Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
www.elsevier.com/locate/jhydrol
Abstract
Increases in groundwater salinity down gradient are a common occurrence in catchments throughout Australia,
exacerbating the effects of dryland salinisation in discharge areas. Groundwater hydrochemical and isotopic data from the
Willaura catchment in south-eastern Australia, which is affected by both primary (natural) and secondary (human-induced)
salinity, allowed the factors that cause the down gradient trend in salinisation within this catchment to be determined. The
overall salinity of the groundwater (0.8–70 mS/cm) is controlled by evapotranspiration, which concentrates cyclic salts in
the unsaturated zone, greatly increasing the salinity of the soil–water to 3700–6400 mg/L ClK. The progressive addition of
this saline soil–water to fresher groundwaters recharged on the catchment margins causes a gradual increase in salinity
down gradient. The groundwater stable isotope compositions show that most recharge occurs in winter and spring.
Groundwater salinities increase around the saline lakes of the discharge zone, due to direct evaporation from shallow
watertables and minor dissolution of halite (as indicated by ClK/BrK ratios). Mineral–water interactions within the aquifers
cause a slight overall reduction in salinity; conversion of kaolinite to smectite and illite, and cation exchange of NaC for
Ca2C on smectites, cause NaC/ClK, Mg2C/ClK, KC/ClK, Si/ClK and HCOK 3 /Cl
K
ratios to progressively decline and pH
to gradually increase down gradient. Oxidation of organic matter causes a strong decrease in the redox potential of the
groundwaters down gradient. The groundwater ages increase from modern (containing tritium) on the catchment margins to
w8000 years (based on 14C dating) at the end of the w25 km flow path. The older groundwaters are isotopically heavier
than the younger waters, probably due to recharge during a wetter climate in the early Holocene. The groundwater ages
show clearly that the progressive addition of saline soil–water, causing groundwaters to become more saline down gradient,
* Corresponding author. Tel.: C61 3 9690 0522; fax: C61 3 9690 0585.
E-mail addresses: darren.bennetts@pjra.com.au (D.A. Bennetts), john.webb@latrobe.edu.au (J.A. Webb), dms@ansto.gov.au (D.J.M.
Stone), dmh@ansto.gov.au (D.M. Hill).
1
Fax: C61 3 9479 1272.
2
Fax: C61 2 9717 9260.
3
Fax: C61 2 9717 9286.
0022-1694/$ - see front matter q 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.jhydrol.2005.08.023
D.A. Bennetts et al. / Journal of Hydrology 323 (2006) 178–192 179
has occurred throughout the Holocene and may explain the occurrence of primary salinisation within many Australian
catchments.
q 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
agricultural grassland, except for small areas of September; the peak period of winter rainfall is June
remnant native forest in the northwest along the to September, when groundwater recharge is most
slopes of the Grampians Ranges (Mann and Nolan, likely to occur. Pan evaporation from the nearest
1989). Currently the area is cropped for wheat, oats weather station at Hamilton, w40 km southwest of
and canola, and used for sheep grazing. the study area, is highest from December to February
and averages 1350 mm annually (data from Bureau of
2.3. Climate Meteorology, Australia). Average temperatures are
26–28 8C in summer and 4–12 8C in winter, and
Rainfall over the catchment decreases from west to humidity (at 3 pm) averages 56% (data from Bureau
east, from over 1000 mm in the Grampians Ranges to of Meteorology, Australia).
613 (G135 SD) mm at Yarram Park in the centre of the
catchment and 545 (G105 SD) mm at Willaura in the 2.4. History of salinisation
east (data from Bureau of Meteorology, Australia).
Maximum rainfall is received over winter, and Natural (primary) salinity has long been a
exceeds or equals evaporation from May to prominent feature of the landscape in the Willaura
D.A. Bennetts et al. / Journal of Hydrology 323 (2006) 178–192 181
catchment, and was first documented by Major sediments are variably consolidated with moderate
Mitchell in 1836: “I was somewhat surprised to find intergranular porosity, and are dominantly composed
after encamping, that the water in the adjacent lakes of clay, silt and sand on the central plain, and clay,
[Cockajemmy Lakes] was extremely salty” (Mitchell, sand and cobbles on the flanks of the range (Stuart-
1839). However, the Willaura catchment has suffered Smith and Black, 1999; Buckland, 1986). Their age is
an increase in salinisation since broad-scale landuse thought to span from the Eocene to the Quaternary
change (i.e. clearing). This secondary salinisation has (Mann et al., 1992; Stanley, 1983). The older Tertiary
occurred through rising watertables and increased sediments are strongly ferruginised, and are covered
groundwater discharge, resulting in higher lake levels, by a thin veneer of Quaternary alluvium, except where
particularly in the Cockajemmy Lakes, increased they underlie the basalt aquifer in the south of the
salinity in pre-existing saline lakes and the emergence catchment. Duplex clay soils are developed on surface
of new saline scalds in topographic lows and drainage exposures of the alluvium (Sibley, 1967).
lines (Mann and Nolan, 1989). The third aquifer comprises Plio-Pleistocene basalts
of the Newer Volcanics, which cover most of the
eastern part of the catchment, overlying the alluvial and
3. Geology and hydrogeology Palaeozoic basement aquifers, with an average thick-
ness of 30–40 m (Cayley and Taylor, 1997). A
Three major aquifers are present in the Willaura restricted palaeovalley intersected in borehole 327
area. Cambrian greenstones and turbidites (Mt (Fig. 1) contains basalts 64 m thick, representing at
Stavely Volcanic Complex and Nargoon Group least three different flows separated by palaeosols up to
respectively; VandenBerg et al., 2000) and Silurian 7 m in thickness. Soils on the basalts are typically clay-
sandstones (Grampians Group; Cayley and Taylor, rich duplex profiles, similar to those on the alluvium,
1997) together form a major regional aquifer (referred with a bleached yellow B-horizon (Sibley, 1967).
to here as the Palaeozoic basement aquifer) beneath Groundwater flow, based on potentiometric data
the study area. The greenstones are largely andesitic– from the present study and Williams (1997), is from
dacitic lavas, tuffs and volcaniclastic sandstones the catchment margins to the north and north-west
(Buckland, 1986); the Nargoon Group comprises (predominantly the Grampians Ranges) towards the
sandstone with minor siltstone and calcareous south-east, ultimately terminating in saline springs
mudstone, whilst the Grampians Group contains (Gellerts Seep, Johns Seep and Boggy Creek spring)
quartzose and feldspathic sandstone with minor on the margins of the Cockajemmy Lakes, about
conglomerate (Cayley and Taylor, 1997). The 25 km from the dominant recharge areas. Ground-
Palaeozoic basement is fracture-dominated, posses- water also flows northwards into these lakes from the
sing almost no primary porosity. It is typically Stavely Range, although this is relatively minor and
confined, except for outcrops in the Grampians not discussed further.
Ranges, Mt Moornambool and Stavely Range
(Fig. 1). Soils developed on the basement exposures
are generally sandy and permeable, particularly on the 4. Methods
Silurian sandstones of the Grampians Ranges, and
often overlie deep weathering profiles (Camilleri, Sixty-nine groundwater observation boreholes and
1999). surface waters were sampled three times for EC, pH,
The second major aquifer comprises colluvium on redox and temperature measurements over an 18-
the flanks of the Grampians Ranges and alluvial month period (May 2000–June 2001). Thirty-eight
sediments in the centre of the catchment (grouped boreholes and five surface water sites were also
together here as the alluvial aquifer). This aquifer is sampled for major element analysis; samples were
typically unconfined, except where overlain by Plio- filtered through 0.45 mm filter paper and stored at !
Pleistocene basalt (Fig. 1), and directly underlies most 4 8C. Alkalinity was determined by standard titration
of the lakes of the catchment; alluvium is up to 30 m with HCl, with further anions being analysed by
thick beneath the Cockajemmy Lakes. These HPLC at CSIRO, Clayton. Cations were determined
182 D.A. Bennetts et al. / Journal of Hydrology 323 (2006) 178–192
0.008
0.008
0.001
0.002
NOK3/
ClK
1.143
0.037
0.050
0.039
0.049
ClK
0.14
0.50
0.10
0.10
0.16
0.11
ClK
0.0017
0.0024
0.0017
0.0017
collected in cleaned (HNO3) glass bottles at ANSTO,
Si/Cl
0.019
0.047
0.105
0.009
0.015
0.016
0.009
0.066
0.094
0.171
0.070
0.074
0.078
0.070
ClK
0.021
0.141
0.339
0.036
0.058
0.048
0.040
ClK
0.55
0.65
0.79
0.40
0.40
0.52
0.41
ClK
7.5
7.2
7.4
pH
23
16
27
24
-
-
80% of TDS), and salinity (as EC) and ClK are very
strongly correlated (r2Z0.98). Mg2C and SO2K 4 are
NOK
3
40
38
9
3 ; Si
HCOK
3
208
334
220
244
2.5
2.4
465
257
974
729
0.8
-
6039
3067
5610
5870
ClK
4.3
1.4
8
7
8
-
0.2
0.2
49
54
70
54
1290
226
488
410
0.4
0.3
(Vaught, 1980).
Cavendish, VIC (Hutton and Leslie, 1958).
Ca2C
223
207
272
248
0.6
0.8
1134
2877
2289
NaC
2.8
1.3
17.3
12.7
14.4
13.2
Drever (1997).
–
Palaeozoic
Seawatera
Australiac
Table 1
basement
Alluviul
14
Rainfall
(nZ51)
(nZ12)
(nZ18)
Median
Overall
aquifer
nZ35)
(bores;
c
b
than the Cambrian and Silurian marine sediments soils. Infiltration through these soils is typically
within the study area, indicating that any connate slow, and strong evapotranspiration forms an inter-
water would have long been removed. ClK/BrK ratios mediate reservoir of saline soil–water in the unsatu-
(Table 1) approximate those in modern precipitation, rated zone. Median soil–water ClK contents measured
consistent with a cyclic origin for these ions (Davis below the root zone across the central plain range
et al., 1998); the lowest ratios occur in groundwaters between 3700 and 6400 mg/L. High salinity soil–
near the saline Cockajemmy Lakes, indicating a water occurs near the root zone in many Australian
minor influence from dissolution of halite in the catchments, and the link between saline soil–water
lakebeds. and high rates of transpiration is well established (e.g.
Leaney et al., 2003; Mazor and George, 1992; Turner
et al., 1987).
5.2. Salinity increase down gradient Groundwaters in the alluvial aquifer and the upper
layers of the basalt display concordant down gradient
Groundwater salinity increases down gradient in increases in salinity (the latter aquifer is mainly
all three aquifers in the study area (Fig. 2). Because recharged by lateral flow from the adjacent alluvium).
salinity and ClK concentration are very strongly This progressive salinisation of both aquifers is due to
correlated, and ClK is chemically inert and not mixing between low salinity soil–waters recharged on
involved in chemical reactions in the aquifer, the the catchment margins and high salinity soil–waters
down gradient increase in salinity is not due to of the central plain (Fig. 2). All groundwater samples,
mineral–water interactions within the aquifers. except those immediately surrounding the saline
In the Palaeozoic basement and alluvial aquifers, Cockajemmy Lakes (discussed below), plot on a
recharge predominantly occurs through the slopes mixing line between these two end-members (r2Z
along the catchment margins (in particular the 0.47). As groundwater flows through the alluvial and
Grampians Ranges), where groundwaters are freshest upper basalt aquifers, it accumulates saline water
(minimum 0.8 mS/cm). The soils are typically thin infiltrating downwards from the soils above. Hence,
and sandy, allowing rapid recharge and thereby the increasing groundwater salinities within the basalt
limiting the degree to which infiltrating water is and alluvial aquifers are limited by the maximum
concentrated by evapotranspiration. However, across salinity of the soil–water, and so cannot exceed
the central plain, surface recharge to the alluvial and 6400 mg/L ClK (w17 mS/cm; Fig. 2) unless affected
basalt aquifers occurs diffusely through clay-rich by another process (e.g. evaporation).
60
Groundwaters up gradient of salt lakes
Groundwaters down gradient of salt lakes
50
40
EC (mS/cm)
10
EC = 0.56 x distance + 3.6
0
0 5 10 15 20 25
Distance down gradient (km)
Fig. 2. Salinity (EC) evolution down gradient. Distances down gradient are measured from recharge area to borehole location perpendicular to
potentiometric surface contours from Williams (1997).
184 D.A. Bennetts et al. / Journal of Hydrology 323 (2006) 178–192
Groundwaters in the underlying Palaeozoic base- saline groundwater intrusions have been identified
ment aquifer are typically fresher than those in the (Price, 1994). The increasing salinisation of the
overlying alluvium and basalts, e.g. half as saline at Cockajemmy Lakes may therefore be partly responsible
the nested boreholes 70920/70921 (Fig. 1), and display for the currently rising salinity of the Hopkins River
a more subtle increase in salinity down gradient. (0.0735 mS/cm/year; Smith and Nathan, 1999).
Fresh groundwater, recharged through outcrops on the Down gradient increases in groundwater salinity
catchment margins, particularly in the Grampians similar to those at Willaura occur in a variety of
Ranges, mixes down gradient with saline groundwaters groundwater systems within Australia (e.g. Arad and
leaking from the overlying basalt and alluvial aquifers. Evans, 1987; Macumber, 1991; Salama et al., 1993b).
Groundwaters from the deepest, valley-filling part Similar examples have also been recorded from USA,
of the basalt (borehole 327) are substantially fresher Sudan, Canada (Salama et al., 1999), England (Elliot
and much older (w8000 years; see later discussion) et al., 1999), Tunisia and Algeria (Edmunds et al.,
than shallow groundwater in the basalt aquifer. Clay- 2003), where a combination of evaporation in
rich palaeosols within the basalt sequence probably act discharge zones and connate salt dissolution explains
as semipermeable aquitards separating the deep and the down gradient salinity increases. In Australia
shallow groundwater. The deeper parts of the basalt considerable salt concentration by direct evaporation
aquifer within the palaeovalley are recharged by lateral may occur in discharge zones (Jenkin and Dyson,
flow of relatively fresh groundwater from the surround- 1983; Cartwright et al., 2004), but connate salt and
ing Palaeozoic basement, and therefore form part of the evaporites are not important, because cyclic salts are
basement regional groundwater flow system. the dominant salt source, with minor influence from
Groundwaters located adjacent to the saline Cock- water-rock interaction (e.g. Cartwright et al., 2004).
ajemmy Lakes, at the end of the groundwater flow path Rather most Australian studies have suggested that
in the Willaura catchment (Fig. 1), have salinities of 18– increased groundwater salinity is due to clearing of
70 mS/cm, greater than expected from progressive native forests, resulting in enhanced recharge, which
additions of saline soil–water (Fig. 2), indicating there either leaches salt downward from salt stores in the
are other processes active here. Watertables in this area unsaturated zone (e.g. Arad and Evans, 1987; Jenkin
are relatively close to the surface (generally !2 m; and Dyson, 1983; Leaney et al., 2003) or causes the
Williams, 1997) so that direct evaporation of the watertable to rise, dissolving salt within the soil as it
groundwater can occur, resulting in very high soil– does so (Macumber, 1991). In addition, differing
water ClK concentrations (17,000–25,000 mg/L ClK; palaeo-recharge rates may influence the down
w50–70 mS/cm). In addition, the waters of Cock- gradient trend (Herczeg et al., 2001), and Love et al.
ajemmy Lakes are very saline (up to 645 mS/cm) and (1994) suggested that this could cause salinity to rise
have enriched d18O and d2H signatures (see later from 500 to 3000 mg/L along a w50 km flow path.
discussion) as a result of direct evaporation. Most None of the above reasons put forward for studies
evaporation of lake waters occurs over summer, forming elsewhere in Australia and other places can com-
dense plumes of saline groundwater that sink into the pletely explain the groundwater salinity trends at
directly underlying alluvial aquifer. Thus groundwater Willaura. Adjacent to the groundwater discharge zone
in borehole 74021, which lies down gradient of the very of the saline Cockajemmy Lakes, evaporation and
saline Gellerts Lake (Fig. 1), increased in salinity from leaching of soil salt by rising watertables are
23 mS/cm in April 2001 to 70 mS/cm in June 2001, as undoubtedly increasing the groundwater salinity, but
the lake water evaporated in summer made its way these processes cannot influence deeper groundwaters
through the aquifer; similar processes have been throughout the remainder of the catchment. Further-
identified at numerous salt lakes throughout southern more, the down gradient increase in salinity occurs in
Australia (e.g. Jones et al., 1994; Macumber, 1992; waters thousands of years old (see later discussion),
Rosen et al., 1996; Simmons and Narayan, 1998; Swane whereas enhanced recharge due to clearing of native
et al., 2001). The groundwater hydraulic gradient around forests has maximum direct influence on only the
Cockajemmy Lakes indicates that the highly saline youngest groundwaters. Changing palaeo-recharge
waters then move east toward the Hopkins River, where rates may have had an impact on Willaura
D.A. Bennetts et al. / Journal of Hydrology 323 (2006) 178–192 185
groundwater, but the effects are small compared to the 5.3.1. Silicate mineral weathering
salinity increases observed (Fig. 2). In contrast, the Weathering of pyroxene, plagioclase and olivine in
explanation proposed here, i.e. that as groundwater the basalt aquifer elevates groundwater HCOK 3 /Cl ,
K
2C
flows down gradient it receives a cumulatively greater Ca /Cl and Si/Cl ratios above those in ground-
K K
input of saline water infiltrating from the soil above, waters within the basement and alluvial aquifers
accounts for the development of down gradient (Table 1). Mg2C/ClK and NaC/ClK ratios in the
increases in salinity prior to land-use change (primary basalt groundwaters should also be increased by these
salinity) in unconfined aquifers, and leakage from weathering reactions, but are not dissimilar to those in
unconfined into underlying confined aquifers can groundwater in the other aquifers (Table 1),
impose the same salinity increase on the deeper suggesting that Mg2C and NaC are being removed
groundwater. The fact that down gradient primary (see below). The Palaeozoic basement and alluvial
salinisation has been identified in many confined and aquifers contain few reactive silicate minerals
unconfined aquifers throughout Australia suggests (Cayley and Taylor, 1997), apart from the andesitic–
that this mechanism probably applies (in combination dacitic greenstones within the basement, which have a
with secondary processes like evaporation) to other limited influence because they are uncommon and
Australian catchments. relatively impermeable.
Analcite 18
11
Albite Laumontite
10 16
Calcite
9 14
pCO 2 =10-3.5
loga(Ca2+/H+) 2
8 12
log a (Na+/H+ )
Quartz
Quartz
2 2
Pyrophyllite
-6 -5 -4 -3 -2 -6 -5 -4 -3 -2
loga(H4SiO4) loga(H4SiO4)
14
Illite 6
13 K-feldspar
12 5
loga (Ca2+/H+) 2
log a (K+/H+ )
Ca-smectite 11 4
10
Gibbsite 3
9
Na-smectite 8 2
7
Quartz
Kaolinite Kaolinite 1
6
Pyrophyllite
Fig. 3. Willaura groundwater compositions plotted on mineral diagrams for the Na2O–Al2O3–SiO2–H2O system, CaO–Al2O3–SiO2–H2O
system and K2O–Al2O3–SiO2–H2O system, all at 25 8C and 1 atm (after Drever, 1997).
(r2Z0.6 for pH versus distance down gradient). Cation (Jankowski and Acworth, 1993). Calcite dissolution
exchange on the smectites is most likely responsible, is not involved, since there is no calcite known in the
whereby Ca2C is replaced by NaC and HC, producing aquifers, and groundwater d13C values are indicative of
the observed gain in Ca2C, loss of NaC and increase in biogenic rather than calcitic carbon (see later
pH down gradient. The removal of HC by this reaction discussion).
is greater than the production of HC during the
conversion of kaolinite to smectite, so NaC/Ca2C 5.3.3. Organic matter oxidation
exchange on smectites controls the Willaura ground- The redox potential decreases down gradient,
water pH. This process has also been recorded particularly in the alluvial aquifer (r2Z0.47 for Eh
influencing saline groundwaters in northern Victoria versus distance down gradient), from 121 to 218 mV
(Arad and Evans, 1987) and New South Wales in the northwest recharge areas to K138 mV at
D.A. Bennetts et al. / Journal of Hydrology 323 (2006) 178–192 187
and their increase down gradient. The decrease in redox during this study (w8000 years; Table 2). Many
potential down gradient may also be partly due to pyrite springs are discharging older groundwater and also
oxidation. Nevertheless, the groundwater SO2K 4 /Cl
K have heavier d18O compositions (discussed further
mass ratios at Willaura (median 0.12) are substantially below). The climate of the study area w8000 years
less than in aquifers where pyrite oxidation is a major BP, as indicated by palynological data from Lake
influence (e.g. 0.35; Jankowski and Acworth, 1993). Bolac, w20 km southeast of Willaura, was warmer
Furthermore, this reaction releases acidity, yet the pH and wetter than at present (Crowley and Kershaw,
rises down gradient. 1994), consistent with similar palaeo-climate studies
from south-eastern Australia (e.g. D’Costa et al.,
1989; Wasson and Donnelly, 1991). Rainfall was
6. Stable isotope evolution of Willaura subsequently more enriched at this time, as indicated
groundwater by speleothems in western Tasmania (Goede and
Hitchman, 1984), where rainfall patterns are similar to
The d18O and d2H compositions of Willaura those of the study area. Thus, the isotopically heavier
groundwater samples plot close to the meteoric signature of the w8000 year old groundwater may be
water line (MWL) for Adelaide (nearest IAEA/WMO linked to the atmospheric circulation at the time;
meteorological station, 450 km west of Willaura; variations in the stable isotope composition of
Fig. 4), indicating that the groundwaters are of groundwater frequently reflect climatic changes (e.g.
meteoric origin and not significantly affected by Rozanski, 1985; Vaikmae et al., 2001).
open water or unsaturated zone evaporation (Allison The enriched d18O and d2H signature of the w8000
et al., 1984; Drever, 1997). Most groundwaters have a year old groundwaters at Willaura has not previously
very similar composition to the average winter rainfall been observed in groundwaters in south-eastern
at Adelaide (K5.1‰, K27.9‰), suggesting that the Australia. This is possibly due to the shorter flow
majority of recharge in the Willaura catchment occurs times at Willaura (w8000 years), as compared with
188 D.A. Bennetts et al. / Journal of Hydrology 323 (2006) 178–192
Table 2
Groundwater ages from tritium and 14C (G1s error) determinations, and d18O and d2H data. 14C ages are determined using half-life of 5730
years (Stuiver and Polach, 1977). ANSTO analysis codes are QZF368 to QZF370. Tritium age determinations are qualitatively determined
using the method of Clark and Fritz (1997) and comparison with rainfall analysis from Adelaide (IAEA/WMO, 2001).
Sample name Date Tritium (TU) PMC d13C (‰) Apparent age d18O (‰) d2H (‰)
(years)
244 03-May-00 K4.7 K26.8
244 21-Dec-00 !0.3 O50 K4.5 K28.0
244 04-Jun-01 !0.3 O50 K4.2 K28.0
244 04-Jun-01 61.4 K14.05 4032 K4.2 K28.0
324 04-May-00 K6.4 K39.0
324 21-Dec-00 2.1 8–10 K5.4 K36.0
324 04-Jun-01 K5.0 K28.0
325 20-Dec-00 !0.3 O50
327 03-May-00 K3.4 K16.9
327 20-Dec-00 !0.3 O50 K3.5 K15.0
327 04-Jun-01 38.06 K12.96 7986
328 03-May-00 K5.2 K31.6
328 20-Dec-00 K4.2 K25.0
328 04-Jun-01 K4.2 K31.0
5019 03-May-00 K4.9 K30.2
5019 20-Dec-00 K5.6 K32.0
5019 04-Jun-01 K4.4 K28.0
5020 04-Jun-01 K4.9 K35.0
5201 04-Jun-01 0.56 O50
87755 04-Jun-01 !0.3 O50
Boggy Creek 03-May-00 K3.1 K14.3
Boggy Creek 21-Dec-00 0.6 30K35 K3.5 K16.0
Boggy Creek 04-Jun-01 4.0 !5 K2.9 K22.0
Gellerts Seep 03-May-00 K2.6 K11.5
Gellerts Seep 21-Dec-00 !0.3 O50 K2.9 K19.0
Gellerts Seep 04-Jun-01 72.63 K9.67 2640 K3.7 K25.0
Johns Seep 04-May-00 K3.7 K18.4
Johns Seep 23-Dec-00 0.6 30K35 K3.0 K13.0
Johns Seep 04-Jun-01 K2.1 K17.0
Gellerts Lake 04-Jun-01 3.0 7.0
Gellerts Lake 21-Dec-00 K2.1 K7.0
Lake Muirhead 04-May-00 K3.5 K17.9
most other groundwater flow systems in south-eastern IAEA/WMO, 2001) is homogenised less than if the
Australia subject to palaeoclimatic investigations (e.g. groundwaters were recharged slowly through low-
Love et al., 1994; Cartwright and Weaver, 2004). permeability soils. Further down gradient the isotopic
The d18O and d2H composition of Willaura signatures show less than 1‰ d18O variability at
groundwaters for some bores show significant inter- individual sites, due to increasing residence times of
annual variation over the sampling period (May diffuse recharge moving through the unsaturated
2000–June 2001), given that most recharge occurs zone, such that differences in rainfall isotopic
consistently in winter and early spring. Borehole 324, composition are homogenised. Borehole 327 in the
on the slopes of the Grampians Ranges (Fig. 1), shows deepest, valley-filling part of the basalt shows no
the largest difference (1.4‰ d18O), because ground- variation, expected given its depth and position down
water is recharged rapidly through the thin permeable gradient (Fig. 1).
soils so that the variability in rainfall isotopic The lake waters and some spring samples at
composition (up to 14‰ d18O at Adelaide; Willaura are strongly affected by evaporation, in
D.A. Bennetts et al. / Journal of Hydrology 323 (2006) 178–192 189
contrast to the groundwaters, which show no years (Table 2). Further down gradient, no tritiated
evaporative influence. The stable isotope compo- borehole water is found in the deeper boreholes
sitions of the evaporated samples are displaced from (O10 m), indicating ages greater than 50 years.
the MWL along a line with a slope of 4.8 (Fig. 4), The addition of diffuse saline recharge down gradient,
typical of evaporation at moderate humidity infiltrating from the soil above and causing ground-
(Gonfiantini, 1986), such as at Willaura (mean 56% waters to become progressively more saline, may add
humidity; data from Bureau of Meteorology, tritiated water to shallow groundwater in the basalt
Australia). The evaporation line intersects the MWL and alluvial aquifers, but there are no shallow
at the average winter rainfall composition, so the boreholes down gradient to verify this. However,
dominant source of these springs and lakes is modern Boggy Creek spring in December 2000 contained
precipitation, consistent with the tritium content of 0.6 TU (Table 2), consistent with a mixture of modern
many spring samples (Table 2; see later discussion). tritiated basalt or alluvial groundwater and older non-
The stable isotope compositions of the lake waters tritiated Palaeozoic basement groundwater. In June
show a large amount of seasonal variation (up to 5‰ 2001, Boggy Creek spring contained 4.0 TU, repre-
d18O), due to increased evaporation over summer. senting modern recharge with no addition of older
Those spring waters not affected by open water groundwater, so spring flow at this time was
evaporation plot on the MWL (Fig. 4), but are heavier dominated by recent rainfall (w260 mm in the three
than most groundwaters, and cluster around the months preceding sampling; data from Bureau of
composition of bore 327. These springs (Boggy Meteorology, 2004).
Creek, Gellerts Seep and Johns Seep) lie at the end Two deep groundwater samples in the basalt and
of the groundwater flow path and feed the Cock- basement aquifers were dated using 14C (boreholes
ajemmy Lakes, and are discharging old, isotopically 327 and 244, respectively; Table 2). Contamination
heavy groundwaters (as described above for bore by modern carbon is unlikely; the samples contain no
327). Mixed with the older groundwater is modern detectable tritium (Table 2), and came from so deep in
rainfall and/or modern groundwaters, as shown by the the aquifers that they were not affected by leakage of
tritium content of some spring waters (see below). young water recharged down gradient. Any addition
of dead carbon was probably minor; the basalt and
basement aquifers contain little or no organic matter
7. Groundwater dating or calcite, and although the overlying alluvial aquifer
does contain carbonaceous material, leakage into the
Of the 11 samples analysed for tritium to determine deeper aquifers is minor, given the substantial
groundwater age, six have tritium counts below differences in groundwater salinity between them.
detection limit (0.3 TU; Table 2). This value is Furthermore, it can be demonstrated that calcite
considered well below baseline for pre-1950s dissolution is not contributing significant levels of
recharge at Adelaide (IAEA/WMO, 2001), indicating dead carbon to the groundwater, because this
that the water at these sites has spent more than 50 process typically gives d13C groundwater signatures
years in the aquifer. Three of these older waters were close to zero (Mook, 2001). The d13C composition
subsequently dated using 14C (see following discus- of Willaura groundwaters is much lighter (K14.05
sion). Approximate ages have been derived for the and K12.06‰; Table 2), consistent with C sourced
five samples with O0.3 TU (Table 2), based on the from the decay of C3 plants, which make up w82%
tritium content of rainfall collected between 1962 and of all vegetation in south-western Victoria (Hat-
1986 at Adelaide (IAEA/WMO, 2001). tersley, 1983). Recharge waters beneath such
The youngest groundwater is from the recharge vegetation typically have d13C values of w14‰ at
area on the slopes of the Grampians Ranges (borehole moderate pH (Clark and Fritz, 1997). The Willaura
324, 8–10 years old; Table 2). Groundwaters increase groundwater d13C values cannot be used for
in age rapidly away from the Grampians Ranges; reservoir correction of the radiocarbon ages because
4 km down gradient in the same alluvial aquifer, the d13C composition of carbon from the alluvial
groundwater from borehole 5201 has an age of 30–35 aquifer is unknown.
190 D.A. Bennetts et al. / Journal of Hydrology 323 (2006) 178–192
The 14C ages from boreholes 244 and 327 can be the slopes of the Grampians Ranges are fresh and
used to determine the approximate groundwater flow young, containing tritium, show significant interann-
velocity, because any contamination by modern ual variations in stable isotope composition, and
and/or dead carbon is probably minor, and in any infiltrated rapidly through thin, sandy soils. The stable
case is likely to have affected each site equally, since isotope compositions show that the majority of
waters in the Palaeozoic basement (244) laterally recharge occurs in winter or spring. Down gradient
recharge the deeper segments of the basalt aquifer groundwaters are recharged through thick clay soils.
(327). The older sample (7986 years) is w12 km Infiltration is slow, so any differences in the isotopic
further down gradient than the younger (4032 years; composition of rainfall are homogenised, and the
Table 1). This yields an approximate flow velocity of recharge water in the clay soils is strongly concen-
3 km/1000 years, or w1!10K7 m/s, a value typical trated by evapotranspiration. When progressively
of fractured rock aquifers (assuming 5% porosity; added to the underlying fresher groundwater, the
Domenico and Schwartz, 1998). Therefore on infiltrating soil water causes the groundwater to
average, groundwater takes around 8000 years to gradually increase in salinity down gradient.
flow from the recharge areas in the Grampians Ranges Carbon-14 dating indicates that it takes w8000 years
to discharge springs at the Cockajemmy Lakes for groundwater to flow from recharge areas in the
(average 25 km flow length through the Palaeozoic Grampians Ranges to discharge areas at the Cock-
basement and alluvial aquifers). There are zones of ajemmy Lakes. Thus the increase in salinity down
variable fracture density, and therefore, hydraulic gradient is natural and has occurred across the area
conductivity within the basement aquifer, so flow throughout the Holocene. This model (in combination
velocities may vary substantially around the calcu- with secondary processes like evaporation) probably
lated value. This probably explains why the ground- applies to other catchments in Australia that demon-
water 14C ages for boreholes 244 and 327 are older strate similar down gradient primary salinisation.
than would be expected from the calculated flow Water–rock interaction processes cause a reduction
velocity. in the overall groundwater salinity down gradient, due
A spring (Gellerts Seep; Fig. 1) was also dated by to removal of ions by conversion of kaolinite to
14
C, and gave an age of 2640 years (Table 2). This smectite and illite, and cation exchange of NaC for
water represents discharge at the end of the flow path, Ca2C on smectite. These reactions increase pH and
and should therefore be at least 8000 years old. As with decrease many species/ClK ratios down gradient.
Boggy Creek spring (see above), modern meteoric Silicate weathering and sulphide and organic matter
water is mixing with older Palaeozoic basement oxidation processes are also evident, the latter causing
groundwater at Gellerts Seep, adding modern carbon a decline in redox potential down gradient.
and decreasing the apparent age of the sample.
The 14C groundwater ages show clearly that the
progressive down gradient salinisation of Willaura
groundwater, due to cumulative additions of saline Acknowledgements
soil–water, has taken place over thousands of years and
is therefore natural (primary) groundwater salinity. The authors would like to thank Dr Ian Cartwright
of Monash University for d18O and d2H analysis,
Dr Fuping Hao of CSIRO Division of Minerals for use
8. Conclusions of HPLC, and John and Lynn Anderson for providing
accommodation and meals whilst in the field.
The Willaura catchment, which is strongly affected Discussions and comments from Dr Dirk Kirste,
by salinisation, shows prominent down gradient Mr Matthew Edwards, Dr Gideon Tredoux and an
changes in the hydrochemical and isotopic compo- anonymous reviewer helped to improve the manu-
sitions of groundwaters, and these have been used to script. Willaura Landcare, the Centre for Land
formulate a model for the development of primary Protection Research, DPI, Bendigo and AINSE
salinity. Groundwaters in the main recharge area on Grant 01/1855 funded this work.
D.A. Bennetts et al. / Journal of Hydrology 323 (2006) 178–192 191
Lawson, E.M., Elliot, G., Fallon, J., Fink, D., Hotchkis, M.A.C., Salama, R.B., Wells, A.S.M., Farrington, P., Bartle, G.A., (1993b).
Hua, Q., Jacobsen, G.E., Lee, P., Smith, A.M., Tuniz, C., Zoppi, The chemical evolution of groundwater in the aquifer system of
U., 2000. AMS at ANTARES - The First 10 years. Nuclear the Yilgarn Craton of western Australia. CSIRO Division of
Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Water Resources Report, Perth.
Interactions with Materials and Atoms 172, 95–99. Salama, R.B., Otto, C.J., Fitzpatrick, R.W., 1999. Contributions of
Leaney, F.W., Herczeg, A.L., Walker, G.R., 2003. Salinization of a groundwater conditions to soil and water salinization. Hydro-
fresh palaeo-ground water resource by enhanced recharge. geology Journal 7, 46–64.
Ground Water 41 (1), 84–92. Schofield, S., Jankowski, J., 2003. The hydrogeology of the
Love, A.J., Herczeg, A.L., Leaney, F.W., Stadter, M.F., Dighton, Ballimore region, central New South Wales, Australia; an
J.C., Armstrong, D., 1994. Groundwater residence time and integrated study. Environmental Geology 44 (1), 90–100.
palaeohydrology in the Otway Basin, South Australia: 2H, 18O Sibley, G.T., (1967). A study of the land in the Grampians area. Soil
and 14C data. Journal of Hydrology 153 (1–4), 157–187. Conservation Authority, Melbourne.
Macumber, P.G., (1991). Interaction between groundwater and Simmons, C.T., Narayan, K.A., 1998. Modelling density-dependent
surface systems in northern Victoria. Department of Conserva- flow and solute transport at the Lake Tutchewop saline disposal
tion and Environment, Victoria. complex, Victoria. Journal of Hydrology 206 (3–4), 219–236.
Macumber, P.G., 1992. Hydrological processes in the Tyrrell Basin, Smith, W.E., Nathan, R.J., (1999). Victorian water quality
south-eastern Australia. In: W.B. Lyons, D.T. Long, A.L. monitoring network trend analysis: Glenelg Catchment Man-
Herczeg and M.E. Hines (Editors), The geochemistry of acid agement Authority area, Sinclair Knight Mertz Report.
groundwater systems, Chemical Geology, 1992, pp. 1–18 Stanley, D.R., (1983). Final report on phase 1 exploration for drilling
Mann, B.S., Nolan, J., 1989. Preliminary hydrogeological appraisal
project GC13: lignite potential of the northern margin of the Otway
of the Willaura west region. Rural Water Commission Report,
Basin. 1983/69, Geological Survey of Victoria Report.
1989/37.
Street, G.J., Pracillo, G., Nallan Chakravartula, P., Nash, C.,
Mann, B.S., Stanley, D.R., Bolger, P.F. Basalt plains
Harvey, B., Sattel, D., Owers, M., Triggs, D., Lane, R., (1998).
hydrogeological salinity investigation, Progress Report no,
Willaura saltmap survey - Interpretation report. World
2 (1992) 1992/1
Geoscience Corporation Limited.
Mazor, E., George, R., 1992. Marine airborne salts applied to trace
Stuart-Smith, P.G., Black, L.P., (1999). Willaura sheet 7422,
evapotranspiration, local recharge and lateral groundwater flow
Victoria, 1:100,000 map geological report. 1999/38, Australian
in Western Australia. Journal of Hydrology 139, 63–77.
Geological Survey Organisation Record.
McArthur, J.M., Turner, J., Lyons, W.B., Thirlwall, M.F., 1989. Salt
Stuiver, M., Polach, H.A., 1977. Discussion; reporting of C-14 data.
sources and water-rock interaction on the Yilgarn Block,
Australia; isotopic and major element tracers. Applied Radiocarbon 19 (3), 355–363.
Geochemistry 4 (1), 79–92. Swane, I.P., Weaver, T.R., Cartwright, I., Lawrence, C.R., (2001).
Mitchell, T.L., (1839). Three expeditions into the interior of Eastern Hydrologic controls on groundwater salinisation, Murray Basin,
Australia: with description of the recently explored region of Australia. In: R. Cidu (Editor), Tenth International Symposium
Australia Felix, and of the present colony of New South Wales. on Water-Rock Interaction. Balkema, Rotterdam, Villasimius,
T. & W. Boone, London. Italy, pp. 589-592.
Mook, W.G., (2001). Environmental Isotopes in the Hydrological Turner, J.V., Arad, A., Johnston, C.D., 1987. Environmental isotope
Cycle: Principles and Applications. UNESCO/IAEA. Available hydrology of salinized experimental catchments. Journal of
online at http://www.iaea.or.at/programmes/ripc/ih/volumes/ Hydrology 94, 89–107.
volumes.htm. Vaikmae, R., Vallner, L., Loosli, H.H., Blaser, P.C., Juillard-
National Land and Water Resources Audit, (2001). Australian Tardent, M., 2001. Palaeogroundwater of glacial origin in
Dryland Salinity Assessment 2000: Extent, Impacts, Processes, the Cambrian-Vendian aquifer of northern Estonia. Geo-
Monitoring and Management Options, Land and Water logical Society Special Publications 189, 17–27.
Australia, Canberra. VandenBerg, A.H.M., Willman, C.E., Maher, S., Simons, B.A.,
Price, R., (1994). The occurrence of saline pools in the non-estuarine Cayley, R.A., Taylor, D.H., Morand, V.J., Moore, D.H.,
section of the Hopkins River. Department of Conservation and Radojkovic, A., (2000). The Tasman Fold Belt System in
Natural Resources, South West Area, Melbourne. Victoria. Geological Survey of Victoria Special Publication.
Rosen, M.R., Coshell, L., Turner, J.V., Woodbury, R.J., 1996. Vaught, T.L. Temperature gradients in a portion of Michigan: a
Hydrochemistry and nutrient cycling in Yalgorup National Park. review of the usefulness of data from AAA geothermal survey
Western Australia. Journal of Hydrology 185 (1–4), 241–274. of North America, Department of Energy Report, (1980)
Rozanski, K., 1985. Deuterium and oxygen-18 in European DOE/NV/10072–DOE/NV/10071
groundwaters; links to atmospheric circulation in the past. Wasson, R.J., Donnelly, T.H., (1991). Palaeoclimatic reconstruc-
Chemical Geology 52 (3–4), 349–363. tions for the last 30,000 years in Australia - A contribution to
Salama, R.B., Farrington, P., Bartle, G.A., Watson, G.D., 1993a. prediction of future climate. 91/3, CSIRO Division of Water
The chemical evolution of groundwater in a first-order Resources Technical Paper.
catchment and the process of salt accumulation in the soil Williams, B., (1997). A preliminary analysis of groundwater
profile. Journal of Hydrology 143 (3–4), 233–258. records, Willaura region, Victoria, Unpubl. Report.