Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Benzodiazepines
C hronic insomnia affects about 10 to 15% of the US adult
population.'''^ Despite the common occurrence of insom-
nia, it is under recognized, under diagnosed, and as a result,
Currently in the United States, there are five benzodiaz-
epines approved for the short-term treatment of insomnia: flu-
under treated.^ Roughly two thirds of patients who have symp- razepam (Dalmane), estazolam (ProSom), quazepam (Doral),
toms of insomnia do not communicate this information to temazepam (Restoril), and triazolam (Halcion). Long-term stud-
their physician and physicians may not always inquire about
sleep patterns."*
The American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and
Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV) defines Key Points
insomnia as difficulty initiating or maintaining sleep or non- • Physicians should routinely inquire about patients'
restorative sleep that causes clinically significant distress or sleep habits as patients may not report these on their
impairment in social, occupational, or other important areas own.
of functioning.^ Insomnia lasting between one night and a • Any secondary causes of insomnia should be investi-
few weeks is referred to as acute insomnia, while insomnia gated and treated before a diagnosis of primary in-
occurring at least three nights per week for one month or somnia is made.
more is referred to as chronic insomnia.'' Insomnia can be • Behavioral therapy has been shown to be equivalent
classified as primary or secondary.^ Primary insomnia has no to, or superior to pharmacologic therapy, at least in
known pathogenesis, but evidence suggests a state of hyper- some patients, and is a reasonable initial approach,
arousal. Secondary insomnia is due to other causes, such as although there are barriers to its use.
• Zolpidem, zaleplon or ramelteon should be consid-
ered for patients primarily suffering from sleep-onset
From the Department of Pharmacy Practice, University of Florida College of insomnia.
Pharmacy, and the Department of Community Health and Family Med- • Eszopiclone or an intermediate-acting benzodiazepine
icine, University of Florida College of Medicine, Gainesville, FL.
(eg, estazolam, temazepam) would be appropriate for
Reprint requests to James R. Taylor, PharmD, University of Florida College of
Pharmacy, PO Box 100486, Gainesville, FL 32610-0486. Email: jtaylor® insomnia that is predominantly associated with sleep
cop.ufl.edu maintenance. Zaleplon can also be used for those suf-
Accepted July 13, 2006. fering from sleep maintenance insomnia when taken
Copyright © 2006 by The Southem Medical Association in the middle of the night.
0038-4348/0-2000/9900-1373
Southern Medical Journal • Volume 99, Number 12, December 2006 1373
Taylor, Vazquez, and Campbell • Pharmacologic Management of Chronic Insomnia
ies beyond 6 months have not been reported. Benzodiazepines hepatic disease, or renal impairment. Starting doses for the
bind to the gamma subunit of the GABA^ receptor, also known short and intermediate agents are: estazolam 1 to 2 mg at
as the benzodiazepine or omega receptor. These agents are dif- bedtime, temazepam 15 mg 30 minutes before bed, and tria-
ferentiated by their pharmacokinetic properties. Flurazepam and zolam 0.25 mg at bedtime. Doses should be reduced by 50%
quazepam have long half-lives due to their metabolites (48-120 in the elderly or those with hepatic impairment.
h), estazolam and temazepam have intermediate half-lives Trial data demonstrates that benzodiazepines produce sig-
(10-24 and 8-15 h, respectively), and triazolam has the nificant subjective improvements in total sleep time, niunber of
shorter half-life (2-5 h). These agents are metabolized in the awakenings, and sleep quality as compared with placebo.'""'
liver. Concomitant administration with alcohol or other CNS Results on sleep latency have been conflicting. Those agents
depressants can potentiate the CNS effects. with intermediate and long half-lives have been shown to
Benzodiazepines are associated with next day sedation, reduce wake time after sleep onset and number of awaken-
psychomotor impairment, and cognitive impairment.^ All of ings, which results in improved sleep maintenance.^ Triazo-
these are of concern when these agents are used in the elderly, lam has a greater effect on sleep latency.^
especially those with a longer half-life. Long-acting agents
have also been associated with increased risk of falls resulting
in hip fractures in the elderly as a result of residual sedation Nonbenzodiazepines
and impaired motor coordination and currently have a limited Zolpidem. Zolpidem (Ambien) acts on the GABA^ re-
role in the management of insomnia.^ Short-acting agents are ceptor benzodiazepine site. It has an onset of action of 30
associated with rebound insomnia and anterograde amnesia.^ minutes, a half-life of 2.5 hours and its effects will last for up
In addition, all benzodiazepines have the risk of patients de- to eight hours." Zolpidem controlled release (Ambien CR)
veloping tolerance, abuse, and dependence.''^ Benzodiaz- immediately releases 80% of the dose with the remainder
epines are pregnancy category X and thus are contraindicated being released 3 hours later. Zolpidem undergoes hepatic
in these patients. They are also not recommended in children metabolism to inactive metabolites. Antiretroviral protease
for treating insomnia. They should be used with caution in inhibitors may inhibit the metabolism of zolpidem resulting
patients with seizure disorders, respiratory depression, severe in excessive sedation. Likewise, alcohol and other CNS de-
pressant drugs may have additive effects on psychomotor Eszopiclone. Eszopiclone (Lunesta) is believed to inter-
performance when used with zolpidem. Side effects are dose act with the GABA-receptor complex at binding domains
related and include drowsiness, amnesia, dizziness, headache, close to the benzodiazepine receptor. Its pharmacologic prop-
and gastrointestinal complaints." erties are similar to those of benzodiazepines, including an-
Zolpidem has not been evaluated for use in patients un- xiolytic, hypnotic, and sedative activity. Eszopiclone has a
der the age of 18. Zolpidem controlled release is classified as half-life of 5 to 7 hours and a duration of about 8 hours."
pregnancy category C, while the regular release is category B. Eszopiclone is hepatically metabolized to two metabolites,
There are no adequate, well-controlled studies in pregnant one with minimal potency and one which is inactive. Use of
women. Although there are no absolute contraindications, it eszopiclone with alcohol or other CNS depressants may have
should be used cautiously in patients with hepatic impair- additive effects. The most common side effects include bitter
ment, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease or depression. taste, dry mouth, drowsiness, and dizziness." Its safety in
The recommended doses are 10 mg at bedtime in healthy children has not been established. Eszopiclone is pregnancy
adults and 5 mg in older patients, those with hepatic dysfunc- category C. There are no published reports on its use in
tion or patients on another drug which causes CNS depres- pregnant women. It should be used with caution in patients
sion. For the extended release product, 12.5 mg or 6.25 mg with pre-existing respiratory depression or those with depres-
should be used, respectively. sion." The starting dose is typically 2 mg at bedtime, al-
Zolpidem has been shown to produce similar effects on though the dose can be titrated to 3 mg as needed. Elderly
sleep latency and total sleep time with fewer next-day resid- patients or those with severe hepatic impairment should begin
ual effects as compared with benzodiazepines.'''^"''* It may with 1 mg. No dosage adjustment is necessary in mild to
also improve sleep efficiency (ratio of time asleep to time in moderate hepatic impairment.
bed), but it has not consistently shown improvement over Eszopiclone has demonstrated a significant reduction in
placebo in reducing wake time after sleep onset or number of sleep latency and improved measures of sleep maintenance,
awakenings. Zolpidem's benefit in sleep seems to be a result such as wake time after sleep onset and number of awaken-
of its effect on sleep onset rather than sleep maintenance. ings as compared with placebo.^""^'* In addition, eszopiclone
Zolpidem has been studied for up to 5 weeks of continuous showed no evidence of clinically significant tolerance after 6
use and for 12 weeks of intermittent use.'''^"'"* Short-term months of treatment and it has been studied for up to 12
tolerance has not been noted in these studies. In addition, months in an open-label extension trial.^'''•^'' This is the first
after discontinuation of zolpidem, rebound insomnia is rare sedative hypnotic with data to support its continuous use for
with short-term use. up to 12 months.
Zaleplon. Zaleplon (Sonata), like zolpidem, binds to the Ramelteon. Ramelteon (Rozerem) is a highly selective
G A B A A receptor benzodiazepine site but with less affinity. It agonist for the melatonin MT1/MT2 receptors and the newest
has an onset of action of 20 minutes, a half-life of 0.5 to 1 FDA-approved agent for insomnia. Melatonin is believed to
hour, and its effects will last about 4 hours.'^ It is primarily mediate the circadian rhythm in mammals. It is also the first
metabolized by the liver to inactive metabolites. Drugs that hypnotic agent that is not classified as a controlled substance.
have CNS depressant effects (eg, alcohol, anxiolytics, barbi- Ramelteon has an onset of action of 30 minutes and a half-life
turates) may potentiate the CNS effects of zaleplon. Zaleplon of 1 to 2 hours.^^ It is metabolized by the liver to several
contains tartrazine dye and thus should not be used in patients metabolites with varying degrees of activity, although they
with an allergy to this dye.'^ Its safety has not been estab- are much less potent than the parent compound. Concurrent
lished in children. It is pregnancy category C with no studies administration with the SSRI fluvoxamine significantly in-
in pregnant women. Zaleplon should be used cautiously in creases the serum concentrations of ramelteon, and thus these
patients with depression or respiratory insufficiency and is medications should not be used together. Other medications
not recommended for those with severe hepatic disease. The that could itihibit the metabolism of ramelteon include agents
most cotnmon side effects include headache, drowsiness, diz- such as ciprofloxacin, norfloxacin, and mexiletine. Without
ziness, nausea, and dyspepsia. The recommended dose is 10 any data, the concomitant use of over-the-counter melatonin
mg at bedtime, although 5 mg is recommended for the el- is not recommended. Alcohol does not directly affect ramel-
derly, those with mild to moderate hepatic impairment or in teon, but it may still result in additive effects on psychomotor
patients taking another CNS depressant medication. performance. Potential adverse effects include somnolence,
Zaleplon has been shown to be effective in reducing dizziness, nausea, fatigue and headache.^^ Serum prolactin
sleep latency as compared with placebo, but lacks data sup- increased in 32% of patients in one study.^^ Assessment of
porting it effects in maintenance of sleep when administered prolactin and testosterone concentrations should be consid-
at sleep onset.'*'" Zaleplon is useful for patients who have ered in patients with unexplained amenorrhea, galactorrhea,
frequent nocturnal awakening because it can be taken in the decreased libido, or problems with fertility. Its use is contra-
middle of the night without causing next-day impairment, as indicated in children, nursing mothers, and those with severe
long as it is taken 4 hours before time needed to awaken.'^ hepatic disease. It is pregnancy category C with no well-
Southern Medical Journal • Volume 99, Number 12, December 2006 1375
Taylor, Vazquez, and Campbell • Pharmacologic Management of Chronic Insomnia
controlled human studies. Ramelteon should be used cau- Melatonin and valerian are alternative therapies which
tiously in those with pre-existing neurologic disease, mild to are also readily available. Melatonin has been shown to in-
moderate hepatic disease, endocrine disease, seizure disorder, duce sleep in healthy volunteers, elderly patients and those
or the elderly.^^ The recommended dose is 8 mg taken within with insomnia.^'"''^ Its effects on sleep maintenance are less
30 minutes of going to bed. impressive with conflicting results."*"'"' The studies have in-
Ramelteon has been shown to be significantly more ef- volved small numbers of subjects treated for short durations.
fective than placebo in reducing sleep latency, increasing It appears to be well tolerated, at least for short-term use.
total sleep time and sleep efficiency in studies for up to 5 Valerian has been shown to reduce sleep latency, and im-
weeks in duration.^*"^' Ramelteon had no effect on any be- prove sleep maintenance, although large, well-designed trials
havioral and cognitive performance tests, and showed no po- are lacking.'*'' It may take 2 to 4 weeks before significant
tential for abuse. effects are seen. Side effects may include next-day sedation,
Trazodone. Trazodone (Desyrel), an antidepressant with headache, uneasiness and excitability. Without more data on
sedating properties, is commonly prescribed for the treatment its efficacy and safety, it is not recommended at this time.
of insotnnia, although it lacks FDA approval for this use. It
inhibits the reuptake of serotonin, a-adrenergic blocking ac- Summary and Recommendations
tion and modest histamine blockade. It is metabolized in the Before the diagnosis of primary insomnia is made, any
liver to inactive metabolites. It can interact with numerous secondary causes should be identified and treated. A reason-
medications, including other medications affecting serotonin able approach is to first begin with behavioral therapy. Cli-
(eg, selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors), other CNS de- nicians may provide this therapy themselves or refer patients
pressants (eg, alcohol), ketoconazole, and itraconazole. The to a sleep specialist. Realizing when referral is needed is very
most common side effects include drowsiness, dry mouth, important for the primary care physician. Referral is appro-
nausea, vomiting, constipation, headache and blurred vision. priate for chronic, resistant and/or unexplained insomnia. Rec-
Trazodone is not approved for use in children and it is preg- ognize that not all patients will adequately respond to behav-
nancy category C. It should be used with caution in patients ioral therapy as it may not be effective in all subsets of
with hepatic or renal impairment. The recommended dose for patients.
treatment of insomnia is 50 mg at bedtime. If it is also being Despite the fact that long-term data is lacking, patients
used for depression, higher doses will be used. who do not respond to behavioral therapy may proceed to
As an antidepressant, trazodone has the advantage of pharmacolgical therapy. Efficacy, tolerance and side effects
treating insomnia while treating concurrent conditions like will need to be closely monitored. The two approaches should
depression or psychological disorders. In addition, trazodone generally not be combined since this may reduce the long-
offers a low cost potential for long-term use, and a low abuse term benefit of behavioral therapy, although this recommen-
potential. However, there is limited data from double-blind, dation is based on somewhat limited data. However, pharma-
controlled studies on its efficacy for treating insomnia. Tra- cologic therapy may be considered for short-term use when
zodone has been shown to be effective in two small trials in initiating behavioral therapy, especially in those who would
patients with concurrent depression without concurrent hyp- benefit from the more rapid results. Combination therapy
notic use.''^'''^ Even though trazodone has shown subjective could be considered in patients who are willing to comply
improvement in ease of falling asleep and quality of sleep, it with the behavioral therapies. Zolpidem, zaleplon or ramelt-
has also been associated with negative effects on ease of eon should be considered for patients primarily suffering from
awakening and feelings at or after wakening. Studies have sleep onset insomnia. Ramelteon is the least likely of these
also shown a decline in efficacy after one to two weeks of agents to cause cognitive or behavioral impairment with short-
treatment, suggesting the potential for development of toler- term use, but long-term differences are unknown. Eszopi-
ance.^^'^"^ Side effects of trazodone include orthostatic hypo- clone or an intermediate-acting benzodiazepine (eg, estazo-
tension and blurred vision which can lead to falls, especially lam, temazepam) would be appropriate for insomnia that is
in the elderly. Other side effects include nausea, dry mouth, predominantly associated with sleep maintenance. Zaleplon
constipation, drowsiness, and headache. Trazodone has also can also be used for those suffering fi-om sleep maintenance
been associated with rebound insomnia after withdrawal. insomnia when taken in the middle of the night. Long-term
Over-the-counter agents Sedating antihistamines such use of hypnotic agents is largely unsupported at this time.
as diphenhydramine are marketed as sleep aids to induce Further research is needed on the long-term effects of
sleep. They are readily available and relatively inexpensive pharmacologic therapy, comparing pharmacologic agents to
and thus are often used by patients. However, data on the use one another, to determine which patients benefit most from
of these agents is sparse and of short duration and poor qual- behavioral therapy, and to clarify the role of combining be-
ity.^^'^^ In addition, they are also associated with next-day havioral and pharmacological therapy. Strategies to improve
sedation, anticholinergic side effects, psychomotor impair- the availability of behavioral therapy and primary care clini-
ment and the development of tolerance.^^'^^ cian training are also encouraged.
Southern Medical Journal • Volume 99, Number 12, December 2006 1377