Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Published by
Mobile Lifestreams Limited
9 The Broadway
Newbury
Berkshire RG14 1AS, UK
Tel: +44 (0) 7000 366366
Fax: +44 (0) 7000 366367
Email: prepay@mobilelifestreams.com
www.mobilelifestreams.com
www.mobilePrepay.com
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, in any form or by any
means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior
permission of the author.
Although great care has been taken to ensure the accuracy and completeness of the
information contained in this publication, neither Mobile Lifestreams Limited nor any of its
authors, contributors, employees or advisors is able to accept any legal liability for any
consequential loss or damage, however caused, arising as a result of any actions taken on
the basis of the information contained in this publication.
PUBLISHER
This report has been edited and published by Mobile Lifestreams Limited
(www.mobilelifestreams.com), a Newbury based research company specializing in and
focusing on nonvoice mobile services such as the Short Message Service (SMS), Circuit
Switched Data, Unstructured Supplementary Services Data (USSD), Cell Broadcast and
Universal Mobile Telephone System (UMTS).
The main purpose of this report is to provide a working knowledge of the technical and
business issues associated with formulating strategy, planning, deploying and operating
mobile prepay communications solutions.
The secondary goal of this report is to prepare the reader for further study. It is beyond
the scope of this report to cover every aspect of mobile prepay or to fully discuss the
supporting technologies and related business issues. As required, the reader is
encouraged to pursue supplemental knowledge and information through other reports,
consulting, and study of mobile communications standards.
The information in this report has been targeted specifically for technical and business
professionals in the field of mobile communications. However, this knowledge is
invaluable for anyone participating or considering involvement in prepay services. More
advanced readers will find the material useful as review. Less experienced readers will
find this report to be an instructional resource and basis for further study.
While there have been many industry reports regarding the business opportunities for
mobile prepay and evaluations of various technical deployments, I am not aware of any
resource that provides instruction as well as technical and business evaluation. This is
the first report of its type to provide all of the following:
§ Discussion and evaluation of the marketing and business issues associated with
successfully deploying mobile prepay
Please let me know how well I have met these goals. My hope is that you will find this
report to be a valuable resource for your technical and business endeavors.
Gerry Christensen
gerryc@mobilelifestreams.com
This report was developed to convey information that would help mobile prepay product
and service providers, and those investing in systems/solutions make more informed
business decisions.
TECHNICAL INTRODUCTION
The purpose of this part of the report is to provide a working knowledge of the basic
technical and business issues associated with deploying and operating mobile prepay
communications solutions.
BACKGROUND
Before we proceed with this part of the report, it is important for you to be aware of the
different radio frequency technologies and have at a basic understanding of the mobile
network elements and their functions.
ANALOG
Advanced Mobile Phone Service (AMPS), Total Access Communication System (TACS), or
Nordic Mobile Telecommunications (NMT).
DIGITAL
Global System of Mobility (GSM), Time Division Multiple Access (TDMA) for IS-136
(sometimes referred to as D-AMPS), Code Division Multiple Access (CDMA) and Personal
Digital Cellular (PDC).
MOBILE NETWORKING
It is important to understand the concept of roaming and have a working knowledge of
the network elements and processes that enable it. You are said to be roaming when
you utilize your mobile phone in a different serving area than your home service area.
Your mobile service provider and your specific communications plan define your home
service area. Some mobile carriers provide a virtual region-wide, nationwide or global
virtual footprint. This generally means that, from a billing and/or feature perspective,
you will experience consistent service, whether in your hometown or across the country.
However, the mobile carrier must still support this roaming capability for purposes of
system and account management. This is accomplished through inter-system signaling.
There are two major types of inter-system signaling for mobile communications: GSM
Mobile Application Part (MAP) and ANSI-41. GSM MAP, as you would expect, is the
Although the two standards have their differences, both have certain key things in
common. They support three network elements that are required for mobile
communications: MSCs, HLRs, and VLRs.
The interaction between the MSC, HLR, and VLR is best understood by walking through
the registration process (see Figure 1 below)
RegNot (Invoke)
HLR
System B System A
FIGURE 1:1:REGISTRATION
Figure PROCESS
Registration Process
This registration process also serves to help validate the user for purposes of fraud
prevention and allows for a process called automatic call delivery (ACD). ACD enables
the user to automatically receive calls while roaming. A calling party does not need to
know the geographical location of a mobile user to place a call; they just call the
(regular) mobile phone number of the user to connect to the roamer in the serving
market.
Mobile operators in the United States recognized (as their European counterparts did
years earlier) that there is a larger market segment for prepay services than merely the
credit challenged. Wireless service providers will need to find innovative methods to tap
into the other segments such as cost control. Technology enhancements, including the
introduction of mobile IN, will enable these improvements to happen. However,
technology is not the only answer. Improved business processes, enabled by
As you read these sections, it is important for you to note that the particular enabling
technologies used and the specific prepay technology solution employed will largely
determine the nature and capabilities of the prepay support systems and business
processes.
ENABLING TECHNOLOGIES
Before we discuss the various prepay solution technology types, we must discuss the
technologies that enable an overall solution. Many functional elements are integrated to
form a mobile prepay communications system. These functions include signaling, data
communications, call control/processing, data administration, storing and retrieval.
These functional elements interlink to form an overall solution including business support
processes.
SIGNALING
Signaling is the ability to provide messaging between mobile switching systems and
prepay systems for purposes of call control and administration. In more advanced or
robust solutions, signaling consists of common channel signaling systems such as SS7 or
C7 that provides the inter-network element messaging necessary for intelligent network
call control. Less robust systems such as “point solutions” will often rely solely on in-
band, direct trunk implementations to facilitate call control.
DATA COMMUNICATIONS
The ability to transport data is crucial for prepay system operation and administration.
For example, common channel signaling can provide the data communications medium
for call control and/or administration of customer information via other technologies such
as Short Messaging Service (SMS). Another example is the automatic transportation of
data between customer provisioning interface points, customer data databases and call
processing systems.
Call processing is the function concerned with user authentication, account management,
call rating, and call management and administrative intervention. When a prepay user
initiates a prepay service, the call control function will hand the request over to the call
processing function*. At that point, the next step is to authenticate the user. The call
processing logic verifies the user as genuine based on the mobile terminal's mobile
directory (dialable) number (MDN) and other information uniquely identifying the mobile
equipment and other information assigned to the user for purposes of roaming
facilitation. The mobile system may also employ other forms of fraud control to
authenticate the user, in many cases prior to the user actually attempting to place a call.
§ Manages the call in terms of decrementing the account balance based on the
current rating and usage during the call in progress
§ Provides appropriate termination treatment when either party ends the call or the
prepay customer account balance has been fully depleted by the prepay user
§ Requests call control treatment when appropriate to inform the prepay user
concerning the occurrence of a low account balance threshold.
Note: In many systems, call control and processing occur in the same physical database
of SCP, but they do not need to. In some scenarios it may be advantageous to distribute
these functions as facilitated by mobile IN and SS7.
SS7/C7
Although there are other variants throughout the world, Signaling System number Seven
(SS7) and C7 are the two predominant telecommunications signaling protocols utilized
primarily in United States and Europe respectively. Telcordia (then Bellcore) and the
International Telecommunications Union (then CCITT) standardized SS7 and C7
respectively.
PSTN
As you can see in the simple illustration above, the signaling links (represented as
dashed lines) are separated from the voice bearer channels (solid lines) that connect to
When we mention signaling throughout this part of the report, remember that it is SS7,
C7 and related technologies that provide the vital inter-system message communication
function between network elements. The Transaction Capabilities Application Part
(TCAP) portion of the SS7/C7 protocol is used for database and other connectionless
communications such as the HLR/VLR interaction discussed above. This is in contrast to
the ISDN User Part (ISUP) portion of the SS7 protocol that is connection oriented. ISUP
is utilized for out-of-band signaling between switches for voice circuit set-up and
teardown.
For more information about SMS and its applications, we recommend that you read the
Mobile Lifestreams report: Success 4 SMS (www.mobilesms.com)
For now, it is important to note that the SIM is an integral part of certain mobile prepay
systems, providing storage of user data used in conjunction with mobile prepay servers
to provide the overall service.
FRAME RELAY OR IP
Frame relay and Internet Protocol (IP) represent a data transport mechanism and
communications protocol (respectively), commonly used for data communications in
prepay systems. IP is typically used to communicate between remote
provisioning/replenishment sites and prepay customer databases. For instance, a mobile
carrier customer care representative may provision requests for establishment of prepay
service via a terminal connected to a database via IP. In addition, a prepay customer
may use an IP connection via the Internet to replenish his account. This is in contrast to
some of the point-of-sale configurations at merchant locations that may, based on
volume and cost effectiveness, alternatively use a dial-up-connection to replenish a
customer account. IP may also be employed over frame relay for intra-system
communications between prepay customer databases in a client-server type
architecture.
DATABASE
At the heart of any prepay system is a database used to store, administer, process and
retrieve customer information. As discussed earlier, this database may simply act as a
repository for customer data in a client-server type arrangement, or fully integrate with
the actual call processing functions such as rating and call intervention.
MOBILE IN
Mobile intelligent network (IN) pertains to the concept of network intelligence. While the
notion of network intelligence is evolving beyond the traditional model of centralized
control and processing, and expanding to network edge devices such as mobile terminals
and servers, the use of the term mobile IN will be used throughout this report to refer to
more traditional centralized network intelligence.
The two recognized global standards for mobile IN are Wireless Intelligent Network
(WIN) and Customized Applications for Mobile Enhanced Logic (CAMEL). WIN and
CAMEL are the standards used to provide network intelligence in ANSI-41 and GSM
networks respectively. As WIN standards are introduced, accepted and evolve, they will
become part of the core ANSI-41 standards. In contrast, the GSM CAMEL Application
Part (CAP) represents that portion of the GSM standard that uses CAMEL, and will remain
a separate yet associated standard to the core GSM networking standard, GSM MAP.
However, WIN and CAMEL are both derived from the same intelligent network conceptual
model (INCM), a framework from which the Intelligent Network Application Part (INAP)
was spawned. INAP represents the IN architectural model conceived by the European
Telecommunications Standards Institute (ETSI) for use in fixed networks. Evolutionary
WIN and CAMEL also utilize SS7/C7 for intersystem data communications. This includes
signaling between and among MSCs, HLRs, VLRs, SCPs, Intelligent Peripherals (IP),
Interactive Voice Response Units (IVRU) and other intelligent network nodes.
The term Mobile IN is sometimes associated with some better known centralized,
intelligent network type technologies such as SMS and the lesser known technologies
such as ISUP loop-back, which will be discussed in the section reviewing network based
prepay technology solutions. It is important to note, however, that when most people
involved in mobile network standards mention mobile IN, they are generally referring to
WIN, CAMEL, or perhaps proprietary vendor extensions of INAP.
§ A database used to determine if a customer is a valid user and how much credit
(typically measured in currency value, but may also be in airtime, number of
bytes for prepay mobile data, and/or number of messages for SMS) they have on
their account
§ An event alerting mechanism for signaling to the mobile network that a pre-
determined account threshold has been reached (note: this is problematic in CDR
based systems – thus the problems with fraud/uncollectable revenue). This
would allow the user to be alerted during a call (to avoid an unexpected
disconnection) and to alert the customer regarding the need to recharge prior to
making a call (so as to avoid the first situation).
POINT SOLUTIONS
Point solutions involve an adjunct piece of equipment that is used to provide call control,
database functions, administrative functions and call processing. These are called
"point" solutions as all calls must traverse a single network element or "point" (see
Figure 3 below).
PSTN
2
Mobile Switch
In the above diagram, a voice connection is established from the mobile switch through
a voice facility to the prepay platform (step 1). The platform processes the call and
reroutes the call through another voice circuit on the same facility (trunk group) that the
call originated from (step 2), meaning that a total of two DS-0 channels are required for
every call. Once the mobile-switch receives this incoming voice channel, it routes the
call to the PSTN as normal (step 3).
A significant disadvantage of point solutions is that they typically require dedicated line
ranges for prepay customers. This means that the prepay customer cannot choose their
phone number; it must be part of a predetermined line range for call routing purposes.
Furthermore, it is problematic to convert prepay customers to post-paid and vice versa,
without changing their phone number.
However, the most significant disadvantage is the loss of call control. Call routing
through the point solution relegates call control to the point solution. There is less of an
issue if the point solution is a robust platform capable of providing value-added services.
However, the fact remains that the mobile carrier will only be able to offer services
accessible via or through the point solution.
HANDSET SOLUTIONS
These methods involve the placement of intelligence in a mobile terminal to determine
the capabilities and account status of the prepay subscriber. Handset solutions fall into
two broad categories based largely on mobile network standards: Subscriber Identity
1
Module (SIM) solutions based on GSM and proprietary handset based solutions.
1
A SIM is the smart card you plug into a GSM telephone that stores the personal subscription data, telephone
numbers and the like.
One disadvantage of the SIM based solution is that it has limited differentiation potential.
Without IN capabilities, there is only limited capability to provide value-added services
such as location sensitive billing (based on predefined rate zones) which we shall discuss
in the Advanced Concepts and Applications part of this report.
However, being a smart card, the SIM offers the advantage of lending itself well towards
mobile commerce applications, which we shall discuss in the third part of this report -
Marketing and Business issues. SIM based solutions also have the additional advantage
of distributed processing.
Additional efforts are underway to provide smart cards for other technologies (other than
GSM) such as CDMA, which will have a Universal Identity Module (UIM), and Wireless
Application Protocol (WAP), which will use a WAP Identity Module (WIM) for storage of
user data on the mobile unit. Each of these smart cards will likely allow prepay service
on their respective technologies once the technology is finalized.
Loop-back Trunk
PSTN
3
Mobile Switch
SCP
2
1
In the above diagram, intelligence is centralized in a Service Control Point (SCP), with
ISUP signaling used to evoke call control. With ISUP loop-back signaling, the SCP
contains software logic to “spoof” the mobile switch. The SCP tricks the mobile switch,
making it appear to be signaling with another switch for call set-up via ISUP (as normal),
when in fact it is performing database operations necessary to process prepay calls.
After receiving the Initial Address Message (IAM) in the ISUP message stream from the
mobile switch (step 1), the SCP begins prepay call processing including account
verification, dialed digit analysis, and call rating (step 2). Once this process is complete,
the SCP returns SS7 signaling information to the mobile switch to indicate a call
connection is complete (step 3), when in fact only signaling has actually occurred at this
point. The call originating mobile switch receives this signal from the SCP and redirects
the call to the PSTN as normal (step 4).
ISUP loop-back requires that the mobile switch contain pre-established translations that
force all prepay customer calls to route (and signal accordingly) over the loop-back voice
trunk. Similar to the point solution this limits customer management and the ability to
offer value added services. Once again, TCAP based IN solutions improve on this issue.
Note: The MSC can also teardown the call (via an ISUP release message) if/when the
prepay customer terminates the call.
PSTN
3
Mobile Switch
SCP
2
1
In the above, the mobile switch contains information in its HLR about all prepay
customers. When a prepay customer attempts to use the service, proprietary vendor
software recognizes the condition as a triggering event and suspends call processing
while an SCP is queried (via a TCAP message) to gain further instructions (step 1). The
SCP performs call-processing functions (step 2) analogous to the ISUP loop-back
example, (in this case) returning a TCAP response message to the mobile switch (step
Unlike the ISUP loop-back or the point solution, there are no dedicated resource
requirements. Additionally, the SCP may contain intermediate or “end-of-call” triggers
that indicate the event in which a prepay customer has reached a pre-determined
account threshold or account exhaust. This mechanism can facilitate a more graceful
and customer friendly operation e.g. the prepay user can be bridged (while the original
call remains intact) to a control circuit for purposes of playing a warning (account low)
message (via “whisper tones”). At this point, the prepay customer may be offered the
opportunity to recharge (rather than merely being disconnected).
The only major limitation of the TCAP based non-standard method is that, due to its
proprietary (vendor specific) nature, roaming is problematic. Roaming can only occur
between like switch types that have the same software logic and triggers armed. This
includes implementations that utilize proprietary extensions of the INAP standard.
Roaming agreements also have to be in place between carriers to support the messaging
interactions between serving and home systems. In the above diagram, the serving
system must recognize the service profile returned by the home system (during the
registration process) and be able to act on that profile information (via armed switch
triggers) when the prepay user initiates a call attempt.
HYBRID SOLUTIONS
A hybrid solution example would be exemplified by a SIM based solution for basic prepay
call processing with a TCAP based IN complement for value-added services such as
location sensitive billing. It is likely that many GSM operators will adopt this approach as
they migrate to a full CAMEL based IN architecture over time.
PSTN
Mobile
Switch
HLR
2 3
Prepay DB
The CDR is created in the MSC and includes pertinent information such as type of
service, user identification, date/time of usage, call destination (if outbound) or calling
party number (if inbound), and location of the prepay customer. The CDR is generated
upon call completion (step 1) and is sent (via an IP connection) to an adjunct prepay
database for processing (step 2). When the account reaches zero, the prepay database
sends a message back to the HLR (step 3) to bar the customer from further calling until
recharge occurs.
This solution has the advantage of low cost compared to other solutions. As CDRs are
monitored after a call is placed, this solution can sometimes allow unbillable usage on
the last call (prior to the system detecting a zero account balance and initiating a
disconnection).
Apart from patents and trade secrets, technology is ultimately duplicable. Therefore, in
order to focus on product differentiation, there should be a strong focus on business
issues and continuous improvement in the areas of market positioning, product support
DISTRIBUTION
The establishment and support of effective sales channels and points of distribution is
very important to success in the prepay business. This relates to both initial sales for
new prepay customers as well as ongoing customer support including support for
customer account replenishment.
The foundation of a successful prepay program is built with the establishment of many
and varied merchant locations, supported by effective marketing focused toward each of
the four respective major target markets: credit challenged, temporary use market,
anonymity market and cost control market.
Distribution concerns include both the mobile equipment (phones and accessories) as
well as prepay cards. A successful prepay distribution system includes an expansive and
effective network of both equipment sales channels as well as points-of-sale for card
purchase and/or prepay account replenishment.
If less traditional means of distribution are employed, such as marketing and sales via a
"virtual storefront" on the Internet or direct marketing, fulfillment must be addressed as
a separate issue. Arrangements must be made with mobile equipment suppliers and/or
distributors to ensure that equipment and/or prepay cards can be distributed to
customers as they make purchases. With utilization of the Internet for commerce
increasing rapidly, the need to secure an independent means of fulfillment will increase.
POINT-OF-SALE SUPPORT
Merchant point-of-sale locations require support in terms of advertising, communications
terminals (for activation and replenishment), equipment returns, and technical
assistance. One of the most important items is the point-of-sale activation and
replenishment device. Depending on the type of prepay system these devices will
consist of either a simple electronic keyboard or modem (in the case of a debit card
based system), or also include a magnetic strip reader (if the system is account based).
These devices, ranging in price from a few hundred dollars up to one thousand dollars,
must be judiciously located in merchant locations where it is expected that users will
replenish often.
POS activation (POSA) is the operation of activating cards at the point of sale, or in the
case of an account card (permanent card type) system, recharging the card at the point
of sale. POSA is an important issue as it has many benefits. We will discuss POS-based
recharge and other replenishment issues in Part Three of this report in the
Replenishment and Distribution Strategy section.
REPLENISHMENT
We have previously defined replenishment as the act of updating a mobile prepay
communications account to include more airtime. Prepay systems are typically
configured (based on operator concerns and user desires) to alert a user when his
account reaches a certain threshold. When this threshold is reached, the user will be
alerted of the condition and is often offered options for replenishment.
There are many physical means of accomplishing replenishment, but not all of them are
available to each user. A user who has good credit (perhaps whose motivation for use is
cost control) may desire an option to replenish via credit card, either via a customer care
representative or an IVRU. Someone in this market segment may even desire automatic
replenishment up to a certain limit.
On the other hand, the credit challenged and the anonymous users are in some cases
unable to meet operator criteria for these options and/or prefer to do business with cash.
For these users, cash payment at a point-of-sale is the only realistic option. However,
some operators, depending on the arrangement with the merchant, will allow credit sales
at the point-of-sale.
In debit card systems, a disposable prepay card (or voucher) is purchased at the point-
of-sale. In this case, the user's prepay account may be replenished immediately after
the sale via a point-of-sale terminal device, or the user may subsequently call an IVRU
or customer care representative to provide card information for replenishment.
In handset based prepay systems, either electronic payment is accepted "over the air"
through a secured connection, or information is programmed into the phone.
PREPAY ISSUES
COST OF ACQUISITION
The cost of acquiring a prepay customer is generally much lower than acquiring a post-
paid customer. A large portion of the acquisition cost for post-pay is sales, dealer, and
agent commissions. On the other hand, prepay is typically distributed in a more cost-
effective manner. Sales assistance is minimal or non-existent as there is little or no
customer information required including no credit check. Prepay phones and cards can
be found in low overhead retail locations such as department and convenience stores.
Another cost of customer acquisition is the phone itself. Prepay customers often receive
refurbished or early model phones rather than top-of-the line phones. In contrast, the
cost of a more high-end phone for a post-paid customer is subsidized, meaning that the
customer pays less than the actual retail cost of the phone. The mobile operator usually
pays the difference to the manufacturer. However, as prepay service becomes a more
widely accepted service alternative in the United States, we will likely see more high-end
phones used by prepay customers.
Generally speaking, the cost of acquisition for prepay customers is lower, however,
churn and/or the lack of replenishment are issues that can drive up the overall cost of
customer ownership (acquisition and retention).
ROAMING
The ability to roam with prepay service is problematic. As we have discussed earlier,
handset based solutions allow roaming, but they are besieged with other problems such
as difficult replenishment and little differentiation capability. Point solutions can enable
roaming by looping calls from the serving switch back to the home system prepay
platform and then back out to the called area (perhaps the serving area), causing
network inefficiencies and higher costs. Proprietary IN solutions do not allow roaming
except between like switches that have the same software logic. Even standards based
IN solutions are not the answer, as it is likely to be four to five years before there is
ubiquitous deployment of WIN and CAMEL based triggers. When ubiquitously deployed,
however, mobile IN capabilities will offer the best long-term roaming solution.
Mobile IN will allow the deployment of feature enhancements and value-added services.
For instance, IN based location technology offers two examples. IN enabled location
querying can enable a voice response system to direct the prepay user to the closest
point-of-sale for replenishment when a pre-determined threshold is reached. Another
example involves Location Sensitive Billing (LSB). Establishing lower priced usage
With the introduction of mobile IN for prepay, we are likely to see an even greater
dependence on service bureaus. However, as prepay becomes a more mainstream
service in the United States, we will see a migration away from service bureaus. Unless
the service bureau can provide operating efficiencies based on economies of scale, or
provide unique value-added services, the mobile service provider will want to take on
more responsibility and control with a goal towards lower long-term costs and
differentiation.
§ Glenarye - an infrastructure provider that promises support for both WIN and
CAMEL on the same platform. Glenayre is partnering with AGCS for WIN.
§ Lucent Technologies develops software for prepay and they have an ISUP-
loopback solution. They have also announced that they will offer a WIN based
solution and are forming partnerships with Boston Communications and Glenayre
to bring the WIN based solution to the market. They have also partnered with
TeleCommunication Systems (TCS) to incorporate TCS’s prepay software
solution into Lucent’s bundled capabilities for multiple services on the same
platform. The solution supports network based GSM and will support WIN as
well. TCS is also an SMS Center vendor, profiled in "Success 4
SMS.
§ Opus Telecom - offers a real-time post-paid service for budget and spending
control
§ SEMA Group - has 200 installations of its prepay solutions with 60 million
customers. The largest is Telecom Italia Mobile with 15 million customers. Sema's
acquistion of LHS in 2000 bougt with it Priority Call, an IN based product. Sema
now offers IN, service nodes and hot billing solutions in its prepay portfolio
§ Systems Link - offers a service bureau solution based on near real-time CDR
analysis
§ SLP InfoWare - offers a churn manager solution to help predict when prepay
subscribers may be incline to try another service provider or simply not recharge
HANDSET BASED
§ JRC International, Telemac, Topp Telecom and US/Intellicom - all offer
proprietary based handset solutions for prepay (detailed profile on Telemac
below)
Applied Global Technologies has been writing software for the Prepay Industry for the
since 1996. AGT worked diligently with AG Communications in the early stages on the
development of its Intelligent Network Solution for prepay cellular. AGT has gone the
full gamut in the prepay cellular industry; from research and development for software
to implementation, support and consulting.
As the trend for Prepay Cellular continues to grow in the US and around the world, it is
of absolute importance that improved accessibility to real-time records and activities of
the prepay cellular customer, making it easier and more efficient for customer care
representatives. There can also be some relief to the customer service representatives
by using a browser based interface that will allow the customer to access their own
account, look at their call records and balance information. While this is not a widely
used application at this time, it is expected that prepay applications will go that direction
in the future.
One of the other applications being used is the Point of Sale (POS) application that
allows customers to walk into a convenience store, gas station or even a pharmacy or
food market and purchase airtime for their telephone. Several large chain stores are
already beginning to make this available to their customers. Using the POS terminal
allows the customer to walk into these locations and purchase time on their phones.
Instead of a prepay card, the customer receives a receipt with a pin number. In reality,
the receipt is just that, a receipt. The purchased airtime amount and the cellular phone
number has been transmitted to the carrier and added to the customers account via the
POS application. This is a great convenience for the customer, and it allows the cellular
carrier and reseller to be in the prepay business without the liability of have cards that
are equivalent to cash on their shelves.
AGT strives to develop provisioning software with versatility in its’ reporting functions
allowing for customization to the needs of the individual carrier. Having found that every
cellular company has their own specific need for certain type customer information; AGT
has worked diligently to develop products that can tailor to the carriers need for real-
time information. AGT offers training and support on all software.
Applied Global Technologies had provided provisioning software for carriers using point
based solutions and those using ISUP loop-back with SS7. The provisioning software is
compatible with any North American standard operating system.
Boston Communications Group, Inc. (BCGI) is the leading provider of prepay services to
wireless carriers in America. Founded in 1988, BCGI provides telecommunications
carriers with a range of resources, support services, and cutting-edge technology
targeted to address the unique needs of the growing prepay, electronic, and mobile
commerce industries. BCGI provides one or more of its services to the top five wireless
carriers in the United States, plus more than 80 additional carriers worldwide.
The BCGI platforms allow wireless carriers to provide prepay service to subscribers using
their existing wireless network. Designed to offer maximum service to both the
subscriber and the carrier to closely mirror all post paid services, the BCGI platform is
customizable, easy to implement, and fully scalable to meet carrier and reseller needs to
implement a prepay offering.
§ BCGI’s real-time rating engine debits the user’s account as the calls are made.
The BCGI network utilizes the SS7 signaling protocol from carriers’ mobile switching
centers for faster and more reliable call set-up and to enhance digital services such as
Caller ID and Voice Mail. BCGI also provides enhanced services like international dialing
capabilities to permit prepay subscribers to make calls from within the United States and
Canada to countries around the world. BCGI’s Passport feature allows subscribers to use
prepay account balances to make calls from any prepay or traditional post paid mobile
phone on a per-call basis. Additional features include prepay roaming, automated
replenishment options, and credit card address verification.
PRODUCT FLEXIBILITY
BCGI understands the prepay market and carriers needs to tailor their prepay programs
to meet market demands. BCGI’s solutions offer carriers total flexibility in the design of
their prepay program. All call rating and debiting, account provisioning, and subscriber
messaging features are totally flexible to meet carrier needs.
REVENUE-GENERATING FEATURES
BCGI continues to lead the prepay industry by providing additional revenue generating
features; for example Passport customers have pre-call access to prepay accounts.
Individual Special Numbers allow subscriber-based private number calling plans.
RESELLER SUPPORT
The BCGI C2 C solution fully supports the implementation of resellers on the North
American network, providing resellers with all of the flexibility and features of the C2 C
solution. Currently, resellers are using the C2 C network all across North America
reselling prepay for a number of wireless carriers.
CONVERGED PREPAY
Recently, BCGI introduced Converged Prepay, a feature that allows subscribers to make
prepay calls from any wireless or landline phone. BCGI works closely with the carriers
on an ongoing basis to develop additional features and functionality to expand the
capabilities and value of prepay wireless services.
OVERVIEW
Comverse, a unit of Comverse Technology Inc., is a leading provider of software and
systems enabling network-based multimedia enhanced communications services to
telephone operators around the world. The company provides a wide range of solutions
including 3G-ready multimedia messaging, multi-protocol mobile Internet platforms,
wireless data and short messaging services, speech-controlled portal, interactive voice
response and other personal communications services.
Comverse has supplied enhanced service solutions to 350 customers in more than 110
countries, including many of the world’s largest operators: British Telecom, Cable &
Wireless, China Telecom, Deutsche Telekom, MCI WorldCom, NTT, SingTel, Sprint PCS,
Telecom Italia and Verizon. The Comverse system is operating in a wide variety of
different network topologies, including several mixed-vendor environments, and in
several sites is supporting over a million active mobile prepay users.
Comverse offers a secure prepay service. Prepay credit and tariff details, recharge
voucher data, and other sensitive information are all stored in a centrally managed
database. Access to the system database is strictly controlled. Different types of service
administrator can be offered different levels of access, and different security levels can
be defined at each terminal location. All administrative activity is noted by the system
and logged to a secure file. An extensive set of reports and complete set of Call Detail
Records enable accurate accounting and reconciliation practices to be followed.
The Comverse prepay solution is flexible, and can be integrated with a wide variety of
network and operations support environments. The system can inter-work with all major
switching products, supports administrative interfaces to a variety of HLR products, and
can be managed from existing support systems using a published message-based
interface. The system is scaleable and the same fundamental architecture can meet
The more popular and widely used features of Comverse’ prepay service product include:
§ The construction of tailored tariff plans (from the very simple to the highly
complex) from a large inventory of individual tariffs
§ Billing based on the location of both the caller and the called party, and hence
support for distance-based billing
§ Billing based on day and time, including the use of regional or culture-specific
calendars
§ Support for concurrent tariffs, such as independent charging for airtime and long-
distance usage
Prepay Service can be combined with other multimedia services offered by Comverse,
including voicemail, Internet-based messaging and mobile originated short message
service, to provide an unrivaled degree of service and cost effectiveness.
TECHNOLOGY
The Comverse prepaid solution is based on the same technology as its successful
messaging platform. This design choice leverages the flexibility and proven performance
of the Comverse messaging platform, which has been deployed to a large number of
carriers around the globe. The distributed internal architecture allows additional platform
components to be added incrementally as service usage grows. Multiple platforms can be
combined together into a single distributed arrangement, offering support for many
millions of prepay subscribers. Since the same underlying technology is used to deliver
other enhanced services, it’s possible to deploy several different services at the same
platform. The platform and services can be managed centrally through the use of
Windows NT-based administrative workstations. Data replication technology is used to
ensure data integrity and synchronization in a distributed platform configuration.
Of the various prepay system architectures that exist in the market today, Comverse is
committed to a platform approach where all credit-related information (tariff plans,
subscriber balance data, recharge information, etc.) is stored in a central, secure
database. This approach delivers the level of security required by a system that controls
large amounts of credit. It also allows the prepaid balance to be used for several types of
service (prepaid SMS, prepaid data services, m-commerce activity, etc.) and not just
voice calls. This approach offers maximum flexibility and places no restriction on the
choice of handset that can be used by prepaid subscribers. Database information is
always current and information presented to subscribers and administrators is accurate
and consistent.
The Comverse system can be configured to inter-work with the telephone network in
several different ways. A traditional Service Node controls all aspects of a call, and offers
the widest set of features. An IN approach allows application logic to be injected into the
call at discrete points. The Comverse prepay platform can also be configured in pre-IN
mode, whereby IN features can be delivered using standard ISUP signalling. The
Comverse prepaid platform can operate in more than one mode at a time, allowing
carriers to take advantage of the best of each interface or migrate between different
configurations with minimal impact on service availability. For example, prepaid services
can be deployed using a pre-IN configuration with the platform migrating to an IN mode
of operation once network switches have been upgraded to support IN triggers. This is a
unique benefit of the Comverse prepaid solution, and can be used to mitigate the risks
associated with deploying IN-based services in the network. However, the same prepaid
application and database are used in each platform configuration, and guarantee a
consistent interface to the prepaid user.
Comverse believes that the long-term success of prepay programs depends less on the
specifics of a particular technology and more on the development of a strong partnering
relationship. To this end, Comverse provides localized product, marketing and service
support to its customers. Prepay services can be deployed and implemented via several
technologies and architectures. One solution may meet some service needs but not
others. Choosing the right solution requires an examination of technical, provisioning and
market conditions. Comverse understands the importance of integrating prepaid services
with the local network, adapting prepay services to blend with existing support
procedures, matching service features with changing subscriber expectations, addressing
the needs of multiple market segments, reacting to rapid prepay take-up rates, and
leaving room for operator and subscriber creativity.
Comverse further supports its customers through its strong commitment to the prepaid
market. New features are driven largely by existing customer requests, and Comverse is
continually investing in new technologies and new services to further enhance its prepaid
offering. Comverse has taken a lead in applying prepay service principles to other areas,
such as SMS and wireless data services, and closely monitors the progress of these and
other emerging technologies. A Medalist marketing program allows Comverse customers
to learn about, and benefit from, successful marketing campaigns from around the
world. These programs help to promote greater success in the deployment and growth of
a new or re-launched prepaid program.
This is the challenge to the prepaid service industry. Wireless data services require a
creative charging approach, one based on the extent of service usage, the content of
data, the quality of service, and more. Supporting these services in a way that does not
compromise prepaid principles is a challenge that Comverse has already accepted.
Prepaid wireless data services are an example of the company’s commitment in this
area, and prepaid support for other enhanced services will emerge over time.
Comverse has become a leader in the delivery of prepay service around the world, and
maintains a commitment to its strong position in this arena.
Comverse
100 Quannapowitt Parkway
Wakefield, MA 01880
Phone: +1 781 246 9000
Fax: +! 781 224 8143
Logica have established a leading position in the provision of prepay infrastructure and
have been supplying telecommunications operators around the world with prepay
services since 1996.
Logica provide a comprehensive range of pre-paid solutions through its series of Aethos
Intelligent Network Platforms (INP). The Aethos family will operate in a Service Node
configuration or in an Intelligent Network (IN) configuration or as a hybrid of the two
approaches. In any of these configurations, the Aethos system provides prepay calling
support for voice, SMS messaging, GPRS and m-commerce transactions. Also provided
is a comprehensive System Management, Administration and Customer Care capability
via the optional Aethos Intelligent Network Support System (INSS).
Initial marketing of prepay services was heavily focused on potential users who were
considered to have a poor credit history. This was a niche market and resulted in a
number of niche solutions characterized by limited functionality (usually only basic voice
services) and low subscriber and traffic capacity.
In Europe, Asia Pacific, South Africa and the Australian sub continent, the prepay market
has evolved beyond the early “limited credit” users to become a mainstream service
offering targeting the mass market of potential mobile phone users. Marketing tactics
such as “user control” and “life style” marketing has resulted in explosive take up of
services. Today, many operators are reporting that prepay sales are outstripping
traditional sales by a factor of more than two to one.
This change in emphasis puts increased demands on the platforms used to support
prepay services. Users now expect to be offered a full range of service options such as
Voice Messaging, Call Diversion, SMS Messaging (both terminating and originating
services), Data and Fax services – in fact anything that the network operator can supply.
Prepay is now considered to be simply a method of payment, not a service
differentiation. Additionally, systems must now be able to scale upwards in order to
handle the increases in subscriber base and traffic that result from prepay’s marketing
success story. Logica report that their systems are supporting increases in capacity of
over 100 times the initial forecast requirement.
NUMBER OF DEPLOYMENTS
Logica state that they have systems deployed in more than 30 networks in all parts of
the world supporting systems ranging in size from l0,000 subscribers to many millions of
subscribers and based on Service Node and IN system designs.
§ E-Plus in Germany
§ Libertel in the Netherlands
§ Telstra in Australia
§ Vodafone in New Zealand
§ Panafon in Greece
§ KG Telecom in Taiwan
Service Node implementations have a number of benefits that are important to network
operators including:
§ Often more flexible service design is possible since fewer interactions with other
network elements are needed
§ Often lower cost (particularly for networks with less than 500,000 subscribers).
The main disadvantage to a Service Node implementation is the cost associated with
routing calls from the point of call origin within the network, to the Service Node and
back again. The Aethos system has a distributed switching architecture that minimizes
these costs for network operators, however once subscriber numbers reach between
500,000 and 1 million, an IN based solution is often the better choice. The Aethos
system design provides a seamless transition between these network architectures.
The Aethos INP consists of a number of software and hardware components, each of
which can be sized appropriately to meet specific functional and performance
requirements. In addition, system designs can be deployed which consist of different
combinations of the available components.
Service Control (SCF) - This function is used to control the progress of the call and
therefore the “look and feel” experienced by the prepay caller. The same Service Control
Function is used with Service Node and with IN implementations so that any existing
switched call based services (SN) can be easily migrated to full IN services.
Service Resource (SRF) - The service resource functions are supported by the
switching sub-system and are accessed via a software layer by the service control
2
functions. Service Control requests the SSP to route calls to the SRF using the
appropriate IN procedures.
Service Management (SMF) & Service Management Access (SMAF) - The Aethos
INP provides a range of integrated service management functions and flexible external
interfaces designed to allow secure access for Network Operator's computer systems and
end-users.
STANDARDS COMPLIANCE
Logica supplies systems that are standards compliant. Wherever applicable, they follow
the standards laid down by ANSI, ITU-T and ETSI. However, they also recognize that
protocol implementations are sometimes non-standard so the system design ensures
that manufacturer or country specific variants can be implemented with ease.
INP CAPABILITIES
§ Implementations using Service Node (switched call) of Intelligent Networking
(IN) call control
2
SSP stands for Service Switching Point
The Customer Care and Management System - offers the operator full
administration and customer care facilities. Logica claim that these capabilities are
needed to implement an operational pre-payment service in the shortest possible
timeframe. It enables:
§ Customer maintenance
§ Provisioning of subscribers in the Intelligent Network Platform
§ Account enquiry and history
§ Processing of balance adjustments (charges & credits) and call refund
3
§ CDR/EDR processing
§ Security/audit
§ Optional Management Information System (MIS)
§ Optional recharge transactions (for loyalty bonus etc.)
§ Optional general charging (for processing and charging of external CDRs).
3
CDR stands for Call Detail Record; EDR stands for Event Detail Record
§ Scalability
§ Value for money
§ Rapid deployment
OVERVIEW
NTC develops call processing and billing systems for the communications marketplace.
Services include prepay wireless under the brand name SmartPay Wireless, nationwide
prepay roaming under the brand name iRoam , and unregistered or default roaming
under the brand name American Roaming Network.
NTC provides services to 13 of the top 20 cellular carriers. NTC has been the first to:
NTC was acquired by Illuminet (www.illuminet.com) in the summer of 2000. NTC will
function as a wholly owned subsidiary of Illuminet, a provider of SS7 and intelligent
network based services in the United States and parts of Asia.
SmartPay was developed to be an alternative, real time billing system that mirrors
postpaid rate plans. Replenishments are treated as financial transactions rather than
retail transactions. The system is account based allowing money in the account to be
used for long distance, features, roaming and airtime. Taxes are charged on usage,
IRoam - NTC’s nationwide roaming system, is a joint development effort between NTC
and Lucent Technologies to provide real time, nationwide roaming. The cross
functionality of iRoam will allow service providers the ability to offer prepay wireless
customers national, seamless roaming mirroring that of post pay roaming plans
regardless if the call is from outside or inside the home network.
TECHNOLOGIES
The current NTC call processing system is based on a loop-around (trombone) and
proprietary ISUP RLT technology. The call rating and billing system is based on a
leading-edge proprietary database design, which allows for very discreet carrier market
segregation and extremely fast, real-time call rating. The billing system is a web-based
user interface that allows for quick and easy access to near-real time billing information.
The nascent prepay industry is and just beginning to accept prepay systems, which are
not mainstream (read non-telco originated).
Challenges: Real-time call rating is very processor intensive and requires 100%
availability of all data processing systems. To meet this challenge, NTC uses the most
current client-server load-balancing, programming and hardware system designs.
Roaming is not ubiquitous due to multiple vendor non-standard prepay solutions. No IS-
41 standards exist for prepay or prepay roaming.
The next generation of prepay call processing, which does not require proprietary vendor
solutions, requires the pending TIA PN-4287 WIN standard. The acceptance of this
standard by major telecom equipment vendors will signal the end of the current
proprietary trombone and RLT designs. There is an industry-wide concern that hardware
vendors may not widely or completely accept the release of the standard. This would
result in many non-standard IS-41 prepay implementations and would ultimately delay a
ubiquitous prepay roaming network. To offset this concern, NTC has developed and
implemented a patented, ANSI-41 standards-based prepay roaming solution called
iROAM. This system allows for wireless carriers to integrate their prepay roaming into
one platform. This system operates independently of the WIN standards and would
easily integrate multiple carrier-prepay platforms when the WIN standards are complete.
ROAMING
NTC utilizes two methods to provide prepay roaming. The first, or on-net model,
incorporates the use of the American Roaming Network. Prepay MINs are unregistered.
When a prepay subscriber’s call comes in to a carrier utilizing on-net roaming, the call is
sent to the on site ARN call processor where the MIN is identified as either an
unidentified roamer, or a prepay roamer from another carrier. If the caller is a prepay
roamer, an inquiry is made to a database asking 1) is this MIN active, 2) does the caller
have money in the account to cover this call and 3) is this subscriber allowed to roam. If
the answer to all three is positive, the call is placed. Any negative responses and the call
are not allowed. If the caller’s account runs out of money during the call, the call is
disconnected even while the call is in progress. Net settlement is processed by NTC.
NTC’s iRoam system will allow real time roaming in off-net situations. A subscriber will
be able to place and receive calls anywhere that the home serving carrier has roaming
agreements. MINs are registered as are the post-paid subscribers. Call charges are
deducted from the caller’s account real time with net settlement processes between
carriers through the carriers’ current clearinghouse and net settlement processes.
NTC also realized that in order for a carrier to be successful with prepay service plans,
the sales and marketing personnel had to be convinced that prepay wireless is not just
for the credit challenged but rather for a broad segment of the market. NTC believes
offering prepay rates higher than post pay does not work.
Prepay wireless is the only product available today that penalizes a person for paying in
advance. For prepay to be successful, the treatment of the prepay subscriber must be
the same as post paid. Rate plans with similar calling areas that include features and
provide roaming must be offered.
Sales staff should be compensated fairly. If a sales representative receives $100.00 for
selling post pay and $10.00 for selling prepay, it is pretty obvious what will be offered
when in fact, studies conducted by successful prepay wireless providers have shown that
Sales distribution through agent locations has also proven to be very successful,
especially when the carrier offers “phone in the box” packaging.
Replenishment must be simple, convenient and available 24 hours a day both in the
home market and while roaming. Multiple replenishment options must be available. The
NTC system does not use debit cards or vouchers that are expensive and difficult to
track. With debit card/vouchers there are commissions to pay, PIN administration costs,
loss and theft. NTC uses an account card that has no value but is simply a means of
branding for the carrier. NTC made the decision early on to find a company that could
provide nationwide real time replenishment. NTC has an exclusive agreement with
Travelers Express to furnish third party replenishment locations nationwide. SmartPay
replenishment can be by cash, credit card or bank draft.
NTC allows the carrier to perform customer service with on-line, real time customer
information. The NTC system operates with Microsoft’s Windows 95 and 98 and is
integrated with the carrier’s customer service screens. Because most prepay customer
service questions deal with account balance information, which is available to the
carrier’s SmartPay prepay customer through a speed dial number on the handset, the
number of customer service calls are a fraction of those experienced with post paid.
The major switch manufactures have come to the realization that prepay service is
moving into wide acceptance from the marketplace and they have begun to incorporate
real time call tear down into proprietary products that will allow a carrier to offer a
“home grown” prepay service. WIN, if and when it is available, will also aid individual
carriers in developing prepay services.
There are a few difficulties that lie ahead for the carriers using switch or WIN solutions
however. Those difficulties are the inability to provide ubiquitous prepay roaming due to
the lack of inter-operability of proprietary systems, the lack of real time back room
functions and real time replenishment outside of the home market.
Carriers now have enough prepay experience to realize that prepayment of services
reduces exposure, fraud, customer service expense, collection cost and operational cost.
Carrier comparisons indicate that net revenue per subscriber on a prepay rate plan is
near or better than the net revenues from the subscriber on a postpaid plan. In the
future carriers will realize the advantage of offering prepay, or more accurately, real
time billing services, to a broader segment of the market.
CONCLUSION
Mobile prepay communications has a bright future due to the capabilities made possible
through deployment of advanced technologies. Within the next five years, we will
witness expanded exploitation of mobile IN technology for prepay service.
Consequently, we shall also see expansion of services to prepay customers and
corresponding expansion of revenues to mobile operators. The acceleration of this
growth will be limited partially by technology availability but perhaps more so by
hesitancy on the part of the mobile operator to deploy.
With millions of people all over the world each repeatedly using their credit and
debit cards more and more, the number of transactions is growing. It is the
process behind each of these transactions that PSINet Transaction Solutions
supports by connecting EPOS and ATM terminals to the acquiring bank’s host
computer.
The mobile phone operator can simply issue its pre-pay customers with an electronic
swipe card containing their account details. This will allow customers to purchase
additional airtime from an electronic terminal in a retail outlet, using existing EPOS and
ATM infrastructure.
Convenient – utilising existing EPOS and ATM infrastructures, the potential is for
customers to be able to top-up their phone at any of hundreds of thousands of
convenient locations.
More secure – without the need to distribute and track paper-based vouchers, the
service is more secure. The risk to retailers is also reduced, as they do not have to hold
stocks of vouchers, which are essentially virtual cash.
PSINet Transaction Solutions can supply a fully robust network enabling customers to
top-up their mobile phones electronically, and enabling us to support your company
between the terminals in the retail outlet to your host.
PSINet Transaction Solutions is already working with two of Europe’s leading mobile
operators, Orange and Vodafone, to provide transaction solutions for their customers in
the UK, and this new team will enable the company to further develop and provide
tailored solutions to the pre-pay market as it continues to develop in the coming years.
The new system will enable Orange Just Talk customers to purchase talk-time at Orange
shops and approved retail outlets, using existing EPOS terminals, with their own
personal swipe card. This eliminates much of the inconvenience that has existed for both
customers and retailers with the paper vouchers system.
This Orange payment service will first be available in over 16,000 participating outlets
with rapid rollout throughout the rest of the UK over the next twelve months. Orange
PSINet Transaction Solutions has provided Orange with a processing service directly
connected to EPOS host systems that acquire transactions from all those retail outlets
authorised to sell Orange pre-pay talk-time. This new service enables the retailer to
provide instant, effortless Just Talk air-time to the customer who simply hands over their
Orange Just Talk account card and their chosen method of payment - cash or
debit/credit card. The retailer then credits the customer’s pre-pay account with the
specified value, which immediately provides the customer with additional airtime.
The solution enables the pre-pay customer to simply present their swipe card, along with
their chosen method of payment such as cash, debit or credit card, to the retailer and
their pre-pay account is then credited in real-time with the additional airtime purchased.
This electronic solution alleviates much of the administration, risk and expense
associated with the paper voucher system that has been in use since the introduction of
pre-pay mobile phones.
PSINet Transaction Solutions is utilizing its network and host processing solution to link
BMS Point-of-Sale terminals at retail outlets, with the Vodafone host computer. Each of
Vodafone’s pre-pay customers will be issued with a top-up swipe card that is unique to
their phone.
PSINet Transaction Solutions also provides Barclays Merchant Services and Vodafone
with management information on all transactions, as well as facilities to monitor the pre-
pay transactions in real time.
For further information about any aspect of our products and services, please call
Peter Lyster of PSINet Transaction Solutions on +44 (0) 114 292 0143 or email
lysterp@psi.com
Q Comm is based in the United States, has been in the telecom business since 1992, and
became a public company in 1998.
PRODUCT
Similar in size and appearance to credit card processing terminals, Q Comm’s Qxpress™
terminal plugs into a standard phone line and prints prepaid wireless replenishment
vouchers/cards from any operator, in any denomination, on demand. This enables
retailers to eliminate inventory, theft, and stock outages, while providing unique
reporting and inventory management solutions to operators, agents, and retailers.
Only simple programming from Q Comm’s data center is required to add products from
an operator throughout Q Comm’s entire retail network. The products offered through
Qxpress™ can be customized for each individual retailer.
In addition to prepaid wireless, Q Comm currently delivers long distance (phone cards)
and home dial tone service through Qxpress™.
Qxpress™ essentially acts as a conduit through which Q Comm helps operators deliver a
virtually unlimited bandwidth of prepaid mobile and other services. This flexible
electronic platform gives Q Comm, its partner retail sites, agents and operators the
ability to quickly grow sales at relatively little additional overhead, increasing profitability
among all parties.
Qxpress™ units are installed in retail locations by Q Comm and its authorized distributors
- usually major telecom agents, food wholesalers, and mobile operators.
With prepaid mobile being predominantly chosen over postpaid throughout much of the
world and just emerging in the U.S., retailers, agents and operators will boost
investments in systems that improve product delivery efficiency. This will include
converting from the traditional vouchers to efficient, electronic replenishment systems to
eliminate prohibitive inventory costs, out-of-stocks, and theft, and to achieve improved
inventory reporting and management.
Through combination and multiplication of flexible software modules, SICAP creates new
solutions with a short time-to-market. In the prepay & billing segments, it provides
services and solutions such as customer loyalty programs, CDR handling, CDR viewing as
well as customer management and GPRS/IN integration. SICAP also offers credit card
reload, information servers as well as over the air solutions.
Several customers have already successfully launched prepay roaming solutions based
on SICAP's prepay roaming platform. Recently, SICAP rolled out a mobile payment
solution in cooperation with a global softdrink provider which allows a customer to
purchase a beverage from a vending machine with a mo-bile phone. Based on its
significant experience in international mobile communications, SICAP has a strong
market position. SICAP has customers in Europe, Asia and Latin-America - Operators as
well as service providers.
RECHARGE
The SICAP platform can interface to a pre-existing voucher system and can collect
requests for replenishment via voice response unit, SMS, or USSD. Alternatively, the
system can be equipped to generate its own vouchers.
REPORTING
The SICAP prepay platform offers both on-line and off-line detailed statistics including
customer data, calling data such as recharge information and calls made, information
about MSISDN blocks used, information about roaming calls, distributor information
(how much income from prepay distributors), and user defined reports.
SICAP Ltd
Bernstrasse 34
3072 Ostermundigen
Switzerland
VISION
Telemac’s first product, introduced nearly 10 years ago, provided a mechanism for
limiting the credit balances in traditional post-paid cellular phones. Then, in 1996,
Telemac began beta testing the first handset-based accounting software for prepay
wireless services. In recognition of its pioneering work, Telemac has received multiple
U.S. and international patents for handset-based billing and accounting software, and
has patents pending in over 30 countries.
§ Enhancing the functionalities and security of its prepay technology, which has
become the global standard for handset-based prepay wireless technology;
TELEMAC TECHNOLOGY™
Telemac’s current product, Telemac Prepay Technology™, is a unique, patented switch-
independent, handset-based billing solution for wireless networks. Telemac Prepay
Technology™ is a complete real-time billing system that can be integrated into all digital
formats. The system consists of Telemac’s DAS™, IMA-Modules™, TRAC®, and certain
interfaces. Telemac’s IMA-Modules™ reside in the handset and "enable" the handsets to
communicate with Telemac's DAS™ software, operated by a wireless service provider.
Utilizing TRAC®, a wireless service provider is able to initialize the IMA-Modules™ to lock
Telemac-Enabled™ handsets into the selected network. Telemac Prepay Technology™
Telemac’s technology allows the handset to securely monitor the value of all calls made,
and decrement the credit balance, so that the user’s credit level is never exceeded.
Telemac Prepay Technology™ has propelled BT Cellnet to more than five million prepay
subscribers in less than two years.
The BriteStar™ System, available from IVB, consists of Telemac Prepay Technology™
and sophisticated subscriber, line management and financial technology developed by
IVB, as well as a state-of-the-art call center and operations managed by IVB, a leader in
a wide range of technology services for the global telecommunications industry. Upon
request, SmartUse™ Technology can also be incorporated into a BriteStar™ System.
Telemac Technology™ offers full national and international roaming capabilities and
supports a real-time handset display of account data, as well as multiple tariffs for
complex billing categories, such as local, long distance, international, incoming,
operator-assisted, roaming, special numbers, mobile-originated and terminated
messaging, WAP, and other categories specified by a wireless service provider.
With the Telemac Advantage™, or BriteStar™, a wireless service provider can also
license sophisticated subscriber and line management technology to maximize the
functionality of Telemac Prepay Technology™. Alternatively, many network operators
already own the hardware and most of the software required to implement a prepay
program using Telemac Prepay Technology™. For those network operators, Telemac’s
core technology and a limited number of additional interfaces licensed by Telemac or IVB
may be all that is necessary technically to launch a prepay service.
Telemac works closely with each of its licensees to integrate Telemac’s technology into
the licensee’s products, and to provide on-going support to enhance and customize
Telemac Technology™ to meet each licensee’s needs. Telemac will also assist in
managing the technology implementation, if requested to do so by a licensee.
British Telecom’s BT Cellnet prepay program in the U.K. utilizing Telemac-Enabled™ GSM
handsets is one of the most successful launches of a wireless program in the history of
the United Kingdom.
In the United States, prepay wireless services utilizing Telemac Prepay Technology™ are
offered by numerous local carriers, and nationally by Shared Technologies Cellular Inc.
under its marketing venture with MCI WorldCom Inc. Telemac-Enabled™ handsets are
sold in the United States via the Internet, television direct response, and national
retailers.
Telemac’s licensees also are planning to launch service in Australia, Asia and Africa.
During 1999, total worldwide airtime using Telemac Prepay Technology™ approached
$500,000,000.
Telemac’s global handset licensees include Motorola, Royal Philips Electronics, Rok
Communications, and Sensei Ltd.
Telemac holds U.S. and international patents and patents-pending covering wireless
phone accounting, programming, distribution, tracking and call accounting controls, as
well as related wireless technology.
TELEMAC’S MISSION
To develop and market proprietary leading edge handset-based billing and accounting
software and systems to create innovative and economical solutions for wireless service
providers, handset manufacturers, and their customers. Telemac has an unshakeable
commitment to the needs of our licensees and the public who use Telemac-Enabled™
phones.
HANDSETS
In 1997, Telemac entered into a manufacturing agreement with Philips Consumer
Communications, L.P. (“PCC”), a joint venture of Royal Philips Electronics N.V. (“Philips”)
and Lucent Technologies.
At the end of 1998, Philips succeeded to the business previously undertaken by the joint
venture. Since that time, PCC has integrated Telemac technology into both analog and
digital handsets, including the ISIS™ (AMPS / N-AMPS), the Diga™ and the Savvy™ (900
MHz GSM handsets), and the Genie , a dual band 900 MHz / 1800 MHz handset. Philips
is now integrating Telemac’s technology into the Ozeo™, a TDMA mobile phone.
In May 1999, Telemac also licensed Rok Communications Ltd. (“Rok”) to customize and
market Telemac-Enabled™ handsets to be manufactured by licensees selected by Rok
and Telemac. Rok is working with Telemac to customize and increase the availability of
Telemac-Enabled™ handsets.
PREPAY SERVICES
Prepay wireless programs utilizing Telemac Prepay Technology™ have been licensed in
Australia, Israel, Namibia, Seychelles, South Africa, St. Maarten, the United Kingdom,
and the United States.
NORTH AMERICA
In the United States, Telemac’s strategy includes a national program from Shared
Technologies Cellular Inc. (“STC”) and MCI WorldCom Inc., and local carrier programs.
STC, a national wireless reseller, provides prepay wireless service through a network of
carriers covering 98% of the United States. From inception, STC and its affiliates
distributed Telemac-Enabled™ handsets via national retailers and television direct
marketing.
In February 1999, STC entered into a marketing and distribution venture with MCI
WorldCom, adding one of the world’s most powerful telephony brands to Telemac’s
national prepay program. MCI WorldCom now has joint responsibility with STC for
distribution of Telemac-Enabled™ handsets, and for consumer marketing of MCI
WorldCom/STC prepay wireless services.
With the participation of MCI WorldCom, Telemac-Enabled™ handsets are now offered
via the Internet, national retailers such as KMart, Bradlees and Ames, and by Home
Shopping Network.
At the end of 1999, Telemac began marketing the Telemac Advantage™, a complete
end-to-end technology solution for digital prepay and SmartUse™ services. With this
program, Telemac has added sophisticated subscriber and line management technology
to its core Telemac Technology™.
Beginning in 2000, InterVoice-Brite Inc. (“InterVoice”) began U.S. marketing for the
BriteStar System™, which combines Telemac Prepay Technology™ with hardware and
software developed by InterVoice, as well as a fully managed call center and service
bureau operated by InterVoice. The BriteStar System™ was introduced in the U.K. in
1998 and has helped propel BT Cellnet to more than 5,000,000 subscribers.
Despite the need to create market acceptance for prepay services in the United States,
over 300,000 Telemac-Enabled™ handsets have been activated since June 1998.
EUROPE
In December 1997, Telemac entered into a marketing agreement with Brite Voice
Systems Inc. In mid-1999, Brite merged with InterVoice Inc., creating InterVoice-Brite,
Inc. (“InterVoice”), a highly regarded global technology firm. Working together, Telemac
and Brite developed the BriteStar System™, which offers compelling advantages,
including cost, rapid deployment, and an array of features.
On July 16, 1998, British Telecom's wireless affiliate, BT Cellnet launched service in the
U.K. using the BriteStar System™. BT Cellnet committed approximately US$8,000,000
in advertising to the launch of its initial Telemac prepay services: “Easy-Life” and “U”,
two programs that target different demographics with customized rate plans.
Today, BT Cellnet offers four separate prepay programs using the BriteStar System™,
with retail sales through over 20,000 stores and kiosks, and roaming service throughout
Europe. More than 5,000,000 Telemac-Enabled™ mobile phones have been activated in
the U.K. BT Cellnet’s prepay wireless program, one of the most successful wireless
programs in U.K. history, continues to grow.
Under the agreement, Vodacom has the right to launch both prepay and SmartUse™
services in Australia, Israel, Namibia, Seychelles and South Africa. As a result,
Telemac’s technology will be the foundation for prepay programs on every continent,
except only Antarctica and South America.
SMARTUSE™ SERVICES
As early as 1990, Telemac’s engineers had developed handset-based applications for
traditional post-pay customers. But, it was not until 1999 that Telemac began licensing
these uses to its customers.
During late 1999, Telemac began licensing SmartUse™ technology, a suite consisting of
various cost controls and tracking functions for traditional post-paid customers, as well
as handset-based transactional capabilities.
Telemac’s handset licensees are expected shortly to begin integration of enhanced IMA-
Modules incorporating SmartUse™.
In March 1999, Telemac entered into its first license for SmartUse™ technology, when it
included certain SmartUse™ features in its technology license and development
agreement with GSM Cellular.
HISTORY
In 1995, a small group of like minded prepaid phonecard leaders gathered with a simple
business plan and a grand vision: to develop a trade association representative of the
rapidly growing and extremely lucrative telecard industry. The association rested on a
key operating premise: that there be a unified interest among those involved early in
these efforts. All those employed in the industry, both then and now, have had an
ardent desire to see the prepaid world prosper and its consumers treated equitably. In
this way, companies that are in direct competition with one another professionally may
yet join forces for the good of the industry. From that early meeting grew the US
Telecard Association, located on Capitol Hill in Washington, DC, and maintained by a
staff headed then and now by Howard Segermark, Executive Director. The USTA quickly
became the unified industry voice on prepaid telecom issues. The founders of the USTA
also had a hand in the formation of the Canadian Telecard Association in 1997. To
reflect the wider scope of the prepaid industry abroad, the association changed its name
to the International Telecard Association soon thereafter and is now in the process of
taking on a more accurate mantle: the International Prepaid Communications
Association.
MEMBER COMPANIES
This new association name encompasses the wide variety of products and services our
members provide to the prepaid telecom arena, among them phonecards, dialtone, long
distance, wireless and VoIP. Members of the association represent an expansive array of
industry services and products: switched resellers, CLECs, wholesalers, distributors,
ISPs, vending machine operators, printers, software developers, service bureaus,
wholesale long distance distributors, IXCs, publishers, switchless resellers, legal and
regulatory consultants, RBOCs, IP telephony service providers, wireless providers, LECs,
brokers, agents, local service providers, promotional card producers, vendors, retailers,
professionals, media and dealers.
MEMBERSHIP BENEFITS
Membership in the ITA signifies a particular firm’s professional commitment to the
promotion and growth of the prepaid industry and a willingness to put ones business and
practices fully behind that commitment. The ITA has vastly expanded and evolved over
the past five years into an association representative of all aspects of the prepaid
market, and now speaks as a unified voice for an expansive array of member companies.
Committees of the ITA represent a wide array of industry interests and garner a high
level of active involvement from our members, and are as follows: Executive, Consumer
§ Represent the interest of our member companies in particular and of the industry
at large, before government agencies, legislatures, regulators and non-
governmental groups. This is accomplished via close interaction and networking
with, among others, state Public Utilities Commissions, Attorneys General, the
Federal Communications Commission and the Federal Trade Commission.
§ Develop technical and ethical standards for the prepaid industry and encourage
the upholding thereof. The ITA Phonecard Disclosure Guidelines have been
adopted by numerous regulatory bodies and enforced as the norm for those who
operate in the prepaid industry. The newly formed Committee on Prepaid
Wireless Affairs is also currently developing comparable industry disclosure
guidelines for the cellular segment of the industry.
With billing increasingly at the forefront of the telecoms debate on new services, the
Global Billing Association (GBA), formed in 1998, aims to promote a greater
understanding and awareness of the importance of billing processes and systems within
competitive environments.
One of the GBA’s key objectives is to enable operators to react quickly to market
changes, technological developments and new service offerings. In order to achieve this,
an unprecedented spirit of co-operation and mutual benefit is currently being fostered
between the demand and supply sides of the industry with a series of ground-breaking
discussion groups.
One major initiative has been the launch of the GBA Operators Focus Group, which has
been created to enable the GBA to address the more immediate problems facing Billing
Managers. The Group, led by Carl Hassan, Director of International Billing at Level(3)
and recently elected President of the GBA, deals with many of the universal issues that
impact carriers and operators globally, and output from this focus group benefits
members worldwide.
Additionally, last year the GBA identified four major themes that have been further
defined for 2001. This initiative has been successful in proving that a concentration of
resources and intellectual debate produces genuine results and benefits for members.
Workshops, facilitated by the GBA, allow service providers and carriers to exchange
views and share experience and information within a confidential and structured
environment. The findings of these workshops are then channeled back to members.
By providing a focus for the industry, the GBA is ideally placed to direct a channel of
information to the industry, and support a lobbying function that can alert other areas of
the communications world to potential problems before they escalate.
To conclude, the GBA is concerned with promoting the interests of the billing industry
worldwide, and ensuring de-regulation expertise and experience of multi-lingual, multi-
currency systems are shared as part of the global communications development. For
more information about the GBA and the benefits of membership, visit
www.globalbilling.org or contact the GBA on +44 131 225 7855.
Throughout this part of the report, we will discuss advanced concepts, applications, and
associated technologies relative to mobile prepay communications. Rather than attempt
to address each of these in sequence, we will label a discussion item as either a concept,
technology, or application as a given subject. We illustration this by the below example.
This will enable us to discuss advanced prepay in an order that makes more sense from
a content absorption perspective. For reference, the concepts, technologies, and
applications discussed in this section are as follows:
CONCEPTS
§ Mobile IN
§ Account spending limit
§ Location enabled prepay account replenishment systems
§ Pseudo Location Register
§ Prepay e-commerce applications
TECHNOLOGIES
§ Mobile IN standards
§ Mid-call control capabilities
§ Smart card technologies
APPLICATIONS
§ Account spending limit
§ Location sensitive billing for mobile prepay communications
§ Short messages to inform the customer and provide replenishment
3
SMSC
4
S PSTN
SM
USSD
1
Mobile
Switch VLR SS7 HLR
Visited
Network
FIGURE 7: ROAMING
Figure WITH
7: Roaming SIM
with SIM BASED
based SOLUTION
Solution
One of the cumbersome issues associated with both of these methods (USSD and SMS of
feature code initiation) is the need for the subscriber to remember the feature code,
which often vary in each country visited. SIM Toolkit (STK) enabled phones may be
employed to help alleviate this problem. The STK enables communication between the
SIM card (which contains a localized applet identifying the country and associated code)
and a database. The STK enabled phone initiates a signal (prior to call set-up) which
updates the feature code stored in the phone, allowing the user to initiate a call without
memorizing codes for each visited country.
IP
Network
Service Service
1 Node Node
Mobile
Switch 3
PSTN
Figure
FIGURE 8: 8: Roaming with
ROAMING WITHService Node based
SERVICE Solution
NODE BASED
Roaming in this solution requires signaling between the SN in the visited network and
the service node in the home network. First the mobile prepay customer (that is
roaming into the visited network) places a call, which is routed to the visited network SN
(step 1). Next, the visited network SN uses (typically an IP based network) to signal to
the home network service node for instructions for call handling (step 2). Once the
home network SN provides instructions back to the visited network SN, the visited
network SN routes the call back to the visited MSC for routing to the intended
destination via the PSTN.
Concept: Mobile IN
WHAT IS MOBILE IN
In the mobile prepay Communications Technical Introduction, we defined mobile IN and
discussed it at a high level. We will discuss mobile IN at a high level for review. Later in
the section we will discuss specific mobile IN technologies, capabilities, and enabled
applications.
Mobile intelligent network (IN) pertains to the concept of network intelligence. While the
notion of network intelligence is evolving beyond the traditional model of centralized
control and processing, and expanding to network edge devices such as mobile terminals
and servers, the use of the term mobile IN will be used in this report to refer to more
traditional centralized network intelligence. The below illustration depicts a high-level
mobile IN concept.
SCP
SS7
Mobile
Switch
FIGURE 9: MOBILE
Figure SWITCH
9: Mobile LAUNCHES
Switch Launches IN MESSAGE
IN Message to SCP TO SCP
The above diagram depicts a mobile switch that is launching a mobile IN message over
SS7 to a SCP. The SCP processes the request and subsequently provides a reply to the
§ Recognize mobile IN based services in the mobile user's profile (through HLR/VLR
interaction)
§ Arm a trigger with the appropriate network address of the SCP to launch the
message
By definition, the mobile switch is also known as a service switching point (SSP) in
mobile in IN terminology. A mobile switch that is not an SSP, and/or is not equipped the
with specific capabilities to handle messaging for IN based service invocation and
control, can not handle mobile IN based prepay.
Before mobile IN came into being, service invocation and control was relegated to the
switch itself and/or adjunct equipment such as a service node (SN). A SN engenders
more of a "point solution" as discussed in the first section of this report. While the SN
approach often provides a fast, low capital expenditure market entry alternative, it is not
as robust as mobile IN as all service control and logic is relegated to the SN itself. This
approach is also not "standards-based", meaning that SNs from various manufacturers
can not communicate with SNs and switches of other vendors. The SN approach also
does not scale as well an mobile IN solutions, meaning that large numbers of prepay
customers are not as efficiently served in terms of capital costs and equipment required.
The two recognized global standards for mobile IN are Wireless Intelligent Network
(WIN) and Customized Applications for Mobile Enhanced Logic (CAMEL). WIN and
CAMEL are the standards used to provide network intelligence in ANSI-41 and GSM
networks respectively. As WIN standards are introduced, accepted and evolve, they will
become part of the core ANSI-41 standards. In contrast, the GSM CAMEL Application
Part (CAP) represents that portion of the GSM standard that uses CAMEL, and will remain
a separate yet associated standard to the core GSM networking standard, GSM MAP.
However, WIN and CAMEL are both derived from the same intelligent network conceptual
model (INCM), a framework from which the Intelligent Network Application Part (INAP)
was spawned. INAP represents the IN architectural model conceived by the European
Telecommunications Standards Institute (ETSI) for use in fixed networks. Evolutionary
stages of INAP are defined by capability sets (CS) that represent continual improvements
in IN functionality. WIN and CAMEL architectures are based on the INCM framework,
utilizing many aspects of the INAP capability sets as that standard evolves, but also
include capabilities to address mobility management issues.
The term Mobile IN is sometimes associated with some better known centralized,
intelligent network type technologies such as SMS and the lesser known technologies
such as ISUP loop-back, which will be discussed in the section reviewing network based
prepay technology solutions. It is important to note, however, that when most people
involved in mobile network standards mention mobile IN, they are generally referring to
WIN, CAMEL, or perhaps proprietary vendor extensions of INAP. Unless other wise
stated, we refer to standards based mobile IN technologies when we speak of mobile IN.
IP IP
Mobile
Mobile
Switch SS7 Switch
Visited Home
System System
SCP
Equipped with
WIN/INAP/CAMEL
control logic
POSITIVE IMPACTS
We will next discuss positive impacts. Many of these impacts are of benefit to the mobile
operator and the prepay customer.
With a mobile IN based solution, triggers are armed in the visiting switch that allow it to
launch a message to the home network SCP, which contains the mobile prepay call logic.
When the mobile prepay customer places a call, the MSC in the visited network launches
a mobile IN message to the SCP (step 1) via the SS7 network. The SCP processes the
request and send a call handling instruction message back to the MSC (step 2). The
MSC then uses that instruction to handle the call (step 3), which is illustrated above as
routing to the PSTN for delivery either to the destination number, or in the event that
the prepay account has diminished, to a voice response unit for notification and/or
recharge.
Proprietary based mobile IN solutions will prohibit this type of scenario for the same
reason as the service node solution - lack of standard messaging. However, standards
based mobile IN solutions (based on WIN and CAMEL) allow for ease of implementation
between network operators with disparate MSC and SCP infrastructure.
With non-mobile IN solutions, call control and processing is relegated to static control of
various network and/or handset elements such as SN, subscriber identity module (SIM),
billing software, and others. On the other hand, mobile IN processes a prepay call and
then provides control back to other elements, taking control again only as necessary for
account management and/or feature interactions.
This enables the mobile operator to bring to bear a great breadth/depth of capabilities,
allowing feature and service opportunities that include:
§ Features and services for prepay customers that match those of post-paid
customers
§ New service support capabilities for more overall robust prepay service offerings
§ Roaming capability (ability to use prepay service while outside of home system).
Unlike point solutions, standards based mobile IN technologies enable capabilities
NEGATIVE IMPACTS
We will now discuss negative impacts. While the positive impacts outweigh the
negatives, fair treatment must be given to negative issues. In terms of purely financial
issues, business case analysis will suffice. However, technology limitations must be
dealt with in a different manner.
TIME TO DEPLOY
While the above issues are certainly non-trivial, they do not represent significant hurtles
in the long-run business plan. The major issue is timing. Well-developed business plans
will clearly indicate the long-term benefit of mobile IN based prepay. However, it is
likely that deployment of mobile IN will take a long time. Until sufficient operational and
service benefit economies of scale are reached, mobile IN capabilities will be rolled out
into major metropolitan areas first, with other areas following later to fill-in gaps in
service area. This also means that the largest mobile operators (those with a nationwide
and/or international service "footprint") will be the most likely to deploy mobile IN for
prepay quickly and extensively.
LIMITATIONS OF TECHNOLOGY
Mobile IN is not a panacea. Certain limitations exist that limit the benefits of deployment
and operation.
One limitation of mobile IN based solutions is that the processing is all centralized within
the mobile network. In contrast, SIM based solutions distribute processing requirements
and also lend themselves toward mobile commerce which we shall discuss later.
Another limitation was stated previously: timing/availability of mobile IN. Some mobile
operators may be slow to deploy mobile IN. Fewer still (very small) mobile operators
may never deploy mobile IN for prepay service. This limits the ability for those mobile
operators that have deployed mobile IN to fully realize the benefits for prepay services.
We will discuss resellers in a later section. We will also discuss a couple of potential
solutions to both of the above limitations.
OVERALL EFFECT
With mobile IN based prepay, the prepaid monitoring system is no longer in the call
path, and no longer needs to incorporate switching equipment. The overall effect is such
that mobile prepay communications is more efficient operationally, has less long-term
costs, and has greater opportunity for differentiation through advanced features and
add-on services.
Perhaps the best technical solution, however, will be a hybrid of mobile IN and smart
card based solutions. Mobile IN can be employed for network control of advanced
MOBILE IN TECHNOLOGIES
Thus far, we have spent considerable effort discussing some of the technological aspects
of prepay. However, in comparison to the business issues, the underlying technology is
of minimal importance, and in fact, should be totally transparent to the user. While
understanding the underlying technology enabling overall system capabilities is
important, the business issues are arguably the most important aspects of a prepay
operation and support.
Apart from patents and trade secrets, technology is ultimately duplicable. Therefore, in
order to focus on product differentiation, there should be a strong focus on business
issues and continuous improvement in the areas of market positioning, product support
and business processes. The next section discusses prepay support and business
processes while prepay offering strategies will be discussed in a later section.
TECHNOLOGIES
We will now discuss various mobile IN technologies. While there are several different
mobile IN technologies, all share the fact that they are network based. Network based
prepay solutions leverage the use of signaling networks for data capture, transmission
and processing. Network based solutions can be broken up into three categories: ISUP
based non-standard, TCAP based non-standard, and TCAP based standard.
ISUP loop-back also requires that the mobile switch contain pre-established translations
that force all prepay customer calls to route (and signal accordingly) over the loop-back
voice trunk. Similar to the point solution this limits customer management and the
ability to offer value added services. TCAP based IN solutions improve on these issues.
This solution was discussed in greater detail in the first part of this report.
Unlike the ISUP loop-back or the point solution, there are no dedicated resource
requirements with this solution. The only major limitation of the TCAP based non-
This solution was discussed in greater detail in the first part of this report.
Unless otherwise stated, we mean TCAP based standard solutions (WIN/CAMEL) when
we speak of mobile IN within this report.
WIN
As discussed earlier, Wireless Intelligent Network (WIN) is the standards based solution
for ANSI-41 based networks. Industry standards organizations have standardized WIN
based prepay. IS-826 was established to provide standards based capabilities for ANSI-
41 networks. One such capability is the capability to perform mid-call messaging and
control of resources. For example, when a prepay caller's account approaches a
predetermined level, the SCP can issue a message to play an announcement and even
release the call if the account reaches zero (see figure below).
SCP
IP
SS7
Mobile
Switch
PSTN
Additional capabilities are added with IS-826 to allow the mobile switch to tell prepay
account databases in the SCP to stop call recording upon disconnection of either the
called or calling party.
CAMEL
Whereas WIN is used for ANSI-41 based networks, Customized Applications for Mobile
Enhanced Logic (CAMEL) is the standards based solution for GSM based networks.
However, most mobile IN based prepay solutions for GSM are based on proprietary
extensions of INAP. This is remains the case primarily because the heretofore-available
version of CAMEL, CAMEL phase I, only has a subset of INAP capability set one (CS-1)
capabilities. Capability Sets are defined in the intelligent network call model as
fundamental capabilities for intelligent networking. For example, CAMEL phase I is
lacking in its ability to utilize the specialized resource function (SRF). The SRF function
provides the ability to utilize adjunct network elements such as the use of IPs for playing
announcements.
CAMEL phase II does allow for the SRF. Many mobile operators will begin to implement
CAMEL once phase II is available, providing the advantage of roaming along with
capabilities enjoyed in CS-1 equipped systems.
CAMEL phase II was defined in standards in 1998, but is only now being completed by
vendors in terms of development, integration and testing. Hardware and software
solutions for CAMEL phase II are in the early stages of implementation with a few mobile
operators across Europe.
One of the significant benefits of CAMEL based roaming versus other methods using SMS
is that is does not involve making multiple calls and tying them together. With CAMEL,
the switches in the visited network automatically signals a request the prepay application
in the home network for call-handling instructions.
PRE-CAMEL SOLUTIONS
We earlier discussed USSD and SMS call-back based solutions. These solutions
represent one approach as an interim step toward CAMEL for GSM prepay roaming.
Several mobile operators have adopted SMS as an interim step because it is relatively
simple, compatible with existing handsets, and available now. There is also an agreed
international billing standard for SMS (unlike USSD). However, the interface can be
somewhat cumbersome as the customer must use a particular menu and there can be
delay in processing due to the store-and-forward nature of SMS.
Alternative migration steps include the use of point solutions, which are typically based
on Service Node implementations in which all calls most be routed through a
programmable switch.
In Europe and portions of the United States that have GSM, INAP will eventually give
way to CAMEL based mobile IN enabled prepay services. However, the migration will not
be any faster than WIN since many of the INAP based prepay deployments enjoy the
core capabilities of CS-1.
MOBILE IN CAPABILITIES
We will now discuss some of the mobile IN capabilities in greater detail. Before we
discuss the first capability we will introduce the account spending limit concept.
Since mobile IN allows for any phone number to be utilized in conjunction with prepay
call processing, a post-paid phone number could be assigned to interact with the SCP to
allow only a certain number of calls and/or monetary value per period. The caller could
be alerted when a predetermined level is reached and afforded the opportunity to extend
the limit (with appropriate permission) or pay for calls based on credit.
One must be careful to recognize that ASL services suffer from the same constraint that
mobile IN based prepay services do: lack of universal deployment. This means that if a
serving mobile operator does not have the required capabilities, cost control will not be
available. In order to have truly robust ASL, all mobile operators most participate. At a
minimum, there must be technology put into place and cooperation to warn the ASL
customer when they roam into an area that does not support ASL.
IP
SS7
PDE
Mobile
Switch
PSTN
When a prepay customer with a low balance initiates a call, a mid-call trigger from the
prepay SCP can launch a message to establish a connection with a voice response unit
(VRU) in an IP. The VRU can announce the low balance condition and offer options for
replenishing the account. If the caller chooses to replenish, certain advanced capabilities
can be utilized to inform the caller where the closest replenishment merchant (with
prepay cards/vouchers) is located (see figure below).
Through communications from the VRU to the SCP, the SCP is alerted of this request (for
replenishment information). The SCP then launches a message to a location information
platform that interacts with position determination equipment (PDE) (such as E-OTD,
STK, A-GPS, and various network-based means such as TOA and AOA) and merchant
databases and in turn provides information to the SCP about the closest replenishment
establishment. The SCP provides this information to the VRU that in turn plays the
information to the prepay customer.
Note: See Part Five of this report for a discussion of location technology middle-ware and
positioning equipment.
Another valuable location based application for prepay that also benefits from mid-call
control capabilities is location sensitive billing (LSB) (see figure below).
Location
Application SCP Prepay
(LSB)
SCP
SS7
PDE
Mobile
Switch
PSTN
Upon initiating call processing, the prepay SCP launches a mid-call message to an LSB
application. The LSB interacts with PDE and also determines whether the prepay
customer is within or outside a predetermined calling zone. The LSB application returns
this information to the SCP that in turn utilizes the data to determine the appropriate call
rating for that zone and dialed number.
Application: Prepay call re-rating based on location sensitive billing and mid-call control
capabilities
In the above example of location sensitive billing, it was assumed that the caller was in a
fixed location. However, mid-call control can be used in conjunction with location
sensitive billing to determine if a prepay customer has left predetermined service zones.
Once the mid-call capabilities have determined if the prepay subscriber has left a
particular zone, the location sensitive billing application will alert the prepay system of
the zone change as indicated in the previous figure. This is a way in which the mobile
operator can protect/control the provision and use of zones in conjunction with
differentiated rate schemes for prepay service based on location.
ANSI-41 TECHNOLOGY
The Position Request (PosReq) message is a Wireless Intelligent Network (WIN) message
that allows the location sensitive billing application to determine the location of the
customer. This is facilitated by the location application launching a PosReq to the HLR of
the subscriber. The HLR in turn determines the appropriate VLR that is serving the
customer and requests location information, with cell ID being the most commonly
available information. Whether the VLR has the most up-to-date information is
problematic due to the fact that the customer may in transit and the VLR will get
updates only when the customer traverses location areas within the RF footprint.
Accordingly, additional technologies may need to be employed to extract the cell ID from
the mobile unit.
GSM
In GSM networks, the SIM Toolkit (STK) provides an API to the SIM for a variety of
applications including location determination. As in the above example, the location
application could launch a location request via a SMS message through the SMSC to the
SIM via the STK. At a minimum, cell ID can be extracted from the mobile unit, and
perhaps better location such as that provided by the timing advance calculations or the
network measurement report algorithms. In any event, STK enables mid-call positioning
as well as idle-mode positioning of the mobile unit.
The equivalent of the PosReq in GSM is the GSM Mobile Application Part (MAP) Any Time
Interrogation (ATI). The MAP ATI message also allows the location application to launch
a message to the HLR, but has the same issue of not necessarily getting the most up-to-
date location information. Additional work will likely be necessary to ensure that location
information from the base station subsystem is provided to the network switching
subsystem for ANSI-41 and GSM based networks that use strictly a mobile IN based
solution such as PosReq and MAP ATI respectively.
However, deploying prepay GPRS services with mobile IN is not without challenges.
CAMEL Application Part (CAP) phase 3, which has worked its way through the standards
process, but has not yet been commercially deployed. In the below diagram, we indicate
the architecture associated with CAP3 and the support of prepay GPRS.
gsmSCF
SCP
gprsSSF
SGSN
CAP3 provides for messaging between the interface of the Serving GPRS Support Node
(SGSN) and the SCP. More specifically, these functions are known as the GPRS Service
Switching Function (gprsSSF) and the GSM Service Control Function (gprsSCF). The
gprsSCF is where the applications reside – in this case, the mobile prepay application.
The gprsSSF is where the triggers reside – in this case, the mobile IN trigger for
launching the CAP3 message from the SGSN to the SCP.
CAP3 provides messaging between these interfaces to allow for service control. For
mobile prepay, this service control means that messaging will occur between the
gprsSSF and the gprsSCF. This messaging accomplishes the goal of letting the prepay
application know that a service event has occurred, just as in a voice call a mobile IN
message is sent to the application to indicate a request for service (either an incoming or
outgoing call attempt). In the case of this non-voice session utilizing GPRS as the
bearer, there is not a connection in the same sense. GPRS sessions are associated with
attachment or detachment of the GPRS device to the SGSN for purposes of
sending/receiving data and then ending the session. Accordingly, the gprsSSF trigger is
In terms of implementing, mobile IN based prepay GPRS, there are some issues of
technology availability. GPRS equipment such as Gateway GPRS Support Nodes (GGSN)
and SGSN are available and many operators are beginning to deploy. However, the
SGSN equipment does not yet support the gprsSSF function. In order to combat this
issue, mobile operators may need to consider forcing all GPRS traffic back to GGSN
(which do have gprsSSF) so that they may offer prepay GPRS services. While this would
be a drastic move, it is one that would be alleviated once vendors provide gprsSSF
functionality.
Mobile IN will benefit all of the target markets by virtue of lower cost prepay service due
to operational efficiencies enabled by the mobile IN architecture. We will now discuss the
implications of deploying/operating mobile IN regarding marketing to the above groups.
CREDIT CHALLENGED
Mobile IN will benefit the credit challenged by removing some of the sigma associated
with prepay service. Prepay users will no longer need to be assigned specific numbers
(as in a SN based solution) or specific phones (as in many handset-based solutions).
The credit challenged will also be availed to many services and features on a prepay
basis that they here-to-fore hand did not have access to use.
ANONYMITY MARKET
This market will not necessarily benefit as much from mobile IN technologies. In fact,
the ability to track usage will improve with mobile IN, something the anonymous user
does not want. Introduction of mobile IN will perhaps create a new market for non-
mobile IN based prepay service at a much higher price to the anonymous user market.
If you want "dumb" service that doesn't have records of your location and/or usage, you
have to pay a premium.
COST CONTROL
This market segment may be the biggest beneficiary. As discussed earlier, the ability to
offer ASL services will allow the truly cost control user to have the type of service and
support they want, without the necessary constraint of prepayment that comes with
non-mobile IN services.
IMPACT ON STRATEGY
ABILITY TO OFFER MORE CUSTOMIZED OVERALL SERVICE TO PREPAY
CUSTOMERS
Service can be more customized with mobile IN technologies. The prepay customer can
choose which additional services are desired, rather than assuming they are unavailable.
This will allow the mobile operator the flexibility to market to groups that were
previously ignored once the initial sale is made. This also underscores the importance of
tracking customer usage and behaviors. We refer back to our discussion in the first part
of this report regarding call detail records and service detail records (SDR). Capturing
and acting on SDRs will be especially important in terms of target marketing to meet the
service and feature needs of various prepay user groups and sub-groups.
POTENTIAL SOLUTIONS
Now we will discuss some potential solutions to the above issues.
IP
SS7
Mobile
Switch
PSTN
Call control could be relinquished to INAP based systems in the event that specialized
resources are required as depicted in the above illustration where INAP based SCPs
direct call control to an IP for announcements. However, this does not solve the problem
of no mobile IN capability and/or the potential that the serving mobile operator may
simply not wish to participate in mobile IN service interactions.
In the first part of this report, we reviewed various network elements such as the HLR,
VLR, and MSC. We also discussed the registration process. However, if a serving
systems does not participate in mobile IN based prepay, the prepay customer will be
unable to register with a WIN/CAMEL trigger profile and thus be unable to utilize mobile
IN based prepay. One solution is to implement a PLR (see figure below).
Home
MSC/HLR System
PLR SCP
SN
SS7
MSC/VLR
PSTN
Visited System
In the above illustration, the PLR (software logic on an SCP) can receive a registration
from the serving system MSC/VLR. The response back to the VLR can be to "hotline" all
calls from the mobile customer. These hot-lined calls would be directed to some other
resource such as a SN (typically located in the home system) for processing. While not
as efficient (from a trunking perspective) as seamless mobile IN, this architecture allows
the home system mobile operator to provide relatively consistent and robust prepay
service to its customers (through the capabilities of the SN) even when the serving
system does not have mobile IN capabilities. While not all of their services would
necessarily be available as they roam, customers would at least be assured that they
could use basic prepay services when roaming.
The PLR is also an alternative for resellers who want to offer basic mobile IN based
services to some customers (with efficient roaming) and perhaps more advanced
services (but yet less efficient due to back-hauling) through the SN.
Through interaction between the mobile IN enabled systems and a short messaging
service center (SMSC), the SMSC could be utilized to send short messages (on a
programmatic and/or on-demand basis) to inform the prepay customer of account
status.
SMS can also be the vehicle to provide the mobile user prepay card/voucher codes for
replenishment of the account via a VRU. In the first part of this report, we discussed the
concept of service detail records (SDR). If an SDR record/trend indicates that a prepay
customer has not replenished very much (or a long time ago), an SMS message could be
sent to the user, alerting him that he will have a discount on his next prepay voucher if
he buys now.
Advanced prepay capabilities are potentially another key element in this chain of
technologies and business trends. It is likely that many e-commerce applications will
either require prepayment or at least make more sense with it.
Prepayment of tolls would be popular with commuters wishing to not slow down while
going through a toll facility. This could be accomplished with a Bluetooth enabled phone.
Prepayment of public transportation could work in the same manner.
Prepayment could be used for many third generation mobile driven services. Examples
include prepayment for games, gambling, financial trading, and ad hoc service needs
such as video calling and picture/video recording.
The needs for prepayment for these e-commerce services meet the same target markets
as those for traditional voice oriented prepay services including credit challenged,
temporary and infrequent use, anonymity market and cost control. However, the impact
In Europe, consumers are much more accustomed to the use of smart card technology
for prepayment and debit based purchasing of goods and services. Therefore, many e-
commerce services will likely be embraced much more quickly in Europe versus the
United States. Ironically, however, mobile IN may prove to be even more critical for
prepay e-commerce in the United States (where there are few smart cards utilized). The
mobile IN platform can provide the prepay account management for non-smart card
based e-commerce applications.
SUMMARY
Mobile prepay communications has a bright future due to the capabilities made possible
through deployment of advanced technologies. Within the next five years, we will
witness expanded exploitation of mobile IN technology for prepay service.
Consequently, we shall also see expansion of services to prepay customers and
corresponding expansion of revenues to mobile operators. The acceleration of this
growth will be limited partially by technology availability but perhaps more so by
hesitancy on the part of the mobile operator to deploy.
MARKETING
We will begin by discussing the marketing issues associated with mobile prepay
communications services. As we have discussed in earlier publications, technology is an
enabler of business. Withstanding patents and trade secrets, technology can ultimately
be duplicated. However, sound marketing and business strategy can create success and
long standing barriers to entry against competitors.
PRODUCT
The product is mobile prepay communications, with a clear need in the marketplace, so
the important point is the manner in which the product is positioned in the marketplace
(see target market). Therefore, promotion and place is key to success.
PROMOTION
An excellent example of the power of promotion (or lack thereof) is the fact that, by and
large, prepay remains stigmatized as a merely a "credit challenged" service in the United
States. This could not be further from the truth as tremendous the success of prepay in
other market segments has been proven in other parts of the world.
PLACE
This P has to do with marketing and distribution. The more that the prepay customer
believes in the value of the service, the more that she will use it. Convenient recharge
will enable this model to perpetuate.
4
As technology matures, it will enable new business processes that will change the face
of the prepay market. However, careful optimization of the four P's remains a
fundamental tenant of success.
The increasingly active lifestyle of today dictates the need for anytime, anywhere
communications. This is no less true for prepay customers as they have the need to
roam and have the same service as in their home market. Accordingly, service
providers must provide seamless service at reasonable rates to prepay customers.
Prepay service is a perfect illustration of people's desire to have more control over
their lives - in this case, control over expenditures. A case in point would be the
father who wants to have assurance that his daughter in college can call home when
necessary but have only a limited discretionary calling "budget" thanks to mobile
prepay communications. We will expand on this example in the Business Strategies
for profitable Business section.
The Internet society we live in today has changed and will continue to change our
expectations of how we share information. Mobile Internet will change our
expectations further as we will no longer be tethered to a fixed network for access to
information. Prepay service will play an important role as many people will find
prepayment a convenient and in some cases required for transactions. A mobile
operator does not want to send a bill to someone for pizza. However, they can
4
As outlined in the Advanced Prepay Concepts and Applications part of this report
The time of when consumers would accept whatever is offered is long gone.
Customers are increasingly savvy of technology and its capabilities. Once exposed
to technology in one area, it is easy for consumers to assume that it should be
available via another medium. For example, why shouldn't instant messaging be
available on mobile phones? Why shouldn't this leverage location technology to
locate friends and co-workers? We will witness the mobile device increasingly
become a device to make our lives not just easier but higher quality lives. Many of
these services will be paid for in advance of use.
CREDIT CHALLENGED
The credit-challenged segment of the market consists of individuals who have not yet
established credit or who have impaired credit. In the United States, this market
segment represents approximately 30% or more of all requests for mobile service.
Wireless carriers meet this demand by offering pay-in-advance mobile service, limiting
their liability and risk of loss.
Temporary users are not travelers. Instead, they seek prepay as a means of short-term
mobile communication, allowing them service without the service commitment
agreement that many mobile carriers require for post-paid service.
The glove box user is the term applied to infrequent users. This group has a phone
primarily for safety and security purposes and is typically located in the glove box of
their car until needed in an emergency or for road assistance. This group does not need
post-paid service to make emergency calls, as they are free to any caller. Mobile users
in this segment do not want to commit to a post-paid rate either for normal calling.
Many post-paid calling plans entail a flat monthly fee for a certain number of minutes.
The infrequent user does not use all his minutes, making the effective cost per minute
ANONYMITY MARKET
The anonymity market contains individuals who prefer the discretion of conducting
business in a pay-in-advance manner. This group does not consist only of individuals
who may be engaged in illegal or immoral activities. In fact, mobile users who regularly
carry and use a business owned phone might find prepay a useful alternative for
personal calls, rather than carrying a separate phone.
COST CONTROL
This category is the broadest and expected to be potentially the largest growth segment
for prepay services. This segment includes the cost conscious and family-use consumer
markets as well as the enterprise market for cost control. Examples include mobile
service budget limits for college students and cost control for corporate fleet operation
communications.
OTHERS
We have discussed the major segments, but there are other potential drivers for prepay
usage. For example, a prepay service is sometimes purchased as a gift. Purchasing a
prepay service is also generally more convenient as little or no information is required
from the customer by the sales agent. Finally, mobile carriers and resellers can market
prepay service on an affinity basis; prepay cards or vouchers can be easily associated
with affinity groups such as the Boy Scouts. Customers will sometimes buy prepay cards
due to the affiliation or perhaps even as a collector’s item.
1. Make sure that people are on the right plan to maintain their loyalty (prevent them
from churning to another network)
2. Try to steer people to the plan that provides the best profit margins to the mobile
prepay service provider
Balancing the two above goals can be quite difficult, as they can at time be mutually
exclusive objectives. It is incumbent on the service provider to optimize the service
offerings, while keeping them relatively simple, easy to understand and use, and
allowing customers to recognize and appreciate the value.
One thing that is common among all markets, however, is that prepay service is
effective at each stage of the product life cycle including:
ASIA PACIFIC
Just as in Europe, mobile prepay is a growing market segment, especially for new mobile
network provider market entrants. With high mobile penetration in certain countries,
mobile prepay represents and opportunity to further expand market penetration into new
market segments. In some of the larger, yet less developed countries such as China,
India and Indonesia, mobile prepay is an opportunity to kick-start the penetration of
mobile service into a large base of potential subscribers.
§ Australia 53%
§ Burnei 34%
§ China 7%
§ Hong Kong 74%
§ India < 1%
§ Indonesia 2%
§ Japan 45%
§ Malaysia 27%
§ New Zealand 51%
§ Singapore 76%
§ South Korea 56%
§ Taiwan 79%
§ Vietnam 1%
INDONESIA
Of the approximate 3.4 mobile customers in Indonesia, about 75% are prepay
customers, with about 85% of all new customers added to the prepay base. While an
excellent penetration for prepay of the total customers, total mobile penetration in
Indonesia remains at approximately 2% of the population. Indonesia is an excellent
example of an opportunity exploit prepay as a means of building a mobile services
business to sustainable and profitable operational levels.
EUROPE
Europe leads the world in overall mobile penetration. Below is the penetration in a few
select countries as of June 2000:
§ Finland 76%
§ Italy 62%
§ Ireland 56%
Prepay is growing at a brisk pace in Europe with some operator's prepay penetration
over 70%. The overall average penetration is just above 50% in Western Europe as
prepay overtook post-paid in 2000. Prepay is expected to overtake post-paid in Eastern
Europe in the 2003 timeframe.
While prepay is enjoying great success in Europe, customer retention is a major issue
due to mobile number portability (MNP) and the ability of customers to switch operators.
We shall discuss MNP more later in this report.
AUSTRIA
According to the Strategis Group, MaxMobil of Austria had 1,200,000 prepay customers
against a total customer base of 2,100,000 as of Q4 2000.
CZECH REPUBLIC
Prepay penetration in the Czech Republic is about 76% of total mobile customers.
LITHUANIA
Prepay penetration is 39% of total customers against a mobile penetration of about
13%.
UNITED KINGDOM
The UK is enjoying splendid growth in mobile prepay. For example, from the January
15th, 2001 edition of Wireless Week:
§ Vodafone added 1.4 million customers is Q4/2000 - 1.2 million were prepay
§ One 2 One grew to 8 million plus customers by Q4/2000 - 6.4 millions of those
are prepay
According to the Strategis Group, BT Cellnet had 6,690,000 prepay customers against a
total customer base of 10,244,000 as of Q4 2000.
MIDDLE EAST
LEBANON
According to the Strategis Group, FTML-Cellis of Lebanon had 255,000 prepay customers
against a total customer base of 382,000 as of Q4 2000.
LATIN AMERICA
As much as 73 percent of the mobile customer growth in Latin America is expected to
come from prepay through 2003. Prepay currently represents slightly less than 50% of
all overall customers in Latin America as of 2001.
50.0%
40.0%
Penetration
30.0% Contract
20.0% Prepaid
10.0%
0.0%
1999 2000 2001 2002 2003
Year
CANADA
According to the Canadian Wireless Telecommunications Association, as of March 31,
2000, prepay penetration was about 17% overall across mobile network operators. The
breakdown:
MEXICO
Prepay represents the method of service for approximately 80% of the mobile users in
Mexico. One of the factors that led to this significant growth was the strategy of mobile
operators to extend the expiration limit on the prepay account, allowing the customer to
wait longer to use the airtime. This is a very good example of a specific demographic
and target market need that, when met, led to improved penetration of service.
UNITED STATES
Prepay is growing at a more moderate rate in the US.
60.0%
50.0%
40.0%
Penetration
Contract
30.0%
Prepaid
20.0%
10.0%
0.0%
1999 2000 2001 2002 2003
Year
MARKETING STRATEGIES
We will next discuss marketing and sales strategies for prepay service providers.
CARRIERS/OPERATORS
Mobile operators are at the top of the value chain in terms of prepay service delivery and
in the best position to fully realize the opportunity. Whereas resellers must buy airtime
from the wireless carrier, the mobile operator has control over those costs, thereby
allowing the carrier to focus on market segment differentiation and delivery of value-
added services. Examples of some innovative mobile operator prepay programs are as
follows:
§ Teensafe programs - prepay service wherein the child can only call emergency
number and home number
§ Campus phone - prepay service wherein the student has unlimited campus
5
calling at a prepay flat-rate, can make calls outside of campus at the prevailing
rates, can call home anytime/anywhere at a flat rate, and can call emergency
number anytime/anywhere
§ Personal use of business mobile phone - many employees have a mobile phone.
The mobile operator could offer a plan wherein the customer may have unlimited
6
use of the phone while at the home zone .
RESELLERS
It is more difficult for resellers to create differentiation, as they do not have control over
the enabling infrastructure. Furthermore, resellers do not have control over costs, as
they must buy airtime from the wireless carrier. Resellers must therefore focus primarily
on certain market segments and/or develop unique marketing programs.
Institute special co-marketing programs such as alliances with roadside assistance and
traffic information services. Calls to these businesses are free. The towing service pays
5
Note: This service would require location technology for service.
6
Note: This service would require location technology for service.
If the mobile operator allows, offer personal number service and/or SMS to help create
loyalty to the reseller.
RECHARGE METHODS
There exist various methods prepay customer recharge. These methods, along with
their advantages and disadvantages, are as follows:
§ High "touch" of human interaction is perhaps the only acceptable method for
some customers
DISADVANTAGES
§ Expensive to service provider
§ Inconvenient compared to other methods
HANDSET
This method entails a customer self-replenishing via the handset. Various options are
available including over the air via SMS, WAP, or USSD or IVR via DTMF.
DISADVANTAGE
§ Must authenticate the user - chance for fraud
RETAIL OUTLET
This method entails recharge at a retail point-of-sale (POS) location such as a
convenience store or department store. The most common payment option is a
In the United States, retail outlet locations for distribution of prepay cards fall roughly
into the following percentages:
As discussed in Part One of this report, POS activation (POSA) is an important issue.
Activating cards at the POS helps in the following ways:
§ Allows cards to be placed on store shelves (rather than placed out of sight in cash
draws)
§ Allows for consignment billing - the ability to keep cards separate from the
physical product/service - the mobile phone and prepaid service - allowing
merchants to keep a zero cost inventory (they only pay for cards once activated -
allows no risk, low cost merchandizing)
DISADVANTAGES
§ Customers may spend money on beer instead of phone
§ Fraud at point-of-sale
ATM
This method entails recharge at an automatic teller machine (ATM).
7
Use once and throw away.
DISADVANTAGE
§ Not all ATM's will work with prepay replenishment system
§ Must either have special ATM to produce voucher or establish financial clearing
with prepay account card provider
INTERNET
This method entails recharge via the Internet. This will typically occur via a PC from a
fixed network. As WAP and other non-voice technologies expand, however, Internet
based replenishment will increasingly occur while mobile.
DISADVANTAGE
§ Not all customers are willing to replenish via the Web
§ Must either have special ATM to produce voucher or establish financial clearing
with prepay account card provider
PAYMENT OPTIONS
CREDIT CARD
This entails the use of a charge or credit card such as American Express, Visa, or
Mastercard.
ADVANTAGES
§ Convenience - the customer does not need to have cash
DISADVANTAGES
Transfer from bank account
This entails transfer of monies from a bank account to a prepay account.
Advantages
§ Independent of card distribution
§ No margin share with card issuer
Disadvantages
§ Cumbersome
§ Takes up to seven days
Advantages
§ Easy to use
§ Dealers like follow-up business
§ Dealer participation in airtime
Disadvantages
§ Good distribution is critical
§ Security and fraud must be managed at point-of-sale
§ Margin, handling, and administrative cost
8
§ Customers may want non-standard replenishment amount
Account card
This method utilizes a permanent card that is used to recharge a prepay account. The
card has a magnetic strip for use at the point-of-sale. The card also has a serial number
and PIN for replenishment via the Internet, ATM, handset, or call center.
Advantages
§ Creates affinity between user and provider
§ Allows purchase of non-standard amount for recharge
Disadvantages
§ Has to be replaced if lost
§ Recharge can not be given as a gift to existing customers
§ Call center
§ IVR via DTMF
§ Handset via SMS, WAP or USSD
§ Internet (from PC)
8
Most debit cards are sold in standard face-value amounts determined by the issuer
The user may be alerted via the mechanisms mentioned above in the balance check
section. While it is a given that these capabilities must be made available by the mobile
operator, the important issue for discussion is policy regarding when and how to alert.
Mechanisms must be in place to alert the user immediately when a low balance threshold
is met, allowing the customer the opportunity to recharge prior to being disconnected
(upon reaching zero balance) or be reverted to an IVR, either scenario being a
inconvenience and/or potentially embarrassing. Beyond this initial alert, the mobile
operator must have churn prediction algorithms and marketing and loyalty programs in
place to prevent churn and encourage recharge. Service Detail Records (SDR) discussed
in the first part of this report are an important element of churn prediction and policy
regarding implementation of loyalty programs.
SUMMARY
While prepay customers will go out of their way for initial purchase of phone and airtime,
they wan convenience for recharge, or they are likely not to replenish at all.
Accordingly, mobile operators need to implement effective marketing and replenishment
strategies.
Certain companies such as SLP InfoWare provide predictive CRM tools for providing an
early warning when customers may churn to other mobile operators prepay plan. These
Marketing programs should address at least three tiers of users: moderate to high end
cost control users, credit challenged moderate users, and low-end glove box users. High
end users should be targeted to receive digital phones, advanced features, and low rates
(with perhaps post-paid service using a prepay process to provide cost control), and
advanced features. These users should also have the most attractive loyalty programs.
Credit challenged moderate users should be targeted with analog phones that have an
associated higher per minute service rate or more expensive digital phones with a lower
per minute service rate and should receive good loyalty plans based on their actual
replenishment rate. They should also be targeted with value-added services to drive up
revenue per unit and usage. Location Sensitive Billing (LSB) could be used to increase
their usage.
Glove box users can be targeted with analog phones and, in return for longer voucher
shelf life (time before account credits expire), they should pay the highest rate plans for
service. They could also receive loyalty programs geared toward infrequent
replenishment. Finally, they should be offered services such as LSB to attempt to move
them to the next tier in terms of usage.
At the discretion of the mobile operator, certain mechanisms may need to be put in force
to prevent the number of SMS messages from becoming prohibitive and/or prevent
messages from certain sources, as the customer is paying a flat, prepaid rate for SMS
Many of the feature add-on's can and should be marketed to the customers as they are
engaging in activities such as account monitoring and recharge. The Internet is a perfect
low-cost, 24 hours/day vehicle to promote these add-on's.
These vouchers can be easily offered in a variety of high profile, low-cost manners such
as attaching them to consumer goods and banner advertisements. These virtual cards
could even be given away as gifts by other merchants (such as a thank you for doing
business and/or completing a survey), allowing the mobile operator to leverage a very
low-cost distribution network.
The idea is to get consumers to try a given mobile operator's prepay service in situations
in which the consumer already has a phone and either post-paid or prepay service from
another plan.
Since the vouchers are a virtual unit (no physical card), they may be distributed via the
Internet. They may even be exchanged via email or SMS between business and
customer, friend, and colleague.
Perhaps the best use of such a strategy will be in support of certain mobile commerce
business models. For instance, an existing mobile prepay customer may listen to an
advertisement from a merchant in exchange for a voucher at the end of the ad as a
reward. This type of mobile commerce would be particularly more useful with the
implementation of additional technologies such as location based applications. The user
could be pin-pointed as being near a merchant location and then be offered the
advertisement in return for the reward of prepay time on the account. The award could
even include a discount on merchandise from the merchant.
The proverbial “double edged sword”, however, is that these resellers will also want
access to WIN and CAMEL triggers necessary to offer value-added services. Mobile
carriers are likely to want to offer access to basic service for prepay but want to limit
access to potentially differentiating capabilities.
TECHNOLOGY ISSUES
As discussed earlier, technology deployment will be driven by market needs.
This provides an advantage at the point-of-sale as the user is easily identified for
replenishment discounts based on loyalty. It can also provide a marketing advantage as
cards can be branded or co-branded (again like ATMs), allowing users to replenish
wherever they see the brand name displayed.
MOBILE IN
It should be the goal to ultimately deploy mobile IN based prepay systems. The benefits
of mobile IN are numerous, but what about the lack of ubiquitous triggers for an
estimated five years? CAMEL and WIN will not support serving carriers that do not have
the triggers, but there is a way around this issue.
DIGITAL PHONES
Digital phones should be provided initially to high-end prepay customers as prices
continue to drop and ultimately to every customer as the increased system capacity and
potential for feature deployment also benefits the operator.
COMMERCIAL OFFERINGS
EUROPE VS. UNITED STATES
Prepay is huge in Europe, with some operators enjoying 50% or more prepay
penetration. Some PCS carriers in the United States are realizing comparable success,
but by and large the penetration rate is somewhere around 5% of the overall customer
base. This is expected to change, however, with some estimates ranging too as high as
20% of overall prepay penetration in the United States by the end of the year 2002.
Prepay is a more mature and accepted service in Europe. This is due to cultural
differences as well as to technology. There is no stigma in Europe associated with
prepay service. In the United States, some people assume that a person is “credit
challenged” if they have a prepay phone, when in fact they may merely desire cost
control. Another reason that there is a more mature attitude towards prepay is Europe
is the same reason post-paid is more prominent. GSM is a ubiquitously available
technology, allowing customers to roam from country to country and SIM based prepay
allows customers to use their service virtually everywhere throughout the whole of
Europe.
Europe also has a well-established Calling Party Pays (CPP) mentality and the network to
support it. Unlike the flat-rate local calling (from fixed network to another fixed number)
available in the United Stated, Europeans are accustomed to paying usage sensitive
pricing for all calls (local, long distance, and calls to mobile numbers). In Europe, mobile
numbers are all assigned to the same major number block (like an NPA or Area Code in
the United States). This means that a caller always knows when they are calling a
mobile number (a call that usually costs more than calls to a local wireline number).
Due to the pervasiveness of CPP in Europe, mobile prepay users (like post-paid users)
receive proportionately more incoming calls than their United States counterparts.
Everything else considered equal, this means more revenue for the mobile operator.
The situation is currently much different in the United States where the premium for
prepay service can be as much as two to three times that of a post-paid service. This is
beginning to change, however, as some operators are offering prepay pricing plans that
are approaching the per minute cost of some of their own post-paid plans.
Perhaps the reason for the difference in pricing between Europe and the United States
has to do with market maturity and ubiquitous technology. As we discussed, prepay has
been more mainstream in Europe for a long time relative to the United States. This is
due to the ubiquitous nature of GSM SIM solutions and the effect on consumer behavior
due to other pervasive technologies such as CPP. These cross continental difference are
likely to change as mobile IN is deployed as the standard in the United States for prepay
service, driving innovation, greater service flexibility, and lower prices.
In addition, many prepay providers in the United States heavily subsidize the cost of the
mobile phone, or in the case of some resellers, offer cheaper model refurbished phones.
In contrast, Europeans view prepay as a convenience - not just for the credit challenged
or those with little money. The cost for phones tends to not be heavily subsidized in
Europe. Next, we compare and contrast prepay pricing plans, using select mobile
operators in England and the United States for comparison.
BT CELLNET
Type of Calling Cost (Pence)
Standard Call Rates (peak/off peak/weekends) 25/10/2p
Calls to other BT Cellnet mobiles (peak/off peak/weekends) 10/10/2p
Calls to other mobiles (peak/off peak/weekends) 50/25/25p
Text messaging (per message) 10p
Voicemail 10p
Mobile Internet 10p
9
Information to compare and contrast these select mobile operators' calling plans was derived from each
respective company's web page, which reflected then current calling plans. Neither the author and Mobile
Lifestreams nor can be responsible for any changes that may occur after publication.
ORANGE
Just Talk
§ Calls from as little as 5p/minute off-peak
§ Text messaging from as little as 5p/message
Out There
§ Five free text messages per day
§ Up to 60 seconds of free calling if account goes to zero
On Campus
§ Calls from as little as 3p/minute off-peak
§ Text messaging from as little as 3p/message
VIRGIN 10
Prepay and post-paid calling is the same price
VODAFONE
Smartstep
§ Cost for first three minutes of use each day: 25p/minute
§ Cost for calls after first three minutes use each day: 5p/minute
§ Calls to other mobile operator's customers: 40p/minute (any time)
Allcalls
§ Monday-Friday: 35p/minute peak and 10p/minute off-peak
10
Many know Virgin only as an airline. They are also a mobile virtual network operator.
Original
§ Monday-Friday: 35p/minute peak and 5p/minute off-peak
§ Weekends: 2p/minute
§ Calls to other mobile operator's customers: 50p/minute peak and 30p/minute off
peak weekdays and 30p/minute weekends
Recharge methods
AT&T wireless provides three ways to recharge including online, calling a toll-free
number, and visiting an AT&T store or authorized dealer.
All calls outside the Cingular Wireless network are charged at $1.95/minute.
SPRINT PCS
Sprint PCS recently discontinued its own prepay program. However, Sprint PCS
launched its Private Label Services program last year, a distribution channel for wireless
resale. Through this program, wireless resellers will develop and promote their own
branded programs, with network services provided on the Sprint PCS network. Among
other things, this program allows affiliates to use the Sprint PCS network to sell mobile
prepay service.
VERIZON WIRELESS
Verizon recently rolled-out a National Prepay Wireless plan, which requires a tri-mode
phone and includes the following:
One might ask questions like: "Why care if customers migrate from prepay to post-paid
anyway?" "Doesn't the mobile operator get to keep the revenues anyway?"
The point here is that the mobile operator must first KEEP the customer if they are to get
any revenues. It is much cheaper to keep a customer then to obtain a customer, even
for prepay. Accordingly, mobile operators must fight to keep their prepay customers on
their prepay plans, lest they try another operator's post-paid or prepay service.
While for certain market segments, prepay remains a convenience, one of future
impetuses for migrating to post-paid service is simply cost. Particularly when mobile
operators roll out 3G networks, new business models will emerge in which non-voice
services garner higher fees and voice based services become more of a commodity. In
this scenario, 3G based post-paid voice may be significantly cheaper than 2G based post
or prepay service. While this again does not affect the operator (so long as they can
keep the customers on their own network), it does affect the prepay industry.
Accordingly, the ability to support prepaid 3G voice and data services will be particularly
important.
Throwaway Phones
A currently small, yet grow threat to the prepay industry is the emerging throw away
phone market segment. Companies like Dieceland (www.dtcproducts.com) are
developing disposable mobile phones and computing devices. The notion is that people
will buy a throwaway phone as a convenience, and perhaps because it is cheaper, rather
than purchase a (normal, durable) phone and simply recharge when needed. Perhaps a
good commercial example would be the success of disposable cameras.
While this notion may seem crazy to some people, it actually has merit in certain market
segments. For example, the traveling customer who does not have roaming service
from his mobile prepay provider would definitely be a customer for such a product. This
underscores the one of the business drivers for the need for improved roaming support
for mobile prepay, which we discuss in the next section. Even if roaming is supported, if
there is not a convenient mechanism in place for replenishment, disposable phones are
still a viable option for the traveler.
Another market segment for this type of product is the gift market. People would be
much more inclined to purchase a disposable phone that costs $10.00 (and has 30
minutes of airtime) rather than pay $100-$300+ for a phone plus airtime. The recipient
Competitive threats such as these underscores the need for mobile operators to
engender loyalty and offer differentiated, value-added services to their traditional prepay
customers. If successful, mobile operators could actually exploit such a threat (the
disposable phone product) as an opportunity to gain airtime revenues while getting new
customers try a low-end prepay service as a prelude to up-selling to a more valuable
traditional prepay service.
It is important to note that this disposable technology for mobile communications has
not yet been commercially proven. We shall watch developments here closely.
While supplying temporary phones and vouchers is always an option, it is certainly not
the best option in a world in which seamless service is expected. Despite the inherent
challenges of weaving together disparate networks and prepay systems, mobile
operators must strive to ensure seamless roaming among all major mobile network
roaming partners.
NON-VOICE SERVICES
Leading mobile operators are beginning to deploy prepay non-voice services such as
Wireless Application Protocol (WAP). This enables the wireless carrier to offer WAP
services to a much broader customer base than if restricted to post-paid alone. While
WAP services have been historically based on circuit switched connections and billing is
based on access duration, WAP services that use GPRS as the bearer will be packet
switched and billing will be based on amount of data accessed as well as content based
pricing scenarios.
In order to fully support prepay WAP customers, mobile operators will need to support
separate rate access, throughput, and content billing. This will also enable revenue
share with content providers for services to prepay customers.
Logica recently announced the launch of its prepaid billing platform, which allows for
billing messaging services on a prepaid basis, without the need for a CDR (hot billing)
type solution which is prone to fraud.
We discussed earlier that prepay customers desire to have the same types of service
features as post-paid customers. This is also the case with GPRS enabled WAP features
which introduces the possibility for a variety of new types of features including:
§ File transfer
§ Remote LAN access and various other corporate applications such as collaborative
working
The advantages of faster connection speed and immediacy of information enable all of
these services. Furthermore, the always-on capability enabled by GPRS will facilitate
many "push" type services as we have seen already in offerings such as NTT DoCoMo's
iMode service which also uses a packet network for mobile data.
By definition, push services are those that do not require user interaction at the time the
service is delivered. Instead, the customer establishes a relationship with the content or
application provider in advance. Examples include daily jokes or horoscopes, news and
financial information, or other alerts and entertainment.
The key issue here is how to pull all of these technologies together so that it is seamless
to the customer and efficient and cost effective to the mobile operator.
As a case in point for the virtue of moving ahead aggressively, BT Cellnet was the first
European operator to commit to large-scale prepaid WAP deployment, allowing them to
lock in up to 90% of the prepay WAP market in the UK in 2000.
It is also believed that mobile prepay is perhaps the best vehicle for most mobile
commerce situations in which a micro-payment is required.
We will next discuss some of the market trends and the potential future of prepay in this
area.
§ Debit cards - These are typically throw-away or virtual cards whose only
purpose is to recharge the prepay account. Often these cards are sold at
merchant locations and must be activated at the point of sale wherein the prepay
customer may immediately replenish the prepay account or wait until later.
§ Account cards - These cards are sturdy, reusable cards and look just like typical
consumer debit/credit cards, but are used to provide account information. The
mobile prepay user will typically use the magnetic strip on the card to replenish
his account at a point of sale location.
§ Smart cards - These are the cards that are embedded with a microchip and used
to provide mobile prepay service with the handset. A Subscriber Identity Module
(SIM) is a perfect example of a smart card.
Of the three types of cards, the last two best lend themselves towards mobile commerce
as they are permanent cards that may be used for more than just the purpose of
recharging the prepay account for minutes.
Account cards and smart cards are the vehicles for the notion of a Universal Card that
may be charged with value that may be used in a variety of commerce. The idea is that
the card could be used for a multitude of consumer needs such as shopping, bill paying,
and entertainment.
Bluetooth establishes a personal area network (PAN) between all bluetooth enabled
(typically mobile) devices. For example, the PAN enables a mobile phone to
communicate with a laptop, making things such as prepaid Internet from the mobile
phone company more of a reality.
Ad hoc networking will allow the smart card-enabled mobile phone to make payments as
well as recharge the smart card.
Payment Scenario: The prepay customer walks up to a refreshment dispenser and gets
a beverage. This is facilitated by Bluetooth communication between the mobile unit and
the beverage machine. Bluetooth provides a communications link to the beverage
machine. The SIM Toolkit (STK) provides an API to the SIM so that the SIM may
acknowledge available funds, decrement the funds appropriately, and send a message
through the STK to the beverage machine that it is OK to provide the beverage.
Recharge Scenario: The mobile prepay customer approaches a kiosk that is advertising
a certain consumer product. The kiosk indicates that if the consumer watches and
listens to an advertisement and answers a couple of questions, she will get some airtime
as credit and a discount at the store. The prepay customer decides to listen to the
advertisement and is instructed to point and click at the Bluetooth-enabled kiosk. After
listening to the advertisement, the prepay customer has ten seconds to point and click at
the kiosk again to receive the credit and discount. The customer is then given the option
to engage in a survey in which the phone is used to make choices. The reward for this is
actual store credit, provided to the customer's account via Bluetooth, STK, and the SIM.
Mobile prepay lends itself especially to these micro-payments. The belief is that
especially the youth market will be most apt to maintain a universal account for buying
everything from sodas to sneakers as well as mobile communications services. Parents
could conveniently put money into the account just as they would pay a weekly
allowance. For young people, prepay mobile commerce may be the only way to shop
on-line as they typically will not have access or be eligible for credit cards - the normal
means for shopping on-line.
These electronic wallets will not only allow portability of funds but also allow merchants
to electronically add to these funds through various promotions. The actual credit to the
account could be accomplished via Bluetooth, offering special promotional stored value
cards, and/or through electronic transfer.
The universal account could be managed on the Internet. Each account could have its
own profile. According to the profile, a customer could receive solicited and/or
unsolicited credits goof for various goods and services. Many merchants would want the
credits to be time-bound or even time-windowed, allowing for the merchant to have
protection from over demand and/or maximum flexibility to increase sales during
historically slow sales periods.
Unlike a post-paid customer who would see a summary report of purchases and inclusion
of the sum as a part of a monthly bill, the prepay customer has no monthly bill.
Accordingly, another value-add for prepay customers whose engage in mobile commerce
would be to offer such a summary of purchases on a on-line account via the Internet. It
is likely that many prepay customers who engage in mobile commerce would be willing
to pay an extra fee just for the ability to see where the monies are spent. In fact, this
capability would be an interesting capability for parents to see how their children's
allowance is being spent and/or to view general spending habits. This is also a impetus
for the child to begin to pay for his own prepay service so as to hide such personal
activities from the parent!!
This evolution is driven by mobile operators' desire to be more than just a bearer of
service. Instead they desire to be a full owner in the value chain of service delivery to
customers. This is important for all types of customers and services, but perhaps even
more important for mobile commerce to prepay customers who tend to have less loyalty
then post-paid customers. Consequently, mobile operators will align themselves with
key partners for co-branded content and transaction services, possibly even aligning
themselves with banking and other financial institutions for the delivery and clearing of
transactions.
Two of the biggest areas for mobile commerce will be mobile entertainment and
messaging.
11
Number of bytes used/downloaded
12
As determined by the provider and the specific premium service
- Treasure hunt, catch the thief, and other location based games
§ Mobile music
§ Movie trailers
§ Ringtones
§ Mobile chat
§ Other presence and availability services such as an alert when a friend to enters a
zone, comes into the proximity of the user, or logs onto her ISP
MOBILE ENTERTAINMENT
Mobile entertainment is already huge in Japan with NTT DoCoMo's iMode service in which
customers play various games and have content such as "virtual pets" automatically
downloaded to their phones. While some of this may be cultural, and also be influenced
by other issues such as long commute time (e.g. need to kill time) to get to work,
entertainment is something that everyone can relate to and embrace. Entertainment
also captures the massive youth market, which tends to have a lot of disposable income
- because young people generally dispose of what income they do have on fun.
Prepaid mobile entertainment makes a lot of sense as it fits well with the psychology of
entertainment spending, which for some product market segments, is geared toward
spontaneous spending. Many people would not make spontaneous purchases on large
ticket items and/or with "real" hard cash or credit. However, the prepay account is
already "paid-in", making it easier psychologically for people to spend their money on
entertainment. This is akin to the concept of time-share properties. Often times the
overall cost is greater than if the person/family would rent a hotel or condominium when
the need arises. The psychology is that the time-share "forces" the time-share owner to
Another less honorable advantage to the mobile prepay customer is anonymity. The
head of household who is spending money on gambling and other adult entertainment
does not want his/her spouse to know where the money is going !
MOBILE MESSAGING
While there is not yet as much prepaid messaging service history to review for analysis,
preliminary studies have indicated that mobile prepay messaging customers actually a
substantial amount more than post-paid customers on things such as basis SMS
messaging. The theory is behind this is two-fold. First, a different target market is
involved. Being a very strong target market for prepaid, and a very strong market for
non-voice services, the youth market heavily favors strong sales for prepaid messaging.
The second reason is once again psychology. If the mobile operator makes basic
messaging very cheap, and the customer has already paid in advance, the customer will
be less adapt to count up the cost of the hundreds of messages placed/received per
month.
While it remains to be seen how successful these more advanced features and services
shall be, one should be confident that they will be embraced by the same users who
using basic messaging and games today.
REVERSE PREPAID
What is reverse prepaid? Traditional prepay involves the customer paying for airtime and
then using it. Reverse prepaid involves advertiser and merchant paying for airtime and
then the customer using it immediately.
Scenario
§ Advertisers list feature codes and phone number that, when called, initiate an
advertisement or promotion of some type. The call or feature code itself is free.
Once the caller listens to the advertising, she may place another call of a certain
duration for free. The caller may remember the phone number or feature code
for future use. However, many advertisers would want this type of arrangement
The advertiser and/or merchant support reverse prepaid themselves. Accordingly, the
fee for the free call made by the mobile customer is paid/debited by the advertiser to the
mobile operator in advance of the mobile customer placing the free call. We also
discussed earlier the notion of advertisers/merchants crediting the mobile prepay
customers universal account for discounts and free goods and services. This is also a
form of reverse prepaid.
The catch is that most mobile operators will not want prepay accounts to be credited
with airtime to be used later. Even if the mobile operator is getting paid a portion of the
advertising money per a new business model, the operator still has a core business to
run that depends on managing capacity of the network. Accordingly, business
arrangements of this type will involve the need for the mobile customer to place a free
call immediately after the promotion. The promoter may alternatively offer a credit for
their own goods and services.
BUSINESS ISSUES
In the first part of this report, we discussed certain basic prepay business issues
including cost of acquisition, roaming, rates, churn and replenishment, services and
differentiation. We will now discuss some additional business issues affecting the
success of offering mobile prepay communications services.
In an effort to keep revenue per unit higher and reduce churn, some wireless carriers
have initiated the misguided practice of cutting prepay customers too soon. For
example, some operators may deactivate customer accounts after only 60 days of
inactivity (non-replenishment). This represents as much as 95 percent of all churn for
prepay accounts. This practice continues for some mobile operators despite the fact that
often customers replenish after a few months.
In other parts of the world where CPP is the norm, prepay customers leave their phones
power-on more. This allows the mobile operator to recognize revenue for additional
mobile-to-mobile calls. Additionally, the implementation of location based technology
may allow the mobile operator to alert the prepay customer when approaching a
recharge location such as a retail outlet or ATM. This is potentially a powerful tool again
churn when coupled with predictive churn algorithms and loyalty programs.
FRAUD
It is important to identity the potential for fraud. Some presumed customers never
intend to pay. Sometimes these people skip from one service provider to another, or
13
use fake names, or engage in true-name fraud . We discuss fraud in greater detail in
Part 4: Operational Issues.
Prepay service should be as simple as possible, triggering few questions for customer
care. Customer care should also be as automated as possible, with almost every
question or concern handled on a Web page or through a voice response unit.
Customers should be able to view their accounts on-line and recharge with automated
tools.
13
Assume the identity of another.
Acquisition $ 300.00
Point of Sale Support $ 25.00
Distribution (including cards) $ 10.00
Customer Care & Replenish $ 50.00
Advertising/Marketing $ 25.00
$ 420.00
$ 410.00 $ 420.00
The above analysis consists of a basic view of costs and revenue and an expanded view
of revenue. Both views are annualized and assumed accurate for the first year of
operation. Assuming the prepay customer remains a customer of the original provider
14
after the first year, the acquisition cost for that customer goes to virtually zero.
However, some customers will require phone upgrades, driving this figure up to a high
percentage of its original number.
The basic view shows us that, if a customer stays a customer for one year, break even
15
occur regarding direct costs . If the prepay service user remains a customer after the
14
Cost of acquisition includes warehousing phones, distribution of phones, commissions to agents and/or
employees, and other handling fees.
The fact of the matter is that churn is prevalent for many service providers. Ideally, the
service provider must put into place programs to reduce churn as well as stimulate
additional revenue per unit. It the analysis above, we show this with the expanded
revenue opportunities.
RECHARGE
While marketing, advertising, and promotion will certainly help with recharge, the area
of focus that we recommend is automation and reward. Simply put, we recommend that
the service provider:
Provide them with recharge tools that they are accustomed to using for other purposes
such as SMS and WAP.
Establish high quality, highly available merchant and banking relationships for recharge.
Use of an ATM for recharge is a great convenience for the user.
15
Direct costs do not include cost of prepay infrastructure, a major fixed cost for the mobile operator. If this
analysis were from the reseller's perspective, the cost for buying minutes of use (MOU) from the mobile
operator would be shown as a direct cost to the reseller.
Alert the user with appropriate periodicity and urgency. As a courtesy, remind the
customer immediately when they have depleted his account. Remind him again at
programmatic intervals based on SDR analysis. Do not harass the user. If he has not
recharged after the certain period of time, there is likely good reason. Wait until a
predetermined period of time prior to making special recharge offers based on a loyalty
program. Send a message to the customer (via SMS, WAP, or voice message); recharge
now at "XYZ" merchant to receive a 20% discount on airtime. Provide the customer a
personalized e-coupon serial number and use location technology to direct the customer
to the closest location. The customer will think it is a special promotion for that time and
location (and they are right), but it is directed at them alone, based on the SDR analysis
and the loyalty program.
Let the customer know that there is a loyalty program to encourage prompt recharge.
Provide additional rewards for frequent recharge such as free use of randomly selected
services such as three-way calling. These services could be made available for sale at a
discount after the free period.
VALUE-ADDED SERVICES
16
By definition, value-added services are services that :
1. Not a form of basic service but rather adds value total service offering
5. Can be an add-on to basic service, and as such, may be sold at a premium price
It is safe to say that it makes sense to provide VAS to any customers, but it is critically
important to provide VAS to prepay customers, as they are more prone to churn.
16
Used with permission from Value-added Service white paper by Gerry Christensen 1999
MOBILE COMMERCE
The service provider can cooperate with financial institutions to provide various mobile
commerce services, many of which would be provided on a prepay basis.
Some customers, perhaps most, prefer the convenience of a monthly bill as opposed to
prepay customers who must remember or be alerted to recharge. Therefore,
prepayment as an alternative to traditional billing is not for everyone, but it is a viable
alternative to many who want to simultaneously control spending while establishing
access to goods and services that would be unattainable with traditional mobile operator
billing.
One unique use for a variation of EBPP would be to use it in conjunction with mobile
prepay simply as a means of electronic notification and recharge. The prepay customer
could receive an email notification indicating a low-balance and/or an opportunity to
recharge at a preferential rate. The customer may have both prepay and post-paid
account with the mobile operator, allowing the customer to authorize payment via EBPP
from the post-paid account to the prepay account for purposes of recharging the
customer's daughter away from home attending college.
This is a viable service offering for those customers that require cost control, but for
whatever reason, really do want a traditional post-paid bill. The beauty of this service is
17
that, while it has certain near-term limitations , this service can be offered immediately
to all customers on a trial basis. In fact, it is often useful to offer this service to select
customers initially as a limited introduction. Interested retail customers would pay $1-2
for this service and corporate customers would pay $2-5 per mobile unit for cost control.
17
See Advanced Prepay Concepts and Applications part of this report for descriptions of interdependencies with
mobile IN and roaming issues
One need only look to the NTT DoCoMo model as an example of what can be successful.
DoCoMo charges every content/application provider 9% of their receipts for
content/services delivered over DoCoMo's iMode service. This provides an incremental
revenue stream for DoCoMo, which is above and beyond the charge the levy to their
customer on a per-packet basis for basic iMode service.
Mobile operators must begin to figure out these new business models NOW. This is
especially critical for prepay service as there will be many advertisers and referral
agencies who will jump at the opportunity to offer potential customers free, prepaid
vouchers for them to try goods and services.
Affinity programs that include co-branded prepay cards and benefits to the supporting
organization can be effective. For example, non-profit groups can distribute phones and
cards at a discount, with the discount value benefiting the charity.
Marketing and sales alliances are another area of consideration. For example, computer
manufacturers, Internet service providers, and prepay service providers could team to
offer a combined package of ISP and mobile service as part of the initial PC purchase.
Additional on-line and airtime could be purchased on-line at a reduced rate.
In cooperation with an ISP, the mobile operator could offer a prepaid Internet account
and mobile prepay service as a combined package. The Internet account would come
with an email address that allows for forwarding and/or alerting to the mobile phone.
The idea is to create customer stickiness. Additionally, the customer would be allowed
to keep the email address so long as the overall account is recharged every month.
SUMMARY
PREPAY POSITION IN THE MARKETPLACE
With numerous market segment (and some virtually untapped such as cost control)
opportunities, prepay is sure to grow in consumer acceptance and become an even more
critical part of the mobile operators service portfolio. As a critical element, wireless
providers must provide service to prepay customers that is at least as good as that
provided to post-paid customers. In fact, a strong argument could be made to provide
prepay customer better service and value-added features, as they may be more prone to
easy churn than post-paid customers. Providing value-added services will be possible
through various technology improvements that are underway.
Better customer segmentation – cost control customer call processing and rate plans will
reflect their unique needs
Feature enhancements such as directing the prepay user to the closest point for account
replenishment
Improved operational efficiencies as fewer trunks will be required with WIN/CAMEL vs.
point solutions or ISUP loop-back
Broaden reseller opportunities with no more direct connections
§ Use of Service Detail Records (SDR) and integration of SDRs with other systems
to support loyalty programs
§ Ubiquitous deployment of CAMEL for prepay in two to three years (standard has a
head-start on WIN)
§ Point and CDR based solutions will fade away as WIN and CAMEL become
ubiquitous. Smart card based solutions will take on more of the role as a vehicle
for mobile commerce
§ Use of prepay for other services including wireless data and some emerging
categories including mobile IP services for Internet communications, information
services, and e-commerce
§ Significantly lower pricing for prepay as WIN and CAMEL become ubiquitous,
although overall market forces are the main driver here
§ As the price for prepay service drops further, and zone billing (based on location
technology) becomes available, prepay service will become an increasing
attractive alternative to fixed line service, especially for the credit challenged or
low-end user segment
DEPLOYMENT AND
OPERATIONAL ISSUES
This part of the report provides a review of the major deployment and operational issues
facing the mobile prepay service provider. We raise these general deployment and
operational issues so as to help prepare the mobile prepay communications service
provider to avoid potential pitfalls and complications.
DEPLOYMENT ISSUES
In deploying a prepay system/service, one must consider many of the issues discussed
earlier in this report - issues such as target market, deployment strategy, and
technology selection. In this section we will discuss some of the commonly overlooked
or glossed over deployment issues.
TECHNOLOGY PERVASIVENESS
We discussed the need for ubiquitous technology during our discussion about mobile IN
technologies. The need for technology pervasiveness is, however, not restricted to any
one technology. It is important for service providers to consider the availability of
subscriber and network equipment prior to making technology selection. Those
technologies that are not widely available will inhibit important aspects of deployment
such as roaming capability.
ROAMING
Services should ideally work in the same manner while roaming as they do at home.
Customers of all types increasing expect to have service availability everywhere. There
is often a careful balance that must be made between advanced features (which may be
available in the home only) versus fully functional basic services (and preferable
TECHNOLOGY OBSOLESCENCE
It is important to consider the possibility of technology obsolescence in planning and
deploying a mobile prepay solution. While all technologies will eventually be supplanted,
a safe bet is to go with standards-based technologies and/or those that are widely
deployed. The last thing that a service provider wants is to be stuck with "throw-away"
technology. Therefore, careful business case analysis most be employed, especially
when the system in question involves even a portion of proprietary technology.
Some services, such as caller ID, voice mail, and SMS, may be provided on a flat-fee,
all-you-can-eat basis. Other services (that require system interaction) may be
prohibited by certain types of prepay systems.
Other services may truly be provided on a post-paid basis to prepay customers. This
market segment includes those that want to control costs for certain services but not
others. An example would be as stated earlier in which a father has a daughter in
college. The father may want the daughter to have prepay as a means of managing
expenses but yet maintain a post-paid account for the main mobile usage.
Regardless of the specific situation, integration of post-paid and prepay services will
require close coordination between billing systems and prepay systems used by the
mobile operator. Leveraging of the Internet and EBPP technologies can make
management of associated post-paid/prepay services much easier.
Exploiting the Internet as a means of allowing prepay customers to make purchases (via
an ISP connection) on the web with funds from their prepay accounts is one of the first
logical steps towards true prepay mobile commerce, which is making transactions while
mobile with funds debited from the prepay account.
PATENT ISSUES
It is important to bear in mind that all legal issues relative to mobile prepay deployment,
not the least of which are patent issues. Below we briefly discuss a few examples of
some patent infringement cases.
Freedom Wireless
It remains to be seen what will come of a legal battle between mobile prepay providers
and Freedom Wireless, a privately held Phoenix, Arizona, USA-based wireless technology
company that was granted US patents for completing prepaid wireless phone calls.
Litigation in the Freedom Wireless case has been engaged with the potential implications
and outcome inconclusive at this point in time. We shall monitor this situation and
provide progress in the next revision of this report.
Telemac
In July 2000, Topp Telecom settled a patent infringement action commenced by
Telemac, which ended in Topp licensing Telemac's technology.
§ There is no requirement that the phone use specific monetary values, rather than
units or any other representation of prepaid funds.
OPERATIONAL ISSUES
Once deployed, there are many issues to address in supporting the operation of a prepay
system and/or service offering. We will discuss some of the more important operational
issues in this section.
FRAUD
The three primary types of fraud that can affect prepay service operations are credit
fraud, subscription fraud, and prepay card inventory fraud.
The Federal Trade Commission of the United States claims that physical credit cards are
not present in up to 54% of all fraud involving credit cards. Most of this type of fraud is
based on "social engineering". For example, a customer may convince a mobile
operator's customer service representative that the replenishment process
malfunctioned. In these cases, the mobile operator does not have the time to follow up
Subscription Fraud
There are many types of subscription fraud, but they all involve an intent to never pay
the service provider. With the percentage of "technical" fraud to other types of fraud at
roughly 40%/60% and growing, many prepay providers are either eliminating (not a
good option as this is a unique market segment) anonymous accounts for prepay and/or
setting up special programs to deal with this problem. However, some nations do not
have the credit bureaus and other means to screen applicants.
Furthermore, a special type of fraud called "true name" fraud makes the battle against
subscription fraud especially difficult, with crooks alluding the best attempts of providers
to perform background checks. With false identities are easy to obtain, true name fraud
arises when an individual falsely represents their identity, never intending to pay for
prepay service. This is an increasingly common form of fraud with post-pay service as
mobile operators (through anti-fraud technology) have beaten other forms of fraud. This
form of fraud is on the up-rise, and along with credit card fraud, is the one of the biggest
forms of revenue leakage for mobile operators. True name fraud can be reduced by
careful identification and background checks.
While subscription fraud by itself is a direct problem for post-paid service, it is enabler of
other types of fraud for prepay such as credit card fraud. The subscription fraud crook
can easily use fraudulent credit cards, vouchers, and/or other means to credit the prepay
account with almost total impunity to prosecution.
§ Are controls in place to safeguard data files for PIN manufacture and retention?
§ What controls are in place to ensure safe delivery of cards from manufacturer
and/or warehouse to merchant locations?
However, try as they might, mobile operators will always experience a certain
percentage of fraud, even with prepay fraud controls in place.
Below are some illustrative figures that may be used as a benchmark for how much
fraud is "too much":
BELOW
INDEX POOR AVERAGE GOOD
AVGERAGE
Fraud as a % of bad debt 45-60% 30-45% 15-30% 10-15%
In the United States, work is underway to institute lawful monitoring of calls by police in
order to catch criminals. As prepay becomes more mainstream in the US, it is likely that
additional measures will be taken such as criminal profiling at the point of sale and
location based tracking of a suspected criminal phone numbers. However, privacy and
protection of human rights are a big issue here, so these are also likely to be very sticky
issues.
MAINTENANCE
Most mature systems will run without any problems, unless something is done to change
the system equilibrium such as a software upgrade. One form of maintenance is
therefore to perform routine system backups of subscriber and system data. Another
common form of maintenance is simply to perform maintenance servicing and
replacement of mechanical parts such as cooling systems for hardware. It is important
to plan for necessary maintenance and personnel to attend to such matters.
§ Allowing the prepay customer to transfer their existing balance to the new plan
and/or a free amount of minutes on the new plan
While the above general suggestions should apply to most every mobile operator, there
will be specific and overall exceptions. One overall exception will be when MNP is
available in the United States where calling party pays (CPP) is not in place. On one
hand, you could say that there is currently no barrier to changing providers today
because few people give out their mobile number. On the other hand, for those that do
receive a lot of calls on their mobile, MNP will be a big benefit. However, prepaid
customers in the US do not tend to give out their mobile very much because of lack of
CPP.
This means that customers may easily port to a different prepay provider, keep their
MDN/MSISDN, despite the fact that MNP requires a change in the customer's MIN/IMSI
on non-point solutions. This is a key point in the comparison between point solutions for
prepay vs. others:
§ A customer may port from a mobile operator that has a point solution to a mobile
operator that has a non-point solution
§ A customer may not easily port from a mobile operator that has a non-point
solution to a mobile operator that has a point solution. Since point solutions
require dedicated phone numbers, mobile operators typically want to manage
prepay customer numbers in contiguous line ranges due to the fact that support
of single numbers would drive up the cost of administration and switch
translations.
CUSTOMER CARE
Even in this evolving world of automation, a mobile prepay provider can not overlook the
need for well-trained and equipped customer care personnel. While many subscribers
will be handled by automated systems such as VRUs, others will want the personal touch
or assistance of a human customer care person. Mobile prepay customers have unique
AGREEMENTS
Any agreement posted on the Web should disclaim implied warranties, limit liability,
disclaim responsibility material to hyper-linked sites, and any errors or omissions.
OPERATING POLICY
This should post the permissible and impermissible uses of the Web site.
PRIVACY POLICY
A privacy policy should be in effect to protect the users of the Web site. This policy
should be clearly posted to assure customers that their personal information shall be
properly handled.
While cost recovery plans are in place for mobile operators to charge fees to post-paid
customers (cost recovery is allocated to the jurisdiction associated with the billing
address), obtaining cost recovery from prepay customers is problematic at best.
§ Charging/allocating the cost recovery fee based on customer's address. This will
problematic as many mobile prepay plans do not require the customer to provide
an address and some users prefer to remain anonymous.
§ Charging/allocating the cost recovery fee in conjunction with the location in which
the customer initially purchases the equipment/card(s) and subsequently where
recharge occurs. This method is also problematic as recharge location is very
difficult to determine due to the fact that replenishment may occur via remote
connection such as a VRU or Internet replenishment in contrast to physical
replenishment at a store or ATM.
§ Charging/allocating the cost recovery fee based on location when actually used.
While this is the most correct from an accounting perspective, it would be a costly
endeavor to monitor and allocate cost recovery monies based on every call
location.
There is no easy answer here. Other countries outside the US will also experience this
issue once similar emergency service initiatives are in place. Once this issue surfaces
outside the US, its magnitude will be even greater as a much large percentage of users
are prepay outside the US, thus making the issue of cost recovery from prepay users
significantly more important.
DISCLOSURE ISSUES
As a part of engaging in fair business practices, every prepay service provider should
provide information about service and charges prior to offering those services. The
4. Any domestic and international connection fee – only one connection fee may
be charged per call.
5. Any periodical maintenance fee – the amount and the period fully disclosed –
and, maintenance fee be levied no more than once per call.
8. The full underlying carrier name or DBA as registered with the governing state
regulatory agency
10. No undisclosed charges should be applied; i.e. “Other charges may apply.”
18
These guidelines were reprinted by permission of the IPCA and are their copyright.
12. There should be a clear statement that all charges for international calls can
be obtained through Customer Service
6. Expiration policy (which, if not stated, the card will be assumed to be live for
at least one year after purchased)
Live customer service should provide a minimum of 40-hours per week, during normal
business hours, with a recording system or an IVR system back up for off hours. When
the recording/IVR system is in use, and when customers request a return call, attempts
to return customer calls must be made by COB the following business day. Customer
service, when requested, should provide:
1. Remaining balance
2. International costs
3. All surcharges
4. Rounding policy
5. Recharge policy and costs
6. Name of issuing company
7. Expiration policy
8. Name and phone number of state regulatory agency.
IX. Promotional Card standards (cards that are not sold, but given to the
consumer of the telecom services)
XI. Refund - When an issuer offers a refund policy, it should be clearly disclosed
prior to sale.
XIII. It is recommended that IPCA members comply with these standards within one
year after the Board of Directors adopts them.
§ Network operators are telling us that prepay users are mostly not profitable for
them- because prepay tariffs are no longer time related (necessitating regular
replenishment), network operators have little or no control over how much return
they will get from that user- who may not use their mobile phone much at all.
Mobile network operators feel compelled to keep pushing prepay to acquire
quantities of customers, even if the quality is not there.
§ Many prepay customers never register with their network operator- despite
inducements such as additional airtime credits for submitting their details. In
such cases, network operators have no customer data or relationships.
Anonymity, one of the advantages of prepay to the user, is proving to be a big
disadvantage to the operators.
§ Mobile terminals are getting more feature-rich as nonvoice services come to the
fore. Youth markets are a key driver for such nonvoice services- and a key
customer group for prepay- yet it is difficult for network operators to aggressively
subsidize sophisticated multimedia capable terminals such as the Casio Message-
Cam (see the Devices Zone on www.mobileMMS.com). Network operators are
generally willing to subsidize such devices when they are connected to post-pay
tariffs on a minimum contract term because they have some guaranteed
minimum revenues and because Average Revenue per User (ARPUs) tend to be
higher for users of such devices. In 3G markets, a substantially larger proportion
of terminals will be smart and multimedia enabled, necessitating post-paid tariffs.
§ Two of the biggest areas of revenues predicted for the 3G world are mobile
commerce and mobile location. Mobile commerce requires user authentication
which is inconsistent with anonymity, and mobile location requires user opt in and
opt out to services, witch is also inconsistent with the anonymity that prepay can
provide.
As such, we predict that prepay will account for a diminishing proportion of the total
mobile market and that the postpaid billing mechanism will become resurgent. Within a
couple of years, the two forms of payment are likely to be roughly equally used in the 3G
world, with application centric devices on postpaid tariffs and voice centric terminals
mainly on prepay tariffs. Thereafter, as network operators begin to focus more on the
quality of their users, prepay may fall away further.
GLOSSARY
ACD - Automatic Call Delivery
ACM - Answer Complete Message
AMPS - Advanced Mobile Phone Service
ANSI - American National Standards Institute
ANSI-41 - Formerly Interim Standard (IS) 41
ASL - Account Spending Limit
ATM - Automatic Teller Machine
CAMEL - Customized Applications for Mobile Enhanced Logic
CAP - Capabilities Application Part
CDMA - Code Division Multiple Access
CDR - Call Detail Record
CPP - Calling Party Pays
CS - Capability Sets
D-AMPS - Digital AMPS
FISU - Fill-in Signal Unit
GPRS - General Packet Radio Service
GSM - Global System for Mobile communications
GSM MAP - GSM Mobile Application Part
GTT - Global Title Translations
HLR - Home Location Register
IAM - Initial Address Message
ID - Identification
IMSI - International Mobile Station Identifier
IN - Intelligent Network
INAP - Intelligent Network Application Part
Written by Mobile Lifestreams’ Prepaid expert, Gerry Christensen, this 161 page report
has been designed to help product and service providers and those investing in
systems/solutions to make more informed business decisions.
The intention of this report is to satisfy the large number of requests that Mobile
Lifestreams receives for detailed quantitative and qualitative information on the growth
of mobile messaging services such as text messaging (SMS), enhanced messaging (EMS)
and multimedia messaging (MMS)
The Wireless Application Protocol (WAP) is a hot topic that has been widely hyped in the
mobile industry and outside of it. Mobile Lifestreams originally produced its first WAP
report, “Data on WAP”, in July 1999. Due to rapid changes and developments this report
was reissued as "Yes 2 WAP" in May 2000 and as “Success 4 WAP” in February 20001.
"YES 2 3G" presents an optimistic look at tremendously exciting possibilities that Third
Generation/ UMTS technologies and applications enable. Timescales, profiles of all the
major infrastructure vendors including the Japanese vendors, every mobile multimedia
application, "At home with your futurephone"- mobile communications in the next few
years, 3G Talking Points, all the 3G contracts awarded, the standards, handset alliances
and partnership opportunities and much, much more are included in this report.
Messaging is evolving beyond text to enhanced text and simple pictures to full
multimedia messages. This report plots this evolution path and is an essential resource
for those working with SMS who are looking to maintain their position in the future. The
transition from text messaging to multimedia messaging is as important for mobile
phones as the transition from DOS to Windows was for the PC.
This report shows how to make mobile data a success by maximizing the use of, and
therefore the revenue from, the General Packet Radio Service (GPRS). Education is the
principle means of achieving this objective- by providing the first and only single source
for accurate and comprehensive information about the development and deployment of
GPRS around the world. “YES 2 GPRS” explains and interprets both the existing and
future aspects of GPRS. It provides both an explanation of these developments, and
analysis to help interpret them. The idea is to identify the critical success factors for the
General Packet Radio Service- now and in the future
NOTE: To order any of the above publications, please visit our secure online ordering
form at https://www.mobilesms.com/ordering.asp