Practical Research 1 Section: _________________

SY 2019-2020 Group No.: ____

Oral Defense Grading Sheet Page 1 of 2

Part 1: Research Paper

EXPERT PROFICIENT APPRENTICE NOVICE SCORE

(96-100) (86-95) (81-85) (75-80)
INTEGRATION The paper The paper The paper The paper does
OF demonstrates that demonstrates that demonstrates that not demonstrate
KNOWLEDGE the authors fully the authors, for the authors, to a that the authors
understand and the most part, certain extent, have fully
have applied understand and understand and understood and
concepts learned have applied have applied applied concepts
in research. concepts learned concepts learned learned in
Concepts are in research. in research. research.
integrated into
the writers’ own
insights.
DEPTH OF In-depth In-depth In-depth In-depth
DISCUSSION discussion and discussion and discussion and discussion and
elaboration in all elaboration in elaboration in elaboration in few
sections of the most sections of some sections of sections of the
paper. the paper. the paper. paper.
COHESIVENESS Ties together For the most part, Sometimes ties Does not tie
information from ties together together together
all sources. Paper information from information from information.
flows from one all sources. Paper all sources. Paper Paper does not
issue to the next flows with only does not flow; flow and appears
smoothly. some disjointedness is to be created
disjointedness. apparent. from disparate
issues.
SPELLING AND No spelling and/or Minimal spelling Noticeable Unacceptable
GRAMMAR grammar and/or grammar spelling and/or number of
mistakes. mistakes. grammar spelling and/or
mistakes. grammar
mistakes.
SOURCES More than eight More than six More than five Fewer than five
current sources, current sources, current sources, current sources.
of which six are of which four are of which three are Not all web
from credible from credible from credible sources utilized
internationally internationally internationally are credible,
published published published and/or sources
journals. journals. journals. are not current.
CITATIONS Cites all data Cites most data Cites some data Does not cite
obtained from obtained from obtained from sources.
other sources. other sources. other sources.
FINAL SCORE FOR RESEARCH PAPER
Practical Research 1 Section: _________________
SY 2019-2020 Group No.: ____
Oral Defense Grading Sheet Page 2 of 2

Part 2: Oral Research Presentation

EXPERT PROFICIENT APPRENTICE NOVICE SCORE

(96-100) (86-95) (81-85) (75-80)
SLIDESHOW: Text is readable. Text is readable. Text is mostly Text is mostly
Graphics support Graphics are readable. readable.
text and verbal mostly adequate. Graphics Graphics are
explanation. somewhat missing.
adequate.
CONTENT: All pertinent Most pertinent Some pertinent Few pertinent
information of information of information of information of
the study is the study is the study is the study is
presented clearly. presented clearly. presented clearly presented clearly
ORGANIZATION Presentation Presentation Presentation Presentation has
: follows a follows a mostly follows a no logical flow or
completely logical logical flow. somewhat logical sequencing of
flow. flow. ideas.
FINAL SCORE FOR ORAL RESEARCH PRESENTATION:

Part 3: Individual Scores

SUBJECT LANGUAGE USE: DELIVERY AND RESPONSE TOTAL

KNOWLEDGE: Explains in EYE CONTACT: TO SCORE
Explains formal English, Talks clearly for QUESTIONS:
assigned parts applying the the audience to (1 – 30
clearly and rules of hear and follow; points)
adequately grammar maintains
(1 – 30 points) (1-20 points) proper eye
contact
(1-20 points)
(Member name)
(Member name)
(Member name)
(Member name)
(Member name)
(Member name)
(Member name)
(Member name)