Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
To cite this article: Chenglong Lian, Kwang-Hee Lee & Chul-Hee Lee (2017): Effect of
Temperature and Relative Humidity on Friction and Wear Properties of Silicone-Based
Magnetorheological Elastomer, Tribology Transactions, DOI: 10.1080/10402004.2017.1306636
Article views: 7
Download by: [Eastern Michigan University] Date: 02 May 2017, At: 19:01
TRIBOLOGY TRANSACTIONS
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/10402004.2017.1306636
Introduction
devices. The friction and wear properties of elastomers in various
Magnetorheological (MR) materials are “smart” materials with mechanical devices were widely examined by previous studies
rheological properties that can be changed rapidly and revers- (Shen, et al. (10); Maegawa, et al. (11). The MR elastomer is a smart
ibly by applying a magnetic field. This effect is known as the elastomer with a friction coefficient that can be controlled by exter-
MR effect, and it was discovered in 1948 (Levin, et al. (1). nal magnetic fields by means of changing the hardness of the MR
Mechanical properties (e.g., shear modulus, elastic modulus, elastomer (Lee, et al. (12); Lian, et al. (13), (14). Lee, et al. (12) stud-
and hardness) of MR elastomers can be controlled by means of ied the tribological characteristics of MR elastomers and friction
an external magnetic field (Levin, et al. (1); Ginder, et al. (2). and wear characteristics of MR elastomers based on a silicone/poly-
When compared with MR fluids, MR elastomers have the urethane hybrid. Additionally, the friction and wear characteristics
advantage of preventing the settling of carbonyl iron (CI) par- of MR elastomers under vibration conditions were studied by
ticles over time. Additionally, MR elastomers do not require extant studies in 2016 (Lian, et al. (14).
containers to hold them in place because they are solid. Fur- Moreover, MR elastomers were also investigated for use in
thermore, the response time of MR elastomers is very short various equipment. Specifically, MR elastomers are also used in
(Levin, et al. (1); Ginder, et al. (2). Thus, MR elastomers possess various external environments at different temperatures and
immense research potential due to the aforementioned proper- relative humidities. Temperature and relative humidity exert a
ties. Several studies examined MR elastomers to control vibra- significant effect on the friction and wear properties because
tion issues or as sensors in mechanical systems (Watson (3); MR elastomers possess a relatively weak resistance to changes
Chen, et al. (4); Liao, et al. (5); Li, et al. (6); B€
ose, et al. (7); Jung, in the environment (Hiratsuka and Hosotani (15). However,
et al. (8). For example, researchers at the Ford Research Labora- there is a paucity of studies examining the friction and wear
tory developed variable-stiffness suspension bushings using an properties of MR elastomers under different temperature and
MR elastomer (Watson (3). Chen, et al. (4) investigated MR humidity conditions. Hence, it is necessary to confirm the
elastomers based on natural rubber. Liao, et al. (5) developed aforementioned properties under various external conditions
an active damping–compensated MR elastomer adaptive tuned in the interest of future studies on MR elastomers.
vibration absorber. Li, et al. (6) developed a force sensor that The present study involved investigating the effects of the
used MR elastomers. B€ ose, et al. (7) and Jung, et al. (8) studied temperature and relative humidity on the friction and wear
soft MR elastomers as new actuators for valves. properties of a silicone-based isotropic MR elastomer. A recip-
Elastomers were studied widely for applications in various rocating friction tester was set up to conduct the experiment.
mechanical engineering devices due to prominent damping, seal- The friction coefficient was measured to determine friction
ing, and other abilities (Dirisamer, et al. (9); Shen, et al. (10). Fric- properties under different temperatures and relative humidity
tion and wear exist at all contact interfaces of a device, and this is conditions. The wear depths were then measured, and surface
important for the availability factor, performance, and durability of state profiles were observed to evaluate the wear properties.
Experimental specimens mixed MR elastomer was hardened for 2 h at 150 C and then
cooled at room temperature.
Silicone was used as the substrate for the MR elastomers in the
A sealed temperature- and humidity-adjustable reciprocat-
present study because silicone-based MR elastomers possess an
ing tribology tester was employed to perform the tests related
optimal MR effect and are widely applied in various medical
to the friction and wear properties of the MR elastomer under
and mechanical applications for their stable and nontoxic prop-
various temperatures and relative humidities because recipro-
erties (Levin, et al. (1); Ginder, et al. (2); Jung, et al. (8); Lian,
cating friction often appears in actual situations. Figures 2a and
et al. (14). Figures 1a and 1b show the pin and MR elastomer
2b show a schematic diagram and a photograph of the recipro-
specimens. The pin was designed as a ball with a 10-mm diam-
cating friction tester, respectively. The tester included the MR
eter at the bottom of the aluminum pin (Fig. 1b) to prevent
elastomer, an aluminum pin, a heating pad, an electromagnet,
extreme tearing on the contact surface between the pin and MR
a laser displacement sensor, an indicator, a motor, a personal
elastomer. The thickness of the specimen of the MR elastomer
computer, a power supply, and a load cell. The heating pad was
was set as 10 mm by considering its MR effect and hardness.
used to adjust the applied temperatures. A humidifier and
The shape of the MR elastomer was designed as a cuboid.
dehumidifier were used to control the relative humidity. A con-
The average size of the interior CI particles approximately cor-
tactless temperature and humidity sensor was used to monitor
responded to 10 mm, and their proportion by weight corre-
the environmental conditions during the tests.
sponded to 80 § 2.0%. Extant research confirmed that the level
The pin was in direct contact with the surface of the MR
of CI particle content produced an optimal MR effect through
elastomer that was located on the heating pad. The electromag-
many tests (Lee, et al. (12); Lian, et al. (14). The fabrication pro-
net was placed below the heating pad to directly apply a mag-
cess of the MR elastomers was mainly divided into mixing, vac-
netic field to the MR elastomer. The pin was connected to a
uum treatment, hardening, and cooling. A silicone gel is
horizontal load cell that was connected to a horizontal motor
composed using a hydrosilylation reaction of a;x-vinyl polydi-
to produce a reciprocating movement. The sliding stroke corre-
methylsiloxane and a;x-hydrido polydimethylsiloxane. Five dif-
sponded to 20 mm with a frequency of 0.5 Hz, which resulted
ferent macromolecules (high polymers) of different viscosities
in a velocity of 10 mm/s. The load was set as approximately
and Fe, Ni, and Co powder are filled with the influence of mag-
2 N because the MR elastomer surface was unable to bear a
netic polarity. As a catalyst, a coordinate number 6 of platinic
high load and high heat. The friction distance was set as
acid and divinyl tetramethyl disiloxane synthesis is added and
1,800 mm, and a magnetic field strength of 80 mT was applied.
adjusted to the proper Pt content. The air bubbles in the MR
The horizontal load cell was used to measure the horizontal
elastomer were eliminated to the maximum possible extent
force (i.e., frictional force) in real time. The friction coefficient
prior to hardening, and a vacuum air pump was used to lower
was then calculated and transferred to a personal computer. A
unnecessary impacts on the friction and wear results. The
laser displacement sensor was used to measure the wear depth.
The first stage involved measuring and discussing the effect
on friction and wear properties of the MR elastomer under
room conditions (temperature of 25 C and relative humidity of
60%). This was followed by measuring and discussing the fric-
tion and wear properties of the MR elastomer at various tem-
peratures (50, 75, and 100 C) and relative humidities (40 and
80%). The errors of the applied temperature and relative
humidity corresponded to §4 and §5%, respectively. Each test
was repeated several times.
Figure 2. Experimental setup: (a) schematic and (b) photograph of the friction tester.
elastomer decreased to 10.2 HA without a magnetic field. The Friction coefficient and wear depth at different
hardness decreased to 13.1 HA from 13.5 HA with a magnetic temperatures
field. The hardness of the MR elastomer did not exhibit a sig-
nificant decrease when a high temperature was applied. This Figure 4 shows the baseline results (room conditions) for
was potentially because the original hardness of the MR elasto- the friction coefficient and real-time wear depth of the MR
mer was small, and the interior CI particles prevented a reduc- elastomer. The friction coefficient with an applied magnetic
tion in the hardness of the MR elastomer. The reduction in the field was lower than that without a magnetic field. With
hardness was low at a high temperature. However, the reduced respect to an applied magnetic field, the increased hardness
hardness could affect the friction and wear properties of the of the MR elastomer led to a small deformation on the con-
MR elastomer. tact surface, and the friction coefficient then decreased. This
4 C. LIAN ET AL.
Figure 6. Results for the average friction coefficient (a) and wear depth (b) at dif-
ferent temperatures.
Figure 7. Results for the friction coefficient and wear depth at 25 C and different
relative humidities of (a) 40% and (b) 80%.
A possible reason could be attributed to the local hydrody- Figure 8. Results for the (a) average friction coefficient and (b) wear depth at dif-
namic effect of the microasperities and cavities in the interface as ferent relative humidities.
the humidity increased, which in turn may result in a lubricating
effect. It was speculated that the adsorbed water could reduce the waves occur in polymer and elastomer materials during a fric-
shear strength of the contact interface between the MR elastomer tion or wear test (Barquins (20), Karnath, et al. (21); Iqbal, et al.
and the pin and reduce the friction coefficient (Xie, et al. (18), (19). (22). In the present study, Schallamach waves are observed in
Furthermore, the wear depth decreased as the relative both Fig. 9a and Fig. 9b. However, the worn hole was not
humidity increased. This could potentially be attributed to the observed. The Schallamach waves in the case with a magnetic
local hydrodynamic effect that reduced the shear strength of field were smaller than those in the case without a magnetic
the contact interface between the MR elastomer and the pin. field. This was because when the magnetic field was applied,
This thereby reduced the energy loss due to the friction move- the hardness of the MR elastomer increased and reduced the
ment, which in turn reduced the wear. When the applied rela- wear, and this matched the results obtained by Lee, et al. (12)
tive humidity exceeded 60%, the rate of wear reduction was and Lian, et al. (13), (14).
lower than the rate of wear reduction prior to a relative humid- Figure 10 shows the images of the wear surface state at dif-
ity of 60%. It was assumed that the lubricating effect reached ferent temperatures. Figures 10a, 10c, and 10e show the wear
saturation. The wear rate became small and stable when a criti- surface states without a magnetic field at temperatures of 50,
cal condition was reached (Bhushan (16). 75, and 100 C, respectively. Figures 10b, 10d,f and 10f show
the wear surface states with a magnetic field at temperatures of
50, 75, and 100 C, respectively. The Schallamach waves were
Wear surface image
observed at 50 and 75 C with a magnetic field. Additionally,
Figure 9 shows the images of the wear surface under room con- the worn hole was observed for the results obtained at high
ditions. Figures 9a and 9b show the results obtained without temperatures. The worn hole with the magnetic field was signif-
and with a magnetic field, respectively. Generally, Schallamach icantly smaller than the worn holes without the magnetic field
TRIBOLOGY TRANSACTIONS 7
Figure 9. Images of the surface state at 25 C and a relative humidity of 60%: (a) without a magnetic field and (b) with a magnetic field.
across all temperatures. When the magnetic field was applied, Figure 11 shows the images of the wear surface state at dif-
the hardness of the MR elastomer increased and reduced the ferent relative humidities. Figures 11a and 11c show the wear
wear. The worn hole grew as the temperature increased. High surface states without a magnetic field at relative humidities of
temperature led to a high surface flow for the MR elastomer 40 and 80%, respectively. Figures 11b and 11d show the wear
and resulted in severe wear. Furthermore, an air hole existed in surface states with a magnetic field at relative humidities of 40
the MR elastomer despite the vacuum treatment performed and 80%, respectively. The worn hole and the most obvious
during the MR elastomer manufacturing process. When a high Schallamach waves were observed at the relative humidity of
temperature was applied, the air hole enlarged and the surface 40% without a magnetic field. Obvious Schallamach waves and
weakened, which could lead to significant wear. holes were not observed at the relative humidity of 80% with a
Figure 10. Images of the surface state without a magnetic field at (a) 50 C, (c) 75 C, and (e) 100 C and with a magnetic field at (b) 50 C, (d) 75 C, and (f) 100 C.
8 C. LIAN ET AL.
Figure 11. Images of the surface state without a magnetic field at relative humidities of (a) 40% and (c) 80% and with a magnetic field at relative humidities of (b) 40%
and (d) 80%.
magnetic field. The wear with a magnetic field was lower than thereby reduced the friction coefficient. Furthermore, the wear
that without a magnetic field because the hardness increased depth decreased as the relative humidity increased.
under the applied magnetic field. Moreover, the wear decreased When a magnetic field was applied, the worn states of the con-
as the relative humidity increased. At a high relative humidity, tact surface decreased across all tests because the hardness of the
a local hydrodynamic effect of the microasperities and cavities MR elastomer increased. When the temperature increased, the
in the interface between the MR elastomer and the pin had a worn hole increased due to the high surface flow. Furthermore, the
lubricating effect and decreased the energy loss, thereby leading air hole in the MR elastomer was enlarged, and this led to a weak-
to low wear (Xie, et al. (18), (19). ened surface that could have caused high wear. The local hydrody-
namic effect of the microasperities and cavities in the interface had
a lubricating effect when the relative humidity increased, and this
Conclusion
decreased the energy loss during the friction test and led to low
The study examined the effects of temperature and relative wear. Although the friction and wear characteristics under different
humidity on the friction and wear properties of a silicone-based relative speeds between two surfaces have not been discussed in this
MR elastomer. A reciprocating friction tester and MR elasto- article, different relative speeds may have an impact on the friction
mer samples were designed and fabricated to evaluate the fric- coefficient and wear characteristics. As the speed increases, the
tion and wear properties of MR elastomers under varying temperature of the contact interface increases, which influences the
temperatures and relative humidities. The friction coefficient friction and wear characteristics. Moreover, in a humid environ-
and wear depth were measured, and the wear surface state was ment, the microinterface of the MR elastomer will tend to form a
observed to evaluate the friction and wear properties. local hydrodynamic water film and hydrodynamic effect under rel-
The results indicated that the friction coefficient and wear atively high speed. This may influence the friction and wear prop-
depth of the MR elastomer decreased across all tests when a erties of the test samples. The results presented in this study are
magnetic field was applied due to the increase in hardness. The only applicable for a silicone-based MR elastomer. This is because
surface flow of the MR elastomer increased when the applied other elastomer materials could have different friction and wear
temperature increased, which led to a large friction coefficient. properties at different temperatures and relative humidities. The
The increased temperature also led to a higher wear depth due results may be used as a reference for future applications and stud-
to the increased surface flow of the MR elastomer. Additionally, ies on MR elastomers under various external conditions.
the reduced hardness at the high temperature could have
increased the wear.
The friction coefficient slightly decreased when the relative Funding
humidity increased because of the lubricating effect of the local
This research was supported by the Basic Science Research Program of the
hydrodynamic effect of the microasperities and cavities in the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) funded by the Ministry of
interface. This may have reduced the shear strength of the con- Education, Science and Technology of the Korean government (Grant No.
tact interface between the MR elastomer and the pin and NRF-2015R1D1A1A09060901). The research was also supported by a
TRIBOLOGY TRANSACTIONS 9
grant from the Advanced Technology Center R&D Program funded by the (11) Maegawa, S., Itoigawa, F., and Nakamura, T. (2016), “Dynamics in
Ministry of Trade, Industry & Energy of Korea (10048876). Sliding Friction of Soft Adhesive Elastomer: Schallamach Waves as a
Stress-Relaxation Mechanism,” Tribology International, 96, pp 23–30.
(12) Lee, D. W., Lee, K., Lee, C. H., Kim, C. H., and Cho, W. O. (2013), “A
References Study on the Tribological Characteristics of a Magneto-Rheological
Elastomer,” Journal of Tribology, 135, pp 014501.
(1) Levin, M., Polesskii, E., and Prokhorov, I. (1997), “Some Features of (13) Lian, C. L., Lee, K. H., and Lee, C. H. (2015), “Friction and
the Magnetorheological Effect,” Journal of Engineering Physics and Wear Characteristics of Magneto-Rheological Elastomers Based
Thermophysics, 70(5), pp 769–772. on Silicone/Polyurethane Hybrid,” Journal of Tribology, 137, pp
(2) Ginder, J. M., Nichols, M. E., Elie, L. D., and Tardiff, J. L. (1999), 031607.
“Magnetorheological Elastomers: Properties and Applications,” Sym- (14) Lian, C. L., Lee, K. H., and Lee, C. H. (2016), “Friction and Wear
posium on Smart Structures and Materials, International Society for Characteristics of Magnetorheological Elastomer under Vibration
Optics and Photonics, Newport Beach, CA, 1 March. Conditions,” Tribology International, 98, pp 292–298.
(3) Watson, J. R. (1997), “Method and Apparatus for Varying the Stiff- (15) Hiratsuka, K. and Hosotani, K. (2012), “Effects of Friction Type and
ness of a Suspension Bushing,” U.S. Patent No. 05,609,353. Humidity on Triboelectrification and Triboluminescence among
(4) Chen, L., Gong, X., Jiang, W., Yao, J., Deng, H., and Li, W. (2007), Eight Kinds of Polymers,” Tribology International, 55, pp 87–99.
“Investigation on Magnetorheological Elastomers Based on Natural (16) Bhushan, B. (1999), Principles and Applications of Tribology, New
Rubber,” Journal of Materials Science, 42, pp 5483–5489. York: John Wiley & Sons.
(5) Liao, G., Gong, X., Kang, C., and Xuan, S. (2011), “The Design of an (17) Chowdhury, M. and Helali, M. (2006), “The Effect of Frequency of
Active–Adaptive Tuned Vibration Absorber Based on Magnetorheo- Vibration and Humidity on the Coefficient of Friction,” Tribology
logical Elastomer and Its Vibration Attenuation Performance,” Smart International, 39, pp 958–962.
Materials and Structures, 20(7), pp 075015. (18) Xie, Z., Rao, Z., Na, T., and Liu, L. (2016), “Investigations on Transi-
(6) Li, W., Kostidis, K., Zhang, X., and Zhou, Y. (2009), “Development of tions of Lubrication States for Water Lubricated Bearing. Part I:
a Force Sensor Working with MR Elastomers,” IEEE/ASME Interna- Determination of Friction Coefficient and Film Thickness Ratios,”
tional Conference on Advanced Intelligent Mechatronics, Singapore, Industrial Lubrication & Tribology, 68, pp 404–415.
14–17 July. (19) Xie, Z., Rao, Z., Na, T., and Liu, L. (2016), “Investigations on Transi-
(7) B€ose, H., Rabindranath, R., and Ehrlich, J. (2012), “Soft Magneto- tions of Lubrication States for Water Lubricated Bearing. Part II: Fur-
rheological Elastomers as New Actuators for Valves,” Journal of ther Insight into the Film Thickness Ratio Lambda,” Industrial
Intelligent Material Systems and Structures, 23, pp 989–994. Lubrication & Tribology, 68, pp 416–429.
(8) Jung, H., Kwon, S., Choi, H., Jung, J., and Kim, Y. (2016), “Magnetic (20) Barquins, M. (1985), “Sliding Friction of Rubber and Schallamach
Carbonyl Iron/Natural Rubber Composite Elastomer and Its Magne- Waves—A Review,” Materials Science and Engineering, 73, pp 45–63.
torheology,” Composite Structures, 136, pp 106–112. (21) Karnath, M., Sheng, Q., White, A., and Mueftue, S. (2010), “Fric-
(9) Dirisamer, F., Cakmak, U., Marth, E., and Major, Z. (2016), “Semi-Active tional Characteristics of Ultra-Thin Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE)
Damping Performance of Iron Particle Filled Silicone Rubber,” Acta Poly- Films Deposited by Hot Filament–Chemical Vapor Deposition
technica Czech Technical University Proceedings, 3, pp 7–10. (HFCVD),” Tribology Transactions, 54(1), pp 36–43.
(10) Shen, M., Peng, X., Meng, X., Zheng, J., and Zhu, M. (2016), “Fretting (22) Iqbal, T., Yasin, S., Zafar, M., Zahid, S., Ishteyaque, S., and Briscoe, B.
Wear Behavior of Acrylonitrile–Butadiene Rubber (NBR) for Mechanical (2015), “Nanoindentation Response of Scratched Polymeric Surfa-
Seal Applications,” Tribology International, 93, pp 419–428. ces,” Tribology Transactions, 58(5), pp 801–806.