Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
districts outside the top-10. Repeatedly, it has been proved that frequent customer
300
engagement is key to success in microfinance (chart 11) and the best way to
250 engage is via central meetings. ‘Weekly collection/meeting’ is CAGL’s core
200 philosophy, which has helped the company navigate challenging events such as
demonetisation and farm loan waivers in its key operational states in recent times.
Aug-18
Sep-18
Nov-18
Dec-18
Oct-18
Oct-18
Renish Bhuva Daily Volume (US$'000) N. A. P/BV (x) 4.9 2.8 2.4 2.1
renish.bhuva@icicisecurities.com Absolute Return 3m (%) 6.2 Net NPA (%) 0.0 0.0 0.1 0.1
+9122 6637 7465
Absolute Return 12m (%) N. A. Dividend Yield (%) - - - -
Sensex Return 3m (%) (2.3) RoAuM (%) 2.9 3.1 4.3 4.1
Sensex Return 12m (%) 9.5 RoE (%) 13.9 11.8 14.1 14.7
Please refer to important disclosures at the end of this report
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Valuation ........................................................................................................................... 3
CAGL – How it is different............................................................................................... 5
Industry overview ............................................................................................................7
NBFC-MFIs are dominant in microfinance and are likely to sustain leadership….......... 7
Rural India a highly under-penetrated credit market … .................................................. 9
‘Weekly collection/meeting’ – a most trusted practice .................................................. 11
Customer behaviour is isolated from farm loan waivers ............................................... 11
India – still not “over leverage” at borrower level .......................................................... 12
Huge growth potential; Large NBFC-MFIs are better placed........................................ 13
Regulations..................................................................................................................... 14
Company overview ........................................................................................................ 15
Customer-centric business mode: Following ‘basics’ .................................................. 16
Focus on under-penetrated rural India… ...................................................................... 20
Best-in-class asset quality............................................................................................. 22
Most efficient MFI player ............................................................................................... 27
Diversified funding sources and effective asset-liability management ......................... 29
Stable management team with extensive domain experience ..................................... 32
Financials........................................................................................................................ 33
Robust AuM growth to continue; huge untapped rural population to fuel growth ......... 33
Industry-leading Opex/AAuM ratio to sustain................................................................ 33
We model earnings CAGR of 70% during FY18-FY20E .............................................. 34
Annexure 1: Financials (standalone) ........................................................................... 35
Annexure 2: Index of Tables and Charts ..................................................................... 37
2
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Valuation
CreditAccess Grameen Ltd (CAGL) stock currently trades at 2.4x/2.1x FY19e/FY20e
P/BV, which is at significant discount (~30% 1 year forward) to its closest peer Bharat
Financial. During recent liquidity crisis period, stock has touched a low of ~Rs250, but
made strong come back after company clarifying on its effective asset-liability
management and comfort of sustaining industry-leading AuM growth. Currently, it
carries six months positive cash on balance sheet. Considering the potential business
growth backed branch expansion plan, consistent decline in PAR portfolio post
demon, focus on cost optimization and better financial leverage, we expect the return
ratios to improve going forward. We initiate coverage with BUY rating and target price
of Rs480/share, valuing it at 2.5x FY20e P/ABV.
Historically CAGL has operated at 5x leverage and the same has enabled it to touch
RoE of 20%, however recent capital infusion had dragged down RoE to 13% as at
Sep’18. We expect ~170bps improvement in RoE to 14.7% by FY20e. We value
CAGL lower than its closet peer Bharat Financial to factor in a) higher exposure in
Karnataka and Maharashtra and b) lower RoE currently.
Chart 1: P/BV 1 year forward CAGL Chart 2: P/BV 1 year forward BFIL
P/ABV 3 yr avg. P/ABV 3 yr avg.
2.6 avg. + 1 SD avg. - 1 SD
6.0 avg. + 1 SD avg. - 1 SD
2.4
5.0
2.2
4.0
2.0
1.8 3.0
1.6
2.0
1.4
1.0
1.2
1.0 0.0
Aug-18
Sep-18
Sep-18
Sep-18
Nov-18
Nov-18
Nov-18
Dec-18
Dec-13
Jun-16
Jan-17
Aug-14
Aug-17
Nov-18
Oct-18
Oct-18
Oct-18
Oct-12
May-13
Mar-15
Oct-15
Apr-18
Source: BBG, I-Sec research Source: BBG, I-Sec research
3
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Market share within the NBFC-MFIs industry is clearly concentrated amongst large
MFIs, who account for 91% of the industry GLP, 89% of the client base and 94% of
debt funding. Considering the current liquidity crisis, we believe smaller NBFC-MFIs
would find it a little challenging in getting incremental funds for short term and the
same will provide an opportunity to large MFIs to gain further market share.
4
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Chart 3: While sticking to ‘basics’, CAGL has been able to double its systemic
market share over past four years.
400 3.0%
300
2.0%
200
1.0%
100
0 0.0%
FY14 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18
Source: MFIN, June’18 data, Company data, I-Sec research
Table 1: CAGL’s state-wise PAR 30+ compared to the MFI industry – Strong come back from
demonetisation-related issues
(%)
Sep-17 Jun-17 Mar-17 Dec-16 Sep-16
PAR 30%+ Industry CAGL Industry CAGL Industry CAGL Industry CAGL Industry CAGL
Maharashtra 27.20 12.50 28.00 17.20 26.70 23.40 16.10 9.90 2.10 0.10
Karnataka 16.80 3.10 18.00 4.60 19.10 8.10 9.40 1.00 1.70 0.00
Madhya Pradesh 16 5.10 16.60 7.20 16.30 7.90 9.60 1.10 1.60 0.00
Tamil Nadu 8.30 0.30 8.80 0.30 8.70 0.30 2.80 0.00 2.10 0.00
Chhattisgarh 7.10 2.10 7.50 2.20 7.30 2.20 4.30 0.80 2.30 0.00
Overall 11.40 5.70 11.60 8.00 11.70 11.90 7.90 3.50 1.50 0.10
Source: Company data, I-Sec research
CAGL enjoys better pricing power as reflected in its higher yields than the
largest player, BFIL. Notably, despite charging higher yields, CAGL has
maintained its growth trajectory.
CAGL is the most efficient listed player in NBFC-MFI space – given that its
cost/asset ratio is ~125bps lower than industry average, mainly on account
of lower employee cost and industry-leading customer retention ratio
enabling it to source new business at lower cost.
CAGL has demonstrated strong comeback (post-demonetization) as
reflected in industry-leading pre-tax profit in FY18, a year of higher credit
cost linked to the demonetization-impacted portfolio.
5
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Table 2: RoAuM decomposition
(%)
BFIL Ujjivan Satin CAGL
FY17 FY18 FY17 FY18 FY17 FY18 FY17 FY18
Net revenue (%) 13.1 12.8 14.5 14.0 9.9 11.3 14.0 12.9
Employee expenses (%) 4.8 4.8 4.6 5.3 4.6 4.3 3.7 3.2
Depreciation (%) 0.2 0.1 0.2 0.6 0.2 0.3 0.2 0.1
Other operating expenses (%) 1.6 1.5 3.0 3.5 2.5 1.6 1.8 1.7
Total operating expenses (%) 6.6 6.5 7.8 9.4 7.2 6.3 5.7 5.0
Pre-provisioning profits (%) 6.6 6.3 6.7 4.6 2.7 5.1 8.3 8.0
Provisions (%) 4.3 2.2 1.3 4.5 1.6 5.0 3.9 3.2
Pre-tax profits (%) 2.3 4.2 5.5 0.2 1.1 0.1 4.4 4.8
Tax (%) -1.2 0.0 1.9 0.1 0.4 0.0 1.6 1.7
RoAUM (%) 3.5 4.2 3.5 0.1 0.7 0.1 2.9 3.1
Leverage 0.0 4.0 3.4 4.0 0.0 5.0 4.1 3.8
RoE 0.0 16.7 11.8 0.4 0.0 0.5 11.8 11.8
Source: Company data, MFIN, I-Sec research
6
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Industry overview
NBFC-MFIs are dominant in microfinance and are likely to
sustain leadership…
NBFC-MFIs dominate the microfinance space with ~32% market share, second-
highest after banks who enjoy leadership position with 39% share, as per latest data
from the Union ministry of finance (Mfin). If we exclude Bandhan Bank’s MFI portfolio,
which is almost ~50% of total MFI loans provided by banks, NBFC-MFIs’ share in
Gross Loan Portfolio (GLP) increases to 40% as at 30-Jun’18. Important to note, as
per Mfin data, portfolio classified under Banks category includes direct and indirect
lending (through Business Correspondents), which is again largely sourced by NBFC-
MFIs. Hence, we believe NBFC-MFIs market share at sourcing level would be much
higher than what it appears at portfolio level.
Q1FY19
NBFCs, 7% Non-profit MFIs,
1%
Banks, 39%
NBFC-MFIs, 32%
SFBs, 21%
Further, our interaction with market participants suggests that NBFC-MFIs are better
placed to sustain their dominant position in the MFI space given: a) small finance
banks’ (SFB) incremental focus on expanding their non-MFI portfolios, b) NBFC-MFIs’
expertise in Joint Liability Group (JLG)-based lending, and c) deep understanding of
under-served rural population.
SFBs
30%
Q2FY18 Q1FY19
25%
25%
21%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
Q2FY18 Q1FY19
7
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
…Large NBFC-MFIs to gain market share
Market share within the NBFC-MFIs industry is clearly concentrated amongst large
MFIs, who account for 91% of the industry GLP, 89% of the client base and 94% of
debt funding. Considering the current liquidity crisis, we believe smaller NBFC-MFIs
would find it a little challenging in getting incremental funds for short term and the
same will provide an opportunity to large MFIs to gain further market share.
Chart 6: CAGL is second-largest NBFC-MFI with o/s Gross Loan Portfolio (GLP)
of Rs55bn as at Jun’18-end
160 138
140
120
100
80 55 54
60
32 29 24
40 22 20 18 14
20
0
BFIL
Satin
Muthoot Microfin*
Asirvad
Annapurna
Fusion
Madhura
Spandana*
Arohan*
CAGL
Training given to
clients
JLG SHG
8
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
10%
0%
Rural Urban
Source: CRISIL Research, Industry
We have analysed state-wise credit penetration data published by Mfin and rural
penetration data as per CRISIL and we conclude that: a) rural penetration in terms of
credit is significantly lower in states with otherwise high credit penetration; b) in value
terms, Maharashtra, West Bengal, Gujarat and Chhattisgarh have less than 10% of
total credit outstanding in rural areas as at 31-Mar’16. Notably, West Bengal and
Chhattisgarh are amongst the top-10 highly penetrated states covered by NBFC-MFIs.
Even in highly Chart 9: Even in highly penetrated Chart 10: State-wise Gross Loan
penetrated states, states, rural credit is still significantly Portfolio (GLP) breakup as at Jun’18;
rural credit in value lower as % of total bank accounts top-5 states account for 53% of GLP
terms is still % of % of credit Market share in GLP (NBFC-MFI) - As on June'18
accounts in outstanding in Maharashtr
significantly lower as rural areas rural areas a Bihar
(FY16) (FY16)
% of total bank 60%
13% 16%
account. 50%
West
40% Bengal
30% 11% Uttar
20% Pradesh
10% 14%
0%
Tamil Nadu
Andhra Pradesh
Madhya Pradesh
Karnataka
Tamil Nadu
Chhattisgarh
Gujarat
Bihar
Uttar Pradesh
Rajasthan
Maharashtra
West Bengal
13% Rajasthan
4%
Madhya
Karnataka Pradesh
17% 12%
Source: MFIN, June’18 data, Isec research Source: MFIN, June’18 data, Isec research
9
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Chart 11: NBFC-MFIs are focused on tapping the under-penetrated rural
segment, which accounts for 66% of industry GLP
Notably, CAGL’s
rural borrower base
stands at ~82% as at
Sep’18 vs ~66% Urban
34%
(GLP) for the
industry
Rural
66%
Only 30% of the total Chart 12: Number of credit accounts Chart 13: Number of deposit accounts
deposit accounts and
120 113.5 1.4
35% of the loan 1.2
1.2
accounts in 100
scheduled 80
1.0
(bn)
60 0.6
are in rural India 0.6
despite rural India 40
0.4
making up about
20 0.2
68% of India’s total
population. 0 0.0
Rural Urban Rural Urban
Source: MFIN, June’18 data, Isec research Source: MFIN, June’18 data, Isec research
10
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Note: PAR > 30 days exclude Andhra Pradesh and Telangana portfolios; PAR > 30 includes all overdues over 30
days; write-offs done by entities are not considered.
Source: Equifax, CRISIL Research
11
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Measures taken by NBFC-MFIs:
All MFIs educate members on how MFI loans and farm loans are different. It is
part of their Compulsory Group Training (CGT) programme.
They educate members on importance of maintaining good credit score and only
MFIs will give them money to support them financially. During our recent channel
checks, we crossed-checked these things as we were skeptical about how the
unbanked rural population will understand the importance of ‘good credit score’.
But, to our surprise (we met almost 40 borrowers), ~80/90% of the borrowers were
aware that if they delay in repayments or default, they will not get any financial
assistance from any other formal financial institutions.
Chart 15: Despite six states announcing farm loan waivers during past 18
months, PAR 30 portfolio for NBFC-MFIs is declining.
35.0%
30.0%
25.0%
20.0%
15.0%
10.0%
5.0%
0.0%
Q1FY17 Q2FY17 Q3FY17 Q4FY17 Q1FY18 Q2FY18 Q3FY18 Q4FY18 Q1FY19
12
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Chart 16: Loan o/s per borrower in India is still significantly lower than
regulatory limits of Rs80,000 and Rs1,00,000 as set by Mfin and RBI respectively
Avg loan o/s per account Avg loan disbursed per account
25,000
24,000
23,000
22,000 23,295 23,510
21,000 21,971 22,388
20,000 21,026
19,000 20,736
18,000
17,000 18,132
16,000 17,511
16,924
15,000 16,016
14,000 15,432
13,000 14,508
13,806
12,000 13,068
11,000
10,000
Q3FY17 Q4FY17 Q1FY18 Q2FY18 Q3FY18 Q4FY18 Q1FY19
Table 5: Uttar Pradesh, Bihar and Maharashtra have similar rural population as Bangladesh, but these
states have only 10/11% of Bangladesh’s total AuM size.
Bangladesh UP Ratios (%) Bihar Ratios (%) Maharashtra Ratios (%)
Rural population (mn) 110 160 146% 90 87% 60 58%
Urban population (mn) 60 50 91% 10 21% 50 89%
Total population (mn) 160 210 127% 100 64% 110 69%
Total micro credit (Rs bn) 440 48 11% 47 11% 450 10%
Source: Industry data, I-Sec research
13
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Regulations
Microfinance sector in India governed by RBI guidelines
MFIs were largely operating unregulated until 2010, when the Andhra Pradesh (AP)
ordinance came into effect. The ordinance addressed issues such as coercive
recovery practices and absence of a social objective among MFIs to help the poor.
Post ordinance, AP saw a sharp decline in MFI activity. In 2011, the RBI released
guidelines that defined NBFC-MFIs and provided an operating and regulatory
framework for MFIs operating in India. Moving forward, the draft bill on microfinance is
likely to provide clarity on certain regulatory aspects.
14
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Company overview
CreditAccess Grameen Limited (CAGL) is the second-largest Indian microfinance
institution headquartered in Bengaluru, focused on providing micro-loans to women
customers predominantly in rural areas, which account for ~82% of CAGL’s current
customer base. Income-generation loans comprised 86.58% of the total JLG loan
portfolio as at 30-Sep’18. Company has recently ventured into retail financing to cater
to high-ticket size loans for their captive customers.
15
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
80%
78%
FY14 FY15 FY16 FY17 Sep'17
Source: Company data, I-Sec research
16
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Receipt of Loan Applications: Loan applications are submitted to the loan officer at the Kendra
CAGL’s branches enroll customers who satisfy the
meetings after ensuring that every group member is willing to take joint responsibility for the loan. If
target clientele criteria.
the group approves the loan, the loan officer grants the loan to the customer based on the
The size of the groups is flexible with a minimum of
understanding obtained from the group discussion. Maximum loan limit the customer is eligible for
five and a maximum of 10 women customers in a
after considering her loan cycle and existing MFI exposure through other loans with CAGL or with
group. Two to six groups form a Kendra which
other MFIs.
typically has 10 to 30 customers.
Once the interested women customers have Loan Evaluation: After the receipt of the loan application, the loan officer makes a compulsory visit
formed their groups, CAGL provides Group training to the customer's residence to interview the customer and other members of her household to
explaining roles & responsibilities of JLG. ascertain the repayment capacity of the customer. During the visit, the loan officer prepares the cash
Immediately after the formation of the group, the flow statement in the prescribed format. A cash flow statement is not required for other types of loans
loan officer visits the prospective customers' house but the Kendra manager has to check the repayment capacity of the customer.
to collect the Know-Your-Customer ("KYC")
Loan Sanction and Further Processing: On the recommendation of the loan officer and after
documents and basic data of the customers.
reviewing the relevant documents, the branch manager will sanction the loan if it falls within his
The company ensures that there are multiple
delegated authority. If not, the branch manager will recommend the loan to the appropriate
levels of check before enrolling a new group or
sanctioning authority as per the Delegation of Powers approved by the Board. Upon sanctioning the
customer.
loan, the branch manager signs the sanction letter and the loan officer carries the sanction letter to
the next Kendra meeting to hand it over to the customer after reconfirming with the other members of
the group that they approve the granting of the loan to the particular customer. The customer is
Collection
required to come to the branch with the sanction letter together with proof of identity to receive
disbursement of the loan. Customers are encouraged to receive disbursements through electronic
Before the Kendra meeting, the customers funds transfers to their bank account. On disbursement of the loan, the customer receives a
hand over their loan passbooks and instalment separate passbook for each loan with the repayment schedule printed in it.
amounts to the group leader.
At the Kendra meeting, the group leader hands over
the amount collected and the passbooks to the
Loan officer. Kendra Meetings - helps in relationship building
The group leader oversees the group’s payment
and reports to the Loan officer.
A Kendra meeting is one of the core activities for the field staff and also a matter of great
Once the amount collected is the same as the importance to both customers and the company. Kendra meetings are conducted strictly as set
amount demanded, the Loan officer checks and out in its operational guidelines either on a weekly or bi-weekly basis. Kendra meetings are vital
signs each member’s loan passbook after verifying for CAGL for the following reasons:
it with the collection sheet, which he brings from the
branch. All financial and non-financial transactions with customers are conducted at the Kendra meeting
The Kendra meeting is the point of contact with customers and this helps in relationship building
All important schemes and policies of the company are shared with customers at the Kendra meeting.
The Kendra meeting plays an important role in building the company’s brand image.
17
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Retail finance: One-stop solution to customers’ growing credit need
In 2016, with a view to diversifying its product profile, CAGL launched its retail finance
vertical for existing customers who have completed at least three years with the
company and fulfil certain other eligibility criteria linked primarily to their credit history.
CAGL offer these loans as business loans either to establish a new enterprise or
expand an existing business in the customer’s individual capacity (for instance, for the
purchase of inventories, machinery or two-wheelers).
The retail loan category targets customers who are more entrepreneurial, have
graduated from the JLG model, and have enough supporting documents to take larger
loans in their individual capacities. Typically, other financial institutions or banks ask
for collateral and take higher turnaround time while CAGL on other hand could
extends credit much faster and at similar interest rates as what other FIs/banks can
offer. Customer’s credit history of more than three years and existing relationship
helps CAGL tap customers whose credit demand increases as they grow.
In order to be eligible for IRF products, customers have to satisfy the following basic
criteria:
18
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Retail finance business process
Business team. The business team is responsible for Credit and operations team. The credit and operations team is responsible for credit
sourcing and converting the group lending customers as assessment, sanctioning or rejecting a loan proposal and maintaining documentation
well as repayment collections from customers. and disbursement for sanctioned cases.
As of September 30, 2017, it had eight IRF branches and
A branch operations executive is responsible for data entry and does the first level
each IRF branch is headed by a branch manager who is
check of the proposals submitted by its business team.
responsible for the business and operations of the branch,
and the branch manager reports to the regional sales A branch operations manager is responsible for keeping records, cash management,
manager, who is responsible for the business and documentation of applications, sanctions and disbursements at the branch.
administration of all the branches under him.
Further, it has telecallers at its central office who are responsible for doing a tele-
The business team comprises Business Development
verification check of all proposals submitted for review.
Officers ("BDOs"), who are field staff who source IRF
customers, and Customer Relationship Officers ("CROs"), It also has credit underwriters who analyze a proposal based on the information
who are responsible for maintaining the relationship with gathered and recommend that a case be sanctioned or rejected to a regional credit
customers post disbursement and conducting loan manager.
utilization checks and post-disbursal document execution.
To ensure proper documentation, safety of all documents and conduct of
disbursement related activities, it has an operations team stationed centrally.
Collection
First branch
opened in Expansion Loan Book Borrowers
Bangalore started crossed Rs250mn crossed 10,000
19
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Retail finance Chart 20: Retail finance portfolio jumped ~3x to Rs1.6bn over past six months;
currently contributes notably, customer base too increased at a similar pace
~3% to CAGL’s total
Portfolio (Crores) Branches Customers Average ticket size
AuM. Importantly, 180 25,000
81,600
CAGL has been able 160
19,420 81,458
20,000 81,400
to successfully tap 140
81,200
JLG dropout 120
15,000
100 11,908 81,000
customers as
80 156
reflected in the ~3x 6,317
10,000 80,800
80,735
60
increase in customer 40
97 80,600
5,000
base over past six 20 51
32
46 80,400
80,330
30
months. Also, the 0 0 80,200
FY18 Q1FY19 #NAME? FY18 Q1FY19 Q2FY19
average ticket-size of
Source: Company data, I-Sec research Source: Company data, I-Sec research
~Rs80,000 does not
appear on higher
side. Focus on under-penetrated rural India…
Despite continued government effort on financial inclusion and bringing rural
population on the formal banking platform, rural India remains an unserved and
underserved population in relation to the country's formal banking system.
Strategically, CAGL has always focused on the rural segment, especially when many
industry players were expanding their customer base in urban India. CAGL believes it
will be able to strengthen its position by tapping into this underserved market and that
it is best placed to capitalise on its strategy of having a deep penetration in the rural
areas. Notably, growth in rural India offers the dual advantage of: a) relatively lower
competition than in urban India, and b) lower cost of business.
CAGL has Chart 21: CAGL’s rural customer-base stands at 82% vs industry average of 66%
strategically focused
Rural customer base
on expanding its
85% 82%
business in the
Urban 80% 77%
under-penetrated 34%
75% 73%
rural segment. This
68%
has resulted in a 70%
We believe CAGL’s deep penetration in rural areas, built through a contiguous district-
based expansion strategy, provides it with significant scale and diversification
advantages. It can carry out its expansion strategy methodically whereby it aims to
expand to the next (typically adjoining) district and ensure deep penetration in it within
three years of commencement of operations in the same district.
20
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Being a Karnataka-headquartered entity, CAGL’s initial business was largely
concentrated in Karnataka with almost 71% of its total AuM originating in the same
state. However, over the years, the company has strategically focused on reducing
exposure in Karnataka and has expanded business in other states. Till FY14, CAGL’s
business operations were limited to only three states, while it currently operates in
eight states and one Union Territory (Puducherry).
21
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Chart 23: Asset quality trend across major MFI players – CAGL stands out
14%
12%
10%
8%
6%
4%
2%
0%
FY16 FY17 FY18 Q2FY19
Source: Company data
*Ujjivan is an SFB, but ~88% of its loan book is MFI.
22
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
A) Weekly collection/meeting
CAGL follows a predominantly weekly collection model, which enables a high degree
of customer engagement. Whilst majority of its customers are on a weekly collection
model, the company also offers fortnightly and monthly collection models based on
customer needs. Further, we note that MFIs that follow a weekly collection model tend
to perform better in terms of asset quality, as they engage more frequently with
borrowers. Since CAGL follows the weekly meeting model, it demonstrated a better
asset quality during the recent crisis of demonetisation, as compared to other MFI
players.
Chart 25: MFIs that follow a weekly collection model tend to perform better in
terms of asset quality
Table 10: CAGL’s state-wise PAR30+ compared to the MFI industry – Strong comeback from
demonetization-related issues
(%)
Sep-17 Jun-17 Mar-17 Dec-16 Sep-16
PAR 30+% Industry CAGL Industry CAGL Industry CAGL Industry CAGL Industry CAGL
Maharashtra 27.20 12.50 28.00 17.20 26.70 23.40 16.10 9.90 2.10 0.10
Karnataka 16.80 3.10 18.00 4.60 19.10 8.10 9.40 1.00 1.70 0.00
Madhya Pradesh 16 5.10 16.60 7.20 16.30 7.90 9.60 1.10 1.60 0.00
Tamil Nadu 8.30 0.30 8.80 0.30 8.70 0.30 2.80 0.00 2.10 0.00
Chhattisgarh 7.10 2.10 7.50 2.20 7.30 2.20 4.30 0.80 2.30 0.00
Overall 11.40 5.70 11.60 8.00 11.70 11.90 7.90 3.50 1.50 0.10
Source: Company data, I-Sec research
23
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Strong customer connects – as reflects in superior net backward flow
rates across buckets…
Chart 26: … PAR 90+ to lower bucket Chart 27: PAR 61-90 to lower bucket
(%)
8
15 12.4
6 5.1
9.3 9.9 9.3 9.4
3.9 10 8.2
4 6.1 6.7 6.6
2.1 4.7 3.7
2 1.0 1.0 5
0.6 0.8
0.2 0.2
0.7 0.5 0.7 0.6 1.4 1.7
0 0
Jul-17
Jul-17
Jan-17
Feb-17
Mar-17
Apr-17
Jun-17
Aug-17
Sep-17
Jan-17
Apr-17
Jun-17
Aug-17
Sep-17
May-17
Feb-17
Mar-17
May-17
Chart 28: PAR 61-90 to lower bucket Chart 29: PAR 1-30 to current
(%)
Jun-17
Jul-17
Feb-17
Mar-17
Apr-17
May-17
Aug-17
Sep-17
Jan-17
Jun-17
Jul-17
Feb-17
Mar-17
Apr-17
May-17
Aug-17
Sep-17
Source: Company data, I-Sec research
24
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Post the introduction session, CAGL advises villagers to form a group. It then
educates groups on how JLG works and their responsibility.
List of documents: Aadhar card and Voter ID is compulsory. It also asks for
husband-wife joint photo, husband KYC and bank statement of women.
Loan officer visits each customer house to check family background, fill MBD
(member basic data), and then submit application form to the RPC (regional
processing centre).
After getting basic details, the Loan Officer (LO) checks credit bureau report and if
all ok, the LO approves the group and starts with group training for five days.
Compulsory Group Training (CGT) is mandatory for all JLG members. Purpose of
the training is to check indirectly how JLG members get along with each other,
punctuality, and other soft checks.
After CGT, the branch manager conducts re-interview of the selected JLGs and
rechecks all the things that the LO is supposed to perform and analyses cashflow.
After branch manager’s visit, the area manager visits the selected JLGs, rechecks
BM/LOs’ work, and checks the cashflow analysis done by them.
Post the 3-tier check LO starts processing new applications and disbursements
happens within a week.
CAGL takes around 15-20 days for any fresh disbursements to new JLGs.
25
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Chart 30: Consistent decline in its per district exposure – It fell to 0.6% as at
Sep’18 from ~2.4% in FY14
2.5% 2.4%
2.0%
1.6%
1.5% 1.4%
1.0%
1.0%
0.8%
0.6%
0.5%
0.0%
FY14 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 Q2FY19
Source: Company data, I-Sec research
70% 65%
60%
50%
40%
30%
10%
3% 1%
0%
< 0.5% 0.5% - 1% 1% - 3% 3% - 5% > 5%
Source: Company data, I-Sec research
26
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
d) Focus on Income-Generating Loans
As per the RBI’s regulations issued in Apr’15, a minimum of 50% of the aggregate
loans should be towards income generation activities. Further, due to the RBI
regulation and better performance of Income Generation Loans (IGLs) as compared to
consumption loans in terms of asset quality, a majority of loans issued by MFIs are for
IG activities. Thus, share of IGLs for NBFC-MFIs remained significantly higher at 94%
in FY16 than the regulatory minimum requirement of 50%.
CAGL always remained focused on extending IGLs, even when it was pursuing high
growth and expanding its reach in newer states. The share of IGLs for CAGL broadly
remained constant at around 86% over past five years.
89%
88%
89% 88%
88% 88%
88%
87% 87%
87% 86%
86%
86%
85%
85%
FY14 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18
Source: Company data, I-Sec research
Key differentiator for CAGL is its ability to control employee cost at the lowest level of
3.2% in FY18 vs 4.8%/5.3%/4.3% for BFIL/Ujjivan/Satin respectively, while CAGL’s
other operating expenses (ex-Ujjivan) at ~1.6% is broadly similar BFIL/Satin.
27
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Chart 33: CAGL per employee cost is lowest amongst key MFI players, notably despite maintaining
second-best AuM/per loan officer
Per employee cost per annum (Rs) AUM per loan officers (Rs mn)
150,000 6
100,000 4
50,000 2
0 0
BFIL Ujjivan Satin CAGL BFIL Ujjivan Satin CAGL
Source: Company data, I-Sec research Source: Company data, I-Sec research
Note: Data as per Annual Report 2018. Note: Data as per Annual Report 2018.
Chart 34: Scope for further improvement in selected productivity metrics; lower
clients per loan officer is largely due to company’s recent expansion
700 645
600
507
500
395
400
300
200
100
0
BFIL Satin CAGL*
Source: Company data, I-Sec research
Note: NFIL/Satin data is as per Jun’18 Ministry of Finance release. CAGL data is as per Q2FY19 PPT.
During H1FY19, the cost ratio appears a little elevated, largely due to CAGL’s strategy
to expand branch network in H1 of any financial year so that they could focus on
leveraging the expanded network from H2 onward.
Importantly, CAGL continues to identify and implement measures that could enable it
to sustain and further decrease the operating expense ratio. In addition, it also invests
in technology platform and technology-enabled operating procedures to increase
operational and management efficiencies. It believes robust technology infrastructure
is necessary to respond swiftly to market opportunities and challenges, improve the
quality of services, scale-up risk management capabilities, optimise operating costs
and improve operational efficiency. It has initiated several measures, which include
following:
28
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
It implemented tablet-based loan application process for moving to paperless
transactions using electronic KYC procedures, which allows it to reduce
turnaround time.
It has recently implemented its new online Core Banking System, which has
facilitated smooth and swift flow of information and data enabling it to control the
cost of operations and provide improved services to customers.
Additionally, it has centralised certain in-house back office processes with the
formation of regional processing centres where customer data entry is carried out
centrally. As at 31-Mar’18, CAGL has eight regional processing centres located in
Bengaluru, Belgaum, Davanagere, Erode, Nagpur, Kolhapur, Indore and
Aurangabad.
CAGL has also implemented on a pilot basis an online loan-processing platform
aimed at providing easier access to customers and is in the process of introducing
this platform in all branches.
8.0%
6.8%
7.0% 6.3%
5.8% 5.7%
6.0%
5.0% 5.0%
5.0%
4.0%
3.0%
2.0%
1.0%
0.0%
FY14 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 1HFY19
Source: Company data, I-Sec research
29
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Chart 36: Well-diversified borrowing mix
As at Sep’18-end,
PTC Direct Assignment
CAGL’s sourcing tie- 1%
11%
ups include:
‒ 32 commercial
banks
‒ Three domestic Foreign Sources
18%
financial
institutions (long- Banks
53%
term)
‒ Eight foreign
institutional FIs
10%
investors (long-
NBFCs
term) 7%
‒ Six NBFCs (three Source: Company data, I-Sec research
are long-term)
This has enabled the company to optimise the cost of borrowings, funding and liquidity
requirements, capital management and asset liability management.
10
0
Q1FY19
Q2FY19
FY15
FY16
FY17
FY18
While managing the ALM positively with diversified funding sources, CAGL has
effectively managed its borrowing cost as well. Its weighted average cost of borrowing
as at Sep’18-end stands at 9.9% but, remarkably, its marginal cost of borrowing during
Q2FY19 fell to 8.9%.
30
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Chart 38: Consistent decline in cost of borrowing
16.0%
14.1%
14.0% 12.6%
12.0% 11.4%
10.2% 9.9%
10.0%
8.0%
6.0%
4.0%
2.0%
0.0%
FY16 FY17 FY18 Q1FY19 Q2FY19
Source: Company data, I-Sec research
21.0
21.0
19.8
20.0
19.0
18.0
BFIL CAGL Satin Muthoot Asirvad Arohan* Fusion Madhura
Microfin*
Data as per June’18 MFIN release
Source: Company data, I-Sec research
31
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
32
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Financials
Robust AuM growth to continue; huge untapped rural population
to fuel growth
CAGL delivered industry-leading AuM growth at 57% CAGR over FY14-FY18 primarily
driven by: a) strategic decision to focus on the huge but untapped rural segment, b)
contiguous expansion strategy, and c) weekly collection method that helped get
repetitive business from same customers. Going forward, with continued focus on the
rural segment and huge unmet rural credit demand with comfortable capital position at
40.4% CAR, we expect CAGL’s AuM to grow at 46% CAGR between FY18/FY20E.
50 20%
20
25 31 10%
8 14
0 0%
FY14 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19e FY20e
33
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Chart 41: Consistent decline in Cost/AAuM ratio
Cost/AAuM (%)
8.0%
6.8%
7.0% 6.3%
5.8% 5.7%
6.0%
5.0% 5.0% 4.9%
5.0%
4.0%
3.0%
2.0%
1.0%
0.0%
FY14 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19e FY20e
Source: Company data, I-Sec research
3.5 193%
200%
3.0
150%
2.5 109% 114%
34
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
35
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Asset Quality
GNPA 0.0 0.1 0.1 1.9 1.0 1.1
NNPA 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.1 0.1
PCR (%) 100% 100% 100% 100% 90% 90%
Valuation
P/E (x) 43.8 35.2 42.7 32.2 21.2 15.2
P/B (x) 5.6 6.3 4.9 2.8 2.4 2.1
RoA decomposition
Net interest income (%) 8.4% 9.9% 13.7% 12.7% 12.8% 12.4%
Other income (%) 5.1% 3.0% 0.3% 0.2% 0.5% 0.5%
Total income (%) 13.5% 13.0% 14.0% 12.9% 13.3% 12.9%
Employee expenses (%) 3.9% 3.5% 3.7% 3.2% 3.2% 3.2%
Depre (%) 0.2% 0.1% 0.2% 0.1% 0.1% 0.1%
Other operating expenses (%) 2.2% 2.1% 1.8% 1.7% 1.7% 1.6%
Total operating expenses (%) 6.3% 5.8% 5.7% 5.0% 5.0% 4.9%
Pre provisioning profits (%) 7.2% 7.2% 8.3% 8.0% 8.3% 8.0%
Provisions (%) 0.6% 0.7% 3.9% 3.2% 1.7% 1.6%
Pre tax profits (%) 6.6% 6.5% 4.4% 4.8% 6.6% 6.4%
Tax (%) 2.3% 2.3% 1.6% 1.7% 2.3% 2.2%
RoAUM (%.) 4.3% 4.2% 2.9% 3.1% 4.3% 4.1%
Leverage 3.9 4.8 4.9 3.8 3.3 3.5
RoE (%.) 16.7% 19.9% 13.9% 11.8% 14.1% 14.7%
Capital Adequacy
Tier I Capital 3,593 4,376 6,312 13,818 23,531 27,265
Tier II Capital 214 965 2,966 427 427 427
Total Capital 3,807 5,341 9,278 14,244 23,958 27,692
Total Risk Weighted Assets 13,556 24,869 31,230 49,221 74,193 103,210
% of total assets 79% 89% 88% 94% 92% 90%
CRAR - Tier I capital (%) 26.50% 17.60% 20.21% 28.07% 31.7% 26.4%
CRAR - Tier II capital (%) 1.58% 3.88% 9.50% 0.87% 0.6% 0.4%
CRAR (%) 28.08% 21.48% 29.71% 28.94% 32.3% 26.8%
Source: Company data, I-Sec research
36
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Charts
Chart 1: P/BV 1 year forward CAGL ..................................................................................... 3
Chart 2: P/BV 1 year forward BFIL ....................................................................................... 3
Chart 3: While sticking to ‘basics’, CAGL has been able to double its systemic market
share over past four years. ............................................................................................. 5
Chart 4: NBFC-MFIs’ microfinance market share stands at 32% ......................................... 7
Chart 5: SFBs losing ground as reflected in sharp decline in their microfinance market
share to 21% in Q1FY19 from 25% in Q2FY18 .............................................................. 7
Chart 6: CAGL is second-largest NBFC-MFI with o/s Gross Loan Portfolio (GLP) of
Rs55bn as at Jun’18-end ................................................................................................ 8
Chart 7: Lending mechanism via different MFI operating models – NBFC-MFIs follow Joint
Liability Group (JLG) model ............................................................................................ 8
Chart 8: Low penetration of bank credit in rural areas (FY17) .............................................. 9
Chart 9: Even in highly penetrated states, rural credit is still significantly lower as % of total
bank accounts ................................................................................................................. 9
Chart 10: State-wise Gross Loan Portfolio (GLP) breakup as at Jun’18; top-5 states
account for 53% of GLP .................................................................................................. 9
Chart 11: NBFC-MFIs are focused on tapping the under-penetrated rural segment, which
accounts for 66% of industry GLP ................................................................................ 10
Chart 12: Number of credit accounts .................................................................................. 10
Chart 13: Number of deposit accounts ............................................................................... 10
Chart 14: NBFC-MFIs following weekly collection method performed better during
demonetisation .............................................................................................................. 11
Chart 15: Despite six states announcing farm loan waivers during past 18 months, PAR 30
portfolio for NBFC-MFIs is declining. ............................................................................ 12
Chart 16: Loan o/s per borrower in India is still significantly lower than regulatory limits of
Rs80,000 and Rs1,00,000 as set by Mfin and RBI respectively ................................... 13
Chart 17: Active Customer Retention rate of 90% is significantly higher than the median
rate of 78% for 15 leading microfinance players ........................................................... 16
37
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
Chart 18: CAGL’s customer base reported robust 37% CAGR over FY14/H1FY19 vs AuM
CAGR of 55% during the same period .......................................................................... 17
Chart 19: CAGL’s journey in retail finance .......................................................................... 19
Chart 20: Retail finance portfolio jumped ~3x to Rs1.6bn over past six months; notably,
customer base too increased at a similar pace............................................................. 20
Chart 21: CAGL’s rural customer-base stands at 82% vs industry average of 66% .......... 20
Chart 22: State-wise AuM breakup ..................................................................................... 21
Chart 23: Asset quality trend across major MFI players – CAGL stands out ..................... 22
Chart 24: Industry players with different collection methods .............................................. 23
Chart 25: MFIs that follow a weekly collection model tend to perform better in terms of
asset quality .................................................................................................................. 23
Chart 26: … PAR 90+ to lower bucket ................................................................................ 24
Chart 27: PAR 61-90 to lower bucket ................................................................................. 24
Chart 28: PAR 61-90 to lower bucket ................................................................................. 24
Chart 29: PAR 1-30 to current ............................................................................................ 24
Chart 30: Consistent decline in its per district exposure – It fell to 0.6% as at Sep’18 from
~2.4% in FY14............................................................................................................... 26
Chart 31: Contiguous district-wise expansion approach reduces exposure to any single
district ............................................................................................................................ 26
Chart 32: The share of IGLs remained at around 86% as at FY18 .................................... 27
Chart 33: CAGL per employee cost is lowest amongst key MFI players, notably despite
maintaining second-best AuM/per loan officer .............................................................. 28
Chart 34: Scope for further improvement in selected productivity metrics; lower clients per
loan officer is largely due to company’s recent expansion ........................................... 28
Chart 35: Trend in opex/AAuM ratio ................................................................................... 29
Chart 36: Well-diversified borrowing mix ............................................................................ 30
Chart 37: Positive ALM continues to contribute to growth; currently running at 6months
positive ALM .................................................................................................................. 30
Chart 38: Consistent decline in cost of borrowing .............................................................. 31
Chart 39: Yields at 22% as at Jun’18-end is in line with large NBFC-MFIs ........................ 31
Chart 40: Trend in AuM growth ........................................................................................... 33
Chart 41: Consistent decline in Cost/AAuM ratio................................................................ 34
Chart 42: Trend in Earnings ................................................................................................ 34
38
CreditAccess Grameen, December 19, 2018 ICICI Securities
This report may be distributed in Singapore by ICICI Securities, Inc. (Singapore branch). Any recipients of this report in Singapore should contact ICICI Securities,
Inc. (Singapore branch) in respect of any matters arising from, or in connection with, this report. The contact details of ICICI Securities, Inc. (Singapore branch) are
as follows: Address: 10 Collyer Quay, #37-16 Ocean Financial Tower, Singapore - 049315, Tel: +65 6232 2451 and email: navneet_babbar@icicisecuritiesinc.com,
Rishi_agrawal@icicisecuritiesinc.com.
"In case of eligible investors based in Japan, charges for brokerage services on execution of transactions do not in substance constitute charge for research reports
and no charges are levied for providing research reports to such investors."
New I-Sec investment ratings (all ratings based on absolute return; All ratings and target price refers to 12-month performance horizon, unless mentioned otherwise)
BUY: >15% return; ADD: 5% to 15% return; HOLD: Negative 5% to Positive 5% return; REDUCE: Negative 5% to Negative 15% return; SELL: < negative 15% return
ANALYST CERTIFICATION
ANALYST CERTIFICATION
We /I, Renish Bhuva, CFA (ICFAI); Research Analysts, authors and the names subscribed to this report, hereby certify that all of the views expressed in this research
report accurately reflect our views about the subject issuer(s) or securities. We also certify that no part of our compensation was, is, or will be directly or indirectly
related to the specific recommendation(s) or view(s) in this report. Analysts are not registered as research analysts by FINRA and are not associated persons of the
ICICI Securities Inc.
Terms & conditions and other disclosures:
ICICI Securities Limited (ICICI Securities) is a full-service, integrated investment banking and is, inter alia, engaged in the business of stock brokering and distribution of
financial products. ICICI Securities Limited is a SEBI registered Research Analyst with SEBI Registration Number – INH000000990. ICICI Securities Limited SEBI
Registration is INZ000183631 for stock broker. ICICI Securities is a wholly-owned subsidiary of ICICI Bank which is India’s largest private sector bank and has its
various subsidiaries engaged in businesses of housing finance, asset management, life insurance, general insurance, venture capital fund management, etc.
(“associates”), the details in respect of which are available on www.icicibank.com
ICICI Securities is one of the leading merchant bankers/ underwriters of securities and participate in virtually all securities trading markets in India. We and our
associates might have investment banking and other business relationship with a significant percentage of companies covered by our Investment Research
Department. ICICI Securities generally prohibits its analysts, persons reporting to analysts and their relatives from maintaining a financial interest in the securities or
derivatives of any companies that the analysts cover.
The information and opinions in this report have been prepared by ICICI Securities and are subject to change without any notice. The report and information contained
herein is strictly confidential and meant solely for the selected recipient and may not be altered in any way, transmitted to, copied or distributed, in part or in whole, to
any other person or to the media or reproduced in any form, without prior written consent of ICICI Securities. While we would endeavour to update the information
herein on a reasonable basis, ICICI Securities is under no obligation to update or keep the information current. Also, there may be regulatory, compliance or other
reasons that may prevent ICICI Securities from doing so. Non-rated securities indicate that rating on a particular security has been suspended temporarily and such
suspension is in compliance with applicable regulations and/or ICICI Securities policies, in circumstances where ICICI Securities might be acting in an advisory capacity
to this company, or in certain other circumstances.
This report is based on information obtained from public sources and sources believed to be reliable, but no independent verification has been made nor is its accuracy
or completeness guaranteed. This report and information herein is solely for informational purpose and shall not be used or considered as an offer document or
solicitation of offer to buy or sell or subscribe for securities or other financial instruments. Though disseminated to all the customers simultaneously, not all customers
may receive this report at the same time. ICICI Securities will not treat recipients as customers by virtue of their receiving this report. Nothing in this report constitutes
investment, legal, accounting and tax advice or a representation that any investment or strategy is suitable or appropriate to your specific circumstances. The securities
discussed and opinions expressed in this report may not be suitable for all investors, who must make their own investment decisions, based on their own investment
objectives, financial positions and needs of specific recipient. This may not be taken in substitution for the exercise of independent judgment by any recipient. The
recipient should independently evaluate the investment risks. The value and return on investment may vary because of changes in interest rates, foreign exchange
rates or any other reason. ICICI Securities accepts no liabilities whatsoever for any loss or damage of any kind arising out of the use of this report. Past performance is
not necessarily a guide to future performance. Investors are advised to see Risk Disclosure Document to understand the risks associated before investing in the
securities markets. Actual results may differ materially from those set forth in projections. Forward-looking statements are not predictions and may be subject to change
without notice.
ICICI Securities or its associates might have managed or co-managed public offering of securities for the subject company or might have been mandated by the subject
company for any other assignment in the past twelve months.
ICICI Securities or its associates might have received any compensation from the companies mentioned in the report during the period preceding twelve months from
the date of this report for services in respect of managing or co-managing public offerings, corporate finance, investment banking or merchant banking, brokerage
services or other advisory service in a merger or specific transaction.
ICICI Securities or its associates might have received any compensation for products or services other than investment banking or merchant banking or brokerage
services from the companies mentioned in the report in the past twelve months.
ICICI Securities encourages independence in research report preparation and strives to minimize conflict in preparation of research report. ICICI Securities or its
associates or its analysts did not receive any compensation or other benefits from the companies mentioned in the report or third party in connection with preparation of
the research report. Accordingly, neither ICICI Securities nor Research Analysts and their relatives have any material conflict of interest at the time of publication of this
report.
It is confirmed that Renish Bhuva, CFA (ICFAI); Research Analysts of this report have not received any compensation from the companies mentioned in the report in
the preceding twelve months.
Compensation of our Research Analysts is not based on any specific merchant banking, investment banking or brokerage service transactions.
ICICI Securities or its subsidiaries collectively or Research Analysts or their relatives do not own 1% or more of the equity securities of the Company mentioned in the
report as of the last day of the month preceding the publication of the research report.
Since associates of ICICI Securities are engaged in various financial service businesses, they might have financial interests or beneficial ownership in various
companies including the subject company/companies mentioned in this report.
It is confirmed that Renish Bhuva, CFA (ICFAI); Research Analysts do not serve as an officer, director or employee of the companies mentioned in the report.
ICICI Securities may have issued other reports that are inconsistent with and reach different conclusion from the information presented in this report.
Neither the Analysts nor ICICI Securities have been engaged in market making activity for the companies mentioned in the report.
We submit that no material disciplinary action has been taken on ICICI Securities by any Regulatory Authority impacting Equity Research Analysis activities.
This report is not directed or intended for distribution to, or use by, any person or entity who is a citizen or resident of or located in any locality, state, country or other
jurisdiction, where such distribution, publication, availability or use would be contrary to law, regulation or which would subject ICICI Securities and affiliates to any
registration or licensing requirement within such jurisdiction. The securities described herein may or may not be eligible for sale in all jurisdictions or to certain category
of investors. Persons in whose possession this document may come are required to inform themselves of and to observe such restriction.
This report has not been prepared by ICICI Securities, Inc. However, ICICI Securities, Inc. has reviewed the report and, in so far as it includes current or historical
information, it is believed to be reliable, although its accuracy and completeness cannot be guaranteed.
39