Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Monitor
The impact
of Brexit on
(global) trade
The impact of Brexit on (global) trade
The outcome of the UK’s EU referendum and Countries most impacted include Belgium, the more to the UK than they import from the UK.
(Global) trade
looming exit negotiations, are already affecting Netherlands and Germany Depending on the price elasticity of the export
trade flows between the UK and the EU. In this Among the top-10 trading partners of the UK in products, these countries might witness a
issue of PwC Europe’s Brexit Monitor, we will 2015, seven countries are part of the EU. In the deterioration of their terms of trade with the UK.
discuss current trade flows and possible effects of same year, about 44% of UK export was directed Post-Brexit outcomes which significantly increase
Brexit on intra-European trade. to EU Member States, while approximately 53% of the cost of trade between the UK and the rest of the
total imports originated in EU countries. Countries EU will be damaging for both sides.
A free internal market that have deep trade ties to the UK are also most
At present, EU countries including the UK, fully vulnerable to immediate economic impact when the Among EU countries that export the most to the
benefit from the EU’s Single Market. This includes the UK leaves the EU. Although Germany is the UK’s UK, relative to the size of their economies, Ireland
absence of duties and quotas for EU Member States largest trading partner in the EU by volume, Ireland sits at the top of this list, followed by Cyprus, the
doing business and trading throughout the EU. The is by far the most dependent on UK trade in terms of Netherlands and Belgium. While German export
principle of free movement of people also facilitates shares of total imports and exports. volumes are the largest in Europe, due to its sheer
access for workers and services. In addition, simplified size, Germany has many other important export
customs procedures reduce the administrative burden Among western European countries, Belgium, the destinations which could compensate for a decline
for companies trading within the EU to a minimum. Netherlands and Germany export significantly in UK bound exports post-Brexit.
Top-10 export destinations of the UK in 2015 (% of total export) Top-10 import origins of the UK in 2015 (% of total import)
0% 5% 10% 15% 0% 5% 10% 15%
United States Germany
Germany China
Switzerland United States
China Netherlands
France France
Netherlands Belgium
Ireland Italy
Belgium Spain
Spain Norway
Italy Ireland
Source: HM Revenues & Customs, PwC analysis Source: HM Revenues & Customs, PwC analysis.
1 Statistical memo of the Belgian Foreign Trade Agency on the impact of Brexit on the trade
between Belgium and the UK, PDF.
PwC | Brexit Monitor - The impact of Brexit on (global) trade
Future UK trade flows
exported to the EU and the UK has a trade surplus Mineral fuels Motor vehicles
with the EU of GBP 19.8 billion. More detailed Motor vehicles Mechanical appliances
information of the impact of Brexit on the financial Mechanical appliances Pharmaceutical products
services industry is available here.
Pharmaceutical products Electronic equipment
The impact on EU-UK trade will depend on the However, in the WTO scenario, tariffs would in the case no comprehensive new deal has
(Global) trade
relationship between the UK and the EU after increase to WTO’s most favoured nation (MFN) been reached.
Brexit. In the most likely scenarios – either a levels. These are higher than the current levels
comprehensive free trade agreement (FTA) or a (see table below), and may impact trade flows. Past experience shows that multilateral FTAs
fall-back to WTO rules – the costs of trade between take between five to ten years to negotiate and
the UK and the EU will increase. These costs can In terms of timing, business can expect new may need to be ratified by national, and even
be broadly defined as market access measures trading regime(s) to be in place any time between regional, parliaments. As such it is unlikely that a
(tariffs and quotas), increased administrative 2019 and 2029. The UK is set to trigger Article 50 comprehensive new agreement will be in place on
burden (including customs formalities and VAT), before the end of March 2017 and will thereby the day that the UK exits the EU. More likely is some
and behind-the-borders rules that define the extent exit the union no later than the end of March sort of temporary regime while the two parties
of non-tariff barriers (NTBs) to trade. Examples of 2019. From this date, trade between the EU and negotiate further future terms. A final deal can
NTBs are health, safety and environment standards the UK may either be subject to an interim regime therefore be expected at the earliest in 2024, but it
as well as rules of origin requirements. These (for example based on EEA rules) or trade may could take up to 2029 for both parties to agree on
increased costs will be borne by businesses and revert back to WTO rules as the fall-back option and ratify a new deal at the national level.
most likely passed on to consumers.
Estimated MFN tariff levels by sector, in percentages
Under a Free Trade Agreement (FTA) based Sector UK imports EU27 imports
relationship, the UK and the EU would negotiate Agriculture 4.517 2.564
the terms of access for specific sectors, including Primary energy and mining 0.003 0.001
the standards and regulations that apply in those Energy 1.568 0.988
sectors. The EU tradition of harmonization, rather Processed foods 7.848 7.075
than mutual recognition, means the choice for the Low-tech manufacturing 4.692 6.672
UK would likely be to either adopt the EU standards Metals and minerals 1.639 1.523
or for firms to bear the cost of meeting two sets of Chemicals, rubber and plastics 2.800 2.890
standards. Tariffs negotiated under a free trade Motor vehicles and parts 7.200 7.360
agreement are likely to be negotiated to a level Electronic equipment 0.840 0.910
close to the current next to zero levels. Source: Centraal Plan Bureau (2016) Trade effects of Brexit for the Netherlands
Supply chains are becoming more important for the Brexit vote, these decisions may be postponed. In value chain transformation, not only the supply
(Global) trade
competitiveness. Supply chains are increasingly Decisions that cannot be postponed may instead chain of source-make-deliver, but also enabling
globalised as companies want to decrease costs become biased in favour on non-UK locations. functions such as sales, marketing and R&D will be
of sourcing, production and delivery. Added to considered when evaluating the most cost effective
this, companies aim for higher service levels as In supply chain management companies frequently and most strategic locations for trade to and from
consumer expectations related to quality and speed calibrate the cost levels versus service levels of one’s the EU.
of delivery increase. nodes in the supply chain. If transaction costs of
trade become too high, companies may reconsider
According to research by boutique consultancy firm their current or planned locations in the UK.
Global Council, the high ratio of gross trade relative
to the value added suggests that much of the UK’s
EU supply chains are important to the UK
trade is connected to global supply chains. 41% of Gross exports divided by value-added exports by destination
the value added in its exports comes from the EU
0,0% 0,5% 1,0% 1,5% 2,0% 2,5%
and 12% from the US. The importance of the UK
Netherlands
in the international supply chains is particularly
concentrated in some sectors. The UK’s financial Sweden
services and professional services industries, Germany
exports in mining and chemical products, transport, Spain
telecom, as well as wholesale and retail sectors, are
France
very important to international supply chains.
China
How will the EU react to a future free trade other hand, many EU countries trade closely with in Europe on how to tackle negotiation with the UK,
(Global) trade
agreement with the UK? The one thing to the UK and any increase in tariffs or NTBs would can therefore be expected along those lines.
remember in the pending negotiations between also hit those countries. A favourable FTA with the
the EU and the UK is that the EU is not a monolith. UK would indeed also reduce costs for the EU. Any final agreement with the UK will be subject
On the one hand, many EU countries would want to unanimity voting in the European Council, in
to avoid Brexit setting a precedent, or encouraging In general, EU Member States in eastern and southern addition to scrutiny by the European Parliament,
other Member States to pick and choose from the Europe are less connected to the UK through trade. as well as possibly by national and regional
different benefits and costs of EU membership. To Those countries, therefore, would benefit less from a parliaments. This shows the magnitude of the
avoid this, there would be an incentive not to make new free trade agreement than countries such as the task and points to a challenging and potentially
any exit terms too favourable for the UK. On the Netherlands, Ireland, Belgium or Germany. Divisions protracted negotiation period that lies ahead.
References
- Oxford Economics
- CPB (2016a) Trade effects of Brexit for the Netherlands
- CPB (2016b) Brexit costs for the Netherlands arise from reduced trade
- https://www.eureferendum.gov.uk/q-and-a/trade/
- Global Council
- https://www.dlapiper.com/en/netherlands/insights/publications/2016/04/brexit-at-a-glance/brexit-trade/
This content is for general information purposes only, and should not be used as a substitute for consultation with professional advisors.
© 2016 PricewaterhouseCoopers B.V. (KvK 34180289). All rights reserved.
PwC refers to the PwC network and/or one or more of its member firms, each of which is a separate legal entity. Please see www.pwc.com/structure
for further details. At PwC in the Netherlands, over 4,200 people work together from 12 offices. PwC Netherlands helps organisations and individuals
create the value they’re looking for. We’re a member of the PwC network of firms in 157 countries with more than 195,000 people. We’re committed
to delivering quality in assurance, tax and advisory services. Tell us what matters to you and find out more by visiting us at www.pwc.nl.