Sie sind auf Seite 1von 3

PAPER REVIEW FORM

No. ID : 24687
Title : Auricular Acupressure for Reducing Pre-operative Anxiety: Relaxation Point vs. Sham Point

Content Comments
Part of review Guidelines
Yes No Editors Reviewers

Title Clear, specific, informative and Yes Please add the ethical committee
interesting (eye catching), approval in the method section, and
describe the content, include that the informed consent had been
key words obtained from each subject.
Abstract Informative, including main Yes
finding and significance?
Please add the hospital/ clinics where
Maximum 250 words and key Yes this research had been taken place.
words?
Introduction Yes
Highlight the importance or Please add information, at the end
magnitude of the problem/issue which statistic analysis did the author
used for each set of data ?

Make general statements about Yes


the problem/issue
Yes
Present an overview on current
research on the issue or
problem

Identify a gap, problems or Yes


unresolved issues in the existing
knowledge/research will be
useful.
Methods Is it clear and ethical? Author
didn’t
include the
ethical
committee
approval
and
subject’s
informed
consent
Adequate (including study No
design, location, subjects, data (comment)
collection, data analysis) and
reasonable for the type of study
Results Should answer the objectives Yes
Data analysis should be Lack of
appropriate to the study design information
and objective of the data
analysis
Interpretation of the analysis in Yes
relation to the problem and
objective
The content is not duplicated Yes
with narrative text or between
tables and figure?
Discussion It comparison to relevant Yes
previous studies/literatures
Focus on the interpretation of Yes
the results
Not a repetition of the results Yes
Conclusion From the analysis of the results Yes
and discussion hypothesis
testing
Not summary or restatement of Yes
the results?
A consistency between Yes
problems, objectives, and
conclusion
Editorial Decision: a) accepted without
revision; b) accepted with minor changes; c)
accepted with major changes

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen