Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
M.HENNEBERG
1. INTRODUCTION
159
P. Dasgupta and R. Hauspie (eds.), Perspectives in Human Growth, Development and Maturation, 159-167.
© 2001 Kluwer Academic Publishers.
160 CHAPTER 14
of changing specific elements of the environment while health policies may ensure
optimal conditions for child growth by setting standards for those specific elements
in addition to the obviously needed general socio-economic improvement.
Figure 1. Secular trends in body height of White and Black South African males and
Khoisan males. Data from Tobias (1975, 1985), Henneberg and van den Berg (1990) and
Louw and Henneberg (1997). Note that slopes of the regression lines do not differ
significantly
162 CHAPTER 14
All slopes were, however, significantly different from zero indicating positive,
but very slow increase of stature. During a comparable period, stature of Dutch
people, from whom the majority of South African Whites are descended, increased at
a rate of about 15 mm1decade (van Wieringen 1986).
It is interesting to note that adult South Australian Aborigines recently surveyed
by ourselves (Pretty et at. 1998) display lack of strong secular increase of stature
similar to oppressed South African Blacks (Figure 2). This occurs despite
documented substantial welfare provided to Aborigines by the government during the
second half of the 20th century. Among some Australian children of European
ancestry a secular increase comparable to those reported for Europe and the US has
been found (Loesch et at. 2000), but this acceleration of physical development did
not translate into substantial increases of adult stature. Data on adult statures of
Australians, though, are scarce. Stature of 5000 adult (18 - 65 years) females
surveyed in 1926 was 1611 mm (Lancaster 1957) while the stature of another 4327
women of comparable age surveyed in 1995 by the Australian Bureau of Statistics
(1995) was 1624 mm. This indicates a rate of about 2 mm/decade. A study of
Australian military men indicated the secular increase of stature at a rate of about 4
mm/decade (Soar 1999). These rates are similar to the weak increase found among
South Africans and to the increases among Aboriginal Australians. The socio-
economic history of Australia is similar to that of Europe and the United States, but
the increase in adult stature seems to be less pronounced.
1900
e-- Aborigines
1850 o Blacks o
o
1800 o
~
o
1750 o o
E
E o~
1700 o -u co
19
....
A
..<::
01)
0 &ctJ 0 i oD
'Q) o 0 I:lll DCO@
::r:: 1650 o 0 0
00
1600
1550
1500
1890 1910 1930 1950 1970 1990
Year
Figure 2. Comparison of secular trends in body height of South African Blacks (sample
means like in Fig. 1) and South Australian Aborigines (individual heights by birthdate
adjusted for loss of stature with age, own anthropometric observations, Pretty et at. 1998)
Soviet-style policies. Yet the secular trend in stature was strong, exceeding 10
mm/decade (Piontek 1971, Wolanski 1978, Bielicki and Welon 1982). Traditionally,
Polish medical students came from the upper socio-economic strata of the society. In
a sample of 300 students observed by ourselves in 1983 (Henneberg et al. 1985)
64% of parents had full university education. Similar situation obtained in the 1930
study of 153 medical students by Wrzosek (1931). This contrasts with about 5% of
university-educated individuals in the country. Post-war policies clearly favoured the
upliftment of people of lower socio-economic backgrounds at the expense of
economic well-being of the upper and middle classes. Despite this alteration of the
rate of change of socio-economic conditions for various socio-economic groups, the
rate of secular trend among the medical students (12 mm/decade) was the same as
among conscripts representing the total population (12 mm/decade) (Figure 3).
Portugal has been considered one of the least socio-economically developed
countries of Western Europe. Sobral (1990) presented data on body height changes in
four provinces of Portugal (1930-1980). For each province data were analysed
separately for rural and for urban conscripts. In all provinces, and at all dates
examined, rural people were shorter than their urban counterparts, yet in all cases
trends had similar rates of about 10 mm/decade (Figure 4). Parallelism, once again,
though socio-economic conditions and their temporal changes different from those of
Poland.
1900
S 1750
S
.._r 1700
,..t:i
b/)
.(j)
::r:: 1650
1600
1550
1500
1910 1930 1950 1970 1990
Year
Figure 3. Secular trends of body height in Polish males. High socia-economic status is
represented by medical students, data from Henneberg and van den Berg (1990).
164 CHAPTER 14
1700
e-- Setubal, urban
1690 .• _.& .. - Setubal, rural
e-- Beja, urban
1680
- - - - E}- - - - Beja, rural
1620
1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980
Year
3. DISCUSSION
The positive secular trend of stature was still going strong in the 1970's and 1980's
in some economically advanced countries, while it has apparently halted in others
(Roche 1979, Malina 1990). Were it true that secular trend is a result of consecutive
generations reaching increasingly greater proportions of their ideal "genetic
potential", privileged groups in various societies would have to halt their trends
SECULAR TRENDS INDICATE SPECIFIC FACTORS 165
earlier than underprivileged ones, who should continue until they "caught up" with
their wealthier compatriots. This certainly was not the case neither in South Africa
nor in Poland. Moreover, the greatest differences in stature between the poorest and
the richest segments of same national populations do not exceed one standard
deviation, i.e. about 60 - 70 mm (Bielicki and Welon 1982, Rosenbaum et al. 1985,
Henneberg and Louw, 1998), while positive secular trends, where they occurred
strongly, shifted stature by as much as 120 - 200 mm (van Wieringen 1986,
Spurgeon et al. 1994). This, coupled with high heritability of the variation in
stature, argues strongly against secular trends being a simple ecosensitive response
to improving general living conditions. In addition, the magnitude of secular trends
in populations experiencing similar changes in socio-economic status varies
considerably from 2 - 6 mm per decade among Australians and South African Whites
to 10 - 15 mm among Europeans.
Secular trends must be caused by specific factors varying from population to
population rather than by the general improvement in living conditions. General
socio-economic improvement may play some role, but it can hardly cause changes
exceeding 70 mm. We cannot yet name specific factors causing greater increases in
height, but certain criteria that they must meet can be specified. This may help to
direct our search for specific factors. Since statural increases in some instances exceed
the range of ecosensitivity, the causative factor must either affect genes determining
stature, or act as a substitute for one of the relevant gene products. If the second is
true then this factor must act early in ontogeny, sometime during the foetal period,
infancy or early childhood, as these are the periods in which most of the body size
determination seems to occur (Bogin 1988, Proos 1993, Delemarrevandewaal 1993,
Henneberg and Louw 1990, 1993). These criteria are met by changing exposure to
pathogens, natural or contained in vaccines, which produce immune responses that
may be biochemically linked to determinants of stature, and by foods which contain
chemical substances influencing regulators of growth. For instance, beef and poultry
may contain additional animal growth hormones used to obtain higher yield on
commercial farms (Moishezon-Blank 1991). Ingestion of dairy products containing
similar natural or artificial compounds is another possibility. Bigger is not always
better, and continued secular increases of body height may be manifestations of the
introduction of undesirable substances into human bodies.
Henneberg, M., 1999, Variation in hominid body size: Do we know how big our ancestors were?
Perspectives in Human Biology, 4, 65-81.
Dettwyler, K.A., 1992, Nutritional status of adults in rural Mali, American Journal of Physical
Anthropology, 88, 309-321.
Eiben, O.G., 1996, Selected data on growth and physical fitness of healthy Hungarian boys and girls in
our changing world, Collegium Anthropologicum, 20, 73-81.
Falconer, D.S., 1980, Introduction to Quantitative Genetics (Edinburgh: Oliver and Boyd).
Frayer, D., 1984, Biological and cultural change in the European Late Pleistocene and Early Holocene.
In The Origins of Modem Humans: A World Survey of the Fossil Evidence edited by F.H. Smith
and F Spencer (New York: Alan R Liss), pp 211-250.
Gerver, W.J.M., Debruin, R, and Drayer, N.M., 1994, A persisting secular trend for body
measurements in Dutch children - The Oosterwolde II study, Acta Paediatrica, 83, 812-814.
Gutierrez-Muniz, J.A., Berdasco-Gomez, A., Esquivel-Lauzurique, M., Jimenez-Hernandez, J.M.,
Mesa-Payan, D., Posada-Lima, E., Romero-Del-Sol, J.M., Quesdada, M.R., and Silva-Ayzaguer,
L.C., 1994, The 1982 Cuban national growth and development study: Secular changes in weigbt and
height, Acta Medica Auxologica, 25, 115-127.
Hauspie, R.C., Vercauteren, M., and Susanne. C .. , 1996, Secular changes in growth, Hormone
Research, 45: (Suppl. 2), 8-17.
Hauspie, R.C., Vercauteren, M., and Susanne, C., 1997, Secular changes in growth and maturation: an
update, Acta Paediatrica, Supplement, 423, 20-27
Henneberg, M., 1976, Reproductive possibilities and estimations of the biological dynamics of earlier
human populations, Journal of Human Evolution, 5,41-48
Henneberg, M., 1988, Decrease of human skull size in the Holocene, Human Biology 60, 395-405.
Henneberg, M., 1992, Continuing human evolution: brains, bodies, and the role of variability,
Transactions of the Royal Society of South Africa 48, 159-182.
Henneberg, M., Budnik, A., Pezacka, M., and Puch, A.E., 1985, Head size, body size, and intelligence:
intraspecific correlations in Homo sapiens sapiens. Homo, 36, 207-218.
Henneberg, M., and Louw, GJ., 1990, Height and weight differences among South African Urban
schoolchildren born in various months of the year, American Journal of Human Biology, 2, 227-233
Henneberg, M., and Louw, G.J., 1993, Further studies on the month-of-birth effect on body size: Rural
schoolchildren and an animal model, American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 91, 235-244.
Henneberg, M., and Louw, GJ., 1998, Cross-sectional survey of growth of urban and rural "Cape
Coloured" schoolchildren: Anthropometry and functional tests. American Journal of Human
Biology, 10, 73-85.
Henneberg, M., and Steyn, M., 1993, Trends in cranial capacity and cranial index in Subsaharan Africa
during the Holocene, American Journal of Human Biology, 5,473-47.
Henneberg, M, van den Berg, E.R, 1990, Test of socioeconomic causation of secular trend: Stature
change among favored and oppressed South Africans are parallel, American Journal of Physical
Anthropology, 83, 459-465.
Huang, Y.C., and Malina, R.M., 1995, Secular changes in the stature and weight of Taiwanese children,
American Journal of Human Biology, 7,485-496.
Jacobs, K.H., 1985, Climate and the hominid postcranial skeleton in Wilrm and early Holocene Europe.
Current Anthropology, 26, 512-514.
Jamison, P.L., 1990, Secular trends and the pattern of growth in arctic populations, Soc. Sci. Med., 30,
751-759.
Kimura, K., 1967, A consideration of the secular trend in Japanese for height and weight by a graphic
method, American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 27, 89-94.
Lancaster, H.O., 1957, Some anthropometrical values of women in Australia, Medical Journal of
Australia (December 1957), 897-900
Leatherman, T.L., Carey, J.W., Thomas, RB., 1995, Socioeconomic change and patterns of growth in
the Andes, American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 97, 307-321.
Loesch, D.Z., Stokes, K., and Huggins, RM., 2000, Secular trend in body height and weight of
Australian children and adolescents, American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 111,545-556.
Louw, GJ., and Henneberg, M., 1997, Lack of a secular trend in adult stature in South African males
born between 1954 and 1974, Homo, 47,54-61.
Malina, R.M., 1990, Research on secular trends in auxology, Anthropologisher Anzeiger, 48, 209-227.
Mathers, K., and Henneberg, M., 1995, Were we ever that big? Gradual increase in hominid body size
over time, Homo, 46, 141-173.
Moishezon-Blank, N., 1991, Commentary of the possible effect of hormones in food on human growth.
Medical Hypotheses, 38, 273-277.
SECULAR TRENDS INDICATE SPECIFIC FACTORS 167
Mueller, W.H., 1976, Parent-child correlations for stature and weight among school aged children: A
review of24 studies. Human Biology, 48, 379-397.
Oyedeji, G.A., Olamilulo, S.K., Osinaike, A.I., Esimai, V.c., Odunusi, E.O., and Aladekomo, T.A.,
1996, Secular trends in the growth of children aged 0-6 years in a rural Nigerian community,
Annals of Tropical Paediatrics, 16, 11-17.
Pretty, G.L., Henneberg, M., Lambert, K.M., and Pro kopec, M., 1998, Trends in stature in the South
Australian Aboriginal Murraylands, American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 106,505-514.
Piontek, J., 1971, Ocena stanu rozwoju fizycznego poborowych powiat6w Inowroclaw i Tuchola
urodzonych w drugiej poTIowie XIX wieku w por6wnaniu z wsp61czesnll mlodzieza Pomorza i
Kujaw, In Rozw6j i Dorobek Antropologii Polskiej w 25-leciu PRL. Poznaj: UAM, pp 71-75.
Prince, J.M., 1995, Intersection of economics, history and human biology - Secular trends in stature in
nineteenth-century Sioux Indians, Human Biology, 67, 387-406
Prokopec, M., 1984, Secular trends in body size and proportions, and their biological meaning. Studies
in Human Ecology, 6, 37-61
Proos, L.A., 1993, Anthropometry in adolescence - Secular trends, adoption, ethnic and environmental
differences, Hormone Research, 39, 18-24
Rao, K.V., Balakrishna, N., and Shatrugna, V., 1993, Secular trends in height of well-to-do adults and
the associated factors, Man in India, 73, 267-273
Roberts, D.F., 1994, Secular trends in growth and maturation in British girls, American Journal of
Human Biology, 6,13-18
Roche, A.F., 1979, Secular trends in stature, weight and maturation, Monographs of the Society for
Research in Child Development, 44, 2-27
Roberts, D.F., Billewicz, W.Z., and McGregor, LA., 1978, Heritability of stature in a West African
population, Annals of Human Genetics, 42, 15-24
Rosenbaum, S., Skiner, R.K., Knight, LB., and Garrow J.S., 1985, A survey of heights and weights of
adults in Great Britain, 1980. Annals of Human Biology, 12, 115-127
Soar, N., 1999, An examination of the secular trend in Australian male stature as seen in the military
data, Perspectives in Human Biology, 4, 157-166.
Sobral, F., 1990, Secular changes in stature in southern Portugal between 1930 and 1980 according to
conscript data, Human Biology, 62, 491-504
Spurgeon, lH., French, K.E., Giese, W.K., Steele, M.F., Utenko, V.N., Bundzen, P.V., and Rogozkin,
V.A., 1994, Somatic comparisons of urban and rural Russian boys ages 6, 9, and 15 years, living in
St Petersburg and surrounding areas, American Journal of Human Biology, 6,141-151
Susanne, C .. , 1971, Recherche sur la transmission des caracteres mesurables de ('homme, Societe
Royale des Sciences Naturelles de la Belgique: Brussels
Styne, D.M., and McHenry, H., 1993, The evolution of stature in humans, Hormone Research,
39(Suppl. 3), 3-6
Tobias, P.V., 1975, Stature and secular trend among Southern African Negroes and San (Bushmen),
South African Journal of Medical Science 40, 145-164
Tobias, P.V., 1985, The negative secular trend, Journal of Human Evolution, 14,347-356
Tobias, P.V., 1990, Adult stature in southern African Negroes - further evidence on the absence of a
positive secular trend, South African Medical Journal, 78, 97-101
Ulijaszek, S.J., 1993, Evidence for a secular trend in heights and weights of adults in Papua-New
Guinea, Annals of Human Biology, 20, 349-355
van Wieringen, lV., 1986, Secular growth changes. In Human Growth. Vol 3 Methodology Ecological
Genetic and Nutritional Effects on Growth edited by F. Falkner and lM. Tanner (New York:
Plenum Press), pp. 307-331
Weber, G., Seidler, H., Wilfing, H., and Hauser, G., 1995, Secular change in height in Austria - an
effect of population stratification, Annals of Human Biology, 22, 277-288
Wolanski, N., 1978, Secular trend in man: Evidence and factors. Collegium Anthropologicum, 2, 69-86
Wrzosek, A., 1931, 0 stosun~u niekt6rych pomiar6w antropologicznych i typ6w rasowych
morfologicznych do sprawnoEci umyslowej. Przeglad Antropologiczny, 5, 1-16.