. The aspirants having
flexible spine can touch the knees with the head at the first attempt.
Gomukasana
Sit on the floor. Fold the left leg and place the heel under the left hip.
Fold the right leg over the left thigh and place the right foot near the left hip.
Take the right arm back over the right shoulder and left arm below and
interlock both hands at the back. Retain this position for few seconds. Repeat
this with the alternate leg and hand.
70
Yogamudra
This asana is called the psychic union posture. Subjects are asked to sit in
long sitting position. Slowly bring the right leg and place it on the left thigh.
The heel of the right foot should as much as possible touch the groin. Slowly
bring the left leg and place it on the right thigh. The heel of the left foot
should as much as possible touch the groin. Slowly bring the hands back and
hold the right hand at wrist by the left hand. Slowly bend the trunk forward
until the fore head touches the ground.
Janusirasana
Sit straight and stretch the left leg forward. Bend the right leg and place
the right foot under the left thigh close to the abdomen. Raise the hands up
while inhaling and bring them down slowly while exhaling. Bend the body
forward and catch the left foot with both the palms. Try to touch the knee with
nose and rest the elbows on the ground. Empty the lungs by exhaling and hold
this position for few seconds. Come to the original position slowly.
Kneeling position
Vajrasana
Bend the legs at the knees. Place the heels at the sides of the anus in such
a way that the thighs rest on the legs and the buttocks rest on the heels.
Support the whole body on the knees and ankles. Breathe normally while
performing this asana. The knees and the ankles will perhaps ache in the
beginning but this ache or pain will disappear by itself. Stretch the arms and
place the hands on the knees. Keep the knees close by. Sit erect keeping the
trunk. The neck and head in a straight line. This is a very simple posture and
one can hold this posture with ease for a longer time.
71
Supta vajrasana
Attain vajrasana. Then with the support of the elbows lie with the back
on the ground. The back should touch the ground. Interlace the arms and put
them on the chest. Tilt the head as far back as possible. Hold this position for
eight to ten seconds. In the beginning, the back may not wholly touch the
ground. The lower part may remain in a raised position.
Ushtrasana
Sit in vajrasana. Stand on knees and separate gradually until they are I
foot apart. Place hands on the waist Bend back from the waist. Take the
hands from the waist and place them on the soles of the feet. Throw the
abdomen front and bend the head back as much as possible. Stay in this pose
for some time and breathe normally. While coming back place the hands on the
waist and sit on the knees. Come to the original position and relax.
Shashankasana
Sit in vajrasana. Inhale and raise both hands above the head with palms
facing forward. Exhale and bend forward from waist and place the hands and
the forehead on the ground a little away from the knees. Stay at this position
for a few seconds. Slowly raise the body and come to the original position
while inhaling.
Supine position
Uttanpadasana
Lie down on your back. Stretch both hands behind the head parallel to
the ears and keeping the palms facing the sky. Raise the left leg to 90o from
the ground while inhaling. Raise the right arm and touch the raises leg while
72
inhaling. Hold this for a few seconds. Bring the leg to the original position
while inhaling. Repeat this with the other leg and other hand.
Pawanmuktasana
Lie down on your back. Stretch the left leg on the floor. Bend the right
leg at the knee. Inhale and press the bent leg on the chest with both the hands
which are interlocked. Retain this position for a few seconds. Hold the
breath. Bring the leg back to the position. Relax for a few seconds and repeat
the same with the other leg.
Hastapadottasana
Lie down on your back. Raise both legs straight up to 45o. Raise the
head from waist and touch the feet with hands without bending. Only the
buttocks should be on the ground. Stay at this position for a few seconds.
Come to the original position and relax.
Ardhachakrasana
Lie down on your back. Bend both legs on knees and bring toes near to
the hip. Lift the waist and make the spine straight. Remain in this position
for a few seconds. Relax all the muscles and continue normal breathing.
Slowly lower the waist to touch the ground and bring legs to the original
position.
Savasana
Lie down on your back. Keep the feet 1 to 1.5 foot apart, arms on the
sides with palms upwards, eyes gently closed with attention on breathing.
Keep the body straight. Keep legs, hands and neck without any curves and
bends. Relax the body completely. Breathe deeply and effortlessly in a
73
natural way. Concentrate the attention on the body and relax each and every
part of the body without any tension in the body and mind. Make the mind
completely vacant and stay in this position for some time.
Prone position
Dhanurasana
Lie down on the carpet with the face downward. Inhale deeply. Bend
legs and grasp ankles with hands. Fingers of both the hands should face the
inner side of the legs. Slowly raise the hind part of the body and then the chest
like a bow. Bend the head backward. Retain this position for a few seconds.
Slowly come back to the original position while exhaling. Relax.
Bhujangasana
Lie down with the face downward touching the ground. Keep palms on
the ground just below the shoulders and wide apart from the chest. Raise the
elbow a little. Inhale and raise the front part up to the naval and backward.
Keep the heels together. Hold this position for few seconds and return to the
original position while exhaling. Relax.
Shalabhasana
Lie down with the face downward. Join the heels and keep chin on the
ground. Place hands under thighs in such a way that the palms should stick to
the thighs. Raise the hind portion and legs backward without bending while
inhaling. Stay in this position for few seconds and come to the original
position slowly while exhaling. Relax.
74
Naukasana
Lie on the carpet, face downward and touching the ground. Stretch arms
forward, palms closed together and forehead on the floor. Exhale and inhale,
lift the arms and neck up at front and legs up at the back without bending like
boat. Continue normal breathing and maintain the same posture for few
seconds. Inhale and exhale and bring knees, legs chin, and shoulder slowly to
the original position. Relax.
Makarasana
Lie on the ground face down, the chest touching the ground and both
legs stretched out. Let the upper parts of the feet touch the ground. Keep the
heels upwards. Raise the arms and put them in front of the head and hold the
middle part of the right upper arm with the left hand. Keep the head
downwards and close the eyes. The head will rest on the arms. The parts of
the arms from the elbows to shoulders, the abdomen, the thighs and the upper
parts of the feet will touch the ground in a straight line. Relax the body while
practicing this asana. Breathe deeply and meditate on God.
Pranyama
Nadi shodhana
75
Kaplabhati
Bhastrika
Sit in Padmasana or Siddhasana. Relax the mind. Close the left nostril
with right thumb. Inhale and exhale with full force through the right nostril.
First slowly and later increase the speed. Do it quickly for 20 times. Repeat
this process by closing the right nostril.
Ujjayee
Sit in Padmasana or Siddhasana. Twist the tongue inward and touch the
palate with the tongue. Now inhale and produce the sound of snoring from the
throat and exhale similarly. Do it for 15 or 20 times in the beginning and
increase gradually. The speed of the breath should be slow and equal.
Bhramari
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
METHOD OF DATA COLLECTION
ADMINISTRATION OF TESTS
Physiological variables
1. Blood pressure (systolic and diastolic)
2. Resting heart rate
3. Breath holding time
Blood Pressure
Purpose
To find out the Blood Pressure (Systolic and Diastolic) through the
blood pressure monitor
Instrument
Electromagnetic Sphygmomanometer Monitor
83
Procedure
84
Administration
The most common places to measure heart rate using the palpitation
method are the wrist (radical artery). To take the resting heart rate at the wrist,
place index and middle fingers together on the opposite wrist, about ½ inch on
the inside of the joint, in line with the index finger. Feel for a pulse. When
you find a pulse, count the number of beats you feel within a one minute
period. We can estimate the rate per minute by counting over 30 seconds and
multiplying this figure by 2 and doubling the result.
The test consisted of voluntary forced inhalation and holding the breath
as long as possible without in haling or exhaling after holding the breathe. The
subject was asked to sit on the chair and the nose clip was clamped over the
nostrils. The subject then tools a voluntary forced maximal inhalation through
his mouth. When the subject finished inhalation as indicated by raising the
Index finger by the subject, the stop was started. It was stopped as soon as the
subject started to exhale. To prevent exhalation or inhalation through the
mouth during the recording time the subject was asked to couple his lips
tightly. To detect exhalation or inhalation through the mouth the investigator
maintained a careful watch on the subject’s mouth. Two trials were permitted
for each subject and the best time was recorded.
85
Scoring
The better of the two breaths holding time was recorded in seconds as
score.
Haematological variables
1. Haemoglobin
2. Packed cell volume
Haemoglobin concentration
Sterilized syringe with needle, cotton, spirit stopper, test tube rubber bung
and drabkin’s solution, photoelectric calorimeter.
Procedure:
2 ml of EDTA blood from the subject were taken in a test tube and 5 ml
of drabkin’s solution was also added to the test tube, stopper tube by means of
a rubber bung and fix the solution through inverting several times.
86
Packed cell volume
Purpose
To find out the packed cell volume in the blood
Apparatus
Wintrobe hematocrit, tubes, pipette, centrifuge and wintrobe stand.
Procedure
Collected venous blood in a wintrobe’s anti coagulant bottle. Shake the
blood to re suspend the cells properly. Fill the blood in to wintrobe tube up to
100 mm mark with the help of paster pipette having a capillary long enough of
reach the bottom of the wintrobe tube centrifuge for 30 min at 3000 rev/ min in
a centrifuge of 22.5 cm radius at a speed of 3800 rev / min centrifuge of 15 cm
radius. Read the height of red blood cell column and express it as a percentage
of whole blood. This shows the concentration of the packed volume.
BIO-CHEMICAL VARIABLES
1. Total cholesterol
3. Triglycerides
Total cholesterol
Venous blood was collected in the early morning after the subjects were
abstained from food and drink except water for 12 hour to estimate the selected
biochemical variables. Ten ml of blood was drawn from the subjects anti
87
cubical vein by venous puncture method and the samples were collected before
and after experimental period of 12 weeks. All bio chemical parameters were
done by Bio-systems semi auto analyzer. (Model BTS -320)
Method
Test Principle
Procedure
Method
88
Principle
Reagents
Phosphotugstic acid – 0.44 mmol /1
Megnesium chloride – 20 mmol/1
Procedure
To 200 µl of sample, 500 ml of precipitating reagent was added, mixed
and kept for 10 minutes at room temperature. The tubes were centrifuged at
4000 rpm for 10 minutes and 100 µl of clear supernatant was removed for
cholesterol estimation by cholesteroloxidaseparaaminopphenazone method
with 1000µl of the reagent.
Triglycerides
Method
Test Principle
89
Glycerol + ATP ------------------------►Glycerol-3- phosphate + ADP
Glycerol-3-phosphate+O2-----------►Dihydroxyacetone Phosphate + H2O2
H2O2 + 4 aminophenazone + 4-Cholrophenol--------------------------------►
4- (P- benzoquione- mono-imino)- Phenazone + 2H2O + Hcl.
Procedure
To 10µl of the sample, standard and distilled water (blank) 1000µl of the
reagent were added, mixed and incubated for 10 minutes at 29oC and the
absorbance of the test and standard were read at 500nm, against the reagent
blank.
The study was based on the groups’ pre-test and post-test design. The
subjects chosen for the study were divided into two experimental groups and
one control group, each group consisting of 20 subjects. Of the two
experimental groups, one was assigned yogic practices and the other was given
aerobic exercises. The subjects of the control group were not allowed to
participate in any of the training programme except in their routine activities.
The data was collected for the selected physiological, haematological and bio-
90
chemical variables first at the beginning (pre-test) and finally at the end of the
experimental period of 16 weeks (post –test). The study was aimed at mainly
in finding out the effects of training on selected dependent variables. In
addition to that it had been analysed if there was any significant difference
between the Yogasana and Aerobic training program.
The data collected from the three groups were statistically analysed for
significance, the analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) was used and the F ratio
was found out. Hence to make the adjustments for significant difference, the
analysis of covariance was used. Since, three grouped were involved,
whenever the F ratio was found to be significant for adjusted post means,
Scheff’s Post Hoc test was followed to determine which of the paired means
difference was significant. In all the cases to test the significance, 0.05 levels
of significance were fixed. The data were analysed by computer using
statistical packages.
91
Chapter IV
In this chapter the data collected were analysed statistically to reveal the
purpose of study. They do not serve the purpose unless and otherwise they
were carefully processed, systematically arranged, scientifically calculated and
analysed, brilliantly interpreted and rationally concluded.
In this study the influence of two independent variables namely aerobic
exercises and yogic practices on physiological, haematological and
biochemical variables were investigated. To achieve the purpose of the study
sixty middle aged men teachers from various schools in Puducherry region
were selected as subjects at random and divided into three groups namely
aerobic exercises Group (I) yogic practices Group (II) and control Group (III).
The experimental groups I and II underwent sixteen weeks yogic practices and
aerobic exercise training respectively and the Group III acted as control. All
the subjects of the three groups were tested before and after experimental
period on selected criterion variables.
To find out the variance in the selected criterion variable, due to the
application of independent variables. Analysis of co-variance (ANCOVA) was
applied on each criterion variables. Whenever the ‘F’ ratio for adjusted post
test means found significant, Scheffe’s post hoc test was applied to determine
which of the three paired means significantly differed.
Analysis of Data
The influence of independent variables on the selected criterion variable
was determined by subjecting the collected data to the analysis of variance and
analysis of variance and analysis covariance.
Level of Significance
To test the obtained results on variables, level of significance 0.05 was
chosen and considered as sufficient for the present study
SYSTOLIC BLOOD PRESSURE
The statistical analysis of the data collected from the pre test and the
post test on systolic pressure of experimental and control group have been
presented in Table VI
Table VI
Analysis of Covariance for the pre and post test data on Systolic
blood pressure of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices
group and control group
Post-test
Mean 121.25 122.50 126.25 B.M. 2 270.83 135.42 4.38*
S.D. 2.22 4.73 8.09 W.G. 57 1762.50 30.92
Adjusted
Post-test
The statistical analysis from the table shows that the pre-test means of
aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control group are 129.70,
127.75 and 130.15 respectively. The obtained F ratio 0.34 for pre test is lesser
than the table value of 3.15 for df 2 and 57 required for significance at 0.05
level. The post test means of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group
93
and control group are found 121.25, 122.50 and 126.25 respectively. The
obtained F ratio 4.38 for post test is greater than the table value of 3.15 for df 2
and 57 required for significance at 0.05 level. The adjusted post-test means of
aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control group are 123.07,
121.06 and 125.88 respectively. The F ratio obtained for adjusted post-test
7.05 is also greater than the table value of 3.16 for df 2 and 56 required for
significance at 0.05 level.
The above analysis of the study indicates that there is a significant
difference among the adjusted post-test means of aerobic exercises group;
yogic practices group and control group. Further, to determine which of the
three paired means had a significant difference, the Scheffe’s was applied as
post hoc test and the results are presented in Table VII
Table VII
Scheffe’s test for the differences between the adjusted post test paired means on
Systolic blood pressure
Aerobic Yogic Control Mean F-Value
Exercise Practices Group Difference
Group Group
123.07 121.06 -- 2.01 2.44
94
training with more positive influences of systolic blood pressure when
compared with the aerobic exercise group and control group. The aerobic
exercise group responded better when compared with the control group.
The mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic practice group and the
control groups on systolic pressure are graphically represented in the Figure I
The adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic
practice group and the control groups on systolic pressure are graphically
represented in Figure II
Figure I
Mean values of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control
group on systolic blood pressure
132
130.15
129.70
130
127.75
128
126.25
126
122.50
Post test
122 121.25
120
118
116
Aerobic Exercise Yogic Practices Control group
group group
95
Figure II
Adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic practice
group and control group on systolic blood pressure
125.88
126
125
124
123.07
123
122
121.06
121
Mm/Hg
120
119
118
Aerobic Exercise Yogic practice Control group
group group
96
DIASTOLIC BLOOD PRESSURE
The statistical analysis of the data collected from the pre test and the
post test on diastolic pressure of experimental and control group have been
presented in Table VIII
Table VIII
Analysis of Covariance for the pre and post test data on
Diastolic blood pressure of aerobic exercises group,
yogic practices group and control group
Post-test
Mean 80.0 79.05 84.0 B.M. 2 276.033 138.017 12.31*
S.D. 2.80 4.07 3.02 W.G. 57 638.95 11.210
Adjusted
Post-test
The statistical analysis from the table shows that the pre-test means of
aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control group are 85.60,
84.10 and 85.50 respectively. The obtained F ratio 0.588 for pre test is lesser
than the table value of 3.15 for df 2 and 57 required for significance at 0.05
level. The post test means of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group
and control group are found 80.00, 79.050 and 84.00 respectively. The
97
obtained F ratio 12.31 for post test is greater than the table value of 3.15 for df
2 and 57 required for significance at 0.05 level. The adjusted post-test means
of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control group are 79.80,
79.40 and 83.84 respectively. The F ratio obtained for adjusted post-test
14.764 is also greater than the table value of 3.16 for df 2 and 56 required for
significance at 0.05 level.
The above analysis of the study indicates that there is a significant
difference among the adjusted post-test means of aerobic exercises group,
yogic practices group and control group. Further, to determine which of the
three paired means had a significant difference, the Scheffe’s was applied as
post hoc test and the results are presented in Table IX
TABLE IX
Scheffe’s test for the differences between the adjusted post test paired means on
Diastolic blood pressure
Aerobic Yogic Control Mean F-Value
Exercise Practices Group Difference
Group Group
79.804 79.406 -- 0.398 0.195
98
compared with the aerobic exercise practice group and control group. The
aerobic exercise group responded better when compared with the control
group.
The mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic practice group and the
control group on diastolic pressure are graphically represented in Figure III
The adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic
practice group and the control group on diastolic pressure are graphically
represented in Figure IV
Figure III
Mean values of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control
group on diastolic blood pressure
86 85.6 85.5
85 84.1
84
84
83
82
81
80
Pre test
Mm/Hg
80 Post test
79.05
79
78
77
76
75
Aerobic Exercise Yogic Practices Control group
group group
99
Figure IV
Adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic practice
group and control group on diastolic blood pressure
83.841
84
83
82
81
Mm/Hg
79.804
80
79.406
79
78
77
Aerobic Exercise Yogic practice Control group
group group
100
RESTING HEART RATE
The statistical analysis of the data collected from the pre test and the
post test on resting heart rate of experimental and control group have been
presented in Table X
Table X
Analysis of Covariance for the pre and post test data on
Resting heart rate of aerobic exercises group,
yogic practices group and control group
Post-test
Mean 71.80 71.00 73.37 B.M. 2 59.24 29.62 8.94*
S.D. 1.72 1.83 1.73 W.G. 57 139.33 3.32
Adjusted
Post-test
The statistical analysis from the table shows that the pre-test means of
aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control group are 74.73,
74.20 and 73.80 respectively. The obtained F ratio 0.62 for pre test is lesser
than the table value of 3.15 for df 2 and 57 required for significance at 0.05
level. The post test means of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group
and control group are 71.80, 71.00 and 73.73 respectively. The obtained F
101
ratio 8.93 for post test is greater than the table value of 3.15 for df 2 and 57
required for significance at 0.05 level. The adjusted post-test means of aerobic
exercises group, yogic practices group and control group are 71.65, 71.01 and
73.87 respectively. The F ratio obtained for adjusted post-test 11.51 is also
greater than the table value of 3.16 for df 2 and 56 required for significance at
0.05 level.
The above analysis of the study indicates that there is a significant
difference among the adjusted post-test means of aerobic exercises group,
yogic practices group and control group. Further, to determine which of the
three paired means had a significant difference, the Scheffe’s was applied as
post hoc test and the results are presented in Table XI
Table XI
Scheffe’s test for the differences between the adjusted post test paired means on
resting heart rate
In the above table, the results of Scheffe’s Post hoc test are presented.
From the table it can be seen that the mean difference between aerobic exercise
group and yogic practices group was 0.651 P>0.05) and the calculated F value
was 2 (P>0.05). The mean difference between aerobic exercise groups and
the control group was 2.218 (P<0.05) and the calculated F value was 23.38 (P<
0.05). The mean difference between the yogic practice group and the control
group was 2.869 (P>0.05) and the calculated F value was 39.19 (P> 0.05).
From that it can be clearly noticed that yogic practice group responded to the
training with more positive influences of resting heart rate when compared with
102
the aerobic exercise practice group and control group. The aerobic exercise
group responded better when compared with the control group.
The mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic practice group and the
control groups on resting heart rate are graphically represented in Figure V.
The adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic
practice group and the control group on resting heart rate are graphically
represented in Figure VI
Figure V
Mean values of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control
group on resting heart rate
75 74.3
74.2
74 73.8
73.37
73
Beats / Minute
72 71.8
Pre test
Post test
71
71
70
69
Aerobic Exercise Yogic Practices Control group
group group
103
Figure IV
Adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic practice
group and control group on resting heart rate
73.869
74
73.5
73
72.5
72
Beats /Minute
71.651
71.5
71
71
70.5
70
69.5
Aerobic Exercise Yogic practice Control group
group group
104
BREATH HOLDING TIME
The statistical analysis of the data collected from the pre test and the
post test on breath holding time of experimental and control group have been
presented in Table XII
Table XII
Analysis of Covariance for the pre and post test data on
Breath holding time of aerobic exercises group,
yogic practices group and control group
Post-test
Mean 36.95 37.40 33.95 B.M. 2 140.70 70.35
S.D. 1.77 2.22 1.96 W.G. 57 238.70 4.19 16.80*
Adjusted
Post-test
105
obtained F ratio 16.80 for post test is greater than the table value of 3.15 for df
2 and 57 required for significance at 0.05 level. The adjusted post-test means
of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control group are 36.90,
37.41 and 33.99 respectively. The F ratio obtained for adjusted post-test 30.81
is also greater than the table value of 3.16 for df 2 and 56 required for
significance at 0.05 level.
The above analysis of the study indicates that there is a significant
difference among the adjusted post-test means of aerobic exercises group,
yogic practices group and control group. Further, to determine which of the
three paired means had a significant difference, the Scheffe’s was applied as
post hoc test and the results are presented in Table XIII
Table XIII
Scheffe’s test for the differences between the adjusted post test paired
means on breath holding time
106
training with more positive influences of breath holding time when compared
with the aerobic exercise practice group and control group. The aerobic
exercise group responded better when compared with the control group.
The mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic practice group and the
control group on breath holding time are graphically represented in Figure VII
The adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic
practice group and the control group on breath holding time are graphically
represented in the Figure VIII
Figure VII
Mean values of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control
group on Breath holding time
38 37.4
36.95
37
36
35
in seconds
33.95
34 Pre test
33.2 33.1 Post test
33.05
33
32
31
30
Aerobic Exercise Yogic Practices Control group
group group
107
Figure VIII
Adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic practice
group and control group on Breath holding time
38
37.41
36.9
37
36
in seconds
35
33.9
34
33
32
Aerobic Exercise Yogic practice Control group
group group
108
HAEMOGLOBIN
The statistical analysis of the data collected from the pre test and the
post test on haemoglobin of experimental and control group have been
presented in Table XIV
Table XIV
Analysis of Covariance for the pre and post test data on Haemoglobin of
aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control group
Adjusted
Post-test
The statistical analysis from the table shows that the pre-test means of
aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control group are 13.40,
13.39 and 13.89 respectively. The obtained F ratio 0.74 for pre test is lesser
than the table value of 3.15 for df 2 and 57 required for significance at 0.05
level. The post test means of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group
and control group are found 14.51, 14.24 and 13.93 respectively. The
obtained F ratio 0.93 for post test is lesser than the table value of 3.15 for df 2
109
and 57 required for significance at 0.05 level. The adjusted post-test means of
aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control group are 14.65,
14.38 and 13.65 respectively. The F ratio obtained for adjusted post-test 16.54
is greater than the table value of 3.16 for df 2 and 56 required for significance
at 0.05 level.
The above analysis of the study indicates that there is a significant
difference among the adjusted post-test means of aerobic exercises group,
yogic practices group and control group. Further, to determine which of the
three paired means had a significant difference, the Scheffe’s was applied as
post hoc test and the results are presented in Table XV
Table XV
Scheffe’s test for the differences between the adjusted post test paired
means on Haemoglobin
In the above table, the results of Scheffe’s Post hoc test are presented.
From the table it can be seen that the mean difference between aerobic exercise
group and yogic practices group was 0.27 (P>0.05) and the calculated F value
was 0.42 (P>0.05). The mean difference between aerobic exercise group and
the control group was 1.00 (P<0.05) and the calculated F value was 5.88 (P<
0.05). The mean difference between the yogic practice group and the control
group was 0.73 (P>0.05) and the calculated F value was 3.13 (P> 0.05). From
that it can be clearly noticed that yogic practice exercise group responded to the
training with more positive influences of haemoglobin when compared with the
110
aerobic exercise group and control group. The aerobic exercise group
responded better when compared with the control group.
The mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic practice group and the
control group on haemoglobin are graphically represented in the Figure IX
The adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic
practice group and the control group on haemoglobin are graphically
represented in Figure X
Figure IX
Mean values of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control
groups on Haemoglobin
14.6 14.51
14.4
14.24
14.2
14 13.89 13.93
gm / dl
13.8
Pre test
13.6 Post test
13.4 13.39
13.4
13.2
13
12.8
Aerobic Exercise Yogic Practices Control group
group group
111
Figure X
Adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic practice
group and control group on Haemoglobin
14.8
14.65
14.6
14.38
14.4
14.2
14
gm /dl
13.8
13.65
13.6
13.4
13.2
13
Aerobic Exercise Yogic practice Control group
group group
112
PACKED CELL VOLUME
The statistical analysis of the data collected from the pre test and the
post test on packed cell volume of experimental and control group have been
presented in Table XVI
Table XVI
Analysis of covariance for the pre and post test data on Packed cell volume
of aerobic exercises, yogic practices and control group
Adjusted
Post-test
The statistical analysis from the table shows that the pre-test means of
aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control group are 43.60,
44.0 and 43.81 respectively. The obtained F ratio 0.07for pre test is lesser than
the table value of 3.15 for df 2 and 57 required for significance at 0.05 level.
The post test means of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and
control group are found 49.37, 48.87 and 43.98 respectively. The obtained F
ratio 27.40 for post test is lesser than the table value of 3.15 for df 2 and 57
113
required for significance at 0.05 level. The adjusted post-test means of aerobic
exercises group, yogic practices group and control group are 49.42, 48.82 and
43.98 respectively. The F ratio obtained for adjusted post-test 31.62 is greater
than the table value of 3.16 for df 2 and 56 required for significance at 0.05
level.
The above analysis of the study indicates that there is a significant
difference among the adjusted post-test means of aerobic exercises group,
yogic practices group and control group. Further, to determine which of the
three paired means had a significant difference, the Scheffe’s was applied as
post hoc test and the results are presented in Table XVII
Table XVII
Scheffe’s test for the differences between the adjusted post test paired
means on Packed cell volume
114
with the yogic practice group and control group. The yogic practice group
responded better when compared with the control group.
The mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic practice group and the
control group on packed cell volume are graphically represented in Figure XI
The adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic
practice group and the control group on packed cell volume are graphically
represented in Figure XII
Figure XI
Mean values of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control
group on Packed Cell volume
50 49.37
48.87
49
48
47
46
in percentage
45 Pre test
44 43.81 43.98 Post test
44 43.6
43
42
41
40
Aerobic Exercise Yogic Practices Control group
group group
115
Figure XII
Adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic practice
group and control group on Packed Cell Volume
50 49.42
48.82
49
48
47
in percentage
46
45
43.98
44
43
42
41
Aerobic Exercise Yogic practice Control group
group group
116
TOTAL CHOLESTEROL
The statistical analysis of the data collected from the pre test and the
post test on total cholesterol of experimental and control group have been
presented in Table XVIII
Table XVIII
Analysis of covariance for the pre and post test data on Total cholesterol
of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control group
Adjusted
Post-test
The statistical analysis from the table shows that the pre-test means of
aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control group are 190.42,
190.45 and 190.45 respectively. The obtained F ratio 0.00 for pre test is lesser
than the table value of 3.15 for df 2 and 57 required for significance at 0.05
level. The post test means of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group
and control group are found 182.71, 184.27 and 191.52 respectively. The
obtained F ratio 0.94 for post test is lesser than the table value of 3.15 for df 2
117
and 57 required for significance at 0.05 level. The adjusted post-test means of
aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control group are 182.72,
184.26 and 191.51 respectively. The F ratio obtained for adjusted post-test
19.46 is greater than the table value of 3.16 for df 2 and 56 required for
significance at 0.05 level.
The above analysis of the study indicates that there is a significant
difference among the adjusted post-test means of aerobic exercises group,
yogic practices group and control group. Further, to determine which of the
three paired means had a significant difference, the Scheffe’s was applied as
post hoc test and the results are presented in Table XIX
Table XIX
Scheffe’s test for the differences between the adjusted post test paired
means on Total cholesterol
118
the yogic practice group and control group. The yogic practice group
responded better when compared with the control group.
The mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic practice group and the
control group on total cholesterol are graphically represented in Figure XIII
The adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic
practice group and the control group on total cholesterol are graphically
represented in the Figure XIV
Figure XIII
Mean values of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control
group on Total cholesterol
192 191.52
190.42 190.45
190.45
190
188
186
gm/ dl
182
180
178
Aerobic Exercise Yogic Practices Control group
group group
119
Figure XII
Adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic practice
group and control group on Total cholesterol
192 191.51
190
188
gm/ dl
186
184.26
184
182.72
182
180
178
Aerobic Exercise Yogic practice Control group
group group
120
HIGH DENSITY LIPOPROTEIN
The statistical analysis of the data collected from the pre test and the
post test on high density lipoprotein of experimental and control group have
been presented in Table XX
Table XX
Analysis of covariance for the pre and post test data on
High density lipoprotein of aerobic exercises group,
yogic practices group and control group
Adjusted
Post-test
The statistical analysis from table shows that the pre-test means of
aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control groups are 83.24,
84.88 and 84.25 respectively. The obtained F ratio 0.061 for pre test is lesser
than the table value of 3.15 for df 2 and 57 required for significance at 0.05
level. The post test means of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group
and control group are found 95.29, 97.24 and 84.50 respectively. The
obtained F ratio 10.16 for post test is lesser than the table value of 3.15 for df 2
and 57 required for significance at 0.05 level. The adjusted post-test means of
121
aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control group are 95.690,
95.906 and 84.44 respectively. The F ratio obtained for adjusted post-test
19.22 is greater than the table value of 3.16 for df 2 and 56 required for
significance at 0.05 level.
The above analysis of the study indicates that there is a significant
difference among the adjusted post-test means of aerobic exercises group,
yogic practices group and control group. Further, to determine which of the
three paired means had a significant difference, the Scheffe’s was applied as
post hoc test and the results are presented in Table XXI
Table XXI
Scheffe’s test for the differences between the adjusted post test paired
means on High density lipoprotein cholesterol
122
compared with the yogic practice group and control group. The yogic practice
group responded better when compared with the control group.
The mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic practice group and the
control group on high density lipoprotein are graphically represented in Figure
XIII
The adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic
practice group and the control group on high density lipoprotein are graphically
represented in the Figure XIV
Figure XIII
Mean values of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control
group on High density lipoprotein
100
97.24
95.29
95
90
gm/dl
Pre test
84.88 84.5 Post test
84.25
85 83.24
80
75
Aerobic Exercise Yogic Practices Control group
group group
123
Figure XIV
Adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic practice
group and control group on High density lipoprotein
98 96.906
95.69
96
94
92
90
gm/ dl
88
86
84.44
84
82
80
78
Aerobic Exercise Yogic practice Control group
group group
124
TRIGLYCERIDES
The statistical analysis of the data collected from the pre test and the
post test on triglycerides of experimental and control group have been
presented in Table XXII
Table XXII
Analysis of covariance for the pre and post test data on Triglycerides of
aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control group
The statistical analysis from table shows that the pre-test means of
aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control group are 109.45,
109.16 and 109.77 respectively. The obtained F ratio 0.03 for pre test is lesser
than the table value of 3.15 for df 2 and 57 required for significance at 0.05
level. The post test means of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group
and control group are found 103.1, 105.09 and 109.75 respectively. The
obtained F ratio 3.80 for post test is greater than the table value of 3.15 for df 2
and 57 required for significance at 0.05 level. The adjusted post-test means of
125
aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control group are 103.1,
105.35 and109.47 respectively. The F ratio obtained for adjusted post-test
57.56 is also greater than the table value of 3.16 for df 2 and 56 required for
significance at 0.05 level.
The above analysis of the study indicates that there is a significant
difference among the adjusted post-test means of aerobic exercises group,
yogic practices group and control group. Further, to determine which of the
three paired means had a significant difference, the Scheffe’s was applied as
post hoc test and the results are presented in Table XXIII
Table XXIII
Scheffe’s test for the differences between the adjusted post test paired
means on triglycerides
126
The mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic practice group and the
control group on triglycerides are graphically represented in Figure XV
The adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic
practice group and the control group on triglycerides are graphically
represented in Figure XVI
Figure XV
Mean values of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control
group on Triglycerides
109.77 109.75
110 109.45 109.16
108
106 105.09
gm /dl
102
100
98
Aerobic Exercise Yogic Practices Control group
group group
127
Figure XVI
Adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic practice
group and control group on Triglycerides
110 109.47
109
108
107
106 105.35
gm/ dl
105
104 103.1
103
102
101
100
99
Aerobic Exercise Yogic practice Control group
group group
128
LOW DENSITY LIPOPROTEIN
The statistical analysis of the data collected from the pre test and the
post test on low density lipoprotein of experimental and control group have
been presented in Table XXIV
Table XXIV
Analysis of covariance for the pre and post test data on
Low density lipoprotein of aerobic exercises group,
yogic practices group and control group
The statistical analysis from table shows that the pre-test means of
aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control group are 119.64,
119.85 and 119.96 respectively. The obtained F ratio 0.00 for pre test is lesser
than the table value of 3.15 for df 2 and 57 required for significance at 0.05
level. The post test means of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group
and control group are found 113.03, 114.22 and 119.51 respectively. The
129
obtained F ratio 2.28 for post test is lesser than the table value of 3.15 for df 2
and 57 required for significance at 0.05 level. The adjusted post-test means of
aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control group are 113.16,
114.19 and 119.4 respectively. The F ratio obtained for adjusted post-test 6.84
is greater than the table value of 3.16 for df 2 and 56 required for significance
at 0.05 level.
The above analysis of the study indicates that there is a significant
difference among the adjusted post-test means of aerobic exercises group,
yogic practices group and control group. Further, to determine which of the
three paired means had a significant difference, the Scheffe’s was applied as
post hoc test and the results are presented in Table XXV
Table XXV
Scheffe’s test for the differences between the adjusted post test paired
means on Low density lipoprotein
In the above table, the results of Scheffe’s Post hoc test are presented.
From the table it can be seen that the mean differences between aerobic
exercise group and yogic practices group was 1.03 (P>0.05) and the calculated
F value was 2.88 (P>0.05). The mean difference between aerobic exercise
groups and the control group was 6.24 (P<0.05) and the calculated F value was
105.80 (P< 0.05). The mean difference between the yogic practice group and
the control group was 5.21(P>0.05) and the calculated F value was 73.76 (P>
0.05). From that it can be clearly noticed that aerobic exercise group responded
130
to the training with more positive influences of low density lipoprotein when
compared with the yogic practice group and control group. The yogic practice
group responded better when compared with the control group.
The mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic practice group and the
control group on low density lipoprotein are graphically represented in Figure
XIX
The adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic
practice group and the Control group on low density lipoprotein are graphically
represented in Figure XX
Figure XV
Mean values of aerobic exercises group, yogic practices group and control
group on Low density lipoprotein
119.85 119.96
120 119.64 119.51
118
116
114.22
gm/dl
112
110
108
Aerobic Exercise Yogic Practices Control group
group group
131
Figure XVIII
Adjusted post test mean values of aerobic exercise group, yogic practice
group and control group on Low density lipoprotein
120 119.4
119
118
117
116
gm/ dl
115
114.19
114 113.16
113
112
111
110
Aerobic Exercise Yogic practice Control group
group group
132
DISCUSSION ON FINDINGS
Physiological variables
The results of the study indicate that the experimental groups namely
aerobic exercise group and yogic practices group has significantly differed
from the selected dependent variables namely breath holding time, systolic
blood pressure and diastolic pressure when compared to the control group. It
is also found that the improvement caused by yogic practice group was greater
when compared to the effects caused by the aerobic exercises group.
It is a known fact that the yogic practice and aerobic exercises is best
suited for developing physical fitness and mainly improving the aerobic
capacity. The reason may be due to the regular, long time practice of
pranayama and aerobic exercises. It will also increase the efficiency of
physiological profiles. The present study also revealed that the above findings
of the study was supported by Gore, M.M., examined the effect of Kapalabhati
on some of the body functions such as breath holding time and heart rate were
significantly improved.
The results of the studies of Telles, Reddy and Nagendra examined the
effect of cyclic meditation and shavasana on some of the physiological
functions. They concluded that the breath volume and heart rate were
significantly decreased before and after sessions of cyclic meditation (CM) and
Shavasana (SH).
According to Chinnasamy, a study on effect of asanas and physical
exercise on six week training, showed that it had significantly reduced the
pulse rate and blood pressure.
Gillett and Elsenman in their study determined the effect of 16 weeks
aerobic dance programme. Random assignment was given to experimental
group and was concluded that a significant improvement was found in the
physiological variables such as breath holding time and heart rate.
The development of physiological variables through yoga and aerobic
training is supported by the findings of Telles et. al., Cox et. al., Rigla et. al.,
and Dengel et. al.
133
It is a known fact that the yogic practices and aerobic training are best
suited for developing physiological variables. Yogic practices and aerobic
training improve the breath holding time and reduce the heart rate for the
same task. This shows that there is a great improvement in all the
physiological variables. The reason may be the pranayama(breathing
practices) and aerobic training. Yogic practices and aerobic exercises reduce
the diastolic blood pressure moderately.
Madanmohan et al. conducted a study on the effect of yoga training on
reaction time, respiratory endurance and muscular strength. It was concluded
that the yoga practice for 12 weeks showed significant reduction in visual and
auditory reaction time and increased in breath holding time. The development
of physiological variables through yogic practices and aerobic training is
supported by the findings of Telles et.al.,Cox et al., Rigla et al., and Dengel et
al.
From the results of the present study and literature, it could be
concluded that there is a significant difference exists between aerobic exercises
and yogic practices in developing dependent variables such as breath holding
time, resting heart rate, blood pressure.
Hematological Variables
Haemoglobin and packed cell volume were developed significantly by
aerobic exercise group and yogic practices group when compared to the control
group. It is also found that the improvement caused by aerobic exercises
group was greater when compared to the effects caused by yogic practice
group.
Aerobic refers to the variety of exercise that stimulates heart function
and lungs activity for a time period sufficiently long to produce beneficial
changes in the body. The heart is always able to deliver sufficient oxygen rich
blood to muscles. So that they can derive energy from fat and glycogen
aerobically, since it increases the efficiency of heart circulation and muscles.
134
The above findings of the study also confirmed by the following findings of
Khare et al ., Angelopoulos et al., and spodaryk.
From the findings of the above literature and results of the present study,
it is concluded that the significant difference exist between aerobic exercises
and yogic practices in developing dependent variables such as haemoglobin
and packed cell volume.
Bio-Chemical Variables
Total cholesterol, high density lipoprotein cholesterol, triglycerides and
low density lipoprotein cholesterol were developed significantly by aerobic
exercise group and yogic practice group when compared to the control group.
It is also found that improvement caused by aerobic exercise group is highly
significant when compared to the effects caused by yogic practices group.
Meditation and other relaxation techniques are not only effective in
relaxation and stress management but also have a limited role in control of
hypertension and cholesterol. Increased physical activity induced a number of
positive changes in the metabolism of lipoproteins. Triglycerides were lowered
when the high density lipoprotein is increased. Since the data of the study
analysed using ANCOVA, it would be appropriate to suggest that the
experimental group showed significant difference. These above findings were
supported by the study of Kin Jsier et. al., Leon and Sanchex., Ades and
Poehiman, Leaksonen, Lemura, Khare, Manchanda et al., Damodaran et al.,
Mahajam et al., and Schmidt.
It is inferred from the above literatures and from the results of the
present study systematically designed aerobic exercises and yogic practices
develops the performance standard as the selected dependent variables are very
important qualities for better performance in almost all sports and games.
Hence it is concluded from the results of the study that systematically and
scientifically designed aerobic exercises and yogic practices may be given due
recognition and be implemented properly in the training programmes of all the
disciplines in order to achieve maximum performance.
135
DISCUSSION ON HYPOTHESIS
1. It was hypothesised that there would be a significant improvement in
physiological, haematological and bio-chemical parameters due to training for
the two experimental groups as compared to the control group. The present
study produced similar results. Hence the research hypothesis of the
investigator was held true and the null hypothesis was rejected.
2. In the second hypothesis, it was mentioned that the significant
differences exist between aerobic exercises and yogic practices groups on
selected criterion variables. The findings of the study were similar to this
hypothesis. Hence the research hypothesis was accepted and the null
hypothesis was rejected.
136
Chapter V
SUMMARY
The summary of the present study was to find out the effects of aerobic
exercises and yogic practices on the selected physiological parameters such as
systolic blood pressure, diastolic blood pressure, breath holding time and
resting heart rate and on haematological parameters such as haemoglobin and
packed cell volume and on selected biochemical parameters viz., total
cholesterol, high density lipoprotein, triglycerides and low density lipoprotein.
To achieve this purpose, sixty men teachers from various schools in
Puducherry region were selected and their age ranged between 35 to 40 years.
As the subjects were all teachers, there was not much difference in the pattern
of their life style. The subjects were randomly divided into two experimental
groups and one control group. Group I was assigned aerobic exercises and the
Group II was given yogic practices. The subjects of the control group were
not allowed to participate in any of the training programme except in their
routine activities.
The study was aimed at mainly in finding out the effects of training on
selected dependent variable. In addition to that it had been analysed if there
was any difference between the aerobics and yogic practices programme. The
collected data from the three groups were statistically analysed for significant
difference, if any, applying the analysis of covariance. Whenever the ‘F’ ratio
was found to be significant for adjusted post means, Scheffe’s test was
followed as a post-hoc test to determine the level of significant difference
between the paired means. In all the cases 0.05 level of significant was fixed to
determine the significance.
CONCLUSIONS
From the analysis of the data the following conclusions were drawn.
138
2. Significant improvement were found in aerobic exercises and yogic
practices groups as compared to control group towards improving the selected
criterion variables such as heamoglobin and packed cell volume.
RECOMMENDATIONS
139
4. A similar study may be attempted by selecting the diabetic and hyper
tension patients as subjects.
140
Appendix I
153
Appendix II
154
APPENDIX III
155
APPENDIX IV
RAW DATA ON DIASTOLIC PRESSURE OF AEROBIC EXERCISES,
YOGASANA PRACTICES AND CONTROL GROUPS (mm/Hg)
Sl.No. Yogasana group Aerobic group control group
Pretest Post test Pretest Post test Pretest Post test
1 85 80 93 85 81 81
2 90 80 82 80 81 80
3 80 80 82 75 91 85
4 80 80 80 80 90 85
5 90 80 83 80 91 90
6 75 80 95 80 90 90
7 88 80 79 80 83 80
8 90 85 83 80 84 85
9 90 80 82 80 85 85
10 90 85 85 75 80 80
11 80 75 83 80 90 85
12 80 70 93 85 90 85
13 85 70 89 80 80 80
14 80 80 90 85 85 85
15 85 80 85 80 84 84
16 90 85 88 80 86 86
17 90 78 82 80 84 84
18 80 78 80 75 80 80
19 78 75 83 80 85 85
20 76 80 95 80 90 85
156
APPENDIX V
RAW DATA ON BREATH HOLDING TIME OF AEROBIC EXERCISES,
YOGASANA PRACTICES AND CONTROL GROUPS (Seconds)
Sl.No. Yogasana group Aerobic group control group
Pretest Post test Pretest Post test Pretest Post test
1 33 38 33 35 35 36
2 39 42 32 36 34 34
3 30 38 35 39 34 35
4 38 40 30 37 35 38
5 30 35 35 38 30 31
6 32 35 32 37 33 33
7 34 38 30 35 30 32
8 32 35 32 35 35 34
9 32 38 35 38 30 32
10 33 38 40 42 32 34
11 40 42 33 38 32 32
12 33 38 32 36 34 33
13 30 35 31 38 35 32
14 30 38 32 35 35 38
15 32 35 32 38 34 34
16 31 36 32 35 34 34
17 35 40 35 38 35 36
18 33 35 30 36 30 33
19 32 36 38 35 30 32
20 33 36 35 38 34 36
157
APPENDIX VI
RAW DATA ON RESTING HEART RATE OF AEROBIC EXERCISES,
YOGASANA PRACTICES AND CONTROL GROUPS (Beats/Minute)
Sl.No. Yogasana group Aerobic group control group
Pretest Post test Pretest Post test Pretest Post test
1 78 73 73 70 74 72
2 78 75 76 72 72 72
3 77 70 72 72 72 72
4 74 70 75 72 74 74
5 75 72 74 70 76 78
6 72 70 77 74 72 75
7 76 70 78 74 74 76
8 78 70 75 70 76 76
9 78 72 76 72 78 74
10 73 72 78 74 75 73
11 76 70 75 70 74 72
12 75 71 76 72 76 74
13 77 72 78 72 75 74
14 78 72 76 70 72 72
15 74 68 74 70 74 72
16 72 70 73 72 72 72
17 76 72 75 72 76 74
18 75 70 74 72 74 72
19 77 72 76 74 78 74
20 78 72 78 74 72 71
158
APPENDIX VII
RAW DATA ON HAEMOGLOBIN OF AEROBIC EXERCISES,
YOGASANA PRACTICES AND CONTROL GROUPS (gm/dl)
Sl.No. Yogasana group Aerobic group control group
Pretest Post test Pretest Post test Pretest Post test
1 13.5 14.5 13.6 15.1 12.5 12.9
159
APPENDIX VIII
RAW DATA ON PACKED CELL VOLUME OF AEROBIC EXERCISES,
YOGASANA PRACTICES AND CONTROL GROUPS (Percentage)
Sl.No. Yogasana group Aerobic group control group
Pretest Post test Pretest Post test Pretest Post test
1 44 48 40 49.2 45 48
3 46 42.8 37 51 42.3 43
5 38 48.6 41 48 41 42
7 41 52 48 48 47 45
8 39.8 49 46 47.3 45 44
11 44 49.9 47 50 45 45
13 48 49.5 42.5 51 40 39
14 51 51 47 49 42 42
160
APPENDIX IX
RAW DATA ON TOTAL CHOLESTEROL OF AEROBIC EXERCISES,
YOGASANA PRACTICES AND CONTROL GROUPS (mg/dl)
Sl.No. Yogasana group Aerobic group control group
Pretest Post test Pretest Post test Pretest Post test
1 169.6 164.9 166.9 152 198.3 192.5
161
APPENDIX X
RAW DATA ON HDL CHOLESTEROL OF AEROBIC EXERCISES,
YOGASANA PRACTICES AND CONTROL GROUPS (mg/dl)
Sl.No. Yogasana group Aerobic group control group
Pretest Post test Pretest Post test Pretest Post test
1 79 88.5 80.45 89 95.15 95
4 89 97.15 97 98 98 95
13 82 85.5 93 98 62.25 65
162
APPENDIX XI
RAW DATA ON TRIGLYCERIDES OF AEROBIC EXERCISES,
YOGASANA PRACTICES AND CONTROL GROUPS (mg/dl)
Sl.No. Yogasana group Aerobic group control group
Pretest Post test Pretest Post test Pretest Post test
1 107.2 100.2 104.2 99.8 107.5 106.2
163
APPENDIX XII
RAW DATA ON LDL CHOLESTEROL OF AEROBIC EXERCISES,
YOGASANA PRACTICES AND CONTROL GROUPS (mg/dl)
Sl.No. Yogasana group Aerobic group control group
Pretest Post test Pretest Post test Pretest Post test
1 112 108.2 109 102.5 115.3 116.5
164
BIBLIOGRAPHY
BOOKS
Bhole, M.V., et.al., Effect of Yoga Training on Vital Capacity and Breath
Holding Time,Yoga Mimamsa XIV: 3 & 4(1971) p.19
Bud, Getchell, Physical Fitness A way of Life. New York: John Willey and
Sons Inc., 196, p.7.
Charles, A. Bucher and Williqm E. Prentice, Fitness for college and Life /
Toronto: C. V. Mosby Company 1985, p.27.
Cooper, Kenneth H., M.S., the New Aerobics. New York: Bantam Books,
p.30.
Cureton, T.K., Physical Fitness appraisal and Guidance, C.V.Mosby Co., St.
Louis, 1947,p.62-65.
Johnson, S.M. and Stalbery.D.C., Sports Exercise and You. New York: Hale,
Rinchant and Winston, 1975, p.42.
Kroemer, K.H.E., and E.Grandjean, Fitting the task to the Human, A text
book of Occupational Ergonomics, Talyler & Francis Ltd., 5:2000,
p.234-37.
Liao MH, Drury CG., Posture, discomfort and performance in a VDT task
Department of Industrial Engineering, University at Buffalo, State
University of New York, 14260. Ergonomics 2000 Mar;43(3):345-59.
Mitchell, Baura and Barbara Dale, Simple Movement: The way and how to
Exercise. London: British Library Catalyzing in Publication Data, 1980,
p.202.
Mohan, A.G., Yoga for body, breath and mind: A guide to personal
reintegration, Boston, MA: Shambala 2002.
142
Morehouse and Miller, Physical and Exercise. Saint Louis: C.V. Mosby
Company, 1976, p.9.
Rodhal, K., The Physiology of Work. Tayler and Francis Ltd., London, 1989,
p.67-6.
Satyapal and Dholan Dass Aggarwal, Yogasanas and Sadhana, New Delhi,
Family Books Pvt. Ltd., 1996,p.30-63.
Sharma, S.K., Health in your hands, New Delhi, Phase – II, Diamond Books
Pvt, Ltd., 2000,p.7 – 11.
Singh, Hardayal, Science of Sports Training. New Delhi: Giri Nagar, Kalkaji
DVS Pub., 1991, p.47.
Stanly Edward, as cited in Simon, Harvey B., and Steven R.Lvisohn, The thlete
Within: A Personal Guide to Total Fitness, Boston: Little Brown and
Company., 1987, p.IV.
Stoll, Sharon Kay and Jennifer Marie Beller. The Professional’s Guide to
Teaching Aerobics. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice Hall Inc.,
1989, p.40.
143
Yadav, Y.P. and Rachna, Art of Yoga. India: Friends Publications, 1998,
p.118.
JOURNALS
Ades, P.A., Poehiman ET. The effect of Exercise Training on Serum Lipids in
the Elderly. Am.J.Geriatr.Cardiol., Oct., 1996, p.27-31.
Angelo Poulos, T.J., et.al., Effect of repeated exercise bouts on High Density
Lipoprotein Cholesterol and its subfractions HDL2-C and HDL3-C”
International Journal of Sports Medicine, 14:4, May,1993,
p.179-238.
Berg, A.L.Keul, J., “Influence of maximum aerobic capacity and relative body
weight on the lipoprotein profile in athletes”, Atherosclerosis, 55:2,
May, 1985, p.225-231.
Borsheim E, et.al., “Essential Amino Acids and Muscle Protein recovery from
resistance Exercise”, American Journal of Physiology and
Endocrinology Metabolism, 283:4, Oct,2002, p.648-57.
Bowman A.J.and Clayton, R.H., et.al., “Effects of Aerobic Exercise Training
and Yoga on the Baroreflex in healthy elderly persons”. European
Journal and Clinical Invest, 27:5, May 1997, p.443-449
.
Brikel, D.A., Edgren, L., Hatha Yoga; Improved Vital capacity of College
Students Alteration Theraphy Health Medicine, 6(6): p.55-63.
144
Burstein, M.et.al., Journal of Lipid Research, 11, 1970.
Colcombe, S.J, and K.I. Ericken “ Aerobic Exercise Training increases Brain
Volume in Aging Humans” – Biological Sciences and Medical
Sciences Journal,1,Nov.2006,61:11,p1166-1170.
Cox, K.L.,et. Al., “Long term effects of exercise on Blood Pressure and Lipids
in healthy Women aged 45-65 years. The Sedentary Women Exercise
Adherence Trail(SWEAT)”. J.Hypertens, 19:10, Oct., 2001, p.33-43.
Fried Wald, W.T., R.L. Levy and D.S. Fredricson, “Estimation of the
Concentration of Low Density Lipoprotein in Plasma without use of
preparative Ultracentrifuge”, Clinical Chemistry, 18,1972.
145
Garber, C.E., Mckineey J.S.and Carleton, R.A., “Is Aerobic Dance and
effective alternative to Walk-Jog Exercise Training? J. Sports Med.
Phys.Fitness, 32:2 June 1992, p.136-41.
Gillett, P.A, and Elsenman, P.A., “The effect of Intensity controlled Aerobic
Dance Exercise on Aerobic Capacity of middle aged, overweight
Women”, Res. Nurse. Health, 10:6, Dec, 1987, p.383-90.
Hager,R.L., Tucker L.A, and Seljaas, G.T. “Aerobic Fitness, Blood Lipids and
Body Fat in Children”, Am.J. Public Health, 85:12, Dec., 1995,
p.1702-06.
Halbert,J.A., Silagy, C.A., Finucane, P., withers RT and P.A Handorf Physical
activity and cardiovascular risk factors, Medical Journal of Australia,
173:84-,2000.
Hardman, A.E, and Hudson, A., “Brisk Walking and Serum Lipid and
Lipoprotein Variables in Previously Sedentary Women-Effect of 12
weeks Regular Brisk Walking Followed by 12 weeks of Detraining”,
British Journal of Sports Medicine, 28:4, Dec., 1994, pp.261-265.
Harinath, K., et.al., “Effects of Hatha Yoga and Omkar Meditation on Cardio
respiratory Performance, Psychological profile and Melatonin secretion.
J.Alern Compliment Med., 10,2004,261-8.
Kin, Jsler A., Kosar SN, Korkusuz, F., “Effect of Step Aerobics and Aerobic
Dancing on Serum Lipids and Lipoproteins” J.Sports Med. Phys.
Fitness, 41:34, Sept.2001,p.380-05.
Leaksonen, D.E. et.al., “Aerobic Exercise and the Lipid Profile in Type 1
Diabetic Men; a randomized controlled trail”.Med. Sci. Sports Exerc.
32:9 Sept 2000, p.1541-8.
Leon, A.S., and Sanchez, O.A., determined the “Response of blood lipids to
exercise Training alone or combined with dietary intervention”. Med.
Sci. Sports Excerc. 33:6, Jun 2001, p.502-15.
147
Manchanda, S.C., et.al., “Retardation of Coronary Atherosclerosis with Yoga
Lifestyle Intervention”. J.Assoc. Physicians India, 26:8,July,2000,
p.687-94.
Manjunath,N.K & Telles, S., “Spatial and Verbal memory Test scores
following Yoga and Fine Arts camps for school children”. Indian
Journal of Physiology and Pharmacology,48(3),2004,353-6.
Masanta, N.C., Dey, S.K., Nayak.P., roy, S., (2000). Indian Journal of
Physiological and Allied Sciences, 54 (1), 13-8.
Niosh., Work practices guide for manual lifting, DHHS Publication, 1981,
p.81-122.
Pansaare, MS., Kulkarni An, Pendsc UB., “Effect of yogic training on serum
LDH Levels”, J.Sports Med. Phys. Fitness, 29:2, Jun 1989, pp.178.8.
Peck, H.L, and Kehle, T.J., “Yoga as an intervention for children with attention
Problems”, School Psychology Review, 34(3), 2005, 415-424.
Pichon, Caterine E. et.al., “Blood Pressure and Heart Rate Response and
Metabolic Cost of Circuit versus Traditional Weight Training”, Journal
of Strength And Conditioning Research, 10:3, 1990,p.153.
Powel, John, “Pre Training and Training”, The Physical Educator, 29:4, 1972,
p.40.
Pronk, N.P., et.al., Acute Effects of walking on serum lipids and lipoproteins in
women”. The Journal of Sports Medicine and Physical Fitness, 35:
50-58, March, 1995.p.50-56.
148
Quig, D.W., et.al., “Effects of short term aerobic conditioning and high
cholesterol feeding on plasma total and lipoprotein cholesterol levels in
sedentary young men: Am.J.Clin.Nutr. 38:6, Dec, 1983, p.825-34
.
Raghuraj, P., et.al., “Effect of two selected yogic breathing techniques of heart
rate variability”, Indian J. Physiol. Pharamacol 42:4, Oct, 1998,
p.467-72.
Rai, L., Ram, K., Kant, U., Madan, S.K., & Sharma, S.K. Energy expenditure
and ventilatory responses during Siddhasana—a yogic seated posture.
Indian Journal of Physiology & Pharmacology 38, 1994, 29-33.
Ray, U.S et.al., “Aerobic capacity and perceived exertion after practice of
Hatha Yogic Exercises”. Indian J.Med.Res., 114; Dec,2001,p.215-21.
Ray, U.S., et.al., “Effect of yogic exercises on physical and mental health of
young Fellowship course trainees” Indian J.Physiol. Pharmacol, 45:1,
Jan.2001, p.37-53.
Saldanha, P.H. et.al., “Maximum heart rate decrease after 7 weeks of intense
training”. Canadian Journal of Applied Physiology, 25:5, 1997, p.52.
Sayed, S., Effects of high and low intensity aerobic conditioning programs on
blood fibrinolusis and lipid profile, Blood congul fibrinolysis, 7:4 June,
1996, P.484 – 90.
Stucchi, F.et.al., “The effect of Exercise on Plasma Lipids and LDL subclass
Metabolism in Miniature Swine, Medicine and Science in Sports and
Exercise,23:5,1991,p.552-561.
Telles, S., S.K. Reddy and H.R. Nagendra, “Oxygen consumption and
respiration. Following two yoga relaxation techniques”. Appl.
Psychophysiol. Biofeedback, 25:4, Dec., 2000, p.221-7.
Tolfrey, K.Jones A.M. and Campbell, I.G. “The effect of aerobic exercise
training on the Lipids-lipoprotein profile of children and adolescents”
Tolfrey K., Jones AM, Campbell IG. Sports Med., 29:2, Feb, 2000,
p.99-112.
Tremblay A and Chiasson, L., “Physical Fitness in Young College Men and
Women”. Canadian Journal of Applied Physiology, 27,(6);2002,
563-74.
151
Unpublished Thesis
Giri, C., “Yoga and Physical Fitness with Special Reference to Athletics”,
IATHPER, 6100,2,April, 1966.
152