Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
00
Printed in Great Britain. # 2002 TEMPUS Publications.
674
Teaching Residence Time Distributions in the Laboratory 675
the reactant conversion will depend on its local tracer perturbations and reaction flow patterns.
concentration. The Stirred reactor with a stagnant volume and Two
Zwietering developed a theoretical treatment for in series stirred reactors experiments are taught at
the prediction of outlet reactant concentration IST, while experiments Packed bed reactor and
corresponding to the perfect micromixing case Laminar flow tubular reactor are taught at FEUP
[8]. In addition to the exit-age distribution func- and are described in detail in reference [12]. All
tion, the `life expectancy' function is used [4, 6] experiments are integrated in senior level classes,
within the Chemical Engineering undergraduate
E
t curriculum.
t 1
E
t dt
Stirred reactor with a stagnant volume
t In this work, a simple way of obtaining non-
ideal reactor behavior is used, by combining a
The final result is the equation
deficient agitation in a continuous stirred vessel
dC dC with the presence of a division inside the vessel
r
C
t
C ÿ C i with
1 0 with two holes, in order to establish a weak
dt dt
communication between the two parts of the
7 reactor (Fig. 1).
where r(C) is the kinetic law, Ci the inlet reactant A solution of methylene blue is used as a tracer,
concentration, and t is the life expectation, i.e. the which is injected in the reactor feed by impulse, or
time the volume element will take to leave the by step input. The tracer concentration at the exit
reactor. The predicted outlet reactant concentra- of the reactor is evaluated by spectrophotometry,
tion at the steady-state, according to the perfect measuring the absorbance at 650 nm. The experi-
micromixing approach, will be the value of C at mentally obtained RTD is used to allow the
t 0 (reactor outlet zero life expectation). evaluation of the deviation of the real flow pattern
The integration of this equation can be from the perfect mixing. Several operating para-
performed by the following procedure: the value meters are regularly changed, with important
of C
1, at a large enough life expectation (for induced modifications in the obtained RTD:
example, 6 mean residence time), is obtained from increasing the agitation speed results in an clear
the condition dC=dt
1 0; starting at this refer- approximation of the real RTD to the ideal case;
ence, the desired value of C
0 results from the different positions of the inlet tube inside the
backwards numerical integration. reactor, as well as different flow rates, induce
This procedure has been exemplified, for different flow patterns.
instance, in reference [10]. Figure 2 presents an example of the experimen-
tal data for the DTR, and the expected curve if the
perfect mixing was effective,
EXPERIMENTAL ILLUSTRATIONS 1 ÿt=tr
E
t e
tr
We describe now four experiments that proved
to be useful in helping students interiorize and where tr V =Q is the expected mean residence
validating the RTD technique concepts. These time. The representation of a possible model that
experiments cover the most important kind of reasonably agrees with the experimental RTD is
also presented; this model is a parallel association
of two in-series ideal CSTR's batteries, constituted
by 6 and 5 equal volume reactors, whose E
t
function is
Q1 t5 ÿtQ1 6
E
t exp
Q V1 6 V1
5!
Q1 6
Q2 t4 ÿtQ2 5
5 exp
8
Q V2 V2
4!
Q2 5
where V1 and V2 are the volumes of the 6 and 5
tanks-in-series batteries, respectively, and Q1 and
Q2 are the corresponding volumetric flows
(V1 V2 V and Q1 Q2 Q).
Fig. 1. Photo of the experimental apparatus of the real CSTR The experiment considers the following main
study. equipment, with approximate costs:
Teaching Residence Time Distributions in the Laboratory 677
. feed pump: e1250 for tracer impulse injection. In this case, the tracer
. magnetic stirring device: e300 used is an aqueous solution of NiNO3; the tracer
. spectrophotometer (Spectronick 20 D): e2200 outlet concentration is measured by spectrophoto-
metry, at 720 nm.
Operating costs comprehend standard glass mate- If the experiment is performed with enough
rial and chemical products, and can be assumed stirring in the reactor vessels, the theoretical expres-
marginal. sion for E
t corresponding to a system of two in-
series ideal CSTR reactors [6], with equal volume,
Two stirred reactors in series E
t t=t2r exp
ÿ
t=tr , can be successfully fitted
The experimental apparatus of two in-series to the experimental values of the RTD function;
continuous stirred tanks is shown in Fig. 3. The the adjusting parameter is tr 4:1 min.
reaction used in this work is the acid catalysed Considering the calculation of the total segrega-
acetone iodination: tion approach, the rate expression has to be
CH3 COCH3 I2 ! CH3 COCH2 I HI: integrated by a numerical method, with the initial
conditions presented in Table 1. From these inte-
The rate law is [11] gration results and taking the E
t function, the
reactant concentration at the effluent of the reac-
CH CACI tor system for complete segregation is then
r
K 1CH K 2CI computed. According to the procedure previously
described, the iodine concentration prediction for
where CH, CA, and CI are the concentrations of the the steady-state from the Zwietering equation is
acid, acetone and iodine, respectively. The solu- also obtained. The experimental results for the
tions of iodine, and of acetone, are pumped separ- iodine concentration, as a function of time of
ately from the feed vessels. At the instant t 0, reaction, as well as the predictions from the
these solutions are fed to the reactors, which are complete segregation and perfect micromixing
initially filled with solvent. The outlet reactant approaches, are presented in Fig. 4. The results
concentration is analysed by iodometry until the obtained from the integration of the mass balances
steady state is obtained. The values of k1 and k2 for two in-series ideal CSTR's (assumes micro-
were obtained from a previous kinetic study. The mixing) are also included, since the experimental
results obtained for a given set of experimental E
t values fitted very well to this model.
conditions (Table 1) are presented in Fig. 4. From the observation of this figure it is remark-
The experimental RTD of this system can be able the close proximity between the reactor
determined after the steady-state is obtained, performance prediction from the theoretical
maintaining all the experimental conditions, approaches and the experimental values, especially
according to the procedure previously described for the steady-state. Since the acetone and acid
concentrations inside a segregated fluid element
are in excess relative to iodine concentration, the
kinetics of the reaction can be reduced to apparent
zero-order; if all the fluid element iodine concen-
trations lie in the range that satisfies the zero-order
condition, k2 CI k1 CH , which is approximately
the case for this experience, the effect of micro-
mixing in the conversion is not very relevant.
Otherwise, if the reaction is performed at higher
levels of conversion, so that a considerable number
of segregated fluid elements does not satisfy the
Fig. 3. Photo of the two in-series CSTR apparatus. mentioned condition, the kinetics will be first order
678 J. Lopes et al.
Table 1. Experimental reaction conditions for the two in-series CSTR operation.
Fig. 5. Packed bed reactor, step purge experiment: a) start; b) approximately at the middle of the experiment; c) experimental results
(points) and model fit (line).
in those lower iodine concentration elements, and diameter of 0.036 m and containing glass beads of
the effect of micromixing between fluid elements 0.003 m diameter.
where the effective kinetics is zero-order with those The reactor is initially filled with a tracer solu-
of first-order will be important in the conversion tion of potassium chloride 0.1 M and 0.1% (w/w)
obtained; in this case the experimental results are carmine indigo (both species are environmentally
much closer to the Zwietering prediction than to safe and harmless for humans). A step purge is
the segregation approach. performed by feeding water at a known constant
All the calculations can be easily carried out flow rate. The indigo indicator is present solely to
using commercial spreadsheet programs. add a visual element to the experiment, since the
The experiment considers the following main quantitative RTD determination is performed by
equipment, with approximate costs: measuring the conductivity of the KCl solution
. feed pump (2): e2500 exiting the reactor. The condutimeter is connected
. magnetic stirring device (2): e600 to a computer through a RS-232 interface (the data
. spectrophotometer (Spectronick 20 D): e2200 acquisition rate is one point every two seconds).
An example of experimental results can be seen in
Operating costs take into account standard glass Fig. 5(c).
material and chemical products, and can be Students are asked to fit the axially dispersed
assumed marginal. plug flow reactor model to the measured data
using the average residence time and Peclet
Packed bed reactor number as fitting parameters. This can be easily
The packed bed reactor, shown in Fig. 5, done using, for instance, the `solver' add-in
consists of a 1.01 m long tube with an internal available in MS Excel1.
Fig. 6. Packed bed reactor, pulse perturbation experiment: a) initial stage; b) approximately at the middle of the experiment; c)
experimental results (points) and model fit (line).
Teaching Residence Time Distributions in the Laboratory 679
While a purge step can present some advantages Laminar flow tubular reactor
over other forms of perturbation, a pulse perturba- The tubular reactor is 1.01 m long and has an
tion is also widely used and students should also internal diameter of 0.022 m, see Fig. 7.
experiment with it. This can be done easily with the The reactor is initially filled with water. A step
available experimental set-up, using an injection input in the inlet concentration is performed using
valve with a 20 cm3 loop. Figure 6 shows the pulse a 5 10ÿ6 M crystal violet solution. This kind of
traveling across the reactor and the corresponding perturbation is the best for visualizing the char-
experimental result. acteristic parabolic shape of the concentration
The experiment considers the following main front, Fig. 7(a). The tracer concentration in the
equipment, with approximate costs: exiting stream is measured using a colorimeter, at
. a wavelength of 590 nm, and recorded into a
packed bed reactor: e150
. computer.
feed pump: e1000
. This experiment demands special care, since
conductimeter and cell: e2000
. convection streams, originated by density gradi-
computer (does not include data acquisition
ents associated to thermal and/or concentration
software): e750
. injection valve: e450 differences inside the reactor, can easily disturb the
laminar profile and ruin the results. Temperature
Operating costs allow for the indicator solutions must be kept constant and homogeneous through-
and can be assumed marginal. out the reactor within 0.58C. To guarantee this
thermal homogeneity, the reactor has an outside
(a) jacket connected to a refrigerated waterbath. The
solutions fed to the reactor are kept in jacketed
vessels also connected to the waterbath. All
refrigeration and connecting tubes are thermally
insulated.
In addition, the density of the tracer solution
should be close to that of the liquid originally
inside the reactor (water). Crystal violet is a very
strong colorant that allows us to use very low
concentrations. Also, the crystal violet solution
should be made from the same water used to fill
the reactor.
A conical diffuser at the reactor's entrance, filled
with 1 mm diameter glass beads, minimizes turbu-
lence that can be originated from the sudden inlet
(b)
section change. A similar conical diffuser at the
reactor's outlet allows for radial mixing of the
exiting stream, approaching a plug flow pattern.
Contrary to carmine indigo or potassium chloride,
crystal violet (in the original powder form) is
described by the manufacturer as being harmful,
irritant and dangerous for the environment [13].
However, the extremely low concentration used,
5 10ÿ6 M, minimizes these negative effects. This
reactant is commonly used in microbiology at
concentrations close to 2.5 10ÿ3 M.
An example of experimental results is shown in
(c) Fig. 7(b). Figure 7(c) shows the linearization of the
experimental curve and the model fitting line. It is
clear from this figure how close to the ideal flow
pattern this reactor behaves.
The experiment considers the following main
equipment, with approximate costs:
REFERENCES
1. R. P. Hesketh, D. Bosak and L. Kline, Automotive catalytic reaction engineering experiment,
Chem. Eng. Ed., 34(3), pp. 240±245 (2000).
2. R. P Hesketh and C. S. Slater, Innovative and economical bench-scale process engineering
experiments, Int. J. Engng. Ed., 16(4), pp. 327±334 (2000).
3. P. V. Danckwerts, The effect of incomplete mixing on homogeneous reactions, Chem. Eng. Sci., 8,
pp. 93±99 (1958).
4. O. Levenspiel, Chemical Reaction Engineering, 3rd. ed., Ch. 9 and 10, John Wiley & Sons, New
York (1998).
5. G. F. Froment and K. B. Bischoff, Chemical Reactor Analysis and Design, 2nd. ed., Chap. 9, 10 and
12, John Wiley & Sons, New York (1979).
6. H. S. Fogler, Elements of Chemical Reaction Engineering, 3rd. ed., Ch. 13, Prentice-Hall, New
Jersey (1998).
7. J. M. Smith, Chemical Engineering Kinetics, 3rd. ed., Ch. 6, McGraw-Hill, Singapore (1981).
8. T. N. Zwietering, The degree of mixing in continuous flow systems, Chem. Eng. Sci., 11, pp. 1±15
(1959).
9. F. Lemos, J. M. Lopes and F. RamoÃa Ribeiro, Reactores QuõÂmicos, IST Press, Lisboa (2001), in
press.
10. J. M. Lopes, F. Lemos and F. RamoÃa Ribeiro, Predicting the Performance of a Chemical Reactor,
Int. J. Engng. Ed., 11(2), pp. 146±151 (1995).
11. K. J. Laidler, Chemical Kinetics, 2nd. ed., p. 514, Tata McGraw-Hill, New Delhi (1973).
12. A. Mendes, LaboratoÂrios de Engenharia QuõÂmica: Reactores em Fase HomogeÂnea, Reactores
CatalõÂticos, SeparacËoÄes naÄo Convencionais e Tecnologia dos SoÂlidos Divididos, EdicËoÄes FEUP,
Porto (2001), in press.
13. http://www.merck.de/english/services/chemdat/english/index.htm