Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
10
History of Science and Technology
N European Pupils Magazine N
HOW WE STUDENTS SEE IT
From Liceo E. Boggio Lera, Catania, Italy
About Cloning …
Stefano Toscano
The word clonation refers to the creation of an exact
copy of a living organism thanks to its DNA. The
process of clonation has already been tested success-
fully by the scientists, because they had succeeded in
creating the clone of a sheep (the famous Dolly), in
1997. The human clonation has always been a reason
for many debates because the opinions always divide
into two well-distinguished groups: the scientific and
the Catholic ones. The first group affirms that human
clonation could be a great step-forward for science,
because it could treat a big number of diseases, trans-
planting cells with the corrected DNA to the ill person
stopping disease this way. The Catholics think instead,
DOLLY AND ITS CREATOR IAN WILMUT
that the creation of a copy of anybody is against God’s
law because, in their opinion, only God has the power of creating people. My opinion about this subject is the
following: if on a side human clonation could help the doctors from all over the world to eliminate many dis-
eases, on the other hand, it could be an offence to create the clone of a human being already existing. Besides the
risk increases if we think that clonation could be a commercial event, because, only for the wish of having a
baby, many people would think about human clonation.
Luca Loria
Human cloning is a medical-experimental system to cure many diseases. This is possible with stam cells.
Stam cells can generate other different cells that are inserted in the human body as substitutes of dead cells. In
this system the embryo is essential because it produces stam
cells. Unfortunately, some people want to use this system to
create new human beings, they want to create life. This is
not possible because we are not Gods, we have not the
power to do that. In human cloning there are many risks;
many times the experiments on animals end with the crea-
tion of monsters, terrible creatures with horrible deformities.
Scientists cannot risk doing experiments with human em-
bryos, It would be a scandal as well as a very dangerous
process. If they create a deformed being then they cannot
kill it because they have not the right to do that.
I think that human cloning is an insult to life; nobody
can give life as well as nobody can give death. Life is not a
laboratory experiment, life is the last natural and beautiful TWO BABIES
thing in this world.
11
History of Science and Technology
N European Pupils Magazine N
Gianfranco Distefano
Scientific discoveries have always roused discordant
opinions; in the past illustrious and capable scientists
were accused of heresy or even witchcraft. Cloning has
certainly multiple values, as it implies religious, moral
and social beliefs.
In my opinion it is difficult to keep silent in front of
such an important discovery but it is also difficult to
give a well-balanced opinion if we consider both the
positive aspects of cloning and the horrors and the dam-
ages caused by genetic experiments.
Not much precise information has been given by the
media, but listening to friends’ opinions I have come to
the conclusion that cloning may turn positive when try-
ing to reconstitute parts for whole human organs, but
I am thoroughly against any cloning of human beings, CLONING
as it is contrary to any natural
laws.
Iconography Visit our web-magazine
www.liceoboggiolera.it/epm
www.ecologiasociale.org
www.focus.it
www.clubgemelli.com
12
History of Science and Technology
N European Pupils Magazine N
For registered users the Xplora portal offers many other features, such as:
-A resource management tool – search for and store learning resources in your personal folder
-Online communities – create or join online communities for science education Online chat tool
-Moderated forum discussions to use our tools for creating online communities and join online discussions
You can join the Xplora Community for free, just registering at:
www.xplora.org/ww/en/pub/xplora/community/register.cfm
The Xplora team edits an online newsletter (every 6 weeks) in which news, activities, events, related to sci-
ence and education, are featured.
Regards
Laura Massoli
EPMagazine
Web Editor
European Schoolnet
Trierstraat 61, rue de Trèves
B-1040 Brussels
laura.massoli@eun.org
13
History of Science and Technology
N European Pupils Magazine N
History of Science and Technology
G European Pupils Magazine G
TAXONOMY TASSONOMÌA
Aristide Tomasino
Dip. Biologia animale “Marcello La Greca”
Via Androne, 81 - Catania, Italy
aristide.tomasino@virgilio.it
The EPM European Editorial Board regrets to inform you all, friends,
co-operators, past and future contributors that Dr. Aristide Tomasino, the
author of the article Taxonomy, published on EPMagazine 2/2005 page
16, sent us word that he is not working at
and that the information published in his article, is due to a mistake in the
submission form sent to the EPM Italian Editorial Board.
14