Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
University of Kansas
Courtney Keedy
2/24/2020
SEXUAL ORIENTATION IN THE MEDIA 2
II. INTRODUCTION
This research will focus on the media’s perception of a variety of sexual orientations.
Specifically, the stereotypes associated with Lesbians, Gays, and Transgenders within movies
and television shows found on Netflix- a subscription-based movie and television series media
hub. The purpose of this research is to identify the different representations of these groups of
people in common modernized media formats. The three research questions focused upon
include: (a) what are the most commonly portrayed groups of sexually oriented people in the
media? (b) what stereotypes of Gay and Lesbians are most predominant in the media? And (c)
how often is the Transgender population represented in the media? I anticipate noticing gender
transgression, as Banks and Banks mention as the intention to critique normal gender roles and
expectations (Banks and Banks, 2013). I hypothesize that Lesbian women will be represented in
a masculine manner while males will challenge their masculinity and be more often represented
This research focus resembles modern inequity in our society, and I feel as though,
through our course readings, that proper representation of different groups of people (and their
history) is one of the most important ways to reduce and eliminate discrimination and prejudice.
Recognizing that many people are becoming enlightened with their sexual orientation in recent
years, I find it important to note how these groups of people are being represented in the media, a
predominant influence in the modern day world, that is causing inequity within our society. It is
important to recognize how and where these groups are being discriminated so educators can
Identifying and analyzing the discrimination toward a variety of sexually oriented people
in the media will help me to better understand multicultural education since this is an issue of the
SEXUAL ORIENTATION IN THE MEDIA 3
present. Noticing how children are growing up, watching television and movies, while learning
different stereotypical qualities toward groups of people, is a notable issue. Acknowledging our
own views towards these groups, as well as identifying the surrounding stigmas in the media,
will help me as well as other educators to work at properly representing these groups in
curricula.
Research Literature
My research questions stated above revolve around the most predominant, sexually
oriented group of people in the media and the stereotypes associated with them. The following
literature represents common stereotypes previously noted in the media, how the media
First, an article by Benecke (2015) illustrates the absence of Lesbian movies in the media
largely influenced by the lack of audience and support by society. This is an opinionated article
about Lesbians having a stereotype of not being humorous, therefore less movies are made about
them. As the article continues, the author relates Lesbian movies reaching less of an audience not
because of the Lesbian aspect, but because of the female aspect. Pushing men out of the picture
does not do well for the movie industry, according to this author (Benecke, 2015). Although
lesbian and female driven films do not receive the same budget as a male-oriented film, 40% of
films are now female-driven, as of 2015 (Benecke, 2015). The author is still pushing for a better,
proper audience to be illustrated for these films. This piece of literature led me to determine how
often Lesbians are featured and are the focus in the media.
The second researched article was “Lesbians and Gay Men in the Media.” This article
identifies different television shows, movies, and news stories about how Gay and Lesbian
SEXUAL ORIENTATION IN THE MEDIA 4
people were represented or misrepresented in the media. Although this article was published in
1992, there are some reoccurring themes within the movies and shows mentioned. Most
television shows underrepresented Gay men and Lesbian women, with only two shows receiving
positive praise at fully integrating these groups of people. One television affiliate even refused to
air a documentary on Gay Black men, while cancelling or highly censoring others. In the movies,
negative stereotypes were mentioned in correspondence to the few Lesbian and Gay
appearances. For example, one movie titled “Basic Instinct” was about man-hating killer
Lesbians- reinforcing the stereotype that all Lesbians hate men. Lastly, in the news, this article
brings up the topic of AIDS being directly related to Gay men, and that a heterosexual woman
named Kimberly Bergalis, who contracted the disease, was labeled as an “innocent victim of
AIDS.” This harmful implication stereotyped this disease to “guilty victims” being Gay men
(Carton, 1992). This article encouraged me to look for stereotypes, like the man-hating Lesbians
The third literature article was written by Chung in 2007 which highlights more modern
stereotypes in popular television shows and movies today. The author believes that the media is
include most Gay men being into fashion and beauty, challenging the typical male role, or
Lesbian women and Gay men tending to have alcohol-based lifestyles. This author notes that
children are learning stereotypes not from school or their parents, but from characters on the
television screen, where they are more likely to develop presumptions and discriminatory
behavior against Lesbian and Gay people. This article ties these modern stereotypes into
education by identifying strategies on how educators can become more socially aware in the
classroom. For example, one art class provides students the opportunity to make them critically
SEXUAL ORIENTATION IN THE MEDIA 5
informed citizens by examining and interpreting media texts to resist problematic representations
in the future (Chung, 2007). This article encouraged me to focus on basic stereotypes that young
adults or teens tend to demonstrate from the use of media, and how to counteract them with
The last research article was written by Harry Yan in 2019. This article studies the
attitudes of viewers when watching media representing the LGBTQ community. The overarching
theme of this study is proving that attitudes transfer among people. For example, the Washington
Post quotes, “If you strongly oppose gay marriage, chances are high that you don’t know anyone
who supports it and the sort of media you consume tends to rarely cover the rapidly increasing
support for gay marriage,” (Yan, 2019). After both heterosexual and non-heterosexual
individuals answered survey questions after watching LGBTQ-inclusive TV shows, the findings
support that watching contemporary Gay and Lesbian storylines on TV has direct positive effects
on changing people’s attitudes toward Gay and Lesbian people in society. The results of this
study also indicate that people’s heavy TV consumption can influence people’s judgements of
public opinions- making the media a reliable source as an effective persuasion technique in the
LGBTQ- equal rights movement. Lastly, this article suggests that attitudes among peers and
friends can influence each other, especially those close in age (Yan, 2019). This article helped
me to relate media to my classroom and see how common exposure of the LGBTQ community
within the media contributes to more positive effects and attitude adjustments within the
classroom.
III. METHODOLOGY
A popular media presentation format was chosen as the methodology for this study. To
include both movies and television shows, I chose to use Netflix as my main database. This is a
SEXUAL ORIENTATION IN THE MEDIA 6
subscription site that includes a plethora of popular movies and television shows from cable
Television as well as Netflix original series and movies. Using Netflix, I based my movies and
television shows on the “Popular on Netflix” and “Trending Now” pages, since these are the two
areas that most young adults and teens venture to when looking for a new movie or show to
watch. Netflix is the most reliable database to use since these media presentations are usually
advertised on cable TV and are frequently discussed in classrooms, on social media, and in social
settings. A variety of genres were explored to account for the different types of young adults or
teen viewers. A sample size of two movies and six television show, chosen by random selection,
were used to then observe how sexually oriented groups were either represented or not
represented, and if they were, what stereotypes were noticeable within the different genres.
football player who committed multiple murders. After being convicted, Aaron takes his own life
to help financially support his fiancé and child. Once he has passed, a rumor began of whether or
not Aaron was heterosexual and if his need to suppress his homosexuality became the driving
factor of his murder sprees (Wetzel & McDermott, 2020). This documentary is demonstrating
heterosexual stereotypical roles. However, in the beginning, the female lead does accuse the
male lead as being Gay since he was wearing eyeliner after a show one night (DeLine & Antin,
2010). This movie relates to Jones’ video (2011) when addressing all stereotypes of Gay men.
One of the noted stereotypes was that gay men wish that they were girls. This movie illustrates
SEXUAL ORIENTATION IN THE MEDIA 7
this stereotype when the woman asks the man wearing eyeliner if he was Gay, since wearing
Regarding television shows, Grey’s Anatomy, has been a popular show on cable
television and Netflix for several years. This is a television show following interns into their
hospital residency to become surgeons (Gray & Corn, 2005). Early in the show, one female
resident later finds herself being attracted to women. Later in the seasons, a transgender male
who has recently returned from deployment overseas begins working at a hospital with a Gay
man who keeps his sexual orientation hidden. This show challenges the stereotypes of Lesbian
women and Transgender men. The Lesbian character, who played a large role at the time, was
portrayed as a feminine woman who had previously been in love with a man and was upset with
the lack of attention that she received from him. She was into fashion and make-up and was
characteristically girly. The woman she fell in love was also extremely feminine. On the other
hand, the transgender male, who is currently still in episodes, has joined the hospital force after
being in the military for some time. Being in the military attains a sense of masculinity, and
perhaps joining the military was intentional to attain that appearance. These are challenging the
Next, the television show Shameless, has also been highly recognized on social media
platforms over the past several years. This is a television show revolving around a family of
multiple kids. One of the children experiments with her sexuality and, in the process, begins to
change her physical appearance and attitude toward her future role in society as a potential
Lesbian. Her brother also identifies as a Gay man early in the show and falls in love with a
Transgender male (Abbott & Mylod, 2011). This show portrays both negative and positive
stereotypes within the episodes. First, the Lesbian daughter, is showing a negative stereotype by
SEXUAL ORIENTATION IN THE MEDIA 8
adjusting her physique and personality to be more manly in order to “fit the role” of a Lesbian.
On the other hand, the Gay brother is masculine and acts a little rough around the edges. The
The next television series is How to get Away with Murder. This is a mysterious
television show about a college-level lawyer class with an instructor who negatively impacts
their social lives and involves them with many difficult situations. One of the main law students,
Connor, is known as the tough guy, yet internally emotional, and is also a Gay man (Nowalk &
Cragg, 2014). This show illustrates how Gay men can have a variety of qualities, as can any
heterosexual human being. Connor can be the masculine, tough man while also being a little
sensitive and overly caring for his boyfriend. He is playing both a feminine role as well as a
Schitt’s Creek is the following show analyzed. This is a comical television show about a
wealthy family who loses all of their hard-earned family riches when a tax evasion suit is filed
(Levy, 2015). The son in the film, David, is a bisexual man who is portrayed in a very feminine,
fashionista manner. This is a prime example of gender transgression. Gender transgression is the
intention to critique normal gender roles and expectations (Banks and Banks, 2013). David is
extremely fashionable and speaks in a way that some would refer to as a “valley girl.” The
Jane the Virgin was the subsequent television show analyzed. This is a Spanish
telenovela who follows Jane and her interactions with others. One of her enemies, which later
turns out to be her good friend, is a strong-willed feminist who later finds herself attracted to
other females (Snyder & Rodriguez, 2014). This is challenging the stereotype that Lesbian
SEXUAL ORIENTATION IN THE MEDIA 9
women must be manly while also challenging the traditional gender roles of women. This
character, Petra, is fashionable, a mother of twins, and battles Jane for the man throughout most
of the show. She is an extremely successful hotel owner that turns the company around as Rafael,
the male lead, gets arrested throughout an episode. Her transformation into a Lesbian only
strengthened her character and enforced gender equality and sexual fluidity.
Lastly, the television show, You, was analyzed. This is a mysterious, television show
about a man who is a psychopath going on killing sprees. One of his best friends is on the search
for love, and eventually falls for a Transgender female (Berlangi & Toland, 2018). This show
subtly includes the Transgender actress. Although she is featured in a few episodes, the fact that
she is Transgender is not noted within the show nor is she present enough for the audience to
truly interact with her. This solidifies Banks and Banks’ (2013) notion that people exclude or
ignore what they are not comfortable with. In this show, the uncomfortable perception would be
stereotypical categories that were frequently evident in my small sample size of movies and
television shows. I identified seven stereotypes and observations to look for when analyzing the
media. These stereotypes were most commonly addressed in the research literature as well as in
Jones’ (2011) video from module five. These stereotypes include: Gay men represented in a
feminine manner, Gay men represented in a masculine manner, Lesbian women represented in a
Transgender people absent from the media. After identifying the different stereotypes within
found in the overall data collected. This process is appropriate to acquire an estimate of
stereotypes among homosexual individuals in the media. These randomly selected media forms
IV. FINDINGS
The findings of the evident stereotypes within the eight analyzed media formats are as
follows: the probability of a television show choosing to portray a Gay man in a feminine
manner is 37% with three out of eight media formats representing this stereotype. The
probability of a television show choosing to portray a Gay man in a masculine manner is 75%
with six out of eight media formats representing this stereotype. The probability of a television
show choosing to portray a Lesbian woman in a masculine manner is 25% with two out of eight
media formats representing this stereotype. The probability of a television show choosing to
portray a Lesbian woman in a feminine manner is 37% with three out of eight media formats
Transgender person in a feminine manner is 12% with one out of eight media formats
Transgender person in a masculine manner is 25% with two out of eight media formats
representing this stereotype. And lastly, the probability of a television show choosing not to
portray a Transgender person within the production is 62% with five out of eight media formats
This data indicates that Gay men are commonly represented in a masculine manner. This
was not my anticipated finding since most of the researched literature mentions Gay men to be
stereotypically represented in a feminine manner. Perhaps the media is aware of this negative
stereotype and is actively working to reduce the common stereotypes of the Gay culture. The
SEXUAL ORIENTATION IN THE MEDIA 11
data also supports that Transgender people are not represented often in the media. The studied
media involved 62% excluding a Transgender character. Perhaps this indicates the media’s
uncomfortableness with the Transgender community and is unaware of how to properly represent
this group of people. Banks and Banks (2013) support this idea with Sleeter’s observation that
White people preform their race by expressing racist attitudes, so people may perform
the discomfort involving the Transgender community within production of movies and
television.
One of my assumptions was that Gay and Lesbian individuals were going to be
misrepresented often in the media. This was a presumption fabricated within my own mind. As
Banks and Banks (2013) suggest, I have not challenged the implicit and explicit heterosexualism,
homophobia, and gender conformity in my curricula and life since I was unable to identify my
own viewpoints. The popular stereotypes I was aware of, are less likely to harm students within
those stereotypical roles, but those who are not. In Chappell’s (2013) article, it states that six out
of ten people say they have been the target or jokes or slurs. This indicates that homophobia may
Banks and Banks (2013) chapter nine, introduces some strategies to help reduce and
eliminate stereotypes regarding the LGBTQ community to create a multicultural classroom. First
off, the LGBTQ community should never be discussed in a negative light. Banks and Banks
(2013) mention that some schools are not allowed to discuss the LGBTQ community within the
classroom, which will only cause a negative perception toward this group of people over time.
Avoiding these conversations is to prevent disruption between the strongly opinionated families
and the school. However, speaking openly and critically within class is necessary (Banks and
SEXUAL ORIENTATION IN THE MEDIA 12
Banks, 2013). As educators, we must teach students to think critically about how
heterosexualism and homophobia influence the understanding of ourselves and our relationships,
communities, and education. This could be done through analyzing current and historical texts
involving LGBTQ community members. Students should have the opportunity to challenge
implicit heterosexualism, homophobia, and gender conformity in current school curricula and
school practices. Lastly, teachers should be aware and vocal about LGBTQ community resources
for youth in schools. Banks and Banks (2013) state that youths are capable of asserting
themselves and finding community with others, but without the support of schools and the staff,
After collecting a random sample of movies and television shows from a notable media
database of popular and trending productions, I was able to determine the probability of common
stereotypes representing the LGBTQ community in the media. My first research question was to
determine the most commonly portrayed LGBTQ group in the media, resulting in 75% of Gay
men being represented in a masculine fashion. My second research question included the most
predominantly used Gay and Lesbian stereotypes in the media. For Gay men, being represented
as masculine was primarily used while Lesbians were often recognized as feminine. Lastly, the
third research question involved the frequency of Transgender individuals’ appearance in the
media. This would be the most notable issue to recognize across current media productions.
After analyzing eight pieces of media, 62% of this media lacked involvement of the Transgender
community. This could be a result of lack of cultural or critical awareness of this community, or
producers feeling as though a choice of a Lesbian, Gay, or Transgender character has already
been included, therefore an additional LGBTQ character is unnecessary. I did find it interesting
SEXUAL ORIENTATION IN THE MEDIA 13
that Gay and Lesbian individuals were more often represented as the stereotypical representation
of their biological sex. For example, Lesbians being portrayed as more girly. I think this largely
media instances, therefore, current producers are working hard to represent this community in a
Using the researched literature, there are a few connections to make. First, based on
Benecke’s (2015) article about the lack of lesbian movies, I found that three of my eight media
presentations represented a largely influential Lesbian character. For example, in Jane the
Virgin, the second female lead later reveals herself to be a strong, powerful, Lesbian woman.
Grey’s Anatomy also featured a strong Lesbian lead character for a few seasons as did Shameless
since one of the two main female lead characters was a Lesbian. This supports this literature
since less than 50% of the studied media highlighted Lesbian women and that the article
challenges gender roles in the media. However, Grey’s Anatomy and Jane the Virgin are both
shows that are from a woman’s perspective. This is challenging the literature by indicating a
Second, based on the “Lesbians and Gay Men in the Media,” article, I found that many of
the common stereotypes mentioned within this article as well as in Jones’ video are less
predominant in today’s society. For example, I noted the man-killing Lesbians in this article,
however, 37% of the media represented Lesbians in a feminine manner and 25% of media
focused on Lesbian women in a masculine manner, which opposes the article’s stereotypical
findings.
Chung’s article from 2007, indicated that students and children are accumulating
stereotypes not from homes and schools, but more from the media. This supports my assumption
SEXUAL ORIENTATION IN THE MEDIA 14
that the media is more aware of the common stereotypes involving the LGBTQ community and
is actively working to counteract them. This is evident in my data by showing 75% of Gay men
being represented in a masculine manner and 37% of Lesbian women being represented in a
feminine manner, which reduces the common stereotypes that Lesbians are manly and Gay men
are girly.
My last research article identified the attitudes that viewers of the media attained after
watching movies and TV shows that incorporated people from the LGBTQ community. This
article relates to my data by showing that every media presentation that was analyzed included at
least one member of the LGBTQ community. This indicates the large presence the media has in
representing different stereotypes involving these groups of people. This article helps me as an
educator to use more media formats to critique and analyze different LGBTQ stereotypes since
student’s attitudes will most likely transfer to other students within the school. This can help
This study can relate to the classroom in many ways. First, students who are facing
homophobic harassment may not even be members of the LGBTQ community. Based on the
stereotypes analyzed, the common stereotypical harassment phrases tend to be from previous
stereotypes that do not represent the current LGBTQ community. Banks and Banks (2013) note
this misfortune within schools and suggest providing a challenging standpoint in curriculum to
confront these stereotypes the students are using. Educators must work in counteracting these
stereotypes in the classroom to avoid this type of bullying. Next, the media is striving to break
the stereotypical standpoints and are representing Lesbian and Gay people in a variety of
different ways. Schools must utilize this media within classrooms to help break the stereotypical
views that students currently have and are using as harassment techniques. Although these
SEXUAL ORIENTATION IN THE MEDIA 15
stereotypes are not prevalent in the media right now, they are predominant thoughts among our
students. These are the popular cultural representations- it’s our job as educators to expand
The limitations of this research study include Netflix being the only database that was
used. Netflix also requires a subscription to view the media, which may hinder the culture of the
audiences. I also only analyzed media tailored to young adults and teens. There is less variability
within age groups. This study helped identify that previously noted stereotypes towards the
LGBTQ community are outdated. Many of these stereotypes are no longer relevant in today’s
society, with new stereotypes waiting to be analyzed. Also, stereotypes involving the transgender
community were not specific to female or male stereotypes. One limitation that is unrelated to
the data collected would be the “White dominance” within my researched media. Most of the
media sources represent white dominance, as Banks and Banks (2013) would refer to as a
predominantly white society, being as most lesbian, gay, or transgender people within these
media formats were Caucasian. This illustrates how different cultures and socioeconomic status
This leads future studies to accommodate more family-friendly movies and television
shows, to analyze the media that younger students are viewing with evident LGBTQ stereotypes.
Also, future studies need to identify more prevalent stereotypes within current society, not those
frequently used in the past. Future studies may also wish to focus on transgender stereotypes
between females and males. Lastly, future studies need to cross-reference stereotypes of sexually
and Transgender individuals are not solely implied to students of the LGBTQ community. Based
SEXUAL ORIENTATION IN THE MEDIA 16
on the prior research and lecture materials, some students facing homophobic harassment may
not even be members of the LGBTQ community. This research implies that the media is striving
to break some of these stereotypical standpoints and represent the LGBTQ community through a
variety of becoming qualities. The media analyzed in this project represent proper cultural
representations to identify within school curriculum to help analyze and expand the LGBTQ
Resources
Abbott, Paul. (Writer). Mylod, Mark. (Director). (2011). Shameless [Television series]. In J.
Distribution.
Banks, J. A., & Banks, C. A. (2013). Multicultural education: Issues and perspectives (8th ed.).
Benecke, J. (2015, 09). Where are all the lesbian movies? Diva, 52-53. Retrieved from
http://www2.lib.ku.edu/login?url=https://search-proquest-
com.www2.lib.ku.edu/docview/1707797725?accountid=14556
Berlanti, Greg; Gamble, Sera. (Writers). Toland Krieger, Lee. (Director). (2018). You
{Television series]. In M. Siega’s (Executive Producer) You. New York City NY:
Netflix.
Carton, E. (1992). Lesbians and Gay Men in the Media. Gay Community News, 19(25).
Chappell, B. (2013, June 13). In Gay America, Optimism Abounds As Stigma Persists, Pew
way/2013/06/13/191355273/in-gay-america-optimism-abounds-as-stigma-persists-pew-
says
Chung, S. K. (2007). Media Literacy Art Education: Deconstructing Lesbian and Gay
SEXUAL ORIENTATION IN THE MEDIA 18
Stereotypes in the Media. International Journal of Art & Design Education, 26(1), 98–
DeLine, Donald. (Producer). Antin, Steven. (Director). (2010). Burlesque. [Motion Picture].
Gray, Henry. (Writer). Corn, Rob (Director). (2005). Grey’s Anatomy [Television series]. In S.
https://kuconnect.ku.edu/courses/1921/pages/m4-presentation-on
gender?module_item_id=131341
Jones, J. [vaprofessor11]. (2011, April 19). Making safe places unsafe [Video file]. Retrieved
from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rNWgWbkZ4nY&feature=emb_title
King, J. (1991). Dysconscious Racism: Ideology, Identity, and the Miseducation of Teachers.
Levy, Eugene. (Writer). Levy, Eugene (Director). (2015). Schitt’s Creek [Television series]. In
Entertainment.
Nowalk, Peter. (Writer). Cragg, Stephen (Director). (2014). How to Get Away with Murder
SEXUAL ORIENTATION IN THE MEDIA 19
[Television series]. In S. Rhime’s (Executive Producer), How to get away with murder.
Snyder Urman, Jennie. (Writer). Rodriguez, Gina. (Director). (2014). Jane the Virgin [Television
series]. In J. Synder Urman’s (Executive Producer) Jane the virgin. United States: CBS
Television Distribution.
Wetzel, Dan. (Writer), McDermott, Geno. (Director). (2020). Killer Inside: The Mind of Aaron
Attitudes and Perceived Attitudes of Peers Toward Lesbians and Gays. Journalism &