Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
July 1994
ABSTRACT The frequency and time domain perfornuance dangerous to personnel working nearby. Moreover, modem elec-
of a typical substation grounding system subjected to a light- tronic circuits generally have weak signal levels and are sensitive
ning strike is described and discusaed. The computed swlar to various kinds of electromagnetic disturbances. The undesir-
potentials, electric fields and magnetic fields are presented able electromagnetic fields induced by the lightning current may
gmphically as a function of spacial coordinate, a8 a function cause measurement error or result in damage to the electronic
of time and as a function of both. It is believed that these circuitry. The grounding system should therefore be designed so
detailed results have not been published before. that these electromagnetic fields do not exceed acceptable levels.
First, a double exponential lightning surge cunent is in- These acceptable levels are defined in several publicationsboth in
jected into the center of a square ground grid. This same terms of safety [ll,121 and equipment susceptibility [1515]. The
mlge c u m n t is then injwted at one corner of the grid. The reader interested in acceptable EM levels should consult IEEE
response of the grounding system to the fnquency domain Transactions on EMC for extensive references on this subject.
electromagnetic spectrum of this signal is computed bar a fre- The ability to compute frequency and time domain responses fol-
quency domain electromagnetic field analysis software pack- lowing a lightning strike or a switching surge provides unique
age. Once all the frequency responses have been computed, opportunities to develop more efficient bonding and grounding
the temporal and spatial distributions of the electromagnetic systems as well as mitigative measures to reduce touch voltages
fields inside and near the substation are obtained by an in- and electrical stresses on equipment.
verse Fourier transformation of all these responses. The It is therefore important to predict accurately the distribution
results are compared with some well known low frequency of currents flowing along the various metallic paths followed by
results and to "nt published work in this area. These re- the lightning surge and discharging into the soil from the ground
sults indicate that the performance of the grounding system conductors. Once these currents are known, it is equally impor-
is significantly dependent on frequency and on the point of tant to determine precisely the resulting electromagnetic fields
impact of the lightning strike. and earth potentials at all pertinent observation points so that
KEYWORDS: Lightning, Grounding, Transients, Electric the electromagnetic transient disturbance can be reduced to an
Field, Magnetic Field, Scalar Potential, Surge Current. acceptable level. Due to the transient nature of the lightning
surge, all the electromagnetic fields vary rapidly with time. As a
result, not only the spatial distribution of the field, but also its
1 Introduction temporal behaviour should be determined.
Two methods have been traditionally used for the analysis of
When lightning strikes an electric substation, large currents flow electromagnetic fields generated by energized conductors. One
in substation and equipment structures before dissipating in the method is the so-called "circuit theory approach". It is based on
soil through the grounding system. The electromagnetic fields replacing all conductor elements, including the lightning paths,
generated by such lightning surges will result in large currents by an equivalent electrical network. The analysis of this net-
and voltages which may cause damage to equipment and may be work leads directly to results in terms of currents and voltages
at all points of interest. The other method is the "field theory
approach" which is based on the direct solution of the electromag-
94 WM 139-6 PWRD A paper recommended and approved netic field equations pertaining to the energized conductors and
by the IEEE Substations Committee of the IEEE Power all other metallic structures nearby, whether directly energized or
Engineering Society for presentation at the IEEE/PES not. This method has definite advantages in terms of accuracy,
1994 Winter Meeting, New York, New York, January 30 - flexibility and modelling capabilities but is however much more
February 3, 1994. Manuscript submitted July 27, 1993; complicated than the circuit approach and, in most cases,is only
made available for printing November 29, 1993. possible through numerical computation methods.
......
x xxxxx 100 kHz(Grcev)
50 Hz (Grcev)
- -- -. Low Frequency
....
::: :
!:I !
b
:: ::
; :..: !
;;A
.-C A4 M
0 500 lo00 1500 2000
3 Frequency @Hz)
d-a 4.75 I
o r
"'.i, 40.0 -20.0 0 20.0 40.0 %-,&. -40.0 -20.0 0 20.0 40.0
% Distance Along X Axis (m) Distance Along X Axis (m)
Figure 5: Earth Surface Scalar Potential at 50 Hz - (Center Figure 7 Earth Surface Scalar Potential at 0.5 MHz - (Cen-
Injection; E, = 9) ter Injection; E, = 36)
9 10.254
&
E
\
1300
2
' C
%t4*,, -40.0 -20.0 0 20.0 40.0
60,
Distance Along X Axis (m)
-40 -20.0 0.0 20.0 40.0
Figure 12: Resultant Electric Field o n Earth Surface at 50
Distance Along X Axis (m)
Hz (Center Injection; E, = 9 )
Figure 9: X-Component of Electric Field o n Earth Surface
at 50 H z (Center Injection; E~ = 9 )
4 Conclusions
A detailed frequency and time domain analysis of the electro-
magnetic performance of a grounding grid subjected to a rela-
tively slow rise lightning surge current has been described and
discussed. This current was injected at the center and a comer
of the w-d respectively. 6, -40.0 -20.0 0 20.0 40.0
A representative sample of the most pertinent results has been Distance Along X Axis (m)
presented in a compact graphical form consisting of 3-D perspec-
tives of scalar potentials, electric fields and magnetic fields along Figure 16: X-Component of Magnetic Field on Earth Surface
earth surface profiles located above and near the ground grid. at 0.5 MHz (Center Injection; E, = 9)
The temporal evolution of a typical profile is also displayed for
the scalar potentials and for X-components of the electric and
magnetic fields for both locations of the current injection. More research work in this area is presently in progress. It
The authors believe that most of these results are being p u b concentrates on fast transient currents in the presence of above-
lished (in this paper) for the first time. ground metallic conductors and structures.
The low frequency results compare very well with those pro-
duced by well known low frequency grounding methods. The Acknowledgements
computed electric fields are also in agreement with recently pub-
lished work in the frequency range of 0 - 1 MHz. Funds and facilities for this research work were provided by Safe
The most salient results of this study indicate that the scalar Engineering Services & technologies ltd. (SES). The assistance
potential and electric field are significantly dependent on fre- of Mr. Robert Southey of SES for his constructive comments is
quency, while the magnetic field is rather insensitive to this pa- highly appreciated.
rameter. In contrast, the magnetic field is heavily influenced by
the current injection location at all frequencies, while both scalar
potentials and electric fields are not affected by this location at
low frequencies.
The time domain results also indicate that the dynamic evolu-
tion of electromagnetic fields is a blend or synthesis of the indi-
vidual significant frequenciescontained in the frequency spectrum
as might be expected. The results also show a sharp simultane-
ous rise of the electric and magnetic fields in the first few mi-
croseconds and a slow but independent decay depending on the
observation point along the profile.
1418
.-0
Y
g 20.0 1
2 480
33 6 0 -
x
3:
2!
-2 240 -
ZL
0
.*
c)
8 120-
2
w