Study: Resistance Exercise May Protect

Bones in Overweight Elderly Adults

What is the best form of exercise for older adults who are dieting?

Doctors do not yet know the answer. But one study suggests that elderly dieters may be able to
protect against bone thinning by doing resistance exercise.

Obesity, BMI, and bone loss

Medical experts often use body mass index, or BMI, to measure obesity – the condition of being
very overweight. BMI compares a person’s height and weight. A BMI of around 30 or higher is
considered obese.

Worldwide the number of obese people has nearly tripled since 1975, notes the World Health
Organization.

Obesity problems among older adults are difficult to deal with. This is because weight loss efforts
can create health problems, such as an increased risk of bone thinning. Thin bones are more likely
to fracture, the study team noted. Their findings appeared in The Journal of Bone and Mineral
Research.

For the study, researchers randomly put 141 obese adults into one of four groups. The first group
had dieters who did only aerobic exercise. The second group had dieters who only did resistance
exercise. The third had dieters who did both forms of exercise. The final group, the control group,
did not exercise or change their diet.

The subjects met with dieticians and did supervised workouts over 26 weeks.

The control group went to some classes to educate them about healthy eating.

All of the subjects in the study had a BMI of 30 or greater. The average age was 70 years old.

In the exercise groups, subjects were given custom diets that created a deficit of about 500 to 750
calories a day. They also did supervised one-hour workouts three times a week.
The aerobic exercises included walking on an exercise machine, riding a stationary bicycle, and
stair climbing.

Resistance exercises included upper- and lower- body exercises using weight machines.

All of the exercisers also did some activities designed to improve balance and flexibility.

People in all three diet groups lost about 9% of their body weight during the study. Members of
the control group lost about 1% of their body weight.

At the end of the study, all of the participants had a decrease in bone density. But bone density
decreased less in the older adults who did resistance exercise. Bone density also decreased less in
those who did resistance exercise and aerobic workouts.

Doctor Dennis Villareal was the lead writer of a report on the study.

“When undergoing weight loss therapy,” he said, elderly patients should use “some resistance
exercise to protect against bone loss.”

“Resistance exercise should be at least moderate in intensity,” Villareal added in an email. “We
do not know if less-intense exercise would be effective in protecting against bone loss during
weight loss.”

Villareal is with the Baylor College of Medicine and the Michael E. DeBakey VA Medical Center
in Houston, Texas.

Limitations and recommendations

One limitation of the study is that researchers only followed the subjects for about six months.

That length of time is too brief to confirm whether one type of exercise might be better than another
for fall or bone fracture prevention, the report said.

Cynthia Brown is a doctor with the Integrative Center for Aging Research at the University of
Alabama at Birmingham.

“Based on this study, one would conclude that (for) an older adult who is obese and trying to lose
weight, the combination of aerobic and resistance exercise will help the most to maintain their
bone mineral density and their general physical fitness,” she said by email. “Older adults who are
able should do muscle-strengthening exercises (resistance exercise) at least twice a week.”

Brown was not involved in the study.

She also suggested that older adults with health issues “make sure they understand how these
conditions affect their ability to exercise.”

She added that “all older adults should be as physically active as their abilities and conditions
allow.”

I'm John Russell.