Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
ON
For
By
Submitted to
UNIVERSITY OF PUNE
THROUGH
ALL INDIA SHRI SHIVAJI MEMORIAL SOCIETY’S
INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT (MBA)
PUNE-411 001
*[2006-2008]*
“DATAMINING FOR CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT”
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I kindly express my sincere thanks to entire RBM and IBM team for providing me
an outstanding platform to carry out the project internship in an efficient manner for the
organization.
developer & Trainer) and Mrs. Nisha Barua (Software Trainer IBM Bangalore) who
in spite of their guidance and pressing responsibilities regarding to clear the exact
concept of software marketing and rendered support at all stages during internship.
I also like to express my deep sense of gratitude to Mrs.Surya Ramdas for their
encouragement and priceless information always provided through out the endeavor.
Last but not the least I extend my special thanks to my friend Mr. Sushil Kumar
(PGP 1st year IIM AHEMADABAD) for selecting the topic and his effective guideline
2
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
1. Introduction
3. Research Methodology
4. Data Sources
Primary Data
Secondary data
www.ibm.co.in
3
LIST OF TABLE
LIST OF FIGURE
4
INDEX
5
“DATAMINING FOR CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT”
1.1 INTRODUCTION
Clients want solutions- not the pieces of technology, or bits of advice so IBM
speaks the language of business. IBM believes in smart work and hires the people who
6
can win the world through technology. IBM provides high value services to build a new
With the help of this project I came to know the concept of software marketing
In brief, we sell the concept to our customers not the goods. IBM has helped
operational management.
In the organization initially I undergone through the software product of IBM and
had to give presentation daily on each software products. These things gave me the
The data mining of customer relationship management is the topic for evaluating
customer satisfaction which can more extensively in the IBM to obtain critical inputs on
features which customers are delighted to find in the offering and are willing to pay more
dollars for more of certain features. But the questions arise here that how will a person
come to know about all these, so IBM has decided to undergo this project title to data
mine the customer’s base and on that basis Company could find out the new strategic
tools.
7
IBM has ranked first in the world for providing business solutions. IBM strategy
is to satisfy the needs of customers. If there is one company who has been present
very exciting towards this topic because topic is really burning and by the help of this
topic one can come to know the exact satisfaction level of customers. We are into the
providing business solutions and are compulsory to mining the customer responses.
8
9
“DATAMINING FOR CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT”
software group. Lotus notes software is an integrated desktop client option for accessing
10
COMMUNICATION COLLABORATION
LOTUS NOTES
COORDINATION
In this server and client can replicate database designs and data access many types
of networks including modems that user can get full advantage while working
offline.
Lotus notes provide the strong firewall protection that no unauthorized user can
access their database. For this a user to provide their own ID and complex
password.
Lotus notes require users to select new memo rather than new mail. Apart from
this there are various shortcut keys has provide to quick access.
11
Websphere is IBM’s integration software platform. It include the entire
middleware infrastructure such as server, services and tools needed to write, run and
Business integration
Commerce
Networking
Software development
MATURITY
SYS. & INFORM.MGMT
RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
12
Business Application management
Service management
PRODUCTS OF TIVOLI
Monitoring express
PEOPLE
13
INFORMATIO
N
Figure No. 2: IBM TIVOLI FEATURES
Information Integration
RATIONAL SOFTWARE
the speed, quality, and predictability of software projects. This full life-cycle solution
combines software engineering best practices, market-leading tools and many more.
14
Architecture Management
Quality management
QUICK FACTS
15
“DATAMINING FOR CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT”
JUNE 6, 2006: The chairman and chief executive officer of IBM, Samuel J.
announced IBM expects to nearly triple its investment in India over the next three years.
Mr. Palmisano spoke before 10,000 employees gathered in Bangalore and via
satellite to thousands of other employees in Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata and Pune. With
43,000 employees in 14 cities, India is IBM's largest country organization outside the
U.S.
IBM is the world's largest information technology services and consulting provider.
Some 190,000 professionals in more than 160 countries help clients integrate information
technology with business value -- from the business transformation and industry expertise
training services.
16
IBM has been present in INDIA since 1992. Its Regional headquarter in
BANGALORE.IBM has its offices in 14 cities including Regional offices in New Delhi,
Mumbai, Chennai, Kolkata. IBM offers serving customers serving better, reducing risks
1951
IBM begins operations in India The business operated successfully until the mid-
1970s, when India’s Foreign Exchange Regulation Act (FERA) required foreign owned
companies to reduce their equity ownership to (in IBM’s case) 26%. For obvious reasons,
IBM was unwilling to take that course of action and so in 1978, the company ‘changed its
Mode of business operation’ and began to conduct business in India as an off-shore entity
1992
1995
1997
TISL Becomes Tata IBM Ltd, IBM Global Services launched - offers a range of
17
Solution Partnership Center is set up in Bangalore to help Indian ISVs port application
1998
January
Information Technology (IIIT), to offer short-term courses to the public and credit
April
1999
2000
June
November
18
financing and leasing programs to fund information technology (IT) requirements of
Indian customers.
2001
enhance and support key IBM products & technologies with a committed investment of
Linux Strategy, working closely with the worldwide Linux Technology Centre.
June 2002
IGSI recognized as the "Top MNC Software Services Exporter" and "Top Foreign
Equity Company" in Karnataka for Year 2001-02 by Software Technology Parks of India
July
IGSI has also been also recognized as ‘Distinguished IT Exporter' for 2001-02 by
MAIT.
Dataquest, India's leading trade magazine has also rated IGSI as the Top MNC
2003
19
RBM (Radix Business Models) is the business partner of IBM. RBM is a
software services provider, which follows Onsite Support Model and Offshore Model,
what is popularly termed as the ODC model (Offshore Development Center). RBM is
serving 8 consistent clients with repeat records, keeping customer satisfaction as focus.
Human Consulting, Education, etc through varied technologies – Louts Notes, .Net, Java,
etc. Our flexible methodology is client-focused to cater client needs, ensuring rapid
20
“DATAMINING FOR CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT”
INDUSTRY PROFILE
Table No. 1
21
Figure No. 3 RANK WISE MARKET SHARE
Following are the major market player in the field of service provider for the
Table No. 2
22
Figure No.-4 TOP SERVICE PROVIDER
23
24
“DATAMINING FOR CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT”
Primary Objectives
Secondary Objectives
PRIMARY OBJECTIVE
includes how Data Mining can allow an organization to market the product to customers
25
To attract more customers to build their Infrastructures, Operations and IT
processes.
To customized the software product as suitable for providing end-to end business
solutions.
SECONDARY OBJECTIVE
and patronage intentions. By using the measuring service quality that expressiveness
provider.
Our activities are very close to what is the need of today’s dynamic demand of the
current trend of business. IBM has 165 clients in Pune and IBM is one of the service
Our innovative technologies have proved that we are the right people to provide
right solutions to the demand business for all type of firm like Manufacturing, IT
26
Building a resilient infrastructure
Optimizing IT performance
27
“DATAMINING FOR CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT”
ensure that their product and service offerings not only meet basic needs of the customers
Data Mining is the process of using analytic methods to explore data to discover
meaningful patterns that enable organizations to operate in a more cost effective manner.
Historical data is based on the past performance. Data Mining Technologies offers a
proprietary technology that is embodied in it two flagship products Nuggets and nuggets
28
DATA MINING ARCHITECTURE FOR IBM SOFTWARE SERVICES
Figure No-6: The use of data mining technique is a global and firm wide challenge for IBM
services to the direct response industry using state-of-the-art, proprietary data mining
Increased competition has intensified the need to operate more cost effectively in
29
Figure No.7 IBM DATA MINING ARCHITECTURE
Figure-8, which shows a "gains chart," suggests some benefits available through
data mining. The diagonal line illustrates the number of responses expected from a
randomly selected target audience. Under this scenario, the number of responses grows
30
GAINS CHART
The top curve represents the expected response if you allow the model scores to
determine the target audience. The target is likely to include more positive responders
than in a random selection of the same size. The shaded area between the curve and the
line indicate the quality of model. The steeper the curve, the better the model.
Organizations.
Lotus Notes is one of the software product which stood at the top and fulfill all
needs of demand business. I had only to deal with Lotus notes product from the software
product line of IBM.I usually speak to our client whether they are satisfy with the
31
At very beginning of project I had to give the presentation on Lotus Notes
software and their features. It is very much important to communicate with the top level
I used to speak to every client who already use IBM software product. Our main
focuses were to develop the better relation ship with our clients. So my profile was
quality.
Data mine is generally a base where all the historical data as well as current
database being stores. According to past experience of the customers IBM develop the
product and quality. With the help of data mine IBM helped a lot in terms of growth of
clients in Pune and outside. Initially in Pune, it was 85 clients were using Lotus notes but
the help of data mine IBM has the clientele base of 135 and also IBM succeed to
penetrate the new market in the major cities like New Delhi, Chennai, Bangalore and
Cochin.
32
Evolutionary Business Question Enabling Product Characteristics
Step Technologies Providers
Data Access "What were unit Relational databases IBM, Microsoft Retrospective,
(1985s) sales in New (RDBMS), dynamic data
England last Structured Query delivery at record
March?" Language (SQL), level
ODBC
The way in which companies interact with their customers has changed
dramatically over the past few years. A customer's continuing business is no longer
guaranteed. As a result, IBM has found that we need to understand our customers better,
and to quickly respond to their wants and needs. In addition, the time frame in which
these responses need to be made has been shrinking. It is no longer possible to wait until
the signs of customer dissatisfaction are obvious before action must be taken. To
33
TARGETING CUSTOMERS
OF SERVICE
We can see that through getting more and more responses from historical and
current information from the client base IBM successfully get in to:
Scoring Customers
34
“DATAMINING FOR CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT”
During my project I visited personally to analyze the INS and out of customer’s
mindset. I visited those organizations which are using Lotus Notes software since many
years and I got the expressiveness value of service quality and patronage intentions.
problem to use the software properly. So to develop better relationship we also provide
training for using Lotus notes software. By this way we got successful to stretch the
product with introducing corporate training and IBM is only the company which provides
training program for Top level executive. So I found that it is very much important to
35
Data Mining and Customer Relationships: IBM technologies understand the value of
collecting customer data, but also realize the challenges of leveraging this knowledge to
Customer Acquisition and Data Mining: For IBM, the primary means of growth
involves the acquisition of new customers. This could involve finding customers who
previously were not aware of IBM product, were not candidates for purchasing our
product (for example, IBM software product for a big garment shop).
Scoring Customers: Once a model has been created by a data mining application, the
model can then be used to make predictions for new data. In July 2007 IBM got
36
Figure No.12: CRM ARCHITECTURE
Here we can observe that data mining is very essential to develop the relationship with
customers. Above figure represent the separate entity for each i.e. Customer, Realtionship
and Management. There are three attributes of customers i.e. customer knowledge,
context and value. These three attributes are the main base from I have data mined the
37
1 Data Mining Improves Decision Making
38
As data mining of customer response data is very much needed in term of customer
IBM clients today are investing in new technologies and services to become on
demand enterprises. As first movers, they are establishing an early, significant edge over
their competitors.
On demand business and computing solutions have improved the economics of and
businesses (SMB). Revenue from IBM’s SMB sales organization was $29.2 billion in
BIGGEST ACHIEVEMENT
YEAR 2004 IBM PENETRATED THE RUSSIA, BRAZIL AND CHINA MARKET
39
IN 2006 IBM COVERED THE MARKET GLOBALY
UK (25%)
AUSTRIA (24%)
40
“DATAMINING FOR CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT”
41
“In the context of management Research concerns itself with obtaining
variables.”
INFORMATION REQUIREMENTS
For successfully done the research, I have two sources of information, that is
Questionnaires
Online Interviews
www.ibm.co.in
www.wikipedia.com
www.google.com
Journals
Company source
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Sampling Drawn: Old user of Lotus notes product & New user
Sample Size: 24
42
IBM thus purpose two value dimensions associated with software service-
performance and expressiveness value through data mining, that impact satisfaction with
software and patronage intensions. If satisfaction has mediating effect, then the
relationship between satisfaction and patronage would be stronger than the relationship
PATRONAGE
INTENTIONS
SERVICE SATISFACTION
QUALITY
PATRONAGE
INTENSIONS
The above figure is based on the premise that satisfaction acts as a mediator on
the relationship between service quality and patronage intentions irrespective of the value
obtained by the customer through data mining. The mediating effect is shown by bold
black arrow. If satisfaction has a mediating effect, then the relationship between
satisfaction and patronage would be stronger than the relationship between service
43
In primary data collection, I used questionnaires. Primary data collection is
necessary when a researcher cannot find the data needed in secondary sources. There are
QUESTIONNAIRES
For this I used open ended and close ended question as well to get the feedback.
SAMPLE SIZE
44
There were two sets of respondent: one for measuring performance of preferred
IBM lotus software products attributes and a second sample for measuring expressiveness
value of software service attributes. A sample quota of 24 respondents for each dimension
was fixed based on Organization structure, Annual revenue and actual need of demand
business based on current trend of management. The sample was divided across SEC A
and SEC B (Old users of IBM lotus note software product) and new emerging user
respectively .Respondents were at least 5 years old user of the software product in Pune
and new users (at least 2 years of using IBM products). There were 16 respondents who
are using IBM lotus notes since last five years and 8 respondents are using IBM products
For final analysis, after deleting incomplete records where several respondents
had mentioned that IBM lotus notes software as preferred. I had a set of 18 respondents
which are completely satisfy with the product and quality of service. The rest 7
respondents gave the information that IBM should also provide corporate training for
45
Since the sample sizes were not very large, I first conducted the sampling
adequacy test for each samples. Figure below is showing the profile of the respondents.
PERFORMANCE EXPRESSIVENESS
%
OLD USER 16 66.7% 66.7% 18 75% 75%
NEW USER
08 33.3% 100% 06 25% 25%
Table No.3
can identify that the importance of data mining of customers response data.
46
Data mining is the best way to get the response of customers and to develop
but IBM evaluates providing better solutions with new technologies are major issue other
then just developing relations. For this reason I believe that service quality, when
referring to the customers perspective, needs to be redefined to include all those cognitive
assessments that influence the customers perception of the overall superiority of software
develop better relations with the customers. Other relevant customer value dimensions
47
“DATAMINING FOR CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT”
CRM analytics solutions from IBM technology for greater customer insight.
Target marketing for higher sales and return on marketing expenditures. Use customer
48
intelligence to personalize messaging and offers across marketing channels. Help predict
THE ADVANTAGE
Extensive experience in successful CRM analytics implementations.
THE BENEFITS
Improve understanding of customers' needs.
Derive insights into customer purchasing patterns and recognize new trends.
Automotive CRM analytics solutions from IBM can help to achieve return on investment
49
Increase the effectiveness of marketing programs to increase revenue
PROVEN BENEFITS
and to track and manage sales leads to improve sales. Outdated, paper-based systems
make it difficult to track and respond to leads efficiently. Our automotive CRM analytics
50
“DATAMINING FOR CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT”
51
IOC CORPORATION PETROCHEMICAL
SOLITOS INFOTECH PVT.LTD IT SECTOR
WHIRLPOOL INDIA HOME APPLIANCES
SKF INDUSTRIES FMCG
Table No.-3
ORGANIZATION?
1 TCS 08 26.6%
2 INFOSYS 05 16.6%
3 IBM 11 36.6%
4 WIPRO 02 6.66%
5 SATYAM 01 3.33%
6 OTHERS 03 10.0%
Table No.4
52
Figure No.8: CONSUMER PERCEPTION
INTERPRETATION
From above chart it can be easily seen that IBM Lotus notes product is the market
Finding:
Average 65
%
Good 26
%
Excellent 8%
53
Figure No.9: IBM LOTUS NOTES RATING
INTERPRETATION
Most of organizations are willing to take IBM lotus notes product for their
organization. They don’t want the pieces of technology but a product which can fulfill all
Finding:
Yes 83
%
No 12
%
Scope of improvement 5%
54
Figure No.10: USER SATISFACTION ANALYSIS
INTERPRETATION
We are least focus on the customers satisfied with the product but more attentive
for the customers who are satisfy or partially satisfied. By this way we can customize our
Findings:
Authentication 2%
Others 2%
55
Figure No.11: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF LOTUS NOTES
INTERPRETATION
This analysis is basically to gather the key area of IBM technology .I found that
most of the customers are satisfied with the performance and more than 90% of the
Finding:
Yes 63
%
No 37
%
%
56
Figure No.12: SERVICE SATISFACTION
INTERPRETATION
From the total sample size, 63% of customers are delighted by the service offering
by the IBM. But 37% of the customers are not satisfied with the service quality. So here
we can find that still 37% scope of improvement in service quality is needed.
Finding:
57
2 ONLINE DELIVERY 3 18.75%
5 OTHERS 1 6.25%
Table No.5
INTERPRETATION
This question is open ended question and can be more type of answers but here
we can see that most customers are satisfied by the IBM payment solution and quality of
Finding:
Yes 72
%
%
No 28
%
%
58
Figure No.14: COST ANALYSIS
INTERPRETATION
This question was a common question for both Old user and new user. It is very
obvious that new user might not get satisfy until or unless they earn the maximum out of
it. To penetrate the new market it is essential to provide the exact solutions to get
8. According to you how can we make our software products much better?
Finding:
59
3 IMPROVE SERVICE DELIVERY 24%
5 EXTERNAL THREATS 6%
Table No.6
INTERPRETATION
As IBM lotus notes provide better protection from external threats but in above
chart we can see that 6% of customers are still not happy with the performance. Such
responses can definitely improve the authentication of IBM Lotus notes software
products.
9. According to you what are the most important features should be added in the
Finding:
60
Electronic learning through Lotus notes 30
%
Other facilities 30
%
INTERPRETATION
Though IBM Lotus notes provide the best facility as compare to giant like
Microsoft and Techno Soft Corporation but the value we can add to our product through
customer data mining. By this way IBM can improve their customer base.
Finding:
This question I had asked to Associate Director (CANON INDIA) one of the giant
users of IBM lotus notes. CANON is using IBM Lotus notes since its inception.
It was really a nice experience to have a talk through E-mail. Following are the
61
In this competititive world no product is perfect until or unless you adding some
No clients want the pieces of technology but they want how products are
Don’t keep changing in your product but add the value and provide better demand
solutions.
Clients are least bother about the features but they are much bother about the
benefits.
62
“DATAMINING FOR CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT”
SUGGESTIONS
During the project I got the opportunity to learn many things about Software
Industry’s. I understand software marketing concept very well. It goes without saying that
IBM is one of the largest software service providers through out the world.
During the project I got some of responses from existing client base on which I
could draw some of the suggestions for the benefit of IBM technologies. Following are
the suggestions:
63
UTILIZE CUSTOMER INTELLIGENCE IN INNOVATION:
Not all ideas will come from a Company’s software developer. There fore, IBM
must constantly be on the look out for customer expectation and customers’ ideas.
The modern marketing is customer focused which has developed the modern
customer not only as a user but also, has offered the opportunities to crystallize their
COST EFFICIENT:
IBM software products are costly and this software is only being used by the
major players in the market. But to capture the small players in the market it is essential
for IBM to cut down the cost of product that a small player can also use it.
CORPORATE TRAINING
Using IBM lotus notes software is not that easy to access for the first time user so
for the new user, software training should be provided to them. It could be the best way to
64
“DATAMINING FOR CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT”
CONCLUSIONS
a powerful tool to assess customer satisfaction and customer relationship. It can be used
in product development and quality assurance. It is very popular quality methodology and
has been effectively used by large organizations. By the help of data mining IBM can
Client base
65
Generate revenue
Customer satisfaction
Customer relationship
Only earning profit cannot lead any organization but developing relationship with
66
“DATAMINING FOR CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT”
BIBLIOGRAPHY
REFERENCE BOOKS
Marketing Management
By Philip Kotler
Data Mining
By Rajanish Dass
By Kurt Thearling
67
Marketing Research
By William Ross
WEBSITES
www.ibm.co.in
www.wikipedia.com
www.iim.ahd.ernet.in
www.google.com
OTHER MATERIALS
IBM Journals
IT Marketing Journals
68
“DATAMINING FOR CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT”
ANNEXURE
NAME: AGE:
ADDRESS:
69
1. WHICH TECHNOLOGY YOU FIND MOST RELIABLE FOR YOUR
ORGANIZATION?
YES NO
70
SERVICE QUALITY ONLINE DELIVERY PAYMENT SOLN.
YOUR ORGANISZATION?
Yes NO
MUCH BETTER?
SOFTWARE PROVIDER?
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
71
THANK YOU
72