Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Güssing Visit
4 November 2008
Report To Clonakilty Town Council
Authors: A Wickham & P Madden
Sustainable Clonakilty Energy Working Group
Table of Contents
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY..................................................................................................................................... 3
BACKGROUND INFORMATION ......................................................................................................................3
MEMBERS OF THE DELEGATION TO GÜSSING.......................................................................................4
ITINERARY FOR THE GÜSSING VISIT .........................................................................................................5
DI DEAN MARCELJA’S PRESENTATION ..................................................................................................... 6
KEY POINTS ...........................................................................................................................................................6
CONCEPTUAL POINTS ON A SUSTAINABLE LOCAL ENERGY SUPPLY ................................................................. 7
ECRE MANAGING DIRECTOR ING. REINHARD KOCH .........................................................................8
KEY POINTS FROM SESSION ................................................................................................................................... 8
LEARNING FROM GÜSSING’S EXPERIENCE ...........................................................................................................8
WHAT CAN ECRE DO FOR CLONAKILTY? ..........................................................................................................9
GÜSSING’S PLANTS ...........................................................................................................................................10
INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................................................................10
WHAT DID THEY DO ...........................................................................................................................................10
GÜSSING BIOMASS PLANT.............................................................................................................................12
PICTORIAL REPRESENTATION OF THE GÜSSING AREA ..................................................................14
GÜSSING DISTRICT HEATING PLANT .......................................................................................................15
BIOGAS PLANT STREM .........................................................................................................................................16
ACTIONS SUBSEQUENT TO VISITING GÜSSING....................................................................................18
RECOMMENDATIONS ......................................................................................................................................18
SUMMARY.............................................................................................................................................................19
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS..................................................................................................................................19
LINKS TO FURTHER INFORMATION .........................................................................................................19
CLARIFICATION OF TERMS ..........................................................................................................................20
UNDERSTANDING UNITS AND MULTIPLIERS USED IN THIS DOCUMENT. ...........................................................20
UNDERSTANDING WATTS AND WATT-HOURS .....................................................................................................20
BIOMASS ..............................................................................................................................................................20
BIOGAS .................................................................................................................................................................20
BIOFUEL ...............................................................................................................................................................20
COMBINED HEAT AND POWER (CHP) ................................................................................................................21
DISTRICT HEATING ...............................................................................................................................................21
Executive Summary
A delegation comprising Town Council and Sustainable Clonakilty Energy Working
Group members traveled to Güssing, Austria, to learn how they had reached
energy self-sufficiency.
The group engaged in discussions with representatives of the European Center of
Renewable Energy based in Güssing and visited three nearby renewable energy
power stations. Information was gathered that will be used to assist Clonakilty in
moving towards its goal of renewable energy self sufficiency by 2020. The visit to
ECRE and to the plants showed the practical side of their project and gave a clear
indication that the goal is achievable in Clonakilty.
Background Information
The Sustainable Energy Working Group, a sub-committee of Sustainable
Clonakilty, was formed in February 2008 by a group of volunteers from the
community who identified and were committed to the following objective:
To enable a strong, sustainable economy for Clonakilty and the surrounding
area by 2020, through self sufficiency in renewable energy.
Hence the project was born.
The group recognized that to meet this goal two interrelated elements needed to
be achieved; one element being the reduction of local energy demand through
conservation and greater efficiency in use, the other being the identification of local
sources of renewable energy and the introduction of means to use these to satisfy
that local energy demand. These two elements are to be concurrently progressed.
The group identified a need to conduct an energy audit to give baseline figures for
energy consumption in Clonakilty. These figures will help predict energy
requirements and enable measurement of progress towards meeting the group’s
objective. The group has received some funding from Failte Ireland (as part of the
2007 Best Emerging Rural Tourism Destination award prize) to initiate the energy
audit.
Güssing in Austria, a town of similar population to Clonakilty, had been identified
within the group as being a leader in the introduction of renewable energy to meet
its energy needs. In moving towards being energy neutral they had reduced their
carbon emissions by 93% over the course of 15 years and created over 1,000 jobs.
Their model facilitates others to follow suit and they were known to have carried
out similar energy audits to that the group thought was needed for Clonakilty.
The group decided that a visit to Güssing should be arranged and that the greatest
benefit would be gained if other local organisations, particularly the Town Council,
were to take part in the trip. Invitations were issued and an application made to the
Town Council for funding to facilitate the trip. Subsequently on Tuesday, 5th August
2008, the Clonakilty Mayor and Town Council unanimously supported Sustainable
Clonakilty’s application for community funding to make possible the group’s visit to
Güssing.
• Energy independency, the energy cycle run by local people for local people
using local resources, means a secured supply of energy.
• As a result there is less likelihood of political tension arising in the region, as
the energy supply cycle is an area of common local interest.
• The raw material supply is secure if sustainable growing and harvesting
practices are used. Currently daily consumption of fossil energy sources on
the planet equals 1347 years of the sedimentation process (clearly not
sustainable).
• Carbon footprint is reduced (in Güssing’s case by 93%).
• A Regional Sustainable Energy Supply is a win/win situation for all, whether
they are in industry, the public sector, agriculture, craftwork, or households.
3. Something they learned was that it is better to ‘take longer and involve all
parties in consultation’ before making changes. This latter point is of
particular relevance to Clonakilty as Sustainable Clonakilty considers
involvement and communication, of and with, the community a vitally
important means of bringing about change, particularly when the threat
necessitating the change is of a longer term nature than that facing Güssing
in 1991.
4. In retrospect, they would not build such a large district heating scheme
using hot water, but would build a gas distribution grid with only a short
distance heating grid to take the heat by-product to nearby consumers. This
way the infrastructure would be much cheaper, it would be more efficient
due to less energy loss in transmission and it is easier to store gas to meet
fluctuations in demand.
5. Reinhard Koch mentioned that Güssing is now the Austrian centre for
research into alternative automotive fuels and reiterated that one should
take only waste products for fuel production.
6. Regarding forestry, which in the Güssing region is mixed deciduous and
evergreen trees, they achieve around a 6 to 7% annual growth rate. They
are now experimenting with fast growing woods such as willow. Much of the
wood they use is grown in small parcels in private ownership, but forest
management unions oversee forest management for most woodlots.
Güssing’s Plants
Introduction
This section describes the energy plants and associated delivery systems
demonstrated on our visit to Güssing together with some additional information to
give context. It does not cover all the plants they operate to enable them to live
energy neutral*. These plants were developed by the Güssing team to meet their
energy needs from the resources available in the Güssing area. Information on
other Güssing plants can be found at: http://eee-info.net/english.php
Under Sustainable Clonakilty’s 2020 energy project our energy requirements will
need to be met from renewable resources available locally; as a result an exact
copy of the Güssing operation would not be appropriate.
*The term ‘Energy neutral’ in this context means the energy used in an area equates to that available from sustainable
resources within that same area.
We were shown how Güssing has been able to react to external factors, both
political and environmental.
A political example of this being one of Güssing’s transport fuel plants where they
had been making Rape Methyl Ester (RME), a form of bio-diesel with no mineral oil
content. This was made from Rape Oil (and waste cooking oil) using a process
called ‘Transesterification’. The by-product of this process, Rape-Cake, was used
to make biogas in a separate plant thereby minimising waste. The RME plant was
closed following the introduction of a 20 % bio-diesel content requirement for all
diesel sold in Austria, this resulted in the price of the main ingredient, rapeseed,
increasing making the process uneconomic.
An environmental example is that of wind energy which is not used in Güssing as
there is not enough of it to convert into a usable energy form viably with current
technology. We did note that it is used in the Vienna area as shown in the picture
below.
Solar power is used in Güssing. In the picture below a combined heat and power
plant (CHP) that we passed during our visit is shown.
The first plant that we visited was the Biomass plant on the edge of Güssing town,
shown above. To give the plant scale, the yellow building in the foreground is
single story. The plant is evolving as a result of research and development.
The fuel that the plant is optimised for is woodchip. This comes from adjacent
factories – the waste product of parquet flooring manufacturing and hardwood
drying* – and from local forests.
*Both new industries attracted to Güssing and sited near the Biomass plant for maximum efficiency.
The picture below shows timber and wood chips at the plant. The timber used in
the plant has been separated from timber that has other uses and is therefore a by-
product. Whilst this can be chipped at the plant, most is now chipped in the forest
as it is more efficient to transport and less noisy for local residents.
The picture below shows that the wood chips are not overly processed, this
minimises the energy used in producing them, whilst maintaining their gassing /
burning efficiency.
The basic product of the plant is gas; this is produced by heating the wood chip to
850°C in a chamber containing steam. This process is known as ‘Fluidised Bed
Steam Gasification’. The benefits of using this process (steam instead of air) are
that very little tar is produced and that the gas produced has a high calorific value –
if produced in air it would be diluted with nitrogen.
Wood chips are burnt together with some of the gas the plant produces to heat the
woodchips to the point where gas is produced. This gas is then cooled and
cleaned. The heat given off in the cooling process is fed into the town’s district
heating system. The residues are fed back into the system so no effluent / waste
results. The remaining gas can be used to fuel a gas engine, which drives a
generator; the resultant electricity is fed to the Grid – again waste heat is fed into
the district heating system.
If running at maximum capacity and all the gas is used to generate electricity the
plant can produce 2 MW, this equates to 25% to 28 % of the energy contained in
the woodchip. Of the rest of the energy contained in the wood chip, 4.4 MW (55%)
is output as heat and fed to the district heating system. This gives the plant an
overall efficiency of better than 80%, the rest is used in the process or lost as heat.
When running at maximum capacity the plant uses 2.3 tonnes of woodchip per
hour. This plant is operated for 8000 hours (11 months) per year.
The gas does not all have to be used to generate electricity. Because of its good
quality it has several other uses. It can be stored as synthetic natural gas, used as
fuel gas for vehicles, made into bio-ethanol (petrol), diesel, methanol or hydrogen.
The output of the plant can be tweaked, within limits, to maximise the product most
needed.
The Güssing plant cost approximately !40m to develop, but we were advised that
a plant of the same capacity could be put in for approximately !9m.
A patent is held for this particular wood gasification process.
Associated with the Biomass plant is the Fischer Tropsch Reactor shown below.
This is a research plant focusing on producing vehicle fuels using gas from the
biomass plant.
The Güssing district heating plant that we visited is shown above, it was built in
1996 and shows that the plants can be much more visually pleasing than the
biomass plant. The vehicles give the scale to the plant. The fuel used is wood chip,
which is processed into heat by efficient combustion. That heat is fed into the
town’s district heating system. This plant can deliver up to 14 MW of heat to the
district heating system and uses approximately 22,000 tonnes of wood per year.
The Güssing town’s district heating system*, which includes a network of pipes 27
km in length through which the heat is distributed, has a 42 MW heat distribution
capacity. When this was installed it was fed to all homes and businesses in the
town, regardless of whether the occupier wanted a connection or not. This was
because they were confident of future buy in and did not want to have to disrupt
the road system more than necessary. The early concerns with respect to
convenience were soon overcome when people realised that it was more
convenient than oil and the price was equal. It now costs 30% less than using oil
for an equivalent amount of energy.
*If starting now they would install a gas grid, with a short distance heating grid only, as the infrastructure would be much
cheaper, it would be more efficient and it is easier to store gas to meet fluctuations in demand.
The on-site store contains a year’s fuel, which consists primarily of grass silage
and maize and is shown below.
In this picture the silage in one lane is covered in wood chip and the other, slurry
produced as waste by the plant. This is to test maintaining the silage condition
with organic products in place of plastic sheeting. There were four lanes, each
approx 20m X 100m which equates to an area of approx 8000 sq m.
The process for producing gas is anaerobic digestion. The by-product slurry (this is
not animal waste) has just been collected by the tanker pictured, to be returned to
the land producing the fuel for the plant. The plant produces 4,250 MWh/year of
electricity to the grid and 4,500 MWh/year heat to the district heating system.
Recommendations
A meeting of the Energy Working Group Steering Committee, which includes the
Council Energy Sub-committee, is recommended to work together on addressing
the following issues:
1. How best to progress the project from the Town Council point of view.
2. Identifying what mechanisms exist, or can be created, to save money on
energy expenditure within the Council operations, and infrastructure.
3. Identifying a mechanism whereby any energy money saved by the Town
Council, through conservation, can be ring fenced for five years for
investment to enable further savings, and thus not lost from future Council
budgets.
4. A show of commitment from the Town Council through an energy audit and
an energy savings campaign in the Town Council run buildings and
operations, with attendant publicity.
5. Identifying suitable Council owned land that could be used to site renewable
energy power plants.
6. Ensuring the Town Council leads the way in ensuring all new properties are
built to the highest BER standards.
7. Ensuring all new industrial and commercial developments built in the area
will be able to be supported by locally produced renewable energy.
8. Gaining commitment and involvement from the Cork County Council, and in
particular the Planning Department.
9. Lobbying the Government for changes in policy, and where necessary
legislation, to support the project objectives.
Summary
In order to assist the Sustainable Clonakilty Energy Working Group progress
toward its project objective – that is ‘To enable a strong, sustainable economy for
Clonakilty and the surrounding area by 2020, through self sufficiency in renewable
energy’ - Güssing in Austria was identified as a town that was a leader in meeting
that objective and a place from which lessons could be learnt, thereby speeding
the project’s progress.
A visit was planned and as a result a delegation comprising Town Council and
Sustainable Clonakilty Energy Working Group members traveled to Güssing to
learn how they had reached energy self-sufficiency over a period of fifteen years.
The visit was centered on the European Center of Renewable Energy based in
Güssing. The group engaged in discussions with the center’s representatives and
visited three nearby renewable energy power stations. Descriptions of how and
why Güssing had moved to a renewable energy economy and how they could
assist Clonakilty in progressing toward being energy neutral were given. The visit
to ECRE and to the plants showed the practical side of their project and gave a
strong feeling of what is possible in Clonakilty. The Information gathered will be
used to assist us in moving towards renewable energy self sufficiency by 2020.
Acknowledgements
• The Mayor & Clonakilty Town Council for funding.
• The Mayor, Town Clerk, Councilors and others who made time to go on the
trip.
• REMS for arranging the visit to ECRE and sponsoring transport and seminar
costs in Austria.
• ECRE for the use of some of their images.
Clarification of terms
Understanding Units and Multipliers used in this document.
System International (SI) units are used unless otherwise stated. This system
includes prefixes, for those who are not familiar with this system, prefixes with the
following meaning are used in this document;
k Kilo Meaning 1,000 times the base unit i.e. 1 kW = 1000 W.
M Mega Meaning 1,000,000 times the base unit.
G Giga Meaning 1,000,000,000 times the base unit.
It should be noted that the kilogram is a base unit and 1000 kg is 1 Tonne.
Understanding watts and watt-hours
Power is the rate at which energy is used (or generated), measured in watts (W), at
any instant. However, energy is normally sold by the watt hour, which is the
product of power and time.
For example, if a 100 watt light bulb is turned on for one hour, the energy used is
100 watt-hours or 0.1 kilowatt-hour. This same quantity of energy would light a 40-
watt bulb for 2.5 hours.
A power station would be rated in watts, but its annual energy sales would be in
watt-hours (or kilowatt-hours or megawatt-hours).
A kilowatt-hour is the amount of energy equivalent to a steady power of 1 kilowatt
running for 1 hour.
Biomass
Biomass is organic matter available on a renewable basis. Biomass includes forest
and mill residues, agricultural crops and wastes, wood and wood wastes, animal
wastes, livestock operation residues, aquatic plants, fast-growing trees and plants,
and municipal and industrial wastes.
Biogas
Biogas can be produced from all kinds of biomass. The biomass can be
anaerobically (in the absence of oxygen) fermented into gas (or the gas can be
made by other methods such as the biomass plant described in this document).
The raw biogas is cleaned and the final product consists of methane.
Biofuel
A renewable fuel derived from biological matter (biodiesel, biogas, methane).
District heating
This is a system for distributing heat generated in a centralized location for
residential and commercial heating requirements such as space heating and water
heating. The heat is often obtained from a cogeneration plant burning biomass
increasingly in place of fossil fuels, although heat-only boiler stations, geothermal
heating and central solar heating are also used. District heating plants can provide
higher efficiencies and better pollution control than localized boilers.