Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Indirect Pulp Capping and Occlusal Matrix: A Minimally Invasive Approach for Restoring
Young Permanent Molars with Deep Carious Lesions
Mariana Pasa Rosa1, Thaisa Ribas Taques1, Mayara Vitorino Gevert2, Ana Elisa Ribeiro2 and Ana Claudia
Rodrigues Chibinski3*
1
Dental Students, Department of Pediatric Dentistry, School of Dentistry, Ponta Grossa State University, Ponta Grossa, Paraná, Brazil
2
PhD Students, Department of Pediatric Dentistry, School of Dentistry, Ponta Grossa State University, Ponta Grossa, Paraná, Brazil
3
Professor, Department of Pediatric Dentistry, School of Dentistry, Ponta Grossa State University, Ponta Grossa, Paraná, Brazil
*Corresponding Author: Ana Claudia Rodrigues Chibinski, Professor, Department of Pediatric Dentistry, School of Dentistry, Ponta
Grossa State University, Ponta Grossa, Paraná, Brazil.
Received: June 28, 2018; Published: July 11, 2018
Abstract
The term “hidden caries” designates a dentinal lesion beneath the dentinoenamel junction with intact or minimally cavitated
enamel, therefore the radiographic exam is fundamental for the diagnosis. One possible treatment for these lesions is the indirect
pulp capping with partial removal of the carious dentin to preserve the tooth vitality and to avoid a more invasive treatment such as
endodontics. Therefore, this study aimed to describe a clinical case of indirect pulp capping in a first permanent molar with a deep
carious lesion of a teenager patient. The final restoration was carried out with composite resin using the occlusal matrix technique,
restoring aesthetics and function. Long-term follow up was accomplished through digital radiographic subtraction technique, which
allowed the observation that mineral density of the affected dentin continue to increase over time, showing positive results after 12
months regarding dentin remineralization.
Keywords: Hidden Caries; Indirect Pulp Capping; Remineralization
Citation: Ana Claudia Rodrigues Chibinski., et al. “Indirect Pulp Capping and Occlusal Matrix: A Minimally Invasive Approach for Restoring Young
Permanent Molars with Deep Carious Lesions”. Acta Scientific Dental Sciences 2.8 (2018): 57-63.
Indirect Pulp Capping and Occlusal Matrix: A Minimally Invasive Approach for Restoring Young Permanent Molars with Deep Carious Lesions
58
pearance, in addition to re-establishing the function and reducing The restorative phase started with the dental prophylaxis us-
clinical hours. This restoring technique can be called occlusal ma- ing pumice and water to remove the dental biofilm on the tooth
trix or occlusal replica [14-16]. surface. Before the tooth dehydration, the shade of the composite
resin was selected (shade A1; Master Fill/Biodinâmica/Ibiporã,
Therefore, the objective of this study was to describe a clinical PR, Brazil), followed by local infiltrative anesthesia and placement
case of indirect pulp capping with composite restoration using the of rubber dam for isolation of the operative field (Figure 3).
occlusal matrix technique in a teenager’s permanent molar, as well
as to present the 12-month clinical/radiographic follow up.
Case Report
A 14-year-old female patient attended the dental clinic of the
State University of Ponta Grossa, accompanied by a caregiver for a
routine examination. During the anamnesis, the patient reported
the absence of tooth pain or systemic alterations. In the intra-oral
clinical examination, it was observed that the upper left first perma-
nent molar exhibit a more opaque area at the occlusal surface and
a small cavity on the palatal surface (Figure 1). The complementary
Figure 3: Baseline clinical situation after rubber dam placement.
examination included periapical radiograph of the region (Figure
2), which revealed the existence of a deep dentin carious lesion,
confirming the hidden caries diagnosis. Prior to cavity preparation, an occlusal-palatal matrix of the
tooth to be restored was manufactured. This matrix manufactur-
ing phases were: (1) lubrication of the tooth with petroleum jelly
(Rioquímica/São José do Rio Preto, SP, Brazil); (2) manipulation of
self-cured acrylic resin (Vipi/Vipi Flash/Pirassununga, SP, Brazil);
(3) adaptation of the acrylic resin on the occlusal-palatal surfaces
to replicate the tooth anatomy; (4) manufacture of the a matrix
handle; (5) matrix finishing with maxicut burs (Figure 4).
Figure 2: Baseline radiographic exam of the left After manufacturing the matrix, the cavity preparation was ac-
first permanent molar. complished. The occlusal/palatal surfaces were opened with high-
speed carbide burs to gain access to the damaged dentin structure
below the enamel. The carious tissue was removed with dentin ex-
Since the occlusal surface of the tooth did not present morpho-
cavators and slow speed carbide burs in a size compatible with the
logical alteration, the treatment plan consisted of partial removal
cavity. The infected dentin presented a soft consistency and yel-
of the carious dentin (indirect pulp capping) associated to dental
lowish color. It was easily removed with dentin excavators (Figure
restoration with hybrid composite resin with the occlusal matrix
5). The carious dentin was totally removed from the cavosurface
technique. This plan was presented to the patient and the caregiver,
margin and surrounding walls of the cavity. The affected dentin,
who consented with the treatment and signed an informed consent
which showed harder consistency and darker shade, was kept on
form.
Citation: Ana Claudia Rodrigues Chibinski., et al. “Indirect Pulp Capping and Occlusal Matrix: A Minimally Invasive Approach for Restoring Young
Permanent Molars with Deep Carious Lesions”. Acta Scientific Dental Sciences 2.8 (2018): 57-63.
Indirect Pulp Capping and Occlusal Matrix: A Minimally Invasive Approach for Restoring Young Permanent Molars with Deep Carious Lesions
59
the cavity floor in order to prevent possible pulp exposure (Figure In sequence, the cavity was conditioned with 37% phosphoric
6). acid gel (Dentsply/Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil) for 15 seconds on
dentin and 30 seconds on enamel. The area was washed for 60
seconds, dried without desiccation and the adhesive system was
applied (Ambar/FGM/Joinville, SC, Brasil) followed by photopoly-
merization for 60 seconds. The composite resin was placed in lay-
ers of 2mm thickness and light cured individually for 60 seconds.
Citation: Ana Claudia Rodrigues Chibinski., et al. “Indirect Pulp Capping and Occlusal Matrix: A Minimally Invasive Approach for Restoring Young
Permanent Molars with Deep Carious Lesions”. Acta Scientific Dental Sciences 2.8 (2018): 57-63.
Indirect Pulp Capping and Occlusal Matrix: A Minimally Invasive Approach for Restoring Young Permanent Molars with Deep Carious Lesions
60
Discussion
Figure 11: Clinical appearance after 12 months. The etiology of this type of carious lesion has been widely dis-
cussed, but it is still very controversial. However, the literature
lists some hypotheses, like the presence of irregularities below
the dentin-enamel junction, intense exposure to fluoride, deep
occlusal cracks with a complex morphology which enable greater
biofilm retention, specific microbiota and thin enamel layer on the
crack base. These are all different factors that might start the cari-
ous process [15]. The proposed treatment must aim the restora-
tion of the tooth and the maintenance of pulp vitality, combining
a minimum invasive and aesthetic restorative approach (Vieira
2016).
Figure 12: Radiographic exam after 12 months; the The case reported in this study associated all these factors, fol-
arrow points out a more radiopaque layer on the cavity floor. lowing a conservative treatment protocol: indirect pulp capping
and aesthetic restoration using the occlusal matrix technique.
In order to confirm this finding, digital subtraction radiography Dental literature showed the benefits of the carious tissue
(DSR) protocol was done. DSR enables the detection of differences selective removal when compared to the complete removal, es-
between sequential radiographs that may be difficult to detect by pecially for deep lesions in teeth that do not present periapical
human eyes. The process creates a new image by subtracting the diseases or irreversible pulp damage [12,19,20]. Researchers have
value of the corresponding pixels of two images. Changes in the final reported that indirect pulp capping reduces the risk of exposure
image will appear as brighter (when the mineral content enhances) and post-operative pulp symptoms, enabling the preservation of a
Citation: Ana Claudia Rodrigues Chibinski., et al. “Indirect Pulp Capping and Occlusal Matrix: A Minimally Invasive Approach for Restoring Young
Permanent Molars with Deep Carious Lesions”. Acta Scientific Dental Sciences 2.8 (2018): 57-63.
Indirect Pulp Capping and Occlusal Matrix: A Minimally Invasive Approach for Restoring Young Permanent Molars with Deep Carious Lesions
61
larger tooth structure when compared to more invasive treatments omy when applied to the restoration before the polymerization of
and the maintenance of tooth vitality [10,21-23]. the last layer of composite resin [33]. Such procedure is only indi-
cated to restore carious lesions in which the occlusal surface does
One of the greatest challenges of indirect pulp therapy is to not present cavity [34,35].
determine clinically the necessary amount of carious tissue to be
removed [24,25]. Carious dentin can be theoretically divided into The occlusal matrix technique is simple, safe, easy to execute
infected and affected dentin with differences in the morphologi- and not expensive [35]. Its use enables the restoration of the
cal, physiological, biochemical and bacteriological aspects. Only the shape, function and aesthetics, eliminating the sculpture phase
most external and superficial portion, which is called infected den- and reducing the clinic hours required by the procedure [36].
tin, should be removed because it is irreversibly denaturized. The Other advantages already reported in the literature are: better
affected dentin can be remineralized, due to the presence of col- marginal adaptation [37,38], the absence of premature contact
lagen fibrils and apatite crystals, therefore, it should be preserved and very little need of finishing and polishing, which reduces the
[26,27]. However, the whole process can only occur if the cavity occurrence of cracks and excessive wearing [33,39]. All these ben-
is accurately sealed and properly restored so that the lesion can- efits were observed during the restorative procedure described.
not develop further [13,28]. After some time, the remaining dentin
becomes darker and harder and the carious lesion paralyzation is The occlusal matrix can be made from different types of mate-
achieved [22,28,29]. rial like photopolymerizable surgical cement [40], photopolymer-
izable temporary cement [4,34,41,42], polyvinyl siloxane [37,43],
The confirm that the treatment was successful, clinical-radio- composite resin [40], prefabricated transparent silicone molds
graphic follow up is necessary, so that the radiographic alterations [38,44] and colorless autopolymerizable acrylic resin [45]. In this
occurred immediately after intervention and the long-term changes case, the material of choice was the auto-cured acrylic resin, since
can be compared [22,27-30]. In this clinical case, a process called it provides an exact replica of the tooth anatomy and its transpar-
digital radiographic subtraction was carried out. This is a non-inva- ency allows some light passage [45]. Due to the lack of contact
sive diagnosis tool [19,22] which uses x-ray images of two different with oxygen during polymerization of the composite resin, its
moments during the treatment to identify mineral alterations in a superficial surface layer is totally photopolymerized, which im-
tooth [19,31]. Anatomical structures that appear in a neutral grey proves the superficial hardness of the resin [38].
shade demonstrate the absence of alterations, while lighter shades
of grey represent an increase in the mineral density [19,22,27]. Af- Finally, it should be stated that the overall treatment was suc-
ter 12 months follow-up, the digital radiographic subtraction, pro- cessful since it kept the pulp vitality, preserved tooth structure
cess showed lighter grey shades in the carious dentin region kept and restored shape, function and aesthetics of the tooth, with a
under GIC, confirming the dentin remineralization (Figure 14). relatively simple and effective technique. Also, it must be pointed
Moreover, there was no report of post-operative pain, presence of out the main achievement of the employed treatment: the continu-
fistula or abscess and no signs of pulp pathologies were observed, ous remineralization of the affected dentin, which guaranteed the
thus confirming the successful treatment.. long-term success of the procedure [46-48].
Citation: Ana Claudia Rodrigues Chibinski., et al. “Indirect Pulp Capping and Occlusal Matrix: A Minimally Invasive Approach for Restoring Young
Permanent Molars with Deep Carious Lesions”. Acta Scientific Dental Sciences 2.8 (2018): 57-63.
Indirect Pulp Capping and Occlusal Matrix: A Minimally Invasive Approach for Restoring Young Permanent Molars with Deep Carious Lesions
62
4. Oliveira Luciana Butini., et al. “Réplica da face oclusal: téc- 19. Alves LS., et al. “Qualitative and quantitative radiographic
nica alternativa para restauração de molares decíduos”. Jor- assessment of sealed carious dentin: a 10-year prospective
nal Brasileiro de Odontopediatria e Odontologia do Bebe 4.21 study”. Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine, Oral Pathology, Oral Radi-
(2001): 405-410. ology and Endodontics 109.1 (2010): 135-141.
5. Echeverria SRPS and Imparato JCP. “Uma opção para restau- 20. Bjorndal L., et al. “Treatment of deep caries lesions in adults:
ração de dentes com cárie occulta”. APCD 569.60 (2002): 423- randomized clinical trials comparing stepwise vs. direct com-
425. plete excavation, and direct pulp capping vs. partial pulpot-
omy”. European Journal of Oral Sciences 118.3 (2010): 290-
6. Corbellini C., et al. “Diagnóstico e tratamento da cárie oculta: 297.
relato de caso clínico”. Revista Saúde 3.3 (2009): 30-35.
21. Falster Caline A., et al. “Indirect pulp treatment: in vivo out-
7. Murdoch-Kinch., et al. “Minimally invasive dentistry”. The Jour- comes of an adhesive resin system vs calcium hydroxide for
nal of the American Dental Association 134.1 (2003): 87-95. protection of the dentin-pulp complex”. Pediatric Dentistry
24.3 (2002): 241-248.
8. Al-Zayer Mohammed A., et al. “Indirect pulp treatment of pri-
mary posterior teeth: a retrospective study”. Pediatric Dentist- 22. Oliveira EF., et al. “The monitoring of deep caries lesions af-
ry 25.1 (2003): 29-36. ter incomplete dentine caries removal: results after 14-18
months”. Clinical Oral Investigations 10.2 (2006): 134-139.
9. Silveira Ana Daniela Silva., et al. “Progression of non-cavitated
lesions in dentin through a nonsurgical approach: a prelimi- 23. Duque Cristiane., et al. “Clinical and microbiological perfor-
nary 12-month clinical observation”. European Journal of Den- mance of resin-modified glass-ionomer liners after incom-
tistry 6.1 (2012): 34-42. plete dentine caries removal”. Clinical Oral Investigations 13.4
(2009): 465-471.
10. Maltz M., et al. “Partial removal of carious dentine: a multi-
center randomized controlled trial and 18-month follow-up 24. Banerjee A., et al. “Dentine caries excavation: a review of cur-
results”. Caries Research 47.2 (2013): 103-109. rent clinical techniques”. British Dental Journal 188.9 (2000):
476-482.
11. Thompson Van., et al. “Treatment of deep carious lesions by
complete excavation or partial removal: a critical review”. The 25. Kidd EAM. “Clinical threshold for carious tissue removal”.
Journal of the American Dental Association 139.6 (2008): 705- Dental Clinics of North America 54.3 (2010): 541-549.
712.
26. Fusayama T. “Two Layers of Carious Dentin; Diagnosis and
12. Maltz M., et al. “Randomized trial of partial vs. stepwise caries Treatment”. Operative Dentistry 4.2 (1979): 63-70.
removal: 3-year follow-up”. Journal of Dental Research 91.11
(2012): 1026-1031. 27. Chibinski ACR., et al. “Evaluation of primary carious dentin
after cavity sealing in deep lesions: a 10- to 13-month follow-
13. Corralo DJ and Maltz M. “Clinical and ultrastructural effects of up”. Pediatric Dentistry 35.3 (2013): E107-E112.
different liners/restorative materials on deep carious dentin:
a randomized clinical trial”. Caries Research 47.3 (2013): 243- 28. Bjorndal L and Larsen T. “Changes in the cultivable flora in
250. deep carious lesions following a stepwise excavation proce-
dure”. Caries Research 34.6 (2000): 502-508.
14. Guimarães Rodrigo and Reis Rodrigo. “Reconstrução da morfo-
logia oclusal através da técnica da matriz individual de acrílico- 29. Marchi JJ., et al. “Indirect Pulp Capping in the Primary Denti-
relato de caso clínico”. Revista Ibero-Americana de Odontologia tion: A 4 Year Follow-up Study”. The Journal of Clinical Pediat-
Estética and Dentística 3.10 (2004): 154-159. ric Dentistry 31.2 (2006): 68-71.
15. Menezes Daniel Alexandre Pedrosa Malta., et al. “Cárie oculta: 30. Bjorndal L., et al. “A clinical and microbiological study of deep
técnica da réplica oclusal atualizada”. Journal of Clinical Den- carious lesions during stepwise excavation using long treat-
tistry and Research 13.3 (2016). ment intervals”. Caries Research 31.6 (1997): 411-417.
16. Pereira Renata Ferreira., et al. “Lesão de cárie oculta: restaura- 31. Martignon S., et al. “Efficacy of sealing proximal early active
ção utilizando a técnica da matriz occlusal”. Revista INPEO de lesions: an 18-month clinical study evaluated by convention-
Odontologia 2.1 (2008): 25-32. al and subtraction radiography”. Caries Research 40.5 (2006):
382-388.
17. Paschoal Marco Aurélio Benini., et al. “Cárie oculta extensa:
relato de caso clínico”. Revista de Odontologia da Universidade 32. Campos Priscila Hernández de., et al. “Reabilitação dentária
Cidade de São Paulo 24.2 (2012): 153-159. pela técnica da réplica oclusal em odontopediatria: relato de
caso”. Revista de Odontologia da Universidade Cidade de São
18. Gomes Valentina Pereira., et al. “Cárie Oculta: Diagnóstico e Paulo 26.2 (2017): 161-169.
alternativa para tratamento-Relato de Casos Clínicos”. Odonto
21.41-42 (2013): 31-38.
Citation: Ana Claudia Rodrigues Chibinski., et al. “Indirect Pulp Capping and Occlusal Matrix: A Minimally Invasive Approach for Restoring Young
Permanent Molars with Deep Carious Lesions”. Acta Scientific Dental Sciences 2.8 (2018): 57-63.
Indirect Pulp Capping and Occlusal Matrix: A Minimally Invasive Approach for Restoring Young Permanent Molars with Deep Carious Lesions
63
33. Ramirez Cláudia Elizabeth Carrero., et al. “Restaurações seria- 46. Anderson Maxwell H., et al. “Modern management of dental
das em dentes posteriores com recurso às matrizes oclusais”. caries: the cutting edge is not the dental bur”. The Journal of
Revista Portuguesa de Estomatologia, Medicina Dentária e the American Dental Association 124.6 (1993): 36-44.
Cirurgia Maxilofacial 48.3 (2007): 155-160.
47. Araújo Natália Costa., et al. “Considerações sobre a remoção
34. Silva Sandra Regina Echeverria Pinho da and Imparato José parcial do tecido cariado”. International Journal of Dentistry
Carlos Pettorossi. “Uma opçäo para restauraçäo de dentes com 9.4 (2010): 202-209.
cárie occulta”. Revista da Associacao Paulista de Cirurgioes Den-
tistas (2002): 423-425. 48. Bjorndal L., et al. “Depth and activity of carious lesions as
indicators for the regenerative potential of dental pulp after
35. Zenkner Júlio Eduardo do Amaral., et al. “Restabelecendo anato- intervention”. Journal of Endodontics 40.4 (2014): S76-S81.
mia, função e estética mediante a técnica da réplica occlusal”.
Clínica International Journal of Brazilian Dentistry 4.2 (2008):
196-203. Volume 2 Issue 8 August 2018
36. Pinto Marcelo Mendes., et al. “Restauração em dentes decíduos © All rights are reserved by Ana Claudia Rodrigues
posteriores pela técnica de moldagem ocluso-proximal”. Jor- Chibinski., et al.
nal Brasileiro de Odontopediatria e Odontologia do Bebe 4.22
(2002): 455-460.
43. Geddes A., et al. “Preoperative occlusal matrix aids the devel-
opment of occlusal contour of posterior occlusal resin compos-
ite restorations-clinical rationale and technique”. British Dental
Journal 206.6 (2009): 315-317.
Citation: Ana Claudia Rodrigues Chibinski., et al. “Indirect Pulp Capping and Occlusal Matrix: A Minimally Invasive Approach for Restoring Young
Permanent Molars with Deep Carious Lesions”. Acta Scientific Dental Sciences 2.8 (2018): 57-63.