Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
ADAM PETRO
is a landside services supervisor for the city and county of Denver, Department of Aviation at Denver International
Airport. He has over five years of experience with airport parking and transportation operations. In 2015,
Adam shared his expertise at the American Association of Airport Executives Parking and Landside Management
conference. His presentation was specific to creative parking products to enhance revenues and improve service.
Prior to coming to Denver International Airport, Adam worked in the field of emergency services for over
20 years with specific experience in operations, administration, emergency plan management and training. He holds
a bachelor’s of science degree in criminal justice administration from Metropolitan State University in Denver.
Abstract
Adam Petro
Airports are continually seeking new and innovative ways to improve customer flow efficiencies while
simultaneously maximising non-airline revenue. A reserved parking programme can facilitate efficient
customer movement beginning with airport arrival through the access point of the airport terminal. When
implementing the reserved parking programme at Denver International Airport (DEN), several factors were
taken into consideration, including customer demographics, physical infrastructural layout and configuration.
Once implemented, the programme at DEN has shown that reserved parking caters to not just the typical
business traveller, but to customers who may not have been thought would take advantage of a reserved
parking product enhancement. Realising the full benefits of a reserved parking programme required a well
thought out design in order to allow for maximum financial and operational flexibility.
Keywords
reserved parking, customer flow efficiency, parking occupancy, business flexibility, configuration
Delivered by Ingenta
© HENRY STEWART PUBLICATIONS 1750-1938 JOURNAL OF AIRPORT MANAGEMENT VOL. 11, NO. 2, 129–135 SPRING 2017 129
IP: 167.98.114.18 On: Thu, 24 Jan 2019 17:14:26
Copyright: Henry Stewart Publications
Petro
intended parking area was already full. exclusively by frequently f lying business
With this in mind, DEN began explor- travellers, the customer demographic has
ing various parking options that would broadened to include customers who
expedite the customer arrival process. travel on a more infrequent basis.
Several were considered and after careful Several questions were raised about a
consideration, it was determined that reserved parking programme during the
a reserved parking programme would conceptual phase of the project. These
most benefit the needs of air travel included, ‘What is the cost of imple-
customers. mentation?’, ‘Who is the intended (and
The reserved parking programme at non-intended) audience?’ and ‘How will
DEN was implemented in March 2014, this affect the usage of current parking
with reserved parking areas established products?’ Answers to some of these ques-
and designated within the existing parking tions came fairly easily; however, some
garage structures immediately adjacent to proved a bit more difficult to predict. As
the terminal building. The programme is discussions continued, there were even
run by DEN’s parking contractor partner, times when the idea of abandoning the
Standard Parking (SP+), in conjunction project came into play, simply because
with Click and Park®. Standard Parking the potential risks seemed to outweigh
provides day-to-day programme operation the possible benefit or gain. As with any
and management, while Click and Park new programme, there are various risks
manages reservations. associated with potentially high up-front
In the time since implementation, the capital improvement costs, combined
reserved parking programme has proven with unknown revenue returns; how-
to be a successful value added product ever, a reserved parking programme can
enhancement that has afforded business take shape in any number of forms.
and operational f lexibility in order to Depending on the type of operation, the
meet the goals of the airport parking options available are vast and allow for
operation as a whole. To date, designated increased risk mitigation, future business
reserved parking spaces have more than f lexibility, as well as maximised return
doubled overall in order to meet the on investment.
demand. Thoughtful development of a
programme such as this required critical
analysis of several aspects of the park- CONCEPTUTAL AND DESIGN
ing process to include physical design CONSIDERATIONS
and configuration, as well as operational Perhaps the most common question that
needs. arose during the conceptual stage of pro-
Reserved parking is often thought of gramme development was the number of
as a stand-alone parking product. While parking spaces that should be designated
various aspects of a reserved parking as reserved. While there was no ‘magic’
programme require specific attention, number or formula used to calculate
such as design, revenue collection, staff- this quantity, factors taken into con-
ing and administration, at DEN, it has sideration included the capacity of the
been viewed from a more macroscopic existing parking facilities within which
perspective. While this type of enhance- the reserved area would be located, as
ment has typically been utilised only in well as the location of these facilities.
a close-in parking facility, for use almost Additionally, perhaps what proved to be
the most important factor in making this Once the location was established, two
decision, was determining what could be additional elements of the programme
realistically managed from both an oper- development had to be determined,
ational standpoint as well as a financial including configuration type and the
standpoint. For instance, operationally, staffing levels necessary to effectively
how many spaces could be effectively manage the area. The configuration of
managed given current as well as antici- the area was vital for planning, devel-
pated future staffing models? Also, from opment and operational purposes. Early
a financial perspective, how many poten- in the process, two configuration types
tially empty spaces could be tolerated were considered. The first configuration
during non-peak periods? Once these option was one that involved the physical
were established, programme develop- separation of the reserved parking area
ment then proceeded to determining the from the general parking area, or a ‘hard’
exact location of the reservation-only configuration. This physical separation is
area within the facility. attained by means of physical barriers
When establishing the reserved park- such as gates and fences. There were
ing area, the location, of course, carried a two main advantages associated with this
very high level of importance. Reserved configuration type. First, it features the
parking located in a non-desirable area ability to ensure that non-reservation
that does not improve passenger f low holders do not access parking spaces that
efficiencies very quickly becomes disad- are intended for the reserved customer.
vantageous to customers and the airport. Secondly, once implemented, it would
It was determined that ideally, the exact not require a high level of ongoing
location should have the following manpower to manage effectively. Despite
characteristics: these advantages, however, disadvantages
existed that included higher up-front
1. CLOSE: the area needed to be close to costs associated with physical set up of the
the terminal facility. area. In addition, a physical barrier would
2. CONVENIENT: the reserved park- limit future possibilities for expansion or
ing area needed to be as convenient reduction of the reserved parking area.
as possible for customers to access The second configuration option
terminal ticketing areas and security considered was a ‘soft’ configuration that
queues. Also, terminal access needed to consists of no physical barriers. This
be accomplished via a well identified configuration relies on strong signage as
route and contain a minimal amount of well as hands on management and carried
vertical movement devices (elevator/ its own associated advantages and disad-
escalator) as possible, in order to reach vantages. First, one advantage recognised
the intended destinations within the was the lower costs associated with initial
terminal.2 establishment and implementation of the
3. COVERED: As Denver does experi- reserved parking area. These lower costs
ence adverse weather conditions such are realised due to the reduced need for
as rain, snow and ice, as a value added hardware and software infrastructure
product enhancement, it was necessary when compared to those necessary with
that the reserved parking area be a hard configuration type. Second, this
covered in order to offer the most pro- configuration also required much less time
tection possible for customer vehicles. in order to design and implement when
Delivered by Ingenta
© HENRY STEWART PUBLICATIONS 1750-1938 JOURNAL OF AIRPORT MANAGEMENT VOL. 11, NO. 2, 129–135 SPRING 2017 131
IP: 167.98.114.18 On: Thu, 24 Jan 2019 17:14:26
Copyright: Henry Stewart Publications
Petro
compared to the design and installation was utilised to clearly establish the area as
of the various infrastructural components a reserved area only. It was imperative that
that are required in a hard configura such signage include the required legal
tion. Third, the soft configuration allows language to facilitate efficient enforce-
for future f lexibility, should the need ment, such as ‘TOW AWAY ZONE’.
arise to either expand or reduce reserved The lack of this language would certainly
capacity. The ability to expand or reduce have a negative impact on enforceability
is important as a programme works and undermine the overall intent of the
to attain its operational and financial programme.
goals. Ultimately, this configuration was After both the location and configura-
chosen for the reserved parking pro- tion were determined, the third element
gramme at DEN. of the programme design then became
As with any component of air travel, staffing levels. As the configuration was
the demand for reserved parking f luctu- of the soft type, it was necessary to ensure
ates based upon the time of year, special that hands-on staffing met the demands
events and even the day of the week. The needed to provide directional assistance to
soft configuration has afforded the abil- traffic, as well as prevent unauthorised
ity to expand the reserved parking area vehicles from parking in the area. DEN’s
during peak travel times (or as often as parking contractor has utilised existing
needed and tolerated). Conversely, when field staff in order to accomplish this,
travel demand and volume is low, the with additional field agents assigned
ability to reduce reserved parking capac- during peak travel times.
ity has been advantageous as it allows for The role of field staff in monitoring
spaces that, if not converted to regular the reserved facility has included not only
parking spaces, would have sat vacant elements of enforcement and compliance,
and would therefore not take full finan- but arguably more important, the role of
cial advantage of existing parking real customer service. While it may initially
estate. In terms of commercial air travel, seem as though a reserved parking spot
this would be the equivalent of an airline may be an option that is typically utilised
having the ability to convert an economy by an experienced business traveller, quite
seat to a business class seat with relative the opposite became the case throughout
ease and as often as necessary when the various travel seasons. The reserved
demand is high for such services, as well parking programme has become quite
as the ability to convert the seat back to popular with the leisure traveller as well
an economy seat in order to generate as the business traveller; and these are,
revenue at a lower price point, rather in fact, very different customers with
than take to the skies empty. different needs.
The main infrastructural element of For example, at DEN, perhaps the
the soft configuration is the signage used most surprising customer to take advan-
to designate an area as a reserved parking tage of reserved parking has been the
area. Clear and concise signage is vital infrequent holiday traveller. Holiday
for the purposes of both directional travel periods are racked with aircraft
assistance as well as enforcement. It was filled to capacity, there are larger crowds
important that customers be able to locate and long security queues that are often
the designated reserved parking area perceived as endless. Holiday traveller
without difficulty. In addition, signage demographics quite often include a high
volume of customers who do not travel were expanded in the spring of 2015 to
frequently and may become easily over- over twice their original space alloca-
whelmed with even the thought of the tion, although the occupancy rate may
f lying experience as we know it today. be comparatively lower, the total number
It was unknown at the time the pro- of reservations for Thanksgiving were
gramme was established, just how popular more than double the previous year. It
a reserved parking programme would be became quickly obvious that reserved
for the holiday traveller at DEN. Would parking was a product enhancement that
the customer pay the additional reser- holiday travellers preferred in order to
vation fee, even though the reserved reduce their anxiety and to ensure that at
parking spaces were located within the least one portion of their trip went
parking garage structure, which is typi- smoothly.
cally wide open during the holidays from With such high occupancies during
an availability standpoint? The data sug- the holiday periods, the reserved park-
gest that not only was a reserved parking ing programme must be able to adapt
space attractive to the holiday traveller, (and at times adapt relatively quickly),
it was indeed at a premium. During the in order to meet the respective needs
week of the Thanksgiving holiday in of this demographic. Upon arrival at the
2014 (Table 1), the reserved parking area airport, these customers typically require
averaged an astonishing 153% occupancy additional assistance with such things as
rate (overfilled), while regular garage locating their desired ticket counter, the
parking averaged a 60% occupancy rate. closest security screening area or even
It was because of the f lexibility afforded the nearest restroom. Field personnel
by a soft configuration that the area overseeing compliance in a reserved
was quickly expanded to meet holiday parking area are also able to assist
customer demands. For the same holiday non-seasoned travellers with such issues
week in 2015 (Table 2), garage parking culminating in an improved experience
averaged a 68% occupancy rate, while for the customer as well as leaving them
reserved parking averaged an 84% occu- with a positive impression of the airport
pancy rate. The reserved parking areas parking operation.
Delivered by Ingenta
© HENRY STEWART PUBLICATIONS 1750-1938 JOURNAL OF AIRPORT MANAGEMENT VOL. 11, NO. 2, 129–135 SPRING 2017 133
IP: 167.98.114.18 On: Thu, 24 Jan 2019 17:14:26
Copyright: Henry Stewart Publications
Petro
Additionally, data indicate that cus- where they are statistically more likely
tomers who reserve a parking space also to spend money on dining and shopping
are not regular garage parking customers opportunities.
who decide to reserve a spot at the last A programme concept that was well
minute due to no availability in the garage thought out and developed was imper-
parking areas. In fact, there have been ative in order to maximise operational
many instances at DEN when the reserved and financial opportunities for future
parking area has been filled to capacity growth, while also maximising the value
while the surrounding garage has not. of all parking product offerings at DEN.
This typically occurs towards the middle A combination of location, configuration
of the week when business travel peaks and customer service has facilitated
(Tuesday through Thursday) (Table 3). greater passenger f low efficiencies while
Indeed, for the first two months of 2016, simultaneously improving non-airline
reserved parking at DEN was at an 86 per revenue. This has resulted in a programme
cent average occupancy rate during that allows for the continuing advance-
peak business travel days, while garage ment of customer service initiatives as
parking (again, located immediately well as overall strategic airport objectives.
adjacent to and surrounding the reserved
parking areas), was at a 79 per cent References
average occupancy rate. Such data suggest (1) J. D. Power (2015) ‘Improved airport
that the customer’s decision of whether experience drives increased traveler spending’,
to reserve a parking space was not based available at: http://www.jdpower.com/
press-releases/2015-north-america-airport-
on existing availability of general garage satisfaction-study (accessed 13th March, 2016).
parking. (2) Transportation Research Board, Federal
Aviation Administration (2009) Airport
Cooperative Research Program. Guidebook
CONCLUSION For Evaluating Airport Parking Strategies and
Supporting Technologies. National Academy
Airports today are faced with multiple of Sciences, Washington DC, p. 1, 43–44.
challenges as they seek to improve cus- (3) Leigh Fisher (2012) FOCUS. Leigh Fisher,
tomer f low efficiencies. The ability to San Francisco, p. 2, available at: http://
www.leighfisher.com/discover-whats-new/
move air travellers smoothly and quickly
publications/focus-role-airport-experience-
enables airports to maximise the time changing-global-economy (accessed
air travellers spend inside the airport 17th March, 2016).
Delivered by Ingenta
© HENRY STEWART PUBLICATIONS 1750-1938 JOURNAL OF AIRPORT MANAGEMENT VOL. 11, NO. 2, 129–135 SPRING 2017 135
IP: 167.98.114.18 On: Thu, 24 Jan 2019 17:14:26
Copyright: Henry Stewart Publications