Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
J. KERN
Department of Chemical Engineering, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa
Abstract--A model for calculating heat transfer in certain types of rotary heat exchangers is presented
which allows for a simple way of specifying the main design parameters under given terminal conditions.
Energy is exchanged between a granulate being conveyed in an inclined rotating drum and a counter-
current gas stream. No flights are considered and radiative exchange is neglected but energy loss through
the shell is taken into account. Typical applications are found in the mineral processing industry but the
analysis may also be applied to unflighted rotary driers and similar equipment.
focussed on a most accurate representation of radiative differential equations for the gas and charge
exchange [4, 5]. temperatures. These are most conveniently solved by
However, in both cases the analytical results are not means of Laplace Transforms and one obtains a closed
entirely satisfying because they rely strongly on existing solution for the temperature profiles in the exchanger.
data published elsewhere [6, 7]. Important parameters
are evaluated from incomplete measurements which
impairs the general applicability. When one comes to 2. F O R M U L A T I O N O F THE P R O B L E M AND
design a new plant a large amount of uncertainty is GENERAL S O L U T I O N
left [5]. Certain parameters or constants which are In order to illustrate the method most clearly a
necessary for the calculation are just not available, and specific arrangement will be considered throughout the
the validity of some assumptions in the analysis has discussion. The decision on which parameters to fix and
been questioned [8]. Own attempts to apply the which to leave variable is arbitrary and may change
methods in [4] and [5] to a basically similar arrange- from one problem to another. Here the exchanger
ment failed so that the results remain doubtful. diameters 2ri and 2ro as well as all the physical
The present investigation is a, first attempt to obtain properties of the gas phase, solid charge and wall
results without using specific plant data and therefore material stay constant, because they have a minor
should be more generally applicable. However, at this influence on the characteristics of the apparatus. The
stage the problem is simplified in so far as flights are operating conditions are investigated under variable
not taken into account and radiative exchange is exchanger length, total temperature difference in the
assumed to be negligibly small. This limits the applica- charge, rotational frequency of the drum and charge
tion to cases where the temperature difference between flow rate. In the majority of applications these
charge and wall is not too large and the gas is perfectly quantities, some of which are interdependent, will have
transparent. A simple way of solving this problem to be determined towards an economic solution of the
analytically is developed, which will be modified at a specific problem. A constant gas flow rate is assumed,
later stage to account for the more complex which may look arbitrary, but is true in many practical
mechanisms. Unflighted rotary heat exchangers are situations. However, the further analysis will show that
quite common where the size range of particles is wide a variable gas flow rate could be introduced without
because then problems of hold-up and dusting arise [3]. further complication.
On the other hand the shell may be damaged by coarse The general set up is shown in Fig. 1. A hot solid
material failing down. At high temperatures the inside granulate of temperature T/enters the inclined rotating
shell surface normally has to be lined with bricks where drum at z = L and has to be cooled to T/'. The counter-
then a proper flight design becomes difficult. A typical current gas stream of temperature T0' enters at z = 0
application, and this motivated the following study, is and is heated to TO",where the final temperature will
a cooler following an ore roasting kiln, where abrasive depend on the energy loss through the shell. The outside
material of extremely wide size range enters at conditions are characterized by a constant surrounding
800 1000~C and has to be cooled down to 200°C or temperature To. With the simplifications introduced
less. Having air as the cooling gas one can neglect earlier the differential energy balance between an
radiative exchange and the installation of flights is not arbitrary cross-section z and z + d z reads as follows
suitable for the various reasons pointed out before. (see Fig. 2):
Under these circumstances it turns out that the major
dqs dqs,~ dq~ o d T~
part of the energy is transferred indirectly via the shell d z - dz + dzz = msc~ dz-" (1)
material. During rotation the inner shell surface is
periodically cooled and heated by the gas and charge It is assumed that T~ is independent of radial position
respectively. In the majority of practical situations the r, which is equivalent to the "well-mixed" condition in
temperature fluctuation will not penetrate to the [5]. For a granulate of wide size range and not too low
outside shell surface so that the storage--release thermal conductivity this is a valid approximation.
mechanism will fully contribute to the energy exchange From Fig. 2 we also find that
between gas and charge. It has been shown experi-
mentally [9, 10] that in the preheating zone of a rotary dqsw dqwg dqwo
cement kiln this mechanism predominates as well, dz dz dz '
although flame radiation is taking place at the same which expresses the steady-state condition of the wall
time. material. Equation (1) thereby becomes
Modelling the described indirect transfer mechanism
as well as the direct convective exchange and the energy d T~ dqwo dqwo dq~o (la)
loss through the shell one obtains two coupled linear mscs d z - d z ~- dzz ~ d z
Heat transfer in a'rotary heat exchanger 983
ro
Tg'
J
/Tls j L ~
Ts"
o~ = T~-T;',
Oo = To- T;
and
By using the Laplace transformation (see Appendix) granulate as a heating agent, where then the larger
equations (3a) and (4a) are solved to give resistance may even lie in the storage material. Further
the time available for heating or cooling is of the order
Os(~) = C1 x e ~ + C2 x e - v; + C3 (6)
of seconds so that a true periodic temperature profile
and develops in the wall. Therefore also the more recent
0~(~)=D1 x e ~ + D 2 x e - r ~ + D 3 , (7) approaches in the field of regenerator research are not
suitable for our purpose; due to the low frequency the
where E, F, C, and D, are elementary combinations of periodic problem is always simplified to a transient one
the original coefficients and are specified in the [13-15]. In addition, most of the results are obtained
appendix. in numerical form [15], hence would be difficult to
For a given heat exchanger equations (6) and (7) apply to this case.
represent the temperature profiles of gas phase and
solid charge. Further, as the coefficients contain all the (a) Storage-release mechanism
relevant parameters it is easy to study each parameter With the coordinate system rotating at frequency co
individually. If, for example, the exchanger length L is the following equation has to be solved (see Fig. 3):
to be determined for a certain total temperature r?Tw ~ 2 T~
difference in the charge As, where all other parameters - ~ (8)
(~t (~y2
are fixed, one sets ~ -- 1 in equation (6) and solves for
L as a function of 0~(1). This will be illustrated further
once the coefficients and thus the parameters have been
discussed in more detail.
3. M O D E L L I N G O F THE HEAT-TRANSFER
MECHANISMS
The most important assumption, which leads to the
simple solution outlined before, postulates a linear
relationship between the differential heat flux densities
and the gas and charge temperatures Tg and T~. The
operating conditions for which this is a reasonable
approximation have to be analyzed and therefore a
more detailed presentation of the modelling process
seems to be justified. Analytical expressions for the
following three modes of transfer have to be developed: FIG, 3. Model for calculating the indirect
energy exchange between charge and gas.
(a) Indirect transfer from the solids to the gas due to
the periodic conduction mechanism in the wall
Axial conduction in the z-direction and the curvature
material (dqw0);
of the cylindrical shell are neglected which are
(b) Conductive/convectivetransfer through the shell to
commonly used approximations [5]. The boundary
the outside (dqwo);
conditions are
(c) Direct convective transfer from the solids to the gas
(dq~a).
,?T~I n n+2~
The latter two parts are easily determined if one hsw(T~- T~)= -kw ~,,, for ~<t~<- -
assumes constant heat-transfer coefficients; they will be (Y y=0 co co
(9)
discussed later. The major contribution, however, ¢
comes from the first transfer process, which is basically n+--
hwo(To- T~) = - kw ?Twl
@ y for 2n ~< t ~<n- -+ l
similar to the regenerator process. Unfortunately, the
0 U~ (D
large amount of results published in this field cannot
n = 0,1,2...
be used here because there are some characteristic
differences in the analytic treatment. The classical and
approach [11, 12] always assumes an infinite thermal
0Tw
conductivity of the storage material. This is a good -- = constant. (10)
approximation for a regenerator, where the main #Y h.=,f,-,,,,
resistance to heat transfer normally lies in the gas The condition (10) expresses that the penetration thick-
phase and where the period of cycle is of the order of ness of the oscillation is smaller than the shell thickness,
hours. However, the rotary heat exchanger employs a which is valid for most practical situations. Due to the
Heat transfer in a rotary heat exchanger 985
W,(t) - ( T ~ - T ~ ) 32 ~- FIsm4 . t
4 3=2_~l-;7-smt2n=o,t. (11) x i (14)
986 J. K E R N
The series converges rapidly, the change between the differential heat flux density becomes
9 10
and
dqs
d-~ = h~°2"~sin (T~- TO), (17)
Table 1
Heat-transfer
Solid charge Gas phase coefficients
I000
to the charge and gas temperatures [see equation (16)],
800 ooo..;jy
u)=1-75rev/min A therefore dqwo will increase from the cold to the hot end
of the exchanger. At low temperatures this effect is
small so that the energy exchange between charge and
600
gas will decrease with z, which gives convex profiles.
k~
However, when an essential fraction of the energy is
k~ lost through the shell then the gas temperature profile
400
jfr~ L I will more or less follow the charge profile so that both
become concave. The actual point of inflexion will
2 O0 largely depend on the value of Ui, the overall heat-
transfer coefficient defined earlier.
I I I I I I However, in most cases one wants to know how long
I0 20 30 40 50 60
the heat exchanger has to be to achieve a certain
cooling As and how this required length varies with
FIo. 5. Typical temperature profiles for charge (T,) and gas charge flow rate and rotational frequency. F o r that
(To) in a rotary heat exchanger. purpose Figs. 6 and 7 have been put up. It is seen that
.o , / /
60
5070/A
m530 O00kg/h /
-//.=,-Orev/min
000
/,. 4o
.O.o/yy
io / / / J 5000
i
~oo
I
2oo
i
300
I
400
i
500 6oo
I i
7o0 800
A,
FIG. 6. Required heat exchange length L for variable charge cooling A,
and mass flow rate ms.
988 J. KERN
80
70
m s = 15 0 0 0 kg/h
60
50
/ / / ~ ~o = 0 ~ rev/mtn
40
////// 25
30 "< I:%
20
I0
• ~ I I I I I I
0 I00 200 300 400 500 600 700 800
/x,
the charge flow rate has a very strong influence on L; other cases represented by Fig. 4(b) up to 75 per cent of
therefore it may easily happen that a cooler is thermally the total energy loss is due to the periodic exchange.
overloaded. This can only partially be compensated by Apart from that the chosen charge flow rate in Fig. 7
an increased rotational frequency as is shown in Fig. 7. seems to be already so high that the energy exchange
The comparatively moderate influence of c~ on the is controlled by the gas flow rate. This is indicated by
required length is a result of the unfavourable wall the inflexion point in the corresponding curve in Fig. 6.
temperature distribution chosen in Fig. 4(a). The The outlined behaviour is illustrated further in Fig.
storage-release mechanism in that case provides only 8. The absolute change in exchanger length for variable
up to half the energy loss of the solids, whereas in rotational frequency is larger at higher charge flow rates.
80
m~=20000 k g / h
70 A~ = 5 0 0 ° C
60
50
l 40
30
20 I0000 ~ ~ - -
I0
5000
I I I
0"5 I'0 1'5 2"0
rev/min
However, the relative change is essentially bigger for 6. W. Gilbert, Investigations on a slurry drier or
the smaller flow rates in comparison with the larger calcinator It, Cement & Cement Man@ 9, 139-154
( 19361.
ones. This applies even more to smaller coolings A~, 7. H. Gygi, The thermal efficiency of a rotary cement kiln
where the energy loss to the surroundings has only a IV (cont.).Hcat transfer, Cement & Lime Mam~ 11,
m i n o r influence. W h a t can now only be seen as a 143 153 (1938).
tendency will come out more clearly once the inter- 8. V. A. Kaiser and J. W. Lane, Correspondence on [4],
I/EC Process Des. Dev. 7, 318-319 (1968).
dependence of o), m~ and various other parameters has
9. H. Gygi, The thermal efficiency of a rotary cement
been developed more strictly. Then the frequency can kiln IV (cont.). Heat transfer, Cement & Lime Manuf.
be varied over a wider range and the described 11,133 141(1938).
relationships will be more marked. 10. H. Gygi, The thermal efficiency of a rotary cement
kiln IV. Heat transfer, Cement & Lime Manuf. 11,
79 84 (1938).
11. H. Hausen, Nfiherungsverfahren zur Berechnung des
5. C O N C L U S I O N
Whrmeaustauschcs in Regeneratoren, Z. An qew. Math.
The performance of rotary solid-gas heat exchangers Mech. l l , 105 114(1931).
has been studied under variable operating conditions. 12. G. Ackermann, Die Theorie der Wgrmeaustauscher mit
After modelling the different heat-transfer mechanisms Wfrmespeichcrung, Z. An qew. Math. Mech. I 1,192- 205
(1931).
a simple method is devised, which allows one to
13. P. Razelos and A. Lazaridis, A lumped heat-transfer
calculate the temperature distributions of gas and solid coefficient for periodically heated hollow cylinders, Int.
charge along the exchanger. Once these temperature J. Heal Mass Tran~,qbr 10, 1373 1387 (1967).
profiles are k n o w n in an analytical form the influence 14, D. Handley and P, J. Heggs, The effect of thermal
of various operating parameters like charge flow rate conductivity of the packing material on transient heat
transfer in a fixed bed, Int. J. Heat Mass Tran~[br 12,
or rotational frequency of the exchanger can be 549 570 (1969).
investigated, It turns out that under certain conditions 15. F. W. Larscn, Rapid calculation of temperature in a
the apparatus may become thermally overloaded and a regenerative heat exchanger having arbitrary initial solid
required charge cooling is only achieved with an and entering fluid temperatures, Int. J. Heat Mass
Tran,@,r 10, 149 168 (1967).
uneconomically long exchanger. The rate of energy
16. J.R. Reed and G. Mullineux, Quasi-steady state solution
exchanged indirectly via the shell material depends of periodically varying phenomena, Int. J. Heat Mass
on the assumed wall temperature distribution T~(t). It Tran,sli'r 16, 2007 2012 (1973).
may require some physical insight to establish this 17. S. S. Zabrodsky, Compound heat exchange between a
high temperature gasfluidized bed and a solid surface,
distribution, but in turn one obtains a simple solution
Int. J. Heat Mass Transfer 16, 241 248 (1973).
to the problem. 18. H. S. Carslaw and J. C. Jaeger, Conduction of Heat in
It has to be pointed out that this study is only a first Solids, 2rid Edn. Clarendon Press, Oxford (1959).
attempt to get analytical results for a basically complex 19. J. D. Sullivan, G. C, Maier and O. C. Ralston, U.S. Bur.
problem. Various parameters like gas flow rate, Mines Tech. Paper 384 (1927
20. A. J. Chapman, Heat Tran,~ler, 2nd Edn. Macmillan,
exchanger slope and residence time of the charge New York (1969).
remained undiscussed and radiative energy exchange
as well as flight instalhltion were not considered here.
APPENDIX
The aim was to illustrate the approach and
With the boundary condition (5) the Laplace trans-
sophistications will be introduced at a later stage. formation of equations Oa) and (4a) gives the two algebraic
equations
Aeknowledgement The author wishes to thank the staff of
Ucar Ltd., Pretoria, for valuable practical suggestions and s x (7, = A~ x (7~+A2 × Oo+Ag/s (A-l)
for making available certain data. and
s X (~q = BI × ~ , + B 2 × (70+B3/s. (A-2)
The bar indicates the Laplace domain, the dependent
REFERENCES
variable now is s. After rearrangement we obtain
1, S. J. Portcr, The design of rotary driers and coolers,
Trans. Inst. Chem. Engrs 41, 272 280(1963). A 2 × B3-B 2 × A 3
2, G.A. Turner, The thermal history of a granule in a rotary s[(s- A1)(s-B2)- A 2 × B1]
cooler, Can. J. Chem. Em3ng 44, 13 16 (1966).
A3
3. S. J. Friedman and W. R. Marshall, Studies in rotary + -- (A-3)
drying, Pts, I and I1, Chem. En¢tng Progr. 45, 482 493 (s AI)(s--B2) A2 X B 1
and 573 588 (1949). a nd
4. A. Sass, Simulation of the heat transfer phenomena in a B1 × A3 A 1 x B3
rotary kiln, I/EC Proee.ss Des. Der. 6. 532 535 (1967). s [ ( s - A 1 ) ( s - B 2 ) - A: × BI]
5. M. Imber and V. Paschkis, A new theory for a rotary-kiln
heat exchanger, Int. J. Heat Mass Tran.~lbr 5, 623 638 B~
(A-4)
(1962). ( s - A ~ ) ( s - B : ) - A2 × B1
990 J. KERN
For inversion the expression in square brackets has to be After elementary inversion and rearrangement one gets
converted as follows: equations (6) and (7), where the coefficients are
[(s- A i ) ( s - B2)- A2 x B1] = (s + E)(s + F) A2 × B a - B 2 x A3-A 3 x E
Cl = (A-8)
E ( E - F)
where
A3 x F-A2 X B3+B 2 X A3
Cz = (A-9)
F ( E - F)
E,F= -(AI2B2
A2 x B~-B2 x A~
C3 = (A-10)
ExF
~--" - ~ - - ) -~-A 2 x e 1 - A 1 x e 2 . (A-5)
A3 x B 1 - A I x B 3 - B 3 xE
O~ = (A-1l)
E(E - F)
Then
B3x F - A 3 x B I + A ~ xB3
D2 (A-12)
A2 × B 3 - A 3 × B2 A3 F(E - F)
fi= 4
s(s+E)ls+F) (s+E)(s+F) (A-6) A 3 x B 1 - A 1 x B3
D3 - (A-13)
ExF
and Equations (A-5) and (A-8)-(A-13) thus are simple com-
binations of the original coefficients and once these are
A3 × B I - A 1 x /{3 B3 (A-7) specified the temperature profiles can be calculated from
s(s+E)(s+F) (s+E)(s+F)" equations (6) and (7).
T R A N S F E R T DE C H A L E U R DANS UN E C H A N G E U R R O T A T I F
R 6 s u m 6 - - O n pr6sente un mod61e pour calculer le transfert thermique dans certains types d'6changeurs
rotatifs. II donne de fac;on simple les param6tres essentiels pour des conditions terminales donn6es,
L'6nergie est 6chang6e entre un milieu granulaire convoy6 dans un t a m b o u r tournant inclin6 et un
6coulement gazeux ',:1contre-courant. On n6glige le vol de particules et l'6change par rayonnement, mais
on tient compte des pertes de chaleur b. travers la paroi. On trouve des applications typiques dans l'industrie
du traitement des min6raux, mais I'analyse peut 6tre appliqu6e aux s6choirs rotatifs et aux 6quipements
similaires.
W A R M E ~ T B E R T R A G U N G IN R O T I E R E N D E N W ~ R M E [ J B E R T R A G E R N
T E H Y l O O B M E H BO BPAIIlAIOII~EMCJ:I TEFLrlOOI3MEHHI/IKE
AnnoTaun~--lqprIBO~riTC~ pacq~Tr~afl MO~e~b Ten~oo6Mena a HeKoropblx r u n a x porattHormb~x
TeFIJIOO6MeHHI'IKOB, aaromafl IIpOCTO,q crtoco6 oi~pe~enermn OCHOBHblX napaMeTpoa KOHCTpyKIIHH
ripH 3a./laHHblX FpaHHqHbIX yCYIOBH,qx, lqepeHoc TerlJla FIpOHCXOjIMT Mex21y Itepe6pacbiBaeMbiMI4 B
HaKJIOHHOM BpatJ/arollteMc~l 6apa6aHe rpaHy~aMH 14 BCTpeqHbIM HOTOKOM ra3a. NpH 3TOM He pac-
CMaTpHI3aeTc~ cJIyqafi HadlMtIM,q pe6ep Ha BHyTpeHHe~ FIOBepXHOCTH TenY~OO6MeHHHKa,17perle6pera-
eTC~I JlyqHCTbIM TeIIYIOO6MeHItOM, HO yql,lTbIBalOTC,'l Terl~OBble I'IOTepH tiepe3 o6oJtotiKy. TaKlie
TelIJ/OOI~MeHHHKI,I ILIkIpOKO HpHMeH,qlOTC~I B FopHo,/106bIBatOLIle~l EIpOMbIIM.rleHHOCTH. ee3y.rlbTaTbI
aHa.ril~3a MOFyT 6blTb TaK~Ke 14CHOJIb3OBaHb[ ,/IJI~ pacq~Ta Heope6peHHblX 6apa6a, HHblX cyuIHJIOK H
aHaYlOFHqHOFO o6opy,/IOBaHH~L