Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Ima Masofa
(imamasofa@gmail.com)
ABSTRACT
This article attempts to analyze Marxism in George Orwell’s Animal Farm.
The article uses basic ideas of Marxism and Historical background to analyze
the characters. The study aims atdescribing some basic ideas of Marxism
which are depicted in the novel. Those are:1.Social life consists of two layers;
it can beseen in the community of the animals that consist ofupper class and
lower class. The upper class belongs to the one who controls the group. This
refers to Old Major who inspires the animals to have revolution. And then
after Old Major dies, Napoleon leads the rebellion.Napoleon(young boar) has
ambition and direct approach to get power cause him to win the struggle for
leadership of animal farm 2.A minority of people holding the power that lies
on the person who proposes rebellion. The revolutionary ideas come out in
Old Major’s dreams. Old major is a well-respected pig and he represents a
minority of people who has a dream about revolution.3.Philosophy, literature,
arts, and other intellectual activities lie on the upper layer that the pigs is the
group who control the farm. The pigs refer to upper layer. As a member of
upper layer, indeed, they perform privileged attitude which possess to this
class.4.Social conflict lie on the second layer: the upper class constantly try to
suppress the lower class/labor/proletarians, and the proletarians are too weak
in facing the pressures of bourgeoisies, and therefore they tend to be
constantly stronger and richer, while the proletarians tend to be constantly
weaker and poorer.The proletarian can be seen inBoxer (cart horse) that is
great loyal labor, strong body, small intelligence, honest and hard working
Keywords:Marxism, upper class, lower class, Historical Background.
ABSTRAK
354
MARXISM IN GEORGE ORWELL’S ANIMAL FARM
Ima Masofa
oleh dalam babi di dalam novel berbuat semaunya sendiri dan menindas kelas
bawah yang di gambarkan oleh tokoh Napoleon.3.Filosofi, sastra, seni, dan
kegiatanak ademis yang menggambarkan kelas atas yang di gambarkan oleh
tokoh babi yang mempunyai kekuasaan pertanian dari hewan
lainnya.4.Konflik social antara kelas atas sebagai penguasa cenderung
semakin kaya dan berbuat sewenang wenang ke kelas bawah dan kelas bawah
semakin miskin dan lemah.
Kata Kunci: Marxism, KelasAtas, KelasBawah,LatarBelakangSejarah
A
. INTRODUCTION who was owner the farm. It happened
Animal Farm tells a group of because of their suffering from
oppressed animals on Manor tyranny of human being. The rebellion
Farm.The novel takes the reader began Old Major’s idea to struggle
through the revolution of the animals. animalism that all animals are equal.
One of Orwell's goals in writing He taught the animalism to all animals
Animal Farm is to portray the Russian in the farm. The idea was continued by
(or Bolshevik) Revolution of 1917 as Napoleon and Snowball after the death
one that resulted in a government more of Old major. They were success to
oppressive, totalitarian, and deadly influence all animals about the
than the one it overthrew (Howard, animalism. The rebellion started when
2009: 1). Mr. Jones drunk and forgot to feed his
Animal Farm primarily animals. The situation used by the
presents Marxism. In this novel, the animal to rebel. In a short time, the
author, George Orwell tries to portray animal took over the farm. They
the idea of Marxism through changed manor farm to animal farm
animalism. Animalism here brings the and wrote seven principle of
revolution of the animals on Manor animalism. For the future of the farm,
farm. It tells of how animals form a Snowball and Napoleon competed for
system of government. The system of leadership of the farm. They had
government in this case refers to the different opinion in build up the
Animalism on the farm. The story tells windmill. During the time, Napoleon
about animal rebellion on Manor farm. had envy to Snowball such as opposed
The animals took over from Mr. Jones the idea, had his rival chased from the
355
MARXISM IN GEORGE ORWELL’S ANIMAL FARM
Ima Masofa
farm by his bodyguard of dogs and he knew the truth and told the others. In a
took over the project of the windmill few time later, Napoleon was elected
as his own idea. Snowball defeated by as the President of the animal farm.
Napoleon from the farm. The animal Certainly he kept the young pigs apart
worked hard to construct the windmill from the other animals, in both
but the result did not work properly. education and normal social context
Napoleon entered an agreement for the and divided into two groups ; the
sale of the timber with either ruling class, with privilege and honors:
Pilkington or Fedrick but never both at the workers, with the privilege of
once. performing their jobs without
In November, the windmill was complaint and without reward.
half built, but one night a violance Napoleon is more and more like Jones
storm blew up and in the morning they all the time. Many years passed and
found windmill in pieces. The animals many of animal farms’ old in habitant
had a little food in the winter. died, although Napoleon, Squealer,
Napoleon snuffled around and Clover, Banjamin and Moses. The
announced that it was Snowball who farm was more prosperous and the
was responsible for the sabotage. final transformation of the pigs begun.
Napoleon and Squealler blamed The animals were happy about the fact
Snowball for everything went wrong that they no longer for tyrannical
in the farm. Frederick blew up the masters.
windmill with dynamite. It caused This article attempts to analyze
many wounded and dead animal. The Marxism in George Orwell’s Animal
animals rebuilt the windmill. At the Farm. The article uses basic ideas of
same time boxer was collapse and he Marxism and Historical background to
was ready for retired. Then the pigs analyze the characters. The study aims
sent him to the hospital but it was not at describing some basic ideas of
the real hospital but the slaughter Marxism which are depicted in the
house. The other animals were novel. Those are: 1.Social life consists
informed by the pigs that boxer has of two layers; it can be seen in the
dead in the hospital. But Benjamin community of the animals that consist
356
MARXISM IN GEORGE ORWELL’S ANIMAL FARM
Ima Masofa
of upper class and lower class. The stronger and richer, while the
upper class belongs to the one who proletarians tend to be constantly
controls the group. This refers to Old weaker and poorer. The proletarian
Major who inspires the animals to can be seen in Boxer (cart horse) that
have revolution. And then after Old is great loyal labor, strong body, small
Major dies, Napoleon leads the intelligence, honest and hard working.
rebellion. Napoleon (young boar) has
ambition and direct approach to get B. RESEARCH METHOD
power cause him to win the struggle
Research Design
for leadership of animal farm 2. A
The study aims at describing
minority of people holding the power
that lies on the person who proposes some basic ideas of Marxism which
rebellion. The revolutionary ideas
are depicted in the novel. Those are: 1.
come out in Old Major’s dreams. Old
Social life consists of two layers; it can
major is a well-respected pig and he
represents a minority of people who beseen in the community of the
has a dream about revolution. 3.
animals that consist ofupper class and
Philosophy, literature, arts, and other
lower class. The upper class belongs to
intellectual activities lie on the upper
layer that the pigs is the group who the one who controls the group. This
control the farm. The pigs refer to
refers to Old Major who inspires the
upper layer. As a member of upper
animals to have revolution. And then
layer, indeed, they perform privileged
attitude which possess to this after Old Major dies, Napoleon leads
class.4.Social conflict lie on the
the rebellion.Napoleon(young boar)
second layer: the upper class
has ambition and direct approach to
constantly try to suppress the lower
class/labor/proletarians, and the get power cause him to win the
proletarians are too weak in facing the
struggle for leadership of animal farm
pressures of bourgeoisies, and
2. A minority of people holding the
therefore they tend to be constantly
357
MARXISM IN GEORGE ORWELL’S ANIMAL FARM
Ima Masofa
power that lies on the person who thesis writer thinks that the novel
ideas come out in Old Major’s dreams. The writer regardsanimal farm
layer that the pigs is the group who historical background of the two
understanding the place and the time of events that have a linear, causal
novel is a novel that the plot reflects its quotation, it can be learnt that
historical period so well that the story historical criticism sees that the
could not have occurred at any other characters presented in the two stories
358
MARXISM IN GEORGE ORWELL’S ANIMAL FARM
Ima Masofa
The object of this study is how there are several elements: raw
Orwell’s Animal Farm. The novel is factory manager and owner (called the
chosen for some reasons. First, George capitalist), and the workman.
essayist, journalist and critic. Second, The main data is taken from
1943 (1974:26). The Russian First, close reading, reading the novel
revolution was partly the inspiration of from the beginning to the end of the
Karl Marx, a German economist and story. Second, note taking, this activity
communism. The main tenet of with. This step is data will be sorted
relations are the most important obtain the main and important data.
relations between people. It teaches Third, select notes to classify the data
359
MARXISM IN GEORGE ORWELL’S ANIMAL FARM
Ima Masofa
problems stated in the first chapter. first types are “Data Sources
based on the problems of the study. The second types are “Methodological
the form of literary text, Marxism and However, in this research, the
get the findings. The findings will be triangulation. First, triangulation with
will discuss the findings have been the source or the data in how the
trustworthiness of the findings. There asked and consulted to the advisor who
are three types of triangulation. The master in literary works. The writer
360
MARXISM IN GEORGE ORWELL’S ANIMAL FARM
Ima Masofa
361
MARXISM IN GEORGE ORWELL’S ANIMAL FARM
Ima Masofa
between the means of production and represents a fusion of Marx and Lenin:
consumer goods. According to he profound the ideals of animalism
socialist theory, the means of and after his death his skull is
production, once legally obtained, exhumed for public honor just as the
should be collectively owned, but embalmed body of Lenin was put on
consumer goods, including what we display in Moscow.
would consider as private property, Cliff’s notes describe that the rest
should be owned by individuals. of the world was concerned lest
York notes explain that in animal communist upheavals spread beyond
farm, Orwell did something towards Russia’s borders and both the USA
restoring the allegory to its rightful and Britain sent troops to assist in the
place as a force in literature. Many overthrow of Lenin’s party, but by
events in the story are allusions to 1921 this counter-revolution had failed
recent history of Russia. In Russia completely; and soon the western
before the revolution of 1917 there powers had recognized the new regime
was undoubtedly a good deal of and started to establish diplomatic
genuine mass discontent against the relation with it (1967:11). These trends
Tsarist regime, both in the towns and find their parallel in the story with the
countryside, and the spontaneous return of Jones aided by his neighbors,
overthrow and expulsion of Jones is a their rout in the battle of the Cowshed,
kin to the uprising by the Bolsheviks and giving up the pretence that animal
(1980:29). farm (Soviet Union) was still called
The philosophy of the revolution the Manor Farm (Russia).
had been worked out and spread by Lenin’s death was followed by a
Karl Marx whose Communist bitter struggle for power between
Manifesto is represented in the story Stalin (Napoleon) and Trotsky
by the “Seven Commandents, and by (Snowball), leading to Trotsky’s
Marx’s disciple, Lenin who became expulsion from the Soviet Union,
first president of the new regime in which roughly coincided with the
Russia. Old Major (whose appearance inauguration of the first five year plan
is confined to the opening chapter) in which capital-producing industries
362
MARXISM IN GEORGE ORWELL’S ANIMAL FARM
Ima Masofa
were to receive preference over the devoted simply to raising local wage
production of consumer goods; in levels and improving local working
Animal Farm this is alluded to in the conditions, but not genuinely
decision to build the windmill. concerned with the welfare of the
Although Stalin entered into a non people of the world at large. One step
aggression pact with Hitler’s towards a genuine socialist society, in
Germany, the nazis suddenly invaded Orwell’s opinion, was setting up of a
Russia in 1941 and destroyed much of United States of Europe, which would
what had been built up before they include about half the skilled industrial
were driven back. In the same way, workers of his world.
although Napoleon started to trade But Orwell was as vehemently
Federick, the latter attacked Animal anti-communist as he was prosocialist.
Farm and blew up the windmill before During the thirties though he was
being forced to retreat. guarded in his comments were so
Orwell believed that socialism difficult to discover the truth about
was the only political system based on Soviet Russia. He argued, for instance,
hope and that all others were that there appeared to be evidence to
movements of despair and disillusion. prove that the people of Russia were
Socialist, unlike utopian idealists, he hungriest, the best fed, the most
argued, only claims that they can make advanced, the most backward, the
the world better, not perfect, and that happiest, the most miserable people in
even if a redistribution of wealth is the world. Under communism, Orwell
attained so that there are no very rich argued, the state takes complete
and no very poor people in society. By control of industry and rations
1948, three years after the end of the consumption goods so strictly that it is
war, Orwell agreed that socialism in impossible to spend a large income
the sense of economic collectivism even if you have one. And the Nazis
was spreading across the world at great found themselves doing the same
speed. In his view, British Labor Party thing, whatever ideas they had when
was not genuinely socialist but they started out: expropriating,
primarily a party of the trade unions, nationalizing, and destroying the very
363
MARXISM IN GEORGE ORWELL’S ANIMAL FARM
Ima Masofa
people they had ostensibly set out to apples to preserve their health. The
save. pigs claim that they are ‘brain-works’,
This article analyzes basic ideas and ‘the whole management and
of Marxism which are depicted in the organization of the farm depend on the
novel. Those are: pigs. It means that if the pigs get sick
1. Social life is like an edifice or fails to do the job mr Jones will
consisting of two layers come (ibid, p. 32-33). From this
Animal Farm portrays animal explanation it is known that the food
community which consists of layers. distribution is not equally shared.
These layers form society classes. There is an exclusive privilege
Throughout the novel, it is reflected condition that ‘the windfall apples
the community of the animals consist (and also the main crop of apples when
of “upper class” and “lower class”. they ripened) should be reserved for
The upper class belongs to the one the pigs alone (ibid, p 32). This is
who controls the group. This refers to obvious that pigs are not equal with
Old Major who inspires the animals to others. They are higher level. In short,
have revolution. And then after Old the Animal Farm portrays society
Major dies, Napoleon leads the classes in its community.
rebellion. In short, the pigs are 2. A minority of people holding
leaders. the power
Moreover, after the revolution, the This idea lies on the person who
pigs ( upper class ) oppressed the other proposes rebellion. The revolutionary
animals (lower class, such chicken, ideas come out in Old Major’sdreams.
sheep, duck, donkey etc.) in the farm, Old major is a well-respected pig and
they betrayed The Seven he represents a minority of people who
Commandments which says that all has a dream about revolution. Then,
animals are equal (Orwell, 1970: 23). Old Major shares to all animals in the
But, after sometimes the pigs have a farm (Orwell, 1970: 7). In his speech,
new rule which states that only pigs Old Major successfully influences all
who can drink milk and eat apples. animals in the farm to have the same
They say that the pigs need milk and belief and dream about revolution.
364
MARXISM IN GEORGE ORWELL’S ANIMAL FARM
Ima Masofa
Old Major says in his speech, the The pigs are the groups who
animals have been living their lives control the farm. The pigs refer to
just to help Mr Jones (ibid, p 9-12). upper layer. As a member of upper
Old Major belief is similar to the layer, indeed, they perform privileged
beliefs of Karl Marx,” who believes attitude which poses to this class. In
that a minority of people holding the the novel, it is presented that the pigs
power was a main flaw of capitalism” has a special room for themselves. In
(William, 1991: 6). this room, they usually study
Old Major tells the animals that blacksmithing, carpeting and other
someday they can reach a time when essay arts from books which they had
all of the animals could get the brought out of the farmhouse (Orwell,
rewards of their labour (Orwell, 1970: 1970: 29). It indicates that only the
12). Marx also believed that a socialist pigs that belong to upper layer do hard
society, where everyone receives activities.The other animalswhich do
equal amounts of goods, was the best not belong to upper layer seem not to
economic philosophy (William, 1991: enjoy reading and learning those kinds
6). Also in Animal Farm the animals of things. The dogs, for example,
revolted after Old Major’s death just as learned to read fairly well, but were
the Bolsheviks revolted after Marx’s not interested in reading anything
death. Old Major’s speech influenced except the Seven Commandments.
the pigs, especially Napoleon, to begin And then, Clovert learns the whole
to prepare for a revolution. Marx’s alphabets, but could not put words
philosophy influenced Lenin and together. Boxer could not get beyond
Stalin to begin the Bolshevik Party. the letter D (ibid, p. 30). It is clearly
The ways which Napoleon uses Old shows that arts and intellectuals
Major’s ideas are similar to the ways activities done by pigs whose belong
Stalin uses Marx’s ideas (ibid, p. 7). to upper class.
3. Philosophy, literature, arts, 4. Social conflict
and other intellectual Social Conflict lies on the second
activities lie on the upper layer: the upper class constantly try to
layer suppress the lower
365
MARXISM IN GEORGE ORWELL’S ANIMAL FARM
Ima Masofa
366
MARXISM IN GEORGE ORWELL’S ANIMAL FARM
Ima Masofa
367
MARXISM IN GEORGE ORWELL’S ANIMAL FARM
Ima Masofa
368
MARXISM IN GEORGE ORWELL’S ANIMAL FARM
Ima Masofa
369