Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
You are West in the auctions below, playing ‘Standard Acol’ with a weak no-trump (12-14 points) and 4-card majors.
1. Dealer West. Love All. 4. Dealer West. Game All. 7. Dealer East. Love All. 10. Dealer North. Love All.
♠ 4 ♠ J 6 ♠ 3 2 ♠ 4 3 2
N N N N
♥ A 9 7 3 W E
♥ A K 8 7 6 W E
♥ A Q 10 9 W E
♥ K Q 8 6 5 W E
♦ A 10 4 3 S ♦ A J 3 2 S ♦ 8 7 6 3 S ♦ 9 3 S
♣ A J 5 2 ♣ 7 2 ♣ A 10 5 ♣ 9 7 6
West North East South West North East South West North East South West North East South
? 1♥ 1NT Dbl 2♣ 1♠ 2♥ 1♣ 1♠ Pass
? ? ?
2. Dealer East. Love All. 5. Dealer West. N/S Game. 8. Dealer East. Game All. 11. Dealer East. Love All.
♠ J 8 7 6 5 ♠ K Q J 10 9 8 7 ♠ A K 7 6 ♠ 3 2
N N N N
♥ 4 W E
♥ Void ♥ 7 2 ♥ 8 7 W E
W E W E
♦ A 7 6 5 4 S ♦ 4 3 2 S ♦ A 9 8 3 S ♦ 9 5 4 3 S
♣ 3 2 ♣ 6 5 4 ♣ K 9 3 ♣ 10 7 6 5 2
West North East South West North East South West North East South West North East South
1♠ Pass 3♠ Dbl Pass 4♥ 1♥ Pass 2♣ Pass
? ? 1♠ Pass 2♦ Pass 2♦ Pass 2♠ Pass
? 2NT Pass 3♥ Pass
?
3. Dealer West. Love All. 6. Dealer West. Game All. 9. Dealer West. Love All. 12. Dealer North. Game All.
♠ A K 2 ♠ Q 3 2 ♠ A K 8 5 4
♠ 6 4 2
N N N N
♥ A K 7 6 ♥ K Q 9 3 ♥ K Q 3 2 ♥ 5 4 2
W E W E W E W E
♦ Q 5 4 S ♦ A 2 S ♦ K 7 S ♦ 8 3 S
♣ K 9 4 ♣ A 9 8 6 ♣ 6 2 ♣ K Q 6 5 3
West North East South West North East South West North East South West North East South
1♥ 1♠ Pass Pass 1♥ Pass 2♥ Pass 1♠ Pass 1NT Pass 1NT Dbl Pass
? ? 2♥ Pass 2♠ Pass ?
?
Individual DVDs. £25 each. Individual DVDs. £25 each. Individual DVDs. £25 each.
Boxed Set of 6. £100. Boxed Set of 6. £100. Boxed Set of 6. £100.
Make your cheque payable to Mr Bridge and send to: Mr Bridge, Ryden Grange, Knaphill, Surrey GU21 2TH
( 01483 489961 www.mrbridge.co.uk/mrbridge-shop
FEATURES 8 Bridge Event
BRIDGE
1 Bidding Quiz Booking Form Mr Bridge
by Bernard Magee 8 Bridge Events with
5 Mr Bridge Bernard Magee AT THE
Ryden Grange, Knaphill, 9 Defence Quiz 9 Bridge Events at: ROYAL KENZ
Surrey GU21 2TH by Julian Pottage Elstead Hotel
Blunsdon House Hotel TUNISIA
( 01483 489961 11 David Stevenson
Answers Your Questions 10 Bernard Magee’s
e-mail: Tutorial Software
Half-board
13 Declarer Play Quiz Duplicate Bridge
bridge@mrbridge.co.uk by David Huggett 12 Duplicate Bridge
website: Rules Simplified Holidays
15 Bidding Quiz Answers
www.mrbridge.co.uk (1-3) by Bernard Magee 14 Wentworth Jigsaws
17 Real Results at Our Club 15 Defence
Publisher and by Hugh Tarran with Bernard Magee
Managing Editor 19 Bidding Quiz Answers 16 Embrace the Middle
Mr Bridge (4-6) by Bernard Magee East Crackers
21 Bidding Quiz Answers 16 Bridge Events at:
Bridge Consultant Chatsworth House
(7-9) by Bernard Magee
Bernard Magee Ardington Hotel
23 Bidding Quiz Answers
Technical Consultant (10-12) by Bernard Magee 18 Bridge Cloths
Tony Gordon 26 Things You Should 18 Pens
Know About . . . 18 Bridge Events at
Typesetting & Design by Andrew Kambites The Olde Barn Hotel
Ruth Edmondson 27 Weak Twos 18 Bridge Tie
by Andrew Kambites 19 Declarer Play
Proof Readers
30 WeakTwos Quiz by with Bernard Magee
Tony & Jan Richards Andrew Kambites 20 Denham Grove
Catrina Shackleton Filming Events
31 Defence Quiz Answers
Richard Wheen by Julian Pottage 23 Feb – 9 March 2014
20 Mr Bridge Christmas
Hugh Williams 32 Julian Pottage & New Year 2013/2014 Bernard Magee
elizabeth@mrbridge.co.uk ADVERTISEMENTS 41 Charity Events Pay £70 per fortnight per person
extra and have a garden-facing
2 Bernard Magee DVDs 42 S R Designs Bridge Tables room, tea & coffee making
All correspondence should 3 Tunisia 2013/2014 45 Mr Bridge 2014 Diaries facilities, bath robe and a bowl of
seasonal fruit.
be addressed to Mr Bridge. 4 Mr Bridge 46 Begin Bridge These holidays have been
Please make sure that all Just Duplicate Bridge organised for Mr Bridge by Tunisia
with Bernard Magee
letters and e-mails carry First Limited, ATOL 5933.
£50
28 Feb – 2 March £199 18-20 July £199
Chatsworth Hotel Blunsdon
31 Jan – 2 Feb £199 House Hotel
OFF*
Elstead Hotel
28 Feb – 2 March £199
Blundson House Hotel 1-3 August £169
31 Jan – 2 Feb £199 The Olde Barn
Just Duplicate Events
Chatsworth Hotel in 2014. See page 5
14-16 March £199
for terms and
Blundson House Hotel conditions. 12-14 September £169
The Olde Barn
14-16 March £169
The Olde Barn 10-12 October £199
Blunsdon
13-15 June £169 House Hotel
21-23 March £199 The Olde Barn
Chatsworth Hotel
10-12 October £199
28-30 March £199 Elstead Hotel
Ardington Hotel Denham Grove
Worthing BN11 3DZ
17-19 October £169
28-30 March £199 The Olde Barn
31 Jan – 2 Feb £199 Elstead Hotel
Clifton Park Hotel
24-26 October £199
Lytham St Annes
25-27 April £199 Chatsworth
Blundson House Hotel Hotel
7-9 February £199 Chatsworth Hotel
Denham Grove Worthing BN11 3DU
21-23 February £199 Elstead Hotel 11-13 July £169 Chatsworth Hotel
Blundson House Hotel Bournemouth, BH1 3QP The Olde Barn Worthing BN11 3DU
£50
the 2014 Tutorial Filming neglected. As they have a
EXTRA DATE
weekend has now expired. serious programme of
If you missed your chance, A new venue has been refurbishment in hand
try a bit earlier next year. added to our listing of Just their management has
Duplicate events. come up with a mind
SCOTLAND 31 January – 2 February boggling deal that simply
OFF
Clifton Park Hotel, cannot be missed.
Lytham St Annes, Lancs.
Readers from the north- Tutorial events at £215 no
west, here is your chance. single supplement. If a
double or twin bedded
The fun of duplicate lies in room is shared, there is an
the numbers, so to be
NEW YEAR’S EVE
additional charge of £35
certain of these, most of the As usual I am going to the making it £250 for the two
Bernard Magee goes to places are sold ahead of the New Year’s Eve Gala occupants sharing. I do
The Queensferry Hotel on event at special prices. Dinner at Denham Grove. hope this is clear as it seems
14-16 March. This venue Payment is taken in full at I’m hoping to stay on for a too good to be true.
overlooks the Firth of Forth the time of booking, by game afterwards and
and is now under new cheque or debit card. I have looking forward to meeting It is so good I am sure they
management. Book early to extended this offer so that it as many people as possible. will never be able to repeat
avoid disappointment. closes 8 January. See you there. it. Call Jessica for details.
BRIDGE
There are a few bridge Jenna Hoyt, driving force
players’ diaries still in of the rescue home for
stock. Standard or luxury children in Addis Ababa,
versions as per mail order has been diverted by a child
form on page 7. of her own, Zöe, already
Make sure you fourteen months old. Time
don’t miss your GIFT SUGGESTIONS flies by. She tells me, ‘thank
favourite monthly all your readers for saving
Either or both of the David the used stamps and for
articles. Bird Robin Hood Books. buying the second hand
Send 4 postage stamps per software.’ Please keep
book or use PayPal at our We are filling up for the saving the stamps and I will
online shop. Both make festive season earlier than provide details of where
excellent stocking fillers. usual this year. As a result, and to whom to send them
SPECIAL Ball point pens with a
we have put on an extra when space permits.
event between Christmas
OFFER built-in torch at the other
and New Year in north-
end. Boxed £5 inc p&p. ANTIQUITY
PRICE west England.
Quality silver-coloured key Mrs Bridge and I join
ring with a spring loaded Inn on the Prom, Lytham Aegean Odyssey in March
reusable pound-sized coin. 27-29 December 2013 on a lovely Voyage that
Boxed £5 inc p&p. Signals and Discards includes the Holy Land. I
Bernard Magee £245 am really looking forward
l Acol Bidding Bernard Magee’s Tutorial No single supplement. to visiting these historic
Quiz & Answers CDs, See page 2.
Bernard Magee sites. I am also looking
A year’s subscription to BRIDGE forward to going to the
l Ask Julian Pottage BRIDGE from £20. See Black Sea in Autumn 2014.
adjacent mail order form. For those who would like
l Julian’s FAQs See the advert for both in
their friends to receive an
the centrefold or better still,
l Misleading Cases as occasional copy of this
CHRISTMAS ring for a brochure.
reported by R Wheen magazine, do send in their
CRUISE ( 01483 489961.
details using the form on
l Ask David Stevenson
the edge of page 7.
l David’s FAQs TIME OF YEAR
If you do and have not
l Mary’s First Lesson recently registered, please It is the season for saying
do likewise. thank you. So, to all my
l Helpful Conventions
and Related Quiz
office staff, my growing
army of weekend hosts and
l Defence Quiz This year’s Christmas QPLUS 11
helpers and my advertisers
cruise is on m.v. Voyager All the outstanding
l Tales from and sponsors, a great big
hosted by Sandy Bell and trade-in and new orders
Sherwood Forest thank you. And this year,
Graham Crane. See the have now been sent out.
by David Bird whether she likes it or not it
back page for an outline or
is time to say a great big
l Things You telephone for a brochure. Here are some more
thank you to Ruth
Should Know... Our bridge room has been interesting hands for your
Edmondson, my typesetter
improved and can now hold amusement.
l Catching up extraordinaire and her
up to 15 tables. 6001-13 2683-13
l Seven Days team of consultants and
8677-12 6071-05 proof–readers.
l Jeremy Dhondy 2014 ON VOYAGER 6071-10
And another great big
l Sally Brock Tip Next year’s cruising on thank you, to you, the
l Travel Tip board Voyager will have BARON FOR MAC readers, as without your
bridge on every sailing with Bridge Baron 24 has just enthusiastic support
l Readers Letters my experienced hosts been published. See mail BRIDGE would not be the
providing on board tuition order form for details. magazine it currently is.
Special Introductory on days at sea and a
Subscription: £20 for duplicate after dinner every Best wishes for me are love,
twelve monthly issues. evening. For full details see BRIDGE TABLES peace and blessings, so that
See adjacent form. page 39. ( 01483 489961 is what I wish for you, too.
If you are looking for a
for brochures or bookings. bridge table see page 42. Mr Bridge
Address..............................................................................................................................................................................
...............................................
E-mail ....................................
Please book ..... places for me at £....... per person, 20-22 Olde Barn Hotel
£245 Finding Slams
Single .... Double .... Twin ....
Chatsworth Hotel OCTOBER 2014
Name of Hotel/Centre............................................................. Worthing BN11 3DU
3-5 Chatsworth
Hotel
Date(s) ....................................................................................
JANUARY 2014 £245 Game Tries
Mr/Mrs/Miss ......................................................................... 10-13 Denham Grove 10-12 Olde Barn Hotel
£399 Filming £245 Endplay &
Address................................................................................... Weekend Avoidance
by Julian Pottage
(Answers on page 31)
1. ♠ K 3. ♠ Q
♥ A 7 5 ♥ A 7 5
♦ A Q J 9 6 5 ♦ Q J 9 8 6 5
♣ A 8 2 ♣ A 8 2
♠ Q 10 7 2 ♠ J 10 9 6
N N
♥ K J 6 W E ♥ K J 6
W E
♦ 10 4 S ♦ K 4 S BRIDGE EVENTS
♣ Q 9 6 4 ♣ J 9 5 4
BRIDGE
10-12 January 2014 £199
EVENTS Just Duplicate Bridge
West North East South West North East South
1♦ Pass 1NT 1NT
10-12 Jan 2014 £199 Pass 3NT End Pass 3NT End 21-23 February £199
Just Duplicate Bridge Just Duplicate Bridge
You lead the ♠2, won by You lead the ♠J. Partner
the ♠A (♠5 from South). wins with the ♠A and 28 Feb – 2 March £199
24-26 January £199
Partner returns the ♠4, returns the ♠4, covered by Just Duplicate Bridge
Just Duplicate Bridge
covered by the ♠J. What the ♠5. How do you
do you do? defend?
14-16 March £199
31 Jan – 2 Feb £199
Just Duplicate Bridge
Just Duplicate Bridge
Distributional Hands
returns the ♠5, on which plays the ♣7 (high encour-
Full Board South plays the ♠J. What ages, low discourages) and Full Board
No Single Supplement do you do? South the ♣4. How do No Single Supplement
you continue?
Booking Form on page 8. Booking Form on page 8.
Make your cheque payable to Mr Bridge and send to: Mr Bridge , Ryden Grange, Knaphill, Surrey GU21 2TH
( 01483 489961 www.mrbridge.co.uk/mrbridge-shop Fax 01483 797302
System Requirements: Windows XP, Vista, 7 or 8, 8mb RAM, CD-ROM
David Stevenson answers your questions on Laws and Ethics
Is Landy
Alerted or
Announced?
Q Q
Does my partner this way. When he corrects In a duplicate ing at the time of the
have to alert his revoke you may change session at my incident. Half the tables
or announce your card. Furthermore, your local club, I were not in spades.
when we use Landy card is now unauthorised was declarer in 3♠. On One had made 3♠ and
as our defence to information to him but completion of trick 7, another had gone two
a 1NT opening? authorised to your partner. an opponent dropped down so the director
Evan St Clair Sepion I have checked in Hoyle’s a card on the floor. She decided that my ‘two
by email. Games Modernised and put her cards face down down’ needed no adjust-
the rule would be exactly on the table and, after ment. I said that I ac-
A
Your partner has to the same in whist. some considerable time cepted her decision, but
alert it. Currently, and effort, retrieved it. I felt I had been placed
announcements ♣♦♥♠ After playing another in an unfair position.
are solely by opener or two tricks, she realised The player who dropped
Q
responder, though since they Further to she had only three cards her card and, more
are popular, their use may your answer in her hand instead of importantly, messed up
be extended in the future. in BRIDGE, four. I called the director her hand after retriev-
September 2013, does who took another five ing it, escaped without
♣♦♥♠ the requirement for the minutes or so to estab- any form of penalty. Do
boards to remain on the lish what had happened you consider this fair?
Q
The ♦10 was led table throughout play and look through the Name and address supplied.
on my left, my also apply to the boards tricks. She then said to
A
partner following not being played? proceed and she would It seems the director
with a small diamond, At our club, one assess whether I had handled it very badly,
RHO discarded and I person, whilst leaving been disadvantaged on though missing cards
took the trick with the the board being played completion of the ses- are a problem. Not allowing
♦K. RHO apologised, on the table, insists on sion. Although it was everyone to have their say is
picked up his discard putting the remaining I who had called the always wrong, though silenc-
and put down the ♦A. I boards on the floor. director, she cut off my ing people who all want to
picked up my ♦K to play Is this allowed? succinct explanation of talk at the same time is rea-
a lower card, but RHO Peter Godfrey by email. what had happened and sonable and often necessary.
said I could not do this. asked questions of the When the card was found
A
What is correct and There are no laws defenders who talked it is put back in the hand
does your answer about other boards. over each other. A dia- and play continues. It is
also apply to whist? Partly it is a matter mond was then led. After unfortunate that there was
Joan Taylor, of custom and practice, or such a delay and discus- so much faffing around that
West Wickham, Kent. a club could make a rule. sion I could not remem- you lost concentration. It
Nevertheless, no player ber how many had gone is difficult to see what was
A
I think your opponent has a right to upset another or the precise trump being said if the facts were as
is trying it on with so this matter should be position. I went down simple and clear as you said.
you. Of course he by agreement, not by by two tricks instead of Nevertheless, there seems no
cannot gain from a revoke in being tiresome about it. the one I was anticipat- reason for any adjustment.
Q
Can I open 2♣ was declarer asked claimer does not, then the claim with no statement, the
without 23 HCP? to state her proposed director is not required to director will often consider
I had a 20 count method of play. It was ask the declarer to state silly mistakes, though not
with a singleton king, quite clear that had she the line of play later. It is completely stupid ones. For
so I opened 2♣ forcing been allowed to play, often pointless asking later example, if there is a finesse
my partner to bid. or state her proposed because claims are often to be taken players do mess
The opposition said method of play, that all contested because declarer up their entries and the
that this was not allowed. the tricks would have has overlooked something, director can allow for that.
Bruce Stevens by email. been made. The only but once the director is called However, he would never
way they could not have and the claim contested, assume that a player would
A
Your opponents are been made was, not by the claimer will realise play a king under an ace.
wrong. Certainly unreasonable play, but what the item overlooked The results at other tables
there are rules, by really stupid play. is and will get it right. are not relevant: we have all
which are often published Declarer is not a ‘stupid’ Apparently, your declarer got bottoms from misplaying
in this column, but it is legal player, in fact she is did not give a line of play hands when every other
to open 2♣ with any hand very experienced and and it is now correct that table made the contract.
of 16 HCP or more, though claimed to save time. the director will decide I do not know what the
not necessarily sensible. The director continued how the play goes, though actual ruling should be on
to insist that it was standing at the table and this board without seeing
♣♦♥♠ possible to play the cards discussing it is not best. it, but I strongly advise
in a manner that would As with other judgement declarer to make a statement
Q
Declarer, in 1NT, result in tricks being lost rulings, the director should of her line in future.
claimed the and declarer continued take it away, consider and
remaining tricks to protest that she wasn’t consult and come back ♣♦♥♠
with about 6 cards still going to play them like with a number of tricks.
Q
to play. The opponents that. She tried to explain When a claim is made, Can you touch
disputed this (very nicely) what her method of doubtful points (as a matter the bidding
and the (EBU Qualified) play would have been, of law) are always decided box when it is
director was immediately but the director refused against the claimer. not your turn to bid?
called. The situation to listen. The director After deciding the Raihana Ehsanullah, Bucks.
was explained and she then declared that she number of tricks, the
A
stated that she, the was going to ‘void’ the director tells both sides While this is a bad
director, would play the board and walked away and if one side does not habit, there is no
remaining hands (all 4 from the table. She like it they can appeal. actual rule to prevent
of them) and see if it was was overheard saying Giving average plus and it. A few people do this,
possible to NOT make to someone else, that minus is illegal, an idea from it’s not a good idea, but
all the remaining tricks the board would be the 1950s. The director has tolerated.
and that she was allowed scored as average plus
to do this by applying a (60%) to the opponents
methodology of ‘careless and average minus
play’. She started to
do this and declarer
(40%) to declarer.
We got a bottom on
DUPLICATE BRIDGE
protested that she was
not intending to play the
that board because of the
director’s ruling, when
RULES SIMPLIFIED
remaining cards in the every other pair in the
manner proposed by the room made the contract.
(otherwise known as the Yellow Book)
director. The situation Would you have
was getting rather handled this situation in
by John Rumbelow and only
heated and the director’s this manner and was the
husband, also a qualified director’s ruling correct? revised by David Stevenson £595
director, come over and Patricia Watson by email.
started to advise the
A
current director and I certainly would not Available from Mr Bridge ( 01483 489961
declarer (and read from have handled it as
Mr Bridge’s Yellow Book) the director did, but
Q
should have been 2♠ not Can a director ♥ A Q 10 3 ♥ 10 8 6 4
4♠ as the pass card, hav- impose penalties ♦ 8 7 6 5 ♦ A 7 3
ing been seen, constitut- or sanctions, ♣ Q 5 4 ♣ K J 3
ed the bid. South main- beyond the normal N N
tained that any calling of penalties, against a W E W E
the director should have player who regularly S S
A
I would have ruled
A
that the contract It is legal for the
was 4♠. Whether director to penalise 2. ♠ A 6 4. ♠ K J 7 5 3
the change from pass to 3♠ a player for any ♥ Q 9 7 5 ♥ J 10 9
was legal or not, by bid- repeated offences, no ques- ♦ A 4 3 ♦ K 6 4
ding on, the opposition tion. Whether it is appropri- ♣ K J 7 3 ♣ 10 3
have accepted the change ate is another matter. If a
N N
so 3♠ was the bid made. player is very elderly and/or W E W E
Certainly, the opponents a bit scatty, it does not seem S S
250-pc puzzle shown here, Size Was Offer £ Qty Sub Total
includes ‘‘Season’s Greetings’’ 100-pc puzzle 14 x 10 ’’ £24.95 £22.46
whimsy shapes. Actual puzzle
dimensions (10” x 14”). 250-pc puzzle 14 x 10‘‘ £26.95 £24.26
500-pc puzzle 20 x 14 ‘‘ £52.95 £47.66
Peace-of-Mind Guarantee 750-pc puzzle 23 x 17 ‘‘ £79.95 £71.96
In the unlikely event that you are 1000-pc puzzle 29 x 20 ‘‘ £99.95 £89.96
less than delighted with your puzzle, Giftwrap. Add £2 per puzzle
Our unique
return it within 30 days of receipt for a Print Gift tag message here:
Peace-of-Mind
full refund
Guarantee
Puzzle UK P&P from £4.25
whimsies
In the unlikely event that FREE
Request Your Free you are less than delighted
with your puzzle, return it Total
within 30 days of receipt
26 page Catalogue Today Our classic laser-cut wooden Make for
cheques/POs payable to Wentworth Wooden Jigsaw Co Ltd
a full refund
puzzles feature our unique Card No or debit my Visa/Mastercard/Switch/Maestro account:
Quote ‘MB13X1’ “whimsical” shapes that reflect
the theme of the image.
Security Code
Start Date Exp Date last 3 digits on back
Issue No
DEFENCE
2. Dealer East. Love All. The Interactive Way of Improving Your Defence
♠ J 8 7 6 5 ♠ A K 9 4 2 with Bernard Magee
N
♥ 4 ♥ 7 6 5
W E
♦ A 7 6 5 4 S ♦ K Q 3 Contents (20 hands each)
♣ 3 2 ♣ 10 9
l Lead vs No-trump Contracts l Attitude Signals
£76
make a supporting bid: raising your
partner. How high should you bid? System Requirements
Using the losing trick count, you have Windows XP, Vista, 7 or 8,
8 losers and five trumps, so this would 8mb RAM, CD-ROM
including postage and packing
suggest 3♠ or with a push 4♠. When I
have 5-card support for my partner’s See Mail Order Form on page 7.
opening major and a weak hand with at
I enclose a cheque payable to Embrace the Middle East 21-23 February Overcalls £215
Please take payment from my credit/debit card as below: 14-16 March Take-Out Doubles £215
(Improvers)
Card No.
11-13 April Hand Evaluation £215
Valid from Expiry date
Security code Maestro Issue No. Full Board – No Single Supplement
(the last 3 digits from the signature strip on the back of your debit/credit card) Booking Form on page 8.
I
’ve come to realise from observing bridge players that anything may happen on a hand. Bidding and play rarely follow
the ‘recommended’ bidding and play. So although a ‘recommended line’ is useful for learning, there are several outcomes
to each bridge hand and this can be understood only by comparing actual results from a bridge club. Comparison with
other bridge players provides learning and often helps build confidence for new players who feel they fail if they do not use the
‘recommended’ bids. In this article, I look at some ordinary hands from our (mainly Acol) club as examples.
Bridge Tie
Declarer Play
£76
System Requirements Counting losing tricks, you must
Windows XP, Vista, 7 or 8, remember to devalue your queens by
8mb RAM, CD-ROM themselves. In spades, you should count
including postage and packing
2½ losers: this gives 6½ in total; not
See Mail Order Form on page 7.
enough to try for game. ■
TRUMP CONTROL
The Olde Handling the play of the hand when trumps break badly is
an important attribute: playing calmly and using a variety
BV901 ALBERT BLACK BV908 MULE BROWN BV119 OUTDOOR MULE BLACK
BV902 ALBERT BROWN BV907 MULE BLACK BV95 OUTDOOR MULE BROWN BV118 SUEDE MOCCASIN BLACK BV94 SUEDE MOCCASIN BROWN
10-PACK OF MEN’S
GENTLE-GRIP SOCKS tailored quality outstanding prices
NOW ONLY
0871 911 7044 * QUOTE
34301
19
*Calls cost 10 pence per minute from a standard BT landline. Calls from other networks and mobiles may vary.
£ .99
RRP £30
www.samuelwindsorshoes.co.uk/34301
Post to: Samuel Windsor (34301), PO Box 87, Brecon, LD3 3BE
ITEM DESCRIPTION CODE QTY SIZE PRICE TOTAL
Haifa
and on-board gratuities, you'll Jerusalem
Israel
Syros
Santorini Bodrum
Antalya
Kos Fethiye
also find exceptional value for money. Rhodes
join
Hosted by
MR & MRS
Bernard bridge
Magee and team
AUGUST 21, 2014 OCTOBER 7, 201
M
28-30 March – £199
Just Duplicate Bridge r Bridge has you not to reinvent the Third Criterion
4-6 April – £169 invited me to wheel: the large number of
Rubber / Chicago write a new series homegrown systems that In real life, does it gain or
Diana Holland
entitled, ‘Things you should I see at club level have the lose? I am afraid that Gerber
4-6 July 2014 – £199 know about . . .’ I have disadvantage of bypassing fails my test.
Just Duplicate Bridge started with 12 articles on the accumulated experience In real life, people regu-
the most important aspects of experts over many years. larly have misunderstand-
Full Board
of the uncontested auction. Other articles will feature ings about when 4♣ is or
No Single Supplement
Some of my articles will be common conventional bids. isn’t Gerber. Bridge is a
Booking Form on page 8. on basic bridge knowledge. I have criteria I apply to game played by fallible hu-
The emphasis will be on conventions. man beings and any con-
explaining why something vention which does not rec-
is the recommended path, ognise this is flawed.
RUBBER / rather that just telling you First Criterion Whatever the merits of a
what to do. Too many convention, do understand
CHICAGO people decide on a system Any convention invariably that all conventions need
as though it is a series of replaces a natural bid. discussion and such discus-
EVENTS unconnected decisions. For example, the best of sion can only take place in a
Any good system is all conventions, Stayman, regular partnership.
Chatsworth Hotel an integrated whole, put prevents you from signing If you sit down for a casual
Worthing BN11 3DU
together as a result of many off in 2♣. Is that a price session opposite somebody
7-9 February 2014 years of experience by strong worth paying? The answer is you hardly know, you might
with Sheila Rogers players. One part affects the a very strong Yes. Finding a both agree to play red suit
rest. For example, I will be 4-4 major suit fit is far more transfers, but that does not
Denham Grove recommending that you important than signing off necessarily mean you mean
Bucks UB9 5DG open all balanced hands in in 2♣. the same thing.
4-6 April the 12-14 point range with My articles try to
with Diana Holland 1NT, even if you have a weak anticipate problems, for
doubleton. There are huge Second Criterion example, if 1NT is doubled,
hidden gains by doing this, is 2♣ still Stayman? If you
The Olde Barn for example, if you open 1♠ How often does it occur? If and your partner both
Marston, and rebid 2♥, you guarantee the answer is every week, study my ideas and accept
Lincs NG32 2HT five spades. Of course, you it is worth the effort in them, you should find them
29-31 August may decide not to accept learning it and you won’t helpful.
with Diana Holland my recommendation about forget it at the table. If it I will also try to advise
opening 1NT with a small occurs once a year, then you whether your partner’s
doubleton, but then you inevitably one of you will bid needs announcing or
£169 Full Board must accept that there are get it wrong. Of course, alerting under current EBU
No Single Supplement drawbacks that you might the more you play with a rules.
Booking Form on page 8. not have anticipated. I partner, the more ambitious Good luck, and enjoy
would strongly advise you can be in your system. your bridge. ■
Weak
Twos
A
n opening bid of 2♥ or to ruff the clubs good. On the other would suggest that you have a guilty
2♠ shows a 6-card suit hand, suppose you try playing it in no- conscience about your pre-empt.
and 6-10 points. trumps. The defenders will find it easy So does it matter if you mislead
to cut you off from the spade suit and partner? After all, you will be
Some pairs prefer to play it as 5-9, or you will end up having to lead away misleading two opponents and only
maybe 5-9 when non-vulnerable, but from the tenaces in the East hand: a one partner.
6-10 if vulnerable. That is a matter of pretty horrific prospect. The biggest gain comes when
personal choice. opponents are strong and you bully
Some pairs play weak two bids in the ♣♦♥♠ them out of their best contract. The
major suits as part of Benjaminised greatest cost comes when partner is
I
Acol. Others play 2♦ as a weak two bid f you open a weak 2♥ or strong and misjudges. If you are in
as well – a method known as ‘Three 2♠, usually you should not second seat, one of your opponents
weak twos.’ have four cards in the other has passed already. That increases
major. the chances that your partner may be
♣♦♥♠ strong. To see the dangers of this, look
This is because the responses are so at Layout B.
G
enerally, opener should geared to playing in opener’s suit. If
have a good suit and you choose to open 2♠ when you also
most of his points in his have 4 hearts, you have no chance Layout B
long suit so that responder can whatsoever of finding a 4-4 heart fit. ♠ A 8 6 5 4 3 ♠ 9
judge accurately what to do. In practice, you might well miss a 5-4 ♥ K 8 6 5 N ♥ Q J 7 3 2
W E
heart fit, as seen in Layout B. ♦ 8 6 S ♦ A K 7 5
The reason is that, if you have a weak ♣ 2 ♣ A 7 6
hand but a strong suit, unless that suit ♣♦♥♠
is trumps, the hand may well prove
I
useless. f you decide to depart from West North East South
the strict criteria for weak Pass
twos, the best time to do so 2♠ All Pass
Layout A is third in hand: the worst is
♠ K Q J 7 6 5 ♠ 8 second in hand.
♥ 8 6 N ♥ A Q 3 2 West’s 2♠ pre-empt in second seat is
W E
♦ J 10 2 S ♦ K 8 3 This is true for pre-empts in general. highly undisciplined. The spades are
♣ 6 5 ♣ A Q 7 4 2 The reasoning is this. If you pre-empt, weak (poor intermediates) and he has
then, provided your pre-empts are 4 hearts. East has a misfitting 14 points
predictable, partner is in the privileged and could not see where 10 tricks for
The hands don’t fit well but, if spades position of being the player at the table game could come from so, correctly,
are trumps, you will probably make 4 best able to know what is going on. he passed. Of course, 4♥ is the right
or 5 spade tricks. You will also be able From now on, he will take decisions. contract.
to use spades (by trumping) as entries For example, if the opponents overcall Third in hand, the situation is very
to the West hand to take finesses. It is and he doubles, that is for penalties different. East has passed already so he
even possible that you might be able and if you remove his double, that cannot have the East hand in
I
if you do so regularly, your convention f your partner opens a weak powerhouse (as in Layout E), delighted
card must say so. Whatever your two bid and you have a to double South if he dares enter the
agreement, I would doubt if there is misfit, be cautious in the auction. Or East could just be pre-
a good player in the country playing bidding. empting North/South out of their
weak two bids who would not open 2♠ rightful dues as in Layout F. South has
on Hand C, third in hand with only Layout A demonstrates a hand where no way of knowing.
the opponents vulnerable. Passing is East has good opening values but
an open invitation for opponents to can only pass West’s 2♠ opening bid. ♣♦♥♠
bid and make 4♥. Looking at Layout A, the correct
O
contract is 2♠. Even that modest pposite a weak two
contract could fail if finesses lose and bid, a change of suit is
Hand C spades break 4-2. natural and forcing.
♠ K Q J 10 9
♥ 9 8 ♣♦♥♠ Partner will expect a 6-card suit:
♦ J 10 9 8 maybe a very good 5-card suit can be
I
♣ 7 4 f your partner opens a weak justified.
two, usually the correct It is a wide ranging principle of pre-
contract has his suit as empting that, unless the pre-empt
Sadly, there are some opponents who trumps. runs into a penalty double, you should
would object. Provided they have not try to ‘rescue’ partner. Suppose
not been misinformed, no laws have In Layout E, West opens 2♠. East partner opens a weak 2♥.
been broken. Perhaps they would not realises there is a misfit but, with this
do it. We all need to understand that excellent hand, game is obvious. The
nobody at the bridge table has the only good game contract is 4♠ and Hand G Hand H
right to impose their judgement on that is what East should bid. ♠ Q J 8 7 6 5 ♠ Q J 8 7 6 5
others. Intolerance drives people away ♥ Void ♥ Void
from the game. ♦ A Q 6 3 ♦ A Q 6 3
Layout E ♣ Q 3 2 ♣ A K 2
♣♦♥♠ ♠ K Q J 7 6 5 ♠ 8
♥ 8 6 N ♥ A K 3 2
F
W E
ourth in hand, it makes ♦ J 10 2 S ♦ A K 3 With Hand G, you have no option but
sense for a weak two bid ♣ 6 5 ♣ A Q 7 4 2 to pass. Yes, 2♠ might be better but
to show 10-14 points and you don’t have the option of playing in
a 6-card suit. 2♠. If you try 2♠, what are you going to
Try comparing this with Layout F. do if partner rebids 3♥?
If 3 players have passed, you are highly With Hand H, you have not given
unlikely to have fewer than 10 points. up on game, so start with 2♠. Partner
Layout F will try to avoid rebidding his hearts
♠ K Q J 7 6 5 ♠ A 8 3 2 and should support you with ♠K-2 or
Hand D ♥ 8 6 N ♥ 9 4 3 ♠4-3-2. If he just rebids 3♥, I would
W E
♠ 9 7 ♦ J 10 2 S ♦ K 9 6 5 4 give up on game and pass.
♥ A Q J 7 6 5 ♣ 6 5 ♣ 4
♦ K Q 6 ♣♦♥♠
♣ 10 4
A
The bidding is identical. West opens direct raise of a weak
2♠ and East raises to 4♠. This time, two to the three level
Of course, this hand qualifies for a 1♥ East is not expecting to make 4♠. He is pre-emptive, not a
bid, but you don’t really want to start a is aware of the excellent East/West game try.
I
If West is minimum, 3♥ may fail 3
High enough. If West has at most f you open a weak two bid,
but, in that case, surely North/South 8 points and two top honours, he you must never bid again
can make 3♠ or even 4♠. It is sensible cannot have anything outside trumps. unless your partner invites
to make it hard for North/South to Looking at the two hands, you can see you to do so.
enter the auction. Note that West is that 4♥ requires both red suit finesses
maximum for 2♥ but doesn’t double- to work: not good odds. This is a statement of the obvious
cross East by raising 3♥ to 4♥. because it is true for all pre-emptive
In Layout L, the 2NT asking bid gets a bids.
♣♦♥♠ reply promising more points. However, let me stress it. Suppose
you open 2♥ with this hand.
O
pposite a weak two
bid, a 2NT response Layout L
is conventional and ♠ A 7 2 ♠ 6 4 3 Hand N
forcing, accepting opener’s ♥ A 10 9 8 6 5 N ♥ J 4 3 ♠ 8
W E
suit as trumps and asking ♦ 9 8 S ♦ A Q J ♥ A K J 10 8 7
him to clarify further. This is ♣ Q 5 ♣ A K 4 3 ♦ J 9 3 2
called the Ogust convention. ♣ 8 6
Requirements: 16+ or a little
less with a good fit. West East
2♥ 2NT1 Your left hand opponent overcalls
There are various types of responses 3♥2 4♥3 with 3♣ and it is passed back to you.
but the following, known as Blue Club Yes, you are maximum. However, it is
responses, are the most popular. 1
2NT is conventional and asking. an act of betrayal of partner to bid 3♥
Opener is required to make two Reasonable because of the good (9- or 3♦.
decisions: card) trump fit. The argument, ‘I have no defence
i) In the context of his weak two bid, 2
3♥ shows maximum hand, but denies to 3♣,’ implies you think of bridge as
is his hand minimum (6 to bad 8 two of the top three honours. an individual rather than partnership
points) or maximum (good 8 to 10 3
You would be unlucky to fail in game. game. You have no idea what partner
points)? has: he has a far better idea of your
ii) Is his suit good (ie 2 of the top 3 Sometimes, the 2NT Ogust enquiry hand. He has decided it is best to
trump honours) or bad? can lead to a surprising choice of game defend 3♣.
The responses to 2NT are as follows: contract. When this hand occurred at the
In Layout M, the 2NT asking bid table West could not bring himself to
3♣ shows minimum hand, bad suit. also gets a more promising reply. pass.
3♦ shows minimum hand, good suit.
3♥ shows maximum hand, bad suit. West North East South
3♠ shows maximum hand, good suit. Layout M 2♥ 3♣ Pass Pass
3NT shows solid trumps (ie A K Q). ♠ 7 4 2 ♠ Q J 6 3♥ 3♠ Pass 4♠
Obviously nothing outside. ♥ A K Q 8 7 6 N ♥ J 3 2 End
W E
♦ 6 3 S ♦ A K Q 4
In Layout K, East is not encouraged ♣ 9 5 ♣ K J 10 The opponents made 4♠ with an
by West’s response to 2NT. overtrick. ■
A Reverse
Always Shows
Extra Values
Q A A
What is the best Whether you are Yes, with a weak You need to be able to show
way of bidding playing Standard 3-suited hand short a good hand when you have
these hands (a) American or Acol, in clubs, it is a good one and to pick up a useful
playing 5-card majors a reverse shows extra idea to respond Stayman to penalty when your side has
and (b) using standard values, 16 or 17 points plus. partner’s 1NT and pass any the balance of power.
Acol? Does a reverse Playing Acol and a weak reply. A 4-4-4-1 or 4-4-5- If they open a strong no-
have the same meaning no-trump, North has to 0 shape would be ideal. A trump, many people over
in both systems? rebid 2♦. Playing Standard 4-3-5-1 or 3-4-5-1 shape here still play the double as
American, North can again is likely to be suitable too: for penalties. Remember,
rebid 2♦ or perhaps 1NT at worst, you will play in a if you have a good suit,
♠ 9 (the 1NT rebid is a weak 4-3 fit with any club ruffs you have the advantage of
♥ A J 6 2 action when playing a strong in the short trump hand. If the opening lead, helping
♦ K 8 5 3 2 no-trump opening). 2♥ you are 4-3-4-2 or 3-4-4-2, you to win the race to set
♣ A 10 5 is not the correct rebid in you are likely to be better up tricks. Moreover, if the
either system. South would off passing: the chance of opening bid was on your
N
W E pass 2♦ or take out 1NT. finding a worthwhile fit is right, your high cards will be
S
A few pairs could reach a not great and you are hardly in a good position relative
♠ 8 7 6 5 2 club contract via 1♦-1♠-1NT- making life harder for your to the opener’s high cards.
♥ Q 5 2♣. To do that, you would opponents because you are In countries where almost
♦ 4 have to be playing a strong giving them two chances everyone plays a strong
♣ K Q J 9 7 no-trump, be comfortable to bid instead of one. no-trump, many people play
about rebidding 1NT with the a double as conventional.
singleton and not be playing ♣♦♥♠ For example, some play
Our sequence, playing any sort of checkback; this the double as either the
Q
5-card majors was: does not sound very likely. I always majors or the minors,
understood others as a 5-card minor
North South ♣♦♥♠ that a double plus a 4-card major.
1♦ 1♠ of 1NT is penalty. Now If you play the double
Q
2♥ 2♠ If partner opens I understand it could as conventional, partner
1NT, might it be a be penalty or take-out might judge to pass with
Incidentally, our good idea to use double. What is the the right hand. Even if it is
opponents failed to Stayman with the inten- thinking behind this? conventional, doubling a
remove my trumps, tion of passing partner’s Niranjan Doshi by email. strong no-trump when you
so 2♠ made, giving us reply? The hands I am have a hand weaker than
A
a rather undeserved thinking about have only If the opponents opener’s is risky. Sometimes
top. Most pairs went one or two clubs, a 4-4- open a weak 1NT, partner will have a weak
down in something. 4-1 shape being ideal. almost everyone hand and no particular fit
Anne Lee, Glasgow. John Watts by email. plays double as for penalties. for your suits.
Q
The way I in response to 4NT? have a lot of secondary
play Landy ♣♦♥♠ values in the other suits
(2♣ overcall and not much in diamonds
Q
of 1NT to show the ♠ Void I know my 2♥ then 1NT could be best.
majors) is as follows: ♥ K J 9 8 6 2 response on
♦ A Q J 4 3 this hand was ♣♦♥♠
Non-Vulnerable: ♣ A 10 not strictly by the book
Q
5-4 majors with 10+HCP with only four hearts. RHO opened 1♠;
N
5-5 majors with 7+ HCP W E I bid 3♦, pre-
S
Vulnerable: emptive. At the
5-4 majors with 12 HCP ♠ K 7 4 ♠ 9 5 4 inquest, the opponents
5-5 majors with 10 HCP ♥ A Q 7 5 4 ♥ A K Q 10 said I should have bid
♦ K 10 ♦ A 6 4 4♦ over a major, as 3♦
In reply, the only ♣ K 7 4 ♣ Q 7 5 shows a very strong
artificial bid is 2♦, hand over a major.
asking for the longer What do you think?
major. Does this all David Brayshaw by email. Partner Me Joan Kelly,
seem reasonable? 1♠ 2♥ Golders Green, London.
A
Evan StClair Sepion, On the hands you 3♥ 4♥
A
East Horsley, Surrey. give, a possible End The strength of
auction is: a single jump
A
Yes, we recommend 4♥ made 10 tricks while overcall is a matter
playing 2♣ over an North South 4♠ would have made 11. of partnership agreement.
opposing 1NT as 1♥ 2NT1 How would you bid? You can play them as weak,
showing both majors and 4♦2 4NT3 J Bardun by email. intermediate or strong.
using 2♦ in reply to ask for 6♥4 7♥ Traditionally, most people
A
the longer major (usually While you should played them as strong.
used with equal length). 1
Game forcing heart raise normally respond Since strong jump overcalls
Your point count (Jacoby). 2♣ with this shape do not come up very
requirements also 2
Good second suit. and values, with such a often, many people have
look about right. 3
RKCB. chunky 4-card heart suit switched to playing them
Bear in mind that, 4
An odd number of key cards you are entitled to exercise as weak. With a stronger
especially at matchpoints, and a void in a suit ranking some judgement and treat hand, it usually works to
whether the opponents higher than the trump suit. it as a 5-card suit. However, start with a simple overcall
are vulnerable also has a you might have bid 3♠ and then repeat your suit
bearing. With neither side Various methods exist for over 3♥ to offer partner or double next time to
vulnerable, anyone going showing a void in reply to a choice of games. show extras. If you play
down is doing so at 50 a 4NT. Kantar recommends in a tournament or watch
time, so making a contract is that you bid 5NT with an ♣♦♥♠ bridge on BBO, you will find
usually better than collecting even number of key cards that almost everyone there
Q
a penalty, while conceding plus a void, six of your void My partner plays weak jump overcalls.
a penalty is usually better (or the trump suit if the void opened 1♦. I had The weaker strength
than letting them make a is in a higher-ranking suit) 8 points and four comes up more often and
contract. This means you if you have an odd number diamonds. Should the enables you to obstruct
are most inclined to bid with of key cards plus a void. In answer be 2♦ or 1NT, the opposing bidding.
neither side vulnerable. the latter case, you expect which is what I bid? What the opponents
partner to work out from your James Harrington by email. thought was irrelevant
♣♦♥♠ previous bidding whether the (assuming your partner gave
A
odd number is one or three. It depends upon a correct explanation of the
Q
Is there a way A fair alternative is that your shape. If you strength of your overcall).
to bid a grand you reply at the six level if have a 4-card They are entitled to play
slam on the you have a void, bidding major, you might well show strong jump overcalls if they
hands below (North the same suit as you would that in preference to raising wish but they cannot stop
dealer)? Nobody bid it. have done without the void diamonds. Assuming you you from playing them as
As a more general point, only one level higher. For do not have a 4-card major, weak.
Q
Defending 10-12, so you would be honour cards to give a suit preference signal
against a slam, about right for the values.
Y
I held the ♠A but Obviously, the bid is ou won’t have been West leads the five of dia-
no other high cards. forcing facing 23+ or out of the beginners’ monds. Plan the defence.
I led the ♠A but then game-going values. class for very long be- It looks obvious that
switched; my part- fore you get a lesson on suit you are going to win and
ner, at the time, told ♣♦♥♠ preference signals. When continue diamonds, hoping
me never to do that partner leads a singleton to promote a trump trick in
Q
but to carry on the If five cards are to your ace, the card you your partner’s hand. Then,
same suit even though missing, the return should tell partner you need him to switch to
they were all small. probability of a what to play next: a high a spade to give you a ruff.
Is this correct? 3-2 break is 67.83%. card for a high-ranking suit, How can you persuade him
Name and address supplied. I have worked out a low card for a low-rank- to do this?
the following card ing suit. But sometimes you You are going to win
A
Whether you combinations: can’t afford to play a low with one honour, hopefully
should continue card at all. cash another and then
or switch depends 3-2 break has 20 lead another. If you play
upon your hand, partner’s combinations, ten, jack, queen, you would
signal and the dummy. 4-1 break has 10 Dealer East. E/W Vul. clearly ask for a club; if you
♠ 7 6 4 2 play ace, king, queen, you
If your partner encourages combinations,
♥ A 5 clearly ask for a spade.
(with a high card) it would 5-0 break has 2
♦ 7 6 2 With no preference, you
be usual to continue the combinations.
♣ A Q 10 9 would do something else,
suit, hoping to find the
♠ K J 10 9 5 3 ♠ Void perhaps winning the jack
king opposite your ace. I thought that the
♥ K 7 4 ♥ 6 2 and then playing the ace,
If you can tell from percentage probability N
♦ 5 W E
♦ A K Q J for example.
dummy that the best hope for a 3-2 break would 10 S 83 Notice that you need
of defeating the contract is be (20/32)x100 but this ♣ K J 3 ♣ 6 5 4 2 your spade ruff to beat the
to give your partner a ruff, gives 62.5% not 67.83%. ♠ A Q 8 contract and partner will
again you continue the suit. Could you explain ♥ Q J 10 9 8 3 take a lot of persuading to
where I have ♦ 9 4 lead one from his king.
♣♦♥♠ gone wrong? ♣ 8 7 When your honour
David Cree by email. holding is known (or shortly
Q
Could you tell me going to be known), then
A
what the correct You need to take West North East South use the order in which you
response to a into account that 4♦ 4♥ play your honours to give
2♣ opening would be as players have a finite All Pass suit preference. ■
responder with 12 points, number of cards (13). While
a balanced hand and no the number of combinations
idea of partner’s shape? you have given is right,
I replied 3NT and, as they are not equally likely.
Travel tip from Emma Thomson:
H
it happened, partner If one suit breaks 3-2, it oliday snaps are a great reminder of the good
had a balanced hand means the other 21 cards times. Only when you get back home and are
and we made 6NT, but in the opposing hands showing them to family and friends do you real-
I am not sure what are breaking 11-10 and ise the photograph doesn’t quite live up to the real-life
my initial response so on. There are more version. To improve your photos, try spending a little
should have been. ways of having an 11-10 longer setting up the shot. Look around the corners of
Liz Luffingham by email. break than there are of the viewfinder to be sure no telegraph wires are cutting
12-9 or 13-8 breaks. across the frame and or there’s no lamp post sticking
A
You are rarely lucky This is why a 3-2 break is a out the top of your loved-one’s head; don’t shoot into
the sun as faces will be covered in shadow; and try
enough to hold 12 hotter favourite than your raw
photographing people and scenery from different an-
points when partner calculations suggest. ■
gles – low, high, even upside down – instead of just at
head height. Relatives will be cooing over your handi-
E-mail your questions for Julian to: work in no time.
julianpottage@mrbridge.co.uk
A
s a teenager at school, I enjoyed of bridge regarding this situation. the ♥8, Kate covered in dummy and
most team sports, like hockey In particular, does Rule 76 apropos East had to win with the ♥A. A club
and netball, but athletics was spectators apply to parrots during return gave Kate the rest of the tricks
a different matter. In the sixth form, a match played in a private house? for a score of +630. Could anything
on compulsory cross-country runs, a When Jo and Kate joined us to score go wrong now? Oh, yes. At our table,
friend and I would soon be trailing the up the first half, Millie greeted them South passed and Millie with two five-
field and would take a short cut along mischievously with, ‘That parrot has card red suits and rule of 19 opened
a footpath by a stream. We would then just told us a great joke.’ ‘The parrot?’ one heart. The complete disastrous
rejoin the official route still behind the queried Jo suspiciously. ‘Well, perhaps sequence was:
other girls now on their return jour- I exaggerated,’ admitted Millie, ‘The
ney. On one occasion, we had stopped joke wasn’t really that good, but not West North East South
to watch a pair of kingfishers, lost our bad for a parrot.’ We enjoyed a splendid Millie Ann Wendy
sense of time and had to hurry back to tea provided by our opponents and Pass
school. To our surprise and dismay, Jo and Kate had the pleasure of the 1♥ 1♠ Pass 2♣
we were the first to finish; we had not parrot’s company for the second half. 2♦ 3♠ Dbl All Pass
realised the course had been length- Being only a few IMPs down, we knew
ened that day as a trial for the school we had everything to play for. The With six trumps in my hand and an
inter-house event. Our performance following board proved to be pivotal ace, I doubled, expecting to defeat the
gained us the unwanted honour of to the final result. contract. What a mistake. I led the
selection for our house team. Pro- ♦5 and Ann, as declarer, played the
tests on the grounds that others were ♦J. Millie won with the ♦K, won the
more deserving were ignored. We ex- Dealer South. N/S Vul. second trick with the ♦A and returned
celled ourselves on competition day ♠ A K Q J 5 the ♦6. I ruffed then took the ♥A, but
by completing the full cross-country ♥ K J 6 3 three spades doubled came home for
course in the slowest time ever re- ♦ 8 3 -730. It would have been a part score
corded in the school’s history, to the ♣ K 6 of -140 had I been more conservative.
great amusement of classmates and I ♠ Void
N
♠ 9 7 6 4 3 2 Kate’s excellent 3NT contract had been
suspect the games’ teacher. In bridge, ♥ Q 9 8 7 4 W E ♥ A 2 cancelled out by my over-exuberance.
one can also be too clever. ♦ A K 10 7 6 S ♦ 5 2 That unnecessary double cost us
Jo, Kate, Millie and I entered a ♣ 10 9 7 ♣ Q 5 2 dearly, a difference of -100 for -3 IMPs
national knock-out teams competition ♠ 10 8 instead of +490 for +10 IMPs. As a
for the first time. In the qualifying ♥ 10 5 result, we lost a match we could have
round, we drew a useful local team ♦ Q J 9 4 won by 4 IMPs. In bridge, like cross-
captained by Ann, who we knew ♣ A J 8 4 3 country, it does not pay to be too clever.
vaguely but had not seen for some As we congratulated our opponents on
time. As we entered her house for the their victory, Ann responded silently
contest, I commented quietly to Millie West North East South with a gleefully exaggerated broad and
that Ann appeared to look slightly Jo Kate toothy grin.
different around the face. ‘I’m sure it’s Pass We retreated to a local hostelry to
her new false teeth,’ responded Millie Pass 1♠ Pass 1NT lick our wounds and soothe Millie’s
unkindly and certainly too loudly. Pass 3♥ Pass 3NT troubled nerves. It was then that Millie
‘I think the dentist fitted the wrong All Pass noticed the new lucky charm on my
ones,’ she continued unnecessarily. bracelet. ‘I think you should ask for
Throughout the first twelve boards, West led the ♦A and East played the a refund,’ she observed drily. It did
Ann’s parrot, on its perch in the corner ♦5. West switched to the ♥9, dummy not seem to be the moment to suggest
of the room, kept up an incessant played low, East ducked and Kate won that Millie’s minimum opener might
chatter. I couldn’t help wondering with the ♥10. Now the play of the ♦Q have been a contributing factor in the
if there was anything in the laws knocked out the ♦K. West exited with debacle. ■
Fares shown are per person based on two people sharing lowest twin-bedded cabin category currently available, are subject to availability and include all applicable discounts for new bookings.
Fares shown include current fuel supplements correct at time of printing, but subject to change. Onboard spend applies per cabin. All offers are subject to availability, cannot be combined with any
other offer or loyalty offer, are capacity controlled and may be withdrawn at any time. See brochure for full terms and conditions. Voyages of Discovery is a trading name of All Leisure Holidays Ltd.
13/0278
Catching Up
by Sally Brock
Sally was a member of the British Ladies’ Team that qualified for the World Championships in Bali.
A
fter our disappointing NICKO a promontory, and second to Taman continue over the next few days, is
match, we went back to High Ayun, a huge royal water temple. that of the air-conditioning in my
Wycombe and out to dinner Then we went to the shopping capital room. One day, after we had been here
with friends on the Saturday evening. of the island, Ubud, and wandered roughly a week, I was woken in the
Then, at 3.40am, Ed picked Barry up around the market for a while, before middle of night by a steady drip-drip-
to go to Stansted for his trip to Pula – returning to our hotel. In the evening, drip in my room. There were drops of
to play in a tournament with Bernard we went back to the same restaurant condensation dripping onto the floor.
Teltscher. on the beach. It was just too good an I eventually resorted to stuffing bits of
Things were a bit hectic after that, experience not to share. toilet paper in my ears to get back to
culminating in flying off to Bali on the The next day was spent mostly sleep despite the dripping.
Friday. I was pleased that Nicola had relaxing until the evening when there Although the hotel fixed this tempo-
had the foresight to book a taxi to take was an opening ceremony. I am sure rarily, the problem arose every couple
us to our hotel, because leaving Bali that there are very good reasons for all of days. And several times I was woken
airport is bedlam. You come out of the the speeches and performances that go in the night by the heat in my room as
main entrance and there are throngs on at these affairs but it is purgatory I lost my power supply and therefore
of people, some of whom are holding for bridge players. my air conditioning. Much of the time
placards with names on while the ma- Here we are, within spitting distance I was in my room, it was in the com-
jority are just waving wildly. Luckily, of all our friends from far-flung places pany of three hotel employees, one
we found our driver quite quickly and whom we don’t see often enough standing on a step ladder, one in the
were soon settled into our hotel. and, instead of being able to talk roof above the ladder and one holding
The next day, we relaxed and read to them, we have to sit through not the ladder. At one stage, they seemed
the system. Simon, who with David only speeches, but also exhibitions of to have plugged the leak, but the wa-
Gold had been here for a few days in Balinese dancing and music. However ter just dripped a bit further along,
order to have a bit of a holiday and brilliant these may be, it is not what this time drenching all my hanging
acclimatisation, met us for lunch. In the players want and they put up with clothes in water. The team had trouble
the evening, we went with them to a it with varying degrees of politeness. containing their eagerness to hear the
wonderful restaurant on the beach While I was settling into Bali, next instalment each day at breakfast.
at Jimbaran. We sat on the sand on Briony was settling into her rooms In the round robin, we were generally
folding chairs with the sea a mere at university. It was a pity I couldn’t lying somewhere between fourth and
ten feet away. We chose our own fish be with her for this important rite of eighth, not really in any serious danger
which was cooked freshly for us and passage, but we Skyped a lot and she of not qualifying, but clearly needing
for a starter there was a stall on the seemed to settle in well. All I could do an improvement in performance if we
beach selling corn on the cob. Later for her birthday was arrange a gluten were going to do really well. Nicola
on, there were fireworks. In different and dairy free birthday cake to be and I were generally played against
company, it would have been very delivered and then Skype even more. weaker teams but even so I didn’t
romantic. Later on that evening, the Then the bridge started. There were feel we played particularly well in
rest of the team arrived and we all had 22 teams in each event. The format the round robin. And our opponents
a drink before retiring to bed. was a complete round robin of three seemed to bid a huge number of slams
The following day was the only real 16-board matches a day, with the top against us which were not generally
opportunity we would have to venture eight to qualify for the quarter-finals. bid either by our other pair, or by the
further afield. So, for about £30, we Then it was knock-out (96 boards rest of the field.
hired a car and a driver for the day. He played over two days) until there was On this deal, from our match against
took us to see a couple of temples: first, only one team left standing. USA2, it was our turn to be aggressive
the beautiful Tanah Lot, perched on An ongoing saga, which will in the slam zone:
Arrow-Switches
A
n arrow-switch is when the gressively on them. a pair plays, they compare their score
boards are rotated ninety Another belief depends on the fact with other pairs all playing the same
degrees so that pairs switch that, with arrow-switches, a pair will way with the same cards. That is what
orientation for a round. play a different set of hands from an- makes an arrow-switch fair, similar to
Many players distrust arrow-switches other pair: is that fair? Perhaps not in a Howell movement which works on
for a variety of reasons. Some players one way of looking at it: a pure dupli- the same principle. If you get a top,
believe they have an evening when cate session is probably one in which you have out-scored other pairs play-
they do not get the cards – and when each N/S pair plays the same boards as ing with the same cards, if you get a
it comes to the arrow-switch round or each other and finishes with two lists, bottom, they have out-scored you, but
rounds, they still do not get the cards. one for E/W, one for N/S. Many clubs still with the same cards. So if you feel
There are two answers to this. First, do, in fact, try to follow this approach, it is a hand where your side should be
players’ perception of whether they with two winning pairs on the night, declarer, then that is true for every
hold the cards or not is notoriously though, with some numbers of tables, other pair with whom you compare
wrong and this bias really happens they do not play everyone or every your score on that board. If you get
incredibly rarely. Also, it does not board. The problem with that ap- bad hands, then you are comparing
matter anyway since it does not affect proach comes in events where a single your score with other players who got
your chance of success. On every board winner is required. Also, many clubs the same bad hands.
you play, your score is compared with want a single winner or single list, for I think the greatest problem with
other people holding the same cards, example, if one free play is handed arrow-switches is that players think
good or bad, with lucky or unlucky out per evening, or if the scores go only of the three or four boards at the
breaks – it is the same for all of you. through to a further competition. end of the session when the boards are
Some think that declarer has an Consider an ordinary Mitchell with switched. In fact, there are some ar-
advantage and arrow-switches affect 15 tables, playing 13 rounds with no row-switches on every board you play.
the number of times a side gets to be arrow-switch. On no board do you Suppose you are a moving pair. Most
declarer. However, you can get a good compete with every other pair sitting of the time you play E/W and you com-
score as a defender by stopping declar- your way, merely with 12 other pairs – pare your score with other E/W pairs.
er making a tenth trick in no-trumps but not the same 12 other pairs. How- Now, you think of them as other mov-
by a judicious lead, or by careful dis- ever, you compete directly with each ing pairs, but, on every board, there
carding. You can set up your defence pair only on each board that both of will be some stationary pairs, the ones
during the bidding by lead-directing you play. The same applies in an ar- who play it at the end of the evening.
bids. Counting hands is very impor- row-switch: you do not compete with Every single board is affected by the
tant, especially when defending, and every other pair on every board, but arrow-switch, not just the last three or
good signalling between defenders is comparisons are worked out between four, but, on every board, your score
most important. My guess is that more you and each other pair that played the is compared only with people playing
matchpoints are lost by sloppy defend- same hands as you on the same board. with your cards – and that is fair.
ing than by poor declarer play. What about the suggestion of calling The other complaint about arrow-
Such players seem to ignore the bid- the winner the pair with the higher switches is that people do not under-
ding and feel it is pre-ordained that percentage between the N/S and E/W stand why it should be one-eighth of
one side will play the hand. A lot of winners, a common approach in the the boards. That is quite difficult to
matchpoint bidding revolves around USA? That is completely illegal and explain, being based on an abstruse
contesting part scores and judging faintly ridiculous: you might just as mathematical argument and a future
whether to bid one more and play the well call the winner the pair with the article will look at this. For those peo-
hand or defend. There are also sacri- higher percentage between this week ple who think instinctively it should
fices and pre-emptive bids to try and and four weeks ago. The point is that be half the boards, mathematicians
deflect the other side from their best they have not played the same hands have proved that it is not correct to
contract, so many hands might be as each other, so the scores cannot arrow-switch half the boards. Remem-
played by either side. In many ways, be compared. In a fair competition, ber you are comparing with people in
good players look forward to weaker you compete against every other pair the other direction on every board.
hands and less experienced players on some of the boards, which cannot Strangely, many people who do not
would perhaps enjoy the game more if happen with the American approach. trust arrow-switches are perfectly
they realised the scope offered to them So how does an arrow-switch work? happy with Howell movements, which
by poor hands and if they bid more ag- What happens is that, on each board work in the same way. ■
PLEASE EXPLAIN
LETTERS
Chairman. It has always been my
English Bridge Union. understanding that a double
of an opening first round
QUIZ ANSWER bid of 1NT is for penalty.
I and a few bridge buddies Recently, I have
played the Chatsworth Hotel encountered such a double
TD Training BOGOFF and may attend further days Quiz hand last month and it for take-out. How can I know
I was surprised at on such topics as ‘book occasioned some interesting that it isn’t for penalty?
Mr Tarsnane’s comments rulings’. An assessment and discussions as to the correct Niranjan Doshi by email.
in BRIDGE 131. He alleges certificate can be gained if way to bid and play. This is another FAQ. Julian
that EBU courses for training all parts of the course are I see the prize has been Pottage will write about it
tournament directors are completed to the required awarded in your November and that really is a promise.
too long, too expensive standard, but this is optional. edition of BRIDGE, but
and too far away. The club A director who has had no definitive answer as WELL DONE
directors’ Essential Course a modicum of training can to the correct bid. POST OFFICE
is held at venues all over the make the evening more Could you please put us On Friday 18 October,
country, it lasts for one day enjoyable for all the players out of our misery . . . I phoned and ordered a
and, for all affiliated clubs, when the movement works what is the answer? 2-year subscription for
if they send one director they without fault, the scoring is Thanking you in BRIDGE. I’d had it for years
qualify to take a second for prompt and anytime there anticipation. and years and missed it for a
nothing, so the total cost for is an incident at the table Mr John Lees by email. few months. When I phoned,
the course for two directors the director deals with it See my column on page 5. I seemed to have missed
is £38. BOGOF at its best. calmly and authoritatively. the info about subscription,
If the booking comes from In most games training REPLAY REQUEST so I paid by phone. Next
an EBU member and not via is offered to organisers, At my local bridge club, day came the receipt and
the club then the discount umpires and referees. It playing rubber bridge one the November magazine.
does not apply but the makes for a better game. night, I mentioned the Mrs Maureen Burke
attendee is still welcome. In both the affiliated ‘Murder Hand’. Everyone by email.
These courses are both clubs I attend in his county, was intrigued but I cannot
popular and frequently full. the game is run by trained find my copy of the story nor NOT SERIOUS
We’d be delighted to see volunteers and makes the actual hand. Would you I was most amused that
either of the clubs he attends the evening all the more please publish the tale and Sally Brock thought herself
in Bridport join the EBU and smooth and enjoyable. One its hand in your next issue. a complete idiot for
the local county and take of those clubs (Allendale) Mrs B Clarke, Newbury. missing a triple squeeze.
advantage of the offer above. is about to hold an EBU If not in the coming issue, Most of us would be
More training is available for course and would be then in the one after. over the moon even to
those who wish to go further delighted to welcome spot such a play double
WELL PICKED UP dummy. However, I suppose
Bernard Magee’s bidding at Sally’s level, missing a
REDUCE THE COST quiz is my favourite spot in
the magazine. I have one
triple squeeze is like me
miscounting trumps.
OF YOUR POSTAGE question and one comment
to make about the current
She says she briefly
thought about giving up the
Postage stamps for sale at 90% of face-value, issue (BRIDGE 130). game. Was she serious? Sally
all mint with full gum. Quotations for Deal 5. Bernard says giving up bridge would be
commercial quantities available on request. game on 18 HCP might like the Prime Minister giving
Values supplied in 100s, higher values seem ambitious – I see up politics – it’s in the blood.
available as well as 1st and 2nd class 22 HCP. Perhaps this is a However, we have all been
deliberate mistake to see if there, if a game can’t destroy
(eg 2nd class: 100x37p+100x13p)
we are paying attention. you occasionally it’s not
Mrs J Windle, worth playing. It’s good to
(/Fax 020 8422 4906
Truro, Cornwall. know that Sally, genius as she
e-mail: Well spotted. Bernard is, is just one of us at heart.
clive.goff@londonrugby.com Magee’s correct answer, Ian Dalziel
22 HCP, was input but Troon, Ayrshire.
card suit if they have one. humour. Our thanks also 12 WIMBORNE ROTARY CLUB
3 If the dealer has not got a We read the brochure to his team of helpers who Allendale Community Centre,
Wimborne, Dorset. 2p.m.
5 card suit they either bid every night were all very friendly. £28 per table, including tea
1 of a suit or one no trump To blow away the blues Lesley and Richard Budgen, and good prizes.
depending on distribution. And dreamt of gourmet Kidlington, Oxon. Don Phillips 01202 972211
4 Either no further bids are food to eat APRIL 2014
allowed or each player Accompanied by booze. MIS-READ
4 Conservative Association
in turn is allowed one Dear oh dear – someone Gt Stukeley Village Hall.
bid – penalty doubles We packed a suitcase has slipped up, letting Sally Tickets £13.50.
are not allowed. – full to brim Brock’s tip past the editor’s Sheila Stephenson
( 01480 457338
5 Play then proceeds along With t-shirts, pants scrutiny, BRIDGE 131 p33.
Kay Brownlow
normal playing rules and trews Surely Sally does not ( 01480 880663
but it is obviously not And left perhaps mean that, ‘she plays
25 CHILDREN’S CHARITIES
scored on the traveller. a little room against many over-aged Doddington Village Hall,
We feel that this would For just one pair of shoes. club players.’ Since when March. 10.00 for 10.30am.
be a bit of fun and it avoids has bridge been ageist? Tickets £14.00.
sitting around waiting to September is a My local club, like most Val Topliss
( 01354 653696
move to the next table. happy month others, has it’s fair share of
Mr Brian Berlanny, To join Bernard on a cruise elderly players. As long as MAY 2014
Portsmouth, Hants. To dream of making they are willing and capa- 15 HUDDERSFIELD PENNINE
Don’t even go there. slams each night ble of arriving at the bridge ROTARY CLUB
Bridge Lunch with tea and
To blow away the blues. club they are welcome.
biscuits £48 per table.
MY CHOICE Nobody will ever be turned 12.00 for 12.30. Outlane
Following receipt of BRIDGE And so our thanks away because we feel that Golf Club, Huddersfield.
131, the November issue, to Mr Bridge they are ‘over-aged’. Rtn Sam Smith
( 01924 492540
please find my cheque for We thought it was a ruse Yours, rather shocked.
samuelsmith396
£20 as subscription for When through the post Andrew Mountain @btinternet.com
this coming year. I much his mag arrived Wrexham.
prefer a hard copy. To tempt us with Go to Specsavers, then have E-mail your charity events:
Robin Bridger, this cruise. another look at the printed maggie@mrbridge.co.uk
Romsey, Hants. word on page 33.
TELL ME WHY
I should explain that in those Could you ask one of your
days we were not playing experts to explain why some
1NT weak all through, we favour the strong no-trump.
played weak no trump non- Mrs Rowntree,
vulnerable and strong no Mundesley, Norfolk.
trump vulnerable. On this Look in the February issue. ■
board, North had dealt at
Game All so that 1NT had Write to Mr Bridge at:
not been available to him. Ryden Grange,
Let’s now look at all four Knaphill,
hands – not a luxury avail- Surrey,
able to me at the time. GU21 2TH
or e-mail
By the time I saw dummy,
letters@mrbridge.co.uk
West had made his open-
Letters may be edited
ing lead and (perhaps on for length and clarity.
the basis of leading through
Mr Bridge
(free) between the two and, are only a few down and
if you miss the bus, a taxi the match is still eminently
costs only £1.50. winnable.