Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Investing in P2P
Lending
A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE FOR BEGINNERS TO INVEST IN P2P LENDING
COPYRIGHT
© 2019 World BizWeek. All rights reserved. This eBook was electronically
published in Malaysia.
DISCLAIMER
This eBook is intended to provide an in-depth analysis on P2P lending as an
investment instrument for educational purposes only. This eBook does not
constitute a financial, investment or any form of advice.
All opinions expressed are based on research and experience and solely for
informational purposes only. While the author strives to ensure the information
published is accurate and up to date, it makes no warranties or representations as
to the accuracy, completeness and suitability of any information.
The author will not be held responsible for any errors or omissions, and accept no
liability whatsoever for any loss or damage you may incur. Should you choose to
rely on the information contained herein, you also agree that the information is
not legal or financial advice and it does not form the basis of a contract.
The author has no affiliation with the organisations mentioned in this eBook.
You are allowed to download this eBook and share the content with anyone for
non-commercial purposes at no charge to the recipients, provided that you cite
the original source https://worldbizweek.com for attribution and do not add to or
revise its content while doing so.
Page(s)
Introduction 1-2
Final Thoughts 88 - 89
INTRODUCTION
Introduction
“What if I don’t get back my money?” “What if P2P lending is a Ponzi scheme?”
These are the real concerns that discourage most investors, if not all, from
investing in P2P lending.
I was very skeptical about such investment when I first heard about it two years
ago. An investment that doesn’t require any specialised financial knowledge yet
could simply generate more than 10% return per annum. Not to also mention the
minimum initial investment is as low as only RM100.
RM100 to get started? More than 10% per annum? It’s no brainer isn’t it? But I
hesitated. I did not jump in right away despite the mouth-watering returns.
In fact, I’ve spent more than a year to study, research and observe the P2P lending
market and activities before I started investing.
And I’m pretty sure that’s what you’re doing right now as a rational investor. The
good news is I’m here to help. In this handbook, I’ve included everything about
P2P lending that you need to know before getting started.
1
Introduction
Other than the basic information, I’ve also included the strategies to minimise
your risk while maximising your returns. More importantly, I’m also going to share
with you a step-by-step guide to get started with investing in P2P lending.
You can save much of your time and effort searching through everywhere to
gather the information that you’re not even sure if it’s relevant. Make good use of
this guide and use your own judgment to decide whether P2P lending is a good
investment choice or not.
The only thing that I can assure you is that P2P lending is certainly a game changer
for the investment landscape of Malaysia.
P.S. I’ve spent hundreds of hours to create this content and it’s absolutely FREE for
everyone. Because I see it as an obligation to share when I find something that
can really benefit you and everyone else. If you think this guide is useful, please
do share with your friends and family. Sharing is caring. Spread the love! Thank
you!
Follow us:
2
CHAPTER ONE
The P2P lending platform facilitates the loan transactions by connecting the
borrowers directly to the lenders. It earns money by charging origination and
servicing fees.
The key distinction between the traditional banking and P2P lending processes is
illustrated below:
3
What is Peer-to-Peer Lending?
The debt offerings through P2P lending may differ in terms of the loan tenure, size
and interest rate. But all P2P lending platforms, in essence, operate based on the
same principle. It doesn’t involve a financial intermediary such as a bank or
financial institution in contrast to the traditional borrowing and lending activities.
The very first P2P lending platform started in U.K. in 2005. It has since gained
popularity over the past decade with a significant increase in market size
globally. According to Allied Market Research, P2P lending market is expected to
reach $460 billion by 2022 at a CAGR growth rate of 51.5% from 2016 to 2022.
4
What is Peer-to-Peer Lending?
Pros and Cons of Peer-to-Peer Lending
There’re obvious reasons why P2P lending is so attractive to both the borrowers
and lenders. Such business model provides a win-win formula to both parties that
fit their interests perfectly. The borrowers get the opportunity to obtain
alternative financing while lenders can get high returns without the need of
specialised financial knowledge.
However, this model also underlies some downsides that both parties may fail to
observe. Let’s look into some of the pros and cons of P2P lending from both
borrower’s and lender’s perspective.
Borrowers
OR
Lenders
5
What is Peer-to-Peer Lending?
Pros and Cons of Peer-to-Peer Lending
Borrowers – Pros:
e) No prepayment penalty
Lastly, the borrowers are not subject to significant penalty if they decide to
pay off the loan before its due date.
6
What is Peer-to-Peer Lending?
Pros and Cons of Peer-to-Peer Lending
Borrowers – Cons:
c) Privacy exposure
Most of the P2P lending platforms require public disclosure of the
borrowers’ financial history and information before lenders choose to bid
the loans.
7
What is Peer-to-Peer Lending?
Pros and Cons of Peer-to-Peer Lending
Lenders – Pros:
c) Diversification of risk
Besides, lenders can diversify their loan portfolios to lower their risk of
investment.
d) Alternative investment
P2P lending appears to be a good investment alternative for investors to
earn a steady stream of passive income. Besides, investors don’t need any
specialised industry knowledge.
8
What is Peer-to-Peer Lending?
Pros and Cons of Peer-to-Peer Lending
Lenders – Cons:
a) Risk of default
The lenders are exposed to the risk of default by the borrowers and the
loans are generally uninsured. Therefore, there’s a risk of losing their capital
in the event of default. However, that doesn’t mean that investing in P2P
lending is totally unsafe. In chapters later, we will cover what are the right
strategies to minimise your risk of investing in P2P lending.
b) Lack of regulations
There’s lacking in regulations and framework to govern the P2P lending
activities in some territories as the industry is still at infancy stage. The
good news is P2P lending is highly regulated in Malaysia. In fact, Malaysia is
the first ASEAN country to regulate P2P lending.
c) Risk of insolvency
There’s a risk of P2P lending operators going out of business causing the
lenders to lose their capital. In contrast to the banks under financial
distress, bailouts are undertaken by the central bank or government to
protect the interest of the depositors.
Although such cases did happen in other countries, our interests as P2P
lending investors are pretty much protected by Securities Commission
Malaysia (“SC”) who regulates P2P lending. We will cover this part in detail
in the chapters later.
9
What is Peer-to-Peer Lending?
Overview of P2P Lending in Malaysia
P2P lending has emerged in Malaysia after SC Malaysia introduced a regulatory
framework in 2016. The framework governs the registration and obligations of a
P2P lending operator.
Malaysia became the first country in ASEAN to regulate P2P lending. The primary
objective is to provide an alternative to the Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises
(SME) to obtain financing to spur economic growth. It’s also meant to provide an
alternative investment option for retail investors.
10
What is Peer-to-Peer Lending?
Borrowers
SC doesn’t impose a limit on the financing amount that a borrower can raise
through a P2P lending platform. The issuer can also raise funds concurrently at
different P2P lending platforms for different purposes.
Investors
SC encourages retail investors to limit their investment to a maximum of
RM50,000 at any one time to reduce their risk exposure. The operator
must disclose all fees and charges to the investors in connection with the
investment.
Besides, investors are eligible to get any relevant information relating to the
investment such as the purpose of funding, business plan, historical financial
information, etc.
11
What is Peer-to-Peer Lending?
P2P Lending Operators in Malaysia
There are currently six licensed P2P lending operators in Malaysia as shown
below.
12
CHAPTER TWO
P2P lending operators generally disclose to investors the measures that have been
put in place to minimise the risk of default. Other than having a rigorous and
transparent credit assessment process as required by SC, such measures
include obtaining personal guarantees from the Directors of the borrowers.
But there’s still a possibility of investors losing their capital invested in a particular
investment note if the borrower defaults. The reality is that the risk of default will
never be eliminated.
To put this into perspective, traditional banks with years in operations have not
ever maintained a zero default rate despite having stringent controls over their
credit risk assessment processes.
The good news is there are certain ways to minimise the risk of default effectively.
With proper investing strategies, the returns that you earn could still be much
higher than the losses in the event of any default. We will cover this in detail in
the next chapter.
13
Risks of Investing in P2P Lending
2. Loans Are Not Secured/Collateralised
P2P lending platforms offer loans that are not secured or collateralised. In
contrast to traditional banks, some borrowers pledge their assets as collateral to
obtain financing. In the event of default, the banks will take possession of the
assets to recover part or all of the bad debts. Collateral helps to mitigate the risk
of default thus provides a layer of protection to the lenders.
Therefore, the risk of default on P2P lending loans is higher than the traditional
bank loans. P2P lending operators do not guarantee any form of return to the
investors. In other words, you as the lender or investor could end up walking away
empty-handed in a worst-case scenario.
The number of P2P lending platforms that have gone bust and collapsed in
China is on the rise. The turmoil sparks fear among the investors and many have
rushed to pull their money out from the platforms.
Many P2P lending platforms have come under scrutiny in China as regulators have
stepped up measures to crack down on illicit use of funds and Ponzi schemes
involved in P2P lending. The increasing number of fraud cases in P2P lending has
shaken the investors’ confidence.
The most well-known being Ezubao, once China’s biggest P2P lending platform
uncovered being a $9 billion Ponzi scam involving more than 900,000 investors.
14
Risks of Investing in P2P Lending
3. Business Risk of P2P Lending Operators (continued)
Now you may wonder what if the P2P lending platform that you have invested go
out of business one day when you wake up in the morning. “Will all my money go
down the drain?”.
As compared to Malaysia P2P lending market, there’re only six licensed operators
with RM118 million raised as at June 2018.
The good news is that P2P lending operators in Malaysia are subject to strict
guidelines and SC regulatory framework. At the time of writing, SC had only issued
six licenses to P2P lending operators in Malaysia.
You may have doubt or fear that similar instance may happen to your investment
in P2P lending. But it should be less of a concern. Under the SC requirements, a
P2P operator must place all the monies received in a third party trust account
(e.g. banks as trustees) before making any disbursement. The operator is
prohibited to place the monies into its own bank accounts.
Besides, a P2P lending operator cannot cease its business without prior
engagement with the SC.
15
Risks of Investing in P2P Lending
4. Liquidity and Prepayment Risks
There are other risks that are less pervasive. But those may still be relevant for
you to consider before investing in P2P lending.
Investing in P2P lending creates a liquidity risk for investors. You cannot withdraw
your money any time at your convenience once you’ve committed into a
particular investment note. You will only receive the principal and interest based
on the maturity of each repayment. Savvy investors with a proper investment
plan may not bother as they would typically set aside funds for emergency
purposes.
The drawback for the investors is the loss of interest associated with the future
repayments. However, it should be less of a concern as it’s effortless for the
investors to re-invest in other investment notes with similar interest rates.
16
Doesn’t it sound a bit risky to invest in P2P lending? Don’t let it damper your
confidence and stop you from giving it a shot. You’ll definitely miss a great
investment opportunity.
In the next chapter, I’ll share with you the effective strategies to minimise
your risk of investing in P2P lending while maximising your returns.
“ In investing, what is
comfortable is rarely profitable.
“
- Robert Arnott
17
CHAPTER THREE
As mentioned earlier, Malaysia became the first country in ASEAN to regulate P2P
lending after SC introduced a regulatory framework in 2016. To date, there are
only six licensed P2P lending operators in Malaysia.
Certainly, there’s always risk associated with any investment. But I will never say
it’s unsafe to invest in P2P lending. You’ll get what I mean as you read on.
18
Maximise Your Returns at the
Lowest Risk
“
“ Don’t put all eggs in one
basket.
19
Maximise Your Returns at the
Lowest Risk
Diversification
But they fail to understand that diversification is far more than just investing in
different investment notes.
20
Maximise Your Returns at the
Lowest Risk
#1 – Diversify by investing in investment notes with low
correlation
No doubt the simplest way of diversifying in P2P lending is to spread your
investment across different borrowers. But investors should also diversify by
always investing in borrowers that operate in different industries with low
correlation.
When there’s any catastrophe or political changes that might adversely affect a
specific industry, your risk of investment would be much lower.
Imagine you’ve now invested in two investment notes where both borrowers are
construction companies. Your risk exposure becomes much higher when the
Government suddenly announced the cancellation of mega infrastructure projects
which may have a direct link to both of your borrowers.
On the contrary, the risk would be minimised if one of the borrowers operates in
the entertainment industry instead. The more uncorrelated your borrowers are,
the lower the risk by using diversification.
Just giving you another perspective, diversification may not be effective if two
borrowers operate in the airline and logistic industries respectively if there’s a
sudden spike in oil price.
21
Maximise Your Returns at the
Lowest Risk
#2 – Diversify by allocating the optimal amount to invest
“How many tranches should I split my investment into?” “How much should I
invest in each investment note?” These are the questions that you should ask
yourself before investing in P2P lending.
22
Maximise Your Returns at the
Lowest Risk
#2 – Diversify by allocating the optimal amount to invest
Scenario 1:
23
Maximise Your Returns at the
Lowest Risk
#2 – Diversify by allocating the optimal amount to invest
Scenario 1: (continued)
24
Maximise Your Returns at the
Lowest Risk
#2 – Diversify by allocating the optimal amount to invest
As shown above, you’ll get a gross return of 10.9% assuming there’s one default
on the loans that you’ve invested throughout the year. Well, you may feel that the
1% default rate seems to be too optimistic.
But if we use Funding Societies as the benchmark, it has a default rate of less than
1% at the time of writing. Funding Societies is a good proxy as it’s the largest P2P
lending platform that offers the highest investment opportunity in Malaysia.
Of course, historical data doesn’t guarantee the exact outcome of the future.
Default rates may be adversely affected by various factors such as economic
recessions, political changes, slowing economic growth due to the effect of US-
China trade war, etc.
25
Maximise Your Returns at the
Lowest Risk
#2 – Diversify by allocating the optimal amount to invest
Scenario 2:
26
Maximise Your Returns at the
Lowest Risk
#2 – Diversify by allocating the optimal amount to invest
Scenario 2: (continued)
27
Maximise Your Returns at the
Lowest Risk
#2 – Diversify by allocating the optimal amount to invest
Based on the 2nd scenario, an investment portfolio of 5% default rate could still
magically generate a positive return of 6.4%!
The net return after service fee would certainly still be much higher taking into
account the effective interest if you reinvest the amounts received throughout the
year.
What does that mean? It means it’s perfectly fine even if there’s a default!
There are expectations that some loans may not be recoverable on day 1. And it’s
totally okay if you’ve fully diversified your portfolio with the right allocation of
amount. It still provides a higher return than the traditional investments like fixed
deposits. In simple terms, you don’t have to worry that some borrowers might not
repay the loans.
The rule of thumb is that each loan that you invest should represent
approximately the historical default rate of the P2P lending platform. It’s effortless
for you to re-adjust your loan portfolios with the appropriate allocation from time
to time.
The default rate is unlikely to swing to different extreme ends since the P2P
lending platforms apply their credit risk assessments consistently. The borrowers’
credit profiles are also unlikely to differ drastically over time.
28
Maximise Your Returns at the
Lowest Risk
#3 – Diversify your investment in different P2P lending
platforms
Next, you should also diversify by investing in different P2P lending platforms.
Although the obligations of P2P lending operators and the platform rules
are broadly similar, the credit assessment methodologies are different.
Each P2P lending platform may have a different level of risk tolerance. For
instance, QuicKash offers investment notes that come with a principal guaranteed
element but a lower interest rate as compared to other P2P lending platforms. It
charges the borrowers a guarantee fee for 3rd party guarantee services. Some
investors may favour such offering as it reduces the risk of default by the
borrowers.
29
Maximise Your Returns at the
Lowest Risk
Do Your Own Due Diligence
Based on SC requirements, each P2P lending platform is obliged to verify the
relevant information or documents submitted by the borrowers. This information
is made available to all investors through the platform.
More often than not, investors will rely on the P2P lending operators’ credit
assessment of each borrower. But each investor may have different risk appetite.
Therefore you should always perform your own due diligence before you invest.
There are certain metrics that can help you decide on which investment note to
invest.
30
Maximise Your Returns at the
Lowest Risk
Do Your Own Due Diligence
Author’s thoughts
31
CHAPTER FOUR
I can’t stress enough the importance of choosing the right platform to invest. Not
only your choice will affect your returns significantly, your risk of investment will
also be different. (I’ll explain in detail later.)
As a quick recap, there are currently six licensed P2P lending platform operators in
Malaysia as shown below.
32
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
Overview of P2P Lending Platforms in Malaysia
Funding Societies is the first and largest P2P lending platform in Malaysia at the
time of writing. It’s also the only P2P lending company featured in the Emerging
50 Rising Stars in the Top Fintech 100 list for 2018. The list is the compilation of
the best FinTech innovators from around the world.
33
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
Overview of P2P Lending Platforms in Malaysia
34
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
Overview of P2P Lending Platforms in Malaysia
35
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
Overview of P2P Lending Platforms in Malaysia
QuicKash offers most of the investment notes that come with a principal
guaranteed element. It charges the borrowers a guarantee fee for 3rd party
guarantee services. Therefore, it minimises the risk of default by the borrowers
and provides the investors with an additional layer of protection. At the time of
writing, QuicKash had successfully disbursed loans amounting to RM16.8 million
since launch in September 2017.
36
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
Overview of P2P Lending Platforms in Malaysia
Alixco had successfully raised more than EUR 37 million for 472 companies
according to its official website.
37
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
Overview of P2P Lending Platforms in Malaysia
Nusa Kapital is operated by Ethis Kapital Sdn Bhd. It is the world’s first regulated
Shariah-compliant P2P lending platform. It was founded by Umar Munshi, the CEO
of the company. He’s also the chairman of the Islamic Fintech Alliance.
Besides, the team comprises experienced elites such as former senior World Bank
and Barclays Bank executives.
38
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
Overview of P2P Lending Platforms in Malaysia
B2B FinPal is operated by B2B Finpal Sdn Bhd. It is a subsidiary of B2B Commerce,
founded by Dr. Lee Thean Seong. He held a senior management position for
Hewlett Packard in Malaysia and Singapore.
As of March 2018, the platform had successfully raised about RM15 million by
issuing invoice financing notes. B2B Finpal offers the largest number of invoice
financing notes to-date.
39
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
Comparison of All P2P Lending Platforms in Malaysia
Funding
Description Fundaztic QuicKash Alixco Nusa Kapital B2B FinPal
Societies
Business
Business loan
loan or Business Business
Financing type Business loan Business loan or Invoice
Invoice loan loan
financing
financing
1 - 24 1 - 24
Financing tenure 3 - 60 months 6 - 24 months 2 - 6 months 1 - 6 months
months months
0.16% - 2%
1.25% -
of each
1% of each 1.5% of 1% of each 10% on 30% sharing on
Service fee repayment
repayment each repayment return interest
or 15% on
repayment
interest
Bullet or Bullet or
Repayment type Instalment Instalment Instalment Instalment
Instalment Instalment
Investment
High Medium Low Very Low Very Low Medium
opportunities
Auto invest option Yes Yes No No No Yes
Mobile application Yes Yes Yes No No Yes
40
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
Which P2P Lending Platform Should You Use? – My Humble
Opinion
Frankly, I’ve signed up for all accounts except for Nusa Kapital. After doing
thorough research and comparison of each P2P lending platform, I am currently
only using Funding Societies and QuicKash.
I hold more than 80% of my P2P lending portfolio in Funding Societies alone. The
obvious reason is that it’s the currently the best P2P lending platform in Malaysia.
Let me explain to you why.
41
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
Why I Choose Funding Societies?
42
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
5 Reasons Why Funding Societies is the Best P2P Lending
Platform in Malaysia
The popularity of Funding Societies has surged significantly since its launch in
2017. The most obvious reason is due to its proven track record of success in
the P2P lending industry. It’s the first and largest P2P lending platform holding a
dominant market position within the industry in Malaysia.
In a short span of time, Funding Societies has established a strong foothold with
the following notable achievements:
July 2017 – Funding Societies is the only P2P lending company from Southeast
Asia included in the Prestigious Fintech 250 List.
October 2017 – Funding Societies wins Global SME Excellence Award from United
Nations’ ITU Telecom Unit.
It’s also the only P2P lending company featured in the Emerging 50 Rising Stars in
the Top Fintech 100 list in 2018. The list is a compilation of the best FinTech
innovators from around the world. Funding Societies had also successfully raised
$25 million in Series B funding led by Softbank Ventures Korea in 2018.
43
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
5 Reasons Why Funding Societies is the Best P2P Lending
Platform in Malaysia
P2P lending was likened to a pyramid scheme and has drawn much skepticism
from all quarters when it was first introduced in 2016. The credibility of a P2P
lending platform is more important than ever to gain trust from the investors. The
success story of Funding Societies has busted the myths surrounding P2P lending
in Malaysia.
44
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
5 Reasons Why Funding Societies is the Best P2P Lending
Platform in Malaysia
Funding Societies is the go-to alternative for SMEs seeking for business loans due
to its strong presence in the industry. As a result, it has the highest investment
opportunities among the P2P lending platforms.
Imagine now you’ve RM1,000 cash to invest in P2P lending. And you’ve chosen a
P2P lending platform XYZ. You’ll be holding the cash without any returns if there’s
no borrower raising funds through the platform.
Let’s say you’ve invested RM5,000 in an investment note that offers 10% simple
interest with 12 months maturity. You’ll get 12 equal monthly installments of
RM458.33 (principal + interest). If XYZ has only 1 investment note throughout the
year, you’ll only earn 10% return on investment.
In contrast to another scenario where XYZ has investment notes every month with
the similar loan terms and you re-invest your RM458.33 repayment every month.
Instead of 10%, you will get a much higher return of 17.97% p.a.! Because every
month when you get back RM458.33, it will earn another 10% p.a. in the following
months.
45
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
5 Reasons Why Funding Societies is the Best P2P Lending
Platform in Malaysia
The effective interest rate will just be a number on the paper if you don’t even
have the opportunity to re-invest! Funding Societies offers high frequency and
sizeable investment notes. That gives investors the opportunities to compound
their returns throughout the year. Therefore, Funding Societies will be the best
choice if you wish to maximise your returns from investing in P2P lending.
There’s a common myth where many investors think that there’s a lack of credit
control in P2P lending. This is clearly not the case. Funding Societies has
maintained a low default rate of below 1.5% across the region since day 1. At the
time of writing, the default rate is only a mere 0.88%.
It’s considerably very low as most SMEs seeking for alternative financing have
lower creditworthiness due to lack of credit history. In other words, the
borrowers’ due diligence and credit assessment processes in place are working
effectively.
46
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
5 Reasons Why Funding Societies is the Best P2P Lending
Platform in Malaysia
It gives the investors a clear perspective to help understand the nature and
underlying risks of the investment notes. It’s more helpful to me as compared to
those risk ratings that are made up of alphanumeric characters only. God knows
what those A or B or C mean?
Funding Societies’ platform is very user-friendly even for the beginners. It also has
a mobile application with excellent user interface designs. Besides, your
investment portfolio and account details are always accessible 24/7.
47
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
5 Reasons Why Funding Societies is the Best P2P Lending
Platform in Malaysia
Funding Societies auto-calculates the income and expenses for your investment
portfolio. You can find out your portfolio’s performance anytime at a glance.
Further, you can also browse through all the available investment notes together
with the investment factsheets. Funding Societies will notify you whenever there’s
a new investment note. So that you can invest anytime, anywhere with just a click
of a few buttons using the mobile app.
Besides, the sign-up process is very fast and straightforward. (I will show you the
step-by-step guide in the next chapter.)
Funding Societies also offers an auto-investment tool to the investors. You can
pre-set your preference on the amount, types of financing, interest rate and
tenure using the auto-investment tool.
The tool will help allocate your money to the investment notes that match your
requirements. Funding Societies will notify you when your money is allocated to
any particular investment note. So that you still have a choice to opt-out before
the investment note goes live.
49
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
5 Reasons Why Funding Societies is the Best P2P Lending
Platform in Malaysia
The auto-investment tool makes everything easy and convenient for those with
never-ending busy schedules. It’s kinda cool, isn’t it?
50
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
Other Tidbits About Funding Societies
Funding Societies has also set up a community – Crowdfundtalks for all investors.
Investors can discuss and share their experiences with one another on investing in
P2P lending. Therefore, you can always find answers to your burning questions
about investing in P2P lending through Funding Societies.
On top of that, Funding Societies also rewards you for signing up as an investor. If
you sign up via a referral link, Funding Societies will credit a FREE RM50 bonus
into both the referral’s and your account when you invest at least RM1,000.
If you are interested, you’re more than welcomed to sign up via my referral
link: Sign up to invest in Funding Societies. Alternatively, you can also enter my
referral code: jler3bcm to grab the RM50 bonus.
51
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
Why I use QuicKash as well?
You may be puzzled as to why will I choose QuicKash to invest in P2P lending. As
depicted in the comparison table above, the service fee for QuicKash doesn’t
really look competitive. The fee also appears to be at the higher end as compared
to other platforms.
QuicKash also doesn’t offer high investment opportunities. And the interest rates
on the investment notes are generally lower. Yes, I know. It contradicted with the
main reason on why I choose Funding Societies as my choice. The main and the
only reason why I choose QuicKash is all about diversification.
The inherent risk of investing in P2P lending is the risk of default by the issuers
when they fail to make their repayments on time. The best way to minimise your
risk is to diversify your loans portfolio as what I’ve highlighted in Chapter 3 earlier.
The beauty of QuicKash is that it charges the issuers a guarantee fee upfront for
guarantee services provided by a third-party guarantee corporation. It deducts
directly from the financing amount. QuicKash claims all investment notes with
good credit rating come with a principal guaranteed element. It discloses that the
investors will never lose their principal investment amount even if the issuer fails
to repay.
52
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
Why I use QuicKash as well?
53
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
Why I use QuicKash as well?
Besides, QuicKash doesn’t impose a limit on the investment amount for retail
investors. For obvious reasons, I choose QuicKash to diversify my loans portfolio to
minimise my risk of investment. The only downside is QuicKash’s investment
opportunity is significantly lower than Funding Societies. You’ve to be really
patient if you want to invest through QuicKash.
54
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
Review of Other P2P Lending Platforms
Now, let’s take a closer look at the other P2P lending platforms. And let me
explain to you why I’m not using them.
First off, I’ll start with Alixco and Nusa Kapital. I got to be brutally honest with you,
these two are never my options. I’ve signed up an account with Alixco, the process
is fairly simple and straightforward. But the biggest problem is that Alixco offers
extremely limited investment notes with small amounts. Here’s the quick
snapshot of the investment notes:
Nusa Kapital is not any better though the world’s first regulated Shariah-compliant
P2P lending platform is a good selling point.
Fundaztic
Fundaztic is the only P2P lending platform that allows a financing with maturity up
to 60 months. But most of the investment notes I’ve browsed through typically
range from 12 to 36 months. Fundaztic does offer quite a number of investment
notes on its platform.
56
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
Review of Other P2P Lending Platforms
Fundaztic
Fundaztic is the only P2P lending platform that allows a financing with maturity up
to 60 months. But most of the investment notes I’ve browsed through typically
range from 12 to 36 months. Fundaztic does offer quite a number of investment
notes on its platform.
57
A Comparison of All P2P Lending
Platforms in Malaysia
Review of Other P2P Lending Platforms
Fundaztic (continued)
Personally, I’m not comfortable investing via Fundaztic. The main reason is that
the tenure of the loans is too long hence doesn’t fit my risk appetite. P2P lending
primarily caters the financing needs of the SMEs which typically have lower
creditworthiness. The reality is that the sustainability of these SMEs is not
guaranteed.
Having considered the high probability of default as shown above, loans with
tenure more than one year would definitely amplify the risk of default. If you have
a higher risk preference, Fundaztic can be one of your options.
B2B Finpal
59
CHAPTER FIVE
A Step-by-Step Guide to
Investing in P2P Lending
A Step-by-Step Guide to
Investing in P2P Lending
Once you’ve clicked on this referral link – Sign up now, you will be directed to the
following sign up page.
After you click “Sign up now” button, it will lead you to the following page. Key in
the following details:
60
A Step-by-Step Guide to
Investing in P2P Lending
Once done, it will lead you to the next page and you’ll need to key in your
personal details:
a) Gender
b) Birthdate
c) Residential address
d) Citizenship & NRIC number. (For non-Malaysians, you’ll need to key in your
passport details)
61
A Step-by-Step Guide to
Investing in P2P Lending
62
A Step-by-Step Guide to
Investing in P2P Lending
You’re almost there! Last but not least, you’ve to upload your national card ID
front and back (passport for non-Malaysians) for account verification.
Sign up is now complete! Now you’ve to wait for Funding Societies to verify and
approve your account registration. It took me only less than two days.
63
A Step-by-Step Guide to
Investing in P2P Lending
How to Start Investing in P2P Lending?
Account approved? Awesome! Next, familiarise yourself with the P2P lending
platform first. Once you logged on to your account via Funding Societies, you’ll be
able to see the overview of your account.
64
A Step-by-Step Guide to
Investing in P2P Lending
Before you invest, click on the PDF icon at the top right corner. That’s the
investment factsheet. It’s HIGHLY advisable to read the factsheet to find out
everything about the investment note before you invest. (I’ll explain in the next
chapter what are the key areas that you should look for before investing.)
65
A Step-by-Step Guide to
Investing in P2P Lending
Confirm Your Investment
Once you’ve decided on any particular investment note to invest, you need to key
in the amount and confirm your investment.
You can download Funding Societies mobile application from the Playstore/App
store. It’s very user-friendly and you can invest anytime with just a click of a few
buttons.
66
CHAPTER SIX
You are not jumping in right away to invest despite the irresistible high returns. It
means that you’re a rational investor. You spend the time to study and analyse
before making your first move. That’s BRILLIANT!
In this chapter, I’ll share with you a simple 3-step system to invest in P2P lending.
This system will help you grow your wealth by maximising your returns at the
lowest risk possible through Funding Societies.
Before that, let me show you how investing in P2P lending strategically can grow
your wealth quickly over time.
67
A 3-Step System to Grow Your
Wealth via Funding Societies
How Investing in P2P Lending Can Grow Your Wealth
Investing in P2P lending can grow your wealth magically through the power of
compounding.
68
A 3-Step System to Grow Your
Wealth via Funding Societies
How Investing in P2P Lending Can Grow Your Wealth
The best part is that the magic of compounding works perfectly in P2P lending
mechanism as an investment instrument.
WHY?
When you invest in the investment notes offered by Funding Societies that are
business term financing type, generally you’ll receive the repayments in equal
monthly installments with some exceptions.
That means, when you receive your monthly repayment from 2nd month onwards,
you can re-invest the amount received in new investment notes. As a result, you
will earn additional interest in the subsequent months.
Based on my past experience, the interest rate typically ranges from 12% to 16%
for business term financing.
69
A 3-Step System to Grow Your
Wealth via Funding Societies
How Investing in P2P Lending Can Grow Your Wealth
Let’s assume the first investment note that you’ve invested gives you only 12%
interest per annum for a more conservative calculation. In the subsequent
months, you re-invest your monthly repayments in new investment notes that
offer the same interest rate.
Want to know what’s your total return and how much interest you can actually
earn?
70
A 3-Step System to Grow Your
Wealth via Funding Societies
How Investing in P2P Lending Can Grow Your Wealth
71
A 3-Step System to Grow Your
Wealth via Funding Societies
How Investing in P2P Lending Can Grow Your Wealth
Based on the illustration above, your net return (assume an average service fee of
1%) would be 18.6% instead of 12%! (Refer to the calculation in the Excel
worksheet: Compounding returns calculation)
Imagine you stay invested in P2P lending for the next 10 or 20 years or even until
you retire. Say you’re 25 years old this year and you plan to invest RM10,000 until
55 years old. For simplicity sake, use the formula below to see how much you’ll
get at the age of 55.
72
A 3-Step System to Grow Your
Wealth via Funding Societies
How Investing in P2P Lending Can Grow Your Wealth
And what if on top of RM10,000 that you’ve invested on day 1, you top up RM500
every month to invest in P2P lending for the next 30 years?
N = 360
I/Y = 1
PV = 10,000
PMT = 500
CPT FV = ???
73
A 3-Step System to Grow Your
Wealth via Funding Societies
Now, let’s get serious about money. Here’s the 3-step system to invest in P2P
lending effectively via Funding Societies.
1st Step: Set your investment budget and allocate your money
First of all, you’ve to set an investment budget before investing in P2P lending.
The budget differs based on individual personal goals and risk appetite. But more
importantly, you should always set aside enough emergency fund apart from your
investment sum. This should apply regardless of what investment you’re going to
make.
Next, you need to allocate your money for each investment note based on your
budget.
As what I’ve highlighted in Chapter 3, the most effective way to reduce your risk of
investing in P2P lending is through diversification. And you can only diversify
effectively by allocating the optimal amount to invest in each investment note.
74
A 3-Step System to Grow Your
Wealth via Funding Societies
1st Step: Set your investment budget and allocate your money
The amount that you allocate to each investment note as a percentage of your
entire budget should be benchmarked against the historical default rate of
Funding Societies.
That means your portfolio will be fully diversified if you invest in 100 different
investment notes with RM100 each.
In the event of default, it’s safe to say that out of 100 investment notes that
you’ve invested, only 1 loan will default if Funding Societies maintains its default
rate. And even if there’s a default, your return will be mouth-watering based on
the illustration shown in Chapter 3.
75
A 3-Step System to Grow Your
Wealth via Funding Societies
1st Step: Set your investment budget and allocate your money
Don’t have so much to invest on day 1? That’s okay! Even if you set a budget of
RM5,000, RM100 investment only represents 2% for each note. (RM100/RM5,000
* 100% = 2%) It’s still considerably low risk based on the low default rate that
Funding Societies has maintained so far.
Even if you are starting out with only RM1,000, you can top-up your investment
gradually every month until it reaches the optimal amount. With this method,
you’ll reduce your risk significantly over time.
Or, if you do proper due diligence when choosing the investment notes before
investing, your risk of default will be significantly mitigated. That’s what I’m going
to talk about in the next step.
76
A 3-Step System to Grow Your
Wealth via Funding Societies
1st Step: Set your investment budget and allocate your money
Do not over-diversify!
However, you should never over-diversify your portfolio. Let’s say you’ve a
RM50,000 budget but you only invest RM100 in each investment note. Each
investment note represents only 0.2% which is way lower than the historical
default rate. Plus, you need to invest in 500 investment notes to fully invest your
money.
How long do you think you need to invest in 500 investment notes as compared to
100? Not only it doesn’t reduce your risk effectively, you’ll not be able to
maximise your returns.
Another key takeaway is that you shouldn’t expect that your whole budget will be
fully diversified immediately. Because it’s impossible that you’ll have 100
investment notes available to invest at once on day 1.
The honest truth is that it takes time. But effortless! Trust me, the time that
you’ve waited will be definitely rewarding. The benefits will significantly outweigh
the costs only if you fully diversify your investment using the method above.
77
A 3-Step System to Grow Your
Wealth via Funding Societies
2nd Step: Choose Investment Notes
Certainly, Funding Societies has already put in place an effective credit assessment
based on its proven track record. As highlighted earlier, your returns would still be
much higher than the losses in the event of default if your portfolio is effectively
diversified.
But as a diligent investor, it’s important to know how to do your own due diligence
when choosing an investment note. No one likes it when there’s a default right?
If you follow proper guidelines when choosing an investment note, your own
portfolio may even have a much lower default rate than the others who invest in
all investment notes.
That’s how you can maximise your returns and grow your wealth quickly.
Before you invest in any investment note, always download the factsheet
provided by Funding Societies. I’ll use a sample factsheet and break it down into
three parts for illustration.
78
A 3-Step System to Grow Your
Wealth via Funding Societies
2nd Step: Choose Investment Notes
The first part comprises the general details of the investment note including the
financing amount, investors’ net return and repayment schedule.
79
A 3-Step System to Grow Your
Wealth via Funding Societies
2nd Step: Choose Investment Notes
There are two financing types – invoice financing and business term financing.
These two financing types typically have different repayment methods - bullet
repayment and monthly repayment.
For bullet repayment, you’ll receive interest every month and the principal will
only be repaid at the maturity date. In the event of any default, you’ll sustain
higher losses as compared to an investment note with monthly repayment
method. Because for the monthly repayment method, you’ll get back at least a
portion of your principal on a monthly basis on top of the interest earned.
Invoice financing also poses a potential fraud risk. The borrowers only repay the
financing after their debtors settle the invoices. There’s a risk of the borrowers
falsifying the invoices to get money through P2P lending. Though such cases are
rare but no one can guarantee that it will never happen. In other words, invoice
financing is inherently more risky than business term financing.
But it doesn’t mean that you can’t invest in invoice financing at all. The beauty of
it is that the maturity normally ranges 1 to 4 months only. You’ll have a much
better liquidity position from investing in invoice financing notes.
80
A 3-Step System to Grow Your
Wealth via Funding Societies
2nd Step: Choose Investment Notes
As part of the investing strategy, you can allocate a smaller amount to invest in
invoice financing. I only invest RM300 in each invoice financing while I’ve
allocated RM500 for each business term financing.
Another tip is that many invoice financing borrowers are recurring customers.
Their repayment records will be a good indicator of their creditworthiness.
81
A 3-Step System to Grow Your
Wealth via Funding Societies
2nd Step: Choose Investment Notes
You should also pay attention to which industry the borrower is operating in.
Some industries tend to have higher risks than the others during certain periods,
especially for cyclical businesses.
For example, construction companies may not be favourable during times when
the Government scales back mega-infrastructure projects and reduces
infrastructure expenditure.
You may also want to avoid palm oil companies when there’s a negative outlook
on palm oil price due to oversupply from Malaysia and Indonesia.
These are just a few examples to give you a feel of how a borrower’s operating
industry may affect your risk of investment.
82
A 3-Step System to Grow Your
Wealth via Funding Societies
2nd Step: Choose Investment Notes
The 2nd part consists of the background information of the company and its
Directors like payment history, litigation, etc.
83
A 3-Step System to Grow Your
Wealth via Funding Societies
2nd Step: Choose Investment Notes
A company with ongoing litigation cases typically has a higher risk of default.
Company and its Directors with bad repayment records will expose you to a higher
risk of default.
84
A 3-Step System to Grow Your
Wealth via Funding Societies
2nd Step: Choose Investment Notes
Last but not least is the historical financial information of the company. Generally,
it includes the audited financial information and also the current year
management accounts. Besides, the information on bank balances based on the
latest bank statements are available as well.
A company that has been consistently making losses for the past few years has a
higher risk of default as compared to a profitable company.
85
A 3-Step System to Grow Your
Wealth via Funding Societies
2nd Step: Choose Investment Notes
Current ratio measures the company ability to pay short term obligations. Current
ratio is positive when its current assets are higher than current liabilities. In other
words, a positive current ratio indicates that the company has the ability to repay
its liabilities within 12 months.
As illustrated in the example earlier, the compounding effect will help you grow
your money magically over time. However, this can only be done if you keep re-
investing your money and stay invested in P2P lending.
Reinvestment also reduces your risk of investment other than maximising your
returns. Because when you maximise your frequency of investing whenever you
have available funds, the returns would be much higher. So even when a default
really happens, your returns would easily exceed the potential losses.
The longer you invest, the lower the risk of investing in P2P lending. And of
course, the faster your wealth grows.
86
Grow Your Wealth Now
The 3-step system above applies purely mathematics
and common sense. It’s easily understandable and
practical to apply for anyone. Doesn’t matter whether
you are a seasoned investor or new to investing.
87
Final Thoughts
Final Thoughts
P2P lending in Malaysia has been growing at an exponential pace since its
emergence in 2016. The most obvious reason is because of its promising high
returns with more than 10% per annum. Also, it doesn’t require specialised
financial knowledge or day-to-day monitoring.
Frankly, I was really anxious in the first few months of investing in P2P lending.
“What if I don’t get back my money?” “What if it’s a scam?” These questions were
floating in my mind every night despite I only started investing after thorough
research.
But after I received my repayments for months while looking at the numbers, I
was grinning to myself. I know the 3-step system is working perfectly for me.
With an entry requirement as low as only RM100, don’t you really think that it’s
worth a try? Do you want to brush it off as an investment alternative just like that
without getting a better understanding?
88
Final Thoughts
What other investment options that are more attractive to you? How has KLCI
stock market been treating you? Fixed deposits? Or, Unit Trusts?
It’s now all over to you…I’m no expert in investing. But I believe that you as a
brilliant investor can form your own judgment based on all the information
available and make the best of any present investment opportunity.
And especially when every piece of information including the historical results and
data are all easily accessible at your fingertips!
If you still have any doubts or questions, refer to the FAQs on P2P lending below.
Thank You!
Follow us:
89
FAQs on P2P Lending in
Malaysia
FAQs on P2P Lending in
Malaysia
General
You can refer to Chapter 4 for the full review and comparison of all P2P lending
platforms in Malaysia.
Among other criteria, the directors of an operator must demonstrate that they are
fit and proper to operate such business. Besides, the operator must also ensure
that a transparent and effective risk scoring system is in place.
FAQs on P2P Lending in
Malaysia
General
The operator also must place the amounts deposited by both investors and issuers
in a 3rd party trustee account before making any disbursement. SC had also issued
additional guidelines for the offering of Islamic investment notes.
Example:
Issuer A issues to Customer Z an invoice with an amount of RM100 with 30 days
credit terms. Issuer A can raise (RM100 – service fee) through a P2P lending
platform immediately with a few months maturity date.
After customer Z settles the invoice, Issuer A will repay the outstanding financing.
FAQs on P2P Lending in
Malaysia
General
Can issuers still raise funds on a P2P lending platform if the amount does not
meet the target?
Issuers can only receive funds if at least 80% of the amount has been raised on a
P2P lending platform.
Can issuers raise funds through multiple P2P lending platforms at the same
time?
Issuers can only raise funds with different purposes via multiple P2P lending
platforms concurrently. However, the issuers have to disclose to each platform
operator.
FAQs on P2P Lending in
Malaysia
Issuers
The process will be much faster because the procedures are more straightforward
as compared to the banks.
Can issuers make early repayment before the maturity date of a loan?
Yes. But an early repayment fee applies.
FAQs on P2P Lending in
Malaysia
Investor
Some P2P lending platforms categorized investors into retail, institutional and
high net worth investors. Each category has a different limit to invest in the
investment notes.
What information can investors get before participating in any investment note?
A P2P lending platform operator needs to disclose the relevant information of an
issuer to the investors. The information includes the purpose of the financing, key
characteristics of the financing, issuer’s financial information. Investors can also
access the general risk warnings and risk disclosure of the issuer.
What happens if the funds raised do not meet the target amount of the
investment note?
If the funds raised do not reach 80% of the target amount, the operators will
refund to the respective investor.
As a last resort, the platform operators may raise funds from investors to initiate
legal proceedings to recover the amount. However, the operators will not
reimburse any losses to investors in the event of a default.
QuicKash, one of the approved P2P lending platform operators offers investment
notes with a principal guaranteed element. It charges a guarantee fee to an issuer.
In the event of any default, the principal amount of the investors will be
protected.
What is the initial amount requirement for investors to invest in a P2P lending
investment note?
The initial amount requirement differs between P2P lending platforms but ranges
between RM50 – RM500. Some platforms require investors to make an initial
deposit to register an account. Once the registration is successful, investors can
use the deposits to invest in any of the investment notes.
How do investors ensure the amounts deposited with P2P lending platforms are
safe?
SC mandated that all P2P lending platform operators must place the amounts
received into trust accounts maintained by trustees (i.e. banks) before making any
disbursement to either borrowers or investors.