Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Development
[Constituent of SYMBIOSIS INTERNATIONAL (DEEMED
UNIVERSITY), SI (DU)] (Established u/s 3 of the UGC Act 1956, by
notification No.F.9-12/2001 – U.3 of the Government of India)
Project II
By
Prasad Joshi
(Roll No. 2016 G 14)
This is to certify that the project work entitled “Investment in Mutual Funds (ELSS Vs
Others) - Comparative study”, is a bonafide work carried out by Mr. Prasad Joshi, a student
of Executive MBA (2016-19) at SCMHRD, is an authentic work which is carried out by him
To the best of my knowledge, the matter embodied in the project has not been submitted to
any other University / Institute for the award of any Degree or Diploma.
Date:
SCMHRD
2
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I take this opportunity to express my gratitude to all of them who in some or other way have
SCMHRD for his valuable guidance and support of this project. I am very thankful to my
friends and colleagues for providing their valuable feedback on the survey.
I also acknowledge with a deep sense of reverence, my gratitude towards my parents, wife
and my kids who have always supported me and sacrifice family time.
At last but not least gratitude goes to all of my friends who directly or indirectly helped me to
3
Table of Contents
Introduction: ............................................................................................................................... 5
References:............................................................................................................................................ 20
4
Investment in Mutual Funds (ELSS Vs
Others) – Comparative study
Introduction:
In India, there are various investment options available for general investors. Some people
who are risk averse they will invest into public provident fund or government bonds like
National Saving Certificates, Kisan Vikas Patra. Some people invest into bank fixed deposit
or recurring deposits. These assets are considered to be a risk free assets and return received
from these assets is considered to be risk free return. Some people can also invest into
immovable assets like land, house, shops, etc. Generally people invest in this category of
asset for a long term investments. They can also invest into assets like gold, silver like
Precious metals.
Other form of investment is investing into bond and share / Stock market. Bond is basically
instrument issues by company to raise its capital. This is debt fund in which company agrees
to pay fixed interest every specific period (generally every year). Investment in share market
is basically investing into actual company and becoming the shareholder of the company.
These investment options are involved with certain amount of risk. This is due to the fact that
return on the investment is depends on the company’s performance. Investor always expects
that the return received from these assets is always greater than risk free return. Investors are
Hence if there is more risk involved the expectation from the investor is more for getting
higher risk premium. But if the investor invests into multiple stocks to diversify his
investment then depending on the level of diversification, he may reduce the risk associated
5
with the investment but he may get higher returns. To achieve this investor need to study the
company performance of all the stocks in detail. He also needs to select the various sectors to
avoid the impact of one sector on to his investment. Doing this activity is most of the time not
feasible for common investor. He needs to spend time and gain knowledge of various facets
of finance and economics. This need of the investor is satisfied by mutual fund companies.
holdings and is professionally managed. So by definition all the activities common investor
need to do to diversify his portfolio to minimize the risk and gaining maximum profit, will be
done by the mutual fund companies. They are the professional experts and can manage the
Government to influence investing behaviour of the people promotes the investment into
mutual funds by their policies with respect to income tax. Due to these mutual funds general
public can get the benefit of the market return with minimum risk. So Indian Government as
part of Income tax section 80C provides the tax rebate, if the investor has invested the
amount into mutual funds. Government also make sure through its policy that the investor is
investing long term into such funds. This is done using lock-in period of 3 years. i.e. any
investor invest to gain the benefits of Income tax sec. 80c then he will not be able to
withdraw his money from these funds for 3 years. For better tracking and validating these
policies and rules mutual fund companies maintain separate fund named equity linked saving
Instead of investing into ELSS funds if investor invested into any other market liked fund
then they get advantage of withdrawing money anytime. But as the government gives the tax
rebate for the ELSS mutual fund schemes; it is important to study that, is consumer actually
getting benefit from such saving with losing the withdrawal rights for 3 years. Instead of
investing into ELSS mutual fund schemes if investor has invested into funds which are linked
6
to index (like Sensex or Nifty) i.e. index funds or invested into any other fund available in the
So it is important to study the comparative analysis of ELSS mutual fund schemes including
tax benefits with any other available fund. Is tax rebate given by government is beneficial for
the investor or there is no significant different with respect to returns of ELSS and any other
Problem Description:
Indian government is providing the tax benefit under section 80c to investor of ELSS
mutual fund schemes to promote the investment into equity market. But from
in equity market then is he getting better benefits in terms of the risk he is taking. So there is
need for common man (who is not aware much details about the equity market) to provide the
guidance for the investment in appropriate mutual fund scheme to maximize the profit. This
7
Literature Review:
There are various studies happened time to time on the comparative analysis of the
mutual fund schemes return and performance. These studies mainly focus on identifying the
mutual fund schemes which is top performing. Below is a review of some of the studies.
Gupta (2001) performed the comparative analysis of 73 mutual funds schemes which are
having various investment objectives from the period April 1994 to March 1999. Result of
the study gives that these schemes were not diversified properly and are not meeting their
investment objectives.
Study done by Ravinderan and Narayan (2003) also conclude that schemes are not generating
expected returns and not well diversified, this study was based on 269 open ended schemes
Elango (2004) did the empirical study on public sector and private sector mutual fund
schemes. The result says that private sector mutual fund schemes are giving higher return
Study done by Sondhi and Jain (2004) with the help of 26 mutual fund schemes gives the
result that Pubilc sector mutual fund schemes are giving the return lesser than treasury bills
but private sector mutual fund schemes are giving better results. Study performed by Guha
(2008) as well as Phaniswara and Rao (2008) says that most of the mutual fund schemes
having a mismatch of risk they possess and return and those are failing to give the better
results.
All these various studies were focusing on the overall aspect of the risk and associated return
for the mutual fund schemes. Some studies were also focusing on comparative analysis
between private and public sector mutual fund companies. But there is a limited study on the
8
comparative analysis between ELSS mutual funds and other type of mutual fund schemes. So
there is a research gap to study the comparative analysis between these two segments.
So as part of this research we are focusing on the performance return with respect to ELSS
mutual fund schemes. But from Investor perspective, performance of ELSS mutual fund
should include the tax benefit. Hence while comparing the returns we have three different
returns for ELSS mutual fund schemes, i.e. 10% tax, 20% tax and 30% tax.
So below are the hypotheses for comparison between ELSS and index mutual funds -
H10: There is no significant difference with respect to return of ELSS mutual fund schemes
H20: There is no significant difference with respect to return of ELSS mutual fund schemes
H30: There is no significant difference with respect to return of ELSS mutual fund schemes
Similarly as part of this research it is better to compare the returns of ELSS mutual fund
So below are the hypotheses for comparison between ELSS and diversified mutual funds -
H40: There is no significant difference with respect to return of ELSS mutual fund schemes
H50: There is no significant difference with respect to return of ELSS mutual fund schemes
H60: There is no significant difference with respect to return of ELSS mutual fund schemes
9
Research Methodology:
ELSS mutual funds schemes with Index mutual fund schemes and any other non-ELSS
mutual fund schemes. This research aimed to identify that tax benefits given by government
in ELSS mutual fund schemes is significantly more than the monetary benefits consumers’
getting by investing into other mutual funds schemes. This research is based on the secondary
data collection for the NAV of the various mutual fund schemes.
As part of this research five ELSS mutual fund schemes are selected which are having
highest return in last 3 to 5 years. These mutual fund schemes are also given a top ranking by
CRISIL India. For Index mutual fund schemes same process has been followed, i.e. Five
Index mutual fund schemes which are having highest return in last 3 to 5 years and top
ranked by CRISIL India are selected for the research. Similarly there are other mutual fund
schemes which are having highest returns selected and top ranked by CRISIL India for this
research. So in total eighteen mutual fund schemes are selected for this research.
For these eighteen mutual fund schemes, daily NAV data is collected for the period 02 Jan
2013 to 02 Mar 2017. Using these daily NAV, daily return % is computed for all these
mutual fund schemes. To avoid the impact on any specific day higher or lower return,
average of the daily return is taken for the further study. From a single investor perspective
we can calculate the return by considering the difference between NAV during the investing
and NAV during sale. But if we want to study the overall return of the mutual fund schemes
irrespective of the entry and exit for the investment then the method of daily return average is
helpful.
Using the daily average present researcher computed the yearly return % for these mutual
10
(yearly working days)
Yearly % Return = ((1+ Daily % Average return) )-1
In a year there are 246 working days for equity market. Hence in above formula Yearly
working days are considered to be 246 days. As the ELSS mutual fund schemes are having
three years locking period hence it is must to compare the returns for three years instead of
one year. Hence using the yearly % returns three years % return is computed by multiplying
the yearly return by three. As part of section 80c there is tax rebate for one lakh fifty
thousand. So as part of this study we are considering if investor invested one lakh in these
mutual fund schemes then what will be his return after three years. This computed return
investors are going to receive after three years so it is important to know what the todays
discounted value for this return. In India in general risk free return is around 8%. So we
discounted the return with 8% return. The tax benefit investors are receiving in case of ELSS
mutual fund schemes will be received at the end of investing year. This benefit will be either
10% or 20% or 30% depending on the earning of the investor (if investor’s taxable income is
between 10% tax bracket then investor will get 10% tax rebate and so on.). So we discounted
this tax benefit by 8% risk free return to get the tax benefit. In case of ELSS, this discounted
tax benefit has been added to the discounted return computed above. For all other mutual
fund schemes the discounted return remains same. These final returns of these mutual fund
schemes are further used for the comparative analysis and arrive at the result.
11
Analysis and Results:
Below are the selected mutual fund schemes along with their daily, yearly and 3 yearly %
returns.
12
Below are the discounted returns for the same selected mutual fund schemes along with
addition of discounted tax benefit, if investor has invested one lakh for three years.
Scheme 10 % 20 % 30 %
Category Code 10% Tax 20 % Tax 30 % Tax return return return
ELSS 119544 ₹ 1,37,404.62 ₹ 1,46,663.88 ₹ 1,55,923.14 37.4% 46.7% 55.9%
ELSS 104772 ₹ 1,36,350.10 ₹ 1,45,609.36 ₹ 1,54,862.62 36.4% 45.6% 54.9%
ELSS 104331 ₹ 1,33,036.61 ₹ 1,42,295.87 ₹ 1,51,555.13 33.0% 42.3% 51.6%
ELSS 118047 ₹ 1,30,412.07 ₹ 1,39,671.33 ₹ 1,48,930.58 30.4% 39.7% 48.9%
ELSS 103339 ₹ 1,26,190.02 ₹ 1,35,449.28 ₹ 1,44,708.54 26.2% 35.5% 44.7%
Index 112351 ₹ 1,05,355.25 ₹ 1,05,355.25 ₹ 1,05,355.25 5.4% 5.4% 5.4%
Index 123651 ₹ 1,27,387.75 ₹ 1,27,387.75 ₹ 1,27,387.75 27.4% 27.4% 27.4%
Index 100822 ₹ 1,07,556.41 ₹ 1,07,556.41 ₹ 1,07,556.41 7.6% 7.6% 7.6%
Index 113063 ₹ 1,05,375.72 ₹ 1,05,375.72 ₹ 1,05,375.72 5.4% 5.4% 5.4%
Index 112877 ₹ 1,08,172.40 ₹ 1,08,172.40 ₹ 1,08,172.40 8.2% 8.2% 8.2%
Mixed 100349 ₹ 1,19,615.01 ₹ 1,19,615.01 ₹ 1,19,615.01 19.6% 19.6% 19.6%
Mixed 112090 ₹ 1,27,328.69 ₹ 1,27,328.69 ₹ 1,27,328.69 27.3% 27.3% 27.3%
Mixed 103504 ₹ 1,22,374.48 ₹ 1,22,374.48 ₹ 1,22,374.48 22.4% 22.4% 22.4%
Mixed 103166 ₹ 1,31,105.99 ₹ 1,31,105.99 ₹ 1,31,105.99 31.1% 31.1% 31.1%
Mixed 111381 ₹ 1,40,729.63 ₹ 1,40,729.63 ₹ 1,40,729.63 40.7% 40.7% 40.7%
Mixed 103490 ₹ 1,20,052.94 ₹ 1,20,052.94 ₹ 1,20,052.94 20.1% 20.1% 20.1%
Mixed 102142 ₹ 1,26,579.48 ₹ 1,26,579.48 ₹ 1,26,579.48 26.6% 26.6% 26.6%
Mixed 101672 ₹ 1,32,403.88 ₹ 1,32,403.88 ₹ 1,32,403.88 32.4% 32.4% 32.4%
Graph 1: Shows the comparison between the return for ELSS and index fund for 10%, 20%
and 30% tax benefit.
60.00%
50.00%
40.00%
30.00%
Average of 10 % return
0.00%
103339
104331
104772
118047
119544
100822
112351
112877
113063
123651
ELSS Index
13
Graph 2: shows the comparison between the return for ELSS and diversified (mixed) fund
for 10%, 20% and 30% tax benefit.
60.00%
50.00%
40.00%
30.00%
Average of 10 % return
0.00%
103339
104331
104772
118047
119544
100349
101672
102142
103166
103490
103504
111381
112090
ELSS Mixed
Graph 3: shows the comparison between the return for ELSS and index and diversified
(mixed) mutual fund schemes for 10% tax benefit.
10 % Tax Benefit
45.00%
40.73%
40.00%
35.66% 36.72%
35.00% 32.35% 32.40%
31.11%
29.73%
30.00% 27.39% 26.58% 27.33%
25.50%
25.00% 22.37%
19.62% 20.05%
20.00%
15.00%
0.00%
118047
100822
103339
104331
104772
119544
112351
112877
113063
123651
100349
101672
102142
103166
103490
103504
111381
112090
Total
14
Graph 4: shows the comparison between the return for ELSS and index fund for 10%, 20%
and 30% tax benefit.
30 % Tax Benefit
60.00%
52.81% 53.87%
49.50%
50.00% 46.87%
42.65%
40.73%
40.00%
32.40% 31.11%
30.00% 26.58% 27.33%
22.37%
19.62% 20.05%
20.00%
10.00%
0.00%
103490
103339
104331
104772
118047
119544
100349
101672
102142
103166
103504
111381
112090
ELSS Mixed
Total
1) ELSS mutual fund schemes return with 10% tax benefit and Index mutual fund
schemes returns
Group Statistics
F Sig. T Df
15
Independent Samples Test
2) ELSS mutual fund schemes return with 10% tax benefit and diversified (mixed)
mutual fund schemes
Group Statistics
F Sig. t Df
16
3) ELSS mutual fund schemes return with 20% tax benefit and diversified (mixed)
mutual fund schemes
Group Statistics
F Sig. t df
4) ELSS mutual fund schemes return with 30% tax benefit and diversified (mixed)
mutual fund schemes
Group Statistics
17
Independent Samples Test
F Sig. t df
So as per above result we reject the hypothesis H10, H20 and H30 and there is a significant
difference between ELSS mutual fund schemes and index mutual fund schemes.
With respect to comparison of diversified mutual funds and ELSS schemes results, we failed
to reject hypothesis H50 but we reject hypothesis H60 & H70. There is a no significant
difference between ELSS mutual fund schemes with 10% tax benefit and diversified mutual
fund schemes but there is significant difference between ELSS mutual fund schemes with
20% & 30% tax benefit and diversified mutual fund schemes.
From the above comparative results and independent sample T test results, index
funds are not giving the expected returns. ELSS funds are giving good returns (32.68%) with
10% Tab benefit compare to Index funds returns (10.77%). So people should not invest into
Index mutual fund schemes unless they want to avoid all the unsystematic risk (Risk
18
associated with the complete market is considered to be systematic risk and it is unavoidable
risk, risk due to less diversification and too much aggressiveness is considered to be
From the result, we also conclude that ELSS mutual fund schemes returns for the 10%
tax benefit (32.68%) are lesser than the returns of diversified (mixed) mutual fund schemes
(27.52%) but those are not having significant difference. So investors’ having tax bracket of
10% can invest in either ELSS or diversified (mixed) mutual fund schemes, there is no
significant difference but considering the locking period for ELSS mutual fund schemes he
From the result, we conclude that ELSS mutual fund schemes returns for the 20% tax
benefit (41.94%) are having better results than diversified (mixed) mutual fund schemes
(27.52%) and those are significantly more. So investors’ having tax bracket of 20% should
invest into ELSS mutual fund schemes than diversified (mixed) mutual fund schemes
From the result, we also conclude that ELSS mutual fund schemes returns for the 30%
tax benefit (51.20%) are significantly higher than the returns with respect to diversified
(mixed) mutual fund schemes (27.52%). So investors’ having tax bracket of 30% should
invest into ELSS mutual fund schemes instead of diversified (mixed) mutual fund schemes.
invest in ELSS mutual fund schemes else he may invest in diversified (mixed) mutual fund
schemes. He should only invest in Index mutual fund schemes if he does not want to have
19
Limitations and Future Research:
This research was focusing only on the return aspect of the mutual fund schemes. Any
other factor consumers’ perceived is not considered as part of this research. Along with return
% of risk factor can be considered as part of future research. This research was focusing only
on 18 mutual fund schemes. Further study can be done by considering large no of mutual
fund schemes. The research is based on the past 4 years data, the result may change in future
if there are changes in the market dynamics. This research need to carry out time to time for
better judgement.
References:
- Elango, R. (2004). Which fund yields more returns?. The Management
- Guha, S. (2008). Performance of Indian equity mutual fund and their style
- Sodhi, H. J., & Jain, P. K. (2004). Financial performance of equity mutual funds:
https://www.amfiindia.com/nav-history-download
20