Sie sind auf Seite 1von 4

ORIGINAL STUDY

Daily Cost of Glaucoma Medications in China


Ying Gao, MD, Lingling Wu, MD, and Aijun Li, MD

regimens, and improved side-effect profiles. And the


Purpose: To determine and compare the daily cost of various prices of glaucoma medications also ranged more widely.
glaucoma medications in China. According to some surveys, the cost of medical therapy
Materials and Methods: The majority of glaucoma medications has a considerable impact on the compliance in glaucoma
commercially available in China were included in this research. patients.1,2 It is much more obvious in developing
The total number of drops in 1 bottle of each medication was countries such as China. The calculated daily cost of
counted drop by drop. The mean volume per bottle of each glaucoma medical therapy is helpful for glaucoma
medication was calculated. The cost per drop, number of days medication selection. Therefore, estimation of daily cost
for both eyes usage per bottle, and daily cost was calculated. was made in this study on the majority of glaucoma
medications commercially available in China, including
Results: (1) The volume per drop ranged from 0.03 mL b-adrenergic blockers, a-adrenergic agonists, cholinergics,
(brinzolamide 1%, travoprost 0.004%, bimatoprost 0.03%, carbonic anhydrase inhibitors, and prostaglandins. This is
and latanoprost 0.005%) to 0.05 mL (timolol 0.5%—Chengrui a cost-minimization study, and all the medications
and pilocarpine 0.5% and 2%—Zhenrui). (2) The cost per bottle included are assumed to have equal efficacy. Despite the
ranged from $0.69 (US dollar) (timolol 0.5%—Malaisuan fact that this cost minimization has limitations, it serves
Saimaluo’er) to $40.78 (latanoprost 0.005%). (3) The number at least as a guide of pricing of medications that could
of days for both eyes usage per bottle ranged from 52 days help to better understand the cost effectiveness of
(bimatoprost 0.03%) to 11 days (pilocarpine nitrate 0.5%— medications in treating glaucoma.
Zhenrui). (4) The daily cost for both eyes usage from expensive
to cheap were latanoprost 0.005%—$0.91, travoprost 0.004%—
$0.77, brimonidine 0.2%—$0.61, bimatoprost 0.03%—$0.46, D-
MATERIALS AND METHODS
timolol 1%—$0.36, brinzolamide 1%—$0.34, pilocarpine 2%—
Zhenrui—$0.28, levobunolol 0.5%—$0.25, betaxolol 0.25%—
All the imported and domestic generic glaucoma
$0.24, pilocarpine 0.5%—Zhenrui—$0.18, pilocarpine 2%—Hum-
medications commercially available in Beijing, including
ing—$0.16, carteolol 1%—Mikelan—$0.15, carteolol 2%—Mike-
the majority of the widely used glaucoma medications in
lan—$0.15, pilocarpine 1%—Huming—$0.10, timolol 0.5%—
China, were included in this research. Seven b-adrenergic
Chengrui—$0.08, timolol 0.5%—Malaisuan Saimaluo’er—$0.03.
blockers and 9 other preparations were included in the
research (Table 1). Each bottle was labeled as containing
Conclusions: The daily cost of glaucoma medications in China 5 mL per bottle except for the 2.5-mL bottles of
ranged much more wildly than developed countries. These data latanoprost 0.005% (Xalatan, Pfizer) and travoprost
may be useful in selecting medications for glaucoma therapy. 0.004% (Travatan, Alcon) and the 3-mL bottle of
The ophthalmic solution of prostaglandins is powerful in bimatoprost 0.03% (Lumigan, Allergan). Five bottles of
reducing intraocular pressure. However, its high price should each medications were kept at room temperature, 221C
be considered when selecting glaucoma medications in China. for more than 24 hours before they were tested separately
Key Words: glaucoma, medicine, cost
by 5 researchers at the same environment. The researchers
squeezed the bottles to make drops one by one and
(J Glaucoma 2007;16:594–597) calculated the number of drops of each bottle. The drops
of each bottle were collected in a tube and then measured
with a graduated cylinder. After the actual volume for
each bottle was measured, the mean number of drops per
T he kinds of glaucoma medications increased rapidly in
the last few years. New glaucoma medications such as
prostaglandins have increased efficacy, reduced dosing
bottle and the mean volume per bottle were determined.
The volume per drop was calculated by dividing the mean
volume per bottle by the mean number of drops per
bottle, the cost per drop was calculated by dividing the
Received for publication September 14, 2006; accepted March 24, 2007.
From the Peking University Third Hospital, Peking University Eye market price by the mean number of drops in a bottle, the
Center, Beijing, China. number of days for both eyes usage per bottle was
This research did not receive any financial support. And none of the calculated by dividing the mean number of drops in a
authors has proprietary interests of the manuscript. bottle by the number of drops administered daily for both
Reprints: Wu Lingling, MD, Peking University Third Hospital, Peking
University Eye Center, Beijing 100083, China (e-mail: wllc@
eyes. And the cost per day was calculated by multiplying
mail.hz.zj.cn). the cost per drop by the number of drops administered
Copyright r 2007 by Lippincott Williams & Wilkins daily for both eyes. The information of standard market

594 J Glaucoma  Volume 16, Number 7, October/November 2007


J Glaucoma  Volume 16, Number 7, October/November 2007 Daily Cost of Glaucoma Medications

price, a set single price for the patient, comes from State
No. d/Bottle

Dose*/d Eyes) (d)


Food and Drug Administration, PR China.
(Both

11
15
12
15
19
22
24

27
29
30
30
32
35

45
47
52
RESULTS
The actual volume per bottle, which was labeled as
QID
QID
QID
QID
TID
BID
BID

BID
BID
BID
BID
BID
BID

QD
QD
QD
5 mL, ranged from 4.15 (timolol 0.5%, Malaisuan
Saimaluo’er, Wuhan Wujing, China) to 4.87 mL (pilo-
carpine 1%, Huming, Yongguang, China). The volume
0.05 ± 0.004
0.04 ± 0.002
0.05 ± 0.002
0.04 ± 0.002
0.04 ± 0.005
0.05 ± 0.001
0.04 ± 0.003

0.04 ± 0.002
0.04 ± 0.001
0.04 ± 0.002
0.04 ± 0.001
0.04 ± 0.002
0.03 ± 0.001

0.03 ± 0.003
0.03 ± 0.001
0.03 ± 0.000
Drop (mL)
Volume/

per drop was 0.03 mL (brinzolamide 1%, Azopt, Alcon)


to 0.05 mL (timolol 0.5%, Chengrui, Zhengda Furuida,
China and pilocarpine 0.5% and 2%, Zhenrui, Zhengda
Furuida, China). The number of days for both eyes usage
per bottle varied from 11 days (pilocarpine 0.5%,
4.55B5.10
4.72B4.97
4.40B4.62
4.58B4.95
4.22B4.84
4.50B4.70
3.94B4.43

4.60B4.87
4.45B4.90
4.57B4.67
4.56B4.73
4.43B4.72
4.10B4.48

2.65 ± 0.036 2.62B2.70


2.55 ± 0.100 2.41B2.64
3.08 ± 0.047 3.01B3.11
Volume/Bottle (mL)

Zhenrui, Zhengda Furuida, China) to 35 days (brinzola-


mide 1%, Azopt, Alcon). The actual volume per bottle of
latanoprost 0.005% (Xalatan, Pfizer) and travoprost
4.86 ± 0.209
4.87 ± 0.106
4.50 ± 0.086
4.73 ± 0.150
4.69 ± 0.266
4.61 ± 0.077
4.15 ± 0.247

4.71 ± 0.114
4.64 ± 0.184
4.62 ± 0.043
4.64 ± 0.072
4.61 ± 0.122
4.28 ± 0.144

0.004% (Travatan, Alcon), which were labeled as


2.5 mL, were 2.65 and 2.55 mL. The volumes per drop
were both 0.03 mL. The number of days for both eyes
usage per bottle were 45 days and 47 days. The actual
volume per bottle of bimatoprost 0.03% (Lumigan,
119 ± 8.2 108B130

119 ± 3.1 116B124


115 ± 8.5 104B127

100B113
112B122
112B123
116B123
112B132
130B150

103 ± 2.5 100B105


98 ± 7.2 92B109

90 ± 7.6 82B100
No. Drops/Bottle
91 ± 4.2 8 6B96

92 ± 4.4 8 6B97

87 ± 2.4 8 3B89

94 ± 2.2 9 0B95

Allergan), which was labeled as 3 mL, was 3.08 mL. The


volume per drop was 0.03 mL. The number of days for
both eyes usage per bottle was 52 days (Table 1).
106 ± 6.3
116 ± 4.1
119 ± 4.3
119 ± 2.6
126 ± 8.4
141 ± 8.0

The price per bottle of the glaucoma medications


ranged from $0.69 (timolol 0.5%, Malaisuan Saimaluo’er,
Wuhan Wujing, China) to $40.78 (latanoprost 0.005%,
TABLE 1. Average Days for Both Eyes Usage Per Bottle of Glaucoma Medication (n = 5)

Xalatan, Pfizer). The daily cost for both eyes usage varied
Zhengda Furuida, China

Zhengda Furuida, China

Zhengda Furuida, China

Allergan, United States

Allergan, United States


Allergan, United States

from $0.03 (timolol 0.5%, Malaisuan Saimaluo’er,


Wuhan Wujing, China

Alcon, United States

Alcon, United States

Alcon, United States


Pfizer, United States
Manufacturer

Wuhan Wujing, China) to $0.91 (latanoprost 0.005%,


Yongguang, China

Yongguang, China

Yongguang, China

Xalatan, Pfizer) (Table 2).


Oostuka, China
Oostuka, China

*BID indicates twice per day; QD, once per day; QID, 4 times per day; TID, 3 times per day.

DISCUSSION
With an increasing older population and increased
rate of detection, the use of glaucoma medications is
increasing. Among people older than 40 years, there are
Saimaluo’er
Trade Name

approximately 9.4 million patients3 who have glaucoma


Malaisuan
Alphagan
Chengrui

Travatan
Lumigan

and may need medical therapy for long time or even for a
Betoptic
Mikelan
Mikelan
Huming

Huming

Levobunolol hydrochloride 0.5% Betagan

Xalatan
Zhenrui

Zhenrui

Dilijian
Azopt

life time. As a result, there has been an increase in


consumption of glaucoma medications. Another reason
for the increase should be the introduction of new, high-
Betaxolol hydrochloride 0.25%

cost medications. The increase of medical cost has a


Carteolol hydrochloride 1%
Carteolol hydrochloride 2%

considerable impact on patients and the health-care


Active Ingredient
Pilocarpine nitrate 0.5%

system. Daily cost is one of the important factors that


Pilocarpine nitrate 2%
Pilocarpine nitrate 1%

Pilocarpine nitrate 2%

D-timolol maleate 1%
b-adrenergic blocker Timolol maleate 0.5%
Timolol maleate 0.5%

go into this decision-making process, besides drug


Latanoprost 0.005%

Bimatoprost 0.03%
Travoprost 0.004%
a-adrenergic agonist Brimonidine 0.2%

efficacy, side-effect profile, and dosing frequency. Accord-


Brinzolamide 1%

ing to the result of this study, all domestic generic


medications cost less than $0.40 as does imported
brinzolamide. The cheapest one was timolol 0.5%
(Malaisuan Saimaluo’er, Wuhan Wujing, China), which
cost only $0.03 daily. However, all topical prostaglandin
analogs and brimonidine cost at least $0.40 daily or more.
Carbonic anhydrase

And the most expensive glaucoma medication in China


Generic Names

was latanoprost 0.005%, which cost $0.91 daily. In


Prostaglandins

America, Japan, and some European countries, similar


Cholinergic

inhibitor

studies have been conducted to examine drop size, fill


volume, and predicted daily cost of glaucoma medica-
tions.4–11 In America, the most expensive medication was

r 2007 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins 595


Gao et al J Glaucoma  Volume 16, Number 7, October/November 2007

TABLE 2. Daily Cost of Glaucoma Medications (n = 5)


Cost/d
Price US No. Drops/d Cost/Drop (Both Eyes)
Generic Names Active Ingredient Trade Name Manufacturer Dollar* (Both Eyes) US Dollar* US Dollar*
Cholinergic Pilocarpine nitrate 1% Huming Yongguang, China 1.53 8 0.01 0.10
Pilocarpine nitrate 2% Huming Yongguang, China 2.32 8 0.02 0.16
Pilocarpine nitrate 0.5% Zhenrui Zhengda Furuida, 2.05 8 0.02 0.18
China
Pilocarpine nitrate 2% Zhenrui Zhengda Furuida, 3.26 8 0.04 0.28
China
b-adrenergic Timolol maleate 0.5% Malaisuan Wuhan Wujing, China 0.69 4 0.01 0.03
blocker Saimaluo’er
Timolol maleate 0.5% Chengrui Zhengda Furuida, 1.66 4 0.02 0.08
China
Carteolol hydrochloride 1% Mikelan Oostuka, China 4.34 4 0.04 0.15
Carteolol hydrochloride 2% Mikelan Oostuka, China 4.34 4 0.04 0.15
Betaxolol hydrochloride Betoptic Alcon, United States 6.99 4 0.06 0.24
0.25%
Levobunolol hydrochloride Betagan Allergan, United States 6.76 4 0.06 0.25
0.5%
D-timolol maleate 1% Dilijian Yongguang, China 11.30 4 0.09 0.36
Carbonic Brinzolamide 1% Azopt Alcon, United States 12.00 4 0.09 0.34
anhydrase
inhibitor
Prostaglandins Bimatoprost 0.03% Lumigan Allergan, United States 23.89 2 0.23 0.46
a-adrenergic Brimonidine 0.2% Alphagan Allergan, United States 11.61 6 0.10 0.61
agonist
Prostaglandins Travoprost 0.004% Travatan Alcon, United States 35.95 2 0.38 0.77
Latanoprost 0.005% Xalatan Pfizer, United States 40.78 2 0.45 0.91
*1 US dollar = 8.2889 Yuan.

latanoprost ($1.25/d), which cost 3 times as much as the drop will have a reduced volume. In this study, we held
cheapest one, timolol ($0.38/d).6 In Japan, the daily cost the bottles as vertically as possible and squeezed the
of latanoprost and timolol were almost the same ($0.44/ bottles as gently as possible, but there is still variation
d).7 However, in China, the most expensive medication, of number of drops of the same medication between
latanoprost ($0.91/d), cost 33 times as much as the different researchers.
cheapest one, timolol ($0.03/d). Comparing with devel- In 1970s, patients were often started on a topical
oped countries, the cost of glaucoma medications range b-blocker, but the contraindications such as asthma,
much more wildly in China. chronic obstructive pulmonary disease limited its applica-
Although the standard market price in China for tion in some. Since later 1990s, some newer glaucoma
each medication is regulated by national agency, the price medications such as prostaglandins, topical carbonic
of medications may change. However, the results of this anhydrase inhibitor, and a2-adrenergic agonist had been
study, more specifically, the average number of drops per brought into use. Some of them have been commercially
bottle or average number of days for usage per bottle may available in China by now, but some medications such as
be useful to recalculate an updated daily cost when the Trusopt, Cosopt, Combigan, and Xalcom are still not
price changes. This study is based on a best-case scenario available. The true costs of some newer medications may
for all medicines and does not account for wasted doses, be further decreased by improved compliance, the need
the frequency of refills, or a medication’s success or for fewer medications to control intraocular pressure,
failure rate. In this study, all of the domestic generic fewer patient interventions (such as office calls, surgeries,
glaucoma medications and most of the imported eye lasers), and an improved side-effect profile. However,
drops except latanoprost, travoprost, and bimatoprost with all the factors above considered, some of the newer
are under filled compared with the label claim. It may medications may be still too expensive in China,
partly result from the volatilization loss or inaccuracy of especially in the rural area. Take prostaglandins for
measurement. The table of number of drops (Table 1) example, the average cost of prostaglandins was $0.71/d.
showed the range found across the 5 bottles. The manner According to the data from the Nation Bureau of
in which we dispense the drops influences the size of the Statistics of China,13 in 2004, the average income per
drops.12 Holding the dropper bottle vertically can help person was $0.97/d in rural and $3.11/d in urban. The
minimize drop size. Squeezing the bottle gently and average cost on food per person was $0.34/d in rural and
slowly induces a low drop formation rate, ensuring that $0.90/d in urban. And the average cost on housing per
only 1 drop of the medication will be formed, and that person was $0.11/d in rural and $0.24/d in urban. And

596 r 2007 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins


J Glaucoma  Volume 16, Number 7, October/November 2007 Daily Cost of Glaucoma Medications

the costs of surgeries are also quite expensive. The cost of 5. Steven DV, William LR, John J. Cost Analysis of glaucoma
laser trabeculoplasty was $36.19 to $72.39. The cost of medications: a 3-year review. J Glaucoma. 2002;11:354–358.
filtration surgery was $72.39. There is basic medical 6. Fiscella R, Geller JL, Gryz LL, et al. Costs considerations of
medical therapy for glaucoma. Am J Ophthalmol. 1999;128:426–433.
insurance for most of the citizens in China, which means 7. Hiroaki I, Eiji S, Teruaki K, et al. Daily cost of ophthalmic solutions
the government will pay 80% of the further medical cost for treating glaucoma in Japan. Jpn J Ophthalmol. 2001;45:99–102.
for a patient when he/her has paid $241 by himself/ 8. Calissendorff BM. Consumption of glaucoma medication. Acta
herself. However, there is no basic medical insurance for Ophthalmol Scand. 2001;79:2–5.
most people in the rural area and some people in the city. 9. Mick AB, Gonzalez S, Dunbar MT, et al. A cost analysis of the
prostaglandins analogs. Optometry. 2002;73:614–619.
Furthermore, in most cities of China, basic medical 10. Stewart WC, Hudgins AC, Pruitt CA, et al. Daily cost of newer
insurance system does not cover the newer medications of glaucoma agents. J Ocul Pharmacol Ther. 1999;15:379–388.
glaucoma, such as prostaglandins and topical carbonic 11. Stewart WC, Sine C, Cate E, et al. Daily cost of beta-adrenergic
anhydrase inhibitor. In some parts of China, especially in blocker therapy. Arch Ophthalmol. 1997;115:853–856.
the rural area, traditional treatments such as acupuncture 12. Luc VS, Annick L. Determinants of eye drop size. Surv Ophthalmol.
2004;49:197–214.
are still regarded as a costless therapy of glaucoma,14 but 13. Nation Bureau of Statistics of China. China Statistical Yearbook
the effectiveness remains to be verified. And there are 2005. Beijing: Nation Bureau of Statistics of China; 2005.
some parts of rural area, to which even the treatments 14. Xuejing LU, Aiqin LIU, Liao P. A review of literature on present
with the lowest daily cost are not accessible. Nowadays, situation of glaucoma for research and treatment with acupuncture.
prostaglandins have become a first-line therapeutic option Chin Tradit Ophthalmol. 2003;13:119–121.
15. Bernard LM, Althin R, Dhawan R, et al. Clinical and economic
in developed countries because of its effective intraocular impacts of latanoprost 0.005% in first-line treatment of open-angle
pressure-lowering ability, minimal risk of systemic side glaucoma and ocular hypertension in France. Eur J Ophthalmol.
effects, and once-daily administration.15–20 But in China 2003;4:S30–S43.
the daily cost is still a main factor to be considered when 16. Perry CM, McGavin JK, Culy CR, et al. Latanoprost: an update of
choosing a medication for a patient with glaucoma. its use in glaucoma and ocular hypertension. Drugs Aging. 2003;20:
597–630.
Further researches will be conducted to study the cost 17. Costagliola C, Parmeggiani F, Sebastiani A. Assessing the cost-
effectiveness of different glaucoma medications in China. effectiveness of switching from a beta-blocker to latanoprost in the
treatment of ocular hypertension. Expert Opin Pharmacol Ther.
REFERENCES 2003;4:1775–1788.
1. Tsai JC, McClure CA, Ramos SE, et al. Compliance barriers in 18. Stewart WC, Leech J, Sharpe ED, et al. An economic analysis of
glaucoma: a systematic classification. J Glaucoma. 2003;12:393–398. switching to latanoprost from a beta-blocker or adding brimonidine
2. Taylor SA, Galbraith SM, Mills RP. Causes of non-compliance with or latanoprost to a beta-blocker in open-angle glaucoma or ocular
drug regimens in glaucoma patients: a qualitative study. J Ocul hypertension. Am J Manag Care. 2002;8(suppl 10):S240–S248.
Pharmacol Ther. 2002;18:401–409. 19. Baudouin C, Rouland JF, Le Pen C. Changes in medical and
3. Wang N. Issues and strategies of glaucoma prevention and surgical treatments of glaucoma between 1997 and 2000 in France.
treatment in nowadays. Chin J Ophthalmol. 2002;138:705–707. Eur J Ophthalmol. 2003;13(suppl 4):S53–S60.
4. Fiscella RG, Green A, Patuszynski DH, et al. Medical therapy cost 20. Schwartz K, Budenz D. Current management of glaucoma. Curr
considerations for glaucoma. Am J Ophthalmol. 2003;136:18–25. Opin Ophthalmol. 2004;15:119–126.

r 2007 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins 597

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen