Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Authors’ contributions
This work was carried out in collaboration between both authors. Both authors read and approved the
final manuscript.
Article Information
DOI: 10.9734/AJRCOS/2018/v2i228749
Editor(s):
(1) Dr. Stephen Mugisha Akandwanaho, Senior Lecturer, Department of Information Systems and Technology, University of
KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa.
(2) Dr. Shah Nazir, Assistant Professor, Department of Computer Science, University of Sawabi, Pakistan.
Reviewers:
(1) Charles Chukwuma Mbah, University of Nigeria, Nigeria.
(2) Samuel Afriyie, Jiangsu University, China.
Complete Peer review History: http://prh.sdiarticle3.com/review-history/28122
ABSTRACT
The purpose of this study is to investigate the factors that influence the adoption of Software as
Service (SaaS) at Small Medium Enterprises (SMEs) that have adopted online business in Sri
Lanka. Prior studies have shown that SMEs significantly benefit due to the adoption of SaaS. The
research sough to explain the adoption of SaaS using Awareness, Trust, Cost, Top Management
Support, Complexity and Relative advantage. Conceptualization of this researcher’s variables and
their interrelationship have been supported by theory of Diffusion of Innovation (DOI) of Rogers’
(1962) and Technological Organizational and Environmental (TOE) Framework of Tornatzky and
Fleisher (1990). The study was conducted among 250 randomly selected SMEs adopting online
business using questionnaires addressed to managerial and ICT professionals who were capable
of making ICT decision at SMEs under study. However only 224 questionnaires were returned with
complete data required for the purpose of analysis. The study employed principal component
analysis to reduce the data and employed Ordinary Least Square (OLS) to test the relationship
between the variables. It is found that Cost (CT), Complexity (CX) and Relative Advantages (RA)
are having significant impact on SaaS adoption in SMEs in Sri Lanka. This study extends the
existing body of knowledge by providing empirical support for explaining SaaS adoption by SMEs in
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
Sri Lanka. The finding will help various parties engaging in promoting the adoption of SaaS among
SMEs with the view of SMEs’ development in Sri Lanka. On this basis, the researchers are able to
recommend firstly, that SaaS is playing a significant role for the development of SMEs in this area
of study and finally, that software vendors, policy makers, technological consultants and application
developers intend to adopt SaaS should consider the validated model tested in this research study.
Keywords: SaaS adoption; cloud computing; small and medium enterprises; software as a service;
Sri Lanka.
2
Ayoobkhan and Asirvatham; AJRCOS, 2(2): 1-13, 2018; Article no.AJRCOS.45904
3
Ayoobkhan and Asirvatham; AJRCOS, 2(2): 1-13, 2018; Article no.AJRCOS.45904
much committed studies on SaaS concerns in Sri According to Siau and Shen [17] and Ayoobkhan
Lanka. According to a study there is inadequate [25], Trust is regarded as a measure of buyers'
information on fruitful case studies and indicators level of accreditation that the service will be well
on SaaS implementation. Moreover, according to furnished with least conceivable anticipation.
Nabeel and Adil [20], SMEs are performing well Amongst the signs of the goal to use SaaS,
but yet they are missing a lot. This could be dependence has been perceived to be a
considered as an issue in this study. standout amongst the most indispensable
fundamentals that influence a person to use the
Further, this research will also cover the gaps in invention [26,27]. According to Erisman [28]
previous studies, as reported by Ondiek [14], that Ondiek [14], Trust is equally an important portion
there‘s a big disconnect between the popular in imagining out if an individual buys products or
scholarly discussion about SaaS for SMEs services by means of the Web. Trust is the base
leading to limited and inadequate access to of the vital association between an industry and
relatable information in this regard. The study will its Internet consumer [12]. A customer's ability to
also review the existing adoption models which utilize from an Internet store which is affected by
are not contextualized for developing countries his or her state of mind and impression of danger
pertaining to SaaS adoption factors by SMEs. [12]. The person's willingness to take part in
Therefore this study will formulate an acceptable online trades of cash and individual delicate data
framework for adoption of SaaS in Cloud [29]. As designated by Eder and Igbaria [30],
computing for SMEs in Sri Lankan context. non-Internet supporters require wide effort of
Moreover, the study brings more understanding influence before they begin participating in e-
of the Cloud Computing Software as used as a keeping money and make an e-propensity. A
service adoption for SMEs. The research tends study carried out by Poon and Swatman [26]
to fill the knowledge gap that exists between reveals that approximately 70% of the
Cloud SaaS computing for the SMEs. This paper, respondents correspond that trust is influencing
consequently, should be able to function as them to use Internet saving money. Therefore, in
instrument for an SME that is uncertain on what this study the factor generated the following
Cloud computing particularly Software as a research hypothesis as given:
service is adopted.
H2: There is a significant relationship between
2.1 Development of Hypotheses from Trust and SaaS adoption Services
Prominent Studies for this Research According to Tornatzky and Fleischer [31], Cost
as the amount to which the usage of a
According to Premkumar and Ramamurthy [21], development is acknowledged to be
the consumers often undergo a lot while striving comparatively exclusive. The application of
to get a new product. The process is hectic and information systems (IS) is measured a safe
entails acquisition of knowledge, conviction, approach for SMEs in terms of as long as
process of making decision and ideally together a substance for transaction based
confirming the decision before proceeding to innovativeness and as a foundation of cost
approve the artefact or even the facility. Once the savings and practical development [25,32]. The
consumer approves and finds the innovation, any distribution of this systems are based on Cloud
innovation begins with adoption or rejection computing knowledge that minimizes the
procedure. On the other hand, [22,23] possession cost, upfront cost and conservation
emphasized that for one to comfortably adopt, cost. In accordance to the conceptual framework
they have to know the new brands that get into this study the factor generated the following
the market. By being unaware of the new brand, research hypothesis as given:
the adoption of IT is affected negatively [24] but
according to Irshad and Md Gapar [8], indicates H3: There is a significant relationship between
that the effect on Awareness in Academic Cost and SaaS adoption Services
institutions have positive influence in the context
of Sri Lankan. In accordance to the conceptual According to many researchers [33,25,8], it
framework of this study the following research mentions to Promising time to the (ICT) program
hypothesis have been developed. to a convinced grade its cost, probable,
infectious up on consequences, measuring plans
H1: There is a positive and significant and hopeful the regulatory matters obligatory
relationship between Awareness and SaaS with organizing ICT with the organization
adoption technique of the business. According to Young
4
Ayoobkhan and Asirvatham; AJRCOS, 2(2): 1-13, 2018; Article no.AJRCOS.45904
and Jordan [33] Irshad and Md Gapar [8], it has According to Rogers [35], the extent to which an
been revealed that the Top Management Support invention is witnessed as being enhanced than
and methods can be biased toward improved the suspected. It is taken as an essential needle
performance change. Cloud computing for the new IS inauguration. The result of relative
implementation management maintenance is improvement on employment occupation has
considered as the chief connection amongst been systematically observed in aforementioned
individual and hierarchical ICT development in benefits that were accepted by some research
their audit of the indicators and biases in IT. scholars [27,38]. According to Lee [38], when
According to Low et al. [7], the topmost dealings have a qualified improvement of
administration maintenance key to possess the invention then the chances of implementation will
reputation of conceivable change over an spontaneously increase. Cloud computing
pronounced deliberation for the reminder, and by notably presents several benefits upon its
directing signs of the importance of the new adoption. Cloud computing can offer several
information to different personalities from the advantages that can be linked to issues of
organization. According to Premkumar and capacity, reliability, as well as flexibility. Having
Ramamurthy [21] Annuka [34], manager this ensures that there is immense reduction in
affiliation guarantees the enough assets to be cost of entry for the SMEs and thus the
disseminated so as to cuddle the new know-how. businesses can access several resources within
The implementation of SaaS Cloud computing is a short time span [37]. Relative advantages that
strategically important when considered from the accrue from Cloud computing are many. So, the
organization top management. In accordance to following research hypothesis which is in
the conceptual framework this study the factor accordance with the research Hypothesis;
generated the following research hypothesis as
given: H6: There is a positive and significant
relationship between Relative Advantages and
H4: There is a positive and significant SaaS adoption Services
relationship between Top Management Support
and SaaS adoption Services 3. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The degree to which an invention is apparent as Adoption of SaaS is broadly a topic under
comparatively difficult to appreciate and use information technology service adoption and it is
representation will be fewer probable if the an aspect of firms’ innovativeness. To examine
detection is careful as actuality more inspirational the factors that influence the adoption of SaaS,
to use. SMEs might be antagonized with trials this study hence broadly adopted two prominent
when commissioning a new knowledge in theories namely diffusion of innovation (DOI)
footings of changing the deportments in which theory of Rogers (1962), and the technology,
they intermingle with their work-related systems. organization, and environment (TOE) framework
Conferring to [35], performing will be fewer likely of Tornatzky and Fleischer [31]. The DOI
if the expansion is watchful as being more theory holds that individual, structural and
thrilling to use. SMEs may be endangered by the external characteristics of organizations are
encounters when accepting a new experience in important antecedents to organizational
rapports of moving the performances in which innovativeness. The TOE framework on the
they interrelate with their commerce systems [36] other hand affirms that three such contexts
[32]. According to Sahin [37], in order to increase namely technological, organizational and
occupation rate, the new know-hows have to be environmental contexts of an enterprise impact
user friendly. This factor is more on technological innovation of a firm. There are
disadvantageous to the adoption probability previous studies that have employed TOE
unlike other innovation characteristics. Hence, framework to explore the IT adoption
SMEs predisposition to implement SaaS services [32,38,4,39]. Accordingly, the conceptual
is increased by the decreased complexity of framework of the present study can be
SaaS. So, it leads to the following research represented in the diagram Fig. 1.
hypothesis which is in accordance with the
research Hypothesis; In line with previous similar studies on this
subject [14,20,6,18,34], this research too adopts
H5: There is a positive and significant a quantitative approach. Self-administered
relationship between Complexity and SaaS questionnaire were issued among selected
adoption Services ICT employees in executive positions
5
Ayoobkhan and Asirvatham; AJRCOS, 2(2): 1-13, 2018; Article no.AJRCOS.45904
Awareness
H1
Trust H2
Cost H3
Adoption of Software
H4
Top Management as a Service
H5
Complexity
H6
Relative Advantage
A total of 250 questionnaires were issued and 3.3 Adopter and Non-adopters of SaaS
231 returned. However, only 224 was used for
data analysis after data screening was To determine whether the respondent’s
completed. Several items were used to measure organizations are currently using SaaS, the
all variables and for each item, a corresponding respondents were asked to indicate whether they
Likert Scale with anchors ranging from 1 as currently use or intend to use SaaS in the
“Strongly Disagree” and 5 as “Strongly Agree” business. Based on the questions, three
was used. For each item listed, the respondents categories of respondents’’ SMEs were identified
were requested to mark any of the five options in this study.
given. The study first examined the
measurement model to test reliability and validity, From the Table 2, 152 (69%) SMEs have been
and followed by the multiple linear regression identified as the adopters of SaaS in this survey
analysis was to test research hypotheses and study. Around 55 (25%) SMEs are expressed
research model of this study. their intention n to use SaaS in the near future,
6
Ayoobkhan and Asirvatham; AJRCOS, 2(2): 1-13, 2018; Article no.AJRCOS.45904
a few number of SMEs (17) expressed their idea variables exceeded the threshold value of 0.6.
as no intention to adopt SaaS even in the near Discriminant and convergent validity was
future. Hence, the descriptive analysis it is measured by means of average variance
apparent that most of the SMEs have adopted extracted (AVE). Convergent validity is adequate
SaaS as it is useful. Moreover, in this study, the when the AVE value of each construct exceeds
researcher has focused on the SMEs who were 50%, [2,49,46]. As shown in Table 4, the AVE
adopted SaaS, for further analysis. values for all of the study’s constructs were well
above the threshold. Consequently, both
3.4 Reliability and Validity of the discriminant and convergent validity was
Construct acceptable in this study. Thus, the scales used in
this study are both reliable and valid.
Validity and reliability are two important steps
that determine the quality and usefulness of data Table 3. Reliability of the constructs
collected. Generally, the higher value of
Cronbach’s Alpha illustrates a higher reliability. Constructs Cronbach’s N of Items
For reliability test, the normal standard value is Alpha
0.7 [47,48,49]. Therefore, if the value of alpha AW 0.734 5
more than 0.7, then a high reliability has been TS 0.701 5
proved (Refer Table 3). For the six constructs: CT 0.715 5
Awareness (AW), Trust (TS), Cost (CT), Top TM 0.812 6
Management Support (TM), Complexity (CX), CX 0.802 5
Relative Advantage (RD) and ADP. RD 0.799 5
ADP 0.770 5
3.5 Validation Test of the Constructs
3.6 Regression Analysis and Hypothesis
This section reveals the results of the factor Testing
analysis based on both independent and
dependent variables. As shown in Table 4, the Regression analysis is used to understand which
KMO for both the independent and dependent among the independent variables are related to
7
Ayoobkhan and Asirvatham; AJRCOS, 2(2): 1-13, 2018; Article no.AJRCOS.45904
the dependent variable, at the same time to was accepted and there is a significant
explore the forms of these relationships. Table 5 relationship between CT and ADP. Hence, it is
describes the results of the linear confirmed that CT is identified as one of the
regression analysis was used to test research major factors in order to adopt SaaS in SMEs in
hypotheses. Sri Lanka. Thereby accepting H3 that “There is a
significant relationship between the Cost (CT)
Awareness (AW): According to the Table 5, the and the SaaS adoption in SMEs in Sri Lanka.
p-value for AW is more than 0.05 and the Top Management Support (TM): According to
coefficient value is 0.059. Hence ADP does not the Table 5, the p-value for TM is more than 0.05
depend on AW. Therefore, the hypothesis was and the coefficient value is 0.098. This implies
rejected and there is an insignificant relationship that the support of the Top level management in
between AW and ADP. Hence, it is confirmed Sri Lanka in particular in SMEs is unfortunate.
that AW was not identified as one of the major Hence ADP does not depend on TM. Therefore,
factors in order to adopt SaaS in SMEs in Sri the hypothesis H4 was rejected and there is an
Lanka. Thereby rejecting H1 that “There is a insignificant relationship between TM and ADP.
significant relationship between the Awareness Hence, it is confirmed that TM is not identified as
(AW) and the SaaS adoption in SMEs in Sri one of the major factors to adopt SaaS in SMEs.
Lanka. Trust (TS): In Table 5, the p-value of TS Thereby rejecting H4 that “There is a significant
is more than 0.05 and the coefficient value is relationship between the Top Management
0.099. Hence ADP does not depend on TS. Support (TM) and the SaaS adoption in SMEs in
Therefore, the hypothesis H2 was rejected and it Sri Lanka. Complexity (CX): In Table 5, the p-
is confirmed that there is an insignificant value for CX is less than 0.05 and the coefficient
relationship between TS and ADP. Hence, it is value is 0.229. Hence ADP depends on CX.
confirmed that TS was not identified as one of Therefore, the hypothesis H5 was accepted and
the major factors in order to adopt SaaS in SMEs there is a significant relationship between CX
in Sri Lanka. Thereby rejecting H2 that “There is and ADP. Hence, it is confirmed that CX is
a significant relationship between the Trust (TS) identified as one of the major contributor to adopt
and the SaaS adoption in SMEs in Sri Lanka. SaaS in SMEs. Thereby accepting H5 that
Cost (CT): Table 5 implies that the p-value for “There is a significant relationship between the
CT is less than 0.05 and the coefficient value is Complexity and the SaaS adoption in SMEs in
0.299. In Sri Lankan context SMEs have been Sri Lanka. Relative Advantage (RD): The Table
realized that adopting SaaS is not expensive and 5 implies that the p-value for RD is less than 0.05
the tendency of Cost is natural. Hence ADP and the coefficient value is 0.387 which is the
depends on CT. Therefore, the hypothesis H3 heist value among the constructs. Hence ADP
8
Ayoobkhan and Asirvatham; AJRCOS, 2(2): 1-13, 2018; Article no.AJRCOS.45904
depends on RD. Therefore, the hypothesis H6 carried out to investigate the impact of these six
was accepted and there is a significant independent variables to the dependent variable.
relationship between RD and ADP. Hence, it is The Table 6, presents the model fitting of this
confirmed that RD is identified as one of the study. The R-square value was 0.521. This
major contributor to adopt SaaS in SMEs. implies that around 52% of the variation in SaaS
Thereby accepting H6 that “There is a adoption by R-squared might be estimated and
significant relationship between the Relative predicted by this Model in SMEs in Sri Lanka and
Advantage and the SaaS adoption in SMEs in Sri can be explained by the factors AW, TS, CT, TM,
Lanka. CX and RD in this study. Hence it can be
concluded that model is accurate and it can be
3.7 Explanatory Power of the Model used for further analysis.
Fitting
3.8 ANOVA in Multiple Regression
Regression analysis helps to identify, how the Analysis
dependent variable changes when there is a
change in independent variables, the researcher The p-value from the ANOVA Test in Table 7 is
has built up several hypotheses to prove the less than 0.05, which means that at least one of
relationship in between adoption of SaaS with the six variables can be used to model SaaS
AW, TS, CT, TM, CX and RD. Regression adoption in SMES in Sri Lanka and also it can be
analysis is the ideal tool to identify the impact or assumed that there is a linear relationship
significance of one variable to another. The between the independent and dependent
Multiple Linear Regression (MLR) analysis was variables is not violated.
9
Ayoobkhan and Asirvatham; AJRCOS, 2(2): 1-13, 2018; Article no.AJRCOS.45904
10
Ayoobkhan and Asirvatham; AJRCOS, 2(2): 1-13, 2018; Article no.AJRCOS.45904
organizations to extent SaaS Technology Island the wide knowledge concerning SaaS innovation
wide by conducting awareness programs. When adoption. Future research should be carried out
all the above variables are put into thought, this in future need to mainly concentrate on the
examination accordingly gives some vital data to various companies and firms that have big data.
organizations, vendors and policy, innovation
specialists and is along these lines, seen as COMPETING INTERESTS
being noteworthy to the present period of fast
improvements of SaaS computing advances. Authors have declared that no competing
Finally, the discourse on the suggestions and interests exist.
commitments of this study was to give rules to
arrangement producers, experts and innovation REFERENCES
merchants in executing and quickening SaaS
computing improvement and usage among 1. Dakshina Tharanga CHM, Indika Perera.
different SMEs. Therefore, this particular study Factors determining the intention to adopt
has been found to be efficient in improving Cloud computing by finance companies in
knowledge on adoption of SaaS innovation Sri Lanka. International Conference on
among SMEs in Sri Lanka. However, there were Business Research, University of
still some areas that needed further and Moratuwa, Sri Lanka; 2018.
elaborate studies. 2. Ayoobkhan ALM, David A. Adoption of
cloud computing services in healthcare
6. CONCLUSION AND RECOMMEND- section: Special attention to private
ATION hospitals in Colombo District, Sri Lanka.
Current Journal of Applied Science and
This research has made an effort to discover and Technology. 2017;23(2):1-10.
construct a SMEs’ SaaS Computing 3. Irshad MBM, Md Gapar Md Johar, Naleer
implementation ideal that is reliant on the DOI HHM. A review on cloud computing
theory and TOE framework. While undertaking adoption: An exploratory. International
the research, a validated conceptual framework Journal of Advanced Research in
was drawn to help in the determination of the six Computer Science and Software
contextual factors in regards to SaaS computing Engineering. 2015;5(1):160-166.
adoption in SMEs within the island. The SaaS 4. Oliveira T, Martins M. Understanding e-
computing adoption is affected by different business adoption across industries in
factors and therefore, making a conclusion that it European countries, Industrial Manage-
depends on three context is fallacious. SaaS ment & Data Systems. 2014;110(9):1337-
computing is considered by many to be a vital for 1354.
ICT invention. This can dispute both the 5. Ayoobkhan ALM, Asirvatham D. Issues
premeditated and operational benefits, for and challenges faced by online business
important rates of implementation amongst organizations in adopting cloud computing:
SMEs. The research reviewed adoption theories A research agenda. International Journals
and various frameworks so as to develop some of Advanced Research in Computer
of the constructs and models the two theories Science and Software Engineering. 2017;
selected for the study included DOI theory and 7(8):260-264.
TOE framework. In order to investigate the 6. Alshamaila Y, Papagiannidis S, Li F. Cloud
implementation of SaaS computing services, a computing adoption by SMEs in the North
conceptual model of the SMEs and the east of England: A multi perspective
developed hypotheses outlined. The model framework. Journal of Enterprise Informa-
consist of six major variable such as Awareness, tion Management. 2013;26(3):250–275.
Trust, Cost, Top Management support, 7. Low C, Chen Y, Wu M. Understanding
Complexity and Relative Advantage, that are the determinants of cloud computing
considered to be significant influencing SaaS adoption‖. Industrial Management & Data
adoption in SMEs in Sri Lankan context. Finally, Systems. 2011;111(7):1006-1023.
statistically analyzing, the research concluded 8. Irshad MBM, Md Gapar Md Johar. A study
that only three constructs such as Cost, on awareness and adoption of cloud
Complexity and Relative Advantage are having computing by academics in Sri Lankan
positive and significant impact on SaaS adoption Universities. International Journal of
in SMEs in Sri Lanka. It is worth noting that this Advanced Research in Computer Science
research covered just a small chunk or part of and Software Engineering. 2017;7(5).
11
Ayoobkhan and Asirvatham; AJRCOS, 2(2): 1-13, 2018; Article no.AJRCOS.45904
12
Ayoobkhan and Asirvatham; AJRCOS, 2(2): 1-13, 2018; Article no.AJRCOS.45904
36. Tiwana A, Bush A. A comparison of 45. Hair JF, Black B, Anderson RE.
transaction cost, agency, and knowledge- Multivariate data analysis. Prentice Hall;
based predictors of IT outsourcing 2010.
decisions: A U.S-Japan cross-cultural field 46. Haleem A, Raisal I. The study of the
study. Journal of Management Information influence of information technology
Systems. 2007;24(1):259-300. sophistication on the quality of accounting
37. Sahin I. Detailed review of Rogers’s information system in bank branches at
diffusion of innovations theory and Ampara District, Sri Lanka. Annual
educational technology related studies International Research Conference. South
based on Rogers’s theory. The Turkish Eastern University of Sri Lanka; 2017.
Online Journal of Educational Technology. 47. Haleem A, Kevin LLT. Impact of user
2006;5(2):14-23. competency on accounting information
38. Lee J. Discriminant analysis of technology system success: Banking sectors in Sri
adoption behavior: A case of internet Lanka. International Journal of Economic
technologies in small businesses. Journal and Financial Issues. 2018;8(6):167-175.
of Computer Information Systems. 2004; 48. Raisal I, Arun Kumar T, Silva DAC.
44(4):57-66. Exploring critical effect of knowledge
39. Caldeira MRM, Ward JM. Using resource- inflows capacity and absorptive capacity
based theory to interpret the successful on product innovation through innovative
adoption and use of information systems culture: A quantitative examination.
and technology in manufacturing small OPCION; 2018.
and medium-sized enterprises. European [ISN1012-1587]
Journal of Information Systems. 2013;12: 49. Habeeb Mohamed Nijam, Athambawa
127 - 141. Jahfer. IFRS adoption and financial
40. Business Directory of Sri Lanka; 2016. reporting quality: A review of evidences
41. Chamber of Commerce Sri Lanka; 2016 - in different jurisdictions. International
2017. Letters of Social and Humanistic Sciences;
42. Available:www.lankayp.com 2016.
43. Available:www.slt.lk 50. Fock HKY, Woo KS. The China market:
Available:www.lankabusinessonline.com Strategic implications of Guanxi. Business
44. Available:www.ips.lk Strategy Review. 2006;9(3):33-43.
_________________________________________________________________________________
© 2018 Ayoobkhan and Asirvatham; This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction
in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Peer-review history:
The peer review history for this paper can be accessed here:
http://prh.sdiarticle3.com/review-history/28122
13