Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
https://doi.org/10.5624/isd.2019.49.3.179
3,*
Supreet Jain 1, Kartik Choudhary 2
, Ravleen Nagi , Stuti Shukla 1
, Navneet Kaur 4
,
Deepak Grover 4
1
Department of Oral Medicine and Radiology, New Horizon Dental College and Research Institute, Sakri, Bilaspur, India
2
Department of Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry, Mansarovar Dental College, Bhopal, India
3
Department of Oral Medicine and Radiology, Swami Devi Dayal Hospital and Dental College, Panchkula, India
4
Department of Periodontology, National Dental College and Hospital, Dera Bassi, Mohali, India
ABSTRACT
Panoramic radiographs and computed tomography (CT) play a paramount role in the accurate diagnosis, treatment
planning, and prognostic evaluation of various complex dental pathologies. The advent of cone-beam computed
tomography (CBCT) has revolutionized the practice of dentistry, and this technique is now considered the gold
standard for imaging the oral and maxillofacial area due to its numerous advantages, including reductions in
exposure time, radiation dose, and cost in comparison to other imaging modalities. This review highlights the broad
use of CBCT in the dentomaxillofacial region, and also focuses on future software advancements that can further
optimize CBCT imaging. (Imaging Sci Dent 2019; 49: 179-90)
- 179 -
New evolution of cone-beam computed tomography in dentistry: Combining digital technologies
Table 1. Clinical applications of cone-beam computed tomogra- treatment of the concerned tooth. Akgül et al.5 used CBCT
phy (CBCT) in dental practice scans to detect a relatively high frequency of enamel pearls
I. Dental assessment II. Bony assessment in the maxillary second and third molars. Young et al.22
Normal anatomy Normal anatomy
found that 3DX high-resolution CBCT images displayed
Impacted teeth Alveolar bone
Root canals Inferior alveolar canal
better detection of proximal surface caries extension than
Pathologies Implant assessment digital intraoral 2D images. Root fracture is the most com-
Dental anomalies/malformed teeth Other structures mon cause of root canal failure that cannot be seen in con-
Caries detection Pathologies ventional periapical radiographs due to the superimposi-
Root fractures Periapical lesions
Root resorption Tumors
tion of anatomical structures. Conventional CT may detect
Internal resorption Fractures around 70% of root fractures, but the higher cost and larger
Cleft lip and palate amount of radiation exposure limit the use of this technolo-
Temporomandibular joint pathosis gy by oral radiologists. For this reason, CBCT is currently
III. Soft tissue assessment IV. Orthodontics thought to be superior to CT in diagnosing root fractures,
Gingival swellings V. Forensic odontology visualizing external and internal root resorption, and visu-
Salivary gland lesions
Calcifications alizing the repair of resorptive defects accurately and with
higher resolution.23-25
- 180 -
Supreet Jain et al
Table 2. Studies from the existing literature showing the application of cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) in dentistry
Authors (Year) Intervention Outcome Conclusion
Akgül et al. Evaluation of enamel Enamel pearls were detected in 36 subjects CBCT is an effective tool in
(2012)5 pearls using CBCT (4.69%). All of the enamel pearls were the assessment of the
detected in molar teeth, with a prevalence prevalence of enamel pearls
rate of 0.83%. compared to conventional
radiography.
Villaça-Carvalho Evaluation of the BMC was observed in 80 cases (26.67%), The visibility of BMC was
et al. (2016)6 prevalenceof bifid of which 39 (48.75%) were in males and higher with CBCT imaging.
mandibular canals (BMC) 41 (51.25%) in females. The right side
using CBCT was more frequently affected (66.67%).
Deeb et al. Assessment of the Panoramic radiographs and CBCT CBCT is more accurate in
(2016)7 necessity of CBCT in accurately predicted implant width to predicting implant length
dental implant placement within 1.5 mm of the implant in 100% of and width and the need for
cases and length to within 1.5 mm in more bone grafting procedures.
than 95% of cases.
Lo Giudice et al. Evaluation of the accuracy A radiolucent area was detected in CBCT CBCT is an essential
(2018)8 of CBCT in the detection scans in 46% of cases, while the intraoral diagnostic tool for the proper
of periapical pathologies periapical X-ray was positive in only 18%. management of various
endodontic problems.
Shweel et al. A comparison of the MDCT underestimated mean depth by CBCT was superior to
(2013)9 accuracy of CBCT and 1.7 mm, underestimated mean width by MDCT for the detection of
multi-detector computed 0.9 mm, and overestimated mean height by thinning and perforation of
tomography (MDCT) in 1.7 mm, whereas CBCT underestimated mean the buccal cortical plate and
radiological assessment of depth by 0.9 mm, underestimated mean width displacement of teeth.
odontogenic cysts and tumors by 0.7 mm, and overestimated mean height
by 1 mm.
Nah Evaluation of condylar The most frequent condylar bony change CBCT was more accurate in
(2012)10 bony changes in TMD observed was sclerosis (133 joints, 30.2%), determining osteoarthritic
patients using CBCT followed by surface erosion (129 joints, condylar bony changes than
29.3%), flattening of the articular surface conventional CT.
(112 joints, 25.5%), and deviation in form
(58 joints, 13.2%).
Nunes et al. Assessment of the Soft tissue calcifications are predominant CBCT scans can be used to
(2011)11 prevalence of soft tissue in the posterior mandible (18.9%), with no analyze the presence of soft
calcifications in the relation to sex and age. 73% were seen in tissue calcifications, but
mandible using CBCT patients aged 35 to 55 years old. more research is required to
prove its diagnostic utility.
Bertin et al. Evaluation of the accuracy of The main findings were stones, stenosis, CBCT sialography is a non-
(2016)12 3D CBCT in detection dilatations, and a “dead tree” appearance invasive and relatively more
of non-tumor salivary of the ductal system. reliable diagnostic tool for
gland pathologies ductal salivary diseases than
conventional sialography.
de Moraes et al. Evaluation of craniofacial The right side was larger than the left for CBCT can better evaluate
(2011)13 asymmetry most of the 20 distances evaluated using craniofacial morphology
digital 2D and CBCT imaging; perfect when compared with digital
agreement (kappa = 0.92) between CBCT 2D images.
and the individual measurements of the
human skull was observed.
Pinchi et al. Assessment of the Pulp height proved to be a significant CBCT allows accurate
(2015)14 accuracy of CBCT for age predictor of age (P<0.001). A negative calculation of pulpal
estimation via calculation correlation was found between pulpal volume.
of pulp volume reduction cavity volume and advancing age.
with advancing age
TMD: temporomandibular joint disorder
- 181 -
New evolution of cone-beam computed tomography in dentistry: Combining digital technologies
al.29 found that CBCT overestimated the presence of dehis- position the implants more accurately and safely. Using this
cence and fenestration defects, and inter-examiner reliabil- technology, minimally invasive surgery can be performed
ity ranged from poor to moderate (Cohen’s kappa = - 0.09 without raising a flap, thereby minimizing surgery time,
to 0.66). In another study, Xu et al.30 found limited diag- postoperative pain and swelling, and recovery time. The
nostic value of CBCT in clinical practice, as the technique stored information from the scan can be used pre-surgically
overestimated the presence of dehiscence and fenestrations to fabricate a master cast, and provisional restoration could
in the maxillary anterior teeth of patients with Angle class be placed immediately after surgery (Teeth-in-an-HourTM;
III malocclusion; however, the level of agreement between Nobel Biocare, Kloten, Switzerland).7,36-38
clinical examination and CBCT imaging was higher for Studies have suggested that assessment of the course of
dehiscence than fenestration. Contrary to this observation, the vascular canals in the maxillary sinus walls, as well
Leung et al.31 found a higher rate of diagnostic accuracy as the distance between the sinus floor, the edentulous al-
for the detection of root fenestrations than for the detection veolar crest, and the vascular canal using CBCT, can pre-
of dehiscence. vent unnecessary bleeding during implant placement. This
technique accurately measures the thickness of the hard
Mandibular canal assessment palate and its overlying mucosa for the purpose of minis-
Accurate assessment of the variation and position of the crew placement.39,40 However, the American Academy of
inferior alveolar canal relative to the mandibular third mo- Radiologists (AAOR) has recommended panoramic radi-
lar roots may reduce the risk of injury to the nerve during ography as the primary imaging modality for the initial as-
extraction and implant placement, thus preventing further sessment of the implant site. Cross-sectional CBCT images
complications.32,33 Panoramic imaging may be adequate should be considered only when clinical conditions require
when the canal is relatively distant from the third molar, sinus augmentation procedures or bone grafting, or if the
but in the case of radiographic superimposition, use of a patient reports implant mobility post-surgery.39
3D imaging approach is preferable. Lee et al.34 reported
4 cases and Villaco-Carvalho et al.6 reported 80 cases of Periapical and bony pathologies
bifid mandibular canal visualized using CBCT imaging. The literature confirms that CBCT has higher diagnos-
Lofthag-Hansen et al.35 suggested that the visibility of the tic accuracy for the visualization of periapical lesions and
mandibular canal and the marginal crest, as well as the lev- their differentiation from other similar-appearing lesions.41
el of observer agreement regarding the location of these In clinical practice, radiological evaluation of periapical
structures, is higher with CBCT. status is essential for both establishment of a treatment plan
and better prognosis of the tooth. Intraoral periapical radio-
Implantology graphs are routinely used in endodontics, but they present
CBCT provides cross-sectional images in several planes some limitations, such as the 2D nature of the produced
that help with the accurate assessment of the height, width, images, geometric compression, and superimposition of
and angulation of bone, as well as with visualization of the anatomical structures, thus obscuring the area of interest;
position of the inferior alveolar canal and mental foramen these limitations may lead to misdiagnosis or unnecessary
in the mandible and the sinus in the maxilla. In edentulous exposure to radiation.8,42 New CBCT scanners that deliver
patients, CBCT provides better visualization of buccolin- a lower radiation dose have become an important diagnos-
gual alveolar ridge patterns, such as irregular, narrow crest- tic tool to address most endodontic problems, and these
al, or knife-edge ridge, undulating concavities, and alveolar devices can be used in all phases of endodontic treatment.
bone quality and quantity. In many situations, CBCT im- CBCT imaging is highly useful in the post-treatment as-
plantology has minimized or eliminated the need for proce- sessment of endodontically treated teeth; it is also very
dures like bone and tissue grafts, as it enables precise mea- helpful for the determination of the cause of a persistent
surement of the distance, area, and volume of the bone in periapical lesion, as well as the visualization of root canal
which the implant is to be placed.36,37 Computer-generated morphology, the localization of accessory canals and cal-
surgical guides (termed stereolithographic models) can be cified canals, the detection of acute root fractures, and the
generated using Digital Imaging and Communications in visualization of external and internal resorption.36-39 Ac-
Medicine data, thus eliminating the possible inaccuracy in- cording to the recommendations put forth by the American
volved in making traditional guide stents. The use of soft- Academy of Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology (AAOMR)
ware planning prior to implant placement helps surgeons for endodontic treatment, intraoral radiography should
- 182 -
Supreet Jain et al
be considered the primary imaging modality, and CBCT split fractures in which the fracture line is not parallel to
should be recommended only if the patient’s condition can- the X-ray beam.46 To facilitate better treatment of trauma
not be accurately diagnosed using intraoral 2D radiogra- patients, CBCT should be made mandatory in maxillofacial
phy or the patient presents with non-specific clinical signs and suspected mandibular fractures. This technique should
and symptoms associated with untreated or endodontical- be used in conjunction with panoramic radiographs, which
ly treated teeth.35,36 CBCT defines the extent and internal are useful for the initial screening of complicated frac-
structure of large intraosseous pathologies such as cysts tures.45,46
and tumors more precisely than intraoral radiography and
also effectively analyzes the proximity of these lesions to Temporomandibular joint disorders
vital structures.9 Thus, CBCT images can serve as a useful Temporomandibular joint disorders (TMDs) constitute
guide for surgeons as they carry out appropriate early sur- the most common category of orofacial pain conditions
gical interventions, especially in the treatment of oral ma- of the temporomandibular joint (TMJ) and its associated
lignancies.43 musculature.47 As of now, CBCT has been found to be
most useful in the evaluation of bony changes of the TMJ,
Maxillofacial fractures such as fractures, ankylosis, dislocation, growth abnor-
Evaluation of a fracture - especially in the maxillary malities, and various degenerative joint diseases including
complex region - using conventional 2D radiography is osteophytes, erosions, flattening, subchondral sclerosis,
very challenging due to the overlapping of various struc- and pseudocysts (Fig. 1). Analysis of the dynamic rela-
tures. Additionally, radiographic evaluation of patients tionship of the articular sufaces of the TMJ is necessary to
with maxillofacial injuries can be very difficult due to their determine the strain undergone by the articular disc while
clinical condition and the fact that these patients are often chewing; this strain, if high, may compromise the integrity
uncooperative. Instead, 3D CBCT is a cost- and dose-ef- of the disc. CBCT provides 3D images of the mandibular
fective alternative to conventional 2D imaging for the di- condyle and surrounding structures to facilitate the analysis
agnosis of complex maxillary fractures.44 It provides the and diagnosis of bone morphological features, joint space,
surgeon with 3D-reconstructed images for analysis of the and the dynamic function, which serve as the critical keys
nature of the injury, the location of the fracture, and the to treatment outcome in patients with signs and symptoms
degree of displacement of the fractured segments. These of TMD.10,47,48 Studies have suggested that the diagnostic
images guide the surgeon to plan the appropriate surgical accuracy of CBCT in the evaluation of erosive changes of
approach for the reduction and stabilization of the fractured the condyle is influenced by FOV, with these studies utiliz-
segments.45 Mandibular fractures are easily visualized on a ing FOVs of 12, 9, and 6 inches with voxel sizes of 0.6, 0.3,
panoramic radiograph in most cases; however, some cases and 0.2 mm, respectively. It has been reported that a CBCT
require further confirmation by CBCT, including disloca- scanner with high resolution and the smallest FOV (voxel
tion of fracture fragments in the mandibular corpus and size, 0.2 mm) detected condylar defects with greater than
- 183 -
New evolution of cone-beam computed tomography in dentistry: Combining digital technologies
80% sensitivity.48 Previous studies have shown magnetic are more advantageous in salivary gland evaluation, ul-
resonance imaging (MRI) to be the preferred imaging mo- trasonography and 2D radiography are routinely used due
datility for evaluation of anterior disc displacement without to their cost-effectiveness and availability. Recently, su-
reduction, but this technique has low accuracy in diagnos- perimposition-free, 3D CBCT images have shown higher
ing bony changes, which should be further examined using sensitivity and specificity for salivary calculus diagnosis,
CBCT.47 Recently, automatic registration of CBCT scans stenosis, and dilatations of the salivary ductal system than
with MRI has been developed to provide complementary images obtained with other diagnostic methods. 12,54,55
images of the hard and soft tissues of the TMJ in a single CBCT sialography is considered a noninvasive diagnostic
picture frame, facilitating accurate diagnosis and optimal tool used for the visualization of salivary glands and duc-
treatment outcomes. Al-Saleh et al.49 found that fused mag- tal pathologies. Drage and Brown54 first described the use
netic resonance imaging-cone-beam computed tomogra- of CBCT sialography for complex cases of salivary gland
phy (MRI-CBCT) registered images improved intra- and obstruction. They proposed that CBCT sialography would
inter-examiner consistency and displayed better diagnostic expose the patient to higher radiation doses than plain
value in the evaluation of internal derangement of the TMJ. film sialography, and therefore it should be reserved for
More clinical research must be conducted to establish the complicated cases. Jadu et al.55 suggested that the delicate
reliability and accuracy of MRI-CBCT registration for secretory branches of salivary gland ducts and the paren-
TMDs. chyma of the salivary glands were more easily detectable
on CBCT images via the maximization of the image signal
Soft tissue assessment difference-to-noise ratio. They achieved moderate to very
In dentistry, CBCT scanners are exclusively used for im- good inter-observer agreement in the visualization of nor-
aging of the hard tissues of the oro-facial complex. These mal gland structures and in the determination of abnormal
scanners have a limited ability to differentiate soft tissues. findings (i.e., sialoliths, ductal strictures, and secondary in-
To address this issue, Januario et al.50 developed soft tissue flammatory changes) by CBCT sialography than plain film
CBCT that scanned the maxilla using an i-CATTM scanner sialography.
(Imaging Sciences International, Hatfield, PA, USA) for 40
seconds with a focal spot of 0.5 mm, voxel size of 0.2 mm, Orthodontics
and grayscale 14-bit resolution. This technique improved Orthodontists routinely use 2D conventional radiographs
the image quality of the soft tissue by reconstructing the (such as cephalometric and panoramic radiographs) to
images in all 3 orthogonal planes (axial, sagittal, and cor- diagnose and plan treatment for patients with malocclu-
onal). It allowed precise measurement of the thickness of sions and facial disproportions. However, many complex
gingival tissues, and i-CATTM software was used to deter- orthodontic and dentofacial orthopedic problems require
mine the relationship of the periodontal structures and den- 3D analysis. To address this, CBCT has been introduced
togingival unit. According to the guidelines set forth by the as a technique for comprehensive orthodontic imaging
AAOR, CBCT constitutes a valuable tool for determining and for the assessment of tooth movement in all 3 planes.3
the location of soft tissue calcifications by oral and maxil- Although it has numerous benefits, one major concern re-
lofacial radiology specialists.51,52 Soft tissue calcifications garding CBCT is the higher radiation dose delivered from
are usually asymptomatic and appear incidentally on radio- CBCT scanners with large FOV. Therefore, the decision to
graphs. One of the greatest difficulties in the diagnosis of conduct CBCT imaging on an orthodontic patient should
soft tissue calcifications is the determination of their exact be solely based on the patient’s history and on the clinical
location. This is especially challenging when using pan- examination, where CBCT should only be used if these
oramic radiographs, since 2D imaging techniques can cre- factors indicate that CBCT is required for proper diagno-
ate ghost images.52,53 Nunes et al.11 reported that a higher sis and optimal treatment outcome. Some CBCT scanners
prevalence of soft tissue calcifications was found on CBCT have a small FOV, which minimizes radiation exposure; in
images as compared to conventional images. these scanners, the number of projection images still allows
for adequate visualization of the region of interest.56,57
Salivary gland pathologies CBCT imaging in orthodontics is selectively indicated
Imaging-based diagnostic measures for sialolithiasis in for the assessment of complex dentoskeletal relationships
clude ultrasonography, panoramic radiography, sialendo and facial esthetics, for severe skeletal discrepancies re-
scopy, sialography, MRI, and CT. Although CT and MRI quiring orthognathic surgery, and for the assessment of the
- 184 -
Supreet Jain et al
position of impacted and supernumerary teeth and their CBCT showed superior results to multidetector CT in the
relationships to adjacent roots and other anatomical struc- detection of structural hard-tissue damage in the immediate
tures, thus facilitating planning of the subsequent tooth vicinity of high-density metal projectiles and in the identi-
movement.56 Compared to 2D radiographs, CBCT imaging fication of the precise location of a projectile in the body.60
better facilitates the accurate determination of tooth and
root length, the assessment of the minute details of root Future perspectives
resorption, the determination of available bone width (to
evaluate the buccolingual movement of teeth), the assess- Optimization of CBCT images
ment of tooth inclination, the calculation of torque, and the Compared with other modalities, CBCT has been docu-
visualization of soft tissue relationships, and it provides mented to have high diagnostic efficacy in the accurate de-
detailed information regarding craniofacial morphology tection of complex oral and maxillofacial pathologies. This
and maxillary and mandibular changes resulting from rapid efficacy could be increased further by the optimization of
maxillary expansion.57 CBCT with respect to various parameters, such as reduc-
tion in focal spot size, alteration of beam geometry, an in-
Forensic odontology crease in detector efficiency, and optimization of exposure
Estimation of the ages of living or deceased individuals and image reconstruction. Moreover, old CBCT scanners
is an important aspect of forensic investigation. Several mostly have large FOV that results in the production of
techniques to estimate the age of individuals by analyzing more scattered radiation, which contributes to an increased
teeth have been reported in the literature. One avenue that radiation dose delivered to the patient. Optimization of old
offers new opportunities in dental age identification is ex- scanners could be achieved by using a small-diameter FOV
amination of the pulp space. Various methods have been that covers only the region of interest.61 Table 3 shows the
developed to study the size of the pulp chamber, including future innovations of CBCT.
tooth cross-sections and radiographs; however, CBCT pro- Focal spot size was the first parameter of CBCT to be im-
vides a 3D view of the pulpal cavity, facilitating a more ac- proved; it was decreased from the standard focal spot size
curate estimation of the dental age of an individual. CBCT of 0.5 mm, thus improving the image resolution. Another
is a reliable imaging technique for the analysis of second- important improvement was the development of adaptive
ary dentin apposition with advancing age, and it simulta- exposure, which enables the clinician to select the opti-
neously measures both the buccolingual and the mesiodis- mal exposure according to the size of the patient. In most
tal dimensions of the tooth.14,58 Yang et al.58 developed a CBCT machines, current and tube voltage is determined
custom-made voxel-counting software that can be used to based on the gray values of scout images, which results in
calculate the ratio of pulp canal volume to tooth volume an automatic reduction of exposure levels for patients of
based on CBCT tooth images, and they obtained promising small size and mass. Recently, some machines have uti-
results for non-invasive dental age estimation. CBCT also lized the concept of dynamic automatic exposure control,
provides accurate and reliable measurements of soft tissue in which exposure is adjusted during acquisition of the im-
thickness for specific landmarks of the face and scalp by age. Image performance could be increased by altering the
producing facial reconstruction at reduced exposure and geometric shape of the beam; this has been achieved by a
increased speed, and it provides higher-quality images than technique termed off-axis scanning, which utilizes a half
spiral CT and other methods. Facial reconstruction requires cone with a small overlap in the iso-center that increases
knowledge of the average thickness of the soft tissues of the FOV to almost twice the diameter as that involved in
the face, which varies among individuals from different full-cone scanning. This contributes to a reduction in the
geographical locations. This technique is very useful in dose administered to the patient. It has also been reported
forensic investigations for the identification of skeletal re- that use of 180° rotation in comparison to 360° rotation led
mains, and it aims to recreate the facial appearance of an to a dose reduction of 40% in the anterior region and 60%
individual using the skull.13,59 in the posterior region. Off-axis scanning reduces the radia-
CBCT is currently used in forensic investigations for tion dose, but its effect on image quality is still under study.
postmortem imaging and for imaging high-density metal Optimization could also be obtained by increasing the ef-
projectiles in cases of gunshot injury. Its use is mainly due ficiency of the detector. Because most CBCT units use flat
to its small apparatus size, portability, low cost, and the panel detectors consisting of a scintillator that transfers
reduction of metal artifacts on the images that it provides. light energy into electrical energy, detector efficiency could
- 185 -
New evolution of cone-beam computed tomography in dentistry: Combining digital technologies
the first and last projection) and exposure time (the cumu-
lative time over which an exposure is made). In contrast,
some machines allow only continuous exposure, for which
the total scan time and the exposure time are same. Pulsed
Upper airway dimensional analysis
- Artificial intelligence
- 186 -
Supreet Jain et al
- 187 -
New evolution of cone-beam computed tomography in dentistry: Combining digital technologies
- 188 -
Supreet Jain et al
- 189 -
New evolution of cone-beam computed tomography in dentistry: Combining digital technologies
A, et al. A deep-learning artificial intelligence system for as- Methods Programs Biomed 2009; 94: 290-8.
sessment of root morphology of the mandibular first molar 66. Lata S, Mohanty SK, Vinay S, Das AC, Das S, Choudhury P. Is
on panoramic radiography. Dentomaxillofac Radiol 2019; 48: cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) a potential imaging
20180218. tool in ENT practice? A cross-sectional survey among ENT sur-
64. Noel PB, Walczak AM, Xu J, Corso J, Hoffmann KR, Schafer S. geons in the State of Odisha, India. Indian J Otolaryngol Head
GPU-based cone beam computed tomography. Comput Meth- Neck Surg 2018; 70: 130-6.
ods Programs Biomed 2009; 98: 271-7. 67. Liu J, Cai W, Ning R. Evaluation of differential phase contrast
65. Ma L, Xu T, Lin J. Validation of a three-dimensional facial cone beam CT imaging system. J Xray Sci Technol 2017; 25:
scanning system based on structured light techniques. Comput 357-72.
- 190 -