Designing for Sociability in Massively Multiplayer Games:

an Examination of the “Third Places” of SWG

. 1' !
+ 2+ 2

.! 1' !
+ 2+ 2

. 1' !
+ 2+ 2
ABSTRACT
Author Keywords
3 + +
! + +! " , +. . '+! +
+ + . 3 +6
+
! +
! " "
+ + 4 INTRODUCTION
" " ' +! 5 - +! - + +! 5 + + +! "
6 + 7 '+!'! --5 +
" 8 --5 . 3 +6 " " '! + .
.3 + .3 " 9 " +
!
+! " ' ' 3 ())< :
+ '+! 6 ! " + +!
+ +
+! 6 " ++
! =>$> + +!
+! % % +! . + ! +'+
+ : + - +
+" ! ())< 2 6,
" ' + " 4 + !
9 ++ " '+
5+ ' "; 7 + 8 ' + + + +
+ " + +! : + ())*
6 " '+ = 0 + " '
+
+ + + " " " + + +!
" +
--5 # =>>& 2 + !
'+ + +

! " # $%& # ' ())*

" +'+ + "
, - " +. / 0 .
 --5 " "
'+ 6 : + ())* '+! . 3 +6 .3
" ++! " Sociability by design in SWG
=
+ +" + --5 .3 + /+
! ())< ++
!
+ "
4 "
+ " " +9 + ! --5
" " +! % % +! ' + " + "
, ? ' + ++
9 7 ' 6 + 6+ + 6 + +
+9 ' " 8 + 5 +
/ ' !+ ())< + + ! ! A ())*
'+ 6 + +! ! + " 6
+ +! " - +!
' +" " +
" +"! , ? 4
+
!" " + .3
+ '! " % " +!
" 6 9 " ; + +
' +!
" ! --5
+
! +
! 5 + .3 ; "
' ! " % + +
+
+ 7 8 7 8" ' ! .3
+! ! +! % + !
" " ; " + ' +
2+ " ! + !+ +"
())< ! ! ! +
+ +"! + + : + ())* 7 8 +
< ! +
+! ' , +!
+ " ' +
! 2 "
+ + " + " ' +
!
+ 7 '+! '! ! " 7' + " 8
"8 +! "+
" ; +! +
+ ' , + 7
+!7 " 8 ' 8 ! +! ;
+ 5 +
: " ' + " ' "
' :! "
.3 +
! +!
=
: + " +! ())* @)) " + '
+" + '! ; ' + ! +
=>>( + 6 '+! + +
+!
(
 " + " =>&> +
+ 7 + 8E "
'! ! !
' A ;+ +
+ " 7. +9 4 7 " " "
# 8( A ())* ! '+ +
"+ + ! +
0 +! + +! " "
# - + '! +
())* ' + 8 5+ ' " =>&>
+! 7 +9 8 + + .3 ; =$
'+ + '
' " " + "+!
+ + " " " ++
+ --5 + ' + +
'! + +" + .3 2 "+
! 5+ ' "
'+! + " "
'+ +" + ! " + '! + +
+
'+ + 4
' '+!
" 3 = # .3 ; 5+ ' ";
! + +! " ! " " F
'+! + ' " F
" ' !
( 3 +' ' +' 7
Research questions + 8 --5 +
. +" ". + =>*> +
! ' '+! '
+ +
! +! F
6 '+! 0 3 +
+ 4 '
7 + +
+ + " '
+ ++ 9 +
+ '
.3 3 '+
+ +
BC D . '+! 6
' + + " RESEARCH METHODS
+! 7 " 8 G ! .3
+ ! 8 + ! 2 + !
. +=>*>
! + + '+ + 7 + " !8 0 ()))H -
'+! 5+ ' " =>>> %" '+
" '+
+ ' %
+ +
(
7. +9 8 7 +9 "8 7 % 8 +!
7 + 8 3 +"" "++ ! +
<
 + 6%
*
" +!' ' 6 7 +8
! +! 2 2 " +
!9 '! /
+ I +! + + + 6
" + 5 " "
+
! ; + !
'+! '+ '
" " "
" +
!
"
+
. ++
! ! + +
" '+
! CANTINAS AS THIRD PLACES
+ + G 5+ ' " +
+ <
3 !'! "7 " +
+
! + ! + +
!
+ >& ! " " " +8
'+ +
! ! '+ + +
G .3 ; 7 +"8 4 K +
+ '+
+! ; + " '
'6 6 + + !
++ '+ +9 " +
!' +
" '! " + 5+ ' " 6
+ " " + +
+
+!'! " '+ 3
+ J*)-' " '+
3 + + " +
!9 .3 ;
" ' 7 +% ! 8 3 ' =>*>
+ + +

2 ! ' + Third places are neutral ground

+ +" 3 7 + ' '+ +
!
" + !
+" B + D +
" !" ! " ! + 8
5+ ' " =>&> 6 ((
<
, =) +
*
3 + + .3 ! +' ! <*)
+! +
!3 " 7 +8 +!
' ! +
+ '++ ! !
' 4 + ! # -
'! +! + "+ ())* ! + + ++
+ + "
*
 +
+ C T
+
Gestures sent Median 0.6 0.8
G ! ! ! / day
+" ! Average 2.2 2.8
! ! 3 + Std. dev. 10.1 12.2
"+ " ! Gestures Median 1 1
received / day
+ '+ = ' + Average 2.1 2.9
'! + " ' +! - Std. dev. 9.5 8
! !+ " Utterances / Median 3 3.25
4 +! +! day
! " >& Average 13.5 10.2
'+ , ! ! Std. dev. 66.5 32
G +" I ! ! " #
+!
+ " J & +
+! 3 +
!9
' " 7' 8 ! +!
+' + " " + !" !
! ! +
+!
" " ! '+ !
! +! ! ! + " '+ !+
+ " " +
++
! 3 +9
+! '!
Coronet Theed " '! ' !
Number of unique 4
visitors 7,167 7,277 '+ (
Days of Median 2 2 5 +
+ + + +
!
presence + + + ! ! "
Average 4.3 5
+! "
Std.dev. 5.6 7.1
" +!
Number of Median 3 4 6 " 9
visits
Average 11.1 14.2 "
Std.dev. 32.8 37.4 I '
Length of Median 6.8 7.9
stay
Average 130.1 77.4
(minutes) +
Std.dev. 860.9 361
+
+
" +

@
 +" '
+! 6 +! +
'! "
+" ' " 5
! !"
+!
" +
+! "
" " ++ !
+ '! . ! +!

" !
+! + " "
$ " % & '+
" '+
3 + +" ' 72GA %
@
8 + ' + '
' +
! !
+" ' " !
4 + ' "
+ "
5 +
+ 6
+" 5
+" ' +! +
+
! + " !
! +
! +
$ ! " %
!'
+ ! + + 7' + " %
0 " 8 +! 4 +!"
+ ' ' + 5
+" I ! + +
+ ' ! '+
+ + 4 " + +! ! !
7 8 ! 6 " + "
" + + '! "
" " ' + " + 7" 8 6
+ 4 +
+ +" '+ 2 ! +
4 + ' I ! +"
+! +
+
! +" # " +
!
4 " + "
K
4 @
. +! ! " 2 + '! +! '
' " + !
!' 2GA
$
 7 + ' ' BC D + ;
I! +!
! !+ + BC D
' " '" BC D '! 6 !
! ! +8 5+ ' " =>&> (*%(@
+ '! '+!
0 " .3 ; "
8 5+ ' " =>&> @J
6 +
! " +
.3 ; + " +! +
" 6 ! : ! +
! ' + +
! +!
I ! 4 '+ "+
! + !
7 "8 '! 5+ ' "
+ +
! ! '! ' -
'+! C ! " + '! '
+ ' + .3 ; + +
!
" 9 +! ! G 5+ ' "; + :
+! 7 !8 !' ! 7+ + "8
'+! + + ! "
" + +
+ +
+ 7B + D !' !
6 + I ' !' ! BC D 2
+ + 6 8 5+ ' " =>&>
+
! 3 + 6
' '! 7 % 8 +
! +
7" 8 '+ - ! J ))) 3 +
++ 5+ ' "; " +! '
+ ' ' <=* <J<
+ " 4 !
'+! +! + 4 0
+" + + +
' " ! 4
+
! '+ +
! ' "
6 " +! ! 4
++
!' +
'+! 6 '! " ""
The third place is a leveler and a mixer
+ +
! +
! +
+ '
7B + D +
' 6+
J
 C T 4 +
!
Prestige Median 1 2 +
Average 3.9 7 Coronet Theed
Std. dev. 8.9 16.7 Total # of sentences 699,135 616,076
Centrality Median 1 1 Unique sentences 247,766 438,689
Average 4 7.2 S/N ratio 0.35 0.71
Std. dev. 11.6 25.6
( )*
' & %
0 '
5 " +! + + ;
* + " +
+ 5 +" '
+
! ' <=* +! +
+ +!
+! 7 8 = (L + " +!
+ E !' ! ' '+
! '+
' J ' + " +! %
<J< = >L + % +! 6 "
' +
! + + " '
+
+ 5+ ' "; + : ' 7" +
+8
" ! + 6 ' "
' +! '! "
+
! + +
+ ' '+ + +!
+ !' ! + ! ++ " +" +!
: ++ ' " '+
+! + +! )= <J )J +! 2 ! !
'+ 3 + ! ' +
!" + !
6 +! '+ ! , "+ ' "
! + ++ + +! % )= <J *$ +! : ! !
6 " ' ' " ' " +
+ ! 6 +
' )= <J @J +! : !
! " ++ C
)= <& )= +! : F
Playful conversation is the main activity
)= <& )J +! 2 ++
7K " + +
!
+ + 3 +
" H + + ! +
+ " " +
! + '+ @H
+ + " " "8 5+ ' " ++ G" <
=>&> ($
+
" " 7+ + 8
7 " " "8
.3 ; G 7" +
%
% 8 .K

&
 C T ! +
! ! '
Unique Median 2.5 3 +
+ ! +!
utterances / + " + + +"
Average 5.8 7.4
day 2 5+ ' "
Std. dev. 12.3 14.9
S/N ratio Median 0.96 0.97 7 + !
+ +
Average 0.76 0.77
'+ BC D
Std. dev. 0.35 0.35
+ +
!" '
+ " )* ' " '+
+ '+
' +
+" 8
5+ ' " =>&> (>
7. 8 ' ;
! " +' +
+
'+
" '+!
: + ++ +
+
4 +
+!
7
+ B + D
$ ' " )*
'!+ " 6
"+
! "
BC D +
;
. K M )J$ 3 + "
+ +
!
' 4 ! +!
+ 8 5+ ' " =>&> (>
+ ' $ +
<J
" + .K
3 7 6 8E
! 6 +
! +! ! I! + "
+
! 6 + 7 + " 8 7 """+8 7 +
8
" ' G" < '! +! "
:! "
; C T
+! " " +" Laughter / Average 15.4 14.4
6 6+ hour of visit Std. dev. 64.9 52.7
! " +. K
+ , " -
"+
! ! " '
+ + +
! "
! "
'+! +
>
 7 ' " 4 + " ! +
2 +" ' " "
!G + + +
! +! + +" +
' + +
+ +
! 8 5+ ' " =>&> @( Third places have regulars
7 "+ " +
'+ $ BC D +
+ 6 +
! ' 5+ ' "; '! "+ '
% + +! +
! + B !D
" + - +! B !
" 4 ++ D "
+ I +" !+ 8 5+ ' "
7 8 ! =>&> <<%<*
' " +! +
6 + 3 7 " + 8'! + "
'+ " +! +!
'+ 7" 8 + ! !
NM =*
(= *& <@ - !+. ! ! + NM << + NM *>
Players visiting the C T
(= *> )) / # %. -!
cantina for…
+ + ++.3
14 days or more [% 422 628
3 + 6 + total] – G1 [5.9%] [8.6%]
" + "
33 days or more [% 36 100
+ total] – G2 [0.5%] [1.4%]
7- + 49 days or more [% 4 23
+! + total] – G3 [0%] [0.3%]
+
+!
BC D- '! . #
+9 6 + # " '
+ " ; "+
"+ " ' >L
+ "+ 2 ' " "+"'+ ' 4
+ ' + !
6 2 ! 6 8 +
! + '!
5+ ' " @< "
+7 8 7" 8 ' + " +
+!
+
+ + ' " 9 '+ "+ !
+ +
! '
' " +! + " 4
' ; + +
, "

=)
 7" +
+8 " +
+
'+ + +9 +
+' " +
!
0
0 5+ ' " + 9
+9 +!'
"+ +
!
+ ' " +
+ !7
+
! '! + +! +
+!8
+ + "
7 6 8 " "+
+! "
Coronet Theed +
! +E + '
G1 2
8.9 (σ =17.7) 12.6 (20.2) " ' '+!
G2 2 + + + -
7.1 (σ =8.4) 11.7 (8.8)
2
+! + + +!
G3 1.6 (σ =2.1) 12.5 (6.6) +
+! !
/ " - " " E +
' +
"+ '
' " " + 5 +
! 4
+ ! " " 7 " '+!8
'+
!+ " --5 3
+ 7 8 ! 7. +9 4 # 8+
+ +
! 4 ' '+!
+ .3 ; +
! .3 ; +
+ ++ "
DISCUSSION • "+ ! "+
5 +! + + 2" !
; +" "+ ! " 4
+ + " " + 5+ ' " =>&> *)
'+! 5 +
+ 6 5 2 +9 + ' +
!
' +
+" + ' " + ! "
- + 2 "+
"+ ! + ' 9 "
! ! +
!' O '
7" "8 6 +
+ '
" +! +
G +
+! +! + • ' + " !
' !' + +
! .3
+ ! ! + +
!
" ' +
! + ' 4 +!
5 + ' ! + I
" +" " +! 4 +! !
+ ! +
! + 2 " '+ +!
" 7 8 + 7 ' '8 +!

==
 +
+ + "% ! + + ""
+ ' +
+! " + +'
+ ' '+
! + 3 5+ ' ";
" ' +! % " % ' "
+ % " '+ "
+ '+!
• " ' +"
• + +! !+"
" + ! + .+ + "
+ ' ! ' 7 ! !
"+ + +! + '! '+! +
' " + + 8 5+ ' " =>&> @J
7 8 +
!'! 5 !
" !' +!
+ +! +9 + + 7" "8 Q
! + +! I! '+
•, " " " " + 6 +
.3 ; + +! K +! ' '+
+ '+! +! ' +
+ 7--5 8 +
+! + P ())(
+ + •2 " % + + +! + +!"
+" + ' +
+! + ! ! "
! + '+ + 4 +
+'
+ ' '+ G 1 ++
! !
+! +9 " +"" " +! +!
CONCLUSION
+
3 ++ + 1 "" " " +
+ 4 + +
!
" + ! +--5 F:! " "
" .3 " + +
% % "' '+! +
! ' + +
+ + %" '+! ! • " + + 3 + +!
+
! ' %" +
' + 5 +
! + +
+
!' P +
+ ++
! + " +! + ' '
+! " " +! " % %
' 5 +
+ + --5 ' +
+" ! ! ! %
' ++ '+! .3 " . +
+ A +
+ ! '+ =>>=

=(
• +! + ! + +
! '
" % 0 "
. 3
' " I +!
3 +! REFERENCES
' " + : +
+
+ + + ! 2 + K K '+ "
7" "8 ())*
Q +
+! ' +R- ". +
+! " 6%: S + + R
+ : +! 2 =>>(
'
# +R +!R
• "+ ! "J =>>& =%J
" 3 + + # K + ' /-
+ '+
!' + +" ())* R + " "R
+
++" "++ ! +! ! ##$ K P 2 -
G 7 8
+ 0 % ."
! +' + '+ ()))
! +! ! " / ' - + 1 !+ R
+ "+ ! . , ? R
--5 " ' ' 6 ##& - + ' 2 + ())<
4 ! +! 4 A A T " "
+ " ())*
! + U +" " " "
6 +N
+
! +
+ +' " - : R + " !R
.3 ; + ' & "
" +6!% ' '!A : , ' "
+
!6 + ? - " +
+" =>>>
! " " '+! - ++" / : " !
+ + %'!% + ' (
' " + K K '+ "
--5 ())<
7 +" 8 " "
5+ ' " ! ) K P
+ " ' + " " %" +
KP - + V ! =>&>
+" + "
' +! ! . + "R +"! '+!R
+ " '+ ' * @@ =>*> (@*%($=
+ +
! +'+ ! . +
+1 .A + (+
0 3 " " " ,
' + 2 +
! ' " -2 - =>>=
'+! .3 " '+!
=<
 !+ 1R " I ())<
F + +! --5 R U = W ' .'
- . ! +
N
K + ())< P K + R2 % "
3 ' - ) --5 R ())(
K P KP G =>*> U ! '
3 : R2 2 +
! --5 +
N
.' ES J )())<R

=*