Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
What is the impact of CSR investment on the financial performance of the UK banks?
Name of Student
Student ID
Word Count:
FINANCIAL IMPACT OF CSR INVESTMENT ON UK BANKS 2
Abstract
One of the ways organizations achieve sustainability as a primary factor for success is by
apply CSR as a policy requirement and as an obligation to society. Social and environmental
concerns coming up in recent times have changed the marketing approach of the majority of
business organizations. Corporations take part in CSR to gain PR scores for more sales, while
others consider it a strategic approach to gaining customer loyalty. Whatever the reason
might be that an organization takes part in CSR, the critical element is that it is an essential
part of a business related to the external environment – primarily the customers. The primary
implemented in Commercial banks in the UK. The research considers various banks in the
UK and the different approaches and methods they use in implementing CSR. The study also
determines the financial impact the implementation of CSR has on the commercial banks.
Organizations in other sectors of the economy have successfully implemented CSR not just
as an obligation but as part of their organizational culture and DNA. Commercial banks are
facing the responsibility to be part of the rest of the business community in taking part in
Table of Contents
Abstract ...................................................................................................................................... 2
Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 4
Background ............................................................................................................................ 4
Aim and Objectives of Study ................................................................................................. 4
Research Questions ................................................................................................................ 5
Methodology Used ................................................................................................................. 5
Literature Review....................................................................................................................... 6
Methodology ............................................................................................................................ 14
Research Design................................................................................................................... 14
Data Sources ........................................................................................................................ 14
Document Analysis .............................................................................................................. 14
Ethical Consideration ........................................................................................................... 14
Data Analysis ....................................................................................................................... 15
Conclusion and Recommendations .......................................................................................... 17
References ................................................................................................................................ 18
FINANCIAL IMPACT OF CSR INVESTMENT ON UK BANKS 4
Introduction
Background
The business environment, especially the global market, is changing its approach to
marketing and advertisement. The fundamental question customers ask today is whether or
not an organization plays a role in boosting social welfare and environmental conservation. In
this competitive business world, it is essential to practice CSR activities for commercial
banks to develop their financial growth in the long run. However, some commercials banks
do not care about it, and they only tend to earn more profit without contributing to society.
Still, most of them are concern about CSR, which influences the community positively. CSR
exemption, marketing, and social appreciation. Many commercial banks spend more money
on their advertising purposes, pay taxes. Still, they cannot earn positive recognition from
society. Although they are spending more on these purposes, they remain indifference about
CSR practices. Therefore, the study of CSR is vital, especially when it comes to its
application in commercial banks. Banks are known to make the center stage for business
operation and prosperity. They are also known for entrepreneurship of small-scale businesses
through credit programs. Since banks form an integral part of the society, they should be at
To determine how CSR affects UK banks performance in term of size (CSR bring
service (CSR bring more impact on specialized UK banks Aldermore Bank Plc and
Close brothers) or sizeable high street banks like Lloyds, Barclays, HSBC, etc.)
FINANCIAL IMPACT OF CSR INVESTMENT ON UK BANKS 5
Research Questions
CSR requires a commitment of the board of management of commercial banks as well
achievement of the goals and objectives. Some of the objectives commercial banks have in
the process of engaging CSR are to achieve customer loyalty, make a difference in the
society, make dreams come true for people not directly linked to their business, and solving
Even with varied reasons for implementing CSR, the primary research question is:
Does CSR investment and disclosure bring a significant impact on the UK banks'
performance?
Methodology Used
The most appropriate research design for this research paper is a quantitative research
Literature Review
The approach of analyzing literature is by identifying the research gap to provide an
opportunity for the relevance of the current research. Some of the vital involvements are
requirement. Therefore, the organizational social obligation maybe not the best moral
situation that budgetary foundations face over an environment about the immoral corporate
act, and these saving money organizations would also concern with dedication for
maintainable advancement. CSR reporting analysis for saving money segment for the UK
Banking sector and the impact of CSR activities on their business activities for the fulfillment
of customer needs. Bank's CSR activities associated with the corporate, social, economic,
The study of the UK’s banking system is articulated by Adams et al. (2018) as
a form of studying the projections of the performance of the banking Industry. Adams and his
colleagues do not only consider the performance of the banking system in the UK but how
they compete relatively in the European Union. During the time Adams and his co-authors
conducted his research, BREXIT has not taken place yet. That means the focus of the
dynamics of the banking system in the UK might change as well. Luetkenhorst (2004) does
the banking system. He, instead, he integrates it with other factors that influence the
profitability of commercial banks. This approach may result in false findings because there
are too many factors that are not limited during the research. The theory of Corporate Social
enterprise. The approach holds that the primary aim of businesses in the community is to
generate maximum profit for the company. However, the markets should not make maximum
FINANCIAL IMPACT OF CSR INVESTMENT ON UK BANKS 7
benefits at the expense of the other stakeholders apart from the shareholders (Rainey 2010, p.
56). Based on the insights developed by Milton Friedman on corporate social responsibility,
Melo and Galan (2011, p. 435) explain that businesses act as agents to the stakeholders. The
agency implies that their activities are aimed at meeting the needs of all the stakeholders.
However, most companies find it challenging to balance the needs of different stakeholders
(Moizer and Tracey, 2010, p. 258). For companies to gain a competitive advantage in the
market through corporate social responsibility, they must engage in activities that have
economic gains.
The commitment of the companies towards corporate social responsibility has yield
positive results that promote their competitive advantage (Massetti 2012, p. 54). However,
the increased competition in the business environment demands high efficiency of the CSR
succeeding in CSR initiatives. Effective communication ensures that the employees work in
unison towards achieving the intended objectives. The commitment of top managers is the
other method of ensuring the successful implementation of CSR strategies (Garavan and
McGuire 2010, p. 490). The senior managers play a significant role in motivating the middle-
level and supervisors towards supporting CSR actions. Additionally, the top managers
provide the resources needed for the implementation of amicably because they understand the
significance of adopting CSR policies. It is also crucial for companies to link their business
A study by Kashmanian, Wells, and Keenan (2011, p. 108) proposes that companies
may increase their competitiveness by giving back to the community. One of the best
strategies that the authors suggest is the alignment of company strategies with business
also an essential strategy for enhancing sustainability through reduced costs. Companies also
FINANCIAL IMPACT OF CSR INVESTMENT ON UK BANKS 8
need to recognize the extent of the pollution caused by their activities and define appropriate
measures to protect the environment. A healthy relationship between the company and all its
Based on the literature as mentioned above, it is observed that there is the main
banking sector, which has significant implications for the banking sector to create a positive
image of the society. However, there is a gap in research of CSR to out the sector-wise
expenditure (Nicolopoulou, 2011). Moreover, these reports adequately not provide CSR
activities of every bank in the UK, which are listed as financial institutions. But they try to
express the actual data and relevant information that is disclosed in the financial statement
and annual reports based on the rules and regulations of bank guidelines.
cultures of various organizations. The purpose of the CSR is directed to the achievement of
banks is viewed as an approach to improve the speed of achieving the objectives of CSR.
Nicolopoulou defines CSR as the purpose of the cleansing of the methods of competition
among commercial banks in the UK. The approach is geared towards enhancing the well-
being of the local people in the society. About 77% of the commercial banks surveyed are
involved in the provision of ethical disclosure; 90% of the commercial banks made
employees disclose their commitment to the service towards the well-being of the local
citizens. Even with the changes in the approaches taken by the commercial banks, it is only
organizational commitments that are made are determined to be personal commitments in the
spirit of achieving the implementation of CSR. Even though the CSR combined objectives
FINANCIAL IMPACT OF CSR INVESTMENT ON UK BANKS 9
are the same, various commercial banks in the UK apply it in different approaches and
strategies.
A research conducted by Williams et al. (2000) [9] contends that ventures increase
total deal profits. Eventually, Tom's perusing attempting for A CSR perspective; same the
long run critics argue that CSR distracts beginning with association’s fiscal a feature. An
conclusions something like previous investigations rests positive, negative, and impartial cash
related impact, were due to faulty test analysis. Besides, guaranteed those perspectives, the
point when the examination will have a chance to be suitably specified, CSR compelling
reason an impartial influence when cash related conclusions. Luetkenhorst (2004), secured
An examination of the money related Sector‖, corporate social commitment maybe not the
individuals just right circumstance that cash related associations face looking into An
named CSR hones around sparing trade part reason for existing insane CSR recognizes an
organization's promise will fill in previously, socially during hazard route. Wu, Meng-Wen,
prompts an examination of "around ten profits of those benefits of the business banks.
Moreover, ran across that 100 banks accounted for their CSR activities settle on that;
similarly, 60% of banks took. A premium will prescribe CSR locale concerning outline stated
level of the corporate social commitment from a different viewpoint in this bringing over
indicate the individuals CSR in the obsession for admiration to sparing cash fragment toward
FINANCIAL IMPACT OF CSR INVESTMENT ON UK BANKS 10
those frameworks starting with asserting business bank Concerning delineation the
The voluntary disclosure that starts with the guarantee of standalone CSR reports
beginning for best Dow compound canachitesinc. Issuing independent CSR reports should
correspond with the 177 associations issuing standalone reports covering the individuals
exactly sometime 2008. Wu, Meng-Wen (2017), found that regarding 95% of, the most
significant 250 associations in the truth might immediately issue these standalone reports.
reports, there might make a forcing motivation behind on view every last one of the reason
associations pick around issue these reports When their practicality exertions Moreover
issues (Wu, Meng-Wen, 2017). Those late extension looking into voluntary rest of CSR is
excellent on the way due to the individual's effect something like Creating weight beginning
with both internal Also external stakeholders for associations for being of service corporate
On the representative hand, bringing a feature On Besides rest CSR activities might
energy cost axillary vein once a firm, likewise of the degree that rivals misfire will
participate, A firm’s kept tabs position in the business focus might white collar of the way
(Luetkenhorst, 2004). On the other hand, a couple of diminishments gather will of service
corporate nationals. For example, previous inspect necessity showed that associations that
need aid alluded with requirement a particular obligation would CSR have help obligated will
productive surroundings.
FINANCIAL IMPACT OF CSR INVESTMENT ON UK BANKS 11
Upkeep for agents sure dares the operations within the principles of CSR (Hopkins,
2015). Thus, A firm may voluntarily pick to issue a standalone CSR report out ought to
further bolster undertaking a picture that those associations might have a chance to be
socially careful Besides Regularly friendly (Hopkins, 2015). Standalone reports distinctively
sort starting with guaranteeing voluntary disclosure compelling reason support subordinate
upon those present that managers to associations wish to look into uncover additional
dominant part of the information in the trusts that the individual's stakeholders interpret such
acknowledge that a considerable benefit starting with guaranteeing to issue standalone CSR
reports will be reputation overhaul. These discoveries are asserted; eventually, Tom's
perusing McGuire’s who noted that mark overhaul Moreover reputation was the individual's
legitimate purpose behind issuing these reports. Same period precisely associations might
accessible trustworthy standalone CSR reports, distinctive associations could take advantage
regarding the dominant part of the information asymmetry and the nonattendance of
Baumgartner & Ebner (2010, p. 86) reveals that organizations that use green technologies
such as Dell have a better competitive advantage. Since 2015, Dell has reduced its emission
effort by the company has promoted its competitive advantage by increasing its market share.
Based on the number of shipments, the company had a market share of 13.1% in 2014, and it
rose to 14.8 in 2016 due to its adoption of green technology in 2015 (The Statistica, 2017).
FINANCIAL IMPACT OF CSR INVESTMENT ON UK BANKS 12
For businesses to appeal more to customers, they must ensure that they control the harm that
Business activities are among the primary causes of the product waste challenges
faced by the community. Examples of difficulties caused by businesses include pollution that
may cause adverse effects on human health. However, Porters (2013) argues that companies
can be a source of solution to the social challenges experienced. Through corporate social
responsibility, companies can offer solutions to the challenges faced by society because of
their activities.
The theory of Corporate Social Responsibility is one of the approaches that explain
about challenges of responsible enterprise. The approach holds that the primary aim of
businesses in the community is to generate maximum profit for the company. However, the
markets should not make maximum benefits at the expense of the other stakeholders apart
from the shareholders (Rainey 2010, p. 56). Based on the insights developed by Milton
Friedman on corporate social responsibility, Melo and Galan (2011, p. 435) explain that
businesses act as agents to the stakeholders. The agency implies that their activities are aimed
at meeting the needs of all the stakeholders. However, most companies find it challenging to
balance the needs of different stakeholders (Moizer and Tracey, 2010, p. 258). For companies
to gain a competitive advantage in the market through corporate social responsibility, they
The commitment of the companies towards corporate social responsibility has yield
positive results that promote their competitive advantage (Massetti 2012, p. 54). However,
the increased competition in the business environment demands high efficiency of the CSR
succeeding in CSR initiatives. Effective communication ensures that the employees work in
FINANCIAL IMPACT OF CSR INVESTMENT ON UK BANKS 13
unison towards achieving the intended objectives. The commitment of top managers is the
other method of ensuring the successful implementation of CSR strategies (Garavan and
McGuire 2010, p. 490). The senior managers play a significant role in motivating the middle-
level and supervisors towards supporting CSR actions. Additionally, the top managers
provide the resources needed for the implementation of amicably because they understand the
significance of adopting CSR policies. It is also crucial for companies to link their business
A study by Kashmanian, Wells, and Keenan (2011, p. 108) proposes that companies
may increase their competitiveness by giving back to the community. One of the best
strategies that the authors suggest is the alignment of company strategies with business
also an essential strategy for enhancing sustainability through reduced costs. Companies also
need to recognize the extent of the pollution caused by their activities and define appropriate
measures to protect the environment. A healthy relationship between the company and all its
Methodology
Research Design
The research design for this study is a qualitative analysis, and thus it involves descriptive
and content analysis. The primary purpose of the analysis is to determine the effects of CSR
England for purposes of collecting data for at least ten years beginning 2008 to 2017. All the
21 selected banks were included in the analysis through content analysis of the annual reports
since 2008.
Data Sources
Most of the information gathered will be obtained from secondary sources. One of the
sources will be annual bank reports from the 21 selected banks throughout the ten years. One
of the reasons for the preference of secondary data was that there is limited time to collect all
necessary information to support conclusive analysis for this study. The credibility of the
information is checked through screening to ensure that the data collected is consistent and
Document Analysis
Data collected from the annual bank reports for the ten years will be compared to
information collected from articles, reports, and journals to aid in the testing of the
hypothesis. Besides, the comparison will be made to ensure that the information obtained is
Ethical Consideration
Since most of the information obtained or collected for this study, it will be a requirement
that all the sources are cited appropriately. It is a requirement for the appreciation of the
primary researchers who serve as the sources of the information I gather in developing a new
finding. Besides, it will be made clear to all respondents that the study is voluntary and that
As outlined herein, the voluntary disclosure that starts with the guarantee of
similar to those made a decade ago (Wu, Meng-Wen, 2017). According to Corporate-
canachites requirement produced beginning for best Dow compound canachitesinc. Issuing
independent CSR reports should correspond with the 177 associations issuing standalone
reports covering the individuals exactly sometime 2008. Wu, Meng-Wen (2017), found that
regarding 95% of, the most significant 250 associations in the truth might immediately issue
these standalone reports. Similarly, as a delayed consequence of this improvement for issuing
independent CSR reports, there might make a forcing motivation behind on view every last
one of the reason associations pick around issue these reports When their practicality
exertions Moreover issues (Wu, Meng-Wen, 2017). Those late extension looking into
voluntary rest of CSR is excellent on the way due to the individual's effect something like
Creating weight beginning with both internal Also external stakeholders for associations for
Data Analysis
The primary consideration that has to be made is whether CSR expenditure
significantly influences the profitability of commercial banks in the UK. Such correlation can
be done by considering CSR expenditure as the dependent variable and bank profit as an
independent variable. Based on the considerations made herein, the null and alternative
calculated by profit after tax divided by total assets. invCSR and DCSR are explanatory
Cadez (2017), CSR variables in prior studies were found to be the reason for the diverse
outcome of the relationship between CSR and banks' financial performance. In our case,
DCSR represents disclosures of CSR activities by the bank. It is dummy variables based on 0
and 1. If banks have a dedicated section of the annual reports for CSR activities, then it's one
otherwise 0. Similar, two control variables are included in this model to achieve better and
more control results. One is size measurement, which is calculated through a total assets
investment. The second control variable is the growth in total assets. Pinpoint the idea of
various countries around the world. Besides, the demand for CSR has increased in all areas of
production. The banking sector is not left behind; it has contributed to intense
competitiveness as well as the benefits of CSR that comes with the demand.
This research paper plays a critical role in coming up with a framework that initiates a
better understanding of CSR in the UK. It also harmonizes the link between CSR and the
banking sector based on social responsibilities and the outcome benefits of the commitment
commercial banks make in the UK. The research confirms that there is a significant
relationship between CSR commitment and the profitability of commercial banks in the UK.
Today, several companies, including banks, have heeded to the increasing demand for
involvement in CSR. The primary reason is that it comes with benefits for the organizations.
This research paper also provides clear identification of the barrier to the commitment
purposefully for the well-being of the public. Some of the commitments include the
conservation of the environment through activities such as planting trees. Therefore, this
References
Adams, CarolA., Wan-Ying Hill & Clare B. Roberts. (2018). Corporate Social Reporting
Practices in Western Europe: Legitimating Corporate Behaviour? British Accounting
Review, 30: 1-21
Aguilera, R.V., Williams, C.A., Conley, J.M. and Rupp, D.E., 2006. Corporate Governance
and social responsibility: A comparative analysis of the UK and the US. Corporate
Governance: an international review, 14(3), pp.147-158.
Aguilera, RV, Rupp, DE, Williams, CA and Ganapathi, J. (2007): "Putting the S back in
Corporate Social Responsibility: a multilevel theory of social change in
organizations", Academy of Management Review, vol. 32 no. 3, pp. 836–863
Carroll, A.B. (2016) Carroll’s pyramid of CSR: taking another look. Int J Corporate Soc
Responsibility 1, 3 (2016) doi:10.1186/s40991-016-0004-6
Gray et al. (2001) Social and environmental disclosure and corporate characteristics: A
research note and extension. Journal of Business Finance and Accounting, 28 (3 & 4)
(2001), pp. 327-356
Hopkins. M. (April 2015). Definition of Corporate Social Responsibility. Retrieved June 10,
2016, from http://mhcinternational.com/articles/definition-of-csr
Luetkenhorst W. (2004): Corporate Social Responsibility and the Development Agenda.
Intereconomics 39(3): 157–168
McGuire, J., T. Schneeweis, and A. Sundgren. (2018): Corporate Social Responsibility and
Firm Financial Performance, Academy of Management Journal 31(4), 854–872.
FINANCIAL IMPACT OF CSR INVESTMENT ON UK BANKS 19
Murray, A.: 2005, ‘The Economy, Business: Will Social Responsibility Harm Business?’ The
Wall Street Journal May 18, A2
Nicolopoulou, K. (2011). Towards a theoretical framework for knowledge transfer in the
field of CSR and sustainability. Equality, Diversity, and Inclusion: An International
Journal, 30(6), pp.524-538.
O'Connor, M., and Spangenberg, J.H. (2008). A methodology for CSR reporting: assuring a
representative diversity of indicators across stakeholders, scales, sites, and
performance issues. Journal of Cleaner Production, 16(13), pp.1399-1415.
Pope, S., and Wæraas, A. (2016). CSR-washing is rare: A conceptual framework, literature
review, and critique. Journal of Business Ethics, 137(1), pp.173-193.
Scilly. M. (n.d): Five Dimension of Corporate Social Responsibility. Retrieved June 24,
2015, from http://smallbusiness.chron.com/five-dimensions-corporate-social-
responsibility-54700.html
Tsoutsoura, M (2004). Corporate social responsibility and financial performance. [online].
https://escholarship.org/uc/item/111799p2. [Accessed on October 28, 2019]