Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
SUMMARY The influence of lateral pterygoid muscle activity on growth of the condylar cartilage
of the mandible remains controversial. As a case in point, two recent studies involving total
resection (myectomy) and sectioning (myotomy) of this muscle have come to contradictory
conclusions. In the study reported here, it was found that young growing rats in which the lateral
pterygoid muscle was bilaterally cut experienced significantly retarded mitotic activity and bone
formation relative to their sham-operated counterparts. Changes in the shape and topographical
distribution of cartilage over the condylar head, as well as the distribution of labelled cells, were
also noted in myotomy animals at 4 days following surgery.
Considerable resorption at the insertion of the muscle on the mandibular ramus was apparent at
14 days after surgery. However, the myotomy surgery was accompanied by a significant post-
operative loss of body weight and incisal supra-eruption indicative of feeding difficulties, thereby
complicating interpretation of the results.
cutting of the muscle, served as a sham surgery The results were expressed as dpm//ig DNA in
group. the acid insoluble precipitate.
Twenty-eight of the animals were killed 4 days The mandibular condyles designated for
following surgery by intravenous injections of biochemical analysis of [45Ca]-uptake were
sodium pentobarbital; the other 24 were killed 14 removed, weighed, and then homogenized in 2
days following surgery. The degree to which the ml ice-cold 0.15 NaCl containing 0.003 M
lateral pterygoid muscle had been damaged was NaHCO 3 at pH 7.4. Following centrifugation at
determined by visual inspection and recorded at 3000 g for 60 minutes at 4°C, the sediment was
sacrifice. Two hours prior to death, six to eight stirred in 5 ml 0.1 M CaCl2 in 0.05 M Tris-HCl
animals from each group were injected intrave- buffer, pH 7.4 at 25°C for 30 minutes, then
nously (femoral vein) with 1 j*Ci/g body weight centrifuged at 3000 g for 30 minutes. The
of [45Ca]-chloride in water (New England Nuc- sediment was washed twice in 10 ml lots of 5 mM
lear, specific activity = 21.9 mCi/mg). One hour Tris-HCl, pH 7.4 and centrifuged at 3000 £ for 30
prior to death, another six to eight animals from minutes. Following washing, the sediment was
each group were injected intravenously with 2 stirred in 10 ml 0.5 M HC1 for 2 hours at 25°C.
fiCi/g body weight of [3H]-thymidine (New Eng- After centrifugation at 3000 g for 30 minutes, an
land Nuclear, specific activity = 6.7 Ci/mmol). aliquot (750 /il) of the supernatant was added to
At sacrifice, both condyles were removed; one 10 ml of ACS (Aqueous Counting Scintillant,
was randomly chosen for biochemical assay, and Amersham) and assayed for radioactivity in a
the other for histology and radioautography. In Beckman LS7500 scintillation counter. The
the condyle designated for analysis of [3H]- results were expressed as cpm/mg tissue.
thymidine incorporation, the articular disc was In condyles reserved for radioautographic and
carefully detached so as not to damage or strip histological analysis, the disc and ramus were left
Table 1 Percentage body weight gain/lossf. Mean + SD. characterized the muscle in the sham surgery
group. By 14 days following surgery, the muscle
Time after surgery was found at death to be cut over half or more of
14 days
its cross-section in all but one myotomy animal.
4 days 7 days
Incisal supraeruption was still present in most
Sham surgery 30.6±4.9 70.4 ±6.5 135.3+12.2 myotomy animals, although to a lesser extent
Myotomy -15.3 + 8.2* 7.4+13.3* 27.3+15.0* than at 4 days.
(7) (6) (6) Considerable intergroup differences in weight
gain were present at both death intervals (Table
• Mean is different from sham surgery group at 1). At 4 days post-surgery, myotomy group
t Calculated as a percentage of body weight immediately
prior to surgery. animals had lost on average 15 per cent of their
pre-surgical body weight, whereas the sham
surgery group had experienced approximately a
its height (i.e. through the superior head and well 31 per cent gain in body weight since surgery.
into the inferior head) in half of the animals and Inspection of weight gain at 7 days post-surgery
cut nearly through in the other half. Upon indicated that the beginnings of weight gain by
examination at death, the lateral pterygoid the myotomy group animals had begun by this
muscle in the myotomy group appeared quite time interval. By 14 days post-surgery, the
pale in comparison to the reddish colour which myotomy animals had gained weight noticeably,
but at a significantly slower rate than the sham a sickle-shape from the medial to the lateral poles
surgery group. of the condylar head (Fig. la). In contrast, the
myotomy group condyles were characterized by
Morphology and radioautography a strongly asymmetrical distribution of the carti-
4 Days after surgery. At 4 days following surgery lage, with very thin cartilage laterally giving way
the cartilage in the myotomy group was consis- to a considerably thicker cartilage medially,
tently different from sham surgery animals in its often peaking in thickness in the medial one-
morphology in coronal (frontal) section and to third of the contour (Fig. lb). The reduced
a lesser degree in sagittal section. In coronal thickness on the lateral aspect of the cartilage
section, the sham surgery condyles exhibited a appeared to be largely due to a greatly attenuated
relatively even thickness of cartilage extending in chondroblastic region (Fig. 2a,b). This atypical
Figure 3 (a-f) Drawings of the distribution of [3H]-thymidine labelled cells in three animals from each group killed 4 days
following surgery. Coronal sections are depicted, with each dot representing the position of one labelled cell. In each instance, the
medial aspect is to the right. Thin irregular line delineates the approximate location of the cartilage-bone interface, (a-c) Sham
surgery, (d-f) Myotomy.
374 R. J. HINTON
distribution of cartilage was a common, but not cartilage in the sham surgery group was crescent-
universal finding in the myotomy sample, being shaped, gradually increasing in thickness from
present in seven of nine animals for which anterior to posterior, attaining its greatest thick-
coronal sections were available. Inspection of ness at the posterosuperior and posterior aspects.
plots of the distribution of labelled cells showed The cartilage in the animals which had under-
that the preponderance of labelled prechondro- gone myotomy 4 days earlier was considerably
blastic cells in the myotomy animals were found thinner over the anterior and superior aspects of
in the medial half of the cartilage, with very few its contour than in the sham surgery group (Fig.
to none laterally. By comparison, the distribu- 4a,b), often constituting a zone only a few cell
tion in the sham surgery animals was much more layers thick. In addition, in some myotomy
uniform (Fig. 3a-f). In both groups, uptake of animals the cartilage appeared truncated on its
the [3H]-thymidine label was confined almost posterior aspect, with the tissue in this region
exclusively, as would be expected, to the pre- resembling bone more than cartilage (Fig. 5b); in
chondroblastic layer of the cartilage and to the sham surgery animals, a cartilaginous tissue of
subchondral bone deep to the cartilage, with an varying thickness was present in this region (Fig.
occasional labelled cell in the articular disc or 5a). Although the appearance and thickness of
fibrous articular layer of the cartilage. Resorp- cartilage in the posterior region of the condyle
tion at the insertion of the lateral pterygoid varied in the sham surgery group from medial to
muscle on the condylar neck appeared to be lateral as well as between animals, nothing
accentuated in some myotomy animals relative comparable to the appearance described above
to the sham surgery group. in certain myotomy animals was observed in any
In sagittal section at 4 days, the condylar of the sham surgery condyles. However, this
finding was not typical of all myotomy animals.
Figure 5 (a,b) Posterosuperior and posterior aspect of condylar cartilage in representative sham surgery (a) and myotomy (b)
animals. Anterior is to the left. (Sagittal section, H & E. Bar represents 400 ^m.)
reduced number and thickness of hypertrophic group routinely one-half to one-third the corres-
cells. ponding figure in the sham surgery group. [3H]-
thymidine incorporation, but not [45Ca]-uptake,
Biochemical analysis declined significantly over time within each
Two-way analysis of variance with group and group.
time interval as factors indicated significant Although labelling indices were not calculated
effects for both group (F=35.7, P^O.001 and due to small sample sizes, the sections taken for
time (F=11.3, PsSO.01) for [3H]-thymidine [3H]-thymidine radioautography supported the
incorporation, but the interaction of the two results obtained from the biochemical assay of
factors was not significant. A similar result was [3H]-thymidine incorporation. As Fig. 3a-f
obtained for [45Ca]-uptake: both group (F= 23.5, show, the primary difference between the myo-
P^0.001) and time effects (F=7.3, /><0.05) tomy animals and the sham surgery group lay in
were significant, but not their interaction. the greatly reduced number of labelled cells in the
[3H]-thymidine incorporation (dpm/^g DNA) prechondroblastic layer of the cartilage, with
was significantly reduced in the myotomy sample more similar labelling in the subchondral bone.
compared to the sham surgery group by 4 days
following surgery, and continued to be so 14 days
following surgery (Table 2). [45Ca]-uptake (cpm/ Discussion
mg tissue) was similarly affected at both post- The biochemical analyses of [3H]-thymidine in-
surgical intervals. Values for both parameters, corporation and [45Ca]-uptake support the ear-
even though corrected for differences in tissue lier findings of Petrovic and co-workers using a
weight or DNA content, were in the myotomy rat myectomy model. They found that the
376 R. J. HINTON
Figure 6 (a) Coronal section of condyle in 14-day myotomy animal. Note resorption at the insertion of the lateral pterygoid
muscle (LPM), 'undermining' the condylar cartilage. (H & E. Bar represents 400 fim.) (b) Higher-power view of insertion of
lateral pterygoid muscle on condylar neck in myotomy animal, showing extensive resorption (arrows), (c) Similar view of
insertion of lateral pterygoid muscle in a sham surgery animal. (Bar represents 400 /im for b and c.)
LATERAL PTERYGOID MYOTOMY 377
Table 2 [3H]-thymidine incorporation and [45Ca]-uptake in tomy, the only time interval which overlaps with
sham surgery and myotomy groups. Mean + SD. those studied by Awn et al. (1987). However, the
data of Awn and co-workers permitted the
[3H]-thymidine examination of the rate of mineralization, so the
incorporation [45Ca]-uptake
(dpm//jg DNA) (cpm/mg tissue)
two sets of results are not strictly comparable. On
the other hand, Goret-Nicaise et al. (1983),
4 days after surgery employing a similar model in older rats, noted
Sham surgery 440.8 + 75.2 786.1 + 172.6 that myotomy of the lateral pterygoid muscle
(8) (6) appeared to produce 'complex deformations of
Myotomy 212.9 + 68.4** 434.9+120.9**
(6)
the condyle', including resorption at its anterior
(7)
border and increased bone growth at its pos-
14 days after surgery terior border. Although their results were con-
Sham surgery 305.2+139.0 569.5 + 169.2
fined to sagittal sections of the condyle, they bear
(7) (5)
Myotomy 111.8 + 94.3** 309.8+115.6* some similarity to the skewing of cartilage
(7) (5) thickness and resorption-associated deforma-
tions observed in my study.
* Mean is different from the sham surgery mean at
fZ0.05. Any interpretation of these results cannot
** Mean is different from the sham surgery mean at overlook the appreciable, often extreme, loss of
body weight which accompanied bilateral myo-
tomy of the lateral pterygoid muscle. Body
weight differences among the experimental
number of [3H]-thymidine labelled prechondro- groups have not been reported in previous
blasts in the condylar cartilage decreased signifi- studies, yet it appears likely that they occurred,
the mandible (Petrovic et al, 1975; Asano, 1986) DE06982. Thanks are due to Trina Morgan and
or even amputation of the incisor teeth to Sheryl Lumbley for their technical assistance.
discourage incision (Hinton and Carlson, 1986;
Hinton, 1988) has the opposite effect. What is
not clear is whether the myotomy affects func- References
tional movements of the mandible more through Asano T 1986 The effects of mandibular retractive force on
its surgical sequelae (i.e. scarring) or through the the growing rat mandible. American Journal of Orthodon-
elimination of lateral pterygoid muscle pull with tics and Dentofacial Orthopedics 90: 464-474.
the associated diminished movement or protru- Awn M, Goret-Nicaise M, Dhem A 1987 Unilateral section
sive capability. Although some scarring may of the lateral pterygoid muscle in the growing rat does not
have been present in the myotomy group ani- alter condylar growth. European Journal of Orthodontics
mals, the extent of incisal supra-eruption in the 9: 122-128.
myotomy animals appeared no worse at 14 days Burton K 1956 A study of the conditions and mechanisms of
than at 4 days; in addition, in the last week before the diphenylamine reaction for the colorimetric estimation
of deoxyribonucleic acid. Biochemical Journal 62: 315—
sacrifice, the myotomy animals increased 20 per 323.
cent in body weight compared to 38.1 per cent in Charlier J P, Petrovic A, Hermann-Stutzmann J 1969 Effects
sham surgery animals—a lower, but not insub- of mandibular hyperpropulsion on the prechondroblastic
stantial, rate of weight gain. Thus, any scarring zone of young rat condyle. American Journal of Ortho-
that was present was presumably not severe dontics 55: 71-74.
enough to greatly hamper the food intake capa- Glineburg R W, Laskin D M, Blaustein D I 1982 The effects
bilities of the myotomy animals in the second of immobilization on the primate temporomandibular
week following surgery. joint: A histologic and histochemical study. Journal of
Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery 40: 3-8.
The reason for the changes in the topographi-
bular condylar growth. Acta Morphologica-Neerlandica and Development, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor,
Scandinavica 10: 25-34. pp. 101-154.
Petrovic A, Stutzmann J1972 Le muscle pterygoidien externe Petrovic A G, Stutzmann J J, Oudet C L 1982 Defects in
et la croissance du condyle mandibulaire. Recherches mandibular growth resulting from condylectomy and
experimentales chez le jeune rat. L'Orthodontie Francaise resection of the pterygoid and masseter muscles. In:
43: 271-285. McNamara J A Jr, Carlson D S, Ribbens K A (eds) The
Petrovic A G, Stutzmann J J 1977 Further investigation into effect of surgical intervention on craniofacial growth,
the functioning of the 'comparator' of the servosystem in Monograph Number 12, Craniofacial Growth Series.
the control of the condylar cartilage growth rate and the Center for Human Growth and Development, University
lengthening of the jaw. In: McNamara J A Jr (ed.) The of Michigan, Ann Arbor, pp. 251-272.
biology of occlusal development. Monograph Number 7, Stutzmann J, Petrovic A 1974 Effets de la resection du muscle
Craniofacial Growth Series. Center for Human Growth pterygoidien externe sur la croissance du cartilage condy-
and Development, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, lien de jeune rat. Bulletin de l'Association des Anatomistes
pp. 255-292. (Nancy) 58: 1107-1114.
Petrovic, A G, Stutzmann J J, Oudet C L 1975 Control Weijs W A, Dantuma R 1975 Electromyography and
processes in the postnatal growth of the condylar cartilage mechanics of mastication in the albino rat. Journal of
of the mandible. In: McNamara J A Jr (ed) Determinants Morphology 146: 1-34.
of mandibular form and growth, Monograph Number 4,
Craniofacial Growth Series. Center for Human Growth