Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Keg words: transmission-line tower. grounding system. So, we think systematic research on the impulse properties of
impulse grounding resistance. simulation experiment, grounding devices of transmission-line towers, especially
impulse coefficient, regressive method. fitting formula those in high soil resistivity region, can make the lightning-
protection designs of transmission lines more reliable.
I. INTRODUCTION
The Chang-Fang 500 kV compact transmission lines, and all
With the development of power system. the failures caused by transmission lines of the Three-Gorges Power Generating
lightning striking the transmission lines have been being Station will pass through mountain regions with high soil
increased. Several methods. including unbalanced insulation. resistivity. how to well design the grounding devices of these
over-insulation. adding coupling ground wires; reducing the transmission lines and make them with good lightning
protective angles. decreasing the resistance of grounding protection properties is a problem needed to resolve. And this
devices, and installing line surge arresters on the study is part of this project.
transmission lines. It should not be suspended that reducing
the resistances of grounding devices of transmission lines is a The impulse grounding experiments of grounding devices can
very important key measure to improve the lightning be classified into actual and simulation tests. The actual test is
withstand level of transmission lines. finished on the grounding devices with actual geometric
dimensions, the real impulse property of grounding device
Usually, the impulse grounding resistance is used to measure can be obtained by this method. But in the esperiment process,
the property of grounding device of transmission-line towers. the related parameters are difficult to be changed, for example,
which is the ratio between the magnitudes of impulse voltage the soil resistivity, so the actual test can not systematically
applied on the device and the impulse current through the study the impulse property of grounding devices.
device. We know the impulse grounding resistance RI. is
directly related to the tripping out of transmission line, whxch The simulation test is performed on the simulating grounding
very strongly affects the lightning protection effect of devices with small geometric dimensions, and simulating
transmission line. When the lightning strikes the device is buried in soil or sand. The simulation test has the
transmission-line tower, the lightning flows into the earth same physical process of actual test, and these parameters
through the grounding device, the potential of the tower top is including the soil resistivity, the geometric dimensions of
grounding device, and the lightning parameters, can be easily
changed. During the test process, the main parameters can be
controlled and not be affected by other factors, so the reflected
regularity from the simulation test is accurate.
- 1 57 -
point will disperse more current into earth than the far
portion, the current distnbution is nonuniform The
punctured soil thickness around the conductor near the
current input point is larger The punctured soil region has a
cone shape as illustrated in Fig 4. The current easily
disperses into earth from this region near the current input
I-
1
-- 1
point due to blocking effect of inductance When the
geometncal lmension of a grounding device reaches certain
a length. the impulse grounding resistance reduces very small
with the increase of geometncal dimension So. the impulse
grounding resistance has a saturation trend. and the
grounding device has effective length (or effective
geoinetncal dimension)
10' ' . ' . ' I
50 100 150 200 250 300
I,, W)
80
Fig. 1 Relationship between the impulse grounding resistance
and the impulse current magnitude.
A. Influences of Impulse Current magnitude on Impulse
Grounding Resistances
The relationshp between the impulse grounding resistance
and the impulse current magnitude is descnbed in Fig 1 the 20
impulse grounding resistance decreases with the increase of
impulse current. and has a saturation trend When the
impulse current exceeds certain a value. even if the impulse
current increases largely. but the impulse grounding
resistance reduces very small It is the same conclusion in [ 10
111 from the actual field expeninents
Fig 2 Relanonship between impulse grounding resistance
Under the effect of impulse current. the electrical field around and geometncal dimension of grounding device
the conductor is a time-vanant one When the electncal field
intensity exeeds the cntic breakdonn kalue of soil Eo. then
the soil around the conductor nil1 be punctured. it is equal to
increase the diameter of the conductor We know the
grounding resistance is in direct proportion with In( lld). so it
will decreases In other hand, there is a saturation propee
between ln(1ld) and d. so there is a saturation relationship G,
between the impulse grounding resistance and the impulse
current From the evpenmental results. n e obsened this
saturation properly is different in different soil resistivity The
smaller the soil resistivity is. the loner the impulse current
value reaching the saturation trend is It is due to the soil with Fig iThe distnbution parameter model of an electrode
low resistivity has good conductivity
-158-
into earth from the far portion of the electrode. thickness around a conductor increases quickly with the soil
resistivity. According to E = yJ. The increase of soil
The relationship between the impulse grounding resistance of resistivity makes the increase of the electrical field around the
Type a and the geometrical dimension of grounding device conductors of grounding devices, then the punctured soil
under chfferent impulse current magnitudes is s h o m in Fig. 5 , thickness will increase too, which leads the grounding
we observed the effective length increases with the impulse resistance reduced. So, the influence of soil resistivity on the
current due to the increase of current leads to the increase of impulse grounding resistance becomes weakly, the increasing
current density on the surface of an electrode, more current velocity .of the impulse grounding resistance with the soil
will flow to the far part. resistivity becomes slow.
3 0 , . , . , . , . , . , . 70
25 4-zM=100~ - 60
--1,,~200kA . 50
--O-1,,=300 kA - E
v
30
K. 30
20
10 - 10
0
0 1000 2000 3000 41000 5000
. l b ' 2 b ' 3 b ' ~ 0 ' 5 b ' 6 0 P (-1
1 (m)
-159-
horizontal grounding device and vertical rods. When the
lengths are the same, the impulse grounding resistance of
vertical rod reduces 35% comparing with that of horizontal
grounding electrode (Type d).
0.6 -
(4) If the installation of grounding device is difficult, Type a
and Type c are suggested by us, they can be easily installed
and have low impulse grounding resistances. t3
0.5 -
0.4 -
0.3 -
0.2 -
-
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100110
1 (m)
-160-
soil has good conductivity, in this region, the impulse (horizontal grounding electrode).
coefficient decreases quickly and linearly with the soil
resistivity. In the soil resistivity region of 500-3000 Q.m, The calculating formula for the power frequency grounding
the soil conductivity becomes bad, the increasing velocity of resistance of vertical rod is
impulse coefficient with the soil resistivity becomes slow, and
their relationship is nonlinear. When the soil resistivity is R = -(PIn-- 8L 1) , (16)
higher than 3000 Q. m, the soil conductivity becomes very 211.L D
bad, and impulse coefficient decreases linearly with the soil here, L is the length of vertical rod in m.
resistivity, but the reducing velocity is very slow. we observed
the impulse coefficienthas a saturation trend. W.COMPARISON WITH TESTED RESULTS
IN THE ACTUAL EXPERIMENTS IN LITERATURE
VI. REGRESSIVE FORMULAS TO CALCULATE
IMPULSE COEFFICIENTS These regressive formulas can be used conveniently in the
grounding device design to estimate the impulse grounding
The impulse coefficient is an important parameter relating resistance and to improve the reliability of the design. In
the impulse property of grounding device, which can provide other hand, we can estimate the impulse grounding resistance
convenient for lightning protection design of transmission of grounding device from the tested value of power frequency
line. If we know the power frequency grounding resistance of grounding resistance. The calculated results of 20 m
a grounding device, then we can obtain the respective impulse horizontal grounding electrode in the soil with the resistivity
grounding resistance of the grounding device. It resolved the of 1OOOQ.m by these regressive formulas were compared
problem to measure the impulse grounding resistance of a with the results obtained from the actual filed experiments by
grounding device. Wen et al. [4] and Liu et al. [ 5 ] in Fig. 10, they have good
agreement each other. These regressive formulas will be
As discussed above, the impulse coefficient is related to the referenced by the new modification version of Chinese
magnitude of lightning current, geometrical dimension of the national grounding standard, and had been used in the design
grounding device, and the soil resistivity. The fitting formulas of 500 kV Chang-Fang compact transmission line.
to calculate the impulse grounding resistances for Merent
grounding devices were obtained by regression analysis from
a large amount of experimental results:
For Type a:
a = o.74p-O4(7.0t J7)[1.56 - exp(-3.01,~-~~)1 (9)
For Type b:
a = 2.94p-O5(6.O+ &)[1.23-e~p(-2.OI,-~~)] (10)
For Type c:
a = 1.36~-o(1.3 + &)[1.55- exp( -l.OI,-o )] ( 11)
For Type d:
cz = 1.62p44(5.0+ fi)[0.79-e~p(-2.31,-~~)] (12)
For Type e:
a = 1.16p-04(7.1+&)[0.78-exp(-2.31,-02)] (13)
For Type f: Fig. 10 Comparison between the calculated and the tested
results of 20 m horizontal grounding electrode in the soil with
a = 2.75p-04(1.8+~ ) [ 0 . 7 5 - e ~ p ( - 1 . 5 0 1 , - ~ ~ ) ] , (14) the resistivity of 1000 Q. m.
here, p is soil resistivity in Q'm; 1 is the geometrical
dimension in m defined in Table 1; I, is the magnitude of VIII. CONCLUSIONS
impulse current in U.
(1) The lightning protection effects of trartsmission lines are
We know the impulse grounding resistance RI is equal to aR , related to the impulse characteristics of grounding systems of
R is the power frequency grounding resistance. In order to transmission-line towers. The influences of several main
obtain the impulse grounding resistance, we must know the R. factors on impulse grounding properties were systematically
The regressive formulas to calculate the power frequency analyzed by simulation experiments according to the
grounding resistances of different grounding devices is simulation theory. The soil resistivity was changed in the
region between 100 to 5103Q-m, the variable spread was
P L2
R = -(h-+ A), (15) very large, which did not reported in literature.
2rL Dh
here, L is the total length of horizontal grounding device in m, (2) The impulse grounding resistance decreases with the
L=4S+41for Type a; L=d+41 for Type c; L =8d for Type b with increase of impulse current magnitude, and has a saturant
I=O, and L=41 with I unequal to 0; D is the diameter of trend; it decreases with the increase of geometrical
conductor in m; h the burial depth of horizontal grounding dimensions and has a saturant trend, all tested grounding
device in m,A is the shape factor, which is 1.76, 1.0. 2., and systems have effective geometrical dimensions when impulse
0, respectively for Type a, Type c, Type b, and Type d current is applied. The impulse grounding resistance
-161 -
increases with tne increase of soil resistivity and has a High Current Impulse Properties of GroundingElectrodes wth
saturant trend. The relationship curve between impulse Long-Effective Low Resistivity Matenals,” High Voltage
grounding resistance and soil resistivity can be divided into Engineenng (In Chinese), No 4, 1981, pp 1-8
three regions. [I 11 C Wen, H S Tang, and S R Yuan, “Charactenstic
Expenments of Groundlng Electrodes LI-I Bgh Resistivity
(3) By analyzing the experimental results, we concluded that Regions,” Power System Technology fin Chinese), No 9-10,
the structure of grounding system should be selected 1962,pp 30-41
according to soil resistivity, geological structure and technical 1121 P L Bellaschi, “Impulse and 60-Cycle Charactenstics of
economy analysis. The ring-type grounding system of Dnven Ground 4,” N E E Transactions, Vol 61, No 3, 1942,
concrete tower has a high impulse grounding resistance and pp 349-363
should not be adopted in the region with soil resistivity higher [ 131 P L Bellaschi, “Impulse and 60-Cycle Charactenstics of
than 1000 Q. m. The impulse grounding resistance of vertical Dnven Ground -a,’’ AIEE Transactrons, Vol62, No 3, 1943,
grounding electrode is 35% lower than that of horizontal pp 333-345
grounding electrode with the same length. [14] B R Gupta, B Thaper, “Effect of Soil Ionization on Impulse
Impedance of Grounding Electrodes,“ Journal df the
(4) Selecting correct impulse coefficients of grounding Instztzttron of Engzneenngs (Indza), Vol64, No 8, 1983, pp
devices for transmission lines is the key of lightning 51-55
protection design. The impulse coefficient increases with the [lj] A B Kopcvntsef, “Simulation of Impulse Property of
magnitude of applied impulse current and has a saturation Groundmg Device.” Elektpztestvo (In Russian), No 5 , 1958, pp
trend. It increases with the geometrical dimension. and 31-35
decreases with the soil resistivity. [ 161J L He and X L Chen, “Smulation Pnnciple of Impulse
Charactenstics of Grounding Devices of Transrmssion-line
(5) The fitting calculating formulae of impulse coefficients Towers.” JOlU““of Tsinghua Uriiversity (In Chinese), Vol34,
and power frequency grounding resistances of different No 4, 1993, pp 38-43
grounding systems were obtained by regression analysis to
experimental results. The simulating expenmental results had XI. BIOGRAPHIES
a good agreement with those of field exyeriment in literature
Dr. Jinliang He was born 111 Changsha, P R Chna,in 1966 He
(6) The research results in this paper can be used in received the B Sc degree from Wuhan Umversity of Hydraulic and
grounding system design of transmission line, and can be the Electncal Engineenng, the MSc. Degree from Chongqing
referred in the modification of grounding standards. Umversitv . and the Ph D degree from Tsmghua University, all m
Electncal Engmeenng, m July 1988, Jan 1991 and March 1994,
respeLtivel1 From Apnl 1994 to June 1996, he was a lecturer m the
M.ACKNOWLEDGMENT Electncal Engineenng Department, Tsmghua Umversity In July
1996. he became an associate professor 111 the same department
This research is a sub-project of the Chinese national Ninth- From 1994 to Jan 1997, he was the head of high voltage laboratory
Five Kev Science and Technolom Plan. in Tsinghua Umversity Since 1996, he has also held a concment
position as an associate professor in the National Key Laboratory of
X. REFERENCES Safetv, Control and Simulation of Power System in Tsinghua
Universitv Dunng Apnl 1997 to apnl 1998, he was a visiting
Chinese Standard SDJ8-79 Grounding Design Standard for scientist in Korea Electrotechnology Research Institute, involved in
Power Apparatus (m Chmese) research on metal oxide vanstor and high voltage polymenc metal
oade surge arrester HIS research mterests are in overvoltages and
R Verma, “Impulse Impedance of Buned Ground Wire,’ EMC in power systems and electromc systems, grounding
IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and System, Vol 99, No 5 technology, and power apparatus
Sept 1980, pp 2000-2007
R Velazquez, “Analytical Modeling of Groundmg Electrode Mr. Rong Zeng was born in Shanx, P R China, in 1971 He
Transient Behavior,” IEEE Trans on Power Apparatus and received his B Sc Degree from the Department of Electncal
System, Vol 103, No 6, Nov 1984, pp 1314-1322 Engineenng of Tsinghua University in 1995 And now he is a Ph D
M Darvenlza, M A Sargent, “Modeling for Lightrung candidate of Tslnghua University HIS mam research fields are hgh
Performance Calculations,” IEEE Trans. on Power .4pparatus voltage technology, groundmg technology, and the applications of
and $stem, Vol 90, No 6, Nov 1971, pp 1900-1908 electronic technology and computer
C Mazzetti, “Impulse Behavior of Ground Electrodes,” IEEE
Trans. on Power Apparatus and Syyrtem, Vol 102, No 9, Sept Dr. Shuiming Chen was bom in Zhejiang, P R Chma, in 1968 He
1983, pp 3148-3156 received his B Sc and M Sc Degrees from the Department of
T Takashma, “High Frequency Charactenstics of Impedance Electncal Engineenng of Zhejiang Umversity, in 1990 and 1993,
to Ground and Field Distnbutions of Ground Electrodes,” respectively He received hs Ph D from Tsinghua Umversity m
IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and System, Vol 100, No 3 , Feb 1997 And now he is a lecturer of Electncal Engineenng
Apnl 1981, pp 1893-1900 department of Tsinghua Umversity His main research fields are
A P Meliopoulos, “Transient Charactenstics of Grounding high voltage technology, EMC, lightning protection, and grounding
System,” IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and System, Vol technology
102, No 2, Feb 1983, pp 389-399
B P Gupta and B Thapar, “Impulse Charactenstm of Ms. Siyun Li was bom m Jiangx, P R. China, in 1975 She
Grounding Electrodes,” Joumal of the Institution of received her B Sc Degree from the Department of Electncal
Engineenng (Indza), Vol 61, No 4, 1981, pp 178-182 Engmeenng of Tsinghua Umversity m 1997 And now she is a M Sc
E D Sunde, “Surge Charactenstics of a Buned Bare Wlre,” Degree candidate of Tsmghua Umversity Her main researLh field>
MEE Transactions, Vol 59, 1940, pp 987-991 are grounding technology, fault-analysis and electromc technological
J Liu, L Y Ye, X P Zhang, and G R Xia, “Study on the application
-162-