Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
12337
Original Article
Background: Timor-Leste has high maternal and infant mortality rates. Estimates of stillbirths are unreliable and limited
by poor collection of vital health statistics. Lack of accurate data impedes the development of interventions to address local
determinants of stillbirth.
Aims: This study aimed to identify the rate, timing and causes of stillbirths at National Hospital Guido Valadares in Dili,
Timor-Leste, between November 2009 and December 2010, during which data were available.
Methods: Hospital birth registry and maternal records were retrospectively reviewed to identify stillbirths during the study
period. The simplified Cause of Death and Associated Conditions system was utilised to classify stillbirths.
Results: One hundred and fifty-three stillbirths were identified, producing a stillbirth rate of 29 per 1000 births. Of
stillbirths with known timing, 70 (66.7%) occurred antepartum and 35 (33.3%) intrapartum. Cause of death could not be
ascertained in 62.7% of cases due to poor or missing records. Where identified, the three most commonly classified causes
of death were intrapartum fetal asphyxia, maternal infection and maternal hypertensive disorder.
Conclusion: This study highlights the need for standardised recording and coding of perinatal deaths at HNGV. The
high proportion of antenatal death transfers from community health centres demonstrates the need for community and
hospital staff training to improve the quality of antenatal and intrapartum obstetric care. A prospective study of
stillbirths is recommended to obtain reliable data on the determinants of stillbirths in Timor-Leste. These data would
inform evidence-based interventions for the improvement of maternity and obstetric care in community and hospital
settings.
Key words: cause of death, East Timor, low-income countries, perinatal mortality, stillbirth.
© 2015 The Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists 331
The Australian and
New Zealand Journal
of Obstetrics and
Gynaecology
A. Wilkins et al.
332 © 2015 The Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists
Hospital stillbirths in Dili, Timor-Leste
3 Excluded
(weight <500
152 Recorded stillbirths (Apgar 0/0)
grams and
retrieved from birth registry
gestation <22
weeks)
149 Stillbirths retrieved
from birth registry
Figure 1 Flowchart of inclusion and exclusion criteria for retrospective review of stillbirth.
Table 1 Demographic characteristics of women with a stillborn No significant relationships were found between timing
baby (n = 147) of stillbirth and demographic and obstetric variables (data
not shown).
Percentage Ninety-six stillbirth cases (62.7%) were classified as
Characteristic Category n of women ‘Unknown’ due to missing records or poor documentation
Maternal age <20 8 5.4 of obstetric complications. Among the stillbirth cases
(years) 20–24 45 30.6 where COD were identified (n = 57), the most frequent
25–34 70 47.6 COD were attributed to intrapartum causes (n = 17) and
≥35 24 16.4 hypertension (n = 12; Table 3).
Residence Dili 88 59.9 Review of the maternal records identified a number of
Other district 51 34.7 examples of care at a lower standard than would be
Unknown 8 5.4 expected for the available facilities. The most common
Parity 0 49 33.3 examples related to birth attendants’ failure to monitor the
1 28 19.0 fetal heart or respond to fetal heart rate abnormalities in
2–5 48 32.7 the active stage of labour, incorrect diagnoses from
≥6 22 15.0 ultrasound (eg singleton pregnancy diagnosed as twins on
ultrasound), failure to record maternal temperature or
blood pressure over periods of more than 24 h in women
record in the remaining cases. Among the antenatal with hypertension or ruptured membranes, and otherwise
deaths, 37 (52.9%) women were transferred into HNGV poorly recorded documentation on the partograph.
from another clinic, 28 (40%) presented to HNGV and in
5 (7.1%) cases, it was unknown whether the woman was
Discussion
transferred or presented to the hospital.
Thirty-five stillbirth cases were diagnosed in labour, and The present retrospective study identified a stillbirth rate
of these, 11 were confirmed intrapartum deaths, one was of 29 per 1000 at HNGV, twofold higher than the most
termination of a presumed nonviable pregnancy, and in recent WHO estimate for Timor-Leste (14 per 1000
23, the exact timing of death was unknown. The majority births) and higher than the average for Southeast Asia (22
of women among whom the timing of death could not be per 1000 births).3 However, the WHO estimates are
determined presented in advanced labour, and there was based on a stillbirth definition (the death of a fetus
no documentation as to whether the infant was fresh or weighing ≥1000 g or ≥28 weeks of gestation) that varies
macerated. from that used in the study.3 Using the narrower WHO
© 2015 The Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists 333
A. Wilkins et al.
Table 2 Characteristics of stillbirth cases (n = 153) Table 3 Simplified Cause of Death and Associated Conditions
(CODAC) Classification of stillbirth cases15 (n = 59)
Percentage
Characteristic Category n of stillbirth cases CODAC Cause of death Cause of death
number (level I) (level II) n
Singleton–multiple Singleton 89 58.2
birth status Twin 22 14.4 05/06† Infection – 9
Unknown status 42 27.4 20 Intrapartum – other Ruptured uterus 3
Gender of baby Male 83 54.2 23 Intrapartum Malpresentation 1
Female 69 45.1 25 Intrapartum Prolonged/obstructed 3
Unknown gender 1 0.7 or incomplete labour
Gestation at 22–26 17 11.1 29 Intrapartum Unknown (fetal 10
birth (weeks) 27–31 15 9.8 respiratory failure/
32–36 23 15.0 asphyxia)
≥37 25 16.3 Cord prolapse 3
Unknown gestation 59 38.6 30 Congenital – 3
Improbable 14 9.2 anomaly‡
gestational age 31 Congenital Central nervous system 5
Mode of delivery Vaginal cephalic 74 48.4 anomaly
Caesarean 21 13.7 60 Placenta Praevia 5
Vaginal breech 28 18.3 63 Placenta Abruption 2
Unknown delivery 30 19.6 71 Maternal Hypertensive disorder 12
mode 94 Termination For maternal condition 1
Birthweight (g) <500 1† 0.7
†Diagnosis of infection was based on clinical diagnosis of
500–1499 52 34.0
chorioamnionitis. No microbiology was performed, so it was not
1500–2499 40 26.1
possible to determine whether infection was GBS or non GBS.
2500–3499 35 22.9
‡One case described only as ‘abnormal baby’, one ‘abnormal feet
≥3500 22 14.4
and hands and cleft lip’, one ‘skull and polyhydramnios’.
Unknown 3 2.0
birthweight
Taking into account the proportion of cases in which
†This case was included despite birthweight less than 500 g
timing of death was known (n = 103), the proportion of
because it was one of a set of twins in which the larger twin
weighed 1200 g.
intrapartum stillbirth in the study was 33.9%; this is
comparable to other population-level studies in low-income
countries.17–20 Most stillbirths occurred in the antenatal
definition results in a stillbirth rate of 24 per 1000 at period, emphasising the need for improved education and
HNGV in the study period, which is still 1.5 times higher awareness among pregnant women and antenatal care
than the WHO estimate for Timor-Leste. This rate is also providers about fetal movements and other danger signs in
higher than previously estimated because of the large the antenatal period. The high parity observed in many
number of women referred to HNGV because of known cases (15% of women with parity ≥6) is consistent with the
stillbirth. high rate of unmet need for family planning in Timor-Leste
More than 60% of all cases weighed less than 2500 g, (31.5%), among the highest in the world.21
and 73% of cases with recorded gestation were <37 There are a number of identified demand gaps in
completed weeks. Gestation was estimated only using the seeking obstetric care at a health facility in Timor-Leste.
woman’s recall of her last menstrual period at the time she Knowledge of danger signs in pregnancy was low among
was seen at the hospital. This is a limitation as it has a women surveyed in the Timor-Leste Demographic Health
high degree of inaccuracy especially in a country where Survey 2009–2010,2 and late recognition of danger signs
illiteracy rates are high.2 In 14 cases, gestational ages were by Timorese traditional birth attendants has been
considered implausible due to large discrepancy between identified as delaying access to care at health facilities.22
the birthweight and the accepted gestational age, and in This was notable in the present study with 19 cases of
these cases, only birthweight was used. Birthweight was women reporting no fetal movement for significant periods
recorded using analog scales, and significant terminal digit prior to presentation.
preference was shown with the majority of weights Other studies in Timor-Leste have outlined barriers to
recorded at intervals of 100 g. Although birthweight and accessing facility-based health care, including mistrust,
gestation data are approximate, these proportions still fear of judgment by health staff, cultural beliefs and family
indicate that a high number of cases were preterm and/or traditions that encourage birthing at home, and
growth-restricted. There are limited published comparative geographical distances and frequent flooding that restricts
data from similar settings, because many babies are not travel to facilities.2,22–25 These all pose challenges to
weighed at birth, and similar limitations exist around increasing the number of facility-based deliveries in
women’s knowledge of gestational age. Timor-Leste.
334 © 2015 The Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists
Hospital stillbirths in Dili, Timor-Leste
There are, however, a number of supply-side gaps at during labour, and obstetric drills and simulations to
HNGV, highlighted by the intrapartum deaths that improve emergency obstetric care.11,25–29
constituted almost one-third of all stillbirths. The events The study emphasised the antenatal period as an
relating to poor care were similar to those identified in other important time to implement interventions to prevent
reviews of stillbirth in low-income settings.26–29 Fifty-three stillbirths. This includes education and awareness raising
(34.6%) babies weighed 1500 g or less; at this weight, among pregnant women and community antenatal care
survival is low and invasive intervention such as caesarean providers on danger signs in the antenatal period.
section would not be appropriate for fetal well-being. Strategies to increase access to healthcare facilities for
Maternal records were missing in 46 stillbirth cases, and childbirth among the Timorese population are also
poor documentation resulted in 62.7% of all cases important and could include greater investment in
classified as Unknown COD. This highlights a critical gap outreach clinics, health promotion campaigns and cultural
in adequate record keeping and patient documentation at awareness training for hospital staff. One such program
HNGV. This poor documentation may be attributed to a already demonstrating success in Timor-Leste is Liga Inan
lack of awareness and understanding among staff of the (‘Mobile Mums’), which uses mobile phones to connect
importance of recording patients’ clinical details, a lack of pregnant women and midwives, whereby women receive
training in data recording, combined with limited weekly text messages with health information and
resources and rudimentary means of storing patient data. reminders to attend antenatal care appointments.30
Standardised recording and auditing of stillbirth data at
HNGV and other hospitals in Timor-Leste would ensure
Limitations
accurate data are collected, local causes and determinants
The limitations of the study are intrinsic to its of stillbirth identified, and evidence-based programmatic
retrospective design. The extremely poor documentation and clinical responses developed.6, 9, 15, 25, 31
of stillbirths at HNGV, the high proportion of missing The use of verbal autopsy in low-resource contexts has
data and the lack of national vital statistics prevented been demonstrated as an effective tool for capturing
exploration and meaningful statistical analysis of timing and cause of stillbirth information and could be
determinants and COD. employed in Timor-Leste to document stillbirth data from
Our data provide only an approximation of the stillbirth both community and healthcare facility settings.17
rate at the national hospital given the inaccuracies inherent A prospective study is the most effective strategy to
in the data collection; however, we believe this study is the identify associated factors and causes of stillbirth; such a
first widely accessible audit of stillbirths in Timor-Leste study is underway at HNGV and has been accompanied
and provides descriptive data on stillbirths at HNGV. The by training for hospital staff in the recording and coding
stillbirth rate could also be an underestimation given the of stillbirths and other perinatal deaths. Results from a
data collection process identified an additional six cases in prospective study can be used to inform priority setting,
the maternal records that had not been recorded in the focussed planning and evaluation of prevention programs
birth registry. and investment in interventions to improve the quality of
The accuracy of COD and associated conditions was maternity and obstetric care at HNGV.6,32
constrained by missing data and lack of documentation on
obstetric complications, limiting the ability to draw
Conclusion
conclusions on the factors that contributed to stillbirth.
Important information may also have been lost when The present study contributes to the widely overlooked
assigning a single COD as this does not always account issue of stillbirths in low-income, resource-poor settings. It
for the complex biosocial context within which the death highlights the critical importance of systematic collection
occurs.16, 26 of vital statistics in Timor-Leste to inform interventions
As a hospital-based study, the large proportion of aimed at improving maternal and infant health outcomes.
homebirths in Timor-Leste was not captured, and Standardised recording, coding and auditing of stillbirths,
therefore, the results are not nationally representative and training for nursing and midwifery staff to improve the
cannot be generalised outside HNGV. quality of obstetric care and labour monitoring, and
increased community awareness of danger signs in the
antenatal period may contribute to reductions in perinatal
Recommendations
mortality in Timor-Leste and other low-resource settings.
The descriptive data from the study and the identified
COD highlight much-needed improvements in the
provision of appropriate standards of obstetric care in
Acknowledgements
Timor-Leste and at HNGV. This includes interventions in The authors wish to thank the staff at National Hospital
line with WHO recommendations, appropriate triage to Guido Valadares for facilitating access to the birth registry
support rapid intervention, and training for doctors and and maternal record data for the purposes of this study,
midwifery staff in practical skills to reduce intrapartum and the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons (RACS)
complications, technical skills to provide continuous care Australia Timor-Leste Program of Assistance for
© 2015 The Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists 335
A. Wilkins et al.
Secondary Services (ATLASS) staff, who provided health programming in developing countries. Paediatr Perinat
ongoing support to undertake the study. Thanks are given Epidemiol 2008; 22: 430–437.
to Dr Ingrid Bucens who shared data from her earlier 19 Bhattacharyya R, Pal A. Stillbirths in a referral medical college
study at HNGV that supported the analysis in this study. hospital, West Bengal, India: a ten-year review. J Obstet
Gynaecol Res 2012; 38: 266–271.
20 National Institute of Population Studies and Macro
References International. Pakistan Demographic and Health Surveys
1 Molnar AK. Timor Leste: Politics, History, and Culture. 2006–07. Islamabad, Pakistan and Calverton, MD: Inc
Routledge Contemporary Southeast Asia Series. Hoboken: NIoPSaMI, 2008.
Taylor & Francis, 2010. 21 United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs.
2 National Statistics Directorate. Timor-Leste Demographic Affairs UNDoEaS. Update for the MDG Database: Unmet
Health Survey 2009–2010. Dili, Timor-Leste: Ministry of Need for Family Planning. New York, NY: UNDoEaSA, 2014.
Finance, 2010. 22 Zwi AB, Blignault I, Glazebrook D et al. Timor-Leste Health
3 World Health Organization. World Health Statistics 2013. Care Seeking Behaviour Study. Sydney: University of New
Geneva: World Health Organization, 2013. South Wales, 2009.
4 Lawn JE, Blencowe H, Pattinson R et al. Stillbirths: where? when? 23 Earnest J, Finger RP. General health in Timor-Leste: self-
why? How to make the data count? Lancet 2011; 377: 1448–1463. assessed health in a large household survey. Aust N Z J Public
5 Lawn JE, Yakoob MY, Haws RA et al. 3.2 million stillbirths: Health 2009; 33: 378–383.
epidemiology and overview of the evidence review. BMC 24 Wild K, Barclay L, Kelly P, Martins N. Birth choices in
Pregnancy Childbirth 2009; 9(Suppl 1): S2. Timor-Leste: a framework for understanding the use of
6 Pattinson R, Kerber K, Buchmann E et al. Stillbirths: how can maternal health services in low resource settings. Soc Sci Med
health systems deliver for mothers and babies? Lancet 2011; 2010; 71: 2038–2045.
377: 1610–1623. 25 Bhutta ZA, Yakoob MY, Lawn JE et al. Stillbirths: what
7 United Nations Children’s Fund. Timor-Leste launches difference can we make and at what cost? Lancet 2011; 377:
National Birth Registration Campaign. UNICEF. 2011. 1523–1538.
8 Flenady V, King J, Charles A et al. PSANZ Clinical Practice 26 Facchinetti F, Ferrari F, Monari F, Neri I. Stillbirths: issues
Guideline for Perinatal Mortality, Version 2.2 edn. Brisbane: and new insights. Expert Rev Obstet Gynecol 2011; 6:
Perinatal Society of Australia and New Zealand Perinatal 93–108.
Mortality Group, 2009. 27 Olagbuji BN, Ezeanochie MC, Igbaruma S et al. Stillbirth in
9 Froen JF, Gordijn SJ, Abdel-Aleem H et al. Making stillbirths cases of severe acute maternal morbidity. Int J Gynaecol Obstet
count, making numbers talk – issues in data collection for 2012; 119: 53–56.
stillbirths. BMC Pregnancy Childbirth 2009; 9: 58. 28 Chigbu CO, Okezie OA, Odugu BU. Intrapartum stillbirth in
10 Froen JF, Cacciatore J, McClure EM et al. Stillbirths: why a Nigerian tertiary hospital setting. Int J Gynaecol Obstet 2009;
they matter. Lancet 2011; 377: 1353–1366. 104: 18–21.
11 Lori JR, Rominski S, Osher BF, Boyd CJ. A case series study 29 Hofmeyr GJ, Haws RA, Bergstrom S et al. Obstetric care in
of perinatal deaths at one referral center in rural post-conflict low-resource settings: what, who, and how to overcome
Liberia. Matern Child Health J 2014; 18: 45–51. challenges to scale up? Int J Gynaecol Obstet 2009; 107(Suppl
12 Bucens IK, Reid A, Barreto AC et al. Three years of neonatal 1): S21–S44, S-5.
morbidity and mortality at the national hospital in Dili, East 30 Health Alliance International, Catalpa International, US
Timor. J Paediatr Child Health 2013; 49: 452–457. AID, Ministry of Health Timor-Leste. Liga Inan Program
13 World Health Organization Country Office for Timor-Leste. Preliminary Results. Dili, Timor-Leste: International HA,
Timor-Leste Strategic Development Plan 2011–2030. Dili, International C, AID U, Timor-Leste MoH, 2013.
Timor-Leste: Timor-Leste WHOCOf, 2011. 31 United Nations Children’s Fund and World Health
14 World Health Organization. ICD-10: International Statistical Organisation Regional Office for South-East Asia. South-East
Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems – Asia Regional Strategic Framework for Improving Neonatal
Instruction Manual, 2nd edn. Geneva, Switzerland: WHO, 2004. and Child Health and Development India: UNICEF
15 Froen JF, Pinar H, Flenady V et al. Causes of death and WHOROfS-EAa. 2012.
associated conditions (Codac): a utilitarian approach to the 32 Pattinson R, Kerber K, Waiswa P et al. Perinatal mortality
classification of perinatal deaths. BMC Pregnancy Childbirth audit: counting, accountability, and overcoming challenges in
2009; 9: 22. scaling up in low- and middle-income countries. Int J
16 Flenady V, Froen JF, Pinar H et al. An evaluation of Gynaecol Obstet 2009; 107(Suppl 1): S113–S121, S21–2.
classification systems for stillbirth. BMC Pregnancy Childbirth
2009; 9: 24. Supporting Information
17 Baqui AH, Choi Y, Williams EK et al. Levels, timing, and
etiology of stillbirths in Sylhet district of Bangladesh. BMC Additional Supporting Information may be found in the
Pregnancy Childbirth 2011; 11: 25. online version of this article:
18 Edmond KM, Quigley MA, Zandoh C et al. Aetiology of Appendix S1. WHO Southeast Asia Regional Office
stillbirths and neonatal deaths in rural Ghana: implications for stillbirth record form, adapted for Timor-Leste.
336 © 2015 The Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists